AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
Heard. ADMIT. Taken up for final disposal forthwith by the consent of the learned counsel appearing for the parties.
This application filed under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (Cr.P.C.) seeks quashing of First Information Report (FIR) No. 211/2026 dated 02.08.2016 registered with Police Station, Saoner, Dist. Nagpur for the offence punishable under Section 420 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC).
The facts of the case, in brief, are as under :-
i] The applicant had agreed to sell an agricultural land owned by him bearing survey No. 52/1, situated at Mouza Malegaon, Tal. Saoner, Dist. Nagpur, vide agreement dated 03.06.2015 to the complainant/non-applicant no.2. The complainant paid an amount of ₹11,00,000/- through a cheque and ₹24,00,000 in cash to the applicant. As per the agreement, the remaining consideration was to be paid by 30.06.2016 in staggered manner. As, the last date to perform the contract was 30.06.2016, the complainant sent the cheques of ₹30,00,000 to the applicant by Speed Post.
ii] It is alleged that the complainant received a notice dated 28.03.2016 from the brother of the applicant namely Waman Gopal Walke in respect of the agricultural land in question. When the complainant sought to talk with the applicant regarding this notice, the applicant avoided to talk with the complainant in that respect. Later on, the complainant came to know that the land in question has been sold by the applicant to one Mamtha Vishnu Aandev, Waman Gopal Walke and Mohan Manohar Khapre vide Sale Deed dated 28.04.2016, in breach of the agreement dated 03.06.2015 executed between the applicant and the complainant and thereby cheated the complainant. Therefore, on his complaint, the FIR came to be registered against the applicant for the aforesaid offence.
Heard Mr. Amol Jaltare, learned counsel appearing for the applicant, Mr. Indraneel Damle, learned APP for non-applicant no.1/State and Mr. Kartik N. Shukul with Mr. K.P. Mahalle, learned counsel appearing for non-applicant no.2/complainant. Perused the record.
Mr. Jaltare, the learned counsel appearing for the applicant vehemently submitted that the dispute is only in respect of cancellation of the agreement dated 03.06.2015. The said agreement has been cancelled because the complainant did not pay the remaining agreed amount on or before 30.06.2016 as per the terms of the agreement, despite various requests. According to the learned counsel for the applicant, the dispute between the applicant and the complainant is purely civil in nature and the colour of criminality has been given to the said civil dispute to pressurise the applicant.
Mr. Jaltare, the learned counsel for the applicant contended that the applicant had received the said property by way of partition in the year 1969. As per the partition deed, the brother of the applicant had preferential right to purchase the said property. Therefore, the brother of the complainant issued notice to the applicant as well as to the present complainant in exercise of his pre-emption right. Since, the brother of the applicant had a right of pre-emption, the applicant sold the land in question as per the terms of the Partition Deed to his brother and the daughter and the son-in-law of his brother. According to him, there was no breach of terms of the agreement executed between the applicant and the complainant at the hands of the applicant and in wake of the exercise of pre-emption right by his brother, the agreement was required to be cancelled. According to him, there is no element of criminality in the present case and no offence is made out against the applicant. There is nothing on record to demonstrate that the applicant had executed the agreement in question with an intention to cheat the complainant since the beginning and not to perform it. According to him, the circumstances led to the cancellation of the agreement. The sum and substance of the submissions of the learned counsel for the applicant is that the present matter is civil in nature and a civil suit is pending between the applicant and the complainant with regard to the property in question. Therefore, he seeks quashing of the FIR.
To buttress his submissions, Mr. Jaltare seeks to rely on the decision in the case of Kunti and Another Vs. State of Uttar Pradesh and another, reported at (2023) 6 SCC 109, wherein relying on the decision in the case of Sarabjit Kaur Vs. State of Punjab [(2023) 5 SCC 360], the Supreme Court has observed that mere breach of contract does not give rise to criminal prosecution for cheating unless fraudulent or dishonest intention is shown right at the beginning of the transaction. Mere allegation of failure to keep up promise will not be enough to initiate criminal proceedings.
