Tribunals and CommissionsDivision Bench(2026) 11 ITAT CK 2940

Deepika vs ACIT, Circle 33 (1)

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, New Delhi · Decided on 18 November 2026

RESULT
Partly Allowed
CASE NUMBER
ITA No.7843/DEL/2026

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

84 paragraphs · 4,707 words

PER S. RIFAUR RAHMAN, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER :

1.

This appeal is filed by the assessee against the order of ld. Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals)/National Faceless Appeal Centre (NFAC), Delhi[“Ld. CIT(A)”, for short] dated 21.07.2026.

2.

Brief facts of the case are, assessee filed her return of income for the Assessment Year 2014-15 on 22.07.2014 declaring income of Rs.95,65,090/-. The case was selected under limited scrutiny with the reason of large short term capital gains declared under section 111A of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (for short ‘the Act’), large value commodity exchange transactions and return filed in ITR 1/2/3/4S and large value of sales of futures (derivative) in a recognized stock exchange. Accordingly notices under section 143(2) and 142(1) of the Act were issued and served on the assessee. In response, ld. AR of the assessee attended proceedings from time to time and submitted the necessary details and documents which were examined on check test basis. During assessment proceedings, the AO observed that assessee has declared income from capital gains and other sources. It was noticed that assessee has shown short term capital gains from trading in shares. When ld. AR of the assessee was asked to submit details of transactions, in response he filed sauda summary of NSE futures. From the perusal of the same, it is found that assessee has traded in Futures & Options (F&O). Vide note sheet entry, ld. AR of the assessee was show caused as to why this gain should not be treated as business income as the assessee is solely involved in this activity and trading on day-to-day basis. In response, assessee vide letter dated 28.11.2016 submitted that she was trading in stock market with the motive of investment and has not been traded on behalf of any other person. After considering the submissions of the assessee, the same was rejected. The Assessing Officer after considering the information submitted by the assessee and the magnitude and frequency of the transactions carried on by the assessee which was very well gauged, Assessing Officer was of the view that these have been done merely in the nature of regular trading. In view of the above observations, the AO has brought the income declared by the assessee at Rs.1,68,32,214/- as normal business income and rejected the short-term capital gains declared by the assessee. Accordingly, he proceeded to add the abovesaid business income as income of the assessee for the year under consideration and not allowed to set off of carried forward loss under the head Capital Gains.

3.

Aggrieved with the above order, assessee preferred an appeal before the NFAC, Delhi. Before the ld. CIT(A), assessee had submitted the status of the investment activities carried on by the assessee from Assessment Years 2013-14 to 2015-16. It was submitted that assessee has consistently classifying the income/loss earned by the assessee in the share trading activities under the head capital gains/loss. It was submitted that in Assessment Year 2013-14, assessee has incurred trading loss and declared the same as short-term capital loss of Rs.72,74,483/- under the head ‘capital gains’ and the same was accepted by the Department. However, for the AY2014-15, assessee has earned short-term capital gain of Rs.1,68,39,570/-from exact similar investment activities. However, AO reclassified this income as income from business and profession and also not allowed to claim the carry forward loss from the earlier assessment year and completely overlooking consistent investment activities carried by the assessee from 2013-14 onwards. It was also submitted that in the assessment year 2014-15, the applicable tax of Rs.15,51,045/-was duly paid as per the method of recording the transaction as short-term capital gains. It was prayed that assessee has followed method of declared income as per the CBDT Circular No.6/2016. After considering the submissions of the assessee, ld. CIT(A) rejected the submissions of the assessee and proceeded to sustain the additions made by the AO by observing as under :-

“7.3

I have carefully considered the assessment order, the ground of appeal and the written submissions filed by the appellant.

7.4

The only issue involved in the present appeal is whether the income earned by the appellant from the transactions in shares and derivatives is liable to be assessed under the head "Short Term Capital Gains" or under the head "Profits and Gains of Business or Profession".

"Section 43(5) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 defines "a "speculative transaction" as a transaction in which a contract for the purchase or sale of any commodity, including stocks and shares, is settled otherwise than by actual delivery. However, clause (d) of the proviso to section 43(5) specifically provides that an eligible transaction in trading in derivatives carried out on a recognised stock exchange shall not be deemed to be a speculative transaction."

