High CourtsDivision Bench(2018) 03 DEL CK 0146

Govind vs State

Delhi High Court · Decided on 23 March 2018

HON’BLE JUDGES
S. MAUMDAR, I.S. MEHTA
RESULT
Disposed Of
CASE NUMBER
CRL.A. 81 Of 2015

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

151 paragraphs · 4,400 words

1.This appeal 8th December 2014 is directed against the passed by the learned impugned Addi(cid:37)onal judgment dated Sessions

Judge-II(„ASJ‟), (North-West), Rohini Courts, Delhi in Sessions Case No.147/2013 arising out of FIR No.244/2013 registered at Police Sta(cid:37)on

(„PS‟) Sultanpuri convic(cid:37)ng the Appellant, Govind, for the offence punishable under Sec(cid:37)on 302 Indian Penal Code („IPC‟), and the order on sentence dated 15th December 2014 whereby he was sentenced to rigorous imprisonment (RI) for life with the further condi(cid:37)on that

he would spend at least 25 years in actual custody and “shall not be considered for grant of remission (cid:37)ll he undergoes an actual sentence

of 25 years” and also a fine for a sum of Rs. 2 lakhs; and in default of payment of fine, to undergo simple imprisonment (SI) for a further

period of six months. The fine amount recovered was ordered to be disbursed to the families/LRs of the deceased, Babloo and Ramesh @

Ramesh, as compensation under Section 357 Cr PC.

2.At the outset, it must be noted that the Appellant, Govind (A-1), was sent up for trial along with Anoop @ Lakhan (A-2) and Sa(cid:37)sh Kumar @

Sonu @ Soda (A-3). The charge against them was that on or before 6th April 2013, all three of them hatched a criminal conspiracy to commit the murder of the deceased, Bablu @ Bhushan and Ramesh @ Lambu, thereby commi(cid:71)ng the offences under Sec(cid:37)on 120B IPC; that at around 5.00

pm on 6th April 2013, at the second floor of House No.P1/970, Sultanpuri, Delhi pursuant to the above stated conspiracy, all three of them

commi(cid:75)ed the murder of Babloo @ Bhushan and Ramesh @ Lambu thereby commi(cid:71)ng offences under Sec(cid:37)on 302 read with 120B IPC. By the impugned judgment, the trial Court has acquitted A-2 and A-3 of the aforementioned offences.

Case of the prosecution

3.On 6th April 2013, at around 6.28 pm, informa(cid:37)on was received at PS Sultanpuri regarding a stabbing incident involving two boys at Gali No.5,

P-1 Block. This informa(cid:37)on was noted down as DD No. 47A. Sub Inspector („SI‟) Vikas Pawar (PW-28) along with Constable („Ct.‟) Balbir

Singh (PW-29) reached the spot and came to know that the incident had taken place inside House No.P-1/970, Second Floor. A large crowd had

gathered. The police team found the dead bodies of two males, one on the floor with head facing towards the northern wall and one on the folding bed with the head facing in the southern direc(cid:37)on towards the door. On enquiries being made, the police team learnt that the bodies were of Babloo @ Bhushan and Ramesh @ Lambu both of whom were friends. While Babloo was stated to be residing as a tenant in the same

room, Ramesh was a resident of Vijay Vihar. The crime team was called to the spot and inquires were made from public persons regarding eye-

witnesses. However, no one came forward to give informa(cid:37)on to the police. Both dead bodies were sent to the mortuary for post-mortem

examination.

Post-mortem examinations

4.Dr. Manoj Dhingra (PW-17) performed the post-mortem examina(cid:37)on of the dead body of Babloo and no(cid:37)ced one stab wound measuring 4

cm x 1.3 cm “cavity deep (upto pancreas and aorta) wedge shaped lying obliquely in epigastrium area”; one incised wound, seen over mid

lateral aspect of dorsum of le(cid:79) hand; and an incised wound on the le(cid:79) palm. The death was opined to be due to “shock associated with

damage for abdominal structures under Injury No.1” which was deemed to be sufficient to cause death in the ordinary course of nature. Dr.

Dhingra was assisted in the exercise by Dr. Vivek Rawat (PW-18).

