Tribunals and CommissionsDivision Bench(2026) 08 ITAT CK 7071

DCIT vs Uflex Ltd.

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, New Delhi · Decided on 21 August 2026

CASE NUMBER
IT(TP)A No.272/Del/2026 & Others

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

869 paragraphs · 47,762 words

PER MANISH AGARWAL, AM :

These are five appeals filed by the Revenue and the Assessee against the common order of Learned Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals)-3, Noida (“Ld. CIT(A)”) arising out of the assessment orders passed for Assessment Years 2020-21, 2021-22 & 2022-23 respectively.

2.

The captioned Appeals filed by the Assessee and the Revenue are tabulated as under:

S. No.Appeal Nos.Asstt. YearCIT(A)’s Order datedAssessment Order datedAssessment Order passed u/s
1IT(TP)A No.272/Del/2026 [Revenue’s appeal]2020-2119.02.202622.05.2024143(3) r.w.s 144C(3) of the IT Act.
2.IT(TP)A No.259/Del/2026 [Assessee’s appeal]2020-2119.02.202622.05.2024-Do-
3.ITA No.5367/Del/2026 [Revenue’s appeal]2021-2224.03.202620.02.2025-Do-
4.IT(TP)A No.260/Del/2026 [Assessee’s appeal]2021-22-Do--Do--Do-
5.IT(TP)A No.280/Del/2026 [Assessee’s appeal]2022-2321.04.202622.05.2025-Do-
3.

Before us, both the parties have stated that most of the issues involved in all these appeals are common, therefore, they are taken together and decided by a common order.

4.

First we take appeal of the assessee in IT(TP) No. 259/Del/2026 of the assessee and IT(TP)A No. 272/Del/2026 of the Revenue for Assessment Year 2020-21.

IT(TP) No.259/Del/2026 [Assessee’s appeal] &

IT(TP)A No.272/Del/2026 [Revenue’s appeal]

[Assessment Year 2020-21]

5.

Brief facts of the case are that the return of income was filed on 03.02.2021, declaring total income of INR 1,01,55,90,800/- which includes income from business or profession of INR 1,10,78,12,302/-and income from other sources of INR 3,57,99,249/-. The assessee claimed deduction u/s 80G of the Act of INR 8,30,500/- and deduction u/s 80IB of INR 12,71,90,249/-.

6.

The business profile of the assessee as stated by the AO in the assessment order for AY 2020-21 is as under:-

Business Profile:

7.

The Assessee is a flexible packaging solution provider serving varied sectors spanning FMCG, Consumer Product Goods, Pharmaceuticals, Building Materials, and Automobile etc. The company provides packaging for a wide variety of products such as snack foods, candy and confectionery, sugar, rice & other cereals, beverages, tea & coffee, dessert mixes, noodles, wheat flour, soaps and detergents, shampoos & conditioners, vegetable oil, spices, marinates & pastes, cheese & dairy products, frozen food, sea food, meat, anti-fog, pet food, pharmaceuticals, contraceptives, garden fertilizers and plant nutrients, motor oil and lubricants, automotive and engineering components etc. Since COVID-19 pandemic, it has also been manufacturing consumer-facing products like N-95 masks and sanitizers. The assessee has its headquartered in Noida and has manufacturing facilities for packaging films in India, UAE, Mexico, Poland, Egypt, USA, Russia, Hungary & Nigeria. It has installed new packaging films plant coming up in Dharwad in South India. In India, its plants are located in Noida & Jammu for packaging products and allied businesses & in Sanand for aseptic liquid packaging. Its clients include global entities like P&G, PepsiCo, Coca-Cola, Nestle, Mondelez, L’Oreal, Britannia, Haldiram, Amul, Kimberly Clark, Reckitt, Dabur, ITC, Perfetti, GSK, Agrotech Foods, Mars Wrigley, Amcor, Mondi, UPM Raflatac etc. The assessee company manufactures and markets flexible packaging products such as biaxially oriented polyethylene terephthalate (BOPET) films, biaxially oriented polypropylene (BOPP) films, cast polypropylene (CPP) films, and metalized films. It also develops packaging allied and printing machines including extrusion coating, aseptic liquid filling machines, and lamination machines.

8.

Besides above, the assessee also has a cylinder business, which carries out the manufacturing of elastomers and sleeves; rotogravure printing cylinders; Flexo-polymer plates and metallic dies. It offers packaging solutions for motor oil and lubricants, automotive and engineering, dairy, pharmaceuticals, textile, fertilizers and plant, confectionery, consumer goods, and food and beverage sectors.

9.

The case of the assessee was selected for scrutiny under CASS and since assessee has carried out specified domestic transactions and well as international transactions with its AE’s, the matter was referred for determination of the Arm’s Length Price (“ALP”) of international and domestic specified transactions to the TPO. The TPO in terms of the order passed u/s 92CA(3) dated 16.02.2022 has made following two adjustments:-

(i)

Interest on delayed receivables from AE’s of INR 33,04,951; and

(ii)

Corporate guarantee fee of INR 6,78,72,478/-.

10.

Thereafter, the AO passed the draft assessment order on 26.03.2024 wherein the AO has incorporated the adjustments made by the TPO. A search and seizure action u/s 132 of the act was carried out at the business premises of the assessee, its business associates, group companies and residence of their directors were also covered. The AO considered the material found and seized during the course of search and after considering all the facts, in terms of paras 8.11 & 8.12 of the order has concluded that assessee has received unsecured loans of INR 74.00 crores from 38 lender parties out of which unsecured loans received from 27 parties amounting to INR 34.75 crores were treated as unexplained credit since the assessee has failed to prove the creditworthiness and genuineness of the transactions and business expediency and accordingly, addition was made u/s 68 of the Act. In first appeal, ld. CIT(A) confirmed the loans taken from 11 parties amounting to INR 15.50 crores and deleted the remaining loans taken from 16 lender parties of INR 19.25 crores. Further, an addition of INR 69.50 Lakhs was made on account of alleged commission paid for obtaining such unsecured loans treated as bogus and held the same as unexplained expenditure u/s 69C of the Act. The AO also disallowed a sum of INR 58,97,071/- out of deduction claimed u/s 80IB of the Act related to income from scrap sales and other miscellaneous non-operative and other income such as insurance claim, balances written off etc. by holding the same as not derived from eligible industrial undertaking. The AO further disallowed rent charges paid to the spouse of the Chairman of the assessee company amounting to INR 2.40 crores. The AO further made the addition u/s 14A of the Act of INR 7,04,621/-. The AO in para 12 of the order, observed that during the course of search simultaneously carried out in the case of Montage Enterprises P. Ltd. (MEPL), a group company, statement of one Shri Manoj Kandpal, AGM (Accounts & Finance) of MEPL were recorded u/s 132(4) of the Act wherein he has stated that the cash was collected from unrecorded sales made by MEPL as found noted in various diaries/notepads seized during the search and out of such cash, a sum of Rs. 7.00 crores were delivered to the head office i.e. the assessee company on monthly basis. This fact was stated in reply to question No.36 as reproduced in page 109 of the assessment order. Accordingly, the AO held the assessee company as beneficial owner of such cash and made the addition of INR 84.00 crores u/s 69A of the Act. Thereafter, total income of the assessee company was assessed at INR 2,31,18,19,921/- by making total addition of INR 1,29,62,29,121/-.

11.

Aggrieved by the said order, the assessee preferred an appeal before ld. CIT(A) wherein assessee has submitted various documents including additional evidences on which the remand report was obtained from the AO. The ld. CIT(A) after considering the submissions and the facts of the case and the Remand Report submitted by the AO, has confirmed the addition of INR 15,94,78,532/- and deleted the remaining additions made by the AO.

12.

The necessary chart of the additions made by the AO and deleted by ld. CIT(A) is tabulated as under:

S.No.ParticularsAY 2020-21
Addition By AOSustained by CIT(A)Deleted by CIT(A)
1.Addition u/s 68 Unexplained unsecured loans34,75,00,00015,50,00,00019,25,00,000
2.Addition u/s 69C ---Estimated commission69,50,00031,00,00038,50,000
3.Disallowance of deductionu/s 80-IB58,97,071NIL58,97,071
4.Disallowance of rent expense2,40,00,000NIL2,40,00,000
5.Disallowance u/s 14A r.w.r. 8D7,04,6217,04,621NIL
6.Addition of unexplained cash receipts u/s 69A84,00,00,000NIL84,00,00,000
7.Enhancement on account of Arm’s Length Price determined by TPO on Corporate Guarantee Commission6,78,72,4786,73,9116,71,98,567
8.Enhancement on account of Arm’s Length Price determined by TPO on Interest on receivables33,04,951NIL33,04,951
13.

Against the order of ld. CIT(A), both the parties are in appeal before the Tribunal by taking following Grounds of appeal:-

IT(TP) No.259/Del/2026 [Assessee’s appeal]

[Assessment Year 2020-21]

1.

“That the Ld. CIT(A) has erred, both on facts and in law, in upholding the assessment framed under Section 143(3) r.w.s. 144C(3), despite the fact that, pursuant to the search conducted on 21.02.2023, the proceedings were required to be initiated under Section 148, with approval under Section 148B; thus, the assessment framed under an incorrect statutory provision is invalid and liable to be quashed.

2.

That the Ld. CIT(A) has erred, both on facts and in law, in sustaining the quantum addition aggregating to 16,33,28,532/-, comprising of ₹15,50,00,000/- on account of unsecured loans under Section 68, estimated commission of ₹69,50,000/- under Section 69C of the Income Tax Act, 1961 ('Act'), ₹7,04,621/-under Section 14A, and 6,73,911/- under Section 92CA(3) towards corporate guarantee commission, without properly appreciating the facts and documents on record.

3.

That the Ld. CIT(A) erred in not appreciating that the impugned assessment is bad in law, as the approval in the draft assessment order and the final assessment order were identical, with no fresh approval obtained from the higher authorities for passing the final assessment order.

4.

That the Ld. CIT(A) erred in confirming the AO's action of not providing the Foreign Tax Credit of 2,69,565/-, despite the corresponding income being included in the return of income for the year under consideration. The CIT(A) incorrectly stated that no addition had been made by the AO in the assessment order, overlooking the fact that the credit was not reflected in the computation of tax liabilities.

5.

That the Ld. CIT(A) erred in confirming the AO's action of not providing the adjustment of *9,18,34,804/- made in the book profit under section 115JB, as per the computation of Income. The CIT(A) incorrectly stated that no addition had been made by the AO in the assessment order, overlooking the fact that the adjustment as claimed in the return of income was not provided in the computation sheet to determine the demand.

6.

That the Ld. CIT(A) has erred, both on facts and in law, in sustaining the addition of ₹15,50,00,000/- under Section 68 on account of unsecured loans received from Bhangbhumi Traders Pvt. Ltd. (1,00,00,000), Carillion VP Estates Pvt. Ltd. (1,00,00,000), First Agri Tech Pvt. Ltd. (₹1,00,00,000), Hapline Commodities Pvt. Ltd. (₹1,50,00,000), Manali Tradecom Pvt. Ltd. (₹50,00,000), Mayur India Pvt. Ltd. (₹50,00,000), Premnarayan Mercantile Pvt. Ltd. (*1,00,00,000), Target Vincom Pvt. Ltd. (*50,00,000), Pravesh Credit and Securities Ltd. (₹4,00,00,000), Radha Fincom Ltd. (1,00,00,000), and Supriya Fincom Pvt. Ltd. (3,50,00,000), on the alleged ground of lack of creditworthiness. That the CIT(A) failed to appreciate that the appellant has duly discharged the onus u/s 68 by submitting necessary documents.

7.

That the Ld. CIT(A) erred, both on facts and in law, in sustaining the addition under Section 68 in respect of alleged credits from Pravesh Credit and Securities Ltd. (₹4,00,00,000), Radha Fincom Ltd. (1,00,00,000), and Supriya Fincom Pvt. Ltd. (₹3,50,00,000), by solely relying on uncorroborated statements of third parties who were not directors during the year under consideration. That the CIT(A) erred in relying on such statements, ignoring the fact that statements recorded during a survey have no evidentiary value, thereby rendering the addition unsustainable in law.

8.

That the Ld. CIT(A) has erred in disregarding the fact that the loans in question had been accepted by the AO in earlier assessments and failed to demonstrate how the creditworthiness of the same lenders was affected in the year under consideration.

9.

That the Ld. CIT(A) erred in confirming the addition of some lenders, ignoring the fact that the loans have been repaid in subsequent years. That CIT(A) failed to appreciate that the addition under Section 68 cannot be made where the repayment has been made.

10.

That the Ld. CIT(A) erred in not adjudicating the ground regarding the estimated commission amounting to 69,50,000/-under Section 69C of the 'Act'.

11.

That the Ld. CIT(A) has erred, both on facts and in law, in sustaining the disallowance of *7,04,621/-under Section 14A, ignoring the fact that no addition can be made where the AO has not recorded his satisfaction after examining the books of account.

12.

That the Ld. CIT(A) erred in sustaining the addition of 6,73,911/- towards corporate guarantee fees by adopting the fees rate of 0.50% instead of 0.40% benchmarked by the appellant, ignoring that the same was at arm's length, rendering the adjustment unsustainable.

13.

That the Appellant craves leave to add, amend, alter or withdraw any of the grounds of appeal at or before the time of hearing.”

IT(TP)A No.272/Del/2026 [Revenue’s appeal]

[Assessment Year 2020-21]

1.

“Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the CIT APPEAL has erred in deleting the addition of Rs. 19,25,00,000 out of the total addition made under section 68 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 in respect of unsecured loans 1 received from various Kolkata based entities, ignoring the detailed findings recorded by the Assessing Officer establishing that the said entities were paper companies and accommodation entry providers lacking genuine creditworthiness and financial capacity, and that the transactions lacked commercial substance.

2.

Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the CIT APPEAL has erred in holding that the assessee had discharged the onus cast upon it under section 68 merely on the basis of documentary evidence such as PAN, confirmations, Income tax returns and bank statements, without appreciating that such documents, in the presence of adverse investigation findings and surrounding circumstances, are not sufficient to establish the identity, creditworthiness and genuineness of the lenders.

3.

Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the CIT APPEAL has erred in deleting the addition of Rs. 84,00,00,000 made under section 69A of the Income tax Act, 1961 on account of unexplained cash, without properly appreciating the statements recorded during the course of search proceedings and the material gathered during investigation, which indicated the existence of unaccounted cash transactions linked with the assessee.

4.

Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the CIT APPEAL has erred in deleting the transfer pricing adjustment of Rs. 33,04,951 made on account of interest on delayed receivables from associated enterprises, without appreciating that outstanding receivables from associated enterprises constitute a separate international transaction requiring independent benchmarking under the provisions of Chapter X of the Income Tax Act, 1961.

5.

Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the CIT APPEAL has erred in restricting the arms length rate of corporate guarantee commission to 0.5 percent as against 2.10 percent determined by the Transfer Pricing Officer, thereby deleting a substantial portion of the adjustment without conducting a detailed comparability analysis OR adequately considering the benchmarking study carried out by the TPΟ.

6.

Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the CIT APPEAL has erred in deleting the disallowance of Rs. 2,40,00,000 made by the Assessing Officer on account of rent paid for a farmhouse guest house, without adequately verifying the extent of actual business utilization of the premises during the relevant previous year and without appreciating that the assessee had failed to establish that the said expenditure was incurred wholly and exclusively for the purposes of business.*

7.

Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the CIT APPEAL has erred in allowing deduction under section 80 IB in respect of receipts such as insurance claim, remission write back of liabilities, scrap sales, purchase discounts and other miscellaneous income, without adequately examining whether such receipts could be regarded as profits derived from the eligible industrial undertaking within the meaning of section 80 IB of the Income Tax Act, 1961.

8.

Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the order of the CIT APPEAL is erroneous both on facts and in law, and therefore the same deserves to be set aside and the order of the Assessing Officer restored.

9.

That the order of Ld. CIT Appeal 3, Noida being erroneous in law and facts be set aside and order of the A.O. be restored.

10.

That the above grounds are without prejudice to each other and appellant craves leave to add, alter OR amend any ground OR grounds on OR before the date of hearing of appeal.”

14.

Ground of appeal No.1 of the assessee is with respect to the framing of assessment u/s 143(3) r.w.s. 144C(3) of the Act, ignoring the fact that the case of the assessee was completed after search u/s 132 of the Act conducted on 21.02.2023 at its business premises and thus, the proceedings should have been initiated and concluded u/s 148 of the Act.

15.

As observed above, a search and seizure operation was carried out on the assessee u/s 132 of the Act on 21.02.2023 alongwith search at the business premises of MEPL, a group concern. Prior to that, the return of income for the year under appeal was filed on 03.02.2021. The claim of the assessee was that the assessment for the year under appeal was completed u/s 143(3) of the Act however, when a search action was taken u/s 132 of the Act in the case of the assessee, therefore, in terms of Explanation 2 sub clause (i) to Section 148, the assessment proceedings should have been initiated u/s 148 of the Act and thus the order passed u/s 143(3) of the Act was invalid. For this reliance is placed on the judgement of the coordinate bench in the case of Montage Enterprises Pvt. Ltd. in ITA No. 5458/Del/2025 dt. 29.12.2025 who followed the judgement of Co-ordinate Bench of Chandigarh Tribunal in the case of Homelife Buildcon (P.) Ltd. Vs. DCIT, reported in (2025) 176 taxmann.com 614 (Chandigarh - Trib.) and further relied on the judgement in the case of Jamna Das Nikkamal Jain Saraf Pvt. Ltd. Vs DCIT in ITA No. 403/Chd./2025 dt. 04.11.2025. He prayed accordingly.

16.

On the other hand, the ld. CIT DR submits that the return of income was filed u/s 139(1) on 23.02.2021 and scrutiny proceedings were already initiated by issue of notice u/s 143(2) on 29.06.2021 which were pending as on the date of search, thus the assessment order was rightly passed u/s 143(3) of the Act.

17.

Heard both the parties and perused the material available on record. In the present case, a search and seizure operation us/s 132 of the Act was carried out on 21.02.2023 and prior to that notice u/s 143(2) of the Act for taking the case of the assessee for scrutiny assessment was issued on 29.06.2021. Claim of the assessee was that when search is conducted on or after 01.04.2021, assessment must be framed u/s 147/148 of the Act and not under Section 143(3) of the Income Tax Act. Before going further, it is necessary to refer Explantion-2 to section 148 of the Act, which reads as under:

Explanation 2- for the purpose of this section :

(i)

A search is initiated under section 132 or books of accounts, other documents or any assets are requisitioned on or after 1st day of April 2021 in the case of the assessee or

(ii)

a survey is conducted under section 133A, other than under sub-section (2A) [***] of that section, on or after the 1st day of April, 2021, in the case of the assessee; or

(iii)

the Assessing Officer is satisfied, with the prior approval of the Principal Commissioner or Commissioner, that any money, bullion, jewellery or other valuable article or thing, seized or requisitioned under section 132 or section 132A in case of any other person on or after the 1st day of April, 2021, belongs to the assessee; or

(iv)

the Assessing Officer is satisfied, with the prior approval of Principal Commissioner or Commissioner, that any books of account or documents, seized or requisitioned under section 132 or section 132A in case of any other person on or after the 1st day of April, 2021, pertains or pertain to, or any information contained therein, relate to, the assessee,

the Assessing Officer shall be deemed to have information which suggests that the income chargeable to tax has escaped assessment in the case of the assessee where the search is initiated or books of account, other documents or any assets are requisitioned or survey is conducted in the case of the assessee or money, bullion, jewellery or other valuable article or thing or books of account or documents are seized or requisitioned in case of any other person.

18.

From the plain reading of the above explanation, it is conferred that the assessment ought to have been made under Section 148 of the Act where a search was conducted on or after 01.04.2021. Despite the search being conducted in the case of the assessee and the AO being fully aware of this fact, he had proceeded to conclude the assessment proceedings initiated by issued the notice u/s 143(2) on 29.06.2021. Thus, under these circumstances, proper course of action would be to drop the proceedings already initiated and proceeded to initiate the proceedings u/s 148 as outlined in Explanation 2(i) to section 148 of the Act as there was deemed escapement of income. Failure to comply the statutory procedure as provided under the Act constitutes a jurisdictional defect. The Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Babu Varghessee Vs Bar Council of Kerala reported in (1999) 3 SCC 422, wherein at paragraph 31 and 32, it is held as follows:

“31.

