AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
Rule. Rule made returnable forthwith. Heard finally with the consent of the learned Counsel appearing for both the parties.
Since these connected petitions stem from a common order, they are taken up together and disposed of by this common judgment. For the sake of convenience, Writ Petition No. 2432/ 2022, is treated as the lead petition, and the relevant particulars of the lead petition and connected matters are tabulated below: -
| Sr No. | Writ Petition No. | Respondents | Date of Oral Appointment on Daily wages basis (According to Respondents) | Post on which respondents were working and claimed for Regularization | Complaint ULP No. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2432/2022 | Vilas Charandas Bhave | 15.09.2011 | Instructor - Plumber | 48/2017 |
| 2 | 2433/2022 | Lekchand Keshavrao Thakre | 15.09.2011 | Instructor – Welder | 47/2017 |
| 3 | 2434/2022 | Yogesh Shyamrao Sarode | 15.09.2011 | Instructor- Carpenter | 43/2017 |
| 4 | 2435/2022 | Santosh Bedram Sinha | 01.08.2014 | Instructor- N.C. Operator | 44/2017 |
| 5 | 2436 /2022 | Nitin Natthuji Bisen | 13.09.2011 | Instructor- Sheet Metal Work | 45/2017 |
| 6 | 2437/2022 | Akshay Vijay Hadge | 11.01.2016 | Instructor- Fitter | 46/2017 |
By way of these connected petitions, the petitioner (employer) are challenging the impugned judgment dated 25.11.2021, passed by learned Industrial Court, Bhandara, in all the Complaint (ULP) No. as mentioned above, wherein the complaint filed by the present respondents (employees) was allowed thereby holding that petitioners are engaged in unfair labor practices within the meaning of Item 5, 6 and 9 of Schedule IV of the Maharashtra Recognition of Trade Unions and Prevention of Unfair Labour Practices Act, 1971. It was further directed that the petitioners should regularize the service of respondents along with all monetary benefits from date of filing of complaint.
The brief facts, as culled out from the lead petition are that, pursuant to the approval given by the All India Council for Technical Education vide its letter dated 04.07.2007, State of Maharashtra vide Government Resolution dated 16.10.2008, decided to open new Government Polytechnic Colleges at seven places including one at Gondia. Thereafter, Government Resolution dated 08.07.2009, State of Maharashtra had approved sanction strength of students in each stream and also the teaching and non-teaching posts for seven new establishments.
It is contended by the respondent that the petitioner No.1 published an advertisement in local newspaper for recruitment of non-teaching staff. The present respondent (employee) was appointed by petitioner No.1 as a Daily Wager as Plumber since 15.09.2011. He filed a complaint before the learned Industrial Court, Bhandara claiming regularization of his service on the said post on account that the petitioner had told the respondent that he is being appointed on a permanent and sanctioned post and after successful completion of probation of period six months his service will be made permanent and that he has completed 240 days of continuous service. The learned Industrial Court, Bhandara, allowed the said application and passed the impugned judgment dated 25.11.2025. Aggrieved thereby, the petitioners have approached this Court.
I have heard the learned Counsel for the respective parties at length and perused the material on record with their assistance.
Shri Harish Dangre, learned Counsel for the petitioner, submits that the learned Industrial Court has failed to record a single finding as to which unfair labor practice petitioner No. 1 is engaged in. He further submits that though an advertisement was published for appointment purely on contract basis, but the said advertisement was not acted upon at any point in time though the applications were invited from eligible candidates. He specifically contends that the appointments of respondents were purely on contract basis, and no appointment order has been issued to respondents at any point of time till now.
It is further submitted that learned Industrial Court has erroneously held the petitioner No.1 institution as an ‘Industry’ and respondent as ‘Workman’ and observed that as respondent had worked for 32 weeks in year, he is entitled for Regularization. He submits that completion of 240 days of service in a year does not entitle him for regularization, it would at most give him benefit to be availed u/s 25-F of the Industrial Dispute Act.
Per contra, learned Counsel for respondent vehemently opposes the present petition and supports the impugned order. He submits that the learned Industrial Court has rightly held that due process was followed for appointment of respondent as he was appointed after he passed the written test, practical, interview and screening of documents. He further submits that the interim order passed by the Industrial Court to not to terminate respondent is not challenged before this Court suggesting that the work is permanently available, the post remained sanctioned.
