High CourtsSingle Bench(2026) 09 BOM CK 7499

Devkant Chichate vs State Of Maharashtra & Ors.

Bombay High Court, Nagpur Bench · Decided on 8 September 2026

HON’BLE JUDGES
Pravin S. Patil, J
CASE NUMBER
First Appeal No. 363 of 2021

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

22 paragraphs · 1,286 words

. Heard Mr. S. D. Chopde, learned Counsel for the Appellant, Mr. M. A. Kadu, learned Counsel for the Respondent Nos.3 and 4 and Ms. D. V Sapkal, learned AGP for the Respondent Nos.1 and 2.

2.

In the present Appeal, challenge is to the Judgment and Award dated 13/5/2019 passed by the Civil Judge Senior Division, Wardha in LAC No. 106/2013, to the extent of 30% deduction from the market value of agricultural land determined by the Reference Court and enhancement of compensation.

3.

In the present case, it is not disputed that the land of the present Appellant was acquired for the purpose of Kolona Distributaries of Lower Wardha Project Division by initiating acquisition proceeding vide Notification dated 25/11/2010 under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894. In the said land acquisition proceeding, the Land Acquisition Officer has awarded compensation of Rs.1,55,000/- per hectare. Being dissatisfied with that compensation amount, the Appellant has preferred the reference proceedings under Section 18 of the Land Acquisition Act Before the Reference Court.

4.

The Appellant, before the Reference Court, has specifically relied upon the sale deed (Exhibit-31), which is in respect of the land situated at the adjacent village namely, Inzala. On the basis of said evidence, it is established by the Appellant before the Reference Court that he is entitled for compensation at the rate of Rs.5,80,433/- per hectare. He also pointed out that the learned Reference Court has specifically recorded that in view of the sale instance, which was relied upon by the Appellant, and the land in question being found of equal quality, the Appellant is held entitled for enhancement of compensation. However, in concluding paras of the Judgment, the learned Reference Court, only on the ground that there is some distance between the land in the sale instance and the land in question, has recorded the finding that deduction of 30% of the amount would be necessary and thereby wrongly deducted the amount in the matter. So also the Reference Court has wrongly held that the land in sale exemplar was/is irrigated land. According to the Appellant, same was/is seasonally irrigated land and thereby granted less compensation.

5.

It is the submission of the present Appellant that finding of the learned Reference Court as regards deduction of 30% of the amount of compensation is without any basis. It was no one’s case before the Reference Court that there is a long distance between two agricultural lands, nor any evidence in that regard was produced on record. Hence, it is the case of the Appellant that in absence of any objection or any reasoning, deduction of 30% of the amount by the Reference Court needs interference in the matter. The Appellant stated that he is entitled for compensation at the rate rate of Rs.5,80,433/- per hectare in the matter.

6.

The learned Counsel for Respondent/Acquiring Body, however, supported the Judgment passed by the learned Reference Court. According to him, if the land in question and the land in the sale deed, which is relied upon, are situated at different place, the learned Reference Court has rightly considered this aspect and deducted 30% of the amount and held that the Appellant is entitled for Rs.3,69,335/- per hectare.

7.

It is well settled position of law that, comparative sale deed is one of the recognised method for awarding compensation to the agriculturist. So also once the Reference Court has reached to the conclusion that the land in question and the land, which is involved in the sale deed, if found to be similar in nature and their fertility and potentiality is also identical, then the Claimant is entitled for the same compensation, irrespective of distance in two agricultural lands.

8.

The learned Counsel for Appellant has pointed out that, before the Reference Court, Appellant has relied upon the sale instance dated 28/7/2009. The said sale instance clearly established the fact that the land involved therein was a seasonally irrigated land. The well situated therein was not a constructed well, rather same was unlined/temporary well. So also 7/12 extract of the said land, which is annexed with the sale deed, does not show that the crops, which the said vendor was yielding from the said land, was irrigated (ckxk;r) land. Hence, according to him, treating the said land as seasonally irrigated land, the Appellant is entitled for enhancement of compensation.

9.

According to the learned Counsel for Appellant, Appellant’s land being seasonally irrigated land, he is entitled for compensation at the same rate i.e. Rs.5,27,667/- per hectare. According to him, the sale deed was executed on 28/7/2009, whereas the acquisition proceeding was initiated by issuing Notification under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 on 25/11/2010, and therefore, 10% escalation price is required to be added in the said amount. As such, according to him, total market value of the land comes to Rs.5,80,433/- per hectare.

10.

The learned Counsel for Respondent/Acquiring Body, in rebuttal of the submission made by the learned Counsel for Appellant, has stated that as per the sale deed there was a well, and therefore, it has to be considered as a perennially irrigated land. According to him, considering the land involved in the sale deed as an irrigated land and the land of the Appellant in question being seasonally irrigated land, market value of the land can be determined as Rs.4,06,258/- per hectare.

11.

In the light of the submissions of learned Counsel for both sides, as far as enhancement of compensation is concerned, as the well in the sale instance was unlined/temporary well and no documentary evidence is available on record to show that the land was irrigated land on the basis of said well, or the crops, which are yielding in the said land shows that the said land was an irrigated land, in my considered opinion, same is required to be considered as semi seasonally irrigated land. Hence, the submission of the Appellant is required to be upheld in the facts and circumstances of the matter.

12.

It is further significant to note that the learned Reference Court has deducted 30% of the amount from the market value determined by the Court, without any justified reasons. Only by recording that 30% of the amount is required to be deducted by taking into consideration the distance between two fields, is not proper and justified reason in the matter. Therefore, such deduction is not permissible in the matter.

13.

In the circumstances, I proceed to pass following order.

ORDER

1.

First Appeal is allowed.

2.

The Judgment and Award dated 13/5/2019 passed by the Civil Judge Senior Division, Wardha in LAC No. 106/2013 is hereby modified to the extent that —

(i)

By determining the market value of the land in question at the rate of Rs.5,80,433/- and the acquired land of the Appellant being admeasuring 0.55 HR, the Appellant is entitled for enhancement of compensation at the rate of Rs.3,19,238/-.

(ii)

The amount which is already paid or determined by the Reference Court would be deducted from the said amount, and accordingly, the Appellant would be entitled for Rs.95,796/- along with all statutory benefits as per the order of the learned Reference Court.

3.

It is made clear that except enhancement of compensation amount, rest of the Judgment and Order dated 13/5/2019 passed by the Civil Judge Senior Division, Wardha in LAC No. 106/2013 is hereby confirmed.

4.

The Respondents shall deposit the enhanced compensation with the Registry of this Court within a period of three months.

5.

After depositing the compensation amount, Appellant would be at liberty to withdraw the same, subject to satisfaction of the Registrar (Judicial) of this Court.

6.

No order as to costs.