Reliance is also placed by Mr. Jaltare on the decision in the case of Radheyshyam and others Vs. State of Rajasthan and another, reported at 2024 SCC Online SC 2311, wherein in paragraph No. 9 the Supreme Court has held as under :-
“9.From the bare perusal of the FIR, it is evident that there was no act of cheating, that is, the complainant was nowhere fraudulently induced or dishonestly deceived by the appellants. A commercial transaction took place between the parties during which the parties consensually agreed for the sale of the property of the appellants and respondent no. 2 paid the part consideration. The default in payment of their loan dues on part of the appellants is not reflective of their deceitful intention towards the complainant. Mere non-registration of the sale or its refusal cannot amount to cheating. The delivery of the advance payment towards consideration was made in furtherance of an Agreement to Sell and it is not the case of the respondent that he was in anyway deceived or duped to make such payments to the appellants. It is a civil dispute and gives rise to the complainant's right to resort to the remedies provided under civil law by filing a suit for specific performance.
On the other hand, Mr. Shukul, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the complainant vehemently objected the application on the ground that the material on record as well as the conduct of the applicant suggests the fraudulent and dishonest intention on his part. According to him, despite the fact that applicant was aware about the right of pre-emption of his brother in view in the partition deed, he agreed to sell the property to the complainant and accepted the amount of ₹11,00,000/- by cheque and ₹24,00,000 in cash. According to him, this itself suggests that the applicant was knowing that he had no right to sell the property in question to any other person and despite that he sold the property to the complainant. Thereafter, a notice was issued to the applicant and the complainant by the brother of the applicant. Mr. Shukul further submitted that the Sale Deed dated 28.04.2016 is not only in the name of the brother of the applicant, but it is in the name of other persons also. According to him, this itself depicts that the property has been sold to other persons just because the rate of the property was increased. According to him, the facts on record are clearly suggestive of the fact that the applicant had fraudulent and dishonest intention since inception of the transaction. Therefore, a case is made out for invoking the criminal jurisdiction by lodging the FIR.
Mr. Shukul submitted that just because a civil suit is pending between the parties, criminal proceeding is not barred. Both the proceedings can go hand in hand. According to him, the Sale Deed dated 28.04.2016 executed by the applicant is nothing but a sham and bogus document just to dodge the complainant. According to him, subsequent payment was to be made after measurement of the land which the applicant failed to do. Therefore, the amount was not paid on due date because of the delay in measurement and obtaining No Objection Certificate from the bank. He further submitted that though the applicant has shown readiness to repay the amount, but till date, he has not paid amount of consideration which the complainant has parted with the applicant. According to him, all these are disputed facts which are required to be gone into during the trial.
To buttress his submission, Mr. Shukul seeks to rely on the decision in the case of Priti Saraf and another Vs. State of NCT of Delhi and another, in Criminal Appeal No. 296 of 2021, decided on10.03.2021, wherein at paragraphs 32 and 33, the Supreme Court has observed as under
“32.In the instant case, on a careful reading of the complaint/FIR/charge-sheet, in our view, it cannot be said that the complaint does not disclose the commission of an offence. The ingredients of the offences under Sections 406 and 420 IPC cannot be said to be absent on the basis of the allegations in the complaint/FIR/charge-sheet. We would like to add that whether the allegations in the complaint are otherwise correct or not, has to be decided on the basis of the evidence to be led during the course of trial. Simply because there is a remedy provided for breach of contract or arbitral proceedings initiated at the instance of the appellants, that does not by itself clothe the court to come to a conclusion that civil remedy is the only remedy, and the initiation of criminal proceedings, in any manner, will be an abuse of the process of the court for exercising inherent powers of the High Court under Section 482 CrPC for quashing such proceedings.