Learned Counsel for respondent contends that the procedure for recommending the name for permanent absorption was required to be made but the same was not forwarded by the then Principal.
Learned Counsel for respondent points out that when the present petition was listed before this Court on 04.05.2022 petitioners made a statement that they are willing to pay regular salary at par with the regular and permanent employee yet this order is not followed till today and instead an application was preferred on seeking recall of the order by making a false averment that the respondent was not appointed on permanent and vacant post and therefore the salary is not admissible.
Lastly, he submits that petitioners have not produced the documents which were placed on record by the respondent which were extracted from the official website of the Government of Maharashtra. He submits that a perusal of the staffing pattern, would reveal that when the State Government took a policy decision to open a Polytechnic College in the year 2008 to 2010 it has to be accompanied with the staffing pattern.
Against these submissions of learned Counsel for respondent, affidavits are filed by the etitioner No.1 on 11.04.2023 and on 09.11.2023 thereby stating that application to recall the order dated 04.05.2022, is filed wherein the issue regarding whether the respondents are entitled for payment as per permanent staff is still pending. He submits that during the pendency of said application petitioner offered to pay respondent as per earlier arrangement which was refused by respondent thereby compelling petitioner to directly deposit the payment in bank account of the respondent.
In response the learned Counsel for the petitioners vide its rejoinder dated 24.07.2023, contends that the Government resolution dated 08.07.2009, provides sanction strength of teaching and non – teaching staff. The foot note of the said resolution specifically states that as far as services of Data Entry operator, security guard, gardener, sweeper, carpenter, welder, fitter, driver etc. are concerned the same can be availed on contract basis after taking due permission from the competent authority. Accordingly vide letter dated 04.11.2010, the petitioner No.2 granted permission to petitioner No.1 to carry the required job on contract basis.
Learned Counsel for the petitioner further contends that vide letter dated 21.08.2012, the petitioner No.1 sought permission from petitioner No.2 to appoint 6 (Six) posts on contract basis as needed for workshop department and for office work, in which the present respondents were allotted the respective works on hourly basis and for limited hours.
It is further urged by Shri. Dangre that the learned Industrial Court ought to have appreciated the Judgment and Order passed by this Court in Writ Petition No. 4914/2017 with connected matters, wherein this Court had refused to grant permanency and regularization to the employees of Government Polytechnic colleges in similar circumstances of the present case.
In rebuttal, the learned Counsel for respondent vide his additional submissions dated 27.10.2023, submits that the plea taken by the petitioner by way of the rejoinder has been taken for the first time in the entire proceedings and therefore the same cannot be countenanced as such plea could have been easily taken by the petitioner before the learned Industrial Court. He further submits that petitioner No.2 vide its circular dated 06.04.2022 (Pg.181 of the Petition), and vide letter dated 23.02.2023 (Pg. 184 of the Petition) the petitioner No.2 had informed that many posts were vacant under them as on 31.05.2023.
As against such contentions raised by the respondent, the learned Counsel for petitioner vide its additional rejoinder dated 03.01.2024, contends that the argument regarding raising of new plea before this Court is contrary to the record and would further contend that all the posts at Sr No. 12 to 17 had ‘nil’ vacancy. He further clarifies that the content of letter dated 23.02.2023, issued by petitioner No.2 only pertains to the listing of posts available under his office and does not mention any sanctioned and vacant posts, thus the said letter is not relevant to the present matter.
Per contra the learned Counsel for respondent vide Affidavit dated 11.12.2024, submits that after the passing of the order dated 04.05.2022 by this Court, the petitioner No.1 was neither allowing the respondent to enter into its premises nor allotting any work to the respondent. Aggrieved thereby the respondent had approached the petitioner No.1 and 2 on multiple occasions pursuant to which the petitioner No.1 and 2 had orally intimated the respondent that unless he obtains an appropriate order from this Court, they are not in position to allot any work and wages to the respondent. He further submits that in the month of July and August 2024, only two persons were allotted work and paid wages, and in the month of October and September work was allotted and wages with regard to the same were paid in installments. It is his submission that after the month of October, 2024 no work is allotted and such situation is very difficult for survival of the respondent, and thus in such circumstances the respondents seeks direction against the petitioner No.1 to allot regular work to him as was done prior to the Order dated 04.05.2022.
In the backdrop of these facts, rival contentions fall for my consideration.
