High CourtsSingle Bench(2013) 02 MAD CK 0222

G. Parvathi vs Ayappan

Madras High Court · Decided on 28 February 2013 · Citation: (2013) 2 MadWN(Civil) 196

HON’BLE JUDGES
S. Manikumar, J.
RESULT
Disposed Off
CASE NUMBER
C.R.P.(NPD) No. 791 of 2013 & M.P. No. 1 of 2013

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

79 paragraphs · 3,029 words

S. Manikumar, J.—Being aggrieved by the order made in C.M.A. No.29 of 2012, dated 17.1.2013, on the file of the learned Principal District Judge, Namakkal, confirming the order and decretal order passed in I.A. No.246A of 2010, in U.S. No.65 of 2010 (renumbered) on the file of the learned Sub-Judge, Thiruchengode, the present Revision Petition has been filed.

2.

Material on record discloses that the Respondent has filed a Suit in U.S. No. 19 of 1999 on the file of the learned Subordinate Judge, Sankari, for recovery of a sum of Rs. 2,67,000/- with interest. As per the Plaint averments, the Revision Petitioners/Defendants have borrowed a sum of Rs. 2,00,000/- on 14.3.1997, from the Respondent/Plaintiff therein, for their family and business expenses and promised to repay the same, with interest, at the rate of 1.50% per month, per hundred on demand, either to the Plaintiff or his order. A Suit Promissory Note has also been executed. Since, the amount borrowed was not repaid, despite, demand and Advocate's notice dated 31.12.1998, Suit in U.S. No. 19 of 1999 has been filed on the tile of the learned. Subordinate Judge, Sankari. After the institution of the Suit, due to the bifurcation of the Districts and change in territorial jurisdiction, Suit in U.S. No.19 of 1999, has been renumbered as U.S. No.65 of 2010, on the file of the learned Subordinate Judge, Thiruchengode. It was posted on 7.3.2002. As the Defendants/Revision Petitioners did not appear, an ex parte decree has been passed on 14.3.2002. To set aside the ex parte decree, an Application in I.A. No.246A of 2010 has been filed on 26.3.2002, contending inter alia that due to sickness, the-1st Revision Petitioner could not appear and hence an ex parte decree came to be passed. The 1st Revision Petitioner has also stated that as she was hospitalised, she could not contact her Counsel.

3.

Per contra, the Respondent/Plaintiff in the Counter Affidavit has contended that the reason assigned is not bona fide. The Respondent/Plaintiff has also submitted that earlier, the Defendants/Revision Petitioners have filed a Debtor I.P. No.63 of 2006 on the file of the learned Subordinate Judge, Thiruchengode and in that proceedings, the Respondent herein has been shown as 12th creditor, with a debt of Rs. 4,85,000/- with interest. In the above said circumstances, the Plaintiff/Respondent, has submitted that when the Revision Petitioners/Defendants themselves have admitted to pay a sum of Rs. 4,85,000/-, they are estopped from blowing hot and cold and hence, Petition I.A. No.246A/2010 has been filed, with the only intention to protract the Execution proceedings. It is also stated that the suit property has already been sold in Court auction, and for the above said reasons, prayed for dismissal of I.A. No.246A of 2010.

4.

Before, the learned Subordinate Judge, Thiruchengode, Ex.P1, Medical Certificate of Parvathy, the deponent of the supporting Affidavit in I.A. No. 246A of 2010 and Ex.R1, dated 2.9.2006, Xerox copy of the insolvency Petition viz., F.P. No.63 of 2006, have been marked.

5.

After considering the pleadings, documents and submissions, the learned Subordinate Judge, Thiruchengode, taking note of the contents in LP. No.63 of 2006, wherein, the Respondent/Plaintiff has been impleaded as the 12th creditor and by observing that the Petitioners themselves in I.P. No.63 of 2006 have admitted their liability to pay the decree amount, dismissed, F.A. No.246A of 2010 in U.S. No.65 of 2010 (renumbered). While doing so, the Court below has also observed that though the Suit has been filed in the year 1999 and after 10 years from the date of ex parte decree, the Petition to set aside the ex parte decree has been numbered, at the time when the execution proceedings were taken. The Court below has also observed that the properties of the Revision Petitioners/Defendants in REP No.37 of 2004 have been brought to sale and the further averments in the said insolvency Petition to the effect that the Revision Petitioners/ Defendants were unable to pay the debts mentioned in the insolvency Petition, due to heavy loss incurred in the business, amounts to admission of their liability, to pay the decree amount.