It is the basic principal of law long settled that if the manner of doing a particular act is prescribed under any statute, the act must be done in that manner or not at all. The origin of this rule is traceable to the decision in Taylor vs Taylor (1875) 1.Ch.D 426 which was followed by Lord Roche in Nazir Ahmed v King Emperor who stated as under :-

“where a power is given to do certain thing in certain way, the thing must be done in that way or not at all.”

32.

This rule has since been approved by this court in Rao Shiv Bahadur Singh & Anr Vs State of Vindhya Pradesh and again in Deep chand Vs state of Rajasthan 1962, (1) SCR =AIR 1961 SC 1527. These cases were considered by a three Judge Bench of this court in state of Uttar Pradesh vs Singhara Singh & Others and the rule laid down in nazir Ahmed’s case (Supra) was again upheld. This rule has since been applied to the exercise of jurisdiction by courts and also been recognized as statutory principal of administrative Law.

19.

Therefore, the AO should have acted strictly in terms of the amended provisions of section 148 of the Act for the searches carried out on or after 01.04.2021. The coordinate bench of Delhi Tribunal in the case of MEPL (supra) held as under:

“Heard both the parties. Case files perused.

2.

We notice at the outset that there arises the first and foremost issue of validity of the impugned section 143(3) assessment itself framed by the learned DCIT, Central Circle-II, Noida as per the assessee's pleadings in its appeal ITA No.5458/Del/2025. A combined perusal of both these case files indicates that the assessee/appellant is engaged in the business of manufacturing and sale of flexible packaging material etc. It has filed its return for the impugned assessment year 2022-23 on 29.10.2022, declaring loss of Rs.64,53,88,702/-. And the same was taken for scrutiny. The learned departmental authorities thereafter carried out section 132 search action as well as section 133A survey in its case on 21.02.2023. There is further no dispute that the learned Assessing Officer then proceeded to frame the impugned assessment on 30th March, 2024 in its case inter alia making various disallowances/additions etc., involving varying sums, which stand partly upheld in the CIT(A)'s lower appellate discussion.

3.

It is in this factual backdrop that the assessee seeks to raise it's precise question challenging validity of the impugned assessment for the sole reason that the same ought to have been framed under section 148 with approval under section 148B of the Act in light of Homelife Buildcon (P.) Ltd. Vs. DCIT, (2025) 176 taxmann.com 614 (Chandigarh - Trib.) as relied in Jamna Das Nikkamal Jain Saraf Pvt. Ltd. Vs DCIT (ITA No. 403/Chd./2025) decided on 04.11.2025, adjudicating the very issue against the department as under:

"11.4

In conclusion, it was submitted that since the year under appeal formed part of the three assessment years immediately preceding the year in which search was conducted, the assessment ought to have been framed under section 148 with approval u/s 148B. The framing of the assessment u/s 143(3) and approval taken only for the purposes of section 143(3) was thus asserted to be fundamentally defective, non-compliant with statutory mandate, and consequently void ab initio. On these grounds, following the ratio in Homelife Buildcon Pvt. Ltd., it was prayed that the impugned assessment be quashed.

12.

The Ld. CIT-DR Shri Manav Bansal opposed the contention, stating that the return for A.Y. 2022-23 was filed prior to the date of search, and validly selected for scrutiny under CASS. The AO was competent to complete the assessment u/s 143(3).

12.1

He contended that section 148B applies only to "re-assessment" and not to "regular assessments." The AO's approval from Addl. CIT, being in line with the CBDT Instruction No. 7/2022 dated 15.07.2022, fulfils the supervisory requirement. The DR also submitted that Homelife Buildcon is distinguishable, as the AO therein relied on third-party search data, whereas the present case is based on assessee's own seized material.

13.

We have carefully considered the rival submissions and perused the record. It is undisputed that search u/s 132 was conducted on 24.11.2022, relevant to A.Y. 2023-24. Thus, A.Y. 2022- 23 is one of the three preceding years under Explanation 2(iv) to section 148. The Explanation reads that if a search is initiated, "the Assessing Officer shall be deemed to have information suggesting escapement of income for the three assessment years immediately preceding the assessment year relevant to the previous year in which the search is initiated."

13.1

Therefore, the only permissible statutory course was to issue notice u/s 148 and obtain prior approval u/s 148B before passing assessment order.

13.2

As the Assessing Officer completed the assessment under section 143(3) of the Act without issuing the notice under section 148 of the Act. Therefore, the question before us is whether the assessment proceedings initiated under section 143(3) of the Act can be validly continued and completed after a search under section 132 has been conducted in the case of the same assessee, without following the procedure prescribed under section 148 (Explanation 2) of the Act.

13.3

In our considered opinion, the answer lies in the scheme of the Act itself. Section 143 provides the general framework for regular assessment, whereas sections 147-148 (post-2021 regime) deal with reassessment based on information suggesting escapement of income, including that unearthed during a search.

13.4

A plain reading of section 143(2) shows that such notice can be issued only when a return of income is furnished under section 139 or in response to a notice under section 142(1). It empowers the Assessing Officer to scrutinize that return if he considers that income has been understated or tax underpaid. However, when a search under section 132 takes place and materials are found indicating possible escapement of income, the statute envisages a different route for carrying out assessment or reassessment under section 147 read with section 148, which is the special mechanism for bringing to tax the income discovered in consequence of a search.

13.5

Although section 148 (inserted w.e.f. 01.04.2021) does not begin with a non-obstante clause similar to the erstwhile section 153A, its context and Explanation 2 make it clear that where a search is initiated, the jurisdiction thereafter must flow through this special channel, subject to prior satisfaction and approval of the Principal Commissioner or Commissioner. The legislative intent is to ensure that when a search is carried out, the assessment is framed under the specific provisions meant for such cases and not under the general provision of section 143(3). Further we may mention that no notice under section 143(2) could have been issued after 3 months from the end of the financial year in which the return is furnished. In the present case the original return of income was filled on 4/11/2022 for the assessment year 202223 and 143 (2) was issued on 21/6/2023 , therefore also the assessment was framed under 143(3) of the Act is not sustainable. In other words the time required for issuing the notice under 143(2) had already expired, and the revenue can not be allowed to issue issue 143(2) on 21.6.2023 after the search was carried out and notice had been issued on 21.6.2023 and assessment was framed under 143(3) of the Act. The relevant portion of section 143(3) reads as under:-

143(2) Where a return has been furnished under section 139, or in response to a notice under sub-section (1) of section 142, the Assessing Officer or the prescribed income-tax authority, as the case may be, if considers it necessary or expedient to ensure that the assessee has not understated the income or has not computed excessive loss or has not under-paid the tax in any manner, shall serve on the assessee a notice requiring him, on a date to be specified therein, either to attend the office of the Assessing Officer or to produce any evidence on which the assessee may rely in support of the return: Provided that no notice under this sub-section shall be issued after the expiry of three months from the end of the financial year in which the return is furnished.

13.6

This position finds substantial support from the ratio of various decisions of Hon'ble High Court and Hon'ble Supreme Court.

The Courts unanimously held that once a search has been conducted and proceedings are triggered under section 153A, the Assessing Officer cannot continue parallel proceedings under section 143(3) or section 147 for the same assessment year, because the entire assessment for that year stands merged in the search assessment. The Courts emphasized that the existence of a special procedure for assessment consequent to a search is a complete code in itself; therefore, ordinary assessments abate and cannot coexist with the search-based assessment.

13.7

Drawing this analogy to the current regime, it is evident that when a search takes place and information is unearthed suggesting escapement of income, the Assessing Officer must act under section 148 (which now performs the role formerly assigned to section 153A) rather than continuing with a pending section 143(3) proceeding. The legislative intent remains the same -- to prevent multiplicity of proceedings and ensure that only one comprehensive order is passed, factoring in both the pre-search and post search materials.

13.8

The rationale is further reinforced by the well-settled principle of generalia specialibus non derogant -- the special provision overrides the general. Section 148 (as a special provision triggered by search information) must prevail over section 143 (the general provision for regular scrutiny). Allowing the Assessing Officer to continue and conclude proceedings under section 143(3) after a search would defeat this legislative scheme and render the safeguards, such as prior approval of the Principal Commissioner, redundant.

13.9

Accordingly, we hold that once a search is initiated under section 132 and material is found relating to the assessee, the pending assessment under section 143(3) cannot validly continue, as the time for issuing the 143(2) in response to original return of income had already expired, therefore the Assessing Officer must necessarily proceed in accordance with the special provisions contained in section 148 of the Act."

4.

Learned CIT(DR) representing the Revenue vehemently supports the impugned assessment that the Assessing Officer had rightly finalized the same under the normal provision once the entire issue was pending before him as on the date of search.

5.

We have given our thoughtful consideration to the assessee's and the Revenue's foregoing vehement submissions. We find merit in the assessee's legal ground herein once the impugned search had taken place in its case, no normal assessment under section 143(3) of the Act could have been framed in light of the tribunal's foregoing twin decisions going against the department. We thus adopt the above extracted reason mutatis mutandis to quash the impugned assessment framed by the learned Assessing Officer on 30th March, 2024 in very terms.”

20.

In view of above discussion, and by respectfully following the judgements of Co-ordinate Benches of the Tribunal as referred herein above, we are of the considered view that the assessment for the year before us must completed u/s 148 of the Act and not u/s 143(3) of the Act and thus, the order so passed is invalid order and is quashed.

21.

Though we have allowed the legal ground of appeal taken by the assessee and quashed the assessment order however, in the interest of justice, the other grounds of appeal taken on the merits of the additions by both the parties are decided as under:

22.

Ground of appeal No.2 raised by the assessee is general in nature, requires no separate adjudication.

23.

Ground of appeal No.3 of the assessee is not pressed hence, dismissed.

24.

Ground of appeal No.4 of the assessee is against the denial of foreign tax credit of INR 2,69,565/- to the assessee.

25.

Heard the contentions of both the parties at length and perused the material on record. Claim of the assessee was that out of total foreign tax credit of INR 1,03,99,055/-, the AO has allowed the credit to the extent of INR 1,01,29,490/- and has not allowed the credit of INR 2,69,565/- though the corresponding income was fully incorporated in the computation of total income and subject to the tax as per India Tax Law thus, it is double taxation.

26.

Considering the overall facts and submission of both the parties made before us, and upon perusing the material available on records, we direct the AO to examine whether income related to such short foreign tax credit was offered for tax in the year under appeal and if the claim of the assessee is found correct, necessary credit of foreign tax be allowed. With these directions, Ground of appeal No.4 of the assessee is allowed for statistical purposes.

27.

In respect of Ground of appeal No.5 of the assessee, no effective submission was made by the assessee. As per this Ground of appeal, assessee has challenged the adjustment made in the book profit.

28.

As per the assessee, the AO has not provided the details of adjustment of INR 9,18,34,804/- made in the book profit, therefore, AO is directed to provide the necessary working details to the assessee so that the necessary action could be taken at the end of the assessee. With these directions, Ground of appeal No.5 of the assessee is allowed for statistical purposes.

29.

The Assessee in Grounds of appeal Nos. 6 to 9 has challenged the addition sustained by ld. CIT(A) whereas the revenue in Grounds of appeal Nos. 1 & 2 has challenged the first appellate order on the amount of addition deleted by ld. CIT(A).

30.

Brief facts leading to this issue are that the assessee has received unsecured loans from 38 different lender parties totaling to INR 74.00 crores out of which loans taken from 27 lender parties amounting to INR 34.75 crores were held as unexplained credits u/s 68 of the Act. The AO has made detailed discussion of the inquiries conducted in respect of these loan creditors from pages 53 to 101 of the assessment order wherein the AO has made observations with respect to the statements recorded of the Directors of some lender companies during the course of survey where they have stated that the respective company was engaged in providing accommodation entries. The AO further referred notices issued u/s 133(6) of the Act. The AO after considering the replies filed by the assessee, was not satisfied about the genuineness of the loan transactions and creditworthiness of the total 27 lender and made the addition of INR 34.75 crores u/s 68 of the Act. The ld. CIT(A) confirmed the addition of the loans taken from 11 lenders of INR 15.50 crores and for the remaining loans of INR 19.25 crores taken from 16 lender parties, ld. CIT(A) after satisfying with the submissions and evidences produced has deleted the addition.

31.

Before us, first and foremost arguments of the assessee was that no incriminating material was found and seized with respect to the loan taken during the year under appeal therefore, without referring to any incriminating material, no addition could be made in the order passed u/s 143(3) consequent to search carried out u/s 132 of the Act.

32.

Regarding the allegation that the lenders have not replied in response to notice issued u/s 133(6) of the Act, the assessee has filed a chart reproduced at page 12 & 13 of the written submissions, stating that they had filed the replies and further filed the confirmations therefore, no addition was required to be made. Ld. AR further submits that from most of the parties, loans were also taken in preceding assessment years where assessments were completed u/s 143(3) and the issue of unsecured loans were examined and no doubts were raised with respect to the genuineness of the transactions and creditworthiness of the parties. He, therefore, submits that entire addition made on account of the loans deserves to be deleted including the additions sustained by ld. CIT(A). The detailed submissions made by the assessee containing various charts as well the item-wise submissions and the judicial pronouncements relied upon are reproduced as under:-

1.

That this present submission being filed in a consolidated manner in the case of UFLEX Limited for AYs 2020-21, 2021-22 and 2022-23. That the cases were selected for scrutiny under CASS on account of TP risk parameters and reference under section 92CA was made to the Ld. TPO. Subsequently, search proceedings under section 132(1) were conducted in the case of Uflex Ltd. on 21.02.2023; however, no incriminating material forming the basis of the impugned additions was found or seized during the search.

2.

That the additions made by the AO were challenged before CIT(A) and the summary of additions sustained by the Ld. CIT(A) is summarized as follows:

Nature of addition2020-212021-222022-23
AOPg no. of orderCIT(A) sustainedPg no. of orderAOPg no. of orderCIT(A) sustainedPg no. of orderAOPg no. of orderCIT(A) sustainedPg no. of order
Addition u/s 68 – Unsecured Loans34,75,00,00052-10015,50,00,000257-27125,25,00,00064-794,00,00,000129-14020,35,00,00061-7310,50,00,000127-137
Addition u/s 69C – Alleged Commission69,50,00010031,00,000255850,50,000798,00,000255940,70,0007321,00,000137
Disallowance of Deduction u/s 80-IB58,97,071102-1040271 2741,91,21,77679-810140-143----
Disallowance of Rent Expense2,40,00,000104-1050274-2752,04,00,00081-8201432,07,60,00073-740137-138
Disallowance u/s 14A r.w. Rule 8D7,04,621105-1067,04,621275--------
Addition u/s 69A – Cash Receipts84,00,00,000106-1090275-28584,00,00,00082-1190143-15384,00,00,00074-10684,00,00,000144-149
TP Adjustment – Outstanding Receivables33,04,951110-1110288-29141,15,310119-1210156-16056,41,069106-1070140-144
TP Adjustment – Corporate Guarantee Fee6,78,72,478110-1116,73,911285-2885,49,35,989119-12125,54,636153-1562,66,73,719106-10724,24,883.5138-140
Total129,62,29,12115,94,78,532119,61,23,0754,33,54,636110,06,44,78894,95,24,883.5
3.

That the Assessing Officer has made certain other disallowances in the computation sheet without any reference to or discussion of the same in the assessment order, and the CIT(A) has erroneously sustained such disallowances without recording any factual findings in support thereof. The summary of the same is as under:-

Nature of disallowance2020-212021-22
AO's ComputationPage no. of PBCIT(A) sustainedPage no. of orderAO's ComputationPage no. of PBCIT(A) sustainedPage no. of order
Foreign Tax Credit26956544-48269565292----
Adjustment of re-measurement of net defined benefit liability to book profit u/s 115JB9183480444-4891834804292----
AY 2020-21
As per AO in Computation SheetAs per computation by Assesse
1,918,517,2081,826,682,404
Disallowance of BDM----44025002401-24044402500161-162
Adjustment u/s 115JB----16092661642405-24081609266164No findings
AY 2021-22
As per AO in Computation SheetAs per computation by Assesse
5,476,803,8313,867,537,667
Total921043699210436916136686641613668664
4.

That aggrieved by the order of the CIT(A), the appellant has preferred the present appeal by filing Form 36 and raising appropriate grounds of appeal. The ground wise submission of the same are as under:-

5.

Submissions on Ground Nos. 6-9 (AY 2020-21), Ground Nos. 5-8 (AY 2021-22) & Ground Nos. 4-7 (AY 2022-23) filed by appellant: Discharge of Onus under Section 68 — Loans Accepted in Earlier Years, Repayments Duly Made, and Survey Statement Cannot Form the Sole Basis for Addition

Submissions on Ground Nos. 1-2 (AY 2020-21 and 2021-22) and Ground No. 4 for AY 2021-22 filed by department: Discharge of Onus under Section 68 — Deletion of Addition under Section 68 Despite Alleged Lack of Creditworthiness, Genuineness, and Reliance on Documentary Evidence

5.1. Unwarranted Section 68 Addition on Properly Documented Loans

It is respectfully submitted that the CIT(A) erred in sustaining the additions made in respect of unsecured loans raised by the Appellant during the relevant assessment years AY 2020-21, 2021-22 and 2022-23, and that the Department equally erred in challenging the deletions granted by the CIT(A) for AY 2020-21 and 2021-22, failing to appreciate that the said loans were duly supported by loan agreements and that the identity, creditworthiness, and genuineness of the lenders stood fully established to the satisfaction of the requirements of Section 68 of the Income-tax Act, 1961. For ready reference, a chart demonstrating the identity, creditworthiness, and genuineness of the lenders is reproduced hereunder:-

TABLE A :- IDENTITY OF LENDERS :- Appeal by Appellant — Addition sustained by CIT(A) for AY 2020-21, 2021-22 & 2022-23
Name of the LenderA.Y.ITRNBFC RegistrationReply u/s 133(6)MCA RecordsLoan agreement along with promissory notes and post dated chequeForm 16AGST Reg-06CIT(A)
Pravesh Credit and Securities Limited2020-216355-57No allegation102-10479-10175-78-257
2021-22742759-765754-757-
2022-23928903-922924-927-
Radha Fincom Ltd.2020-21115107-109106136-137129-135127-128-258
2021-22769No allegation787-793782-785-
2022-23943977-986975-976-
Bangbhumi Traders Pvt. Ltd.2020-21147-138-139173166-172162-165-260-261
Carrillion VP Estates Pvt. Ltd.2020-21191-174-177224217-223209-216-261
First Agri-Tech Pvt. Ltd.2020-21254-225-228278261-277255-260229-230261-262
2022-231082-2529-25321099-11081097-1098
Hapline Commodities Pvt. Ltd.2020-21287-279-280320-321311-318303-310-263
Manali Tradecom Pvt. Ltd.2020-21343-322-323362352-361344-351-265
Mayur India Private Limited2020-21379364363390384-389380-383-265
Premanarayan Mercantile Pvt. Ltd.2020-21404N/A391-394450425-448419-424-268
2022-231050-2523-25271070-10791066-1069-

= Loans accepted in earlier years from three Parties (Paper Page 22 of Written Subments)

* Insured paid on unsecured loans accepted as genuine - Page 246 CIT(A) 2020-21

Supriya Fincom Pvt. Ltd.2020-21462453-455452495479-494475-478-269
2021-22796No allegation804-809810-813-
2022-239921028-10471024-1027-
Target Vincom Pvt. Ltd.2020-21502N/A496-497528-529520-527516-519-370

TABLE B :-IDENTITY OF LENDERS :- Appeal by department AY 2020-21--- Addition deleted by CIT(A)