7.5

The above provision makes it clear that trading in derivatives, including Futures & Options carried out on a recognised stock exchange, is treated as a non-speculative business transaction under the Income-tax Act.

7.6

In the present case, the Assessing Officer has recorded that, on examination of the details furnished during the assessment proceedings, the appellant had carried out transactions in Futures & Options. The Assessing Officer also observed that the magnitude and frequency of the transactions indicated regular trading activity and, therefore, treated the income as business income instead of Short Term Capital Gains.

7.7

The appellant has submitted that the money was invested with the intention of making investments and that similar income was accepted under the head "Capital Gains" in the preceding assessment year. However, except for these general submissions, no material has been produced to establish that the transactions during the year were actually in the nature of investments. The appellant has not furnished any details regarding the holding period of the shares, demat account, pattern of transactions or any other evidence to show that the shares were held as investment and not for trading.

7.8

The appellant has also 'argued that similar treatment was accepted in the earlier assessment year. This contention, by itself, cannot be accepted. The nature of income has to be examined on the basis of the facts of each assessment year. Unless it is shown that the facts and pattern of transactions remained identical, the treatment given in an earlier year cannot be applied automatically.

7.9

The burden to establish that the income was assessable as Short Term Capital Gains was on the appellant. In the present case, that burden has not been discharged by producing sufficient documentary evidence. On the other hand, the findings recorded by the Assessing Officer regarding the nature, magnitude and frequency of the transactions have remained unrebutted.

7.10

Considering the facts of the case and the material available on record, I find no reason to interfere with the conclusion reached by the Assessing Officer. The income has, therefore, been rightly assessed under the head "Profits and Gains of Business or Profession" instead of "Short Term Capital Gains". Accordingly, the action of the Assessing Officer is upheld and Ground No.1 of the appeal is dismissed.”

4.

Aggrieved with the above order, assessee is in appeal before us raising following grounds of appeal :-

“1.

On Erroneous Reclassification: The authorities below erred in law and on facts in treating capital transactions as business income without appreciating the nature of holdings.

2.

On Impossibility of Performance (Broker Default): The lower authorities failed to consider that furnishing historic broker-level documentation is rendered impossible due to the total shutdown and default of the broker, *Arcadia Share & Stock Brokers Private Limited*, leaving the Appellant reliant on available bank statements and tax filings.

3.

On Failure to Consider Subsequent Catastrophic Losses: The lower authorities failed to appreciate that the taxable surplus of AY 2014-15 was entirely wiped out by a subsequent severe loss of Rs.33,823,007/- in AY 2015-16 rendering the enforcement of an artificial tax demand unjust and oppressive.

4.

On Absolute Financial Incapacity and Insolvency: The demand of Rs.31,00,000/- is impossible to satisfy due to zero liquidity, negative/nominal bank balances, an income of only Rs.6-7 Lakhs, and over Rs. 2 Crores in unpaid debts.

Prayer:

In light of the facts and total financial destitution, the Appellant prays that this Hon'ble Tribunal may be pleased to:

* Set aside the appellate order passed by the NFAC and the underlying assessment order;

* Accept the attached bank statements as primary financial evidence in lieu of missing broker records given the default and closure of Arcadia Share & Stock Brokers Private Limited;

* Grant an absolute and unconditional stay of demand under Section 220(6) / ITAT rules due to total lack of assets, zero bank balance, and extreme financial hardship; and

* Pass any such further order(s) as this Hon'ble Tribunal may deem fit in the interest of justice.”

5.

At the time of hearing, ld. AR submitted as under :-

“1.1

The Appellant is an individual and a regular income-tax assessee. For AY 2014-15 (previous year 2013-14) she filed her return on 22.07.2014 (Ack. No. 244511870220714) declaring total income of Rs.93,65,090 (gross total income Rs. 95,65,089), after accounting for short term capital gains, and paid self-assessment tax of Rs.15,51,046.

