Tribunals and CommissionsDivision Bench(2025) 11 ITAT CK 3835

Devender vs Income Tax Officer

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Delhi Bench 'A', New Delhi · Decided on 27 November 2025

RESULT
Allowed
CASE NUMBER
ITA No. 4363/Del./2025

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

37 paragraphs · 2,937 words

Per Satbeer Singh Godara, Judicial Member:

This assessee’s appeal for Assessment Year 2015-16, arises against the C IT(A)/NFAC, De lhi’ s DIN & order No. ITBA/NFAC/S/250/2025-26/1076246252(1) dated 16.05.2025, in proceedings u/ s 147 r .w.s. 144 of the Income Tax Act, 1961.

2.

Heard both the p arties at length. Case file perused.

3.

It transpires d uring the course o f hear ing that the first and foremo st issue between bo th the partie s befo re us is that the validity of sectio n 148 pro ceedings initiated vide notice dated 04.04.2022 itself. This is for the precise reason that the learned assessing authority had set into motion the impugned proceedings beyond the statutory time period of six years from the end o f the relevant assessment year 2015-16 which has been held as not sustainable in law in learned co-ordinate bench’s order in ITA No. 926/Mum/2025 Babu Hasan Shaikh Vs. ITO decided on 28.04.2025 reading as under:

“6 . We hear d t he parties and perused the material on rec ord. In order to examine t he whet her i n assessee's case the notice under s ection 148 is time barr ed or not, we need to first look at the relevant provisions of the Act and the legal position as per judicial prec edenc e. S ection 149(1) of the Act contai n the provisions with re gard to the time limi t for issue of notice under s ecti on 148 of t he Act a nd the s ame reads as under –

149 - T ime limit for no tice.

(1 ) No notice under section 148 shall be issued f or the rel evant assessment year,—

(a)

if three year s have elaps ed f rom the end o f t he rel evant assessment ye ar, unl ess the case falls under claus e (b);

(b)

if three years, but not more t han ten years, have elapsed from t he end of the relevant ass essment year unl ess t he Ass essi ng O fficer has i n his possession books of acc ount or o ther doc uments or evi dence w hich reveal tha t the i ncome charge abl e to tax, r epresented in the form of—

(i)

an ass et;

(ii)

expenditure i n r espect of a tra nsacti on or i n relation to an eve nt or occasion; or

(iii ) an ent ry o r entri es i n the books of acc ount, which has esc aped assessment amounts to or is likely to amo unt to fifty lakh rupees or mor e:

Pro vided that no notice under section 148 shall be issued at any ti me i n a case for the relevant assessment year beginning on or before 1st day of A pril, 2021, if a notice under secti o n 148 or sec tion 153A or s ection 153C could not have been iss ued at that time on acc ount of being bey ond the ti me l imit specified under the provisions of claus e (b) of sub-section (1) of this sec tion or s ect ion 153A or section 153C, as the case may be ], as they stood immediatel y befo re t he c ommencement of the Fi nance Act, 2021 Pro vided fur the r that the provisions of this sub-s ection shall no t apply in a case, whe re a notice under s ecti on 153A, or section 1 53C read wi th secti on 153A, is required to be iss ued i n relation to a search initi ated under section 132 or books of acc ount , other documents or any assets requisitio ned under s ecti on 132A, o n or before t he 31st day of Marc h, 2021: Pro vided also t hat for cases referr ed t o in claus es (i), (iii ) and (iv ) of Explanation 2 to sect ion 148, where,— (a) a sea rch is i nitiated under section 132; or (b) a s ear ch under secti on 132 fo r which the last of aut horizations i s exec uted; or (c ) r equisiti on is made under s ec tion 132A, aft er t he 15th day of Marc h of any fi nancial y ear and t he period for i ssue of notice unde r secti on 148 expir es on the 3 1st day of March of such fi nancial year, a period of fift een days s hall be excl uded for t he purpose of computing t he perio d of li mitation as per this section and t he notice issued under s ecti on 148 i n s uch c ase s hall be deemed to hav e been iss ued on the 31st day of March of suc h financial year: Pro vided also that where the i nf ormation as ref erred to i n Explanati on 1 t o secti on 148 em anates f rom a statement rec orde d or documents i mpound ed und er section 13 1 or section 133A, as t he c ase may be, on or before t he 31st day of March of a financial year, i n conseque nce of,— (a) a sea rch under s ecti on 132 whi ch is i nitiated; or (b) a s ear ch under secti on 132 fo r which the last of aut horizations i s exec uted; or (c ) a requisiti on made und er secti on 132A, after t he 15th day of March of s uch fi nancial year, a perio d of fi fteen days s hall be excl uded for t he purpose of com puti ng the pe riod of limitati on as per t his s ection and the notic e issued unde r claus e (b) of secti on 148A in such case shall be deemed to have been issued on t he 31st day of Marc h of suc h fi nancial year Pro vided also tha t for the purposes of comp uti ng the perio d of limitatio n as p er this secti on, the time or extended time al lowed t o t he assesse e, as per show-cause no tice i ssued under clause (b) of secti on 148A or the perio d duri ng which the proc eedi ng under s ection 148A is stayed by an order or injuncti on of any court , shall be excl ude d:

