High CourtsDivision Bench(2026) 10 BOM CK 5329

Dunga @ Yeshu @ Vasantrao vs State Of Maharashtra

Bombay High Court, Nagpur Bench · Decided on 30 October 2026

RESULT
Disposed Of
CASE NUMBER
Criminal Appeal No.159 of 2022

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

17 paragraphs · 1,511 words

( Rohit W. Joshi, J.)

1.

The present appeal is filed challenging the judgment and order dated 07.12.2020 passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Gadchiroli, in Sessions Case No.110 of 2019 whereby the appellant/accused was convicted for the offences punishable under Section 302 read with Section 149 and Section 148 of the Indian Penal Code (for short “IPC”) and sentenced to suffer imprisonment for life and to pay fine of Rs.5,000/-, in default to suffer further rigorous imprisonment for three months and further for the offence punishable under Section 148 of the IPC, sentenced to suffer rigorous imprisonment for three years and to pay fine of Rs.1,000/-, in default to suffer further rigorous imprisonment for one month. The sentences were ordered to run concurrently.

2.

Prosecution in present case is initiated pursuant to registration of FIR No.02 of 2009 with Police Station, Zinganur. PW-1 is the first informant. As per the prosecution case, the appellant along with around 40 naxalites had surrounded the house of deceased Nagesh Papayya Payam (police constable serving at Gadchiroli) and his wife Sunita Satyam Payam on 28.09.2009 at about 10:00 P.M., he entered the house of Nagesh at village Kopela, Tah. Sironcha, Dist. Gadchiroli and fired gunshots on him and his wife. Perusal of the report indicates that PW-1 had stated that on 28.09.2009 at around 10:00 P.M., somebody had knocked the door of their residential house and grandfather of the informant namely, Papayya, opened the door of the house and two naxalites, one male and one female, entered the house armed with guns. She has stated that both naxalites entered the room where deceased Nagesh and Sunita were sleeping. She has deposed that naxalites fired gunshot on the head of Nagesh, dragged him by his legs outside the house and were beating him by butt of the gun. She has further stated that naxalites shot deceased Sunita on her head and waist, as a consequence of which she died on the spot. She has deposed that three naxalites had entered the house. In the FIR as well as in the deposition, she has stated that around 40 naxalites were surrounding the house. In her examination-in-chief, she has stated that she was in a position to identify the naxalites who had entered the house since there was a lamp in the house and the naxalites were also carrying a torch, and as such, there was sufficient light for her to witness the naxalites who had entered the house. She named one of the naxalites, Sinu, who had entered the house. The present appellant/accused was present during the course of recording of evidence through video conferencing. She identified the present appellant/accused as one of the naxalites who had entered the house on the video conferencing unit. In her cross-examination, she has stated that the statement in her report that two naxalites, one male and one female, had entered the house is incorrect. She has further stated in the cross-examination that during the course of her earlier evidence, she had stated that Sinu, Ramakant, Shamlal and other naxalites had entered the house. She has stated that after the incident, the police had never called her to the police station in relation to investigation and that test identification parade was also not conducted. She has denied the suggestion that she had identified the appellant/accused on the basis of his photograph shown to her by the police.

3.

The other witnesses examined by the prosecution are panch witnesses, the doctor who conducted the post-mortem examination and the investigating officer. However, for deciding the present appeal, their evidence is not relevant.

4.

The appellant/accused was arrested on 20.02.2019, and he was identified by PW-1 during the course of evidence recorded on 09.10.2020. The learned Sessions Court has held that the involvement of the appellant/accused in the offence was duly proved and accordingly convicted him and imposed sentence as aforesaid. The learned Sessions Judge has placed reliance upon evidence of PW-1, finding her testimony to be reliable.

5.