1.2

The case was selected for limited scrutiny on the following reasons: large short term capital gains declared under section 111A, large value commodity exchange transactions and return filed in ITR 1/2/3/4S, and large value sale of futures (derivatives) on a recognised stock exchange.

1.3

During assessment, the Assessing Officer (AO) called for details of the transactions. The Authorised Representative filed the sauda summary of NSE transactions. Vide note-sheet entry dated 22.11.2016 the AO show-caused the Appellant as to why the gain should not be treated as business income. The Appellant replied on 28.11.2016 that she trades in the stock market with the motive of investment and has not traded on behalf of any other person.

1.4

By order dated 08.12.2016 under section 143(3), the AO rejected the reply as "not tenable" solely on the basis of the "magnitude and frequency" of the transactions, treated the derivative transactions (gross receipts of Rs.5,71,29,18,537.18 against cost of acquisition of Rs.5,69,60,86,323.36, a net gain of Rs.1,68,32,214) as business income instead of short term capital gains, and assessed total income at Rs.1,68,39,570. Penalty proceedings under section 271(1)(c) were initiated separately.

1.5

The Appellant filed Form 35 before the CIT(A) on 06.01.2017 (Ack. No.584572151060117), disputing the reclassification. The NFAC dismissed the appeal by order dated 21.07.2026 and upheld the reclassification. [Insert in two or three lines the reasoning of the NFAC order.]

1.6

Aggrieved, the Appellant filed the present appeal on 06.08.2026, within the period of limitation (the order was served on 21.07.2026), so no condonation of delay is required. The tax effect is Rs.56,74,890.

1.7

Subsequent loss (AY 2015-16). In the immediately following year (FY 2014-15, AY 2015-16) the Appellant suffered a current-year loss of Rs.3,38,23,007 (gross total income of Rs.3,38,23,007). This eroded her assets, capital and savings, and left her with unpaid liabilities of over Rs. 2 crores owed to friends and family.

1.8

Closure of the broker. The broking firm through which the demat account and transactions were maintained, Arcadia Share & Stock Brokers Private Limited, has permanently closed down on account of broker default. The Appellant is therefore unable to access, download or furnish the historical demat statements, broker ledgers or trade logs.

1.9

Present position. For the past two years the Appellant's earnings have been only Rs.6 to 7 lakhs a year. She has two bank accounts: one carries a negative balance because of non-maintenance charges and the other holds only a few thousand rupees. She has no unencumbered movable or immovable assets.

2. Issues for determination

(a)

Whether the gains of Rs.1,68,32,214 are assessable as short term capital gains under section 111A, as returned, or as business income, as held by the authorities below. (Ground 1). Appellant was having huge losses of Rs.72,74,483/- in AY 2013-14 as well. Computation attached on Page No.16.

(b)

Whether, in view of the default and closure of the Appellant's broker, the bank statements and tax filings on record should be accepted as primary evidence, or the matter remitted for verification. (Ground 2)

(c)

Whether the subsequent loss of Rs. 3,38,23,007 in AY 2015-16 and the Appellant's present financial incapacity warrant relief, in equity and by way of stay of demand. (Grounds 3 and 4)

3. Ground 1: Nature of the income (capital gains vs business income)

3.1

Settled test. Whether shares are held as investment or as stock-in-trade is a question of fact turning on the assessee's intention and the totality of circumstances, not on volume alone. See Parimisetti Seetharamamma v. CIT (1965) 57 ITR 532 (SC) and CIT v. Associated Industrial Development Co. (P) Ltd. (1971) 82 ITR 586 (SC). The CSDT has itself laid down the relevant indicia in Instruction No. 1827 dated 31.08.1989 and Circular No. 4/2007 dated 15.06.2007: the assessee's intention at the time of purchase, the period of holding, the frequency and volume of transactions, the source of funds (own or borrowed), whether the transactions were recorded as investment or stock-in-trade in the books, and whether the assessee carries on any organised trading activity.

3.2

The AO's finding is conclusory. The AO's only reasoning is that the "magnitude and frequency" of transactions "clearly establish" regular trading. The order does not examine the holding period of the scrips, the proportion of delivery-based transactions, the source of funds, the absence of any business set-up, or the Appellant's stated intention. Frequency and volume alone are not decisive, and the one circumstance the AO relied on cannot by itself displace the Appellant's consistent stand.

