AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
The appellants are the defendants in O.S. No. 10 of 2015, a suit for partition before the Additional Sub Court, North Paravur, and the appellants in A.S. No. 73 of 2020 before the Additional District Court-I, North Paravur. They challenge the concurrent findings of the courts below in the proceedings culminating in the final decree.
The suit property, having an extent of 1 Acre 27.025 cents and covered by Document No. 2051/1123 of the SRO, Aluva, was acquired by Sri. Pathrose. On his death, the property devolved upon Thressia and, on her death on 10.12.2013, devolved equally upon the plaintiff and the defendants. The plaintiff instituted O.S. No. 10 of 2015 before the Additional Sub Court, North Paravur, seeking partition. A preliminary decree was passed declaring the property partible and the plaintiff entitled to a 1/7th share.
In the final decree proceedings, the plaintiff filed I.A. No. 874 of 2018 seeking a final decree. An Advocate Commissioner was appointed to divide the property by metes and bounds. The Commissioner submitted Exts. C1 and C1(a), the report and plan. The defendants filed objections to the report and plan. By order dated 18.12.2019, the Additional Sub Court remitted the report for the limited purpose of ascertaining the value of each plot, having regard to its market value, the improvements, structures and other valuables situated therein, its peculiar advantages and disadvantages, and the nature of access. Pursuant thereto, the Advocate Commissioner filed an additional report, Ext. C1(b), which was also objected to by the defendants.
The Additional Sub Court overruled the objections and passed the final decree. In doing so, it held, inter alia, that the objection regarding the difference in level did not warrant interference, in view of the earlier order dated 18.12.2014, which had observed that the difficulty in access could be remedied by the respective allottees by levelling their plots at their own cost; that a similar difficulty was faced in respect of Plot A; and that the difficulty was attributable to the nature and terrain of the property and was common to the sharers. The Additional Sub Court accepted the supplementary report and directed that Ext. C1(b) form part of the decree for the purpose of stamp duty and valuation.
Aggrieved by the final decree, the defendants preferred A.S. No. 73 of 2020 before the Additional District Court-I, North Paravur. By judgment dated 24.11.2025, the First Appellate Court found that there was no material to show that the appellants had paid court fee for separate allotment of their individual shares and, consequently, the Commissioner could not be faulted for not allotting separate plots to them. It further found that Ext. C1(a) disclosed a road on the eastern side of the decree-schedule property and a private way on its northern side; that the northern way could be accessed from Plot A by placing a slab across the canal, subject to obtaining the consent of the owner of the way; and that the difference in level was attributable to the excavation of earth from the decree-schedule property. It also held that, there being no dispute regarding the survey number, the assistance of the Taluk Surveyor was unnecessary.
The First Appellate Court further held that the existence of a Panchayat road on the eastern side of the decree-schedule property negatived the contention that the remaining property had no vehicular access or that the plot allotted to the respondent was of greater market value. It was noticed that Plot A was at a lower level by about 10 metres and that its value could not, for that reason, be considered higher than that of the remaining property. The report and plan were accepted. The final decree was modified by directing that Ext. C1(a) form part of the final decree and that a revised final decree be drawn accordingly. The present Second Appeal is directed against that judgment.
The learned counsel for the appellants contended that the Advocate Commissioner had not determined the market value of the property in the supplementary report, notwithstanding the specific direction issued by the Additional Sub Court, and had merely adopted the fair value fixed by the Government. It was further contended that the Commissioner had specifically reported that Plot B had no access for ingress or egress except through Plot A, but that this circumstance had not been considered by the courts below.
It was also contended that the Commissioner could not ascertain whether the thodu and the slab on the northern side of Plot A were in private ownership or were of public nature. In that circumstance, according to the appellants, the First Appellate Court was not justified in proceeding on the basis that the northern way was a private way. The appellants further challenged the allotment of Plot A and submitted that the Commissioner had failed to assess the value of the plots with reference to their respective advantages, disadvantages and access, as directed in the order of remand. It was also pointed out that Ext.C1(b), the supplementary report, was not seen marked among the Court exhibits. Finally, it was contended that the finding of the First Appellate Court regarding the Panchayat road on the eastern side was inconsistent with the Commissioner's report that access to Plot B could be obtained only through Plot A.