6.

Being aggrieved by the order in I.A. No. s246A of 2010, the Revision Petitioners have filed C.M.A. No.29 of 2012, before the learned Principal District Judge, Namakkal. After considering the pleadings and submissions, the learned Principal District Judge, Namakkal, has confirmed the fair and decreetal order in I.A. No.246A of 2010 on 1.10.2010. Being aggrieved by the same, the present Revision Petition has been filed.

7.

Assailing the correctness of the orders, passed by the Courts below, Mr. P. Valliappan, learned Counsel for the Revision Petitioners submitted that the Court below has failed to consider that filing of a insolvency Petition in I.P. No. 63 of 2006 is not a bar, for the Revision Petitioners to maintain an Application under Order 9, Rule 13, C.P.C. He further submitted that no sooner, the Suit was decreed ex parte on 14.3.2002, an Application to set aside the ex parte decree was filed on 26.3.2002, within the period provided for under the Limitation Act and that therefore, the Court below ought to have considered that there was bona fide, on the part of the Defendants/Revision Petitioners, to contest the Suit, on merits.

8.

Learned Counsel for the Revision Petitioner further submitted that averments made in I.P. No.63 of 2006 that there was a decree in O.S. No.65 of 2010 (renumbered) resulting in R.E.P. No.37 of 2004, before the learned Subordinate Judge, Namakkal, could not at any stretch of imagination to be construed as admission of liability to pay the decree amount, on the Suit Promissory Note. He further submitted that the Court below has failed to consider that a substantial defence has been made in the Written Statement, wherein, the Petitioners have been contended that the Pro Note itself, is a forged and fabricated document. He also submitted that though I.A. No. 246A of 2010, the Petition to set aside the ex parte decree has been filed within a period of 12 days, due to bifurcation of the Districts and the change in the territorial jurisdiction, the cause papers were transferred to different Courts and for that reason, the Revision Petitioners, cannot be blamed that they had taken a long time to get the Petition numbered. For the above said reasons, he has prayed to set aside the fair and decreetal order made in I.A. No.246A of 2010 dated 1.10.2012 and the order made in C.M.A. No.29 of 2012 dated 17.1.2013

9.

Heard the learned Counsel for the Revision Petitioners and perused the materials available on record.

10.

The Suit has been filed in the year 1999 before the learned Subordinate Judge, Thenkasi, for recovery of a sum of Rs. 2,00,000/- on a Promissory Note dated 14.3.1997. The Suit has been decreed on 14.3.2002. Admittedly, there is no delay in filing the Application to set aside the ex parte decree.

11.

Material on record discloses that when execution of the decree was sought for, the Petitioners have filed I.P. No.63 of 2006 on the file of the learned Sub-Judge, Namakkal on 2.9.2006. The Respondent herein has been shown as the 12th creditor. At Paragraph Nos.VI to VIII, the Revisions Petitioners have stated as follows.

"VI. While borrowing the amounts from creditors by the Petitioners/Debtors some of the Respondents/Creditors asked this Petitioners to sign several blank Pronotes, and as well as several empty stamped papers, as per the customs adopted in the business community for borrowing amounts. The Petitioners respectably submit. that they are liable to pay the amounts which are mentioned only in "A" Schedule. The Petitioners are also used to execute Pro-Notes in connection with the Tractor and Van TN-28-U-5316 (Bajaj Tempo Van) the same has been missed at Dharmapuri. The 3rd Petitioner/Debtor also gave a Complaint at Dharmapuri Police dated 30.5.1999. While borrowing amounts from some of the Respondents/Creditors, this Petitioners have to sign in blank stamped papers also. But the Petitioners/Debtors are liable to pay the amounts mentioned only in the "A" Schedule herein.

VII. The Petitioners/Debtors had been paying heavy rate of interest to the creditors, moreover there where heavy fluctuations in the prices of rate of interest, they have not able to settle the interest itself and at the result the Petitioners/Debtors could not control their business which consequently resulted in heavy loss. The creditors are pressing the Petitioners/Debtors for payment. The 12th creditor has filed a Suit against the Petitioners/Debtors. The 12th creditor has filed a Suit in U.S. No.19 of 1991 before Sub-Judge, Sankari and got a decree and now he is bring the properties of the Petitioners/Debtors in R.E.P. 37/2004 before the Sub-Judge, Namakkal. The said R.E.P is posted Pr sale on 6.9.2006. The Petitioners/Debtors are unable to pay the debts mentioned in the Petition, due to heavy loss incurred by the Petitioners. Therefore the Petitioners/Debtors are forced to file this Petition to adjudge them as an insolvent. The Petitioners/Debtors are shown all their assets in Schedule hereunder and they are willing to place the said assets at the disposal of the official receiver for the benefit of all the creditors when this Petitioners/Debtors were not able to pay the debts. Several creditors took several documents for unregistered from this Petitioners/Debtors and in several blank Pro-Notes, but all the documents are not true and not binding upon the Petitioners and they were obtained under pressure and coercion and threat.