As stated above, in the present case, the offence is committed on 28.09.2009 in the night at around 10:00 P.M. PW-1, who is informant, has named three naxalites in the FIR. The names of other naxalites are not mentioned. It is obvious that PW-1 did not know the other naxalites who were present at the spot at the relevant time. She has specifically stated in her FIR that one male and one female naxalite had entered the house. In her examination-in-chief, she has stated that Sinu was one of the naxalites who had entered the house. Sinu is also known by the name Shriniwas, who is named in the FIR. Although the learned Sessions Court was right in stating that an FIR cannot be expected to be a complete encyclopedia of the facts constituting the offence, it ought to have appreciated that in the FIR, which was lodged on the date of the incident itself, the informant had stated that one male and one female naxalite had entered the house and had named the male naxalite as Sinu @ Shriniwas. Her version in the examination-in-chief that three naxalites had entered the house is contrary to the statement in the FIR. Apart from this, the FIR and the report are proved during the examination-in-chief of PW-1. She has stated that the contents of the FIR and report are correct.

6.

Thus, there is a clear contradiction between the FIR, contents whereof are confirmed in the examination-in-chief, that only one male and one female naxalite had entered the house and her previous statement in the examination-in-chief that three naxalites had entered the house. Apart from this, the witness has also stated that she had deposed that Sinu, Ramakant, Shamla and other naxalites had entered the house. The learned advocate for the appellant informs that this question was put to witness since in another sessions trial in relation to same incident, she has deposed that aforesaid three persons had entered her house.

7.

There is a time lag of approximately 9 years and 5 months between the date of incident and the date of arrest. The prosecution has not conducted test identification parade, as is admitted by PW-1 in the cross-examination. The witness has identified the accused for the first time in the witness box, while the accused was appearing through video conferencing on 09.10.2020 i.e. after a period of 11 years. It is difficult to accept that she could identify the person who had entered the house after a period of 11 years, particularly because the incident has occurred during night time.

8.

The statement in the complaint that one male and female naxalite has entered the house is confirmed in the examination-in-chief by stating that contents of complaint are correct. As per face of PW-1, male naxalite who has entered the house was Sinu @ Shriniwas. PW-1 has allegedly seen the face of accused during the night time when he allegedly entered the house for committing crime. It is stated that face was seen in the light of the lamp. The identification was after period of around 11 years. The version of PW-1 that the accused/appellant is one of the naxalites who had entered the house does not, therefore, inspire confidence. It must be stated that after the incident, PW-1 was employed in police department in view of demise of her relatives, Nagesh and Sunita, in the present incident.

9.

It must also be stated that although PW-1 has stated that appellant/accused was present at the spot of incident and was one of the naxalites who had entered the house, she has not attributed any specific role to him. She has not stated what was the appellant/accused allegedly doing at the time of the incident.

10.

In the light of the evidence recorded above, in the considered opinion of this Court, the conviction of the appellant/accused on the basis of testimony of PW-1 cannot be sustained. Apart from the oral evidence of PW-1, there is no other material to link the appellant/accused to the offence. In view of the above, the appeal deserves to be allowed and is accordingly allowed in the following terms :-

ORDER

i)

Criminal Appeal is allowed.

ii) The impugned judgment and order dated 07.12.2020 passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Gadchiroli in Sessions Case No.110 of 2019 convicting and sentencing appellant – Dunga @ Yeshu @ Vasantrao s/o Bapu Tekam of the offences punishable under Sections 302, 149 and 148 of the Indian Penal Code, is hereby quashed and set aside.

iii) The appellant – Dunga @ Yeshu @ Vasantrao s/o Bapu Tekam is acquitted of the offences punishable under Sections 302, 149 and 148 of the Indian Penal Code, for which he was tried in Sessions Case No.110 of 2019 by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Gadchiroli.

iv) The appellant – Dunga @ Yeshu @ Vasantrao s/o Bapu Tekam be released forthwith, if not required in any other case.

v)

The criminal appeal stands disposed of in the above terms. Pending application(s), if any, stand(s) disposed of.