AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
PER MANISH AGARWAL, A.M.:
The present appeal is filed by assessee against the order dated 28.03.2021 passed by Ld. Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax, Noida [“Ld. PCIT”] u/s 263 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 [“the Act”] arising out of assessment order dated 20.12.2017 passed u/s 143(3) of the Act pertaining to Assessment Year 2015-16.
Brief facts of the case are that the assessee is a company, incorporated on 13.10.2012 and engaged in the business of providing health care services by establishing multi-specialty hospital. The return of income for the year under appeal was filed on 30.09.2015, declaring loss of INR 8,56,20,656/-. The case was selected for scrutiny, and assessment order was passed u/s 143(3) of the Act vide order dated 20.12.2017 wherein addition of INR 27,75,620/- was made on account of delayed payment of employee’s contribution towards PF & ESI and accordingly, total loss stands assessed at INR 8,28,45,036/-. Thereafter, ld. PCIT in terms of show cause notice dated 18.02.2021 has asked the assessee as to why not the assessment order so passed be treated as erroneous and pre-judicial to the interest of the Revenue as there were certain issues which were not examined by the AO. In response, assessee filed detailed replies on 15.03.2021 and 25.03.2021. After considering the submission of the assessee, ld. PCIT in terms of para 5 of its order has dropped majority of the issues raised in terms of the show cause notice however, held that the no basis for bifurcation of expenditure between the capital WIP and Revenue expenditure was provided and the proportion of bifurcation of expenses made was not proper as compared to receipts. Ld. PCIT further observed that the assessee has not filed any details with respect to the bifurcation of expenses between the capital WIP and revenue expenditure and therefore, held the assessment order as erroneous and pre-judicial to the interest of the Revenue and direct the AO to make independent inquiries and verification with respect to the expenses claimed in the Profit & Loss Account vis-a-vis income offered.
Against the said order, the assessee preferred the present appeal before the Tribunal by taking various Grounds of appeal as per the appeal memo.
All the Grounds of appeal are with respect to the action of ld. PCIT in invoking the provision of section 263 of the Act and held the assessment order as erroneous and pre-judicial to the interest of the Revenue, therefore, all the Grounds of appeal Nos. 1 to 12 raised by the assessee are taken together for consideration.
Before us, Shri Ajy Vohra, ld. AR submits that ld. PCIT has failed to appreciate the fact that during the course of assessment proceedings in terms of replies filed on various dates, assessee has filed complete details with respect to the expenses debited in Profit & Loss Account and corresponding Revenue declared. He further submits that during the year under appeal, the hospital was under its initial stage where only Four (04) Departments were operational completely viz [i] Internal Medicine: [ii] Radiology; [iii] Pathlab and [iv] Executive health checkup. The other Departments were under trial run where the receipts related to such department were reduced from the corresponding expenditure taken to WIP. For this, ld. AR drew our attention to page 18 of Paper Book (PB) where Note-10A to Balance Sheet is appended as per which, out of which total expenses related to these departments of INR 1,72,12,38,866/-(including opening balance of INR 52,41,55,410/-), a sum of INR 32.32 crores (being the receipts from the Departments which were not fully operated and under trial run) was reduced since the final approval for running these Departments as independent units was not received. Ld. AR further submits that total expenditure incurred during the year of INR 1,19,70,83,456/- out of which the expenditure related to the four departments fully operational were taken to the P&L A/c and remaining expenditure were capitalized as work-in-progress after reducing the receipts related to such Departments. Ld.AR submits that the assessee had duly disclosed receipts of those Department which were 100% operational and the corresponding expenses incurred in such Departments were directly debited to the Profit & Loss Account. Ld. AR drew our attention to various replies filed during the course of assessment proceedings before AO wherein all these facts were brought to the notice of the AO such as reply dated 01.02.2017 placed at pages 51 to 54 of PB where the assessee has explained the basis of Revenue recognition. Ld.AR for the assessee submits that assessee had disclosed all the material facts and filed all the necessary details with respect to the expenses incurred therefore, the action of ld. PCIT in holding the assessment as erroneous and pre-judicial to the interest of the Revenue is incorrect and requested for the cancellation of such order.
Ld. AR further submits that before ld. PCIT, the assessee re-iterated the same facts and further explained in detail the basis of Revenue recognition however, ld. PCIT had failed to appreciate these facts and held assessment order as erroneous and pre-judicial to the interest of the Revenue. He further submits that in compliance to the directions given by the ld. PCIT, the AO has passed the effect order u/s 143(3) r.w.s. 263 of the Act dated 31.03.2022 wherein addition has been made of INR 32.32 crores, being the revenue from those Departments which were not fully operational by observing that assessee has not recognized its revenue however, corresponding expenses have not been allowed which were taken to the WIP by the assessee. It is submitted by ld.AR that though the present appeal is against the order passed u/s 263 of the Act by ld. PCIT however, in the said order, ld. PCIT has not given any such direction to the AO for making additions of the remaining revenue which was already reduced from the expenditure added to work-in-progress.