VIII. The debts payable by this Petitioners exceeds Rs. 50,00,000/- and the Petitioners are permanently the resident at Kollapatti Village and Post, Tiruchengode Taluk, Namakkal District within the jurisdiction of this Hon'ble Court. The Petitioners/Debtors are also submits that some of the creditors have taken away some domestic and Temp Van in the year 1999 itself by force and the Petitioners could not prevent them, because of the said creditors threaten this Petitioners/Debtors ."

12.

On the above averments, the Revision Petitioners, at paragraph No.10 of I.P. No.63 of 2006, have stated that the cause of auction for the insolvency Petition arose on 15.9.2004, when the Petitioners became incapable of repaying the debts incurred by them at Kollapatti Village, Tiruchengode Taluk, Namakkal District and hence sought for an order to adjudge them as insolvents. The schedule-A liabilities, in I.P. No. 63 of 2006, are extracted hereunder.

S. No.

Creditors

Nature of Debts

Amount

1

Rathinam

Pronote

Rs. 6,00,000/-

2

K.C. Sellappahn

Pronote

Rs. 4,50,000/-

3

Ganesan

Pronote

Rs. 3,00,000/-

4

Revathi

Pronote

Rs. 2,50,000/-

5

R. Anandan

Pronote & Stamp papers

24,00,000/-

6

R. Sengottaiyan

Pronote

55,00,000/-

7

A. Pavayee

Pronote

Rs. 4,50,000/-

8

P. Arunachalam

Pronote

Rs. 3,00,000/-

9

S. Saravanan

Pronote

Rs. 7,00,000/-

10

N. Palanisamy

Pronote

Rs. 6,00,000/-

11

K. Shanmugam

Pronote

Rs. 6,00,000/-

12

Ayappan

Pronote with interest

Rs. 4,85,000/-

13

Chinnagounder

Pronote

Rs. 4,05,000/-

Total

Rs. 60,40,000/-

13.

In so far as the liability to the Respondent is concerned, the Revision Petitioners at Serial No.12, have stated that a sum of Rs. 4,85,000/- was due to the Respondent on a Pro-Note with interest. At Para No.VI, the Revision Petitioners have clearly admitted that they are liable to pay the amounts, mentioned only in "A" schedule. Though, the Revision Petitioners in I.P. No.63 of 2006 have inter cilia contended that they had executed certain Pro-Notes in connection with the Tractor and Van, at the end of Para No.VI, they have specifically reiterated that the Petitioners/Debtors are liable to pay the amount mentioned only in the "A" schedule liabilities.

14.

Though, the Petitioners/Debtors in I.P. No.63 of 2006 have preferred for a further direction to bring the properties under the control of the Official Receiver of the jurisdiction for the benefit of the creditors mentioned in the insolvency Petition, 12th creditor/decree holder, in O.S. No.19 of 1999, at Para No.7 of the Counter Affidavit has categorically stated that in R.E.P. No.37 of 2004, the property of the Revision Petitioners, have already been brought for Court auction on 21.2.2007 and that one Mr. Allimuthu has already been declared, as the successful bidder. In as much as the property had already been sold on 21.2.2007 itself and that the sale amount has also been sent to the Official Receiver of the jurisdiction, the Respondent has prayed for dismissal of the insolvency Petition. Thus it could be seen from the averments made in Para Nos. VI & VII in I.P. No.63 of 2006, the Revision Petitioners have categorically admitted their liability to pay the amounts mentioned in the "A" schedule, which includes a sum of Rs. 4,85,000/-with interest: due to the Respondent. A Counter Affidavit in I.P. No.63 of 2006, setting out that the sale that had already been taken place on 21.2.2007, has also been filed.

15.

