AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
G.S. Sandhawalia, J.
C.M. No. 14982-CII of 2011
This is an application for condoning delay in refiling the appeal.
Application is allowed in view of averments made in the application, which is duly supported by an affidavit.
RSA No. 5141 of 2011
The present appeal has been filed by the defendant who is aggrieved against the concurrent findings of the Courts below whereby the suit for possession of the plaintiff-respondent for land measuring 38 kanals 15 marlas has been allowed.
The brief facts of the case are that the respondent-plaintiff purchased the land from Seeba Ram through three different sale deeds, two of which are dated 16.12.1997 and one is dated 18.12.1998. It is alleged that the plaintiff is a Non Resident Indian and the land owner Seeba Ram was also a Non Resident Indian and the land was being looked after by Nazar Ram-father of the appellant. After the death of Nazar Ram, Gurmail Singh-the present appellant started looking after the land as a care taker. In an earlier suit filed by the appellant-defendant for permanent injunction which was decided on 27.11.2004, it had been held that the land owner could get possession in due course of law since admittedly possession was with the present appellant. The present suit was instituted thereafter on 03.02.2005; wherein the plaintiff-respondent claimed possession of the land. The plea taken by the defendant was that he was a tenant and only the Revenue Courts would have the right to decide the dispute of tenancy.
The Trial Court, after examining the pleadings and the evidence on record, came to the conclusion that mere mentioning of the word "gair marusi" would not prove that the defendant was a tenant and there was no evidence on record to show that he had been inducted as a tenant. There was nothing in writing with regard to any creation of tenancy or lease or theka. Reference was also made to the judgment dated 27.11.2004 to hold that it had only been held earlier that the defendant was in possession but there was no finding that he was in possession as a tenant. Accordingly, the suit was decreed on 23.01.2009.
The appellant preferred an appeal before the Lower Appellate Court wherein also, the issue was raised regarding the jurisdiction of the Civil Court as the property was agricultural in nature. The Lower Appellate Court, while discussing the evidence, has come to the conclusion that the defendant did not produce any receipt on the file and there is nothing to show if any rent had been paid to the plaintiff and that the defendant-appellant was a nephew of Seeba Ram, the original owner of the land and thus was continuing in possession. Accordingly, it was held that it could not be held that he is a tenant on the basis of the entry in column no. 5 of the Jama bandi and that his possession over the suit land was at most permissible and accordingly the appeal was dismissed.
Counsel for the appellant has contended that the Civil Court had no jurisdiction since it was a dispute between the landlord and tenant of the agricultural land and, therefore, the Revenue Court would have jurisdiction, in view of the bar u/s 77 of the Punjab Tenancy Act, 1887 and learned counsel has placed reliance on the judgment dated 27.11.2004 Ex.P-2 inter se between the parties. However, a perusal of the said judgment shows that the present appellant had filed a suit for permanent injunction whereby he sought protection that Sant Ram should not take possession by force of the land in dispute. So, a specific issue was framed regarding the fact that whether the present appellant was in possession of the suit land as tenant. However, the Court came to a conclusion that the possession of the plaintiff was clearly established and, therefore, the defendant cannot be allowed to take the law into his hand and dispossess the plaintiff forcibly and possession can only be taken after following the due process of law. However, no finding was recorded that there is a relationship of landlord and tenant between the parties. Accordingly, the issue was decided in favour of the plaintiff therein, who is the appellant in the present appeal. Thus, once it was held that there was no relationship of a landlord and tenant between the parties nor any finding has been recorded that there was any rent being paid by the appellant; the contention that the Civil Court would have no jurisdiction is not justified. Both the Courts below have already come to a conclusion that there is no written document inter se between the parties which would show that there is a relationship of landlord and tenant.
Thus in view of the absence of any such evidence before the Court, no substantial question of law arises for consideration. The orders passed by the Courts below are just and there is no perversity as such which can call for interference in regular second appeal.
Accordingly, the present appeal is dismissed.