On the other hand, ld. CIT DR for the Revenue vehemently supported the order of ld. PCIT and submits that despite of repeated opportunities, the assessee has failed to give the basis of bifurcation of the receipts and expenditure incurred which were taken to the work-in-progress and taken to the Profit & Loss Account. As per ld. CIT DR in absence of such details, verification of claim of assessee could not be possible nor feasible, therefore, ld. PCIT has rightly held the assessment order as erroneous and pre-judicial to the interest of the Revenue. He prayed accordingly.
Heard the contentions of both parties at length and perused the material available on record. Ld. PCIT in terms of the show cause notice dated 18.02.201 initiated the proceedings u/s 263 and had raised many issues which according to ld. PCIT remained to be examined by the AO. It is further observed that after considering the replies of the assessee, in terms of para 5 of the order, ld. PCIT has observed that there was disparity between the proportion of expenses taken to WIP and corresponding Revenue recognised. As per ld. PCIT, percentage of expenditure debited in Profit & Loss Account out of total expenses incurred was 9.75% and the corresponding revenue taken to the Profit & Loss Account was 24% of the gross revenue. As per ld. PCIT, out of total revenue of INR 42.58 crores, no details were filed before the AO to Examine whether the bifurcation of the revenue was correct or not. It is further observed that the assessee since beginning of the proceedings has claimed that the revenue relates to four departments fully functional was declared as revenue receipt in the P&L Account and remaining receipts were reduced from the cost of WIP however, it is observed that no details of department wise receipts and corresponding expenditure were filed.
From the financial statements, it is observed that the assessee has built a high-end multi-specialty hospital equipped with latest technologies, advanced machines where health care services are to be provided in different branches like, Cardiology, Oncology, Gastro Intestinal Surgery, Ortho-Neuro Surgery and Trauma Center. The hospitals have 504 beds alongwith 17 operation theaters and 108 room for out-patient healthcare services and follow-up check-up for the in-patients. The Hospital is also equipped with facilities enabling complicated procedures, in the diverse specialty mix at one place including cardio thoracic vascular surgery, spine surgery, joint replacement, radiation and surgical oncology and bone marrow transplant etc. Apart from this, the hospital provides high end diagnostics and imaging services, including machines such as Stereotactic body radiation therapy, Biplance Cath labs with Intra Venous Ultrasound, 3 Tesla MRI with HIFU etc. During the year under appeal, only Four departments have started operations which facts was never disputed by the department, these are [i] Internal Medicine: [ii] Radiology; [iii] Pathlab and [iv] Executive health checkup. The remaining departments were under trial run and therefore, the cost of construction as well as cost of equipment’s and expenditure incurred in all these other Departments were taken to work-in-progress. It is observed that out total expenses incurred during the year were of INR 119.70 crores and after including the opening value of WIP of INR 52.41 crores and after reducing the sum of INR 32.32 crores towards the receipts of these departments during the trial run from the patients, the remaining was taken to the WIP.
Ld. PCIT observed that only 7.9% of the expenses was taken to Profit & Loss Account has ignored the fact that the total expenses taken from the previous year as opening balances and only the expenses incurred during the year of INR 119.70 crores were taken to the work-in-progress. Likewise, out of the total revenue of INR 42.58 crores, the assessee has declared revenue of INR 10.26 crores which includes the revenue from hospital, revenue from Pharmacy of INR 0.75 crores and interest and other income of INR 3.21 crores. From the perusal of the Profit & Loss Account, it is observed that out of revenue of INR 7.50 crores, the assessee has claimed expenditure to the tune of INR 2.63 crores as cost of sales being medicines etc. utilized in providing services to the patients and 4.26 crores towards employees benefits and INR 4.12 crores as other expenses which includes Doctor consultancy fees etc. Besides this, a sum of INR 1.77 crores were claimed as finance cost and INR 2.03 crores as depreciation and amortization expenses.
From the perusal of the facts and details, it is observed that though the assessee has stated that it had offered the revenue from Four Departments operational during the year and claimed expenses with respect to such departments only however, no department-wise details were furnished with respect to the receipts and expenditure were filed before ethe AO or before the ld. PCIT thus verification of such claim of the assessee was not done. It is further observed that the AO has never verified these facts which are crucial to determine the correct income of the assessee. Once the assessee has been able to bifurcate the same, certainly such details were maintained by the assessee however, they were not produced even after making specific query by ld. PCIT. In absence of such details, verification whether such bifurcation of receipts as well as expenditure was correct or not was not carried out and the same leads the assessment order as erroneous and prejudicial to the interest of revenue. Under these circumstances, we are not inclined to interfere the order of ld. PCIT in invoking the provisions of section 263 and holding that the assessment order as erroneous and pre-judicial to the interest of the Revenue. Accordingly, all the Grounds of appeal raised by the assessee are dismissed.
Here we are restrained ourselves for making any comments on the effect order passed by AO which is not subject matter of appeal before us.
In the result, appeal of the assessee is dismissed.