Having agreed to their liability to pay the amounts under the Pro notes, the Revision Petitioners have sought for a direction to adjudge them as insolvents. Now, the Revision Petitioners, after nearly four years, have numbered the I.A. No. 246A of 2010, to set aside the ex parte decree, contending inter cilia that they have got a valid defence in the Suit. If there was any bona fide intention on the part of the Revision Petitioners, in justifying the cause to defend the Suit on merits, nothing preventing the Revision Petitioners from numbering the Petition filed on 26.3.2002, to set aside the ex parte decree. Though, the Execution Petition has been filed in the year 2004, and that Petitioners, in order to avoid execution, have also filed an insolvency Petition in the year 2006, the Revision Petitioners have not numbered the Petition to set aside the ex parte decree and on the contra, contended that the delay in numbering was due to the transfer of the Suit in Sankari Sub-Court and thereafter, to Thiruchengode Sub-Court. In order to extricate from their liability to pay a huge sum, mentioned in "A" Schedule liabilities with the assets under the "B" schedule properties, when the Revision Petitioners have taken steps in filing I.P. No.63 of 2006 to declare them as insolvents, nothing prevented the Revision Petitioners, in numbering the Application filed to set aside the ex parte decree. Transfer of the Suit to other Courts cannot be accepted as a valid reason, for not prosecuting the Petitions filed to set aside the ex parte decree. If the intention of the Petitioners was to adjudicate the Suit on merits, then there is no reason to prefer an insolvency Petition, admitting their liability under "A" schedule, to repay the debts. On the one hand, in the insolvency Petition, the Petitioners have clearly admitted their liability to pay the amounts under the Promissory Notes, per contra, in the Application to condone the delay, they have contended that the Suit Pro-Note is forged.

16.

In the light of the specific averments made in I.P. No. 63 of 2006, extracted supra, the contention of the learned Counsel for the Revision Petitioners that the averments made in I.P. No.63 of 2006 would not amount to admission on the part of the Defendants/Revision Petitioners in the Suit, cannot be countenanced. The Suit has been filed in the year 1999, for the money said to have been borrowed on 14.3.1997. The same has been decreed on 14.3.2002. Application to set aside the ex parte decree has been filed on 26.3.2002. E.P. has been filed in the year 2004. As per the averments in I.P. No.63 of 2006, the cause of action for preferring the Insolvency Petition arose on 15.9.2004. Insolvency Petition has been filed in the year 2006, admitting their liability to pay the amounts, under the "A" schedule to the said Petition. Sale of the property has been effected on 12.2.2007. At this juncture, after nearly 8 years, from the date of tiling of the Petition to set aside the ex parte decree, the said Petition has been numbered in the year 2010. From the sequence of events, it is evident that in order to avoid the execution in R.E.P. No.37 of 2004, the Revision Petitioners have numbered the Petition, after three years when the property had already been sold in Court auction on 21.2.2007. The successful bidder, Allimuthu had not taken delivery.

17.

Though the learned Counsel for the Revision Petitioners has contended that there is a valid defence in the Suit, this Court is of the view that in the light of the specific averments made in the insolvency proceedings, as observed by the Courts below, it is not open to the Revision Petitioners to blow hot and cold, to avoid their liability to pay the amount borrowed. Though, the learned Counsel for the Revision Petitioners has contended that filing of an Insolvency Petition in I.P. No.63 of 2006, is not a bar to maintain an Application under Order 9, Rule 13, C.P.C., stated to have been filed in time, while considering an Application to set aside the ex pane decree, the Court has to see whether there is any bona fide, on the part of the Defendant/Revision Petitioners, as to what prevented them from appearing on the date posted for trial, but can also take into consideration the subsequent events and the conduct of the judgment debtors, and to ascertain from the facts pleaded ''as to whether, the judgment debtors, had any bona fide intention of contesting the Suit on merits or admitted their liability in any subsequent proceedings, between the same parties. Merely because the Application to set aside the ex parte decree has been filed in time, it cannot be contended that the said Application, has to be ordered, ignoring the averments made in the subsequent proceedings, between the parties.

18.

Considering the subsequent events, this Court is of the view that there is absolutely no bona fide on the part of the Revision Petitioners in considering that there is cause for defending the Suit, but on the other hand, they have admitted their liability. There is no manifest illegality committed by the Courts below in relying on the specific admission of the Revision Petitioners in the Insolvency Petition, in so far as their liability to pay the sum borrowed. Hence, the Civil Revision Petition is dismissed. No costs. Consequently, the connected Miscellaneous Petition is closed.