Heard the learned counsel for the appellants and perused the records.
The suit for partition was instituted by the respondent. Under the preliminary decree, the respondent is entitled to a 1/7th share in the decree-schedule property, and the appellants are each entitled to a 1/7th share. It is not in dispute that only the fourth defendant filed a written statement in the suit. The records do not disclose that the appellants had, at any stage, sought separate allotment of their respective shares by metes and bounds. Nor is there material to show that they had paid the requisite court fee for such separate allotment. In the absence of a request for separate allotment, supported by the requisite court fee, the Commissioner cannot be faulted for not proposing distinct plots for each of the appellants. Equally, the Trial Court cannot be faulted for not directing such separate allotment, particularly when there was no material to indicate that the appellants objected to the remaining property being retained jointly. The First Appellate Court was, therefore, justified in declining to interfere with the manner in which the shares were dealt with in the final decree.
Ext. C1(a) is the plan submitted by the Advocate Commissioner. It indicates the existence of a road on the eastern side of the decree-schedule property. Plot A, allotted to the respondent, lies in the north-western portion of the property and has no direct access to the eastern road. The plan also depicts a way on the northern side and a channel intervening between that way and the decree-schedule property, including Plot A. The Commissioner reported that, while the extent as per the records is 127.025 cents, the extent measured on the ground is 138.853 cents. Plot A is reported to have an extent of 19.836 cents. The report further states that Plot A lies about 10 metres below the level of the remaining property and contains no valuable trees or buildings. The appellants' contention that Plot A is situated at a higher level is, therefore, contrary to the Commissioner's report. The courts below accepted the report after considering the objections, and no specific material has been placed before this Court to discredit the Commissioner's physical observations.
The existence of a channel on the northern side of Plot A is not in dispute. The Commissioner's report and plan indicate that access from the northern way to Plot A could be provided by placing a slab across the channel. Such access, however, is dependent upon the legal status of the way and, if it is a private way, the consent or other legally recognised entitlement of its owner. The Commissioner's inability to ascertain the ownership of the way cannot, by itself, establish that it is a public way; equally, the mere description of it as a private way in the appellate judgment cannot confer a right of access over it. The relevant point for the present appeal is that the plan also shows a road on the eastern side and the Commissioner has spoken of the possibility of providing vehicular access by placing a slab across the channel separating that road from the property. The evidence that earth had been excavated from the decree-schedule property also affords an explanation for the difference in levels. These circumstances were considered by the courts below while evaluating the objections to the allotment.
As regards valuation, the supplementary report records that the Commissioner had not been furnished with documents enabling an independent assessment of the market value, either by the parties or otherwise. She therefore referred to the fair value fixed by the Government. The report also records that, even if access to about 80 cents of the B-schedule property is unavailable, the remaining 40 cents has access through the Panchayat road at the south-eastern corner. It further states that the northern way is available as a possible access to the remaining property as well. The report thus considered not merely the stated extent or the fair value, but also the access available to the respective portions and their relative advantages. The fair value adopted by the Commissioner cannot, in the absence of supporting material, be equated in every case with the actual market value; nevertheless, the appellants have not placed any valuation material before the courts below or before this Court to demonstrate that the valuation adopted has resulted in a material inequality in the allotment. Nor have they shown, by reference to any specific comparable transaction or other reliable material, that Plot A is of a higher value than the remaining property. On the material available, the concurrent factual conclusion that the allotment has not been shown to be inequitable does not call for interference in this Second Appeal.
The First Appellate Court noticed that the final decree did not expressly incorporate the plan submitted by the Advocate Commissioner. It accordingly modified the decree by directing that Ext. C1(a) form part of the final decree and that a revised final decree be drawn in conformity with that direction. In all other respects, the final decree was confirmed. The direction to incorporate the plan removes the ambiguity as to the precise allotment made under the decree. On an examination of the reasons recorded by the courts below and the material referred to above, I find no perversity or material misappreciation of evidence warranting interference under Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The objections raised by the appellants essentially seek a reappraisal of the Commissioner's factual assessment and the comparative advantages of the plots. No substantial question of law arises for consideration.
In the result, the Second Appeal is dismissed. The judgment of the First Appellate Court modifying the final decree shall stand.
