High CourtsDivision Bench(2026) 11 AHC CK 3620

Digambar vs State Of Up & Ors.

Allahabad High Court · Decided on 3 November 2026

CASE NUMBER
WRIT - C No. - 30318 of 2026

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

28 paragraphs · 1,388 words

(Per: Garima Prashad, J.)

1.

Heard Sri Rishi Kant Rai, learned counsel for the petitioner and learned Standing Counsel for the State.

2.

The present Writ Petition has been filed seeking a direction to the Chief Development Officer, Aligarh, to consider the petitioner’s application no. 138772486 for inclusion in the selection process under the Mini Nandini Krishak Samriddhi Yojana, implemented under the Nand Baba Dugdh Mission. The petitioner’s grievance is that his application has been excluded because the land offered for the project stands recorded in his father’s name and the consent furnished by his father is not a registered lease deed.

3.

Briefly stated, the facts are that the State Government issued Government Order no. 929/53-2-2024 dated 23.10.2024 for implementation of the Scheme. It provides financial assistance for establishing dairy units of ten cows of specified indigenous breeds, with an estimated project cost of Rs.23.60 lakh and a subsidy of 50%, limited to Rs.11.80 lakhs. The Scheme requires approximately 0.20 acre of land for the dairy unit and an additional 0.80 acre suitable for fodder production. The fodder land may be the applicant’s own, ancestral/shared, or taken under a registered agreement or rent deed for at least seven years.

4.

The petitioner, a resident of village Rajawal, Block Gonda, District Aligarh, submitted an online application under the Scheme. In support of the availability of land, he furnished the khatauni relating to Gata no. 578, Khata no. 00213, recording an area of 0.9300 hectare in the name of his father, Jagvir Singh. He also furnished his father’s affidavit dated 18.09.2025 consenting to the use of that land for the proposed dairy activity. A consent letter dated 21.08.2025 issued by Canara Bank, Gonda Branch, was also placed on record.

5.

According to the petitioner, the authorities insisted upon a registered agreement or rent deed despite the land being available within the family with the recorded tenure-holder’s consent. He submitted a representation dated 06.11.2025 requesting inclusion of his application in the lottery. His application was nevertheless excluded from the selection process.

6.

Learned counsel for the State respondents submits that the district had a target of eight units for 2025–26. Of 75 applications received, 55 were returned for removal of deficiencies and 28 were resubmitted. Thereafter, 48 applications were treated as suitable for the e-lottery held on 06.11.2025, in which eight applicants were selected and the remaining 40 were placed on the waiting list.

7.

Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the Scheme permits ancestral or shared land and does not require a registered lease where the applicant relies upon such land. The khatauni and his father’s consent establish the availability of land exceeding the prescribed area. The insistence upon a registered lease adds a condition which the Government Order does not prescribe and has deprived him of consideration under the Scheme.

8.

Per contra, learned Standing Counsel for the State submits that the dairy site must belong to the applicant himself. The petitioner’s name does not appear in the khatauni, and no registered agreement or rent deed has been produced for the fodder land. He therefore does not fulfil the requirements of clauses 5(iv) and 5(v). The selection for 2025–26 has been completed, and he may apply afresh upon fulfilling the requirements in a subsequent year.

9.

Having considered the rival submissions and the documents placed on record, the question is whether the Government Order requires the dairy site to stand recorded in the applicant’s own name and makes a registered lease compulsory even where the land is recorded in his father’s name and the father has expressly consented to its use.

10.

Clauses 5(iv) and 5(v) of the Government Order dated 23.10.2024 read as follows:

“(iv)

इकाई स् थापना हे तु लगभग 0.20 एकड़ (8712 वगर् फु ट) भूिम उपलब्ध हो।

(v)

इसके अितिरक्त लगभग 0.80 एकड़ (34848 वगर् फुट) भूिम चारा उत्पादन हेतु स् वयं की अथवा पैतृक/साझेदारी अथवा न् यूनतम 07 वषोर्ं के िलए पंजीकृत अनुबन्ध/िकराए नामे पर ली गयी हो तथा भूिम पिरयोजनान्तगर्त चारा उत्पादन के अनुकूल हो। जल भराव वाली तथा ऊसर भूिम जो चारा उत्पादन के अनुकूल न हो अनुमन्य नहीं होगी।”

11.