5.PWs- 17 and 18 also performed the post-mortem examina(cid:37)on of Ramesh @ Lambu. They found a stab wound 4 cm x 1.3 cm “cavity deep

(upto pancreas and aorta)” and an incised wound situated 3.5 cm inferolateral to injury no.1. There was a reddish coloured abrasion 4 cm x 3

cm over the left knee. Injury No.1 was said to have been sufficient to have caused the death.

6.In respect of both Babloo and Lambu, it was noted in the post-mortem reports that “there was history of chronic alcoholism”.

Apparently, the viscera were not preserved to confirm this.

Investigation

7.The inves(cid:37)ga(cid:37)on of the case was taken over by Inspector K.S.N. Subudhi (PW-32) who was posted at PS Sultanpuri as Sta(cid:37)on House Officer

(SHO). When he reached the spot, he found PW-28, PW-29 and Ct. Komesh (PW-30) were already present there. He prepared the site plan

(Ex.PW-28/B). PW-28 converted the DD No. 47A into rukka and handed it over to Ct. Sa(cid:37)sh for registra(cid:37)on of the FIR. A(cid:79)er receipt of the registered FIR, PW-32 lifted various exhibits from the spot including earth control sample.

8.A(cid:79)er the post-mortem examina(cid:37)ons, the police returned to C-Block, Sultanpuri and the statements of Sagar (PW-12) and Vinod (PW-9) were

recorded. PW-12 was only 14 years old and a resident of a jhuggi in Block P-1, Sultan Puri. He stated that on 6th April 2013, at around 12.30 pm,

he was sitting with PW-9 in the park in Block C-6 of Sultanpuri when he noticed that a quarrel was ongoing between Ramesh and Babloo on one side and Govind, Anoop and Sa(cid:37)sh Kumar on the other. He saw Ramesh slap Govind. PW-12 claimed that he and PW-9 pacified the par(cid:37)es. He

no(cid:37)ced that the present Appellant had a knife and he was snatched by Ramesh. While Ramesh and Babloo therea(cid:79)er le(cid:79) the park, the

Appellant was using abusive language against them. The Appellant is stated to have followed Ramesh and returned with the knife while also

muttering, “aaj hi aaj me inhe maroonga”.

10.The statement of Sagar was recorded before the learned Metropolitan Magistrate („MM‟) (Ex.PX/6) under Sec(cid:37)on 164 Cr PC on 20th April

2013. In the said statement, he stated that he and PW-9 were, at 12.30 pm on 6th April 2013, proceeding from their house towards the park at

Block C-6 when they no(cid:37)ced that Ramesh was with Babloo. Ramesh slapped Govind who had a knife. Ramesh then snatched Govind‟s knife.

Therea(cid:79)er, they fought and Govind took back the knife. Therea(cid:79)er, Babloo went away. He further added that Ramesh had also slapped Sa(cid:37)sh

Kumar. After some time, Anoop, Govind and Satish Kumar are stated to have come to the park and all three of them began abusing Ramesh and

Babloo. Govind, Anoop and Sa(cid:37)sh Kumar were all three sta(cid:37)ng that they will kill Babloo and Ramesh. Govind is stated to have had a knife with a long iron blade. A(cid:79)er some (cid:37)me, the three co-accused as well as PWs- 9 and 12 le(cid:79). PW-12 also states that Govind had consumed ten golis

(drugs) and he was giving a large number of the said golis to Ramesh and Babloo. He stated that he suspected that it was Govind who, along

with Anoop, had killed Ramesh and Babloo.

164The police also recorded the statement of Vinod (PW-9) under Sec(cid:37)on Cr PC. In his statement, Vinod (PW-9) stated that a fight ensued between Babloo and Ramesh on the one hand and Govind, Anoop and Sa(cid:37)sh Kumar on the other hand; Ramesh had slapped Govind, Anoop and Sa(cid:37)sh Kumar and both PW-9 and 12 had tried to pacify them; that Ramesh had snatched the knife of Govind and Govind forced him to give it back and therea(cid:79)er, Ramesh and Babloo le(cid:79) from there. Govind was abusing the two deceased and also threatened to kill them. Anoop and

Sa(cid:37)sh Kumar were also with Govind at the (cid:37)me. According to PW-9, that is all he saw and a(cid:79)er that, both of them, i.e. PW-9 and PW-12, le(cid:79)

from there and he was not aware as to what happened thereafter.