33.We have perused the pleadings of the parties, the complaint/FIR/charge-sheet and orders of the Courts below and have taken into consideration the material on record. After hearing learned counsel for the parties, we are satisfied that the issue involved in the matter under consideration is not a case in which the criminal trial should have been short-circuited. The High Court was not justified in quashing the criminal proceedings in exercise of its inherent jurisdiction. The High Court has primarily adverted on two circumstances, (i) that it was a case of termination of agreement to sell on account of an alleged breach of the contract and (ii) the fact that the arbitral proceedings have been initiated at the instance of the appellants. Both the alleged circumstances noticed by the High Court, in our view, are unsustainable in law. The facts narrated in the present complaint/FIR/charge-sheet indeed reveal the commercial transaction but that is hardly a reason for holding that the offence of cheating would elude from such transaction. In fact, many a times, offence of cheating is committed in the course of commercial transactions and the illustrations have been set out under Sections 415, 418 and 420 IPC. Similar observations have been made by this Court in Trisuns Chemical Industry Vs. Rajesh Agarwal and Ors. (supra) :-
"9.We are unable to appreciate the reasoning that the provision incorporated in the agreement for referring the disputes to arbitration is an effective substitute for a criminal prosecution when the disputed act is an offence. Arbitration is a remedy for affording reliefs to the party affected by breach of the agreement but the arbitrator cannot conduct a trial of any act which amounted to an offence albeit the same act may be connected with the discharge of any function under the agreement. Hence, those are not good reasons for the High Court to axe down the complaint at the threshold itself. The investigating agency should have had the freedom to go into the whole gamut of the allegations and to reach a conclusion of its own. Pre-emption of such investigation would be justified only in very extreme cases as indicated in State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal [1992 Supp (1) SCC 335]"
Reliance is also placed by Mr. Shukul on the order dated 22.06.2015 of the Rajasthan High Court in the case of Gajanand Vs State of Rajasthan and another, in S.B. Criminal Writ Petition No. 08/2014, wherein, the Court has observed as under :-
“So far as the dispute between the parties is essentially a dispute of civil nature is concerned, it is well settled legal position that if prima facie there are ingredients of an offence, as disclosed from the complaint/FIR, the same cannot be quashed on the ground that civil proceedings can also be filed against the accused on the basis of same facts. It is now well settled legal position that both civil and criminal proceedings can proceed simultaneously, if essential ingredients of the offence are also made out. It is also well settled legal position that at the stage of considering the issue of quashing of FIR in exercise of jurisdiction conferred on the High Court under Section 482 Cr.P.C. or under Article 226 of the Constitution of India defence or proposed defence of the accused cannot be considered and only on the basis of prima facie perusal of the FIR and documents filed alongwith it, it is to be decided whether from them an offence is made out or not. In the present case, the material towards which the attention of the Court has been invited by the learned counsel for the petitioner and which has been filed alongwith the petition at the most can come within the purview of defence of the petitioner.”
The judgment of the Coordinate Bench of this Court (Principal Seat) in the case of V.B. Padode and another Vs. M/s Indus Cruising and Shipping (P) Ltd. in Criminal Writ Petition No. 1690 of 2007, dated 27.09.2019 is also pressed into service by the learned counsel for the complainant, wherein, in paragraphs 20 and 21, the Court has observed as under :-
“20.To sum up, according to the complainant, there is no compliance of all the requirements/clauses of the MOU by the Petitioners within the stipulated period, nowhere the Petitioners are placed any document on record showing that the complainant in express words before writing letter dated 15/07/1997 has communicated the Petitioners that the complainant is not in a position to take steps in furtherance of MOU. As already observed, it is clear from the letter dated 13/10/1997 that the Petitioners agreed to refund the amount to the Petitioners, however, till date the said refund has not been done by the Petitioners, on the contrary, the Petitioners advertised the subject property for sale to third party, which according to the complainant, amounts to breach of trust. As already observed herein above, the Petitioners gave impression to the complainant that there is clear title to the subject property, however, prima facie it appears that since inception the Petitioners had intention to cheat the complainant. In the facts of the present, it needs to be noted that till hearing of this Writ Petition, admittedly the Petitioners did not refund the amount as mentioned in their letter dated 13/10/1997 which they agreed to pay to the complainant.
21.It is pertinent to mention at this stage that the facts of the present case stand on different footing vis-a-vis the judgments (supra) cited by the learned counsel for the Petitioners. The ratio laid down in the recent judgment of the Supreme Court in Kamal Shivaji Pokarnekar (supra) squarely applies to the present case, wherein it is observed by the Supreme Court that criminal complaints cannot be quashed only on the ground that the allegations made therein appear to be of a civil nature, and if the ingredients of the offence alleged against the are prima facie made out in the complaint, the criminal proceedings shall not be interdicted.”
Before adverting to the facts of the case, let me state the law with regard to cheating which is filed under Section 415 of the IPC and runs thus :
“415. Cheating.—
Whoever, by deceiving any person, fraudulently or dishonestly induces the person so deceived to deliver any property to any person, or to consent that any person shall retain any property, or intentionally induces the person so deceived to do or omit to do anything which he would not do or omit if he were not so deceived, and which act or omission causes or is likely to cause damage or harm to that person in body, mind, reputation or property, is said to “cheat”.
Explanation.— A dishonest concealment of facts is a deception within the meaning of this section.” Whereas, Section 420 of the IPC reads as under :
“420. Cheating and dishonestly inducing delivery of property.—
Whoever cheats and thereby dishonestly induces the person deceived to deliver any property to any person, or to make, alter or destroy the whole or any part of a valuable security, or anything which is signed or sealed, and which is capable of being converted into a valuable security, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to seven years, and shall also be liable to fine.”
