AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
GURVINDER PAL SINGH, J. (ORAL)
This writ petition is filed on behalf of the Petitioner under Article 226 of Constitution of India seeking writ of mandamus directing the Respondents to grant disability pension to him along with interest @ 9% p.a.
Case of the Petitioner is that he was appointed in BSF as Constable (GD) in 2004 after being declared completely medically fit in all respects upon detailed medical examination. No pre-existing disease or illness was recorded at the time of his enrolment in service. Medical Board held on 26.03.2024 diagnosed that Petitioner was suffering from “Bipolar Affective Disorder” and percentage was assessed as 35%. Resultantly, Petitioner was placed in medical category S5H1A1P1E1 and the proceedings were approved by IG/Director Medical, FHQ, BSF on 14.04.2024. Notice was issued on 19.04.2024 to the Petitioner tentatively proposing to invalidate him from service under Rule 25 of Border Security Force Rules, 1969 (BSF Rules, 1969) and he was called upon to make a representation within 15 days as to why he should not be invalidated. Petitioner submitted his response on 19.04.2024 to the show cause notice and sought Review Medical Board. Petitioner was brought before a Review Medical Board on 01.05.2024 at Jalandhar (Punjab), which declared him unfit for service with 35% permanent disability “Bipolar Affective Disorder” with medical category S5H1A1P1E1 and recommended his invalidation from service. Following this recommendation, Petitioner was invalidated w.e.f. 15.05.2024 with admissible pensionary benefits.
Learned counsel for the Petitioner submits that Petitioner was physically and mentally sound when he was enrolled in BSF in 2004 and there was no note of any pre-existing illness or disease and therefore, following the judgment of the Supreme Court in Dharamvir Singh v. Union of India, 2013 SCC OnLine SC 538, the disability “Bipolar Affective Disorder” shall be presumed to have arisen in BSF service sans any evidence to the contrary. It is urged that nature of duties performed by the Petitioner involved continuous operational stress, high risk deployment and prolonged exposure to adverse service conditions, which establishes a clear and proximate nexus between the disability and conditions of service, which therefore, materially contributed to and aggravated Petitioner’s illness.
It is argued that Rule 4 of Central Civil Services (Extraordinary Pension) Rules, 1939 (EOP Rules), provides that disability pension shall be granted if there is casual connection between disablement of Government servant and Government service and disablement shall be reckoned as due to Government service if it is certified that the same is due to disease which is attributable to Government service or existed before or arose during the Government service and has aggravated thereby. Rule 9(1)(B) of EOP Rules provides that disability arising from disease contracted because of continued exposure to hostile work environment or on being subjected to occupational hazards or extreme weather conditions shall entitle the individual concern to disability pension. In the instant case, while the Medical Board recorded that disability was not attributable to service, it was recorded that it stood aggravated due to stress and strain in service and therefore, the requirement of Rule 9(1)(B) is satisfied entitling the Petitioner to disability pension.
In this backdrop, it is also contended that case of the Petitioner is squarely covered by the judgment of this Court in Roshan Lal v. Union of India and Others, 2024 SCC OnLine Del 3679, wherein it was held that opinion of the Medical Board must be supported by reasons as also that where no pre-existing disease is recorded at the time of enrolment, presumption arises that an individual was in sound health on entry into service and any subsequent deterioration is attributable to or aggravated by service, unless rebutted by cogent evidence.
Learned counsel for Respondents fairly and candidly does not dispute that there was no record of pre-existing disease or illness, when Petitioner was enrolled in BSF in 2004 and the disability occurred during the service as also that there is no material indicating that any extraneous factor led to the disability.
Heard learned counsels for the parties and examined their submissions.