11.PW-32 stated that on 8th April 2013, he received informa(cid:37)on that A-2 and A-3 were si(cid:71)ng in the park in Block C-6. He cons(cid:37)tuted a raiding party and found both A-2 and A-3 in the corner of the park and got both of them apprehended, interrogated, and arrested. Their disclosure statements were recorded. Both stated to have disclosed the name of the third accused, i.e. Govind (A-1), who was injured a(cid:79)er he jumped from a roof and was stated to be present in his house.

12.A-1 was therea(cid:79)er apprehended from his house. He is supposed to have disclosed that he had received the injuries at the (cid:37)me of incident.

He had already been medically examined and treated at Jeevan Hospital. He produced treatment papers from Jeevan Hospital. These were taken into possession under seizure memo (Ex.PW-26/I). In his disclosure statement, A-1 is stated to have offered to get the weapon of offence recovered as well as the clothes he was wearing at the (cid:37)me of incident. The clothes were a T-shirt, capri and an underwear. These were converted into a pullanda and sealed and taken into possession.

13.Neeraj (PW-16), the son of the landlord of the place of incident, then met the police. He iden(cid:37)fied all the three accused sta(cid:37)ng that they were the same persons who had met him on 6th April 2013. The accused then took the police to the place of incidence and the poin(cid:37)ng out memo was drawn up. Therea(cid:79)er, A-1 is stated to have led the police party towards the ganda nala, Block P-1, Sultanpuri and got recovered the knife which was used in the commission of the offence (Ex.PW-16/A).

14.While the police were s(cid:37)ll at the ganda nala, one child, Gaurav (PW-24), came to the spot and iden(cid:37)fied A-1 as the person who was having injuries on both his legs and A-1 had requested PW-24 for using his mobile phone to call somebody from his family to pick him up. The accused were then sent to SGM hospital for medical examina(cid:37)on. They were produced before the Illaka Magistrate and they were remanded to judicial

custody. At the end of the inves(cid:37)ga(cid:37)on, the police filed a charge sheet. By an order dated 27th August 2013, charges were framed as indicated hereinbefore against the three accused.

Statement of the accused under S 313 Cr PC

15.Thirty-three witnesses were examined by the prosecu(cid:37)on. In his statement under Sec(cid:37)on 313 Cr PC, while denying the circumstances put to him, A-1 stated that it is a false case in which he has been falsely implicated and that no recoveries at his instance have been made. He maintained that the police want to save the real culprits and, therefore, had made a false case against him.

16.A supplementary statement was recorded on 27th August 2013 that the accused were admi(cid:71)ng the statements made under Sec(cid:37)on 164 Cr

PC of Vinod and Sagar and they had no objection if the learned MM who had recorded the statement is not examined as a witness.

Impugned judgment of the trial Court

17.By the impugned judgment, the learned trial Court came to the following conclusions:

(i)Neeraj (PW-16) was the landlord of the deceased, Babloo. He confirmed that at around 11.00 am on 6th April 2013, he was leaving his house and he saw that A-1 and A-2 were calling out to Babloo. According to PW-16, he had learnt that Babloo was involved in stealing/the(cid:79) and was not a man of good character. The grandmother of PW-16 had asked Babloo to vacate the room but Babloo had requested her to permit him to stay explaining that his daughter was studying and her educa(cid:37)on was con(cid:37)nuing in a local school. On the date of the incident, Babloo‟s minor daughter was not present.

(ii)The oral testimony of PW-16 and members of the investigation team had confirmed that both the deceased were good friends and that they

o(cid:79)en consumed alcohol and drugs together; this was confirmed from the post-mortem and viscera reports; A-1, A-2, and A-3 were also addicted to drugs; at the (cid:37)me of incident, A-1 consumed intoxica(cid:37)ng pills and was under the influence thereby exhibi(cid:37)ng extremely

aggressive behaviour.

(iii)PW-9 and PW-12 had confirmed that both of them were ganja addicts and o(cid:79)en went to the park at C-Block, Sultanpuri. They witnessed the quarrel between A-1, A-2 and A-3 on the one side and the two deceased on the other at around 12.30 pm. They pacified it.

