AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
Rule. Rule made returnable forthwith.
Heard the learned Counsel for the petitioner.
Even though served, nobody appears for the respondent. The previous orders of this Court also marked the absence of the respondent. In that context, I have heard Shri. Thakur, learned Counsel for the petitioner.
The present petition challenges order dated 07.01.2026 passed by the 5th Joint Civil Judge, Senior Division, Chandrapur, in R.C.S. No. 52 of 2017, passed below Exhibit 448. By way of said order, the Trial Court has rejected the application filed by the petitioner herein who is the original defendant No.3 seeking re-examination of his witness.
I have heard Shri. Thakur, learned Counsel for the petitioner who contends that in the cross-examination, a document which was titled as a "Relinquishment Deed" dated 09.04.2010 was shown to the witness. In spite of the fact that he denied the existence of the said document, since it was put in cross-examination, it was marked as Exhibit 445. He submits that since such a new material was brought on record, it was imperative for the Trial Court to permit the re-examination. It is his submission that having failed to do so, the Trial Court has committed an error of law, rendering the order perverse.
I have gone through the impugned order, as also the cross-examination referred by Mr. Thakur, learned Counsel for the petitioner. The impugned order takes into consideration the provisions of Section 138 of the Indian Evidence Act and proceeds on a premise that re-examination is permissible only for explaining matters arising out of cross-examination. However, in my considered opinion, having held so that the scope of Section 138 of the Indian Evidence Act is only for explaining the matters which were elucidated in cross-examination, in my considered opinion, it was obligatory on the part of the Trial Court to allow the application for re-examination. Having not done so, the Trial Court has committed an error of law.
Furthermore, even though the Trial Court records a finding that the application does not specify any ambiguity, contradiction, or adverse answer, bare perusal of the cross-examination, as stated supra, would reveal that there was some material in the form of an alleged Relinquishment Deed for which opportunity will have to be granted to the witness to explain the same. The order, therefore, cannot be sustained in law and the same is set aside. In that view of the matter, following order is passed:
ORDER
The Writ Petition is allowed.
ii) The impugned order dated 07.01.2026 passed by the 5th Joint Civil Judge, Senior Division, Chandrapur, in R.C.S. No. 52 of 2017, passed below Exhibit 448, is quashed and set aside.
iii) Application below Exhibit 448 is allowed.
The Writ Petition is allowed and disposed of. Rule is made absolute in above terms.
