AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
A complaint was filed by M/s Ideal Breweries Private Limited (“Complainants” or “Complainant Company”) against M/s Omaxe Heritage Private Limited (“Respondents or Respondent Company/Promoter”) under the provisions of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 read with the NCT of Delhi Real Estate (Regulation and Development) (General) Rules, 2016
The Complainants booked a commercial unit in the project “Omaxe Chandni Chowk,” situated in Delhi. The unit was originally booked as FF-84, subsequently changed to FF-158, and finally to FF-157. The Complainants has approached this Authority alleging statutory violations, contractual breaches, and fraudulent conduct by the Respondents, and sought physical possession of the unit as per sanctioned plans, compensation for delayed possession, payment of commitment charges and guaranteed rent, registration of the Builder-Buyer Agreement (hereinafter referred to as “BBA” or ‘Agreement for Sale”) & Sub-Lease Deed, and a restraint on unlawful demands towards annual lease rent and property tax.
A notice was issued to the Respondents on 25.11.2024, who filed a detailed reply on15.01.2025 . Both parties filed their written submissions and were heard at length. This Authority has also taken on record its earlier orders dated 31.10.2023 and 24.07.2024 passed in relation to this project.
For the sake of convenience, the submissions made on behalf of the Complainants are summarised as under:
In late 2020, the Respondent Company’s sales team approached the Complainants with an investment proposal for the project, offering two options, a “Lockable Unit” with assured returns of 12% per annum until possession and guaranteed rent of 9% per annum for three years post-possession. These assurances formed the basis of the Complainants investment decision and cannot be disowned.
On 22.01.2021, the Complainants booked unit FF-84 (super area 398 sq. ft., carpet area 187 sq. ft.). In February 2021, the Respondents proposed an upgrade to unit FF-158 (super area 554 sq. ft., carpet area 260 sq. ft.), assuring that all earlier terms would remain unchanged. The Complainants accepted, and an Allotment Letter for FF-158 was issued on 09.03.2021.
The Respondents also delivered an Addendum to the Allotment Letter, stipulating commitment charges of Rs. 2,99,160/- per month from 02.03.2023 until the date of filing of Occupancy Cum Completion application, and guaranteed rent of Rs. 4,98,600/- per month for three years post-possession.
In January 2023, the Complainants visited the project site and observed material deviations from the sanctioned plans, including changed location of unit FF-158, a reduced Central Atrium, and altered positioning of lifts and common amenities. Written objections were raised on 06.02.2023 and followed up in March, June, and October 2023, with no formal response from the Respondents.
On 27.10.2023, the Respondents offered “symbolic possession” of unit FF-158 while retaining physical control, and simultaneously demanded payment of the balance consideration. The Complainants contended that offering of symbolic possession was not in accordance of the Agreement to Sell entered into between the parties.
On 15.12.2023, the Respondents informed the Complainants that the unit has been renumbered from FF-158 to FF-157. The Complainants contended that this is not a mere administrative exercise but it involved a change in carpet area and physical location.
In response to Respondent’s letter dated 25.01.2024, the Complainants sent a signed BBA dated 03.02.2024 and a cheque for Rs. 50,00,000/-as part payment. The Complainants contend that the Respondents did not take any step further for registration of the signed Agreement to Sell.
On 18.02.2024, the Complainant Company’s Directors inspected unit FF-157 and found that no lockable shop conforming to the agreed specifications had been constructed, the first floor was largely open space, without partitions, lockable doors, or necessary infrastructure.
The Respondents issued a “Last and Final Opportunity” letter on 04.03.2024, asserting readiness of the unit and offering possession subject to full payment, followed by a cancellation threat on 16.03.2024 if dues were not cleared within three days.
On 20.03.2024, the parties met and agreed that commitment charges for the period 02.03.2023 to 01.08.2023 would be adjusted against the Complainant Company’s outstanding dues. The Complainants accordingly paid Rs. 3,47,69,498/- under protest. Despite, Respondents encashing the cheque on 27.03.2024, neither the BBA nor the Sub-Lease Deed has been executed or registered, till date in violation of the Respondent Company’s statutory obligations under the Act.
In June 2024, a dispute over residual dues was resolved when the Respondents issued a Credit Note on 13.06.2024 acknowledging the TDS amount. The Respondent Company’s own ledger dated 14.08.2024 confirmed no further dues outstanding and the fact that Complainants have made payment in full.
