AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
Harpreet Kaur Jeewan, J.
The plaintiff-appellant has filed present Regular Second Appeal, impugning the judgment and decree dated 24.02.2025, passed by the Civil Judge (Junior Division), Rohtak (hereinafter the ‘trial Court’) and the decision of the Additional District Judge, Rohtak (hereinafter the ‘First Appellate Court’) dated 29.05.2026, whereby, both the Courts have dismissed the suit filed by the plaintiff.
The relevant facts, in brief, are that the plaintiff filed a suit seeking permanent injunction and possession against the defendant-respondents, alleging that she is owner-in-possession of plot No.7, measuring 117 sq. yds., comprised of Rectangle No.317, Killa No.08 (08 Kanals), situated within the revenue estate of Village Garhi Bohar, Tehsil and District Rohtak.
It is the case of the plaintiff that she had purchased the aforesaid plot vide sale deed dated 13.10.2014, from one Ashok Kumar S/o Shadi Lal, whereas, defendant-respondent Suresh allegedly purchased Plot No.6 measuring 135 sq. yds. and a portion of land measuring 54 sq. yds. on the southern side of Plot No.7 from his brother Ishwar Singh vide transfer deed dated 20.12.2017. The defendants, who had formed a land-grabbing group, are threatening to dispossess the plaintiff; hence the plaintiff moved an application to the Police on 19.01.2018. It is further the case of the plaintiff that defendant Nos.6 & 7 have illegally encroached about 09 sq. yds. of land from the plot of the plaintiff, hence the suit was filed.
Defendant Nos.1 to 4 filed joint written statement and contested the suit. Defendant Nos.6 & 7 also filed a separate joint written statement and they also contested the suit alleging that they have not encroached upon any land of the plaintiff.
The trial Court framed the following issues: -
“Issue no.1: Whether the plaintiff is entitled for the relief of permanent injunction as prayed for? OPP
Issue no.2: Whether the suit of the plaintiff is not maintainable? OPD
Issue no.3: Whether the present suit has not been properly valued for the purpose of court fee? OPD
Issue no.4: Whether the plaintiff has not approached the court with clean hands and has suppressed material and relevant facts? OPD
Issue No.5: Relief.”
Both the parties were permitted to lead evidence and ultimately, the trial Court dismissed the suit, while observing that the plaintiff had failed to prove that she is in possession of a specific portion of land; the plaintiff could not file any application before the Court for appointment of a Local Commissioner for demarcation of the land; there is no evidence on record to prove the encroachment of 09 sq. yds. by defendant Nos.6 & 7; as such, the plaintiff is not entitled to the decree prayed for.
The First Appellate Court also dismissed the appeal and confirmed the findings of the Court at the first instance.
The plaintiff/appellant is before this Court by way of present Regular Second Appeal.
Learned counsel for the appellant contends that the suit has been wrongly dismissed on the ground that the parties are co-sharers; they are not in exclusive possession over any portion of the suit property. It is submitted that the plaintiff has purchased a specific plot with specific dimensions vide sale deed dated 13.10.2014, which has been proved as Ex.PW2/A. However, both the Courts have overlooked that the plaintiff has become owner-in-possession of a specific portion, whereas, defendant Suresh got the alleged Plot No.6 and some portion adjoining plot No.7 by way of a subsequent alleged transfer deed dated 20.12.2017. The possession of the appellant is fully established, as such, she is entitled for the decree as prayed for.
I have considered the aforesaid submissions.
It is not disputed that Plot No.7 measuring 117 sq. yds. is a part of Rectangle No.317 (Killa No.08). The total area of that Khasra/Killa is 08 Kanals, whereas, ownership of the plaintiff is only 117 sq. yds. In order to seek the relief of permanent injunction, the plaintiff was required to establish that she is in exclusive possession of a specific portion out of the said Killa/Khasra number. The said khasra number has not yet been partitioned. The plaintiff was also required to lead evidence in order to prove that defendant Nos.6 & 7 have encroached over a part of the said plot or that the plaintiff is in exclusive possession of the said plot. The trial Court has observed that no demarcation report was available, since no application was moved by the plaintiff in this regard. The said observations are correct since the best evidence would have been a demarcation report having been conducted by a Revenue Authority.
The defendants are not claiming the ownership rights of plot No.7, which is claimed by the appellant as her ownership. Both the parties are claiming ownership of different plots with different boundaries. The controversy could have been properly resolved by way of appointment of a Local Commissioner from the Revenue Authorities. On the basis of said demarcation report, the controversy could have been put to rest; however, such an exercise was neither conducted by the trial Court, nor by the First Appellate Court. At the same time, even the appellant remained silent. She did not move such an application either before the trial Court, or before the First Appellate Court.
At this stage, there is not even an iota of evidence on record that there is any encroachment having been done by defendant Nos.6 & 7 or that there is an interference in the peaceful possession of the plaintiff, as such, this Court does not find any ground to interfere in the findings arrived at by the trial Court as well as the First Appellate Court.
Consequently, present appeal is dismissed. However, keeping in view the peculiar facts and circumstances of this case, it is made clear that in case the appellant choose to approach the Revenue Authorities for demarcation as per law and in case, any cause of action arises in favour of the appellant, this order shall not be construed as a bar for fresh action by plaintiff, if taken any, in accordance with law.
Pending miscellaneous application(s)shall stand disposed of.
