High CourtsDivision Bench(2023) 05 KL CK 0126

Dr. A. P. Jayadevan vs Arun K.V

High Court Of Kerala · Decided on 22 May 2023

HON’BLE JUDGES
P.B.Suresh Kumar, J · Sophy Thomas, J
RESULT
Dismissed
CASE NUMBER
Writ Appeal Nos. 242, 259 Of 2023

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

17 paragraphs · 2,846 words

P.B.Suresh Kumar, J.

1.

Among these appeals, W.A.No.242 of 2023 is preferred against the order in R.P.No.1272 of 2022 in W.P.(C) No.13120 of 2022 and W.A.No.259 of 2023 is preferred against the judgment in W.P.(C) No.42241 of 2022. As the issues arising for consideration in the appeals are closely interlinked, they are disposed of by this common judgment. Parties and documents are referred to in this judgment for convenience, as they appear in W.P.(C) No.13120 of 2022.

2.

The petitioner is an Assistant Professor in an aided college affiliated to the University of Calicut. He was eligible to be considered for Career Advancement Promotion to the Senior Scale (Academic Level 11) in terms of the Regulations issued by the University Grants Commission. Career Advancement Promotions are to be granted by the Screening-cum-Evaluation Committee constituted in terms of the Regulations. As far as the teachers of affiliated colleges are concerned, the Screening-cum-Evaluation Committee is to consist of the Principal of the College, the Head of the Department and two subject experts to be nominated by the University. When the petitioner and another teacher namely, Smt.Jewel John Alappat in the Political Science Department of the College became eligible to be considered for Career Advancement Promotion to Senior Scale, at the request of the College, the University appointed one Smt.J.Anuja and one Smt.Sheela Kumari M.P. as subject experts for constituting the Screening-cum-Evaluation Committee. Pursuant to the nomination of the subject experts, a Screening-cum-Evaluation Committee (the Committee) was constituted for assessing the performance of the petitioner as also Smt.Jewel John Alappat, and a meeting of the Committee was convened on 05.11.2020 by the fourth respondent who was the Principal of the college then. It is stated by the petitioner that even though the Committee met on 05.11.2020 and resolved to grant Senior Scale to the petitioner, the fourth respondent refused to sign the minutes of the meeting of the Committee. According to the petitioner, having attended and presided over the meeting, the fourth respondent was obliged to sign the minutes of the meeting, and on account of the refusal on the part of the fourth respondent in signing the minutes, the petitioner is unable to secure promotion, which is legitimately due to him. The writ petition was filed, in the circumstances, seeking directions to the Manager and the Principal of the College to ensure that the fourth respondent signs the minutes of the meeting of the Committee and to initiate steps to promote the petitioner to the Senior Scale.

3.

The fourth respondent filed a counter affidavit contending that even though the meeting of the Committee was convened by him on 05.11.2020, the said meeting did not take place as he had to make various arrangements on the said day for conducting a few examinations as per the protocol fixed by the Health Department of the State Government for students suspected to have been inflicted with Covid-19. It was also stated in the counter affidavit that he could not convene the Committee again as he resigned from the office of the Principal a few days after 05.11.2020.

4.

It is seen that when the writ petition was taken up, the learned counsel for the Manager and the Principal of the College asserted that the meeting had very much taken place as scheduled on 05.11.2020 and that the fourth respondent, after having attended and presided over the meeting, refused to put his signature in the minutes of the meeting, and the learned counsel handed over to the Court the Minutes of the meeting. In order to substantiate the said stand, it was also pointed out by the learned counsel that the fourth respondent issued Ext.P6 duty certificate to Smt.J.Anuja, the subject expert nominated by the University for having participated in the meeting held on 05.11.2020. Even though the learned counsel for the fourth respondent asserted that the meeting of the Committee did not take place on 05.11.2020, in the light of Ext.P6 duty certificate, the learned Single Judge took the view that the fourth respondent cannot be heard to contend that the Committee did not meet on 05.11.2020. Though it was observed by the learned Single Judge that the Court does not intend to go into the question whether the Committee met on 05.11.2020, it was held that insofar as the minutes of the meeting reveal that three among the members of the Committee have affixed their signatures therein, there is no reason to deny the benefit of promotion due to the petitioner. Consequently, the writ petition was disposed of directing the Manager of the College to take necessary steps to enable the petitioner to get the promotion due to him.

5.