(iv)Both PW-9 and PW-12 spoke about A-1 taking out the knife and threatening Ramesh @ Lambu who then snatched knife and walked away but A-1 followed him and retrieved the knife. He threatened to kill both the deceased on the same day. PW-9 and PW-12 had supported each other on the material aspects. While PW-9 and PW-12 had confirmed the presence of A-2 and A-3, no allega(cid:37)ons were made against A-2 or A-3

of having issued any threats.

(v)On the date of incident, A-1 was found in an injured condi(cid:37)on by Gaurav Kumar (PW-24). He was found si(cid:71)ng in front of his house crying in

pain. A-1 was si(cid:71)ng on the chabutra. Gaurav Kumar was aged about 14 years. A-1 is supposed to have used the mobile phone of the mother of

PW-24 for making a call.

(vi)A-1 did not deny his presence in the area par(cid:37)cularly in the front the house of PW-24. He failed to explain why he reached the area, i.e. P-

1/84, Sultanpuri situated in the same street where Babloo was residing. Electronic evidence confirmed that A-1 had made a call from the mobile number of the mother of PW-24 at 5.33 pm and A-1 did not deny the same. He, however, claimed that he had met with a motorcycle

accident. The killings of the two deceased was discovered soon thereafter. Around 6.30 pm, a call was made to the PCR.

(vii)As per Sec(cid:37)on 106 of the Indian Evidence Act („IEA‟), A-1 was the person in the best posi(cid:37)on to offer an explana(cid:37)on for his injuries. His claim that he met with a motorcycle accident stands demolished due to the medical record (Ex.PW-13/A) which confirms that he had received fractures on both heel bones. Such an injury could only have been sustained on account of a fall from a height and not due to a road accident.

This is consistent with the fact that the family members had given the history to Dr. Ashutosh Gupta (PW-13) of Jeevan Hospital as fall from a

height. There was close proximity between when A-1 had come to the house of Babloo looking from him and Ramesh at 11.00 am and the quarrel that took place in C-Block park at 12.30 pm.

(viii)The recovery of the knife at the instance of A-1 was also believed. This was witnessed by PW-25 as well was an independent witness.

There was human blood on the t-shirt of the Appellant.

(ix)It was argued before the learned trial Court that the Appellant was under the influence of drugs having consumed intoxica(cid:37)ng pills and

was, therefore, incapable of knowing the nature of the act or that what he was doing is contrary to the law. A(cid:79)er referring to Sec(cid:37)on 85 and 86

IPC, the trial Court held that Sec(cid:37)ons 85 and 86 protected only such offenders being intoxicated “without knowledge or against their will”.

It was held that such a defence does not come to the aid of an offender who “voluntary consumes alcohol or other intoxica(cid:37)ng substances

like drugs etc. and then commits the offence”. Even otherwise, A-1 was fully conscious and aware of the consequences of his act. It is for this

reason that a(cid:79)er commi(cid:71)ng the double murder he panicked and in order to save himself and avoid detec(cid:37)on, he jumped from the window of the bathroom a(cid:75)ached to the room of the deceased onto the roof of the lower floor which is how he sustained the injuries on his ankles. It was held that no person can be permi(cid:75)ed to voluntarily consume drugs/intoxicants and then wreak havoc by going on a killing spree and claim

the same as a defence.

18.Accordingly, the trial Court proceeded to acquit A-2 and A-3 while convic(cid:37)ng A-1 for the offence under Sec(cid:37)on 302 IPC and sentenced him by a separate order on sentence in the manner indicated hereinbefore.

19.This Court has heard the submissions of Mr. M.L. Yadav, learned counsel for the Appellant and Mr. Kewal Singh Ahuja, learned APP for the

State.

Last seen

20.It is submi(cid:75)ed by Mr. Yadav, learned counsel for the Appellant that there was no actual evidence of „last seen‟ because PW-16 saw the accused outside the house of the deceased at 11.00 am and therea(cid:79)er, PWs- 9 and12 spoke about his presence in the park at 12.30 pm whereas the deaths are supposed to have occurred around 5.00 pm. On account of the (cid:37)me gap between the (cid:37)me of death and the (cid:37)me of „last

seen‟ and also on account of the fact that the place of „last seen‟ was not the same as the place where the dead body was found, the evidence of PWs- 16, 9, and 12 cannot be said to be „last seen‟ evidence.

