AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
The Court has heard learned counsel for the parties and examined the enquiry reports. In light of the statements made by the witnesses, and the internet logs, the Court is satisfied that no interference is called for, as far as the finding of guilt of the Petitioners is concerned.
However, on the question of punishment, the Court notes that while the punishment awarded to HC/GD Vedpal is of compulsorily retiring him from service with consequential benefits, the punishment awarded to Ct./GD Sunil Kumar, is that of removal from service. As far as Sunil Kumar is concerned, he was a new recruit, with no previous track record of any misconduct. As far as Ex.HC/GD Vedpal is concerned, learned counsel for the Respondents referred to “various instances”, which do not appear to have been actually discussed in the order imposing the penalty.
In that view of the matter, the Court directs that both these cases be placed again before the Revisional Authority to examine whether a lesser punishment can be awarded, keeping in view the previous track record of each of the Petitioners. A decision be taken afresh, uninfluenced by the earlier decision on punishment, not later than eight weeks from today. The consequential orders be communicated to each of the Petitioners by the Respondents, within a further period of two weeks. If aggrieved, it will be open either one or both Petitioners, to seek appropriate remedies in accordance with law.
Both the petitions are disposed of in above terms. No costs. Order dasti under signature so the Court Master.