Name of the LenderA.Y.ITRNBFC RegistrationReply u/s 133(6)MCA RecordsLoan agreement along with promissory notes and post dated chequeForm 16AGST Reg-06
Pioneer Iron & Steel Corporation Ltd2020-211181N/AAs per AO no reply to 133(6)1198-11991188-11971182-1187N/A
Shree Sudarshan castings Pvt Ltd2020-2112081201No allegation12461240-12451238-1239N/A
Anyula Steels Pvt Ltd2020-21125412491247-124812831277-12821275-1276N/A
APM Finvest Ltd2020-2112971291-12921285-12901372-13761357-13711355-1356N/A
Greencrest Financial Services Ltd2020-21138913781377, 1379-138114371419-14361413-1418N/A
GSR Tradefin Pvt. Ltd.2020-21147814401438-1439 ,1441-144214931483-14921479-1482N/A
Kamalpur Finance Ltd.2020-211512N/A1494-14971548-15491538-15451530-1537N/A
Maharaj Ji Agro Products Pvt. Ltd.2020-211578N/A1550-15531624-16251566-15731562-15651599-1609 ( FSSAI), 1610 (( GST Reg-06 )
Neelam Securities Marketing Pvt Ltd2020-21163616301627-16291679-16801662-16781658-1661N/A
Paritosh Electricals Pvt Ltd2020-21169016851683-16841717-17181709-17161705-1708N/A
Perfect Business Advisory services Pvt Ltd2020-211747N/A1719-172117601749-1752 , 1757-17591753-1756N/A
Prachur Traders Pvt Ltd2020-21177317631761-1762,1764-1799-18131790-17981788-1789N/A
1765
Ricon Merchants Pvt Ltd2020-211821N/A1814-18171843-18581835-18421833-1834N/A
Shyamnagar Packaging Works Pvt Ltd2020-211862N/AAs per AO no reply to 133(6)18961886-18951884-1885N/A
Unity Merchandise Pvt Ltd2020-211906,1919N/A1897-189919301922-19291920-1921N/A
Zigma Electricals Pvt Ltd2020-211955N/A1931-19341966-19671958-19651956-1957N/A
TABLE B 1 :- IDENTITY OF LENDERS :- Appeal by department AY 2021-22— Addition deleted by CIT(A)
Name of the LenderUnsecured Loan raised via Banking ChannelsDocuments submittedPage no. of CIT(A) orderPage no. of Findings from CIT (A)
M/s Hallow Securities Private Limited5,00,00,000ITR, NBFC Registration, Confirmation, Loan Agreement along with Promissory Note and Post Dated Cheque, Form 16A, Repayment Ledger, Bank Statement of the Lender Entity, Bank Statement Evidencing Repayment, Audited Financial Statements14-20129-132
M/s Dhankalash Distributors Pvt. Ltd10,00,00,000ITR,MCA Records, Confirmation, Loan Agreement along with Promissory Note and Post Dated Cheque, Form 16A, Bank Statement of the Lender Entity, Bank Statement Evidencing Repayment, Audited Financial Statements20-25133-135
Kamalpur Finance Ltd1,00,00,000ITR, MCA Records, Confirmation, Loan Agreement along with Promissory Note and Post Dated Cheque, Form 16A, Bank Statement of the Lender Entity, Bank Statement Evidencing Repayment, Audited Financial Statements,34-38136-137
MaharajiAgro Products Pvt. Ltd3,50,00,000ITR, Reply U/S 133(6), MCA Records, Confirmation, Loan Agreement along with Promissory Note and Post Dated Cheque, Form 16A, Bank Statement of the Lender Entity, Bank Statement Evidencing Repayment, Audited Financial Statements ,FSSAI document, GST reg-0638-41137
Neelam Securities Pvt. Ltd1,00,00,000ITR, NBFC Registration, MCA Records, Confirmation, Loan Agreement along with Promissory Note and Post Dated Cheque, Form 16A, Bank Statement of the Lender Entity, Bank Statement Evidencing Repayment, Audited Financial Statements42-46137-138
Paritosh Electricals Pvt Ltd.25,00,000ITR, NBFC Registration,MCA Records, Loan Agreement along with Promissory Note and Post Dated Cheque, Form 16A, Bank Statement of the Lender Entity, Bank Statement Evidencing Repayment, Audited Financial Statements47-50138-139
Ricon Merchants Pvt Ltd50,00,000ITR, NBFC Registration, Reply U/S 133(6), MCA Records, Confirmation, Loan Agreement along with Promissory Note and Post Dated Cheque, Form 16A, Bank Statement of the Lender Entity, Bank Statement Evidencing Repayment, Audited Financial Statements.50-54139-140
TABLE C :- GENUINENESS AND CREDITWORTHINESS OF LENDERS :- Appeal by Appellant — Addition sustained by CIT[A]for AY 2020-21,2021-22 & 2022-23
Lender EntitiesA.Y.Unsecured Loan raised via Banking ChannelsShare capital including reserves and surplusNon-Current Investments/Trade Receivables/Fixed AssetsShort term Loans & AdvancesCash & Cash EquivalentsTotal RevenuePage no. of FinancialsBank statement of lenderIncome declared in ITR/ Profit as per P& LPage No. of PB
Pravesh Credit and Securities Limited20-214,00,00,00091.97 crores5,96,06,28(TR)86,67,44,260.904,32,3458,39,04,20764-7459-6020,44,77363
21-221,50,00,00092.13 crores18,41,26,067(TR)77,94,41,93512,66,11418,80,34,700743-753740-74119,28,402742
22-233,50,00,00092.17 crores14,92,53,230(TR)77.67 crores72,39,5806,80,96,690929-940901-9024,02,632(MAT)928
Kadha Fincom Limited20-211,00,00,00099.27 crores12,62,93,278.34(TR)86,94,73,96314,14,783.8319,68,13,874116-126112-11333,37,852115
21-221,00,00,00099.45 crores17,17,49,742.37(TR)84,86,05,289.602,50,85,99224,74,50,480770-781767-76824,26,585769
22-231,00,00,00099.40 crores16,57,24,740(TR)1,15,25,86,1703,16,39,76015,41,32,420944-9749424,17,280943
Bangbhumi Traders Pvt. Ltd.20-211,00,00,00020.26 crores3,79,31,500(NCI) 4,19,000(TR)16,37,68,51233,54,505.992,44,09,788.68148-161141-145NIL147
Carrillion VP Estates Pvt. Ltd.20-211,00,00,00024.13 lakhs11,11,247(NCI)2,07,27,58916,361.6023,06,098,27192-208179-1888,69,880191
First Agri-Tech Pvt. Ltd.20-211,00,00,00036.38 lakhs20,25,173(NCI) 98,93,817(TR) 4,86,95,810(FA)1,52,97,06310,03,5844,65,95,439236-253232-233NIL254
22-232,00,00,00065.24 lakhs400.52 lakhs (PPE)374.81 lakhs63.85 lakhs137.13 lakhs1083-1096108148,66,4881082
Hapline Commodities Pvt. Ltd.20-211,50,00,00025.006 crores4,77,87,500(NCI) 95,78,314(TR)18,98,65,09835,08,9434,11,23,319288-302282-28457,940287
Manali Tradescom Pvt. Ltd.20-2150,00,00012.85 crores4,99,92,690(NCI) 50,56,000(TR)8,70,78,9521,80,32878,71,498329-342325-32611,69,360343
Mayur India Private Limited20-2150,00,0003.04 crores1,95,019(DCA) 4,40,866.58(tangible assets)3,40,82,2377,44,293.8560,29,223.50369-37836723,65,709(MAT)379
Premanarayan Mercantile Pvt. Ltd.20-211,00,00,00013.59 lakhs3,12,000(NCI)85,83,2004,31,814.7462,22,125405-418398-4003,18,569404
22-2350,00,00018,59,8646,53,03,926(Total Assets)5,90,46,90749,48,93181,38,8191051-106510493,10,6401050
Supriya Fincom Pvt. Ltd.20-213,50,00,00038,48,69,9682,66,64,300(TR)33,71,99,36735,78,58112,95,60,559463-474458-45918,81,330(MAT)462
21-221,50,00,00038.64 crores5,95,55,528(TR)30,61,37,9451,96,48,7725,47,52,135815-82679520,63,898796
22-233,50,00,00038.68 Crores26,15,17,210(TR)34,33,39,04058,56,39016,31,50,180993-1023989-9917,00,354(MAT)992
Target Vincom Pvt. Ltd.20-2150,00,00012,88,45,6757,84,20,000(NCI)8,81,41,66092,40158,09,946503-515499-50011,12,140(MAT)502
TABLE D :- GENUINENESS AND CREDITWORTHINESS OF LENDERS :- Appeal by department in AY 2020-21-- Addition deleted by CIT(A)
Lender EntitiesUnsecured Loan raised via Banking ChannelsShare capital including reserves and surplusNon-Current Investments/Trade Receivables/Fixed AssetsShort term Loans & AdvancesCash & Cash EquivalentsTotal RevenuePage no. of FinancialsBank statement of lenderIncome declared in ITR/ Profit as per P&LPage No. of ITR
Pioneer Iron & Steel Corporation Ltd50,00,00030,61,59,70613,40,17,518 (NCI) 15,01,480(TR) 4,71,02,766 (F.A)1,38,679,17310,83,8752,08,97,1021151-1180114818,32,6701181
Shree Sudarshan castings Pvt Ltd1,00,00,00047,07,83,1863,00,000 (NCI) 4,03,48,600 (TR)47,60,580.6046,63,532.936,75,86,565.301209-12371202-120618,17,038.391208
Anjula Steels Pvt Ltd1,00,00,0009,80,99,132.375,92,05,000 (NCI)7,00,00,000₹1,43,99,380.371,12,67,6951255-1274125216,95,5901254
APM Finvest Ltd7,00,00,00070,84,99,00059,43,94,000 (NCI) 55,33,000(TR)20,45,47,00062,03,0001,69,07,0001298-135412941,77,42,780 (ITR)1297
Greencrest Financial Services Ltd1,00,00,00050,38,20,23990,00,000(NCI) 18,59,966(TR) 3,24,717(FA)42,23,50,82830,95,931₹3,64,68,6401390-14121383-138460,28,3061389
GSR Tradefin Pvt. Ltd.75,00,0003,00,09,3062,16,82,993(NCI) 10,540 (TR)23,49,27,6945,48,2977,18,63,7321454-14771445-144822,08,9601478
Kamalpur Finance Ltd.50,00,00010,22,89,292.63,74,48,032(FA) 14,13,240(TR) 1,21,46,440.87(CI)6,72,80,3733,73,517.5597,95,013.211513-15291500-150918,86,9101512
Maharaj Ji Agro Products Pvt. Ltd.2,75,00,0002,58,29,3163,00,06,428(FA) 1,86,49,305 (TR)1,96,24,9382,50,48,35721,78,60,7701579-1598555-1561,1574 157523,48,8161578
Neelam Securities Marketing Pvt Ltd50,00,0005,66,58,8762,10,29,191(NCI)3,36,61,2394,21,72879,79,5081637-16571632-16331,81,0001636
Paritosh Electricals Pvt Ltd25,00,00014,93,26,0691,04,000(NCI)1,39,897,01422,89,9176,55,96,2041691-1704168799,37,7381690
Perfect Business Advisory services Pvt Ltd1,00,00,00015,13,62,0064,27,34,066 (TA) 6,56,75,851(NCI) 2,95,02,115(CI)1,12,15,21744,33,66651,66,5371726-17461723,1748(25,71,140)1747
Prachur Traders Pvt Ltd50,00,0002,95,90,651.281,42,53,207.67(NCI) 42,469 (TR)1,44,87,693.3214,57,952.2920,98,074.211774-17871767-17714,88,839.211773
Ricon Merchants Pvt Ltd50,00,00019,97,48,936.141,99,95,873(TR)15,15,30,5141,66,10,017.1434,61,7981822-18321818-181911,51,7701821
Shyamnagar Packaging Works Pvt Ltd1,00,00,000126,60,27,858.73114,40,43,744.07(NCI)2,89,37,52810,69,19,948.662,37,75,622.351863-188318602,30,00,368.731862
Unity Merchandise Pvt Ltd50,00,0002,43,30,37036,79,447(NCI) 81,43,599(FA) 29,16,927(TR)2,55,57,6928,48,8842,38,42,5051907-19181901-190341,01,1401906,1919
Zigma Electricals Pvt Ltd50,00,0008,05,78,23533,876.75 (FA)8,92,53,376 (LTLA)8,30,0002,11,93,6491939-1954193723,73,612.881955
TABLE D1 :- GENUINENESS AND CREDITWORTHINESS OF LENDERS :- Appeal by department in AY 2021-22— Addition deleted by CIT(A)
Lender EntitiesUnsecured Loan raised via Banking ChannelsShare capital including reserves and surplusNon-Current Investments/Trade Receivables/Fixed Assets/Total Assets/current investmentsShort term and Long Loans & AdvancesCash & Cash EquivalentsTotal RevenueProfit as per P&L /Total income as per ITR
M/s Hallow Securities Private Limited5,00,00,00096,92,54,10876,55,079 (FA)1,52,25,77350,83,0936,25,25,7411,73,97,990
M/s Dhankalash Distributors Pvt. Ltd10,00,00,00066,13,52,657125,31,34,488 (NCI)1,52,83,83,9875,66,8948,68,56,63452,22,232(MAT)
Kamalpur Finance Ltd1,00,00,00010,35,81,209.923,56,22,794 (FA) 12,75,358.16(TR) 1,18,18,066.62 (CI)7,74,43,62310,886.101,77,44,877.6119,95,330
MaharajiAgro Products Pvt. Ltd3,50,00,0002,75,95,2672,79,53,871(FA) 1,65,54,404(TR) 53,67,964 (CI)1,04,88,8333,64,35,28813,38,77,7604,48,997 (MAT)
Neelam Securities Pvt. Ltd1,00,00,0006,18,89,2592,52,74,795(NCI)2,91,47,4614,14,1281,30,59,50854,00,383
Paritosh Electricals Pvt Ltd.25,00,00015,67,59,40115,95,34,704 (TA)14,60,66,967*32,74,0327,51,76,26799,33,630
Ricon Merchants Pvt Ltd50,00,00020,04,18,189.141,76,12,433(TR)16,45,30,06242,57,06733,73,4119,17,910
5.2.

Judicial pronouncements upon full compliance with Section 68—identity, creditworthiness, and genuineness duly established through documentary evidence

i.

2026 (4) TMI 1188 - ITAT DELHI DCIT, ARTO Complex, Noida Versus ACE Infracity Developers Pvt. Ltd. And (Vice-Versa) (Refer page no. 649-655 of the case law PB). ii. 2025 (7) TMI 1285 - ITAT DELHI ACIT, ARA Centre, DCIT, New Delhi Versus Filatax India Limited And (Vice-Versa) (Refer page no. 656-698 of the case law PB). iii. 2025 (10) TMI 1091 - ITAT AGRA Income Tax Officer-1 Morena, (M.P.) Versus Shri Agrasen Logistics (Refer page no. 699-727 of the case law PB). iv. 2026 (4) TMI 1470 - ITAT DELHI DCIT, Circle-9(1), Delhi Versus Paramount Propbuild Pvt. Ltd., Delhi (Refer page no. 728-738 of the case law PB). v. 2026 (1) TMI 1567 - ITAT DELHI Vidur Chharia; Rakesh Chharia & Pole-Ads Advertising Pvt. Ltd. Versus DCIT/ACIT, Central Circle, Ghaziabad (Refer page no. 739-753 of the case law PB). vi. 2026 (1) TMI 470 - ITAT DELHI Passion Realtech Pvt. Ltd. Versus Asstt. Commissioner of Income Tax, CC-II, Haryana (Refer page no. 754-761 of the case law PB). vii. Principal Commissioner of Income-tax (Central) vs. Mukul Kakar [2026] 182 taxmann.com 372 (SC) [07-01-2026] and Rajnandani Projects (P.) Ltd. vs. Principal Commissioner of Income-tax [2026] 182 taxmann.com 147 (Patna) [18-12-2025] (Refer page no. 762-763 of the case law PB). viii. Preity G Zinta vs. Income-tax Officer, International Taxation [2025] 181 taxmann.com 48 (Mumbai - Trib.) [17-11-2025] (Refer page no. 764-770 of the case law PB). ix. Income-tax Officer vs. Arpitam Builders LLP [2025] 180 taxmann.com 397 (Delhi - Trib.) [07-11-2025] (Refer page no. 771-782 of the case law PB). x. Principal Commissioner of Income-tax vs. Hamlet [2025] 178 taxmann.com 639 (Karnataka) / [2025] 307 Taxman 248 (Karnataka) [02-09-2025] (Refer page no. 783-786 of the case law PB). xi. Income-tax Officer vs. Cornerstone Property Investments (P.) Ltd. [2024] 164 taxmann.com 464 (SC) / [2024] 300 Taxman 85 (SC) [15-07-2024] (Refer page no. 787-788 of the case law PB).

5.3. Absence of Incriminating Material During Search

That no incriminating material was seized during the course of search regarding any exchange of cash. This confirms that all transactions were genuine and properly accounted for. In this regard reliance is being placed upon following judicial pronouncements :-i. Principal Commissioner of Income-tax Central vs. Priya Blue Industries (P.) Ltd. [2025] 181 taxmann.com 745 (Gujarat) [14-10-2025] (Refer page no. 789-794 of the case law PB). ii. Commissioner of Income-tax vs. Dilbagh Rai Arora [2019] 104 taxmann.com 371 (Allahabad) / [2019] 263 Taxman 30 (Allahabad) [15-03-2019] (Refer page no. 795-799 of the case law PB). iii. Principal Commissioner of Income-tax vs. Agson Global (P.) Ltd. [2022] 134 taxmann.com 256 (Delhi) / [2022] 286 Taxman 519 (Delhi) / [2022] 441 ITR 550 (Delhi) [19-01-2022] (Refer page no. 800-825 of the case law PB). iv. Principal Commissioner of Income-tax (Central) vs. K.R. Pulp and Papers Ltd. [2025] 175 taxmann.com 278 (Delhi) [31-05-2025] (Refer page no. 826-838 of the case law PB). v. [2024] 162 taxmann.com 792 (Allahabad) – PCIT v. Anshika Consultants (P.) Ltd., Allahabad HC, ITA No. 32/2024, 25-04-2024 (Refer page no. 839-842 of the case law PB). vi. [2023] 148 taxmann.com 94 (Calcutta) – PCIT v. Overtop Marketing (P.) Ltd., Calcutta HC, ITAT/243/2022, 03-01-2023 (Refer page no. 843-844 of the case law PB). vii. [2024] 159 taxmann.com 604 (Allahabad) – DCIT v. Paswara Papers Ltd., Allahabad HC (Refer page no. 845-847 of the case law PB). viii. [2019] 111 taxmann.com 89 (Delhi - Trib.) – Prime Comfort Products (P.) Ltd. v. ACIT, ITAT Delhi (Refer page no. 1512-1522 of the case law PB). ix. [2014] 45 taxmann.com 203 (Rajasthan) / [2014] 224 Taxman 87 / 366 ITR 217 / 267 CTR 396 (Rajasthan) – CIT, Ajmer v. Jal Kumar Bakliwal, Rajasthan HC, 06-02-2014 (Refer page no. 848-854 of the case law PB).

5.4. No Addition Warranted Where Loans Repaid

It is respectfully submitted that the CIT(A) and department has failed to consider that all lenders have fully repaid the loans over time, and in light of settled law, where repayments are made and no incriminating material is found during search, no addition can be warranted. Your honors will appreciate that repayment was made within the prescribed period as mentioned in the loan agreement and in major cases the repayment has been made before the search dated 21.02.2023.