I have scrupulously gone through the pleadings of the parties right from the complaint filed by the respondent – herein. As can be seen from the said complaint, it is a specific averment that he was appointed on 15.09.2011 in pursuance to an advertisement issued by the petitioner No.1 herein. It is his specific contention that various posts of operators are lying vacant, which are sanctioned. He further states that he was appointed on daily wages and continues to be so, without any appointment order and that the nature of work is continuous. He also states that there is no break in service.
As per the complaint, the cause of action for filing the same was a Government Resolution dated 19.09.2017 which directed all the departments to submit details of the temporary employees working since more than three years so as to regularize their services. It is also stated in the complaint that in pursuance to the said Government Resolution, the respondent and his colleagues (original complainants before the Industrial Court) went to the office of the petitioner No. 1 with a request to send the information to the petitioner No. 4 in the prescribed form for regularization of their services. However, as the complaint avers, this irritated the first petitioner and he drove out original complainants and his colleagues from his chamber and also threatened them that if they claim regularization, their services would be discontinued. In the backdrop of these facts, it was prayed that the acts of the petitioners herein amounts to unfair labor practices under Item 5, 6 and 9 of Schedule 4 of the MRTU and PULP Act, and therefore relief of permanency was claimed.
Written statement filed before the Industrial Court by the petitioners herein make a very interesting reading. The main contention of defence by the petitioners, who were the original respondents before the Industrial Court, was that the employees were never appointed by following due process of law and then the said posts upon which they were working were not sanctioned. It is also pleaded that the first petitioner is not an appointing authority for any type of post and therefore even if the said posts are filled, the same is to be done by the Joint Director of Technical Education and therefore would not clothe the employees with any right.
In nutshell, therefore, twin contentions were raised regarding absence of sanctioned posts and that the appointments were not done by following due procedure of law. As far as the applicability of the Government Resolution dated 19.09.2017 is concerned, even though the said contention was denied, the denial was evasive in as much as it was stated that the said resolution is not applicable, but without spelling any reasons therefor. As far as the applicability of the Model Standing Orders was concerned, again the denial was evasive and vague.
Thus, conspicuous by its absence in the defence was any data regarding the sanctioned and vacant posts in the petitioner No. 1 College and specific rules of recruitment placed on record.
On the basis of these pleadings, the parties chose to lead evidence. The employee, i.e. the complainant, i.e. the respondent herein, chose to enter witness box and he was also cross-examined by the opponents. He placed on record Government Resolutions which were duly marked as exhibits. Even though a slipshod cross-examination has been conducted, there is nothing material elucidated in the said cross-examination.
As far as the petitioners (employer) are concerned, they chose to adduce evidence of one Rajiv Wakodkar. He stated in his examination-in-chief that the posts on which the respondent was working is of daily wages and is not a regular post. He, however, nowhere states regarding any vacancy position or number of sanctioned posts. He has been thoroughly cross-examined where he has given various admissions. Firstly he admits that he was not working at Gondia at the relevant time and he has no personal knowledge. He also admits that all the employees/original complainants are working continuously with the petitioner No. 1 from the date of their initial appointment. He also states that the nature of work of the employees is to provide practicals to the students under the supervision of Workshop Superintendent.
He also candidly states that the respondent is working on the basis of the first appointment order itself. He also states and admits that the employees herein are not employed on contract basis, but they are appointed directly. He also admits the omission of not showing any salary with respect to Exhibit U-24. He also admits that as per the requirement of the Government Resolution dated 19.09.2017, no information was sent to the State Government as required. Thus, various admissions which destroy the entire case of the petitioners herein are brought on record during the cross-examination, which are vital for adjudication of the matter.
Thereafter, the judgment of the Industrial Court which is impugned in the petition is perused, it has framed issue regarding the petitioner No. 1 institution being an industry and the complainant being a workman. It has chosen to answer the said issue in the affirmative.
The core issue is issue No. 2 in the judgment. The said issue pertains to the fact that whether the complainant proves that the respondents have engaged in unfair labor practice was complained of. The said issue has also been answered in the affirmative. It has consequently directed and held that the complainants are entitled for the relief as sought. While arriving at such a finding, the Industrial Court has taken into consideration the various admissions as stated by me Supra in the evidence of the witness of the petitioners. For reaching a finding that the respondent No. 1 herein is not employed on a contractual basis, the Industrial Court has recorded a finding that even though the advertisement is titled as recruitment as on contractual basis, but procedure appears to have been followed is that of a regular recruitment. This finding, in my considered opinion, is entirely in consonance with the absence of the alleged procedure of regular recruitment in the petitioner No. 1 institution on record.