21.The statement of PW-12 statement under Sec(cid:37)on 164 Cr PC was recorded on 20th April 2013 itself. He speaks of the presence of the deceased in the park at around 12.30 pm quarrelling with A-1, A-2 and A-3. This is fully corroborated by PW-9. Both their statements under

Sec(cid:37)on 164 Cr PC were not challenged by the accused in terms of the statement recorded by the trial Court on 27th August 2013. Therefore, it clearly shows that there was a quarrel preceding the incident but not immediately prior to the (cid:37)me of death. There was sufficient (cid:37)me for the accused to commit the murder of the two deceased. Neither PW-9 nor PW-12 has been shaken in their cross-examination.

22.As pointed out by the trial Court, both these witnesses proved that the two deceased and the three accused were also drug addicts. Even

PW-16 has confirmed that the deceased used to consume drugs and Babloo was not of a good character. He also no(cid:37)ced A-1 and A-2 outside the house where the offence occurred at 11.00 am.

23.Although there is a (cid:37)me gap between when the quarrel involving the two deceased and the three co-accused took place and the (cid:37)me of

deaths, i.e. 5.00 pm, in the absence of evidence which would probablise the presence of either the Appellant or the two deceased elsewhere,

such evidence can be taken to be evidence of „last seen‟. This circumstance is therefore conclusively proved by the prosecution.

Presence of Appellant at the scene of crime

24.There is no direct evidence to prove the presence of the Appellant at the scene of crime. However, PW-24 spoke of the presence of the

Appellant at the chabutra in front of his house at around 5.30 pm which is not far from the house of the deceased. The case of the prosecu(cid:37)on is that the Appellant panicked a(cid:79)er having commi(cid:75)ed the murders of the two deceased and jumped first on to the roof of the the first floor and thereafter again on the street thereby fracturing both his heels.

25.Strangely, the Appellant does not deny that he was on the chabutra. The explana(cid:37)on given by him for being found there is strange. In

answer to ques(cid:37)on 21 regarding the evidence of PW-24, he said that “the alleged incident has nothing to do with the offence. The injuries

sustained by me were due to road accident”. The Appellant also did not deny that he had used the mobile phone bearing the number

8743977286 “to inform the family members about my accident”. He did not know about the owner of the mobile phone “but some boy

gave me the mobile phone”. Therefore, he did not deny that he was in fact on the chabutra and borrowed the phone from PW-24 to call his

family.

26.Then we have the evidence of the treatment received by the Appellant at Jeevan Hospital. This is spoken to by Dr. Ashutosh Gupta (PW-13).

He states that at around 7.30 pm the Appellant was brought there to the Jeevan Hospital where he was working as Orthopaedic Surgeon on 6th

April 2013. The OPD receipt issued by him is marked as Ex.PW-13/A. As per his deposi(cid:37)on, the Appellant was brought there by his mother,

Santosh, brother, Bunty, and another brother, Ram Kishan “with alleged history of fall from height”. Therefore, this clearly showed that

the explana(cid:37)on offered by the Appellant for the fractures on both heels being due to a road accident was false. The medical evidence disproved this. There is no cross-examination of PW-13 to suggest that he was speaking falsehood.

Other circumstances

27.The FSL report was proved by Santosh Tripathi (PW-15). The blood samples of the two deceased showed the presence of alcohol, and clearly therefore both the deceased were to in an inebriated state.

28.The Court is sa(cid:37)sfied that the Appellant has no valid explana(cid:37)on for the injuries on both heels. He has not cared to examine his own mother and brothers. The medical evidence disproves that he suffered injuries as a result of a road accident.

29.It is argued by Mr. Yadav that the chabutra was at a distance from the house of the deceased. He submits that the prosecu(cid:37)on has not been able to explain how the Appellant could, in such an injured condition, possibly carry himself to the chabutra.

30.On the other hand, the learned APP sought to explain that the Appellant could have dragged himself to the chabutra which was down the road where the house of the deceased was. In fact, it was pursuant to his own disclosure that he could reach Jeevan Hospital and collected the medical treatment papers as proved by PW-26, PW-31, and the IO (PW-32).