Pro vided also t hat where immediately after the excl usi on of the period referr ed to i n t he immediately prec eding proviso, the period of limitati on available to t he Assessi ng Offic er for passi ng an or der under clause (d) of section 148A 30[does not ex cee d s even days], suc h remai ni ng peri od shall be exte nded t o s eve n days and the peri od of limitati on under this sub-secti o n shall be dee med to be extended accordi ngly .

Explanati on.—For t he purposes of cla use (b) of t his sub-section, "asset" shall include immo vabl e property, bei ng land or buil ding or both, s hares and securities , loans and adv ances, deposits in bank account.

(1A) & (2) *****

7.

The time limi ts for issue of no ti ce under s ection 148 of the Act were amended as above w.e.f. 01.04.2021. P rior to the ame ndment t he relevant provi sions of s ection 149(1) of the Act read as under –

149 - T ime limit for no tice.

(1 ) No notice under section 148 shall be issued f or the rel evant assessment year,—

(a)

if f our y ears have elapsed from the end of the rel evant assessment ye ar, unl ess the case falls under claus e (b) or cla use (c);

(b)

if four ye ars, but not more t han six years , have elapsed from t he end of the relevant ass essment year unl ess the i ncome chargeable to ta x which has esca ped assessment amo unts to or is li kely to amount to one lakh rupees or more for that year ;

(c ) ****

Explanati on.—In deter mi ni ng i nc ome c hargeable to t ax whic h has escaped assessment for the purposes of this sub-secti on, t he provisions of Ex planatio n 2 o f s ection 147 shall apply as t hey apply for the purposes of that section.

(2 ) & (3) ****

8.

The ti me limit for issue of notic e under section 148 of the Act was revis ed wi th e ffec t fr om 01.04.2021 and t he legislature i n order to ma ke the ame ndment pr ospective intr oduced the firs t p roviso to section 149(1). The i nte nt of the first provis o is t hat the revenue does not get t he extended time of ten years where the notices w ere not issued wi thi n a period of six years for AYs prior t o 2021-22. The said le gisl ative int ent has been cl early explained by the Hon'ble S uprem e C ourt i n t he cas e of UOI vs R ajiv Bansal [2024] 167 ta xmann.com 70 (SC ). The rel eva nt of observati ons of the Apex Court is extrac ted bel ow–

46.

The i ngredi ents of the pro viso could be broken down for analysis as follows: (i) no notic e under secti on 148 of the new regime can b e issued at a ny time for an assessment year begi nni ng o n or before 1 Apri l 2021; (ii) if i t is barred at the time when the notice is sought to be issued b eca use of the "ti me limits specified under t he provisions of" 149(1 )(b) of the old r egime. Thus , a notice could be issued under sec tion 148 of t he new re gi me for assessment y ear 2021-2022 and before only if the ti me limit for i ssuanc e o f s uch notice continued to exis t under section 149(1)(b) of the old regi me.

47.

****

48.

Notices have to be judged accordi ng to t he l aw existing on the date the notice is is sued. S ecti on 149 of the old regi me primaril y pro vided two time limits: (i) four years for all situations and (i i) b eyond four years and withi n six years i f the i ncome c hargeabl e t o tax whic h escape d assessment amounted to R upees one la kh or more. Aft er 1 April 2021, the time limits presc ri bed under the new re gime came i nto force . The ordi na ry ti me limit of four years was reduced to three ye ars. Therefore, in all situations, reass ess ment notices could be iss ued under the new regime if not more t han thre e yea rs ha ve elapsed fro m the end o f t he r elevant assessment year . For exampl e, for assessment year 2018-2019, the four ye ar peri od woul d have e xpi red o n 31 March 2023 under the old regim e. Howe ver, if the notice is iss ued after 1 April 2021, the three year time limit prescribed und er t he new r egime will be applicable. T he three year tim e limit will expire on 31 Mar ch 2022.

