High CourtsSingle Bench(1998) 09 AHC CK 0171

In Re: M.K. Vinyl (P) Ltd.

Allahabad High Court · Decided on 14 September 1998 · Citation: (1999) 1 ACR 97

HON’BLE JUDGES
S.K. Phaujdar, J
CASE NUMBER
Criminal Miscellaneous Application No. 3602 of 1998

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

6 paragraphs · 1,028 words

S.K. Phaujdar, J.—Through this application u/s 482, Code of Criminal Procedure the applicant has prayed for quashing an F.I.R. dated 25.8.1998 lodged at P.S. Hallandale, district Defraud u/s 420. I.P.C. in Case Crime No. 338 of 1998.

2.

When asked if the powers u/s 482, Code of Criminal Procedure could be exercised to quash an F.I.R. in view of the judgment of this Court in Ram Lai Adam's case and A.S. Bindra's case, the learned Counsel submitted that the cases may be distinguished as the F.I.R. was against a corporate authority and no criminal action lies against a corporate authority as no individual was named as an accused. Reliance was placed on a decision of the Supreme Court in JT 1997 10 SC 165. as also on an unreported decision of this High Court dated 8.5.1998 in Criminal Misc. Application No. 9353 of 1986.

3.

The facts of the case may be stated in brief before the law point could be taken up. The F.I.R. now under challenge is at Annexure-14 to the present application which was lodged on the basis of a report from the Superintending Engineer, U.P. Jai Nigam at Dehradun, which is at Annexure-13 to the present application. The report was made to the Officer-in-Charge of the concerned police station stating that M.K. Vinyl (P.) Ltd. had supplied to the Jai Nigam, between February and July, 1997, certain quantity of pipe of certain specifications under an indent from the Department. Payment was made by the Department to the Firm, but on actual use the pipes were found broken and suffering from excessive leakage. The pipes were inspected by the experts from the Roorkee University as also from Shri Ram Institute for Industrial Research and the same were found not in conformity with the standard given by the Indian Standard Institute and as such the Department was cheated. , An F.I.R. is to be drawn up u/s 154, Code of Criminal Procedure when an information relating to commission of a cognizable offence is given to Officer-in-Charge of a'' Police Station. If it is given orally, it is to be reduced into writing and is to be read over to the informant. Every such information of commission of cognizable offence is to be signed by the person giving the information and the substance thereof is to be entered in a book to be kept by the officer in such form as the State Government may prescribe in this behalf. This is popularly known as the F.I.R. (First Information Report). Lodging of an F.I.R. no doubt requires information relating to commission of a cognizable offence but it no where requires that any particular person be named as perpetrator of the offence. It may not, therefore, be proper to describe an F.I.R. to be untenable in law simply because it names a corporate person as an accused.

5.

The case law that has been relied upon does not cover the instant point. Here was a case before the Supreme Court in which in a prosecution u/s 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act the accused was acquitted by the Magistrate on the ground of absence of the complainant. The complaint was, however, filed by a Co. and was not a corporal person capable of making physical presence in the Court. The Supreme Court observed that where the complainant is a body corporate it is demure complainant and it must associate a human being as de facto complainant to represent the company. In case of absence of a corporeal representative, the company could seek permission of the Court to send another person to represent it. The Supreme Court set aside the order of acquittal on the ground of absence of the company as the complainant and other witnesses had already been examined by the Court. The Supreme Court in explaining the term "complainant" had referred to the word "person" as defined in Section 11 of the Indian Penal Code which states that the word person'' includes any company or association or body of persons, whether incorporated or not. An offence of cheating is defined u/s 415. I.P.C. and it is made punishable u/s 420. I.P.C. and Section 420, I.P.C. begins with the words "whoever cheats". An offence of cheating could be committed on proof of certain components like deception, fraudulent or dishonest inducement to deliver any property and damage or harm to the person deceived in respect of his property. This deception, prima facie was made by the Firm and only investigation could reveal as to who were the persons actually involved in the act of deception and inducement which resulted in damage or harm to the property of the complainant.

6.

The records of the unreported case were not available from the office nor did the learned Counsel places a copy of the orders before me. The position of law is, however, clear. If there be a prima Jackie allegation of commission of a cognizable offence, an F.I.R. can be drawn up and investigation can be taken up. There is no necessity of mention of the name of the accused and as such naming a corporate person as an accused may not be a legal bar against entertainment of an F.I.R. Once this point fails, we are back to the general question whether an F.I.R. could be quashed in exercise of powers u/s 482, Code of Criminal Procedure The decision in the case of A.S. Bindra was referred to by the learned Counsel to say that it was open to distinction because of the above ground. When that ground has failed, there is no reason to distinguish the decision in A.S. Bandar's case. That case has been relied on even recently by this Court on 11.9.1998 in Urinal Kant Malice and Ors. v. State of U.P. and Anr. Criminal Misc. Application No. 3517 of 1998. The applicants in that case were also directed to seek relief in a proper writ petition.

7.

The present application, accordingly, stands disposed of with a direction that the applicant may choose to file a writ petition for proper relief as the relief prayed for may not be granted u/s 482. Code of Criminal Procedure.