TABLE E:- REPAYMENT:- Appeal by Appellant — Addition sustained by CIT(A) for AY 2020-21,2021-22 & 2022-23
Lender EntitiesA.Y.Date of Repayment of loanPage No. of ledgerPage No. of appellant bankJudicial Pronouncements Supporting the Proposition that No Addition under Section 68 is Warranted Where Repayment of Loans Has Been Duly Made
Pravesh Credit and Securities Limited2020-2128.09.2020549-55161-62i. Income Tax Officer v. Kayathwal Estate (P.) Ltd. — [2022] 139 taxmann.com 317 (SC) (Refer page no. 1506-1511 of the case law PB). ii. Principal Commissioner of Income-tax v. Bairagra Builders (P.) Ltd. — [2024] 164 taxmann.com 162 (Bombay HC) (Refer page no. 1780-1782 of the case law PB). iii. Principal Commissioner of Income-tax (Central) v. Dharmesh Padamshibhai Patel — [2023] 156 taxmann.com 491 (Gujarat HC) (Refer page no. 1783-1787 of the case law PB).
2021-2231.03.2021758
2022-2325.10.2021923
Radha Fincom Limited2020-2128.09.2020555-556114iv. Principal Commissioner of Income-tax (Central), Surat v. Neotech Education Foundation — [2023] 148 taxmann.com 372 (Gujarat HC) (Refer page no. 1501-1505 of the case law PB).
2021-2231.03.2021786
2022-2325.10.2021987
Bangbhumi Traders Pvt. Ltd.2020-2131.03.2023530-531146v. Principal Commissioner of Income-tax v. Merrygold Gems (P.)
Carrillion VP Estates Pvt. Ltd.2020-2103.10.2022532-535189-190
First Agri-Tech Pvt. Ltd.2020-2121.12.2020536-539234-235
2022-2320.08.20222534
Hapline Commodities Pvt. Ltd.2020-2131.03.2023540-543285-286
Manali Tradecom Pvt. Ltd.2020-2117.02.2023544-546327-328
Mayur India Private Limited2020-2116.01.2020547-548368Ltd. — [2024] 164 taxmann.com 764 (Gujarat HC) (Refer page no. 1496-1500 of the case law PB). vi. Principal Commissioner of Income-tax v. Ambe Tradecorp (P.) Ltd. — [2022] 145 taxmann.com 27 (Gujarat HC) (Refer page no. 1794-1796 of the case law PB). vii. Principal Commissioner of Income-tax v. Ojas Tarmake (P.) Ltd. — [2023] 156 taxmann.com 75 (Gujarat HC) (Refer page no. 1788-1793 of the case law PB).
Premanarayan Mercantile Pvt. Ltd.2020-2125.08.2021552-554401-403
2022-2331.03.20232528
Supriya Fincom Pvt. Ltd.2020-2128.09.2020557-559460-461
2021-2231.03.2021814
2022-2318.10.2022990, 2533
Target Vincom Pvt. Ltd.2020-2101.01.2020560-561501
TABLE F:- REPAYMENT:- Appeal by department for AY 2020-21 and AY 2021-22— Addition deleted by CIT(A)
Lender EntitiesA.Y.Date of Repayment of loanPage No. of ledgerPage No. of appellant bank
Pioneer Iron & Steel Corporation Ltd2020-2101.10.20202543-25441149-1150
Shree Sudarshan castings Pvt Ltd2020-2114.10.20191996-19971207
Anjula Steels Pvt Ltd2020-2111.10.20191970-19711253
APM Finvest Ltd2020-2122.02.20211972-19731295-1296
Greencrest Financial Services Ltd2020-2116.12.20221974-19761385-1386
GSR Tradefin Pvt. Ltd.2020-2121.01.2021 / 25.02.20211977-19791449-1453
Kamalpur Finance Ltd.2020-2113.02.20231980-19851510-1511
2021-2231.03.2023
Maharaj Ji Agro Products Pvt. Ltd.2020-2117.03.20201986-19891576-1577
2021-2220.03.2021/26.03.202141 of CIT(A) Order
Neelam Securities Marketing Pvt Ltd2020-2114.10.20191990-19931634-1635
2021-2201.02.2021/02.08.202146 of CIT(A) Order
Paritosh Electricals Pvt Ltd2020-2104.01.20232535-25391688
2021-2227.02.202350 of CIT(A) Order
Perfect Business Advisory services Pvt Ltd2020-2105.04.20232540-25421724-1725
Prachur Traders Pvt Ltd2020-2103.08.20192545-25461772
Ricon Merchants Pvt Ltd2020-2105.12.20191994-19951820
2021-2221.12.202054 of CIT(A) Order
Shyamnagar Packaging Works Pvt Ltd2020-2126.11.20191998-19991861
Unity Merchandise Pvt Ltd2020-2103.01.20222000-20011905
Zigma Electricals Pvt Ltd2020-2130.09.20192002-20031938
M/s Hallow Securities Private Limited2021-2221.11.202020 of CIT(A) Order20 of CIT(A) Order
M/s Dhankalash Distributors Pvt. Ltd2021-2201.02.202324 of CIT(A) Order24 of CIT(A) Order

5.5. Confirmation of Loans Received

The loans raised by the appellant have been duly confirmed by the lenders under section 133(6) of the Income-tax Act. These confirmations establish the genuineness, identity, and creditworthiness of the parties concerned.

TABLE G :- Confirmation of Loans Received against Notices u/s 133(6)- Appeal by Appellant — Addition sustained by CIT(A)for AY 2020-21,2021-22 & 2022-23
Name of the LenderA.YReply u/s 133(6)Confirmation of Loan
Pravesh Credit and Securities Limited2020-21No allegation58
2021-22739
2022-23900, 911
Radha Fincom Ltd.2020-21No allegation (106)110
2021-22No allegation766
2022-23No reply u/s 133(6)941
Bangbhumi Traders Pvt. Ltd.2020-21Allegation but reply submitted 138-139140
Carrillion VP Estates Pvt. Ltd.2020-21Allegation but reply submitted 174-177178
First Agri-Tech Pvt. Ltd.2020-21Allegation but reply submitted 225-228231
2022-232529-2532 (No allegation)1080
Hapline Commodities Pvt. Ltd.2020-21Allegation but reply submitted 279-280281
Manali Tradecom Pvt. Ltd.2020-21Allegation but reply submitted 322-323324
Mayur India Private Limited2020-21363 (No allegation)365-366
Premanarayan Mercantile Pvt. Ltd.2020-21Allegation but reply submitted 391-394396-397
2022-232523-2527 (No allegation)1048
Supriya Fincom Pvt. Ltd.2020-21No allegation (452)457
2021-22No allegation794
2022-23988
Target Vincom Pvt. Ltd.2020-21Allegation but reply submitted 496-497498
TABLE H :- Confirmation of Loans Received against Notices u/s 133(6)- Appeal by department— Addition deleted by CIT(A)
Name of the LenderA.YReply u/s 133(6)Confirmation of Loan
Pioneer Iron & Steel Corporation Ltd2020-21No reply to 133(6)1146
Shree Sudarshan castings Pvt Ltd2020-21No reply to 133(6)1200
Anjula Steels Pvt Ltd2020-21No allegation 1247-12481251
APM Finvest Ltd2020-21No allegation 1285-12901293
Greencrest Financial Services Ltd2020-21No allegation 1377 ,1379-13811382
GSR Tradelink Pvt. Ltd.2020-21Allegation but reply submitted 1438-1439 , 1441-14421443
Kamalpur Finance Ltd.2020-21No allegation 1494-14971499
Maharaj Ji Agro Products Pvt. Ltd.2020-21Allegation but reply submitted 1550-15531554
Neelam Securities Marketing Pvt Ltd2020-21No allegation 1627-16291631
Paritosh Electricals Pvt Ltd2020-21No allegation 1681-16841686
Perfect Business Advisory services Pvt Ltd2020-21No allegation 1719-17211722
Prachur Traders Pvt Ltd2020-21Allegation but reply submitted 1761-1762,1764-17651766
Ricon Merchants Pvt Ltd2020-21Allegation but reply submitted 1814-1817
Shyamnagar Packaging Works Pvt Ltd2020-21No reply to 133(6)1859
Unity Merchandise Pvt Ltd2020-21No allegation 1897-18991900
Zigma Electricals Pvt Ltd2020-21No allegation 1931-19341936

5.6. Rebuttal to CIT(A) observations:-

a)

Your Honors will appreciate that the CIT(A) has made certain additions relying on the AO's assertions, and a pointwise rebuttal is tabulated below for ease of reference. It is respectfully submitted that the matters relied upon by the CIT(A) are irrelevant, the facts considered are incorrect, and, in any event, statements recorded during surveys of other persons cannot form the basis for such additions.

Pravesh Credit and Securities Limited—Addition sustained by CIT(A)for AY 2020-21,2021-22 & 2022-23
S No.Allegations of AO/CIT(A) for AY 2020-21Rebuttal to Allegations :- That the submissions filed for A.Y. 2020-21 may kindly be read and considered mutatis mutandis for A.Ys. 2021-22 and 2022-23, as the facts, issues involved, and grounds raised are identical/similar in nature.
1.AO— Absence of Fixed Assets(Page No. 52 of the AO Order) for AY 2020-21 CIT(A)— No adverse comments have been pointed out (Pg 257-258 of CIT(A) order)for AY 2020-21The AO's allegation is incorrect; as an RBI-registered NBFC with no manufacturing activity, ownership of fixed assets is neither required nor relevant for evaluating it's creditworthiness. Refer Page no. 55-57 of PB.
2.The company's operational address does not match its registered address. (Page No. 52 of the AO Order) CIT(A)— No adverse comments have been pointed out (Pg 257-258 of CIT(A) order)The AO's allegation of address mismatch is factually incorrect and self-contradictory, as the notice u/s 133(6) was duly issued to and complied with by the lender. The AO's own observation that commercial expediency was not explained confirms the lender responded and furnished information; thus, no adverse inference on its identity, genuineness, or creditworthiness can be drawn in absence of contrary material.
3.Admission by Director – Director Sanjay Kumar Singhi admitted in post-survey proceedings to engaging in accommodation entry business through the company. (Page No. 52 of the AO Order) CIT(A)— That CIT(A) at Page No. 257-258 for AY 2020-21 has relied upon the statement of Sanjay Kumar Singhi to confirm the addition. Identical Observations of CIT(A) for AYs 2021-22 and 2022-231. Copy of statement not provided and only extracts reproduced in notice/order. It is respectfully submitted that no copy of the statement relied upon by the Department has been furnished to the appellant. 2. No opportunity for cross examination Furthermore, no opportunity for cross examination could be availed as full statement was never provided. 3. Shri Sanjay Kumar Singhi Not a Director – Statement Cannot Be Relied Upon Without prejudice to above, It is further submitted that the statement as relied upon by department is wholly irrelevant, as Shri Sanjay Kumar Singhi was not a director of the lender company during the relevant assessment years. This is substantiated by the enclosed MCA Director Master database, which clearly shows that he held no directorship. It is also submitted that Shri Sandeep Kumar Singhi ceased to hold office w.e.f. 16.11.2016 (Ref. Pg. no. 102-104 of PB). 4. Survey Statement and Incriminating Material – No Evidentiary Value It is respectfully submitted that the AO relied upon the statement recorded during survey u/s 133A dated 28.06.2022 to impugn the genuineness of the loan. The Ld. AO erred in failing to appreciate that such statements carry no evidentiary value and that no incriminating material was found either during the search of the appellant or in the survey of Shri Sandeep Kumar Singhi's office. 5. Loans Fully Repaid Prior to Survey – No Addition Warranted It is respectfully submitted that the AO failed to appreciate that the loans for the respective years were fully repaid on 28.09.2020, 31.03.2021, and 25.10.2021, i.e., well before the survey conducted on 28.06.2022. 6. Erroneous Addition Without Assessing Creditworthiness
That the CIT(A) erred in making the addition without commenting anything adversely on the creditworthiness. Moreover, the assertion of the CIT(A) for share capital and share premium cannot be taken as base for questioning the creditworthiness. 7. Acceptance of Lender in Earlier Years – No Comment in Appeal It is respectfully submitted that the appeal does not address that the same lender has been treated as genuine by the Assessing Officer in earlier years. The summary of the same is as under:-
S No.Name of LenderFYAmount of loanPage No. of PB
1.Pravesh CreditsAnd Securities Ltd.17-183,00,00,000610-612(Confirmation) 601-609(AO Order)
8.AO—Lack of Commercial Expediency – The company did not explain the commercial rationale for advancing the loan in response to the notice under section 133(6). (Page No. 53 of the AO Order) CIT(A)— No adverse comments have been pointed out (Pg 257-258 of CIT(A) order)It is respectfully submitted that the AO’s observation regarding the commercial expediency of the loan is misconceived. The commercial expediency is fully evident as the lender is a duly registered NBFC, and advancing funds to earn interest is a legitimate business activity for such an entity. That commercial expediency is also proved from ICD agreement submitted by the appellant. (Ref Page no. 79-101 of PB)
9.AO—Defective Agreement– The loan agreement was neither notarized nor witnessed, rendering it non-credible. (Page No. 53 of the AO Order) CIT(A)— No adverse comments have been pointed out (Pg 257-258 of CIT(A) order)The loan agreement, duly executed on non-judicial stamp paper and signed by both parties, cannot be invalidated merely for absence of witness signature, especially when the transaction is fully substantiated by surrounding circumstances.
10.AO—Unverifiable Creditworthiness – The lender’s creditworthiness and the genuineness of the transaction cannot be verified. (Page No. 53 of the AO Order) CIT(A)— Majority of Funds Reflected as Share Capital Including Share Premium Identical Observations of CIT(A) for AYs 2021-22 and 2022-23.(Pg 257-258 of CIT(A) order)Erroneous Addition Without Assessing Creditworthiness That the CIT(A) erred in making the addition without commenting anything adversely on the creditworthiness. Moreover, the assertion of the CIT(A) for share capital and share premium cannot be taken as base for questioning the creditworthiness. Moreover, creditworthiness is explained in above paras.
Radha Fincom Ltd. Addition sustained by CIT(A)
S.NoAllegations of AO/CIT(A) for AY 2020-21Rebuttal to Allegations :- That the submissions filed for A.Y. 2020-21 may kindly be read and considered mutatis mutandis for A.Ys. 2021-22 and 2022-23, as the facts, issues involved, and grounds raised are identical/similar in nature.
1.Admission by Director – Director Sanjay Kumar Singhi (Page No. 53 of the AO Order) CIT(A)— That CIT(A) at Page No. 258 for AY 2020-21 has relied upon the statement of Sanjay Kumar Singhi to confirm the addition. Identical Observations of CIT(A) for AYs 2021-22 and 2022-231. Copy of statement not provided and only extracts reproduced in notice/order. It is respectfully submitted that no copy of the statement relied upon by the Department has been furnished to the appellant. 2. No opportunity for cross examination Furthermore, no opportunity for cross examination could be availed as full statement was never provided. 3. Shri Sanjay Kumar Singhi Not a Director – Statement Cannot Be Relied Upon Without prejudice to above, It is further submitted that the statement as relied upon by department is wholly irrelevant, as Shri Sanjay Kumar Singhi was not a director of the lender company during the relevant assessment years. This is substantiated by the enclosed MCA Director Master database, which clearly shows that he held no directorship. It is also submitted that Shri Sandeep Kumar Singhi ceased to hold office w.e.f. 16.11.2016 (Ref. Pg. no. 102-104 of PB). 4. Survey Statement and Incriminating Material – No Evidentiary Value It is respectfully submitted that the AO relied upon the statement recorded during survey u/s 133A dated 28.06.2022 to impugn the genuineness of the loan. The Ld. AO erred in failing to appreciate that such statements carry no evidentiary value and that no incriminating material was found either during the search of the appellant or in the survey of Shri Sandeep Kumar Singhi’s office. 5. Loans Fully Repaid Prior to Survey – No Addition Warranted It is respectfully submitted that the AO failed to appreciate that the loans for the respective years were fully repaid on 28.09.2020, 31.03.2021, and 25.10.2021, i.e., well before the survey conducted on 28.06.2022. 6. Erroneous Addition Without Assessing Creditworthiness That the CIT(A) erred in making the addition without commenting anything adversely on the creditworthiness. Moreover, the assertion of the CIT(A) for share capital and share premium cannot be taken as base for questioning the creditworthiness. 7. Acceptance of Lender in Earlier Years – No Comment in Appeal It is respectfully submitted that the appeal does not address that the same lender has been treated as genuine by the
Assessing Officer in earlier years. The summary of the same is as under:-
Name of LenderFYAmount of loanPage No. of PB
Radha Fincom Ltd.2017-181,50,00,000613-615(Confirmation) 601-609(AO Order)
2.Funds were transferred from the company M/s Pravesh Credit and securities Ltd. and the same were transferred to the assessee. (Page No. 54 of the AO Order) CIT(A)— No adverse comments have been pointed out (Pg 258 of CIT(A) order)i. The "source of source" theory is wholly inapplicable; in absence of any incriminating material, the allegation of accommodation entries is purely speculative and legally unsustainable. ii. Without prejudice, the lender, M/s Parvesh Credit & Securities Ltd., advanced the loan from ordinary business funds (trade receivables), fully corroborated by bank statements, conclusively establishing the genuineness and creditworthiness of the transaction. Refer Page No. 112-113 of PB.
Ultimate sourceDate of ReceiptAmount (₹)Date of advanceAmount
PRAVESH CREDIT AND SECURITIES LIMITED (DEBTOR OF LENDER COMPANY)15.10.201950,00,00015.10.201950,00,000
3.AO— Absence of Fixed Assets(Page No. 54 of the AO Order) CIT(A)— No adverse comments have been pointed out (Pg 258 of CIT(A) order)The AO's allegation is incorrect; as an RBI-registered NBFC with no manufacturing activity, ownership of fixed assets is neither required nor relevant for evaluating it's creditworthiness.
4.AO—Lack of Commercial Expediency – The company did not explain the commercial rationale for advancing the loan in response to the notice under section 133(6). (Page No. 54 of the AO Order) CIT(A)— No adverse comments have been pointed out (Pg 258 of CIT(A) order)It is respectfully submitted that the AO's observation regarding the commercial expediency of the loan is misconceived. The commercial expediency is fully evident as the lender is a duly registered NBFC, and advancing funds to earn interest is a legitimate business activity for such an entity. That commercial expediency is also proved from ICD agreement submitted by the appellant. Ref Pg no.129-135 of PB)
5.AO—Unverifiable Creditworthiness – The lender's creditworthiness and the genuineness of the transaction cannot be verified. (Page No. 54 of the AO Order) CIT(A)— Majority of Funds Reflected as Share Capital Including Share Premium Identical Observations of CIT(A) for AYs 2021-22 and 2022-23(Pg 258 of CIT(A) order)Erroneous Addition Without Assessing Creditworthiness That the CIT(A) erred in making the addition without commenting anything adversely on the creditworthiness. Moreover, the assertion of the CIT(A) for share capital and share premium cannot be taken as base for questioning the creditworthiness. Moreover, creditworthiness is explained in above paras.
6.AO—Agreement not notarized nor witnessed, rendering it non-credible. (AY 2022-23) (Page No. 64 of the AO Order) CIT(A)— No adverse comments have been pointed out (AY 2022-23)(Pg 131 of CIT(A) order)The loan agreement, duly executed on non-judicial stamp paper and signed by both parties, cannot be invalidated merely for absence of witness signature, especially when the transaction is fully substantiated by surrounding circumstances. (Ref. Pg. no. 977-986 of PB).
Supriya Fincom Pvt. Ltd. Addition sustained by CIT(A)
Allegations of AO/CIT(A) for AY 2020-21Rebuttal to Allegations :- That the submissions filed for A.Y. 2020-21 may kindly be read and considered mutatis mutandis for A.Ys. 2021-22 and 2022-23, as the facts, issues involved, and grounds raised are identical/similar in nature.
1. AO— Registered Address – The registered address of the company is identical to that of Pravesh Credit and Securities Ltd. (Ref Pg no. 91 of AO Order). CIT(A)— No adverse comments have been pointed out (Pg 269-270 of CIT(A) order)Observation Regarding Company Addresses – Factually Incorrect It is respectfully submitted that the observation that the addresses of the two companies are the same is incorrect. As per the MCA portal, the registered addresses are distinct: Supriya Fincom Private Limited – 133, Canning Street, 3rd Floor, Kolkata – 700001 (PB, pg no. 495); Pravesh Credit and Securities Limited – 33/A, N.S. Road, Marshall House, 6th Floor, Room No. 647, Kolkata G.P.O., Kolkata – 700001 (Refer Page No. 102 of PB).
2. AO— Bank Statement Indicative of Entry Operator – Bank statements show funds received from unverifiable sources just before transfer to the assessee, with low opening and closing balances(Refer Pg No. 91-92 of AO Order)Source of Source explained The AO's allegation is misconceived, as the bank statements clearly establish the ultimate source of funds, which the appellant has duly substantiated as under. Refer Page No. 458-459 of PB.
CIT(A)--- No adverse comments have been pointed out (Pg 269-270 of CIT(A) order)Ultimate SourceAmount (Rs.)Remarks
Beaulah Enterprises Pvt. Ltd.2,00,00,000Lender received Rs. 50 lakhs in four tranches on 02.04.2019
Uflex Ltd.1,50,00,000Lender received from repayment by Uflex Ltd. of Rs. 2 crores dated 14.10.2019
3. AO--- Negligible Fixed Assets(Refer Pg No.92 of AO Order) CIT(A)--- Addition Made on Ground of Lack of Fixed Assets and Alleged Entry Operations Identical Observations of CIT(A) for AYs 2021-22 and 2022-23(Pg 269-270 of CIT(A) order)Absence or minimal fixed assets is immaterial to the creditworthiness of an NBFC, which advances loans from its liquid financial assets and not fixed assets.Refer Page No. 455 of PB.
4. AO---Disproportionate Income - Total declared income is disproportionate to the funds transferred to the assessee.(Pg 92 of AO order) CIT(A)--- No adverse comments have been pointed out (Pg 269-270 of CIT(A) order)The lender's declared income is not determinative of creditworthiness, which must be assessed on the basis of overall financial strength, net worth. Even otherwise company has filed the ITR at ₹ 18,81,330(MAT) (for AY 2020-21).Refer Page No. of 462 of PB.
5. AO---Defective Agreement - The loan agreement was neither notarized nor witnessed, rendering it non-credible.(Pg 92 of AO order) CIT(A)--- No adverse comments have been pointed out (Pg 269-270 of CIT(A) order)The loan agreement, duly executed on non-judicial stamp paper and signed by both parties, cannot be invalidated merely for absence of witness signature, especially when the transaction is fully substantiated by surrounding circumstances.Refer Page No. 479-481 of PB.
6. AO ---Admission by Director - Director Sanjay Kumar Singhi admitted post-survey to engaging in accommodation entry business through his companies.(Pg 92 of AO order) CIT(A)--- That CIT(A) at Page No. 269-270 for AY 2020-21 has relied upon the statement of Sanjay Kumar Singhi to confirm the addition. Identical Observations of CIT(A) for AYs 2021-22 and 2022-23.(Pg 269-270 of CIT(A) order)1. No Reference to Supriya Fincom Private Limited in Survey Statement It is respectfully submitted that a perusal of the entities listed in the sworn statemen of Sanjay Kumar Singhi It is noticed there is no reference of lender "Supriya Fincom Private Limited." 2. Survey Statement and Incriminating Material - No Evidentiary Value It is respectfully submitted that the AO relied upon the statement recorded during survey u/s 133A dated 28.06.2022 to impugn the genuineness of the loan. The CIT(A)
erred in failing to appreciate that such statements carry no evidentiary value and that no incriminating material was found either during the search of the appellant or in the survey of Shri Sandeep Kumar Singhi's office. 3. Loans Fully Repaid Prior to Survey – No Addition Warranted It is respectfully submitted that the CIT(A) failed to appreciate that the loans for the respective years were fully repaid on 28.09.2020, 31.03.2021, and 18.10.2022, i.e., well before the survey conducted on 28.06.2022.
7.AO—Lack of Commercial Expediency – The company did not explain the commercial rationale for advancing the loan in response to the notice under section 133(6).(Pg 93 of AO order) CIT(A)— No adverse comments have been pointed out (Pg 269-270 of CIT(A) order)It is respectfully submitted that the AO's observation regarding the commercial expediency of the loan is misconceived. The commercial expediency is fully evident as the lender is a duly registered NBFC, and advancing funds to earn interest is a legitimate business activity for such an entity. That commercial expediency is also proved from ICD agreement submitted by the appellant. (Ref Pag no.479-494 of PB)
8.AO—Unverifiable Creditworthiness – The lender's creditworthiness and the genuineness of the transaction cannot be verified.(Pg 93 of AO order) CIT(A)— Majority of Funds Reflected as Share Capital Including Share Premium Identical Observations of CIT(A) for AYs 2021-22 and 2022-23.(Pg 269-270 of CIT(A) order)Erroneous Addition Without Assessing Creditworthiness That the CIT(A) erred in making the addition without commenting anything adversely on the creditworthiness. Moreover, the assertion of the CIT(A) for share capital and share premium cannot be taken as base for questioning the creditworthiness. Moreover, creditworthiness is explained in above paras.
Rebuttal to CIT (A) allegation confirming the additions on the common allegation that the financials of the lender do not inspire confidence regarding the credibility of the said entity. That no other defects were pointed out.
S.No.Name of lenderPg no. of CIT(A) orderAppellant's remarksJudicial pronouncements :- Creditworthiness Cannot Be Disputed Merely on the Basis of Minuscule Income
AY 20-21AY 21-22AY 22-23
1.Bangbhumi Traders Pvt. Ltd.260-261NANAa) Erroneous Doubt on Creditworthiness - The Ld. CIT(A) erred in doubting the lender's creditworthiness based solely on vague assertions that the financials "do not inspire confidence," despite complete documentary evidence including PAN, ITRs, audited accounts, confirmations, and bank statements, discharging the onus under section 68 (Ref. Table A &C). b) Loans Fully Repaid - The CIT(A) failed to note that the loans were fully repaid (Ref. Table E). c) No Material During Search - No material was unearthed during the search of the appellant that could suggest the unsecured loan was an accommodation or bogus. d) Confirmation Under Section 133(6) - All lenders duly responded to the AO's notice under section 133(6), which the CIT(A) failed to appreciate.(Ref. Table G). e) Acceptance in Previous Years - The lenders referred to at S.No. 2,4,5,6were accepted as genuine in earlier assessment years. The summary of the same is as under:-i. B & B Sharecom (P.) Ltd. vs. DCIT [2025] 178 taxmann.com 678 (Refer page no. 1-9 of the case law PB). ii. CIT, Meerut vs. Miq Steels (P.) Ltd. [2013] 36 taxmann.com 422 (Refer page no. 10-11 of the case law PB). iii. CIT-IV vs. Dwarkadhish Investment (P.) Ltd. [2010] 194 Taxman 43 (Refer page no. 12-18 of the case law PB). iv. M/s. Hindon Forge (P.) Ltd. vs. DCIT, Ghaziabad [2020] 87 ITR (Trib) 258 (Refer page no. 19-25 of the case law PB). v. M/s. Thirubala Chemicals Pvt. Ltd. vs. ITO, New Delhi [2020] 10 TMI 405 (Refer page no. 26-34 of the case law PB). vi. ACIT vs. Supreme Placement Services (P.) Ltd., New Delhi [2021] 3 TMI 720 - ITAT Delhi (Refer page no. 35-48 of the case law PB). vii. Garima Polymers (P.) Ltd. vs. ACIT [2021] 86 ITR(T) 261 (Refer page no. 49-53 of the case law PB). viii. Vishnu Jaiswal vs. CIT(Appeals),
2.Carrillion VP Estates Pvt. Ltd.261NANA
3.First Agri-Tech Pvt. Ltd.261-262NA136-137
4.Hapline Commodities Pvt. Ltd.263NANA
5.Manali Tradecom Pvt. Ltd.265NANA
6.Mayur India Private Limited265NANA
7.Premanarayan Mercantile Pvt. Ltd.268NA136
8.Target Vincom Pvt. Ltd.270NANA
Name of LenderFYAmount of loanPage No. of PB
Carrillion VP5-1690,00,000616(Ledger) 562-567(AD Order)
Estates Pvt. Ltd.16-171,00,00,000617(Ledger)568-600(AD Order)
Mayur India Pvt. Ltd.16-171,00,00,000618(Ledger) 568-600(AD Order)
Hapline Commodities Pvt Ltd18-1975,00,000281(Ledger) No Adverse Findings under Section 148A in AY 2019-20
Manali Tradecom Pvt Ltd18-1975,00,000324(Ledger) No Adverse Findings under Section 148A in AY 2019-20
f)