Earlier, on 06.01.2022, the Manager of the College issued a notice to the fourth respondent directing him to show cause why disciplinary action shall not be taken against him for his misconduct in refusing to sign the minutes of the meeting of the Committee, after having participated in the meeting. The fourth respondent sent a reply to the said show cause notice refuting the allegations against him and reiterating his stand taken in the counter affidavit. After the disposal of the writ petition, having found that the explanation offered by the fourth respondent to the show cause notice is unsatisfactory, the Manager of the College ordered a disciplinary enquiry against the fourth respondent into the allegation levelled against him in the sho w cause notice. Annexure A4 in W.A.No.259 of 2023 is the order issued in this regard.

6.

It is in the light of Annexure A4 order that the fourth respondent preferred R.P.No.1272 of 2022 seeking review of the judgment in the writ petition mainly on the ground that the finding rendered by this Court in paragraph 6 of the judgment that the fourth respondent cannot be heard to contend that there was no meeting on 05.11.2020 would prejudice him in the disciplinary enquiry. Simultaneously, the fourth respondent filed a writ petition also as W.P.(C) No.42241 of 2022 challenging Annexure A4 order and seeking a declaration that the meeting of the Committee did not take place on 05.11.2020.

7.

The learned Single Judge dismissed the review petition taking the view that the observation made in paragraph 6 of the judgment was in the context of the claim of the petitioner for promotion and not one made against the fourth respondent, indicating that the same may not prejudice the fourth respondent in any manner in the disciplinary enquiry.

8.

It is seen that at the time of hearing of the review petition, it was submitted by the counsel for the fourth respondent that despite specific requests, the fourth respondent is not being served with a copy of the minutes of the meeting of the Committee relied on by the College. In the context of the said submission, the learned Single Judge directed that if a request is made in that regard by the fourth respondent, the same shall be acted upon by the competent authority. After the disposal of the review petition in the aforesaid manner, the learned Single Judge closed W.P.(C) No.42241 of 2022 also, holding that nothing survives in the writ petition in the light of the order in the review petition. The fourth respondent is aggrieved by the order in the review petition as also the judgment in W.P.(C) No.42241 of 2022 and hence, these appeals.

9.

Heard the learned counsel for the fourth respondent, the learned counsel for the petitioner, the learned Standing Counsel for the University as also the learned counsel for the Principal and the Manager of the College.

10.

The learned counsel for the fourth respondent pointed out at the outset that the fourth respondent was not provided by the College a copy of the minutes of the meeting of the Committee relied on by them and the same was served on him only after the disposal of the review petition. It was also pointed out by the learned counsel that the minutes of the meeting of the Committee given to the fourth respondent reveals that the meeting stated to have taken place on 05.11.2020 is one which does not have the requisite quorum. Relying on the provisions contained in the Regulations issued by the University Grants Commission, it was submitted by the learned counsel that the quorum for the meeting shall be three, and only two members constituting the Committee is seen to have attended the meeting. It was contended by the learned counsel, therefore, that the question whether the fourth respondent refused to put his signature in the minutes of the meeting of the Committee after having presided over the same, is very much relevant in the context of adjudicating the right of the petitioner to claim promotion, for, if the fourth respondent had not participated in the meeting, the claim of the petitioner that he is entitled to be promoted to the Senior Scale can only be rejected, as such a meeting would be invalid for want of quorum. It was argued by the learned counsel that the said question being a disputed question of fact, this Court ought not have decided the writ petition in the manner aforesaid. It was submitted by the learned counsel that even though the fourth respondent is not affected in any manner by the promotion claimed by the petitioner, in the light of the disciplinary proceedings initiated against him by the College and the stand taken by him in the said proceedings, he is very much aggrieved by the finding in the judgment that he cannot be heard to contend that the meeting did not take place on 05.11.2020.

11.

The learned counsel for the Principal and the Manger as also the counsel for the petitioner did not dispute the fact that without the presence of the fourth respondent in the meeting stated to have taken place on 05.11.2020, there would not have been the requisite quorum for the meeting, and the petitioner was entitled to succeed in the writ petition only if the case put forward by him that the fourth respondent had participated in the meeting was accepted by the court. The learned counsel, however, asserted based on Ext.P6 duty certificate that the stand taken by the fourth respondent that the meeting of the Committee did not take place on 05.11.2020, cannot be accepted.

12.

We have examined the arguments advanced by the learned counsel for the parties on either side.

13.