49.

The first proviso to S ecti on 149(1)(b) requi res the det ermi nati on of whether the time limit pre scribed under section 149(1)(b) of the old regime conti nues t o exist for the ass essment year 2021-2022 and before. R esult antly, a notice under Section 148 of the ne w r egime cannot be issued if the period o f si x years from the end of t he rel evant assessment year has expired at the time of issua nce of t he notice. This als o ens ur es tha t the new ti me limit of t en years prescr ibed under s ection 149(1)(b) of the new r egime applies prospectively. For example, for the assessment year 2012-2013, t he ten ye ar peri od woul d have expi red on 31 March 2023, while the six y ear peri od expir ed on 31 Marc h 2019. Without the pr ovis o to Section 149(1 )(b) of the new re gi me, t he Revenue could have had the power to r eopen assessments for the year 2012-2013 if the escaped assessment amount ed t o Rupees fifty lakhs or m ore. The proviso limits t he retrospective operation of S ection 149(1)(b) to prote ct t he i nteres ts o f the assesses.

50.

to 52. ***

53.

The position of la w whic h can be derived based on the above discus sion may be summari zed thus : (i) Secti on 149(1) of the new regime i s not pr ospective. It also applies to past assessment yea rs; (ii) The ti me limit of four years is now reduced t o thr ee years for all situati ons. T he R evenue can issue notices under s ection 148 of the new r egi me onl y i f thr ee years o r less have elapsed fro m the end of the rel evant assessment year; (iii ) the pr oviso t o Sectio n 149(1)(b) o f the new re gime stipul at es that the Rev enue can iss ue reass essment notices for past assess ment ye ars only if the time limit survives acc ordi ng to Sectio n 149(1)(b) of t he old regim e, that is, six years from the end of the rel eva nt assessment year; and (i v) all no ti ces issued i nvoki ng the ti me limit unde r section 149(1 )(b) of t he old re gime will hav e t o be dropped if the i ncome chargeable to tax which has escaped assessment is less than Rupees fift y la khs.

9.

Fr om the perus al of t he legislati ve i nte nt of the fi rst proviso t o s ecti on 149(1) as laid down by the H on'ble Supreme Co urt it is cl ear that R eve nue cannot issue notice under s ecti on 148 for assessment years pri or to AY 2021-22 if six years from the end of the rel evant assessment year has expir ed on t he date of issue of such notice. In the li ght of the above le gal position we will now exami ne t he facts i n assessee's case. The year under consideratio n here is AY 2015-16 and ther efore the time limit as per the fi rst provi so is appl icable. Therefore the ti me limit as per the old regime, f or issue of notice for AY 2015-16 under section 148 of the Act si x years from the end o f the rel evant assessment year i.e . 31.03.2022. Accordi ngly the notice dated 18 .04.2022 issued in assessee's case beyo nd t he time limit and not valid.

10.

The argume nt o f the ld DR is that t he time allowed to the assessee t o respond to the notice issued under section 148A(b) i.e. from 24.03.2022 to 08.03.2022 shoul d be ex cluded as per the fif th pr oviso to s ection 149(1). We are of the consider ed view, for the purpose applyi ng the excl usi on period, the notic e shoul d fi rst survive the test o f being issued eit her under s ection 149(1)(a) or 149(1 )(b) under the new regime . In the given cas e t he notice under secti on 148 of the Act for A Y 2015-16 does no t survive the test by virt ue of the fi rst proviso and there for e t he question of applying the fifth proviso for calculating the ti me li mit does not arise.

11.

In vi ew of these discussions and consideri ng t he provisions of the Act r.w. t he ratio laid down by t he Ho n'bl e S upreme Court we hold that the notice iss ued under sectio n 148 of t he Act dated 18.04.2022 is bar red by limitation. Acc ordi ngly the reassess ment proc eedi ngs bas ed on the i nvalid notic e does no t survive and the additi ons made t herei n are liable to be del et ed.”

4.

We adopt the above extracted de tailed reasoning mutatis mutandis to reject the Revenue’s veheme nt contentions supporting the impugned reopening in very terms. The assessee succeeds in his first and foremost legal ground therefore.

5.

All o ther remaining issue between the parties stand rendered acade mic.

6.

This assessee’s appeal is allowed.