AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
Order dated 21.11.2025 contains some typo error. The extract of the relevant portion is reproduced as below:
The husband of the complainant no. 1 herein was using the vehicle which was registered in the name of Ms. Ruhi Parveen, who was listed as respondent no. 4 before the District Commission and during the accident she died. During the hearing, it was pointed that during the accident it was the husband of the Respondent No.1, who died, i.e. Mr. Kamaruddin Ansari. Accordingly, the said order is hereby corrected to that extent.
Present SA has been filed with a delay of 473 days as per calculations made by the Registry. In order to condone the delay in filing the SA, the Appellant has to satisfy this Commission that there was sufficient cause for preferring the SA after the stipulated limitation period. An IA No.13593 of 2025 has been filed seeking condonation of delay. In the said IA, period of delay mentioned is 430 days and following reasons for delay / grounds for condonation have been mentioned:
The impugned judgment was 28.06.2024 and a certified copy was applied on 05.06.2025 and a certified copy was presented on 10.05.2025. In between, the Appellants were not properly advised by their previous Advocate as to the correct forum for approaching against the impugned judgment. The Appellants in bonafide pursuance of their remedies approached the Hon'ble High Court of Chhattisgarh in WP227 No.641 of 2025 on 17.06.2025 which was then withdrawn on 11.07.2025, for which period the Appellants seek the benefit of Section 14 of the Limitation Act;
The delay has occurred due to significant time required to transmit certified copies and then translate all documents from Hindi to English in order to understand the judgment of the District Commission and State Commission.
The Appellant herein relied upon the judgment of the Collector, Land Acquisition, Anantnag And Another vs. Ms. Katiji And Others, 1987 S SCC 107.
IA seeking condonation of delay is strongly opposed by learned Counsel for the Respondents who submits that no satisfactory explanation has been given seeking condonation of delay. Learned Counsel for the Respondents submits that the Appellants herein being the Appellants themselves before the State Commission were fully aware of the impugned order dated 28.06.2024. No satisfactory explanation has been given why they took almost one year for applying the certified copy of the said order.
A perusal of the records before us show that the impugned order of the State Commission was pronounced on 28.06.2024 and the present SA has been filed on 13.11.2025, i.e., after a period of 503 days. Allowing the period of the statutory permissible period of 30 days, the delay in filing SA comes to 473 days.
We have carefully gone through the reasons for delay / grounds for condonation mentioned in IA No.13593 of 2025 as well as those adduced during the hearing in the light of observations/decisions of Hon'ble Supreme Court and this Commission in various cases. In Sheo Raj Singh (deceased) through Legal Representative and Ors. Vs. Union of India and Anr. (2023) 10 SCC 531, Hon'ble Supreme Court observed that condonation of delay being a discretionary power available to courts, exercise of discretion must necessarily depend upon the sufficiency of the cause shown and the degree of acceptability of the explanation, the lengths of delay being immaterial, each case for condonation of delay based on the existence or absence of sufficient cause has to be decided on its own facts. In Basawaraj and Another. Vs. Special Land Acquisition Officer (2013) 14 SCC 81, the Hon'ble Supreme Court observed that when a case is filed beyond the limitation period, the applicant must demonstrate "sufficient cause," meaning an adequate and enough reason for not approaching the court within the prescribed time. If the party is found to be negligent, lacking bona fides, or not acting diligently, there is no justified ground for condoning the delay. Courts are not justified in condoning such delays by imposing any conditions and must adhere to the established parameters for condonation of delay. Condoning delay without sufficient cause and proper justification would violate statutory provisions and show disregard for legislative intent. In Esha Bhattcharjee v. Raghunathpur Nafar Academy [(2013) 12 SCC 649], the Hon'ble Supreme Court expressed concern over the growing tendency to perceive delay as a trivial matter and to exhibit a lackadaisical attitude towards it, which needs to be addressed within the confines of legal parameters. In Popat Bahiru Govardhane v. Land Acquisition Officer, (2013) 10 SCC 765, the Supreme Court affirmed the principle that the law of limitation must be applied rigorously as prescribed by statute, even if it causes hardship to a particular party. The court cannot extend the limitation period on equitable grounds. In H. Dohil Constructions Co. (P) Ltd. v. Nahar Exports Ltd., (2015) 1 SCC 680, the Hon'ble Supreme Court emphasized that the law of limitation is based on sound public policy, and therefore, applications for condonation of delay should be strictly construed in the absence of genuine reasons. Hon'ble Supreme Court in Pathapati Subba Reddy v. LAO, 2024 SCC OnLine SC 513 observed that the law of limitation is rooted in the public policy of concluding litigation by forfeiting the remedy rather than the right itself, emphasizing that rights or remedies not exercised within a specified time should cease to exist. In State of M.P. v. Bherulal, (2020) 10 SCC 654, the Supreme Court observed that the notion that merit in a case justifies disregarding a period of delay is preposterous. Regardless of a case's merit, the limitation period can bar its consideration, potentially excluding even strong cases. However, this does not negate the court's jurisdiction to condone delay in appropriate circumstances. In Bappanand Narshimman Annu Vs. Hirmanidevi G.S. Gupta & Ors., 2016 SCC OnLine NCDRC 2605, the National Commission observed that in accordance with the broad principles established by numerous decisions of the Hon'ble Supreme Court, the term 'sufficient cause' cannot be interpreted liberally when negligence, inaction, or lack of bonafides are attributable to the party seeking such discretion. Emphasizing the importance of applying the statutory period of limitation rigorously, the Commission observed that unlimited leniency in time limits fosters uncertainty.
The reasons for delay stated in the IA No.13593 of 2025 and those adduced during the hearing are not found convincing. Further, if a party pursues a wrong remedy or approaches a wrong Forum, they cannot claim the benefit of Limitation Act. In this case, the Appellants herein have chosen to approach the Honble High Court of Chattisgarh while the Appeal against the order of the State Commission lies before the National Commission. Hence, this cannot be accepted as a sufficient cause for delay. Moreover, the said Writ Petition was withdrawn from the High Court on 11.07.2025 and the present SA has been filed on 13.11.2025 i.e. after a delay of 126 days. No valid explanation has been given even for this period of delay. Hence, we are of the considered view that the Appellants have not given cogent reasons for delay in filing the SA. The Appellants after being aware of the impugned order, acted in a negligent manner and have failed to explain the sufficient cause of delay. Accordingly, IA No.13593 of 2025 seeking condonation of delay is dismissed. Consequently, SA No.761 of 2025 is also dismissed being barred by limitation.
All other pending IAs, if any, also stand disposed of.