As noted, the fact that the quorum for the meeting of the Committee shall be three is not in dispute. Similarly, the fact that only two members constituting the Committee have affixed their signatures in the minutes of the meeting relied on by the petitioner is also not in dispute. Of course, if the case of the petitioner that the fourth respondent had participated in the said meeting and agreed to the decision taken therein to grant Senior Scale to him is accepted, there may not be any difficulty in allowing the claim of the petitioner. But, inasmuch as the said case of the petitioner is refuted by the fourth respondent, without there being an adjudication on the said question, the petitioner could not have been granted any relief in the writ petition. Even though it was held by the learned Single Judge that the fourth respondent cannot be heard to contend that a meeting of the Committee had not taken place on 05.11.2020, the case set out by the petitioner that the fourth respondent refused to sign the minutes of the meeting after having attended the meeting was not accepted by the learned single judge. The question to be considered is whether the case set out by the petitioner that a meeting of the Committee had taken place on 5.11.2020 and that the fourth respondent, after participating in the meeting, had refused to put his signature in the minutes of the meeting, has been established by the petitioner. Even if it is conceded that a meeting of the Committee had taken place on 05.11.2020, there is absolutely no material to infer that the fourth respondent had participated in the meeting. Ext.P6 duty certificate does not lead to the inference that the fourth respondent had participated in the meeting. Be that as it may, the minutes of the meeting of the Committee as given to the fourth respondent is part of the records as Annexure A1 in W.A.No.242 of 2023. The said minutes contains only signatures of the Head of the Department and Smt.J.Anuja. It does not contain the signature of the fourth respondent and Smt.Sheelakumari M.P., the other subject expert nominated by the University. Ext.P4 in W.P.(C) No.42241 of 2022 is the communication addressed by the fourth respondent in his capacity as the Principal of the College on 03.11.2020 to Smt.J.Anuja requesting to intimate a convenient date for convening the meeting of the Committee to consider the entitlement of the petitioner and Smt.Jewel John Alappat for promotion to Senior Scale. The minutes, however, is seen to have been prepared as if the meeting of the Committee was convened solely for the purpose of considering the entitlement of the petitioner for promotion. Had the minutes of the meeting been produced in the writ petition, it would have been obligatory for the College to offer an explanation as to the reason why Smt.Sheelakumari M.P. had not participated in the meeting stated to have been held on 5.11.2020 and as to the reason why the entitlement of Smt.Jewel John Alappat was not considered in the said meeting. The aforesaid circumstances, according to us, would cast some doubt as to the genuineness of the case put forward by the petitioner as also the college that the Committee met on 05.11.2020 and the fourth respondent, after having participated in the meeting of the committee, refused to sign the minutes of the meeting. Needless to say, in the peculiar facts of this case, the learned Single Judge ought not have entertained the writ petition, ought to have allowed the review petition and vacated the finding in the judgment that the fourth respondent cannot be heard to contend that there was no meeting on 05.11.2020. As the direction to the Manager of the College to take necessary steps so as to enable the petitioner to get the promotion due to him cannot be granted without there being a finding that a valid meeting of the committee had taken place on 05.11.2020, the learned Single Judge ought not have granted the relief sought for by the petitioner.

14.

While holding so, we are conscious of the fact that the fourth respondent may not have the locus standi to challenge the judgment in the writ petition insofar as it relates to the grant of Senior Scale to the petitioner. But, insofar as the finding in the judgment that the fourth respondent cannot be heard to contend that there was no meeting on 05.11.2020 is likely to prejudice him in the disciplinary enquiry, it cannot be said that he has no locus standi to seek review of the decision of the learned single judge.

15.

Coming to the writ petition filed by the fourth respondent, as noted, the same was instituted for a declaration that the meeting of the Committee did not take place on 05.11.2020 and that the fourth respondent did not participate in the said meeting. The fourth respondent has also claimed in the writ petition orders quashing Annexure A4 communication in W.A.No.259 of 2023 on that basis. As noted, the petitioner as also the Principal and the Manager of the College were asserting all throughout that the meeting of the Committee did take place on 05.11.2020 and that the fourth respondent had participated in the said meeting. In other words, the fourth respondent was seeking in the writ petition, a declaration on a disputed question of fact. Such a declaration cannot be granted in a proceedings under Article 226 of the Constitution. Since the fourth respondent has challenged Annexure A4 communication on the basis of the declaration sought in the writ petition, he is not entitled to the said relief also.

In the result, W.A.No.259 of 2023 is dismissed. W.A.No.242 of 2023 is allowed, the order impugned therein is set aside, R.P.No.1272 of 2022 is allowed and W.P.(C) No.13120 of 2022 is dismissed. It is made clear that this judgment will not preclude the College from taking steps to convene a proper meeting of the Committee to consider the entitlement of the petitioner for promotion to Senior Scale and grant him Senior Scale, if he is entitled to the same, in accordance with law. It is also made clear that the findings in this judgment as regards the meeting stated to have taken place on 5.11.2020, is only that the petitioner could not establish that such a meeting had taken place and the same, therefore, will not preclude the College from continuing the disciplinary enquiry against the fourth respondent, if there are independent materials available with the College that the fourth respondent, having participated in the meeting, refused to sign the minutes of the meeting.