It is an admitted fact on record that an advertisement was issued and the applications were called from the eligible candidates. It is a specific contention in the complaint, (which is not denied in the written statement), that the written examination was conducted, qualified candidates were interviewed, and thereafter appointment were given. Thus, I find substance in the contention raised by the learned Counsel for the respondent that in absence of any other recruitment process, the Government Resolution dated 08.09.2014 is the only process which can be said to be the same. In my considered opinion, therefore, the finding regarding the same is based on material on record and cannot be said to be perverse.
For reaching a finding that as to whether the work of the complainant is of regular nature, the Industrial Court has recorded a finding that the complainants have produced copy of Muster Rolls which are duly marked as exhibits and have therefore discharged the initial burden which shows that they are working for 240 days or more. It has rightly stated that there is no adverse material placed on record by the petitioners herein to discharge that burden. By relying on a judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court reported in AIR 2010 SC 1236, Director Fisheries Terminal Division vs. Bhikubhai Meghajibhai Chavda, the Industrial Court has arrived at a conclusion that the respondents since have not discharged the burden, it can very well be said that the employees have worked for more than 240 days in a year. Thus, the said finding is also on the basis of material on record in the form of Muster Rolls; which were neither disputed nor any adverse material was placed in rebuttal on record, and hence cannot be said to be perverse.
What is interesting to note that even though the petitioners i.e. the employer has taken aid of judgment of this Court in Writ Petition Nos. 4914/2017, 4915/2017 and 4917/2017, they had not cared to place the judgment on record. It was the Industrial Court which obtained the copy of the said judgment on its own. After going through the judgment, it has recorded a finding that the same is not applicable because there is no reference in the said judgment regarding the fact that teaching and non-teaching staff of the petitioners have been appointed by the same recruitment process.
As far as question of the post being vacant and sanctioned, the reasoning of the Industrial Court begins at paragraph No. 30 onwards. After taking into consideration various judgments as cited, the Industrial Court in paragraph No. 35 has recorded a categorical finding that from the admissions of the witnesses of the petitioners and the material placed by the respondent employees on record, it can safely be said that the continuous long period of the employment demonstrate that work is of regular nature and the same is available. It also makes a reference to the Government Resolution stated supra, wherein the State of Maharashtra directed the petitioner No.1 to send information of the employees who have completed temporary work for more than three years. It is an admitted fact by the witness of the petitioner employer that no compliance of the said Government Resolution was made. Thus, the finding regarding the sanctioned and vacant post is also supported by documentary and oral evidence on record. In my considered opinion, the said findings being based on some material on record cannot be said to be perverse.
The parties to the petition have filed rejoinder, additional affidavit, sur-rejoinder, etc., in support of their respective contentions. By way of rejoinder/additional submissions on behalf of the petitioners, a document which is a Government Resolution dated 08.07.2009 is placed on record. It is a matter of record that the said resolution was not placed before the Industrial Court by either of the parties. The said resolution makes an interesting read. The said resolution states about periodical sanction to the various posts of Government Polytechnic Colleges as mentioned therein, which includes the petitioner No. 1.
As can be seen from the said Government Resolution, the name of the petitioner No. 1 is referred along with six other similar institutions, wherein the total 336 posts of teaching and 266 posts of non-teaching staff, thus totaling to 602 posts were shown to have been sanctioned periodically. It is further stated that the said posts should be filled in by sending the proposal thereof to the State Government. Such proposals are to be sent within further period of three years and two years for absorption. As far as the petitioner No. 1 is concerned, the said Government Resolution speaks that the students are shown to be 60 out of 180.
Furthermore, condition No. 2 of the said Government Resolution clearly stipulates that if the appointments are made pursuant to condition No. 1 on contract, and if after five years, a further proposal to continue such contractual employment is not forwarded, then such posts shall be lapsed or shall not be allowed to continue. Furthermore, in condition No. 3, it is specifically observed that firstly the teaching staff should be filled in and thereafter non-teaching staff should be filled in.
As has been rightly submitted by the learned Counsel for the respondent No. 1 that perusal of the said Government Resolution would clearly indicate that the posts were sanctioned, and against those sanctioned posts initially the recruitment was to be made on contract basis and periodically the proposals for regularization of such posts was to be sent to the State Government.