On 08.10.2024, the Respondents demanded a share of Annual Lease Rent and Property tax for unit FF-157. The Complainants rejected the legality of this demand.
The Respondents have mortgaged the unit FF-158 to Kotak Mahindra Bank without the Complainant’s knowledge or consent.
For the sake of convenience, the submissions made on behalf of the Respondents are summarised as under:
No representations were made beyond what is documented in the Application Form, Allotment Letter, and BBA. Oral discussions cannot override executed contractual documents.
The Complainants voluntarily opted for a discount of Rs. 52,35,300/- in lieu of commitment charges, subject to OCC application being filed by 01.03.2023. Commitment charges for the delay period from 02.03.2023 to 31.07.2023, amounting to Rs. 3,78,700/- have already been adjusted.
The renumbering from FF-158 to FF-157 was purely administrative exercise, with no change in location or dimensions. The unit has been constructed as per sanctioned plans, and the OCC obtained from MCD on 16.10.2023.
Respondents submitted that the walls were initially left uncarved because most allottees opted to rent their spaces collectively to prospective tenants. However, on Complainant Company’s specific request, a wall partition has been erected and lockable unit completed to their satisfaction.
Physical possession has been offered to complainant repeatedly since 16.10.2023. The delay is attributable solely to the Complainant Company’s failure to complete necessary formalities.
They issued a letter on 12.07.2022 requesting the Complainants to execute and register the Agreement for Sale. But, it was the Complainants did not come forward to execute it until February 2024.
A letter from Kotak Mahindra Bank dated 06.01.2025 confirms that the Complainant Company’s unit is not mortgaged. Only unsold units are encumbered.
Guaranteed rent is payable only to allottees who execute the Consent to Let/Rental Agreement. Since the Complainants refused to sign Consent to Let/Rental Agreement, no guaranteed rent is due.
Delay in Sub-Lease Deed registration is attributable to procedural issues with MCD, which the Respondents are actively pursuing.
The Complainants have simultaneously pursued proceedings before the Economic Offences Wing and in Arbitration, amounting to forum shopping and suppression of material facts.
The Complainant’s prayers can be summarised as follows:
To give direction to the Respondents to register the Builder-Buyer Agreement or Agreement for Sale and Sub-lease Deed
To give direction to the Respondents to construct the allotted shop no. FF-157 as permanent Lockable Shop.
To direct the Respondents to hand over the mortgage free physical possession of shop no. FF-157.
To direct the Respondents to pay delayed possession charges.
To take action against Respondents for making substantial deviations from approved layout, sanctioned building plans and take on record that Occupation cum Completion Certificate issued by the Competent Authority is flawed.
To direct the Respondents to pay the Annual Lease Rent and Property Tax till the date of handing over of actual possession of the unit FF-157 and set aside demand of Rs. 1,86,708.97 raised by them.
To direct the Respondents to not to insist on signing of “Consent to Let Out / Rent Agreement”.
We have heard the arguments of the learned counsel for both parties and perused the records.
We may now consider the prayer of the Complainants in detail as follows:
Prayer (i) — Registration of Builder-Buyer Agreement/Agreement for Sale
The fact that the BBA dated 03.02.2024 remains unregistered, is a recorded fact and that both parties’ bear responsibility for this state of affairs. The Respondents collected substantial payments exceeding 10% of the total cost of unit without executing and registering BBA, in clear violation of Section 13(1) of the Act. The Complainants, on their part, continued to make payments over a period of more than three years without insisting upon registration, and signed the BBA only in February 2024 once OCC had already been obtained without taking any steps to ensure its registration.
As a consequence of the non-registration, the BBA creates no binding obligation on either party under the RE (RD) Act, 2016. No rights can be claimed and no obligations can be enforced by either party on the basis of this document in its present state.
Both parties are accordingly directed to take all necessary steps to execute and register the Agreement for Sale in the format prescribed under Rule 3 of the NCT of Delhi Real Estate (Regulation and Development) (Agreement for Sale) Rules, 2016, before the concerned Sub-Registrar, within thirty days from the date of receipt of this order. Upon such registration, all rights and obligations of the parties shall become enforceable in accordance with the terms of the registered Agreement for Sale and the provisions of the Act.