Low Income Not Determinative – It is settled law that nominal income or operational revenue alone cannot impugn creditworthiness when sufficient evidence of capital, funds, and banking transactions exists; creditworthiness must be assessed holistically.

x.

Rohit Kumar Jindal (HUF) vs. ITO, Chandigarh [2020] 208 TTJ (Chd) 764 (Refer page no. 471-491 of the case law PB). xi. Naveen Infradevelopers & Engineers (P.) Ltd. vs. DCIT, Delhi [2021] 213 TTJ (Del) 344 (Refer page no. 492-506 of the case law PB). xii. Psychotropics Leasing & Finance (P.) Ltd. vs. ITO, Delhi [2018] 196 TTJ (Del) 877 (Refer page no. 507-525 of the case law PB). xiii. Anjani Associates vs. ITO, Raipur [2019] 197 TTJ (Raipur) 44 (Refer page no. 526-536 of the case law PB).

5.7. Judicial pronouncements

Consistency:The assessments for the respective years i.e. from FY 2015-16 to FY 2017-18 were completed after due scrutiny, wherein the issue of unsecured loans was examined by the Department, and the same stood accepted without any qualification or reservation.Statement recorded during survey carries no evidentiary value
i. Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax vs. Ace Infracity Developers (P.) Ltd. [2025] 181 taxmann.com 63 (Delhi - Trib.)[28-11-2025] ii. RadhasoamiSatsang v. CIT [1992] 193 ITR 321 (SC) iii. Principal Commissioner of Income-tax (Central) vs. MBL Infrastructure Ltd. [2023] 155 taxmann.com 657 (SC)/[2023] 295 Taxman 586 (SC)/[2024] 461 ITR 150 (SC)[27-09-2023] iv. Commissioner of Income-tax, Exemptions vs. Swami OmkaranandaSaraswati Charitable Trust [2023] 150 taxmann.com 428 (Allahabad)/[2023] 453 ITR 245 (Allahabad)[15-03-2023] v. Friends Clearing Agency (P.) Ltd. vs. Commissioner of Income-tax-II [2011] 9 taxmann.com 238 (Delhi)/[2011] 199 Taxman 265 (Delhi) (Mag.)/[2011] 332 ITR 269 (Delhi)/[2011] 237 CTR 464 (Delhi)[04-301-2011] vi. Commissioner of Income-tax vs. Dewan Steels Ltd. [2007] 165 Taxman 526 (Delhi)/[2009] 311 ITR 161 (Delhi)[13-07-2007] vii. Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax vs. Bombay Footwear (P.) Ltd. [2025] 170 taxmann.com 298 (Mumbai - Trib.)[12-12-2024] viii. Birlasoft Ltd. vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax [2025] 173 taxmann.com 634 (Delhi - Trib.)[16-04-2025]i. CIT vs. S. Khader Khan Son [2013] 6 TMI 305 (SC) / [2013] 352 ITR 480 (Refer page no. 86-87 of the case law PB). ii. M/s. Kalpana Biri Mfg. Co. Pvt. Ltd. vs. ACIT, Circle, Berhampur [2017] 12 TMI 988 (Kolkata - ITAT) (Refer page no. 88-104 of the case law PB). iii. MNP Turnmatics C/o Devinder Proothi vs. ITO, Ward-2, Rohtak [2020] 1 TMI 1021 (Delhi - ITAT) (Refer page no. 105-109 of the case law PB). iv. ACIT vs. M/s. Legend Developers & Constructions, Kurnool [2021] 7 TMI 11 (Hyderabad - ITAT) (Refer page no. 110-125 of the case law PB). v. Shri Shriram Toshniwal vs. ACIT, Khandwa [2019] 6 TMI 652 (Indore - ITAT) (Refer page no. 126-142 of the case law PB). vi. Jigarkumar Navinchandra Soni vs. ACIT, Circle-5(2), Ahmedabad [2018] 10 TMI 1024 (Ahmedabad - ITAT) (Refer page no. 143-159 of the case law PB). vii. Shri K. Somasekhar vs. DCIT, Central Circle-1(1), Bangalore [2019] 10 TMI 903 (Bangalore - ITAT) (Refer page no. 160-168 of the case law PB). viii. DCIT, Circle-2(3), Surat vs. M/s. Shhlok Enterprise [2021] 1 TMI 676 (Surat - ITAT) (Refer page no. 169-180 of the case law PB).
33.

Ld.AR stated that the assessee has discharged the burden casted upon it of proving the identity and creditworthiness of the lenders and further established the genuineness of transactions and therefore, in absence of any incriminating material found / seized as a result of search from the business premises of the assessee company or during the course of survey carried out at the business premises of some of the lenders companies which established the loans taken by the assessee was not genuine, no additions could be made u/s 68 of the Act. Ld. AR further submits that since all the loans were repaid and therefore, the main allegation of the revenue that they are the accommodation entries itself demolished considering the fact that if assessee had taken accommodation entries, there was no reason to repay the same within the year itself or in subsequent years. The accommodation entries are in the nature of the credits which have been taken by providing cash of the same amount to the respective lenders with the understanding that such entry would not be squared off or returned or even if it has to be squared off, the same will happen after an long period and not within few months or short period of one year. Therefore, the ld. AR submits that all the unsecured loans taken by the assessee are genuine loans and the additions made by AO without providing an opportunity to cross-examine the directors whose statements were relied upon by the AO for treating the loans as accommodation entries and further without providing their complete statements and the material based on which lower authorities have reached to the conclusion that the loans of accommodation entries could not be utilized against the assessee. Ld.AR submits that an opportunity of cross-examination of such witnesses of the revenue should be allowed to the assessee which has not been allowed by the AO despite of the fact that the assessee has filed complete details. Further, in the statements relied upon of Shri Sandeep Singh in respect to the loans taken from M/s. Radha Fincom Ltd. and Parvesh Credit and Securities Ltd., Shri Sandeep Singhi clearly stated that he was not the Director of the said company during the period when the loans were taken by the assessee and therefore, such statements has no relevance and cannot be relied upon. Ld. AR further submits that in case where the AO observed that notice was issued u/s 133(6) of the Act and was returned unserved however, all the relevant details of such parties were duly filed containing bank statements, financial statements etc. to establish their present whereabouts. However, without making any further inquiries solely based on the fact that notices issued u/s 133(6) of the Act were returned unserved, the AO alleged that these parties were not in existence and the loans taken by the assessee are mere accommodation entries and made the addition. Under these circumstances, ld.AR humbly prayed that the entire addition made by the AO and sustained by ld. CIT(A) be deleted.

34.

On the other hand, ld. CIT DR for the Revenue vehemently supported the orders of the lower authorities and submits that the AO has made every possible inquiry in order to examine the genuineness of the transactions and creditworthiness of the lenders. He placed reliance on the chart given by the AO at pages 53 to 101 of the assessment order wherein AO discussed each and every loan creditor and further referred the outcome of the inquiries conducted by issuing summons u/s 133(6) of the Act or by examining their financial statements stated to have been filed by the assessee. Ld. CIT DR for the Revenue drew our attention to the observations of AO wherein AO stated that he has not only examined their financials and further observed that they do not have the capacity to advance loan or there was no commercial expediency in advancements of loans to the assessee company. Ld. CIT DR further submits that the assessee argued that loans were repaid however, for the purpose of examination of loans u/s 68 of the Act what is to be seen is the creditworthiness of the lender at the time of granting loan and nothing to do with the repayment of the loan. Nowhere in the Act, it is provided that if the loan taken is repaid, no addition could be made u/s 68 of the Act. He therefore, prayed that the additions made by AO, be restored. With respect to the deletion made by ld. CIT(A), he supported the orders of AO and submits that ld. CIT(A) has wrongly deleted the additions by placing reliance on the material which has already examined by the AO for holding the said loan creditor as accommodation entries. He, therefore, requested that the addition to such extent be confirmed.

35.

On merits of the additions, ld.AR submits that during the course of assessment proceedings as well as appellate proceedings, assessee has duly established the fact that all the loans taken were duly supported by the loan agreements, identity and creditworthiness of the lenders and genuineness of the transactions was fully established as provided u/s 68 of the Act. In support, the ld. AR drew our attention of the chart submitted in the written submissions filed containing details of documents filed and the inquiries conducted by the AO and the replies filed. Ld.AR submits that in order to establish the identity of the creditors, assessee has filed the NBFCs registration (wherever applicable), copy of the MCA records, loan agreements alongwith promissory notes and post-dated cheques, form 16A issued and GST registration (wherever application). All these documents were filed before the lower authorities and are placed in the Paper Books filed before us. Regarding the genuineness of the transactions and creditworthiness of the lenders, ld. AR drew our attention to the chart given in page 6 & 7 of the written submissions containing the financials of each and every lender company and further referred their bank statements, ITRs so as to establish that the funds were available in their bank accounts when the funds were transferred to the assessee company and all the lenders had sufficient net worth to advance the loans to the assessee company. It is further submitted that the loans were raised through banking channel therefore, genuineness cannot be doubted. Ld.AR submits that loans were repaid in the year under appeal or during subsequent period and necessary details have already been filed with respect to such repayment and therefore, no addition should be made by holding that the loans has taken accommodation entries of unsecured loans.

36.

Heard the contentions of both the parties at length and perused the material on record. The facts leading to this issue as described by ld. CIT(A) in its order are as under:-

4.

“As per the AO, the assessment proceedings for Assessment Year 2020-21 were completed under section 143(3) read with section 144C(3) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, since the assessee did not file any objections before the Dispute Resolution Panel against the Draft Assessment Order dated 26.03.2024, and therefore the draft order became final and binding under the provisions of law. The AO stated that the case of the assessee was initially selected for scrutiny through Computer Assisted Scrutiny Selection (CASS) on account of transfer pricing risk parameters, and accordingly a reference was made to the Transfer Pricing Officer under section 92CA of the Act, whose findings were taken on record during the assessment proceedings. The AO mentioned that subsequently a search and seizure operation under section 132(1) of the Act was conducted on 21.02.2023 in the cases of Uflex Group concerns, including the assessee company, during which, as per AO, several incriminating materials, statements and evidences were gathered.

As per the AO, the assessee had filed its return of income declaring total income of 101.55 crore, which included business income and income from other sources, after claiming deductions under Chapter VIA, including a deduction under section 80-1B (Jammu Unit), and the correctness of these claims was examined in the light of search findings and post-search investigations.

The AO stated that during the search and post-search enquiries, it was noticed that the assessee had accepted unsecured loans amounting to 74 crore from as many as 38 entities, most of which were based in Kolkata, and these entities were prima facie found to be paper companies having no real business activities or financial strength.

The AO mentioned that it was revealed that the lender companies did not have adequate income, assets, employees, or genuine business operations, and their financial statements mainly reflected paper transactions such as interest income or routing of funds, thereby raising serious doubts about their creditworthiness.

As per the AO, as per page no. 33 of the assessment order, notices under section 142(1) were issued to the assessee calling for complete details regarding the unsecured loans, including loan agreements, bank statements, income-tax returns of lenders, purpose of loans and evidence of business expediency, however the assessee failed to furnish complete and satisfactory replies despite being granted multiple opportunities.

The AO stated that independent third-party enquiries were also conducted by issuing notices under section 133(6) of the Act to the lender entities, seeking confirmation of transactions, financial details, bank statements and proof of business activities, but in many cases, as per AO, either no replies were received or the replies were incomplete and non-substantive.

The AO mentioned that several notices sent to the lenders were returned unserved by the postal authorities with remarks such as "no such company", "address not found" or "left without instructions", which clearly established that these entities were non-existent at their registered addresses and were merely paper companies.

As per the AO, statements recorded under oath during other search and survey proceedings of entry operators such as Shri Ashish Begwani, Shri Vikas Kumar Agrawal, Shri Ramesh Poddar and Shri Sandeep Kumar Singhi show that they were engaged in the business of providing accommodation entries in the form of bogus unsecured loans in exchange for cash and commission.

The AO stated that these entry operators specifically admitted that funds routed through shell companies were used to provide unsecured loans to beneficiaries, including group concerns of the assessee, and that the so-called loans were nothing but a method to convert unaccounted cash into accounted money.

The AO mentioned that it was further established that certain lender entities such as Radha Fincom Limited and Pravesh Credit and Securities Limited were directly controlled by entry operators who had confessed to providing accommodation entries, and therefore the loans received from such entities were clearly bogus.

As per the AO, the assessee was confronted with the findings gathered during investigation through show cause notices, but the replies filed by the assessee were found to be general in nature, unsupported by credible documentary evidence, and failed to rebut the strong material brought on record by the department.

The AO stated that the assessee could not establish the three essential ingredients required under section 68 of the Act, namely the identity of the creditors, their creditworthiness, and the genuineness of the transactions, and merely filing basic documents without proving the real source of funds was held to be insufficient.

The AO mentioned that the conduct of the assessee in accepting large unsecured loans from dubious Kolkata-based entities, despite being a reputed and financially strong company capable of obtaining finance from recognized institutions, further strengthened the inference that the transactions were not genuine.

As per the AO, considering the totality of facts, including search findings, sworn statements of entry operators, failure of lenders to respond, non-existence of companies at registered addresses, and inadequate explanations offered by the assessee, the unsecured loans amounting to Rs. 34.75 crores received during the year were treated as unexplained cash credits under section 68 of the Act and were added to the income of the assessee. Further, as per AO, as usual practice, a commission @1-2% was paid on booking these accommodation entries in the form of unsecured loans. Therefore, as per AO, the expenses incurred by the assessee to make commission payment was estimated @2% which amounts to Rs. 69.50 lacs which were covered within the ambit of Section 69C of the Act as unexplained expenses and also added the same to the total income of the assessee.”