3.3

Circumstances supporting investment/capital gains treatment. The Appellant submits that the following facts support her case:

 The Appellant is an individual with no other business or profession. Her only other income for the year was Rs. 7,358 from other sources.

 She has no office, employees or organised trading infrastructure, and did not trade on behalf of any other person (a fact the AO did not dispute).

 The transactions were in her own name through a registered broker, were settled through a recognised stock exchange, and the securities transaction tax was paid.

 She declared the gains as short term capital gains in the return, and no books of account were maintained treating the securities as stock-in-trade.

3.4

Two portfolios are permissible. An assessee may hold securities in an investment portfolio and, separately, in a trading portfolio, and each is taxed according to its own character:

CIT v. Gopal Purohit, 228 CTR 582 (Bom). The AO treated the entire gain as business income without examining whether any part was investment in nature.

3.5

Quantum is not in dispute. The AO accepted the figure of Rs. 1,68,32,214 on the basis of the details furnished by the Appellant and the AIR information, which he recorded as "filed and verified". The only dispute is the head of income. The Appellant's inability to produce further broker-level records (see Ground 2) therefore does not affect the computation of the gain.

3.6

The Appellant accordingly prays that the income be assessed under the head "Capital gains" as returned.

4. Ground 2: Impossibility of producing broker records; additional evidence

4.1

The Appellant's broker, Arcadia Share & Stock Brokers Private Limited, has permanently closed down on account of broker default, and the Appellant is unable to access, download or furnish the historical demat statements, broker ledgers or trade logs from that end. Contract notes, ledgers and similar broker-level records for a period nearly a decade old are therefore beyond the Appellant's reach through no fault of her own. The law does not demand the performance of the impossible (lex non cogit ad impossibilia).

4.2

In these circumstances the Appellant has placed on record her bank statements and tax filings, which show the funding of the transactions and the settlement of trades and corroborate the figures accepted by the AO. The Appellant seeks admission of these documents under Rule 29 of the Income Tax (Appellate Tribunal) Rules, 1963, on the ground that the Tribunal requires them to decide the appeal justly and that their non-production earlier was due to circumstances beyond her control.

4.3

In the alternative, the Appellant requests that the matter be restored to the file of the AO/CIT(A) to examine the bank statements and the other material, after giving the Appellant a reasonable opportunity of being heard.

5.

Grounds 3 and 4: Subsequent loss and financial incapacity

5.1

The Appellant is conscious that a loss of a later year cannot be carried back and set off against income of an earlier year. Ground 3 is not pressed as an independent ground for deleting the addition. It is placed before the Tribunal because it bears on the following points:

(a)

Consistency. The same activity in the next year resulted in a current-year loss of Rs.3,38,23,007 in AY 2015-16 (gross total income of Rs. -3,38,23,007), which wiped out the surplus of AY 2014-15 together with the Appellant's capital and savings. The Revenue cannot treat the same activity as profit-making business in one year and ignore its nature in the next.

(b)

Equity and the character of the demand. Considering the Appellant's overall result across the two years, enforcement of a tax demand of Rs. 56,74,890 (tax effect) on a reclassified surplus is harsh and oppressive.

5.2

Financial incapacity. The Appellant has zero liquidity. Of her two bank accounts, one carries a negative balance because of non-maintenance charges and the other holds only a few thousand rupees. She has no unencumbered movable or immovable assets, her earnings for the past two years are only Rs. 6-7 lakhs a year, and she owes over Rs. 2 crores to friends and family. The Appellant states that the demand outstanding is approximately Rs.31,00,000.

5.3

In view of this, the Appellant requests that the recovery of the demand be stayed under section 254(2A) of the Act (read with the Tribunal's powers under the 1963 Rules) until the appeal is decided. The Appellant is prepared to co-operate with any reasonable condition the Bench may impose.

6.