Even though, as stated by me supra, the said document was not placed before any of the parties, the petitioners have chosen to place the said document without seeking leave of the Court or without making an averment in the additional affidavit regarding the fact that the same was not placed before the Court below. Even though, the learned Counsel for the petitioners tried to submit that the said document is in continuation with the pleadings of the respondent No. 1, I am hardly impressed by this contention.
It is more than settled that the scope of interference in a writ, and more specially under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, is very narrow in as much as it is only testing the correctness or otherwise of the judgment of the Lower Court or Tribunal and that too can interfere only when it is perverse. Perverse in the sense would mean that the findings recorded and the conclusions reached could not have been reached by any of the Court/Tribunal on the basis of the material available on record. Had there been any material on record which could have enabled the Court/Tribunal to reach that findings, this Court under Article 227 would be loath to interfere in the said judgment. In the present matter, the petitioners for reason best known to them had not chosen to place this document on record. This omission to place the document on record lends credence to the pleadings of the respondent that they approached the petitioner No. 1 to regularize their services on the basis of the subsequent Government Resolution dated 19.09.2017.
A conjunctive reading of the Government Resolution dated 08.07.2009, along with the Government Resolution dated 19.09.2017, underlines the policy of the State of Maharashtra. It can be easily said that the policy is that even though initially the posts are to be filled on contract basis, they are to be periodically sanctioned in accordance with the modality as stated in the said Government Resolutions. Admittedly in the present case, the petitioner No. 1 in his own wisdom has not even chosen to send the requisite information as contemplated under the Government Resolution dated 19.09.2017. Thus, connecting this fact with the admissions of the witnesses of the petitioner No.1 it can be safely presumed that the petitioner No. 1 was engaged in unfair labour practice of not regularizing the concerned employees. The omission of the petitioners to place additional documents on record without seeking leave of the Court or without stating the fact in their affidavit that the said documents were not a part of the record of the Trial Court does not end at the Government Resolution dated 08.07.2009. The leanred Counsel for respondent has placed the pursis on record stating that the documents at page No. 151 to 172 and from page No. 230 to 237 were never placed before the Industrial Court. There is no counter to this and therefore it can safely be said that the statement made in the said pursis is correct. It is thus clear that some new material is sought to be placed on record, which in my considered opinion, is not permissible.
Plethora of judgments have been cited by both the parties in in support of their respective contentions. The petitioners have chosen to rely upon the celebrated judgment of the Constitutional bench of the Apex Court reported in(2006) 4 SCC 1, Secretary State of Karnataka and others vs. Umadevi and others, and more particularly paragraph 12 and 13 thereof. The said paragraphs state that there cannot be any inequality in the public matter of public employment and the strict rules of recruitment are to be followed. There cannot be any dispute about this proposition of law as has been enunciated by the Hon’ble Apex Court. However, in the said judgment itself in paragraph No. 53 the Constitutional Bench laid down an exception in case of irregular appointments and not illegal appointments and relies on the earlier judgments of the Hon’ble Apex Court in State of Mysore vs. S.V Narayanappa, AIR 1967 SC 1071, R.N. Nanjundappa vs. T. Thimmiah (1972) 1 SCC 409, and B.N. Nagarajan vs. State of Karnataka, (1979) 4 SCC 507,
It states that the Union of India and the State Governments and their instrumentalities should take steps to regularize as a one-time measure the services of such irregularly appointed persons who have worked for ten years or more in duly sanctioned posts but not under the cover of orders of the Courts or Tribunals. It further directs that the Government should ensure regular recruitments are undertaken to fill those vacant posts that required to be filled up in cases where temporary employees or daily wagers are being now employed. In my considered opinion, the Government Resolutions referred to supra are in consonance with the said exception laid down.
The next judgment on which reliance is placed by the learned Counsel for the petitioners is of this Court reported in 2008 SCC Online Bombay 716 State of Maharashtra versus Pandurang Jadhav. By relying on the said judgment the learned Counsel for the petitioner would submit that it has been held in the said judgment that the Industrial Court could not have granted permanency by observing that the sanction for the said posts can be obtained by the State Government. It further holds that the provisions of the Model Standing Order by themselves cannot and does not confer any right of permanency unless and until the other two pre-requisites are satisfied i.e., appointment being in conformity with the Rules and permanent sanctioned posts. There cannot be any dispute about this proposition, but in my considered opinion the judgment cannot take the case of the petitioners any further. As I have stated supra, the claim in the original complaint is not based only on the Model Standing Order, but on the basis of an averment that the appointments are in conformity with the Rules and there are permanent sanctioned posts. Had the claim been based only on the provisions of Model Standing Order, then the things would have been different.