37.

Before going further, we first refer to the provision of section 68 of the Act.

Cash credits.

68.

Where any sum is found credited in the books of an assessee maintained for any previous year, and the assessee offers no explanation about the nature and source thereof or the explanation offered by him is not, in the opinion of the Assessing Officer, satisfactory, the sum so credited may be charged to income-tax as the income of the assessee of that previous year :

Provided that where the sum so credited consists of loan or borrowing or any such amount, by whatever name called, any explanation offered by such assessee shall be deemed to be not satisfactory, unless,—

(a)

the person in whose name such credit is recorded in the books of such assessee also offers an explanation about the nature and source of such sum so credited; and

(b)

such explanation in the opinion of the Assessing Officer aforesaid has been found to be satisfactory:

Provided further that where the assessee is a company (not being a company in which the public are substantially interested), and the sum so credited consists of share application money, share capital, share premium or any such amount by whatever name called, any explanation offered by such assessee-company shall be deemed to be not satisfactory, unless—

(a)

the person, being a resident in whose name such credit is recorded in the books of such company also offers an explanation about the nature and source of such sum so credited; and

(b)

such explanation in the opinion of the Assessing Officer aforesaid has been found to be satisfactory:

Provided also that nothing contained in the first proviso or second proviso shall apply if the person, in whose name the sum referred to therein is recorded, is a venture capital fund or a venture capital company as referred to in clause (23FB) of section 10.”

38.

A bare reading of Section 68 suggests that there has to be credit of amounts in the books maintained by an assessee; such credit has to be of a sum during the previous year; and the assessee offer no explanation about the nature and source of such credit found in the books; or the explanation offered by the assessee in the opinion of the Assessing Officer is not satisfactory, it is only then the sum so credited may be charged to income-tax as the income of the assessee of that previous year. The expression "the assessee offer no explanation" means where the assessee offer no proper, reasonable and acceptable explanation as regards the sums found credited in the books maintained by the assessee. It is true that the opinion of the Assessing Officer for not accepting the explanation offered by the assessee as not satisfactory is required to be based on proper appreciation of material and other attending circumstances available on record. The opinion of the Assessing Officer is required to be formed objectively with reference to the material available on record. Application of mind is the sine qua non for forming the opinion.

39.

As observed above, the AO has verified treated the unsecured loans taken in AY 2020-21 from 27 companies/lenders totaling to INR 34.75 crores out of which addition of INR 15.50 crores was sustained by ld. CIT(A) and balance was deleted. The claim of the assessee was that all the documentary evidences establishing the identity and the creditworthiness of the lenders and genuineness of the transactions were filed before the lower authorities. The lender companies are either the NBFCs having valid RBI license or are the corporate entities for which their MCA data were submitted alongwith their PAN, ITRs, Certificate of incorporation and audited financial statements. All the loans were received through banking channels and the lender companies have sufficient funds in their accounts as and when funds were transferred to the assessee which is evident from their bank accounts filed. It is further stated that the interest paid on such loan have not been doubted and the same was allowed as regular business expenditure. The assessee further claimed that in case of M/s Radha Fincom Ltd. and M/s Parvesh Credit and Securities Ltd., the AO placed heavy reliance on the statements of one Shri Sandeep Singhi who was Director of these companies in 2016 and not in the year under appeal and therefore, his statements cannot be made sole basis to hold that the loans taken from these two companies were accommodation entry. Moreover, no opportunity was provided to the assessee to cross-examine Shri Sandeep Singhi though he was the witness of the department and as stated above, his statements were made the basis for holding the loans taken from M/s Radha Fincom Ltd. and M/s Parvesh Credit and Securities Ltd. as accommodation entry. It was further claimed by the assessee that the notice issued u/s 133(6) of the Act were duly complied with by many of the lender companies. Once the transactions were carried out through banking channel and all the plausible evidences were filed thus, without bringing on record the contrary material nor linking the loans taken with the incriminating material, if any, found and seized during the course of search, it cannot be said that the lenders were not in existence or loan taken from them are mere accommodation entries.

40.

With respect to the commercial expediency, claim of the assessee is that for the purpose of section 68 of the Act, three basic conditions are to be satisfied i.e. identity, creditworthiness and genuineness of the transactions and it has nothing with do with the commercial expediency. It is the assessee who has to decide as to when and how much funds are required for smooth running of business and therefore, Revenue cannot direct any assessee to borrow funds irrespective of the requirements of business or otherwise.

41.

With this background, we proceed to first consider those lenders, loans taken from whom were treated as accommodation entries and additions made by the AO were sustained by ld. CIT(A) in all the three assessment years.

M/s. Radha Fincom Ltd. and Parvesh Credit and Securities Ltd.

42.

The allegations of the AO were that this company has no fixed assets and address given is not matched with the registered office address. The reply filed in response to notice issued u/s 133(6) of the Act, the commercial expediency for advancement of the loan to the assessee was not explained and the loan agreement submitted was neither notarized nor having signature of witnesses. Further its Director, Shri Sanjay Singhi in the statements recorded during post survey proceedings admitted that this company was involved in providing accommodation entries. Therefore, AO was of the opinion that neither the creditworthiness of the lender is proved nor genuineness of the transactions is found verifiable. Ld. CIT(A) confirmed the addition by observing that though the company is having share capital and Reserves of INR 90.00 crores and having profits of INR 20.00 Lakhs on the gross revenue of INR 83.35 crores however, it appears that its entire funds are in the shape of premium and further when its Director had admitted the fact that the company was involved in providing accommodation entries therefore, he confirmed the additions of INR 4.00 crores towards loan taken from the said company. Similarly, in the case of M/s. Radha Fincom Limited from whom loan of INR 1.00 crores was received, the addition was sustained by making similar observations by the ld. CIT(A).

43.

It is observed that to prove the identity of both the companies, assessee has filed their ITRs & NBFC registration Certificate issued by RBI which are placed at pages 55 to 57, 63, 115, 107 to 109 of the Paper Book. Further, both the lender companies had filed replies in response to notice issued u/s 133(6) of the Act. The assessee also filed copy of the MCA records, loans Agreements and Form No.16A for both the companies. From the perusal of the financial statements, it is observed that M/s. Parvesh Credit & Securities Ltd. has Share Capital including Reserves and Surplus of INR 91.97 crores and having total turnover of INR 8.39 crores and not of INR 83.85 crores as observed by ld. CIT(A). The assessee has further demonstrated from the copy of their bank statements that sufficient funds were available with them to advance loans to the assessee. It is further observed that loans taken were repaid in subsequent Assessment years and the date of repayment were incidentally be fallen much prior to the date of survey in their own cases and search in the case of the assessee. Further, confirmations were filed and reliance was placed solely on the statements of Director, Shri Sandeep Singhi that the company was engaged in providing accommodation entries. The assessee filed the necessary evidences placed at page 102 to 104 in support of the claim that Shri Sanjay Singhi was ceased to hold the office of the Director w.e.f. 16.11.2016 whereas the loans were received from both the lender companies in FY 2019-20 i.e. after the expiry of 03 years from the date of cessation of Shri Sandeep Singhi from the post of Director. It is further observed that despite of the repeated requests, no opportunity for cross-examination was provided to the assessee nor complete statements of Shri Sandeep Singhi were supplied to the assessee company.

44.

When the source was proved of loans received from both the companies, and once the assessee has discharged the burden casted upon it of proving the identity, creditworthiness of the lenders by filing their assessment particulars, MCA data etc. and their financial statements were filed, it cannot be held that the loans taken were not genuine. Moreover, it is also a matter of fact that loans were repaid before the survey carried out in their cases by the Department. The statements relied upon was of the persons who was having no authority to make any comment on behalf of the lender companies as he was not connected in any manner when the funds were advanced to the assessee thus such statements cannot be relied upon, more particularly, as observed above, when such statements have not been supplied to the assessee nor any opportunity to cross-examine was allowed though the person was the witnesses of the department and such statements were made the sole basis for alleging the loans taken as accommodation entries. Considering the entirety of the facts and further keeping in mind that loans have been repaid, we find no reason to hold the loans taken as accommodation entries, in absence of any contrary material, accordingly, the addition made towards the loans taken from these two companies are deleted.

45.

The Ld. CIT(A) has further sustained the loans taken form the following lender companies:

Name of Lender CompanyAmount (INR)
Bangbhumi Traders Pvt. Ltd.1,00,00,000
Carrillion VP Estates Pvt. Ltd.1,00,00,000
First Agri-Tech Pvt. Ltd.1,00,00,000
Hapline Commodities Pvt. Ltd.1,50,00,000
Manali Tradecom Pvt.Ltd.50,00,000
Mayur India Pvt. Ltd.50,00,000
Premanarayan Mercantile Pvt. Ltd.1,00,00,000
Supriya Fincom Pvt. Ltd.3,50,00,000
Target Vincom Pvt. Ltd.50,00,000
46.

With respect to all these companies, assessee has filed every plausible evidence / details to establish the identity comprising of its ITRs, MCA records, loans Agreements, Form No.16A, to prove the genuineness of the transactions, bank statements of the assessee as well as of the lender companies and to establish the creditworthiness, their financial records were submitted. All these evidences so filed are placed in Paper Book and is tabulated by the assessee in its written submissions which is reproduced herein above.

47.

Further from the perusal of Table (c) reproduced herein above, it is observed that all the companies having sufficient net worth to advance the loans to the assessee and most of the companies have filed replies in response to the notices issued u/s 133(6) of the Act. It is further observed that in none of the case, contrary statements of any person were available nor their names were ever appearing in the so-called statements of any of the entry operators available with the department. It is also a matter of fact that the loans taken have been repaid prior to the commencement of search in the case of the assessee. The additions were sustained by ld. CIT(A) for the reason that the commercial expediency has not been established. As observed above, as per section 68 of the Act, assessee has to prove the identity and creditworthiness of the lenders and genuineness of the transactions. Section 68 of the Act does not cast any burden upon the assessee to prove the commercial expediency of loan transaction. It is settled law that the commercial expediency has to be judged by the parties to the transactions and the AO cannot walk into the shoe of businessman to examine the commercial expediency of loan transactions. It rests upon the lender entity to examine the purpose for which the funds were utilized so as to ensure that loan funds would be applied in the manner, it remained safe and be repaid as per agreed terms.

48.

It is also relevant to state that the “source of source” could not be questioned in the instant year as the amendment was made in section 68 enabling the AO to examine the “source of source” of the unsecured loan w.e.f. 01.04.2022 and applicable from AY 2023-24 and onwards.

49.

Once the assessee has successfully discharged the burden casted upon it of proving the identity and creditworthiness of lender parties by filing their all relevant details and the allegations made by the AO were rebutted, the loans taken in the regular course of business duly supported by the necessary loan agreements and were repaid cannot be doubted. It is also observed that the AO has already allowed the interest paid on such loans as genuine. Under these circumstances we find no error in the order of ld. CIT(A) in deleting the additions made towards the loans taken from these companies.

50.

Now coming to the Revenue’s appeal for deletion of the additions of INR 19.75 crores made out of the unsecured loans taken from following companies made by the AO by holding that the assessee has failed to establish the creditworthiness of the lenders and genuineness of transactions and further has not proved the Commercial expediency however, the same were deleted by ld. CIT(A). These companies are tabulated as under:-

Name of Lender CompanyAmount (INR)
Pioneer Iron & Steel Corporation Ltd.50,00,000
Shree Sudarshan Casting Pvt. Ltd.1,00,00,000
Anjula Steels Pvt. Ltd.1,00,00,000
APM Finvest Ltd.7,00,00,000
Greencresh Financial Services Ltd.1,00,00,000
GSR Tradefin Pvt. Ltd.75,00,000
Kamalpur Finance Ltd.50,00,000
Maharaj Ji Agro Products Pvt. Ltd.2,75,00,000
Neelam Securities Marketing Pvt. Ltd.50,00,000
Paritosh Electricals Pvt. Ltd.25,00,000
Perfect Business Advisory Services Pvt. Ltd.1,00,00,000
Prachur Traders Pvt. Ltd.50,00,000
Ricon Traders Pvt. Ltd.50,00,000
Shyamnagar Packaging Works Pvt. Ltd.1,00,00,000
Unity Merchandise Pvt. Ltd.50,00,000
Zigma Electricals Pvt. Ltd.50,00,000
51.

From the perusal of the order of ld. CIT(A), it is observed that ld. CIT(A) has deleted the additions appreciating the fact that these companies are not appearing in any of the statements of entry operator relied upon by the AO. Further, they all have submitted replies in response to the notices issued u/s 133(6) of the Act which are placed in the Paper Book. From the perusal of Table D reproduced herein above forming part of the written submission, it is observed that all these companies are having sufficient net worth to advance loans to the assessee which facts has been discussed elaborately by ld. CIT(A). All these companies are having regular business activities and positive income was declared in their ITRs filed. The loans were repaid during the year or in subsequent AYs but prior to the survey/search carried out by the Revenue. It is further observed that no incriminating material was found and seize, suggesting any cash payment against the loans so taken. Once the assessee has discharged the burden casted upon it u/s 68 of the Act of proving the identity and creditworthiness of the lenders and genuineness of the transactions is also established, we find no infirmity in the order of ld. CIT(A). For the sake of convenience, the observations made by ld. CIT(A) while deleting the additions loans of INR 7.00 crores taken from these companies is reproduced herein below:-

“The submissions of the appellant reveals that the said entity is not named in any of the statements of the entry operators relied upon by the AO in the assessment order. The AO has also not made any specific allegation in his observations in the assessment order with respect to naming of the said company in the statements of the entry operators. The AO has made specific observations about receipt of reply to notice u/s 133(6) but has stated that the commercial expediency of the loan has not been explained. The AO has stated that there are rapid credits debits from the bank account of the lender company and there is some operational revenue of Rs. 1.69 crores. The AO has further stated that the ITR of the said entity has been filed at Rs. 1.77 crores. Moreover, the ITR, confirmation, bank account statement, loan agreement, audited balance sheet have been filed before the AO in support of the genuineness and creditworthiness of the transaction. Apart from this, the lender has share capital of Rs. 4.32 crores, the lender has reserves & surplus of Rs. 6.65 crores. Further, the lender has short term borrowings of Rs. 10.45 crores, non-current investment of Rs. 59.43 crores, revenue from operations of Rs. 1.69 crores and various expenses under different heads claimed in the profit & loss account. It is further seen that the said loan has already been repaid during the year under consideration. It is further observed that to establish the creditworthiness and genuineness of the transactions, it is imperative that the audited financials of the lender are properly examined and observations regarding low returned income/rapid credits & debits/ value of fixed assets cannot be the sole basis of disregarding the creditworthiness of the lender. In absence of any adverse evidence with respect to identity, credibility and genuineness of the said lender and detailed observations regarding the sound financials of the lender as already discussed above, the addition made by the AO is deleted.”

52.

Likewise in the case of Maharaj Ji Agro Products Pvt. Ltd. from whom unsecured loan of INR 2.75 crore was received, while deleting the addition, the ld. CIT(A) has made following observations:-

“The submissions of the appellant reveals that the said entity is not named in any of the statements of the entry operators relied upon by the AO in the assessment order. The AO has also not made any specific allegation in his observations in the assessment order with respect to naming of the said company in the statements of the entry operators. The AO has made specific observations about receipt of reply to notice u/s 133(6) but has stated that the commercial expediency of the loan has not been explained. The AO has further stated that notice u/s 133(6) could not be delivered to the said entity which is in-contradiction to the above observations of the AO at page 75 of the assessment order. The appellant has also submitted that the lender had filed reply in physical form in response to notice u/s 133(6) dated 26.02.2024. The copy of the reply has also been filed during the appeal proceedings. The AO has stated that the lender has shown income of Rs. 12.44 lacs. Moreover, the ITR, confirmation, bank account statement, loan agreement, audited balance sheet have been filed before the AO in support of the genuineness and creditworthiness of the transaction. Apart from this, the lender has shareholder's funds of Rs. 2.58 crores, long term liabilities of Rs. 1.88 crores, short term borrowings of Rs. 3.74 crores, outstanding creditors of Rs. 1.03 crores, tangible assets of Rs. 3 crores, inventories of Rs. 1.03 crores, trade receivables of Rs. 1.86 crores, revenue from operations exceeding Rs. 21 crores and various expenses under different heads claimed in the profit & loss account. It is further seen that the said loan has already been repaid in the near future. It is further observed that non-notarization of agreement cannot be considered as a condition which requires prior satisfaction of rigors of Section 68. It is further observed that to establish the creditworthiness and genuineness of the transactions, it is imperative that the audited financials of the lender are properly examined and observations regarding low returned income/rapid credits & debits/value of fixed assets cannot be the sole basis of disregarding the creditworthiness of the lender. In absence of any adverse evidence with respect to identity, credibility and genuineness of the said lender and detailed observations regarding the sound financials of the lender as already discussed above, the addition made by the AO is deleted.”

53.

Similarly in the case of Shree Sudarshan Castings Pvt Ltd. from whom loan of INR 1.00 crores was taken, ld. CIT(A) has made the following observations while deleting the additions:-

“The submissions of the appellant reveals that the said entity is not named in any of the statements of the entry operators relied upon by the AO in the assessment order. The AO has also not made any specific allegation in his observations in the assessment order with respect to naming of the said company in the statements of the entry operators. It is further observed that the appellant has submitted that reply to the notice u/s 133(6) was duly submitted on e-portal of the AO by the said lender and copy of the reply has also been submitted as filed before the AO. It is further seen that the AO in the assessment order on page 57 has stated that commercial expediency has not been explained by the company in its reply in response to notice u/s 133(6) and on the same page, the AO has stated that the notice issued u/s 133(6) was returned undelivered making the observations of the AO as self-contradictory. Further, the observation of the AO that the directors of the company did not file ITR for the year under consideration is inconsequential as the credibility of the lender entity is under question and not the directors of the said entity. The AO has stated that the said entity has declared Rs. 17.23 lacs as income and the fixed assets are of very meager value. Perusal of the financials of the said entity reveals that a sum of Rs. 1 crore has been received from the said concern. Moreover, the ITR, confirmation, bank account statement, loan agreement, audited balance sheet have been filed before the AO in support of the genuineness and creditworthiness of the transaction. Apart from this, the lender has share capital of Rs. 7.02 crores, the lender has reserves & surplus of Rs. 40.05 crores. Further, the lender has inventories of Rs. 7.56 crores and trade receivables amounting to Rs. 4.03 crores. The entity has revenue from operations of Rs. 6.73 crores, purchases of Rs. 3.53 crores and various expenses under different heads claimed in the profit & loss account. Moreover, the said entity has other current liabilities of Rs. 19.38 crores. It is further seen that the said loan has already been repaid during the year under consideration. It is further observed that to establish the creditworthiness and genuineness of the transactions, it is imperative that the audited financials of the lender are properly examined and observations regarding low returned income/rapid credits & debits/value of fixed assets cannot be the sole basis of disregarding the creditworthiness of the lender. In absence of any adverse evidence with respect to identity, credibility and genuineness of the said lender and detailed observations regarding the sound financials of the lender as already discussed above, the addition made by the AO is deleted.”

54.

After considering the entire discussion, as made herein above, the details filed by the assessee can be summarized as under:

A. To prove the Identity of the Lender companies: Assessee has filed the following documents  Copy of Permanent Account Number (PAN) of each lender company;  NBFC certificate of the lender companies wherever applicable;  Company Master Data as available on the Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA) portal.

 Copy of their PAN card and ITR acknowledgements  Copy of GST registration wherever available;

B. To prove the Genuineness of the Transactions, following documents were submitted:  Bank statements showing the receipt of loan amounts through normal banking channels;  Copies of the loan agreements and promissory notes wherever available;  Signed confirmations of account from each lender;  Details and evidence of repayments, where applicable;  Ledger accounts of lenders maintained in the books of the assessee;  Interest payment records with TDS deduction, including Form 26AS.

C. To prove the Creditworthiness of the Lender companies, following documents were filed:  Audited financial statements of all the lender companies for the relevant financial years;  Acknowledged copies of Income Tax Returns of the lender companies;  Bank statements reflecting adequate balances prior to the transfer of funds.

55.