Prayer (ii) — Construction of unit FF-157 as a permanent lockable shop
The Complainant Company’s case is that upon inspection of unit FF-157 on 18.02.2024, they found no lockable shop in existence at the demised premises. The first floor was found to be largely open space, without partitions, lockable doors, or any infrastructure consistent with a functional commercial unit.
The Respondent Company’s defence rests primarily upon the OCC being obtained from MCD on 16.10.2023, which they contend is sufficient proof that the project has been completed as per sanctioned plans. This contention is not accepted as the Respondents have not certified that each individual unit has been fitted out and completed in accordance with its specific agreed specifications.
The prayer of the Complainants is allowed. The Respondents are accordingly directed to ensure that unit FF-157 is constructed, demarcated, and handed over as a fully functional permanent lockable shop, in accordance with the agreed specifications and the sanctioned building plans immediately after registration of BBA. This obligation shall be given effect contemporaneously with, and subject to, the registration of the Agreement for Sale as directed under Prayer (i) above.
Prayer (iii) — Mortgage-free physical possession of unit FF-157
The Complainants have alleged that unit FF-157 has been mortgaged to M/s Kotak Mahindra Bank without their knowledge or consent, which is a serious statutory violation. The Respondents have denied this allegation and have relied upon a letter from Kotak Mahindra Bank dated 06.01.2025, purportedly confirming that the unit referenced as OCDL/FIRST/158 is not mortgaged. The Respondent Company’s explanation is that only unsold units are encumbered.
This Authority notes that the Respondents explanation, though plausible, is not conclusive. The correspondence between unit numbers FF-158 and FF-157, and the precise scope of the mortgage, must be placed beyond all doubt.
The Respondents are, hereby directed to ensure that the allotted unit is handed over free from mortgage and any other encumbrance. They are further directed to file an undertaking before this Authority within thirty days from the date of this order, affirming that unit FF-157 is free from all encumbrances and is not mortgaged to any bank or financial institution. Upon registration of the Agreement for Sale as directed above, the Respondents shall hand over mortgage-free physical possession of unit FF-157 to the Complainants.
Prayer (iv) — Delayed possession charges
The Complainants have claimed interest due to delay in granting possession from the date by which possession ought to have been handed over. Before this Authority adjudicates on the question of delay, it is necessary to take note of the sequence of events as they have unfolded on record.
The Respondents have placed on record that physical possession of unit FF-157 was offered to the Complainants on multiple occasions. The Respondents first offered possession of unit FF-158 on 27.10.2023, shortly after obtaining the OCC from MCD on 16.10.2023. Thereafter, possession was again offered vide the Respondents letter dated 04.03.2024, wherein the Complainant Company was given a last and final opportunity to complete the necessary formalities and take over the unit. On each of these occasions, the Complainants chose not to accept possession, raising objections regarding the condition of the unit.
It is a well-settled principle that a party cannot be permitted to take advantage of its own delay or default. The Complainants, having failed to accept possession when it was offered and have continued to withhold acceptance over an extended period on grounds that were at least partly attributable to their own conduct cannot now turn around and claim compensation for the very period during which they declined to take over the unit.
In these circumstances, the prayer to grant interest on delayed possession is hereby denied.
Prayer (v) — Deviations from sanctioned plans and validity of OCC
The Complainants have consistently alleged, since January 2023, that the project as constructed deviates materially from the sanctioned building plans specifically in respect of the location of unit FF-157 within the floor plan, the reduction in the size of the Central Atrium, and the altered positioning of lifts and common amenities. These objections were raised in writing on 06.02.2023 and followed up repeatedly, without any substantive written response from the Respondents.
The Respondents have argued that the project stands constructed in accordance with the Sanctioned Building Plans, and places considerable reliance on the OCC granted by MCD as conclusive proof of this fact. This Authority has no reason to dispute the weight that such a certificate carries. The OCC has been issued by the competent authority after due inspection. Any allegation of unapproved deviations or changes to the Sanctioned Building Plans, in the face of a validly issued OCC, is debatable and cannot be accepted at face value. The Respondents are directed to file an affidavit before this Authority within Thirty days from the date of this order, affirming that the project, including unit FF-157, has been constructed strictly in accordance with the approved layout and sanctioned building plans submitted at the time of registration, and that no deviations have been made therefrom. In case the sanctioned building plans have been revised subsequently, the Respondents would show that due approval of this Authority was taken and no provision of the Act has been violated.