Next judgment relied on by the learned Counsel for the petitioners is again of this Court reported in (2012) 3 MH.L.J. 478 Chief Conservator of Forests (Territorial), Nagpur and Others vs. Ashikque s/o Jabbar Sheikh and others, as also the judgment of this Court in Writ Petition 4914/2007, Government of Maharashtra vs. Maroti Wasnik. By relying on the said judgment, it is the contention of the learned Counsel for the petitioner that merely since the original complainants were working for 240 days or more cannot ipso facto clothe them with a right of permanency. Again, there cannot be any dispute about this proposition, but as stated by me supra, the claim in the present case is not only based on the employee completing 240 days of service.
The basic judgment on which the learned Counsel for the petitioners have relied is a judgment of this Court in Writ Petition No. 2046/2010 Sachin Ambadas Dawale and others vs. State of Maharashtra & another, 2013 (0) BCI 1318. The said judgment of Sachin has been followed in Vishal Bansi Tambe vs. State of Maharashtra & others [Writ Petition No. 5552/2015, Bench at Aurangabad], and also by this Bench in Writ Petition No. 1609/2020, State of Maharashtra vs. Santosh & another. The said judgments need not be discussed since as has been admitted by the learned Counsel for the respondent that he is not relying on the judgment of Sachin stated supra. Therefore, the other two judgments which follows the judgment of Sachin or differentiates on facts need not be discussed in the present judgment.
The learned Counsel for the petitioners have also placed on record judgments of the Labour Court at Gondia in Complaint ULP No. 12/2019, Jagdish Meshram vs. State of Maharashtra & others, and other allied complaints with respect to the same petitioner. However, in the said matters before the Labour Court there was an oral appointments and therefore the said judgments can be said to be of hardly of any relevance.
Another judgment, which is pressed into service by the learned Counsel for the petitioner is reported in 2016 (6) MH.L.J. 867, Municipal Council Tirora and another vs. Tulsidas Baliram Bindhade. The said matter pertain to a reference by the Single Judge of this Court and the question was that whether in the absence of creation or sanction of the posts under Section 76 of the Maharashtra Municipal Council, Nagar Panchayat and Industrial Townships Act, 1965, the complainants therein were entitled to claim permanency or regularization on the basis of Clause 4-C of the Model Standing Orders under the Industrial Employment (Standing Orders) Act, 1946. While answering this question, the Division Bench stated that violation of Clause 4-C of the Model Standing Order may tantamout to an unfair labor practice under Item 9 of Schedule IV of the 1970 Act, but certain additional factors are to be proved on record, one of which is availability of a vacancy. In the light of these facts, the Division Bench went on to record that the workman who has put in continuous service of 240 days or more in span of twelve months cannot invoke Clause 4-C of the Model Standing Order to claim either permanency or regularization. Thus, the judgment of the Hon’ble Division Bench refers only to Clause 4-C of the Model Standing Order.
The next judgment relied by the learned Counsel for the petitioners is of this Court in Writ Petition No. 5387/2007, Atmaram Telang vs. Dairy Manger & another, and a companion Writ Petition, wherein it is stated that the powers of the Labor Court and the Industrial Court, even though wide, they cannot be extended to a direction to order regularization where such a direction would, in the context of public employment, offend the provisions contained in Article 14 of the Constitution of India. However, in the said judgment, it was an undisputed fact that there was no permanent post available, nor the complainant was appointed on any post.
The next judgment relied is AIR OnLine 2024 Bom 653, Raghu Ghadga and others vs. Project Officer Dapchari Dugdha Prakalpa and others, in which it is held that permanency or regularization cannot be granted in Government Departments or its instrumentalities in absence of availability of a regular sanctioned post, and the Industrial Court does not have jurisdiction to create such posts. This judgment is also of no help to the petitioner, since, as I have already stated supra, that there was no data before the Industrial Court to arrive at such a finding regarding absence of vacant and sanctioned post. Furthermore, even if the Government Resolution dated 08.07.2009 is placed before this Court, the said Government Resolution unequivocally states otherwise and provides for periodical sanctions of such persons who are appointed even though initially on daily wages.
