AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
Heard learned counsel for both side.
The admitted fact is that, that interconnect agreement, said to be entered with India Cast, expired on 31.03.2013 itself, and the disconnection notice, which was challenged in this petition, was of a date subsequent to it, when there was no existence of any interconnect agreement. Then how a right for enforcing the liability arises in situation of settled proposition of law that without being any interconnect agreement in existence, rights and liabilities are not being enforced by either side? How this petition was maintainable against disconnection notice, which was on a date subsequent to end of interconnect agreement. Learned counsel for petitioner admitted this proposition of law and said that the contest is for counter claim too, for which this proposition of law will apply and is to be applied for petitioner.
Learned counsel for respondent argued that the counter claim relates with the period when interconnect agreement was in operation, i.e. from November 2012 to March 2013. The assignment made by India Cast to present respondent / petitioner for counter claim, was effective since November 2012, as was written in the notice of disconnection. Though this was of June/July 2013 and sent by speed post of 6.8.2013, with a presumption of 3-4 days delivery to addressee, to be held evident since 10.8.2013. But date of operation of this assignment was from 1st November 2012 to 31st March 2013 and for these four months, the counter claim is to be calculated and specified by respondent / petitioner, for which some time is being requested.
Hence, even if counter claim for four months is to be awarded, though not being accepted or observed, the same is to be calculated and specified by the respondent and there may be an exercise by petitioner too, with regard to reconciliation and settlement for these four months, allegedly claimed.
Hence, let this exercise be got completed by learned counsel for both sides.
List 'for hearing' on 30.11.2023 for further disposal.