Perusal of both the aforesaid provisions reveal that in order to constitute the offence of ‘cheating’, there must be dishonest or fraudulent inducement of a person to deliver any property to another, or to consent to the retention of any property by any person. There must be intentional inducement causing a person to do or to omit an act which he would not have done or omitted if he was not so deceived and such an act or omission causes or is likely to cause damage or harm to that person’s body, mind, reputation or property. Where such cheating results in the delivery of property or involves the making, alteration, or destruction of a valuable security, the offence becomes punishable under Section 420 of the IPC.
It is now well settled that in order to constitute an offence of cheating, the intention to deceive should be in exitence at the time when the inducement was made. If there is a dishonest and fraudulent intention on the part of an accused since inception, it will amount to the offence of cheating.
If the prosecution has prima facie established that the accused had a dishonest intention right from the inception of the transaction, criminal proceedings can certainly be initiated. There is no bar for simultaneously proceeding with civil and criminal proceedings. If the element of criminality is found, a civil proceeding can co-exist with a criminal proceeding on the same facts. Availing of civil remedy ipso-facto is not a sufficient ground to quash the FIR. The obvious caveat being that the allegations, even if having a civil flavour to them, must prima facie disclose an overwhelming element of criminality. In the absence of an element of criminality, if both the civil and the criminal cases are allowed to continue, it will definitely amount to an abuse of the process of the Court.
With this legal principle, let me deal with the facts of the present case. Minute perusal of the FIR depicts that the agreement to sell agricultural land was executed by the applicant in favour of the complainant on 03.06.2015 for valuable consideration. After accepting the cheque of ₹11,00,000/- and ₹24,00,000/- in cash, the agreement depicts that the balance consideration was to be paid by 30.06.2016 in staggered manner. It is alleged that after receipt of notice issued by the brother of the applicant, the complainant tried to contact the applicant, but he avoided to talk with him. It is further alleged that the applicant in breach of the agreement, sold the land in question to his brother and the relatives and thereby cheated him. The FIR does not depict any allegation of dishonest and fraudulent intention on the part of the applicant since inception of the transaction.
It is contended by Mr. Shukul that dishonest and fraudulent intention on the part of the applicant was there since inception. Despite knowing that there was a right of pre-emption in favour of his brother, the applicant intended to sell the land to the complainant.
It is also the matter of record that the brother of the applicant namely Waman Gopal Walke had issued notice to the applicant as well as the complainant after he came to know about the dealing of the agricultural land in question wherein he claimed to have a right of pre-emption in the property. It is also not in dispute that the said property was received by the applicant in partition of the year 1969 wherein right of pre-emption to purchase the property was with the brother of the applicant pursuant to which a sale deed came to be executed by the applicant in favour of his brother and the daughter and the son-in-law of his brother.
Merely because there was a right of pre-emption clause in the Partition Deed of the year 1969 between the applicant and his brother and despite that if the applicant agreed to sell the land to somebody else that does not amount to fraudulent or dishonest intention on his part, particularly when the applicant after issuance of notice by his brother to him and the complainant, the applicant was ready to return the amount which he had accepted from the complainant. Therefore, unless there is something overwhelming material in the FIR showing dishonest and fraudulent intention at the very inception, which is absent in this case. Despite of condition in the partition deed of exercising prior right of purchase if a person agree to sell the property, it cannot be said that the applicant had dishonest intention to cheat the complainant at the time of execution of the agreement. The applicant ought to have asked his brother before entering into an agreement with the complainant. Nonetheless it will not be cheating towards the complainant who agreed to purchase the property just because the applicant’s brother exercised the right of pre-emption.
An attempt is made to show that the Sale Deed dated 28.04.2016 executed by the applicant is not in the sole name his brother in exercise of his right of pre-emption. Perusal of the sale deed shows that the applicant had executed sale deed in favour of his brother as well as his daughter and the son-in-law. This will not help the complainant to say that the property has been sold to someone else. Even otherwise there was a dispute between the applicant and the complainant about the performance of their part of the contract which is a civil dispute pending before the competent Civil Court. Just because the dispute existed with regard to performance of contract, this itself will not decide the dishonest intention on the part of the applicant at the time of execution of the agreement in absence of overwhelming evidence.
The decision of the Coordinate Bench of this Court in the case of V.B. Padode (supra) relied upon by the complainant will not help him, wherein the accused, despite knowing that the title of the property was not clear, had agreed to sell the same. Thus, in the said case, title itself was defective. Therefore, in that scenario, the FIR was not quashed by this Court.
