AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
Learned Counsel for the parties were heard on 12.02.2026 and the matter was reserved for orders.
Vide order dated 30.04.2025, after referring to the earlier final order dated 05.11.2023 passed in CC No. 1197 of 2015, this Commission recorded that the Complainants had booked Flat No. TPD-G-F11-1105 admeasuring 1950 sq. ft. for a total consideration of ₹1,37,50,741.50 and that the Builder Buyer Agreement dated 19.04.2011 stipulated delivery of possession within 30 months.
The complaint was disposed of on 05.11.2023 with directions to revoke cancellation, hand over possession within three months subject to payment of the original consideration, pay delay compensation as specified therein and pay ₹1,00,000/- towards litigation costs. While dealing with the cross Execution Applications, this Commission, by order dated 30.04.2025, clarified the following:
The issue concerning the Bank and the subvention scheme did not survive, the Bank not being a party to the proceedings;
The amount actually received by the Judgment Debtor (JD) i.e., ₹89,78,375/-, shall be treated as the consideration received;
The liability of JD to pay compensation under Para 17(B) of the order dated 05.11.2023 would arise only upon compliance by the Decree Holder (DH) with Para 17(A), namely payment of the balance sale consideration.
The JD contended that under the Tripartite Agreement dated 26.04.2011, the JD settled the loan account with the Bank by paying ₹1,09,67,000, and the amount payable by the DH to take possession is Rs.1,07,09,010 as on 28.05.2025. Thereafter, pursuant to the order dated 13.11.2025, the DH was directed to file a detailed statement of calculation explaining the variance with the JD's computation. Accordingly, the DH had filed revised calculation dated 13.01.2026 (filed on 15.01.2026), computing the balance payable as ₹66,63,719.
As regards the amount received by the JD from the Bank, on behalf of the DH under the tripartite agreement and the liability thereon, the issue has already been answered by the earlier clarification dated 30.04.2025, wherein it was clarified that disputes relating to the Bank or the subvention scheme do not survive in the execution proceedings and that the amount actually received by the JD, i.e., ₹89,78,375, shall be treated as the consideration received.
At the stage of execution, neither of the parties can enlarge the scope of liability determined under the final order dated 05.11.2023. The payment made by JD to the Bank pursuant to the Tripartite Agreement constitutes a separate arrangement and it cannot override or modify the operative directions already attained finality.
In view of the above, after due consideration of the calculations filed by the learned Counsels for the DH dated 15.01.2026 and the JD dated 29.05.2025, the following liabilities are determined:
The total Sale Consideration is Rs.1,41,97,932.
The advance paid by DH is Rs.25,24,213.
Payment from HDFC Bank as on 29.04.2021 (Loan Amount) is ₹89,78,375.
The total payment paid by DH therefore is Rs.1,15,02,588.
Interest on total payment @ 6% from April 2013 to December 2016 i.e. till the loan amount repaid to HDFC is Rs.28,53,334.
Interest @ 6% for balance period, from December 2016 to January, 2018 on Rs.25,24,213/- paid in advance by DH is Rs.3,00,000.
The claim for interest @ 9% by the complainant from January 2018 to December 2025 on Rs.25,24,213 is rejected for being inadmissible and this issue was clarified vide order dated 30.04.2025.
Litigation cost is Rs.1,00,000.
Payment made to HDFC Bank for loan repayment by JD is Rs.1,09,67,000/-.
In view of the foregoing the balance due to be paid by the Complainant to the OP is as below:
| Sl. No. & Particulars | Amount to be paid to the JD | Admissible Deductions | Balance due to be paid by the DH |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1.Total Sale Consideration | Rs.1,41,97,932 | ||
| 2.Advance paid by DH | Rs.25,24,213 | ||
| 3. Interest on total payment @ 6% from Apr 2013 to Dec 2016 i.e. till the loan amount repaid to HDFC Bank. | Rs.28,53,334 | ||
| 4. Interest @ 6% from Dec 2016 to Jan 2018 on Rs.25,24,213 paid in advance by DH. | Rs.3,00,000 | ||
| 5. Litigation cost | Rs.1,00,00 | ||
| 6. Total amount paid by DH | Rs.57,77,547 | ||
| Total amount payable by DH | Rs.1,41,97,932 | Rs.57,77,547 | Rs.84,20,385 |
Upon receipt of the said amount, the JD shall, within four weeks:
Hand over peaceful and physical possession of the subject unit to the DH, if not already done; and
Execute and register all necessary documents;
In the event of default by either party, the other side is at liberty to revive the Execution for further action under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019.
The Execution Application No. 383/2024, E.A. No.1/2025 and RA No.80/2025 along with all pending applications stand disposed of in the above terms.