By filing all the relevant details of the loan creditors before the AO as listed above, assessee has discharged the onus lies upon it. It is also a matter of fact that the AO has failed to point out any defects in the same and made general observations more particularly harped upon the justification for commercial expediency. Therefore, there is nothing left on the part of the assessee to prove further. It is also a matter of fact that in many cases notices issued u/s 133(6) of the Act were duly replied as could be seen from the chart reproduced herein above.

56.

Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in case of Commissioner of Income-tax v. Lovely Exports (P.) Ltd. reported in [2008] 216 CTR 195 (SC) held:

"2.

Can the amount of share money be regarded as undisclosed income under section 68 of IT Act, 1961?. We find no merit in this Special Leave Petition for the simple reason that if the share application money is received by the assessee company from alleged bogus shareholders, whose names are given to the AO, then the Department is free to proceed to reopen their individual assessments in accordance with law. Hence, we find no infirmity with the impugned judgment."

57.

The Hon’ble Allahabad High Court in the case of Principal Commissioner of Income-tax v. Anshika Consultants (P.) Ltd. reported in [2024] 162 taxmann.com 792 (Allahabad) held as under:-

“INCOME TAX : Where assessee had received unsecured interest bearing loans from three corporate entities and had furnished necessary acknowledgement of return, balance sheet, profit and loss account, etc., to prove identity, creditworthiness and genuineness of transaction of unsecured loan taken by it, addition under section 68 was not warranted.”

58.

Similarly in the case of Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax v. Paswara Papers Ltd. reported in [2024] 159 taxmann.com 604 (Allahabad), the Hon’ble Court has held as under:

“INCOME TAX : Where assessee received loan from various creditors who sold their old jewellery and gave loan to assessee out of sale consideration, since assessee had disclosed name of jewellers to whom jewellery was sold and also established mode of payment through banking channel, and moreover existence of deposits made to assessee by creditors was not in dispute, impugned addition under section 68 with respect to loan could not be sustained.”

59.

The Hon’ble Jurisdictional High Court in the case of CIT v. Kamdhenu Steel and Alloys Ltd. reported in [2012] 361 ITR 220 (Delhi) has held as under:

28.

“The contention of the assessee has been found to be convincing by the Tribunal and the learned Tribunal has allowed the appeal thereby deleting the addition. The Revenue is in appeal before us. The entire case of the Revenue based on the plea that as per the report, the investing companies were not found at the given addresses and on this basis, argument is raised that the companies are non-existing and the transactions were bogus and not genuine. Here, the case of the Revenue is even weaker than the cases discussed above. It is not even the case that the Directorate of Income Tax (Investigation) has found Mr. Mahesh Garg in such racket of floating bogus companies. We state at the cost of repetition that after the assessee had furnished the evidence, initial onus had been discharged and it was for the AO to make further necessary inquiries which are completely missing.

29.

We are, thus, of the view that no question of law much less substantial question of law arises. This appeal is dismissed.”

60.

The SLP filed by the revenue against the aforesaid of hon’ble Delhi High Court was dismissed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in SLP (CC) no. 15640 of 2012.

61.

The Hon’ble Jurisdictional High Court in the case of Pr. CIT-5 v. Laxman Industrial Resources Ltd. reported in [2017] 397 ITR 106 (Delhi) has held as under:

“This Court notices that the assessee had provided several documents that could have showed light into whether truly the transactions were genuine. It was not a case where the share applicants are merely provided confirmation letters. They had provided their particulars, PAN details, assessment particulars, mode of payment for share application money, i.e. through banks, bank statements, cheque numbers in question, copies of minutes of resolutions authorizing the applications, copies of balance sheets, profit and loss accounts for the year under consideration and even bank statements showing the source of payments made by the companies to the assessee as well as their master debt with ROC particulars. The AO strangely failed to conduct any scrutiny of documents and rested content by placing reliance merely on a report of the Investigation Wing. This reveals spectacular disregard to an AO's duties in the remand proceedings which the Revenue seeks to inflict upon the assessee in this case. No substantial question of law arises. The appeal is dismissed.”

62.

On the issue of discharging the onus, the Hon'ble Delhi High Court in the case of Mod. Creations (P.) Ltd. v. ITO reported in [2013] 354 ITR 282, held as under:

"It will have to be kept in mind that Section 68 of the I.T. Act only sets up a presumption against the Assessee whenever unexplained credits are found in the books of accounts of the Assessee. It cannot but be gainsaid that the presumption is rebuttable. In refuting the presumption raised, the initial burden is on the Assessee. This burden, which is placed on the Assessee, shifts as soon as the Assessee establishes the authenticity of transactions as executed between the Assessee and its creditors. It is no part of the Assessee's burden to prove either the genuineness of the transactions executed between the creditors and the sub-creditors nor is it the burden of the Assessee to prove the creditworthiness of the sub-creditors.”

63.

It was further observed by the Hon’ble Court as under:

14.

“With this material on record in our view as far as the Assessee was concerned, it had discharged initial onus placed on it. In the event the revenue still had a doubt with regard to the genuineness of the transactions in issue, or as regards the creditworthiness of the creditors, it would have had to discharge the onus which had shifted on to it. A bald assertion by the ASSESSING OFFICER that the credits were a circular route adopted by the Assessee to plough back its own undisclosed income into its accounts, can be of no avail. The revenue was required to prove this allegation. An allegation by itself which is based on assumption will not pass muster in law. The revenue would be required to bridge the gap between the suspicions and proof in order to bring home this allegation. The ITAT, in our view, without adverting to the aforementioned principle laid stress on the fact that despite opportunities, the Assessee and/or the creditors had not proved the genuineness of the transaction. Based on this the ITAT construed the intentions of the Assessee as being mala Ride. In our view the ITAT ought to have analyzed the material rather than be burdened by the fact that some of the creditors had chosen not to make a personal appearance before the A.O. If the A.0. had any doubt about the material placed on record, which was largely bank statements or the creditors and their income tax returns, it could gather the necessary information from the sources to which the said information was attributable to. No such exercise had been conducted by the A.O. In any event what both the A.O. and the ITAT lost track of was that it was dealing with the assessment of the company, i.e., the recipient of the loan and not that its directors and shareholders or that of the sub-creditors. If it had any doubts with regard to their credit worthiness, the revenue could always bring it to tax in the hands of the creditors and/or sub-creditors. [See CIT v. Divine Leasing & Finance Etd (20092-229-178.268 (Delhi) and CIT v. Lovely Exports (P.) Ltd. 2006) 215 CTR 495 (SC).*”

64.

The Hon'ble Delhi High Court in the case of CIT vs. Vrindavan Farms Pvt. Ltd. etc. in ITA. No.71 of 2015 dated 12th August, 2015 held as under :

"The sole basis for the Revenue to doubt their creditworthiness was the low income as reflected in their return of income. lt was observed by the ITAT that the Assessing Officer had not undertaken any investigation of the veracity of the documents submitted by the assessee, the departmental appeal was dismissed by the Hon’ble High court.”

65.

The Hon'ble Delhi High Court in the case of PCIT vs. Agson Global Pvt. Ltd reported in [2022]134 Taxmann.com 256 (Delhi) while allowing the appeal in favour of the assessee deleting the additions made u/s 68 of the Act has held as under :

“Section 68 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 – Cash credits (Share capital money) – Assessment years 2012-13 to 2017-18 – Assessee-company received share capital and share premium money from several investors – Assessing Officer made addition in respect of same on account of unaccounted income under section 68 on basis of recorded statement of managing director of assessee-company – Whether since assessee placed sufficient documentary evidence to establish that money which assessee had paid to investors was routed back to it in form of share capital/share premium and identity, creditworthiness and genuineness of investors was proved, there was no justification to make addition under section 68 – Held, yes [Paras 11.4, 11.5 and 14.4] [In favour of assessee]”

66.

As observed above, all the loans taken were repaid in the year under appeal or in subsequent years and much prior to the search carried out in the case of assessee or survey in the case of lender companies and relevant copies of the ledger accounts evidencing the repayment are placed in the paper book and reference of the same is made in the chart reproduced herein above. It is a matter of record that no adverse inference was drawn by the revenue in the year of payment and thus question of getting accommodation entries in the guise of loan does not survive. The Hon’ble Gujarat High Court in the case of PCIT Vs Ojjas Tarmake Pvt. Ltd. reported in 156 Taxmann.com 75 has observed as under:

“Where appellant showed unsecured loans received during relevant assessment year and AO made addition on ground that appellant failed to discharge onus of liability as laid down under section 68, since amount of loan received by appellant was returned to loan party during year itself and all transactions were carried out through banking channels, impugned addition was to be deleted.”

67.

The Hon’ble Jurisdictional High Court in the case of Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax-12, Delhi vs. Jagmag Builders in ITA No. 325/2024 has held as under:

2.

“The issue itself pertains to additions under Sections 68 and 37 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 [‘Act’] which were made by the Assessing Officer [‘AO’] on account of unexplained unsecured loans and disallowance of interest expenses. We note that the Tribunal while affirming the conclusions which were arrived at by Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) has observed as follows:-

“6.

From the evidences furnished by the assessee before the departmental authorities, it is established that the entire loan, which is subject matter of addition, as unexplained cash credit has been repaid either in the year under consideration or subsequent assessment years. The entire transaction relating to availing of and repayment of loan has been done through banking channel. All details relating to loan availed and repayments made have been furnished before the departmental authorities, the details of which have been produced at pages 24 to 29 of the order of learned First Appellate Authority. It is also a fact on record that assessee has furnished all supporting evidences not only to prove the identity of the lenders but even creditworthiness as well as genuineness of the transaction by furnishing their bank statements, income-tax return copy, confirmations etc. Thus, it is evident, assessee has discharged its onus of proving the identity and creditworthiness of the creditors as well as genuineness of the loan transactions. Therefore, in our considered opinion, learned First Appellate Authority was justified in deleting the addition of Rs.2,67,05,959 made under Section 68 of the Act. Since, the addition made under Section 68 of the Act has been deleted, as a natural corollary, the disallowance of interest paid on such loan also has to be deleted. Accordingly, we do so. Grounds are dismissed.”

68.

Another major fact which has not been doubted by the AO is the interest payments made on the loans alleged as unexplained credits which was accepted as genuine expenditure. Once it is alleged that the principal loan is a bogus accommodation entry, the payment of interest on such loans should not be allowed as genuine expenditure. In the instant case, the AO has not only allowed the interest payment but also accepted the fact of TDS made on such interest payment as genuine and accepted the income declared by the assessee after claiming such interest as expenditure. This dual approach leads to belief that the AO has proceeded with preconceived notion of making addition of the loans as bogus without applying his mind to overall facts of the case and the relevant details submitted by the assessee.

69.

In view of the above, in our considered opinion no addition could be made when the assessee has duly discharged the onus lied upon it of establishing the identity and creditworthiness of the lenders and genuineness of the loan transactions through every plausible evidence like confirmations of the lender companies, their Financial Statements, their Income tax records such as their ITR’s and PAN, bank statements and further evidences of repayment in subsequent years and RBI license etc. which were never revoked. Thus in view of above discussion and by respectfully following the judicial pronouncements as referred herein above of the hon’ble Supreme court and various high courts including the jurisdictional high court, the entire addition of INR 34.75 crores made by the AO towards unsecured loans treating the same as unexplained credit u/s 68 of the Act is hereby, deleted. Accordingly, the Grounds of appeal Nos. 6 to 9 raised by the assessee are allowed and Ground of appeal Nos. 1 & 2 raised by the Revenue are dismissed.

70.

Ground of appeal No.10 of the assessee is with respect to the deletion of addition of INR 69.50 Lakhs made u/s 69C of the Act being alleged commission paid for obtaining the accommodation entries of unsecured loans held as unexplained which according to the assessee was not adjudicated by the ld. CIT(A).

71.

Heard the contentions of both the parties at length and perused the material on record. The addition was made by holding that the assessee had paid commission @ 2% on the accommodation entries of unsecured loans of INR 34.75 crores for which separate addition u/s 68 of the Act was made by the AO. Since we have already, deleted the additions made u/s 68 of the Act towards unsecured loans, therefore, there is no question of any such payment of commission. Accordingly, we hereby, delete the addition. Ground of appeal No.10 raised by the assessee is hereby, allowed.

72.

Ground of appeal No.11 raised by the assessee is with respect to the confirmation of addition of INR 7,04,621/- made u/s 14A of the Act r.w.s. 8D of the Rules.

73.

Heard the contentions of both the parties at length and perused the material on record. The AO by observing that assessee is having exempt income to the tune of INR 62,12,900/- in the shape of dividend and no disallowance was made u/s 14A of the Act, has computed the disallowance by invoking Rule 8D(2)(ii) of the Income Tax Rules, 1962 (‘the Rules’) and computed the disallowance at INR 7,04,621/- being 1% of the average value of the investments. It was the claim of assessee that AO has not recorded the satisfaction as required u/s 14A(2) of the Act. Further reliance is placed on the judgement of Co-ordinate Bench in its own case for preceding AY 2016-17, where addition made u/s 14A was deleted as no satisfaction was recorded before making the addition. Further, the assessee claimed that it is having interest free funds of INR 2,25,959 Lakhs and the average investment made was of INR 70.40 crores therefore, it could be safely presumed that the investment was made out of the interest free funds available with the assessee. It is observed that ld. CIT(A) while confirming the addition, has observed that the AO has recorded the satisfaction and further, the disallowance has been made under sub-clause (2) of Rule 8D of the Rules and no further disallowance out of the interest payment was made.

74.

Before us, the assessee has failed to controvert the findings given by ld. CIT(A) and merely relied upon the orders of the preceding AYs where no satisfaction was recorded. However, as observed above, in the instant case, satisfaction was recorded in the assessment order before invoking the provision of section 14A and therefore, we find no error in the order of ld. CIT(A) in confirming the addition made. Accordingly, Ground of appeal No.11 of the assessee is dismissed.

75.

Ground of appeal No.12 of the assessee and Ground of appeal No.5 of the Revenue are with respect to the transfer pricing adjustment made by TPO on account of corporate guarantee fee of INR 6,78,72,478/- which is reduced by ld. CIT(A) to INR 6,73,911/-by reducing fee rate from 2.10% applied by the TPO to 0.50% by ld. CIT(A).

76.

Briefly stated facts are that the appellant has extended corporate guarantee in favour of financial institutions on behalf of its AEs namely Flex Africa, Flex Egypt & Flex USA to avail credit facilities from foreign banks. The assessee has charged guarantee commission @ 0.40% on such corporate guarantee. It was the claim of the assessee that corporate guarantee issued by parent company cannot be equated with the bank guarantee provided by the commercial bank where the regulatory requirement involves capital, independent credit etc. The assessee further claimed that in the case of Flex Egypt & Flex USA, no fresh guarantee was given during the year under appeal and the guarantee was extended in preceding years and guarantee commission @ 0.40% was charged which stood accepted by AO/TPO and adjustment was made. As there was no change in the circumstances, the commission charged @0.40% by the assessee on such guarantee deserves to be upheld as a principal of consistency. With respect to the fresh guarantee given for fresh finances taken by its AE Flex Africa, it had benchmarked the guarantee commission by adopting “interest saving approach” according to which total benefit derived by AE on account of explicit support and credit enhancement provided by the parent company was computed and a substantial portion thereof i.e. 50% of such benefit which comes to 0.40% in the instant case was attributed as guarantee commission. The claim of the assessee was that ld. CIT(A) has deleted the addition made on account of corporate guarantee given to Flex Egypt and Flex USA however, ld. CIT(A) has reduced the guarantee commission @ 0.50% on the guarantee extended to Flex Africa without any basis whereas the assessee has adopted interest saving approach.

77.

Ld.AR for the assessee thus submits that assessee has already charged corporate guarantee commission @ 0.40% and therefore, action of ld. CIT(A) in restricting the same to 0.50% deserves to be deleted. For this, reliance is placed on various judgements which are stated in the written submissions.

78.

On the other hand, ld. CIT DR for the Revenue vehemently supported the order of AO and submits that AO/TPO has rightly enhance the corporate guarantee commission to 2.10% as against 0.40% charged by the assessee for which no basis/ working was provided and therefore, requested for the confirmation of the order of AO/TPO on this issue.

79.

Heard the contentions of both the parties at length and perused the material on record. This issue is elaborately discussed by ld. CIT(A) from pages 285 onwards where ld. CIT(A) has relied upon the judgement of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Glenmark Pharmaceuticals reported in 2018 (12) TMI 608 (SC) and observed that approach taken by TPO for benchmarking the transaction is not correct where TPO has taken SBI rate. It is further observed that ld. CIT(A) has deleted the adjustment made in respect of corporate guarantee provided to two AE’s namely, Flex Egypt and Flex USA by holding that in preceding assessment years when the guarantee was given, commission was charged @ 0.40% which was accepted in the order passed u/s 143(3) and since there was no change in the circumstances, no adjustment is required to be made. For this, ld. CIT(A) has referred proviso to Rule 10D(4) which provides that were international transactions continued for more than one year and if there was no significant change in the nature or terms of international transactions, fresh documentation is not mandated. Thus, we find no error in the order of ld. CIT(A) in deleting the adjustment made towards corporate guarantee provided to Flex Egypt and Flex USA.

80.

Regarding fresh guarantee extended during the year under consideration to Flex Africa, ld. CIT(A) has confirmed the rate of 0.50% for the corporate guarantee given. From the order of ld. CIT(A), it is observed that the application @ 0.50% on corporate guarantee is based on the judgment of Co-ordinate Bench of Chennai in the case of ACIT v. Bahwan Cybertek (P.) Ltd. reported in [2025] 181 taxmann.com 231 (Chennai - Trib.) and the decision of Kolkata Tribunal in the case of Electrosteel Castings Ltd. in ITA No. 2303 & 2304/Kol/2019 vide order dated 17.05.2022 (Kolkata ITAT) and further in the case of DCIT vs Ashok Leyland Ltd. reported in 177 taxmann.com 785 (Chennai. Trib.).

81.

Considering the overall facts and circumstances of the case and further keeping in mind that in respect to the corporate guarantee extended to other Two AE’s namely, Flex USA and Flex Egypt, commission charged @ 0.40% was accepted by the Revenue in preceding assessment years and also in the year before us, we have held the same as reasonable, therefore, solely for the reason that in some judicial pronouncements, corporate guarantee commission @ 0.50% was held as reasonable, the same cannot be applied in the case of assessee without any basis. There is no thumb rule to follow the rate adopted in various judicial pronouncements which depends upon the facts of each individual case. In the instant case, as observed above, assessee has adopted “interest saving approach” where 50% of the total benefit derived by AE towards the explicit support provided by the assessee which was worked out at 0.40% and was attributed as guarantee commission by the assessee itself. Further the revenue has failed to bring any material before us, to controvert the approach adopted by the assessee. Thus, in our considered opinion, corporate guarantee commission charged @ 0.40% by the assessee from its AE is fair and reasonable and accordingly, the addition so sustained by ld. CIT(A) by applying rate of 0.50% as against 0.40% taken by the assessee is hereby deleted. Ground of appeal No. 12 of the assessee is allowed and ground of appeal No. 12 raised of the Revenue is dismissed.

82.

In the result, appeal of the assessee is partly allowed.

83.

Coming to the remaining Grounds of appeal of the Revenue.

84.

Now we take Ground of appeal No.3 of the Revenue where Revenue has challenged the action of ld. CIT(A) in deleting the addition of INR 84.00 crores made on account of cash received from MEPL.

85.

Brief facts leading to this issue are that search was simultaneously carried out in the case of MEPL Wherein statements u/s 132(4) of the Act of its employees were recorded including the statements of Shri Manoj Kandpal. In the said statements he has stated that cash of INR 84.00 crores (monthly INR 7.00 crores) was given to Shri Arvind Gupta, Director of MEPL who handed over the said cash to Shri Rajiv Jain, CFO of assessee at its head office i.e. of the assessee company. Based on these statements, the AO concluded that the assessee was the beneficial owner of the cash so received in its head office and addition of Rs. 84.00 crores was made u/s 69A of the Act. The said addition was deleted by ld. CIT(A) by observing that no incriminating material was seized relating to the year under appeal of cash sales by MEPL, thus no addition could be made for the alleged cash being handed over to the assessee at its head office.

86.

