High CourtsSingle Bench(2026) 10 BOM CK 5392

Executive Engineer vs Dadarao Namdeo Bagul & Ors.

Bombay High Court, Nagpur Bench · Decided on 28 October 2026

HON’BLE JUDGES
Pravin S. Patil, J
RESULT
Dismissed
CASE NUMBER
First Appeal No.950 of 2022

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

16 paragraphs · 674 words
1.

By this appeal, the challenge is to the judgment and order passed by the Joint Civil Judge, Senior Division, Buldhana in Land Acquisition Reference No.10/2016, decided on 09.03.2022.

2.

The undisputed fact of the present matter is that the original respondent no.1 Dadarao Namdeo Bagul was the owner of House No.101/127, ad-measuring 42 sq. meter and cattle shed bearing no.105/131, ad-measuring 25.41 sq. meter situated at Patoda, Tahsil-Chikhli, District-Buldhana was acquired for irrigation project in pursuance of Notification issued in official gazette on 13.10.1994.

3.

In the said land acquisition proceeding, the Land Acquisition Officer by his award dated 27.08.1998 awarded the compensation for construction of house at Rs.30,595/-. The original respondent Dadarao being dissatisfied with the meager amount of compensation has preferred the reference before Civil Court. He has stated before the reference court that in a adjacent area of his plot, the market value of the land is at higher rate and same is not considered by the Land Acquisition Officer and, therefore, seeks enhancement in the compensation.

4.

It is pointed out that during the pendency of the reference the original owner namely, Dadarao was expired and his legal heirs are brought on record. The legal heirs then contested the proceeding before the reference court.

5.

Before the reference court, the claimant entered into the witness box and to establish that at nearby area there was a higher market value of land and to substantiate the submission, put reliance on various documents and more particularly the judgment delivered by the reference court in Land Acquisition Reference No.94/2003 – Vishwanath Trimbak Jawanjal .vs. The State of Maharashtra and others, decided on 27.01.2015.

6.

It is also pertinent to note that the acquiring body did not enter into the witness box. They have only cross-examined the respondent-claimant before the reference court. However, during cross-examination, the claimant evidence was remained unshaken.

7.

In the light of this oral and documentary evidence, the learned reference court by the impugned judgment enhanced the compensation doubled of the amount which was awarded by the Special Land Acquisition Officer and thereby awarded Rs.61,190/-.

8.

The appellants-acquiring body challenged the said impugned judgment before this court stating that there was no evidence available before the reference court and in absence of such evidence the reference court has wrongly doubled the compensation towards the construction area and, therefore, indulgence of this court is necessary in the matter.

9.

The respondent-claimant, however, stated that by applying the rule of parity, the learned reference court has rightly appreciated the controversy in the present matter. According to the respondent-claimant, in Land Acquisition Reference No.94/2003, the reference court has enhanced the compensation at the rate of Rs.160/- per sq. mtr. and, therefore, considering the same principles, the learned reference court has rightly enhanced the compensation.

10.

The respondent-claimant has relying upon the judgment delivered by this court in First Appeal No.830/2016 and First Appeal No.1222/2016, whereby coordinate bench by relying upon the judgment of reference court in Land Acquisition Reference No.94/2003 has held that the compensation awarded therein is just and proper in the matter and same was accordingly followed to determine the market value of acquired land.

11.

In the present matter, it is admitted fact that the reference court by relying upon the same judgment of the reference court in Land Acquisition Reference No.94/2003 has awarded compensation in favour of respondent-claimant. Hence, once this court by recording the cogent reasons has upheld the judgment passed on Land Acquisition Reference No.94/2003, there is no reason to take a different view in the present matter.

12.

After going through the judgment of Reference Court, it is seen that court has rightly considered the controversy in the light of the various judgments relied therein by the parties. Accordingly, following order is passed :

O R D E R

(i)

The appeal is dismissed.

(ii)

The respondents-claimants are permitted to withdraw the amount which is deposited by the appellants-acquiring body before this court, subject to the satisfaction of Registrar.

(iii)

No order as to costs.