31.The t-shirt worn by the Appellant also had bloodstains which were of human blood. This is apart from the fact that the knife got recovered at his instance from the ganda nala.

Proved circumstances

32.Therefore, the following circumstances can be said to have been proved by the prosecution beyond reasonable doubt:

(i)The presence of the Appellant outside the house of the deceased at 11.00 am as proved by PW-16;

(ii)The quarrel that took place in the park between the accused and the deceased as spoken to by PWs- 9 and 12;

(iii)The fact that the accused was consuming drugs and also giving them to the deceased is again proved by PWs 9 and 12;

(iv)Homicidal death of the both deceased from the house of Babloo at around 5.00-5.30 pm;

(v)The accused being found with injuries to his heels at chabutra by PW-24 outside the house of PW-24 which is down road from the place where the house of the deceased was located;

(vi)The accused opera(cid:37)ng the mobile phone of PW-24 to make a call informing family members at 5.30 pm as proved by the CDR of the said mobile and is not denied by the police;

(vii)The treatment received by the Appellant at Jeevan Hospital for fractures on both ankles as a result of a fall from a height;

(viii)Recovery of the knife and presence of human blood on the t-shirt of the Appellant.

33.The net result is that the impugned judgment of the trial Court as regards the convic(cid:37)on of the Appellant for the offence under Sec(cid:37)on 302

IPC is hereby confirmed.

Sentence

34.As regards the sentence awarded to the Appellant, the Supreme Court has repeatedly stressed that while the imprisonment for life is itself a severe punishment it should not be combined with a heavy fine.

35.A reference may be made to the decision of the Supreme Court in Palaniappa Gounder v. State of Tamil Nadu (1977) 2 SCC 634, where the

Supreme Court has observed that “the sentence of fine must not be unduly excessive”. It was further observed:

“Though there is power to combine a sentence of death or life imprisonment with a sentence of fine that power is to be sparingly

exercised because the sentence of death is an extreme penalty to impose and adding to that grave penalty a sentence of fine is hardly

calculated to serve any social purpose.”

36.In Shahejadkhan Mahebubkhan Pathan v. State of Gujarat (2013) 1 SCC 570 the Supreme Court reiterated the earlier decision in

Shan(cid:37)lal v. State of M.P. (2007) 11 SCC 243 which analysed in detail the scheme of the provisions in Sec(cid:37)ons 63 to 70 IPC. The SupremeCourt in

Shahejadkhan Mahebubkhan Pathan (supra) observed:

“It is clear and reiterated that the term of imprisonment in default of payment of fine is not a sentence. To put it clear, it is a penalty which

a person incurs on account of non-payment of fine. On the other hand, if sentence is imposed, undoubtedly, an offender must undergo unless it is modified or varied in part or whole in the judicial proceedings. However, the imprisonment ordered in default of payment of fine stands on a different foo(cid:37)ng. When such default sentence is imposed, a person is required to undergo imprisonment either because he is unable to pay the amount of fine or refuses to pay such amount. Accordingly, he can always avoid to undergo imprisonment in default of payment of fine by paying such an amount. In such circumstance, we are of the view that it is the duty of the Court to keep in view the nature of offence,

circumstances in which it was commi(cid:75)ed, the posi(cid:37)on of the offender and other relevant considera(cid:37)ons such as pecuniary circumstances of the accused person as to character and magnitude of the offence before ordering the offender to suffer imprisonment in default of payment of fine. The provisions of Sec(cid:37)ons 63 to 70 of IPC make it clear that an amount of fine should not be harsh or excessive. We also reiterate that

where a substantial term of imprisonment is inflicted, an excessive fine should not be imposed except in exceptional cases.”

37.Also, a(cid:79)er the judgment in Union of India v. V. Sriharan (2016) 7 SCC 1, the trial Court cannot possibly order that the accused will undergo life imprisonment for a certain number of years beyond 14 years without being considered for remission.

38.Consequently, the order on sentence of the trial Court is modified by sentencing the Appellant to imprisonment for life for each of the counts to Sec(cid:37)on 302 IPC with fine of Rs. 5,000 on each account and upon failure to pay fine, to undergo SI for three months. The sentences

shall run concurrently.

39.The appeal is disposed of in the above terms. The trial Court record be returned forthwith with a certified copy of this order.