The next judgment relied on is of this Court in Writ Petition No. 391/2023, Shri. Purushottam Ramkrushna Bahetwar and others vs. State of Maharashtra and others, in which again the settled proposition of law is reiterated. However, a distinct fact in the said judgment is that the petitioner therein were visiting Lecturers and were working on clock-hour basis. Thus, the facts in the said judgment are clearly distinguishable.
Next judgment is of this Court in Writ Petition 4967/2023, Subhash Sukhdeo Sahare and others vs. Nagpur Municipal Corporation and another, along with other connected matters. In the said judgment, the learned Single Judge of this Court has taken into consideration the entire case law and reiterated the well-settled proposition of law that daily wagers or ad-hoc employees who are initially appointed in public institutions de hors the statutory and constitutional scheme of public employment, and they do not have any right to the post on which they work and cannot claim regularization in service on the strength of length of the service rendered with the employer as daily wagers or on temporary basis. However, in the said matter also there was a direction by the Industrial Court to forward the fresh proposal to the State Government to grant the benefit of permanency in service to the complainants upon completion of 240 days of service and to grant all consequential benefits. Thus, even in the said judgment, the facts can be distinguished.
As far as the judgments relied on by the learned Counsel for the respondent is concerned, he has relied upon the judgment of this Court, delivered at Principal Seat, in Writ Petition No. 1644/2025, Film & Television Institute of India vs. Javed Rasul Banedar and others, along with connected writ petitions. In the said matter, learned single judge of this Court, by taking into consideration the entire provisions of law, as also the judgment of Umadevi referred supra, has stated that in view of the existence of certain number of vacancies in the Film and Television Institute of India, the same can be made available for consideration for the workman therein for regularization. Even though the learned Counsel for the petitioners has tried to differentiate the said judgment, stating that the reference was sought after termination, I am hardly impressed by the said contention. The fact remains that the proposition of law is stated in the judgment, by taking into consideration the entire case law in that regard.
The learned Counsel for the respondent has also relied on judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in J.H. Jadhav vs. M/s Forbes Gokak Ltd., AIR 2005 Supreme Court 998, and more particularly, paragraph No. 10 thereof, that a specific contention which was first time raised before the Hon’ble Apex Court was not permitted to be raised before the said Court for the first time since it was not raised before the Industrial Tribunal at all.
The next judgment relied by the learned Counsel for the respondent is in SLP No. 22241/2016 of the Honble Apex Court, Vinod Kumar and others vs. Union of India and others, (2024) 9 SCC 327. In the said judgment, he relies on paragraph No. 5 onwards, which essentially states that the essence of employment and the rights thereof cannot be merely determined by the initial terms of appointment when the actual course of employment has evolved significantly over time. The continuous service of the appellants in the capacity of regular employees performing duties indistinguishable from those in permanent posts and their selection through a process that mirrors that of regular recruitment constitutes a substantive departure from the temporary and scheme specific nature of their initial engagement. By considering the judgment of Umadevi referred to supra, the Hon’ble Apex Court in this judgment unequivocally states that the reliance on procedural formalities at the outset cannot be used to perpetually deny substantive rights that have accrued over a considerable period through continuous service. It has therefore went on to record that the appointments of the employees therein cannot be said to be through back door entry as discussed in the case of Umadevi. By recording these findings, the Hon’ble Apex Court has stated that in the backdrop of the said facts the service conditions as evolved over time warrants a reclassification from temporary to regular status and the failure to recognize the substantive nature of their roles and their continuous service akin to permanent employees runs counter to the principles of equity fairness and the intent behind employment regulations.
The next judgment relied on by the learned Counsel for the respondent is also of the Hon’ble Apex Court in Civil Appeal No. 8157/2024, Shripal and another vs. Nagar Nigam, Ghaziabad, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 221, wherein also the same principles as enunciated in the previous judgment are amplified.
The next judgment is also of the Hon’ble Apex Court in SLP No. 5580/2024, Jaggo vs. Union of India and others, 2024 SCC OnLine 3826. In the said judgment, there has been a detailed narration between continuous and substantive appointment nature of duties etc. and thereafter in paragraph Nos. 22, 23 and 25, it is reproduced as under:
“22.The pervasive misuse of temporary employment contracts, as exemplified in this case, reflects a broader systemic issue that adversely affects workers' rights and job security. In the private sector, the rise of the gig economy has led to an increase in precarious employment arrangements, often characterized by lack of benefits, job security, and fair treatment. Such practices have been criticized for exploiting workers and undermining labour standards. Government institutions, entrusted with upholding the principles of fairness and justice, bear an even greater responsibility to avoid such exploitative employment practices. When public sector entities engage in misuse of temporary contracts, it not only mirrors the detrimental trends observed in the gig economy but also sets a concerning precedent that can erode public trust in governmental operations.