Prayer

In view of the above, it is respectfully prayed that the Hon'ble Tribunal may be pleased to:

(a)

hold that the gains of Rs. 1,68,32,214 are assessable as short term capital gains under section 111 A and delete the addition made by treating them as business income;

(b)

admit the bank statements and other documents as additional evidence under Rule 29 and accept them in lieu of the unavailable broker records; or, in the alternative, restore the matter to the AO/CIT(A) for fresh adjudication after giving the Appellant a proper opportunity of being heard;

(c)

in the alternative, direct that the delivery-based equity gains be assessed as short term capital gains and that the business income, if any, be computed after allowing all deductions and set-offs;

(d)

stay the recovery of the demand arising from the impugned order till the disposal of the appeal; and

(e)

pass such other order as the Tribunal may deem fit in the interest of justice.”

6.

On the other hand, ld. DR of the Revenue submitted that assessee is entered into share transaction on the basis of F&O. He brought to our notice detailed findings of the ld. CIT(A) at paras 7.1 to 7.10,. He relied on the detailed findings of the lower authorities.

7.

Considered the rival submissions and material placed on record. We observed that assessee is an individual entered in share transactions aggressively from Assessment Year 2013-14 onwards and assessee has transacted in future and options (F&O)in NSE platform. In Assessment Year 2013-14, assessee has incurred loss of Rs.72,74,483/- and assessee has duly filed the return of income and claimed the above loss under the head capital Gain. In the assessment year under consideration, assessee has entered into similar transactions and earned profit in the share transactions of Rs.1,68,39,570/-. Since assessee was declaring income from capital gains, assessee has adjusted the carry forward loss and paid the due tax for the year under consideration. During assessment proceedings, we noticed that AO has called for sauda summary of NSE futures and based on the above summary and volume of transactions, he came to the conclusion that the assessee has carried on the nature of transaction regularly and it shall be taxed under the head business income. Accordingly, he proceeded to treat the income earned by the assessee under the head income from business. He completely overlooked the fact that the assessee has earned the income from the exact similar activities carried in the previous assessment year. Since there was no scrutiny assessment in the earlier assessment year, the claim of the assessee was undisturbed. AO has taken a divergent view in this year and proceeded to compute the tax, treating the gains earned by the assessee as business income only. In that process, he has overlooked the fact that F&O transactions are not delivery based, the volume has no relevance to determine whether the transactions are carried for investment or trading. The AO has proceeded to treat the transaction as business income on the basis of volume/magnitude and frequency. Further he overlooked the fact that assessee has continued with the same transaction in the subsequent assessment year and incurred huge losses. In appeal before ld. CIT (A), we observed that ld. CIT(A) has by referring to section 43(5) of the Act observed that it is not a speculative transaction, accordingly he rightly treated the transactions in F&O as business income and sustained the additions made by the Assessing Officer.

8.

The Revenue, however, appears to have attempted to pick and choose its treatment of the Assessee’s transactions, depending on whether they have resulted in the allowance of a loss in the preceding and subsequent years, and the tax that can be assessed from the income in the year under consideration. In AY 2013-14 and AY 2015-16 losses suffered by the Assessee from F&O activity have been duly declared as capital loss, while in the present year, where the Assessee has earned a profit, income from the same activity has been reckoned as business income. This approach is untenable. The Assessee’s F&O activity is either in the nature of a business or an investment activity, it cannot be one in the first year, another in the second, and back to one again in the third year, merely on the basis of how much tax the activity can be made to yield. As the AO had treated the transactions such a way that loss is to be carried forward as capital loss and gain is to be taxed under business income. This dual nature of treating the transaction is just not proper, it is noticed from the treatment given by the AO to carry forward loss of the previous year.

9.

This is not merely with regard to res judicata or consistency, though the latter principle would apply in full force, especially when the Act itself provides for offset of losses when the Revenue’s approach is consistent. It is simply common sense also, since as stated above, the same activity cannot be an investment in one year and a business activity in the next, and an investment again in the third year.

10.

