High CourtsSingle Bench(2023) 12 KL CK 0136

Geetha vs Rugmini

High Court Of Kerala · Decided on 14 December 2023

HON’BLE JUDGES
Sathish Ninan, J
RESULT
Dismissed
CASE NUMBER
Ex.FA No.15 Of 2023

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

10 paragraphs · 414 words

Sathish Ninan, J.

1.

The claim petitioner under Order XXI Rule 58 of the Code of Civil Procedure in the proceedings of execution of a final decree in a suit for partition, is the appellant.

2.

The claimant claims to have obtained title over the property under Ext.A3 Sale Deed dated 13.12.2008.

3.

A larger extent of property, including the property which is the subject matter of the present execution proceedings, belong to one Ponnuchami. He died on 10.08.1988. The plaintiff and the 1st defendant are his daughters. The 2nd defendant is the son of the 1st defendant. In the suit for partition filed by the plaintiff, the 2nd defendant set up Ext.A1 Will dated 02.08.1988 claimed to have been executed by Ponnuchami. The Court held against the Will and decreed partition. A final decree was also passed. In the execution petition filed by the plaintiff, the claim petition has been filed.

4.

The suit was instituted on 28.03.1995. After the institution of the suit on, 02.06.1995 the 2nd defendant relying on the Will sold the property in question under Ext.A2 to one Sundari. On 30.12.2008 Sundari conveyed the property to the claim petitioner as per Ext.A3. It is thus that the claim petitioner claims title over the property.

5.

The Execution Court noticing that Ext.A1 Will was held against by the trial Court and that Ext.A2 and A3 are conveyances pendente lite, held that the 2nd defendant and also the claimant are bound by the decree.

6.

I  have  heard  the  learned  counsel  on  both sides.

7.

The claim of the appellant is in respect of plaint item no.3. As per the decree, the plaintiff is entitled to one half share. The contention of the appellant is that, the defendants 1 and 2 sail together, that the 1st defendant is entitled for one half share and that the share of the 1st defendant could be made liable for the assignment by the 2nd defendant.

8.

As rightly held by the Execution Court, such questions would arise only in an execution proceedings, if any, initiated by the 1st defendant. The present execution petition is one filed by the plaintiffs for delivery of her share. The present contention does not arise at all. The validity of Ext.A1 Will having already been negatived and the assignees A2 and A3 being pendente lite, the claim was rightly rejected by the execution Court. There is no merit in the appeal.

The appeal fails and the same is dismissed.