These provisions require approximately 0.20 acre (8,712 square feet) of land to be available for establishment of the unit. In addition, approximately 0.80 acre (34,848 square feet) for fodder production must be the applicant’s own land, ancestral/shared land, or land taken under a registered agreement/rent deed for a minimum of seven years. The fodder land must be suitable for that purpose; waterlogged or barren land unsuitable for fodder production is not permissible.

12.

The requirement in clause 5(iv) is availability of land for the unit, not an entry in the applicant’s own name in the khatauni. The recorded holder’s consent to the proposed use is therefore relevant to its fulfilment.

13.

The registration requirement in clause 5(v) applies to land taken under an agreement or rent deed for at least seven years. It is not an additional condition for reliance upon ancestral/shared land.

14.

These requirements must be applied in keeping with the Scheme’s object of promoting rural employment and increasing the income of cattle rearers. The authorities must examine the prescribed area, suitability and availability of land without adding a requirement of individual ownership or a lease in every case.

15.

This approach is supported by Union of India v. Prabhakaran Vijaya Kumar, (2008) 9 SCC 527, wherein the Supreme Court has held that beneficial legislation must receive a liberal and purposive construction so as to advance its underlying object. The present Scheme, being a social welfare measure, must be applied in that spirit, so that legitimate claims are not defeated on hyper-technical grounds.

16.

The treatment of family land was considered by this Court in Smt. Gayatri Devi v. State of U.P. and 4 others, Writ–C no. 29414 of 2021, decided on 18.12.2025. In the context of the Mukhyamantri Krishak Durghatna Kalyan Yojana, the Court held that the Scheme was a social welfare measure and did not require the agricultural land to stand in the deceased farmer’s own name. It recognised that land may remain recorded in an elder family member’s name while other members undertake agricultural work, and required the claim to be examined on that basis together with the other conditions of the Scheme.

17.

The same approach applies to the father’s recorded holding and consent under the present Scheme, even if the petitioner has no separate personal right in the land.

18.

The khatauni filed as Annexure no. 4 records Khata no. 00213, Gata no. 578, measuring 0.9300 hectare, in the father's name. This exceeds the combined requirement of approximately one acre for the unit and fodder. The identity of the recorded holder as the petitioner's father is acknowledged by the State.

19.

The father's affidavit, filed as Annexure no. 5, identifies the same Gata and states in paragraph 4:

“यह कि शपथकर्ता के पुत्र द्वारा किये गये आवेदन में गाटा सं० 578 की भूमि में गोपालन करने में मुझे कोई आपत्ति नहीं है बल्कि पूर्ण सहमति है।”

The father thus states on oath that he fully consents to his son carrying on cattle rearing on Gata no. 578. Read with the khatauni, the affidavit establishes the recorded holder's permission for the proposed use.

20.

It is accordingly held that the Government Order does not require the dairy site to stand recorded in the applicant's own name or make a registered lease compulsory where the applicant relies upon his father's holding with the father's express consent. This answers the question framed above. The petitioner's exclusion on that basis is unsustainable.

21.

The petitioner is therefore entitled to consideration of his original application for inclusion in the waiting list, subject to fulfilment of the remaining requirements of the Scheme.

22.

Accordingly, the Writ Petition is allowed and the exclusion of application no. 138772486 is set aside. The Chief Development Officer, Aligarh, in coordination with the Mission Director, Nand Baba Dugdh Mission, shall restore and consider the application for inclusion in the waiting list in accordance with the Scheme and the findings recorded above, after giving the petitioner an opportunity to clarify or supplement his documents. A reasoned decision shall be communicated within eight weeks from the date of production of a certified copy of this order.

23.

There shall be no order as to costs.