High CourtsDivision Bench(1957) 07 MP CK 0029

Harihar prasad vs State

Madhya Pradesh High Court · Decided on 26 July 1957 · Citation: (1958) JLJ 480

RESULT
Dismissed
CASE NUMBER
L.P.A. No. 99 of 1954

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

6 paragraphs · 469 words

Hidayatullah C.J.

1.

This Letters Patent appeal was filed against an order made by Bhutt J, on 21st October 1954, but most of the grounds which have been urged against the learned Single judge's decision have now been abandoned except one.

2.

The appellant contends that the meeting of the Sabha, which took place on the 24th and 25th March 1954 with the old councillors constituting the Sabha, was illegal in view of the fact that on 27th November 1953 the election of the new councillors had been notified and they must be deemed to have entered office from that date, The learned Single Judge in his discussion has considered the effect of Section 20 along with Section 33 of the C. P. and Berar Local Government Act, 1948. The learned Judge has held that Section 20 is only an enabling provision and that the councillors do not enter upon their office by the fact of mere notification. In our opinion, and we say it with all due respect, the matter has to be considered u/s 12 and the scheme of the Act.

3.

Under the scheme of the Act, the first Sabha had to be nominated, because the elections were not required. The nominated Sabha continued in office according to the proviso to sub-section (1) of Section 12 either till the 31st March 1954 of an earlier date, if so notified by the State Government. If is admitted before us that there was no notification by the State Government terminating the life of the nominated Sabha prior to 31st March 1954. Thus, in accordance with the proviso, which is a special law enacted to indicate the life of the nominated Sabha. the old Sabha continued till 31st March 1954. The meeting was held on 24th and 25th March 1954 and was within the life of the old nominated Sabha.

4.

It is contended that by virtue of the notification the new councillors must be deemed to have entered office. But, in our opinion, that provision can only come into play after an elected Sabha has taken office after its first meeting. The life of the nominated Sabha has been statutorily fixed, and it can only be cut short by a notification of the State Government, which it is admitted before us, was never issued. In view of this, the point mooted before us, namely whether the meeting of the 24th and 25th March 1954 by the old councillors was in order is answered in the affirmative, though for reasons different from those of the learned Single Judge. The appeal fails and is dismissed.

5.

In view of the circumstances of the case and considering that the whole of the matter has now been righted by an Act, we see no reason to award costs in the present matter.