Indisputably, when Petitioner was enrolled in BSF in 2004, he was not suffering from any disease or disability and was completely medically fit. The disability “Bipolar Affective Disorder” was incurred by the Petitioner during his service and to this extent, there is no dispute by the Respondents. It is now settled that member of a Force is presumed to be in sound physical and mental condition upon entering service, if there is no note or record at the time of his entrance to the contrary and in the event of his subsequently being discharged from service on medical grounds, any deterioration in health will be presumed to have occurred due to service as also that the onus of proof is not on the claimant but on the employer to show that disability is neither attributable nor aggravated by service conditions. In this context, we may first allude to a passage from the judgment in Dharamvir Singh (supra), as follows:-
“29.A conjoint reading of various provisions, reproduced above, makes it clear that:
29.1.Disability pension to be granted to an individual who is invalided from service on account of a disability which is attributable to or aggravated by military service in non-battle casualty and is assessed at 20% or over. The question whether a disability is attributable to or aggravated by military service to be determined under the Entitlement Rules for Casualty Pensionary Awards, 1982 of Appendix II (Regulation 173).
29.2.A member is to be presumed in sound physical and mental condition upon entering service if there is no note or record at the time of entrance. In the event of his subsequently being discharged from service on medical grounds any deterioration in his health is to be presumed due to service [Rule 5 read with Rule 14(b)].
29.3.The onus of proof is not on the claimant (employee), the corollary is that onus of proof that the condition for non-entitlement is with the employer. A claimant has a right to derive benefit of any reasonable doubt and is entitled for pensionary benefit more liberally (Rule 9).
29.4.If a disease is accepted to have been as having arisen in service, it must also be established that the conditions of military service determined or contributed to the onset of the disease and that the conditions were due to the circumstances of duty in military service [Rule 14(c)].
29.5.If no note of any disability or disease was made at the time of individual's acceptance for military service, a disease which has led to an individual's discharge or death will be deemed to have arisen in service [Rule 14(b)].
29.6.If medical opinion holds that the disease could not have been detected on medical examination prior to the acceptance for service and that disease will not be deemed to have arisen during service, the Medical Board is required to state the reasons [Rule 14(b)]; and
29.7.It is mandatory for the Medical Board to follow the guidelines laid down in Chapter II of the Guide to Medical Officers (Military Pensions), 2002 — “Entitlement: General Principles”, including Paras 7, 8 and 9 as referred to above (para 27).”
In Union of India and Another v. Rajbir Singh, (2015) 12 SCC 264, the Supreme Court reiterated the legal position and held that essence of Pension Regulations, Entitlement Rules and Guidelines to Medical Officers is that member of the Armed Force is presumed to be in sound physical and mental condition at the time of his entering into service if there is no note or record to the contrary at the time of such entry and in the event of his subsequent discharge on medical ground, any deterioration in health is to be presumed to be due to military service. This necessarily implies that no sooner a member of the Force is discharged on medical ground his entitlement to claim disability pension will arise unless the employer is in a position to rebut the presumption that the disability was neither attributable to nor aggravated by the military service and that this position is reinforced by Rule 14(b) of Entitlement Rules 1982. Relevant passages from the judgment are as follows:-
“14.The legal position as stated in Dharamvir Singh case is, in our opinion, in tune with the Pension Regulations, the Entitlement Rules and the Guidelines issued to the Medical Officers. The essence of the rules, as seen earlier, is that a member of the armed forces is presumed to be in sound physical and mental condition at the time of his entry into service if there is no note or record to the contrary made at the time of such entry. More importantly, in the event of his subsequent discharge from service on medical ground, any deterioration in his health is presumed to be due to military service. This necessarily implies that no sooner a member of the force is discharged on medical ground his entitlement to claim disability pension will arise unless of course the employer is in a position to rebut the presumption that the disability which he suffered was neither attributable to nor aggravated by military service.