23.The International Labour Organization (ILO), of which India is a founding member, has consistently advocated for employment stability and the fair treatment of workers. The ILO's Multinational Enterprises Declaration encourages companies to provide stable employment and to observe obligations concerning employment stability and social security. It emphasizes that enterprises should assume a leading role in promoting employment security, particularly in contexts where job discontinuation could exacerbate long-term unemployment.
25.It is a disconcerting reality that temporary employees, particularly in government institutions, often face multifaceted forms of exploitation. While the foundational purpose of temporary contracts may have been to address short-term or seasonal needs, they have increasingly become a mechanism to evade long-term obligations owed to employees. These practices manifest in several ways:
Misuse of "Temporary" Labels: Employees engaged for work that is essential, recurring, and integral to the functioning of an institution are often labeled as "temporary" or "contractual,"even when their roles mirror those of regular employees. Such misclassification deprives workers of the dignity, security, and benefits that regular employees are entitled to, despite performing identical tasks.
Arbitrary Termination: Temporary employees are frequently dismissed without cause or notice, as seen in the present case. This practice undermines the principles of natural justice and subjects workers to a state of constant insecurity, regardless of the quality or duration of their service.
Lack of Career Progression: Temporary employees often find themselves excluded from opportunities for skill development, promotions, or incremental pay raises. They remain stagnant in their roles, creating a systemic disparity between them and their regular counterparts, despite their contributions being equally significant.
Using Outsourcing as a Shield : Instiutions increasingly resort to outsourcing roles performed by temporary employees, effectively replacing one set of exploited workers with another. This practice not only perpetuates exploitation but also demonstrates a deliberate effort to bypass the obligation to offer regular employment.
Denial of Basic Rights and Benefits: Temporary employees are often denied fundamental benefits such as pension, provident fund, health insurance, and paid leave, even when their tenure spans decades. This lack of social security subjects them and their families to undue hardship, especially in cases of illness, retirement, or unforeseen circumstances.”
Thus in the totality of circumstances, as can be seen from the recent judgments of the Hon’ble Courts, the recent law is that the misuse of temporary employment as exemplified in various cases is a matter of concern. By taking overall consideration of the matter, and in view of the fact that the petitioner employer did not choose to plead or prove the duel defences raised by it, I am of the considered opinion that the findings of the Industrial Courts cannot be branded as perverse.
It is a settled proposition of law that Writ Petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India is supervisory in nature and cannot be said to be an appeal in disguise. The law in this regard is more or less well-settled. A beneficial reference in this regard can be taken from the recent judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in Nandi Infrastructure Corridor Enterprise Ltd. and B. Gurappa Naidu and others, 2026 SCC OnLine SC 745. It is thus clear that only when the findings of the judgment of the Industrial Court are perverse, then in that event only this Court would be interfering in the same. As I have already stated above, that all the findings of the Industrial Court are based on some material on record and therefore cannot be said to be perverse in law.
As far as judgments cited by the learned Counsel for the petitioners are concerned, I have already stated supra that there are distinguishing features which non-suit the petitioners. It is a settled proposition of law that the judgments are not to be read as statutes and any different fact can make a lot of difference. I am supported in my view by the landmark judgments of the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Haryana Financial Corporation vs. Jagdamba Oil Mills, reported in (2002) 3 SCC 496 and reiterated and observed in latest judgment of Vanashakti vs. Union of India, 2026 INSC 761. Thus, taking taking into consideration the fact that no such recruitment procedure or any data of sanctioned vacant or filled post were placed before the Court (which was sought to be placed before this Court for the first time without seeking leave of the Court), cannot brand the judgment impugned of the Industrial Court as perverse. Likewise even if the documents placed before this Court are perused (more particularly Government Resolution dated 08.07.2009, the underlying policy of the State is amply clear as I have elaborately dealt with supra.
In that view of the matter, I am of the considered opinion that the judgment of the Industrial Court is liable to be confirmed and the petitions are liable to be rejected. The petitions are therefore rejected. No order as to costs.