After careful consideration of the facts available on record, we observed that the controversy under consideration is, whether the share transactions are business income or capital gain. There were decisions on both sides, in order to address the above controversy, we refer to the CBDT Circular No.4/2016 wherein guidelines were issued to the Assessing Officer to check the intention and conduct of the assessee, magnitude and frequency of the transactions and accounting treatment recorded by the taxpayers in their books of account and it was reiterated that no single test is absolute and the factors depend on the total facts and circumstances of each case. However, subsequently CBDT issued another Circular No.6/2016 dated 29.02.2016 wherein in order to minimize needless litigations, CBDT allowed dual portfolio as per which a taxpayer is permitted to maintain two separate portfolios as investment portfolio and trading portfolio. Further, if a taxpayer treats listed shares as stock-in-trade, irrespective of holding period, the resulting surplus/profit shall be taxed as business income only. Further, a safe harbour rule was brought in for long-term holdings, if listed shares or securities are held for more than twelve months and the assessee desires to treat the surplus as capital gains, the AO is directed to accept the same. Further, it was reiterated that once the taxpayer adopts a particular method for a particular assessment year, it generally binds the assessee for subsequent assessment years. In the given case, as discussed above, F&O is not delivery based, the above CBDT instruction has to be interpreted on the basis of actual facts on record. Therefore, consistency rule has to be accepted.

11.

Coming to the present financial status of the assessee, it is brought to our notice that assessee has declared loss in Assessment Year 2013-14, profit in Assessment Year 2014-15 and huge loss in AY 2015-16. The net result is huge loss and assessee has eroded the whole capital. In terms of results, the status are as under :-

S.No.Assessment YearLoss/ProfitAmount (in Rs.)
12013-14Loss72,74,483/-
22014-15Profit1,68,32,214/-
32015-16Loss3,38,83,193/-
NetLoss243,25,462/-
12.

Considering overall facts and situation of the assessee, assessee has declared the income earned by her under the head capital gains which was not disturbed by the department in the previous assessment year and assessee has continued to declare the same method of accounting in the current assessment year as well as subsequent assessment year. We observed that the assessee had declared the profit/loss under the head ‘capital gains’ whereas the Assessing Officer had treated the income under the head ‘Business’. After careful consideration, we noticed that ld. CIT (A) had rightly came to the conclusion that the transaction made by the assessee under F&O category falls under ‘Business Income’ as per the provisions of section 43(5) of the Act. In our view, the ld. CIT (A) should have directed the Assessing Officer to treat the transaction carried on by the assessee in the previous year also under the head ‘Business Income’ instead of restricting himself to adjudicate for the year under consideration. Since the assessee had carried the same nature of transaction which squarely falls under the head business income, we accordingly direct the Assessing Officer to treat the transactions carried on by the assessee in the previous and also in the subsequent assessment year under the head ‘Business Income’ only and direct him to give credit of carried forward loss of previous year i.e. AY 2013-14 and allow the assessee to carry forward the loss suffered by her in the Assessment Year 2015-16.

13.

We are aware that the assessee had declared the losses suffered under the head capital gains. Merely because the assessee had declared consistently, the mistake cannot be rectified on the basis of consistency of disclosure. At the same time, Assessing Officer also should have considered the nature of transaction and applied the rule of consistency.

14.

We noticed that ld. AR prayed to remand the matter to the Assessing Officer. As per the plea of the assessee, we are not inclined to remit this issue back to the file of Assessing Officer for the reason that the issue pertains to AY 2014-15. There is no point in remittance and all the relevant documents and material are already available on record. Further, the assessee wanted to bring on new details which were not available with the assessee. This inability was expressed by the assessee in the submissions.

15.

After considering the overall facts on record, we direct the Assessing Officer to allow the assessee to take credit of carry forward loss of AY 2013-14 by treating the whole transaction as business income only as under :-Income for the AY 2014-15 Rs.1,68,32,214/-Less : Carried forward loss of AY 2013-14 (Rs.72,74,483/-) Rs.95,57,731/-

16.

Accordingly, we direct him to determine the tax liability on the above net business income and adjust the tax already paid by the assessee u/s 140A of the Act. The loss suffered by the assessee in the AY 2015-16 should also be allowed to carry forward the same as business loss.

17.

In the result, the appeal filed by the assessee is partly allowed