In the circumstances, the Respondents are directed to file an Affidavit before this Authority within Thirty days from the date of this order, stating that the project, including unit FF-157, has been constructed in accordance with the sanctioned building and approved layout plans, and that no deviation or unauthorised change have been made. Prayer (vi) —
Property Tax, and demand of Rs. 1,86,708.97/-
The Respondents have raised a demand of Rs. 1,86,708.97/- upon the Complainants towards Annual Lease Rent and Property Tax in respect of unit FF-157. The Complainants have contended that these charges are not payable by them, as actual possession of the unit has not been handed over.
The legal position is unambiguous. Section 11(4) of the RE (RD) Act, 2016 casts a statutory obligation upon the Promoter to discharge all outgoings including lease rent, ground rent, municipal taxes, and other charges in respect of the unit until actual possession is handed over to the allottee. The Respondents offer of symbolic possession in October 2023 does not constitute actual handover within the meaning of the Act.
In these circumstances, the demand of Rs. 1,86,708.97/- raised by the Respondents upon the Complainants is contrary to the statutory mandate of Section 11(4) and is hereby set aside. The Respondents are directed to bear and discharge the Annual Lease Rent and Property Tax in respect of unit FF-157 until the date of actual handover of possession to the Complainants in accordance with law.
Prayer (vii) — Consent to Let Out/Rental Agreement
The Respondents have insisted upon the execution of a “Consent to Let Out/Rental Agreement” as a precondition both for handing over possession and for payment of guaranteed rent. The Complainants have refused to execute this document, contending that it is unilateral, one-sided, and not part of the original agreement between the parties.
Agreement to Sell is dependent on sweet will of the parties, the promisee parties cannot be forced or coerced in any way to enter into any other Agreement. The Authority finds that the introduction of the “Consent to Let Out/Rental Agreement” as a precondition for possession or for the discharge of any obligation flowing from the allotment is not permissible under the RE (RD) Act, 2016. An obligation under the Act and under the Agreement for Sale cannot be held hostage to subsequent demand of Promoter on allottee to accept & sign a fresh, unilateral, post-allotment document that was not part of the original terms of the transaction. The Respondents cannot unilaterally introduce new condition after allotment and make fulfilment of their statutory and contractual obligations contingent upon the allottee’s compliance with those conditions.
In view of the above, Authority hereby orders as follows:
Both parties are directed to execute and register the Agreement for Sale as per the provisions of the Act and Model Agreement for sale annexed to Rule 3 of National Capital Territory of Delhi Real Estate (Regulation and Development) (Agreement for Sale) Rules, 2016 before the concerned Sub-Registrar within thirty days from the date of this order.
The Respondents are directed to file an undertaking before this Authority within thirty days from the date of this order, affirming that unit FF-157 is free from all mortgages and encumbrances, and shall hand over mortgage-free physical possession thereof to the Complainants upon registration of the Agreement for Sale.
The Respondents are directed to ensure that unit FF-157 is constructed, and handed over to the Complainants, in accordance with the agreed specifications and sanctioned building plans immediately after registration of Agreement for Sale.
No interest can be given to Complainants for delay in granting possession due to reasons explained earlier.
The Respondents are directed to file an Affidavit-cum-Undertaking within Thirty days from the date of this order, affirming that the project has been executed in accordance with the sanctioned building and approved layout plans, and no deviation has been made therefrom. If these plans have been revised, the Respondents shall demonstrate that they took prior approval of this Authority before their implementation.
The demand of Rs. 1,86,708.97/- raised by the Respondents towards Annual Lease Rent and Property Tax is hereby set aside. The Respondents shall bear Annual Lease Rent and Property Tax until actual handover of possession to the Complainants.
The office is also directed to issue notice -
To the Respondents to explain why action should not be taken against them under Section 61 of the RE(RD) Act, 2016, for accepting more than ten percent of the total cost of the unit from the Complainants before registering the Agreement for Sale in violation of Section 13 of the RE(RD) Act, 2016.
To the Respondents to file an Affidavit before this Authority that Occupation Cum Completion Certificate has been issued for complete project and is not for partial completion.
For directing the Respondents to inform about all loans taken for the project since registration and whether they informed this Authority about availing of these loans.
To direct Commissioner MCD, to explain why sub-lease deed are not being executed in such cases.
No order as to cost.
File be consigned to record room after due compliance.