15.From Rule 14(b) of the Entitlement Rules it is further clear that if the medical opinion were to hold that the disease suffered by the member of the armed forces could not have been detected prior to acceptance for service, the Medical Board must state the reasons for saying so. Last but not the least is the fact that the provision for payment of disability pension is a beneficial provision which ought to be interpreted liberally so as to benefit those who have been sent home with a disability at times even before they completed their tenure in the armed forces. There may indeed be cases, where the disease was wholly unrelated to military service, but, in order that denial of disability pension can be justified on that ground, it must be affirmatively proved that the disease had nothing to do with such service. The burden to establish such a disconnect would lie heavily upon the employer for otherwise the rules raise a presumption that the deterioration in the health of the member of the service is on account of military service or aggravated by it. A soldier cannot be asked to prove that the disease was contracted by him on account of military service or was aggravated by the same. The very fact that he was upon proper physical and other tests found fit to serve in the army should rise as indeed the rules do provide for a presumption that he was disease-free at the time of his entry into service. That presumption continues till it is proved by the employer that the disease was neither attributable to nor aggravated by military service. For the employer to say so, the least that is required is a statement of reasons supporting that view. That we feel is the true essence of the rules which ought to be kept in view all the time while dealing with cases of disability pension.
16.Applying the above parameters to the cases at hand, we are of the view that each one of the respondents having been discharged from service on account of medical disease/disability, the disability must be presumed to have been arisen in the course of service which must, in the absence of any reason recorded by the Medical Board, be presumed to have been attributable to or aggravated by military service. There is admittedly neither any note in the service records of the respondents at the time of their entry into service nor have any reasons been recorded by the Medical Board to suggest that the disease which the member concerned was found to be suffering from could not have been detected at the time of his entry into service. The initial presumption that the respondents were all physically fit and free from any disease and in sound physical and mental condition at the time of their entry into service thus remains unrebutted. Since the disability has in each case been assessed at more than 20%, their claim to disability pension could not have been repudiated by the appellants.”
We may also note that recently in Union of India & Others v. Col. NC Isaac (Retd), 2026 SCC OnLine SC 1895, the Supreme Court inter alia dealt with the issue whether Entitlement Rules, 2008 make a significant departure from Entitlement Rules 1982 and comparing the relevant rules held that mere addition of a casual requirement and removal of the presumption by amending Rule 5 of Entitlement Rules, 1982 and incorporating words ‘the mere fact that a disease has manifested during military service does not per se establish attributability to or aggravation by military service’, does not by itself, change the core scheme of Entitlement Rules, 2008 because other beneficial provisions broadly remain untouched. The Supreme Court observed that the onus to prove that member’s disability is not attributable to service, still lies on the employer and the relevant rules regarding attributability and aggravation continue to hold that if cause of disability is unknown and presumption of attributability is not rebutted, then the disability is attributable to service and Rule 7 of Entitlement Rules, 2008 read with Regulation 423 of Regulations for the Medical Services of the Armed Forces, 2010 continue to generate a reasonable benefit of doubt in favour of the service member. Albeit this judgement deals with Entitlement Rules, the ratio of the judgement is that in the absence of any note in the record of the Petitioner at the time of the entry that any of the disabilities owing to which he is discharged pre-existed and sans the Respondents placing on record any cogent material, which reflects that disabilities were attributable to any other cause, it must be held that the disabilities are attributable to military service.
Learned counsel for the Petitioner is also right in his submission that the disability was contracted during the course of his service and in circumstances over which Petitioner had no control and therefore his case is also covered by the judgement in Shatrughana Pingua v. Union of India and Others, 2025 SCC OnLine Del 9975, where the Division Bench held that so long as the disability is contracted in service and is owing to circumstances beyond the control of the individual, disability pension cannot be denied in light of the judgment in Dharamvir Singh (supra).
For all the aforesaid reasons, this writ petition is allowed and Respondents are directed to grant disability pension to the Petitioner for his disability “Bipolar Affective Disorder” assessed @ 35%. The arrears shall be paid within 12 weeks from today, failing which Respondents shall be liable to pay interest @ 6% p.a., till actual payment.
Writ petition stands disposed of along with the pending application.