In the case of Gajanand (supra), pressed into service by the complainant, a civil suit between the accused and his brother over the title of the property was pending. Rather, the Civil Court had stayed the further transactions in respect of the land in question before it. Despite that, the accused had agreed to sell the land to the complainant in the said case and obtained consideration. Therefore, on facts, the said decision will not help the complainant.
In the case of Priti Saraf (supra), relied upon by the complainant, the accused had not only made false representation, but also forfeited the consideration amount paid by the complainant therein. In that scenario and the facts of the case, the Supreme Court held that the FIR discloses the offence of cheating and allowed the appeal filed by the complainant therein. Whereas, in the present case, there are no allegation against the applicant that he made any positive false representation. Even the FIR does not disclose any allegation of dishonest and fraudulent intention on the part of the applicant. Therefore, the judgment in the case of Priti Saraf (supra) is distinguishable on facts of the present case.
No doubt, the FIR is not an encyclopaedia of all imputations but it must disclose commission of a cognizable offence as held in the case of Somjeet Mallick Vs. State of Jharkhand and others, [2024 INSC 772], which is a pre-requisite condition for registration of the FIR under Section 154 of the Cr.P.C.
Having gone through the FIR and the documents placed on record by both the parties, it is quite clear that the complainant’s grievance was regarding failure on the part of the applicant to perform his part of the contract and breach of the agreement. Thus, essentially the dispute between the parties is for breach of conditions of the agreement. It is a settled law that mere breach of contract is not itself a criminal offence. It only gives rise to a civil liability. Therefore, I do not find that the ingredients of Section 420 of the IPC attracted against the applicant. As such, from the allegations in the FIR, no offence is made out against the applicant.
A reference can be made to the decision of the Supreme Court in the case of State of Haryana and others Vs. Bhajan Lal and others, reported at 1992 Supp (1) SCC 335 which reads thus :
“102.In the backdrop of the interpretation of the various relevant provisions of the Code under Chapter XIV and of the principles of law enunciated by this Court in a series of decisions relating to the exercise of the extraordinary power under Article 226 or the inherent powers under Section 482 of the Code which we have extracted and reproduced above, we have given the following categories of cases by way of illustration wherein such power could be exercised either to prevent abuse of the process of any court or otherwise to secure the ends of justice, though it may not be possible to lay down any precise, clearly defined and sufficiently channelised and inflexible guidelines or rigid formulae and to give an exhaustive list of myriad kinds of cases wherein such power should be exercised.
(1)Where the allegations made in the first information report or the complaint, even if they are taken at their face value and accepted in their entirety do not prima facie constitute any offence or make out a case against the accused.
(2)Where the allegations in the first information report and other materials, if any, accompanying the FIR do not disclose a cognizable offence, justifying an investigation by police officers under Section 156(1) of the Code except under an order of a Magistrate within the purview of Section 155(2) of the Code.
(3)Where the uncontroverted allegations made in the FIR or complaint and the evidence collected in support of the same do not disclose the commission of any offence and make out a case against the accused.
(4)Where, the allegations in the FIR do not constitute a cognizable offence but constitute only a non-cognizable offence, no investigation is permitted by a police officer without an order of a Magistrate as contemplated under Section 155(2) of the Code.
(5)Where the allegations made in the FIR or complaint are so absurd and inherently improbable on the basis of which no prudent person can ever reach a just conclusion that there is sufficient ground for proceeding against the accused.
(6)Where there is an express legal bar engrafted in any of the provisions of the Code or the concerned Act (under which a criminal proceeding is instituted) to the institution and continuance of the proceedings and/or where there is a specific provision in the Code or the concerned Act, providing efficacious redress for the grievance of the aggrieved party
(7)Where a criminal proceeding is manifestly attended with mala fide and/or where the proceeding is maliciously instituted with an ulterior motive for wreaking vengeance on the accused and with a view to spite him due to private and personal grudge.”
In view of the above, the case of the applicant is covered under clause (1) of para 102 of the decision in Bhajan Lal (supra).
Considering the facts mentioned above, a case is made out for exercise of the inherent powers of this Court under Section 482 of the Cr.P.C. in favour of the applicant. Hence, the following order :
ORDER
The Criminal Application is allowed.
First Information Report No. 211/2026 dated 02.08.2016 registered with Police Station, Saoner, Dist. Nagpur for the offence punishable under Section 420 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860, are quashed and set aside.
The application stands disposed of in the above terms.