Before us, ld. CIT DR vehemently supported the order of AO and submits that during the course of search carried out at the premises of MEPL, various note pads were found and seized which were marked as Annexure D-1 to D-39 containing details of unaccounted cash sales made by MEPL to various parties. Ld. CIT DR submits that in the statements recorded of Shri Manoj Kandpal, he categorically stated that cash of INR 7.00 crores was given to the assessee on monthly basis. Since MEPL is one of the group company and cash was given by it to the assessee company who enjoyed the said cash and thus become the beneficial owner of such cash. Ld. CIT DR further submits that this cash was not found recorded in the books of the assessee. As per ld. CIT DR, assessee has sold the goods to the MEPL and therefore, cash so received was against unrecorded /under billing sales made by the assessee and therefore, the AO has rightly made the addition in the hands of the assessee company as its undisclosed income and requested to restore the addition deleted by ld. CIT(A).

87.

On the other hand, ld. AR vehemently supported the order of ld. CIT(A) and submits that no incriminating material whatsoever, was found/seized from the possession of the assessee company or from MEPL indicating receipt /payment of any such cash as has been stated by Shri Manoj Kandpal in his statement recorded. Ld. AR further submits that Diary seized marked as Annexure D-1 to D-39 relied upon for alleging the cash sales by MEPL, contained the entries for FY 2022-23 and no entry whatsoever was found noted pertaining to the year under appeal and therefore, extrapolating the said statement for the year under appeal is incorrect. Ld. AR further submits that besides the solitary statement of Shri Manoj Kandpal, there was no corroborative material/evidence was ever brought on record to support the allegation as against which assessee has filed affidavit of Shri Arvind Gupta, Director of MEPL denied the receipt of any such cash and further referred statements of various employees of assessee and MEPL wherein they all had denied of making payment/receipt of any such cash. He further submits that assessee has requested to cross-examine Shri Manoj Kandpal however, no such opportunity was provided. Ld. AR further submits that statements of Shri Rajiv Jain to whom Shri Arvind Gupta handed over the cash were also recorded where in reply to Question No.54, he categorically denied of receiving any such cash from MEPL. Ld. AR further submits that Shri Ashok Chaturvedi, Director of the assessee company and Shri Rajesh Bhatia, CEO of the appellant group also denied of receipt of any such cash from MEPL. As per ld.AR, when there was constant denial by the Senior Officials of the appellant company, not providing the opportunity to cross-examine of only witness of the Revenue whose statements were heavily relied upon by the Revenue, is a serious violation of principal of natural justice and thus under these circumstances, no addition could be made u/s 69A of the Act. Ld. AR finally submitted that the ld. CIT(A) appreciated these facts and then, deleted the addition which order deserves to be sustained.

88.

Heard the contentions of both the parties at length and perused the material available on record. It is observed that sole basis for making addition is the statement given by one Shri Manoj Kandpal who was the employee of MEPL in whose case search was carried out simultaneously. During the course of search in the case of MEPL, some loose papers and diaries were found and seized which were marked as Annexure D-1 to D-39. As per the AO, these diaries contained unaccounted cash sales made by MEPL In his statement, Shri Manoj Kandpal stated that out of the cash collection recorded in the said diaries, a sum of INR 7.00 crores was given by him to Shri Arvind Gupta, director of MEPL who has handed over the said cash to Shri Rajiv Jain of the assessee company. Accordingly, AO was of the opinion that this monthly cash of INR 7.00 crores was received by the assessee company from MEPL and thus is unexplained money sources of which is out of undisclosed sales. Therefore, addition was made u/s 69A of the Act as unexplained money. Ld. CIT(A) after considering the facts, the arguments of the parties and the statements of various employees of the assessee as well as of MEPL and the issue of cross-examination and by placing reliance on various judicial pronouncements has deleted the addition made, by making following observations:-

The assessment order, the submissions of the Authorized Representative, the statements relied upon by the Assessing Officer, and the material available on record have been examined. The AO has made the addition on the basis of incriminating material seized during the course of search carried out in FY 2022-23 relevant to AY 2023-24, wherein, documents pertaining to AY 2022-23 & AY 2023-24 were seized from Montage Enterprises Pvt. Ltd. As per AO, the said documents show that cash was paid to the assessee company by Montage Enterprises Pvt. Ltd. The AO has further relied upon the statement of Sh. Manoj Kandpal, AGM Finance of MEPL. The present appeal relates to AY 20-21 whereas, examination of the assessment order of the appellant company for AY 21-22 and AY 2022-23 reveals that the AO has discussed statements of various other persons also which shall be discussed later in the body of the order.

Issue of Statement Recorded

The impugned addition has been made primarily on the basis of statement of Sh. Manoj Kandpal recorded during search proceedings and material seized pertaining to AY 2022-23 & AY 2023-24, without any corroborative incriminating material unearthed for the year under consideration. On careful consideration of the material available on record, it is observed that the Assessing Officer has primarily relied upon the statement of Sh. Manoj Kandpal recorded during the course of search proceedings to support the impugned addition. The statements of some other persons has been discussed by the AO in the assessment order of the assessee pertaining to AY 2021-22 & AY 2022-23 and the same shall be discussed underneath to bring all the facts on record. It needs to be emphasized that the appellant has also highlighted the statements of various other persons recorded during the search proceedings in its submissions from page no. 197 to page 203 which have not been highlighted by the AO. It shall be important to highlight the roles of various persons whose statements were recorded and which shall be discussed hereunder:

i.

Ashok Kumar Chaturvedi (Chairman and Managing Director of U Flex Limited) ii. Rajesh Bhatia (CFO of U Flex Limited) iii. Vipin Agarwal (Taxation Head of U Flex Limited)

v.

Rajiv Jain (Personnel Manager of U Flex Limited)

v.

Ajay Krishna (Employee of U Flex Limited) vi. Arvind Gupta (Director of MEPL) vii. Manoj Kandpal (Manager of MEPL) viii. Harwinder Singh Matharu (Director of MEPL) ix. Amit Jaiswal (Employee of MEPL)

The contentions of the appellant and the findings of the AO with respect to the statements of above persons shall be discussed in brief in the coming paragraphs. It needs to be highlighted here that for the year under appeal, the AO has relied only upon the statement of Sh. Manoj Kandpal, whereas, it is seen from the assessment order of the assessee for AY 2021-22 & AY 2022-23 that the AO has discussed some other statements as well. Similarly, the appellant has brought on record some statements which have not been discussed in the assessment order by the AO. It shall be in the interest of justice to bring on record in brief the relevant context of all statements as contended by the appellant and the AO which have been produced before this office.

Issue of Statement Recorded

The impugned addition has been made primarily on the basis of statement of Sh. Manoj Kandpal recorded during search proceedings and material seized pertaining to AY 2022-23 & AY 2023-24, without any corroborative incriminating material unearthed for the year under consideration. On careful consideration of the material available on record, it is observed that the Assessing Officer has primarily relied upon the statement of Sh. Manoj Kandpal recorded during the course of search proceedings to support the impugned addition. The statements of some other persons has been discussed by the AO in the assessment order of the assessee pertaining to AY 2021-22 & AY 2022-23 and the same shall be discussed underneath to bring all the facts on record. It needs to be emphasized that the appellant has also highlighted the statements of various other persons recorded during the search proceedings in its submissions from page no. 197 to page 203 which have not been highlighted by the AO. It shall be important to highlight the roles of various persons whose statements were recorded and which shall be discussed hereunder:

i.

Ashok Kumar Chaturvedi (Chairman and Managing Director of U Flex Limited) ii. Rajesh Bhatia (CFO of U Flex Limited) iii. Vipin Agarwal (Taxation Head of U Flex Limited) iv. Rajiv Jain (Personnel Manager of U Flex Limited)

v.

Ajay Krishna (Employee of U Flex Limited) vi. Arvind Gupta (Director of MEPL) vii. Manoj Kandpal (Manager of MEPL) viii. Harwinder Singh Matharu (Director of MEPL) ix. Amit Jaiswal (Employee of MEPL)

The contentions of the appellant and the findings of the AO with respect to the statements of above persons shall be discussed in brief in the coming paragraphs. It needs to be highlighted here that for the year under appeal, the AO has relied only upon the statement of Sh. Manoj Kandpal, whereas, it is seen from the assessment order of the assessee for AY 2021-22 & AY 2022-23 that the AO has discussed some other statements as well. Similarly, the appellant has brought on record some statements which have not been discussed in the assessment order by the AO. It shall be in the interest of justice to bring on record in brief the relevant context of all statements as contended by the appellant and the AO which have been produced before this office.

Statement of Shri Rajiv Jain (Personnel Manager)

It is noted that in his statement, particularly in response to Question No. 35, Shri Manoj Kandpal stated that the alleged cash amounts were handed over by him to Shri Rajiv Jain. The appellant has stated that on examination of the statements of Shri Rajiv Jain recorded from 21.02.2023 to 23.02.2023, it is observed that he denied having received any cash from Montage Enterprises Pvt. Ltd. (MEPL). Further, as per appellant, however, in his subsequent statement dated 24.02.2023, he stated that cash was received on various occasions and further claimed that such cash was passed on to Shri Vipin Agarwal and Shri Rajesh Bhatia. Finally, as per appellant, it appears from above that the statement of Sh. Rajiv Jain dated 24.02.2023 is at complete variance with the statements recorded from 21.02.2023 to 23.02.2023.

Statement of Sh. Ajay Krishna (Employee of U Flex Limited)

The AO has stated that as per Ajay Krishna, Sh. Rajiv Jain was responsible for receiving the cash and management of the same.

Statement of Sh. Ashok Kumar Chaturvedi (CMD)

It is further seen that the Director of the company Sh. Ashok Kumar Chaturvedi in his statement recorded on 27.02.2023 on being confronted with the statement of Sh. Rajiv Jain in response to question no. 219 stated that he did not know about the said transactions and Sh. Vipin Agarwal, Taxation Head and Sh. Rajesh Bhatia CFO of the U Flex Group can explain about the same.

Statements of Sh. Vipin Agarwal (Taxation Head) and Rajesh Bhatia (CFO)

It was pointed out by the appellant that Shri Rajesh Bhatia, in response to Question No. 13, has expressly denied any receipt of cash from Shri Rajiv Jain. Similarly, Shri Vipin Agarwal, in response to Question No. 14, has unequivocally denied any receipt of cash from Shri Rajiv Jain. Finally, as per AR, the statement of Sh. Rajiv Jain is in complete contradiction to the statements of Sh. Vipin Agarwal and Sh. Rajesh Bhatia.

Statement of Sh. Manoj Kandpal (Manager of MEPL)

As per AO, Shri Manoj Kandpal, in his statement, had stated that certain diaries were maintained in earlier years and that the same were subsequently destroyed, and that such practice was being followed for many years. On the other hand, the appellant stated that Shri Manoj Kandpal, in his last statement dated 25 August 2023, has stated that the term "Corp" refers to corporate business payments and not to the appellant, M/s U-Flex Ltd. As per AR, this clarification directly contradicts the inferences drawn by the Assessing Officer on the basis of the earlier statement.

Statements of Ah. Harvinder Singh Matharu and Amit Jaiswal (Employees of MEPL)

As per AO, Amit Jaiswal has described the business connection between MEPL and U Flex Limited. Further, as per AO, Harvinder Singh Matharu has stated that Sh. Manoj Kandpal was responsible for management of cash.

Affidavit of Arvind Gupta (Director of MEPL)

The appellant has also relied upon the affidavit of Shri Arvind Gupta, Director of M/s MEPL, wherein he has stated that Shri Manoj Kandpal was never authorized to make any cash payments on behalf of the company. In the said affidavit, Shri Arvind Gupta has further explained that, in certain unavoidable situations, marketing personnel, after late working hours, used to temporarily deposit cash collections with Shri Rajiv Jain purely for security reasons, and such cash was subsequently returned to Shri Arvind Gupta. As per appellant, the said affidavit of Sh. Arvind Gupta also submitted before the AO during the assessment proceedings in the case of MEPL, directly contradicts the statement of Sh. Manoj Kandpal. Further, as per AR, it is an admitted position that no incriminating material was unearthed during the search pertaining to the year under consideration to substantiate the allegation that any cash was received by the appellant.

Opportunity for cross examination

The appellant has stated that the cross-examination of Shri Manoj Kandpal was specifically requested during the assessment proceedings as well as during appellate proceedings. An email was sent to the AO vide this office email dated 23.10.2024 wherein, it was stated as under:

"During the course of appellate proceedings in the above-mentioned case, the AR has filed submissions. The copy of the same is attached for ready reference. It is directed to offer your comments on para 3.1 to para 5 of the submissions. It is further directed to give a factual report regarding the entities from whom replies u/s 133(6) were received during the assessment proceedings either on ITBA or in physical mode. Relevant evidence in the form of copy of ITBA screen or the receipt of 133(6) reply, if received, may be furnished along with. Hard copy of the 133(6) replies along with the mode in which they were submitted before the AO as claimed by the appellant are being handed over in physical mode being voluminous.

It has further been submitted by the appellant that opportunity of cross examination of Sh. Manoj Kandpal has not been provided to the appellant during the assessment proceedings with respect to the addition made regarding receipt of cash. An affidavit of Sh. Arvind Gupta denying having issued any instruction to Sh. Manoj Kandpal has also been filed (copy of the same is attached). To meet the end of justice, permission is granted u/s 250(4) to conduct enquiry with respect to the issue mentioned in this para. Needless to say, opportunity of hearing be granted to the assessee while conducting any enquiry.

It is directed to send your report on or before 15.11.2024 so that pending appeal can be disposed-off.

As per appellant, no opportunity to cross examine Sh. Manoj Kandpal was afforded to the assessee, though a date was initially indicated but no fresh date was ever intimated.

From the reading of the above statements, it is clear that the AO has relied upon the statements of Sh. Manoj Kandpal (in assessment order for AY 2020-21 & AY 2021-22) and Sh. Rajiv Jain, Sh. Ajay Krishna & Sh. Amit Jaiswal (in the assessment order for AY 2021-22). The appellant has stated that there are many contradictions in the statements of Sh. Manoj Kandpal as highlighted above. Further, as per appellant, the statements of Sh. Ashok Chaturvedi, Vipin Agarwal, Rajesh Bhatia are contradictory to statements of Sh. Manoj Kandpal and Sh. Rajiv Jain. Further, as per appellant, the affidavit of Sh. Arvind Gupta totally rebuts and contradicts the statement of Sh. Manoj Kandpal. The maze of the above statements have been used both by the revenue as well as appellant to support their cases. However, to reach a fair conclusion viz the viz the issue under consideration what needs to be examined is the presence or absence of incriminating material pertaining to the year under consideration.

Absence of corroborative material

In the present case, no documentary evidence such as cash books, diaries, ledgers, seized documents, or corroborative financial trail for the year under consideration has been brought on record to substantiate the alleged cash receipts. It is a settled legal position that a standalone statement cannot be the sole basis for making an addition in the absence of any corroborative incriminating material moreso, when the statements are contradictory.

With regard to the annexures D-1 to D-39 relied upon by the Assessing Officer, it is observed that none of these documents pertain to the assessment year under consideration, either in the case of the appellant or in the case of MEPL. Therefore, drawing adverse inferences for the year under consideration based on alleged practices of other years, without any direct documentary linkage, is not sustainable in law.

Standalone Statements

On the issue of standalone statements, the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in the case of Commissioner of Income-tax vs. Mantri Share Brokers (P.) Ltd. reported at [2018] 96 taxmann.com 280 (SC) has held as under:

No section 69B addition in hands of assessee where except statement of director of assessee-company, offering additional income there was no other material either in form of cash, bullion, jewellery or document in any other form to justify said additional income: SLP dismissed

Further, the Hon'ble High Court of Allahabad in the case of Commissioner of Income-tax vs. Dilbagh Rai Arora reported at [2019] 104 taxmann.com 371 (Allahabad) has held as under:

As per appellant, no opportunity to cross examine Sh. Manoj Kandpal was afforded to the assessee, though a date was initially indicated but no fresh date was ever intimated.

From the reading of the above statements, it is clear that the AO has relied upon the statements of Sh. Manoj Kandpal (in assessment order for AY 2020-21 & AY 2021-22) and Sh. Rajiv Jain, Sh. Ajay Krishna & Sh. Amit Jaiswal (in the assessment order for AY 2021-22). The appellant has stated that there are many contradictions in the statements of Sh. Manoj Kandpal as highlighted above. Further, as per appellant, the statements of Sh. Ashok Chaturvedi, Vipin Agarwal, Rajesh Bhatia are contradictory to statements of Sh. Manoj Kandpal and Sh. Rajiv Jain. Further, as per appellant, the affidavit of Sh. Arvind Gupta totally rebuts and contradicts the statement of Sh. Manoj Kandpal. The maze of the above statements have been used both by the revenue as well as appellant to support their cases. However, to reach a fair conclusion viz the viz the issue under consideration what needs to be examined is the presence or absence of incriminating material pertaining to the year under consideration.

Absence of corroborative material

In the present case, no documentary evidence such as cash books, diaries, ledgers, seized documents, or corroborative financial trail for the year under consideration has been brought on record to substantiate the alleged cash receipts. It is a settled legal position that a standalone statement cannot be the sole basis for making an addition in the absence of any corroborative incriminating material moreso, when the statements are contradictory.

With regard to the annexures D-1 to D-39 relied upon by the Assessing Officer, it is observed that none of these documents pertain to the assessment year under consideration, either in the case of the appellant or in the case of MEPL. Therefore, drawing adverse inferences for the year under consideration based on alleged practices of other years, without any direct documentary linkage, is not sustainable in law.

Standalone Statements

On the issue of standalone statements, the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in the case of Commissioner of Income-tax vs. Mantri Share Brokers (P.) Ltd. reported at [2018] 96 taxmann.com 280 (SC) has held as under:

No section 69B addition in hands of assessee where except statement of director of assessee-company, offering additional income there was no other material either in form of cash, bullion, jewellery or document in any other form to justify said additional income: SLP dismissed

Further, the Hon'ble High Court of Allahabad in the case of Commissioner of Income-tax vs. Dilbagh Rai Arora reported at [2019] 104 taxmann.com 371 (Allahabad) has held as under:

Section 69, read with section 143, of the Income-tax Act, 1961 - Unexplained investment (Search & seizure) - Assessment year 2006-07 - Whether where a person can explain exclusively with supportive evidence/material or otherwise that true state of affairs was different from that he presented in his statement of admission, tax liability should be fixed on basis of correct and true affairs as ascertained from material on record - Held, yes - During search operation, assessee, in his statement, surrendered Rs.18 crores on account of investment made in purchase of jewellery, precious stones and Rs. 6 crores as cash in hand duly shown in books of account - Rs. 7 crores were surrendered in stipulation that details of same would be given in due course of time - However, no incriminating materials or documents had been brought on record for said amount of Rs. 7 crores - No assets of Rs. 7 crores were found by authorities, nor such assets were identified or declared by assessee - Whether it could be inferred that no such assets actually existed - Held, yes - Whether Tribunal was right in holding that addition in respect of Rs. 7 crores was not based on any evidence - Held, yes [Paras 17 and 21] [In favour of assessee]

Further, the judgment of Hon'ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh in the case of Commissioner of Income-tax-II, Hyderabad vs. Naresh Kumar Agarwal reported at [2015] 53 taxmann.com 306 (Andhra Pradesh) has held as under:

Where in absence of any incriminating material etc., found from premises of assessee during course of search, statement of assessee recorded under section 132(4) would not have any evidentiary value

Further, the judgment of Hon'ble High Court of Madras in the case of Commissioner of Income-tax, Tiruchirappalli vs. Smt. S. Jayalakshmi Amma reported at [2016] 74 taxmann. com 35 Madras) has held as under:

Where addition of undisclosed income was made on basis of mere statement given by his son under section 132(4) which was not corroborated by any material evidence, neither such statement would be conclusive evidence, nor any addition could be made

Further, the Hon'ble High Court of Gujarat in the case of Commissioner of Income-tax vs. Shardaben K. Modi reported at [2013] 35 taxmann.com 264 (Gujarat) has held as under:

In absence of any independent material, statement of assessee's son recorded during survey would not form a valid basis for reopening assessment of assessee

Further, the Hon'ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh in the case of Commissioner of Income-tax-II, Hyderabad vs. Naresh Kumar Agarwal reported at [2015] 53 taxmann .com 306 (Andhra Pradesh) has held as under:

Where in absence of any incriminating material etc., found from premises of assessee during course of search, statement of assessee recorded under section 132(4) would not have any evidentiary value;

Further, the Ld. ITAT Bench at Chandigarh in the case of Jagbir Singh Nehra reported at ITA No. 687/Chd/2023 in its order dated 11.06.2024 has held as under:

7.

We have considered the issue and we have also considered case laws brought on record by the Id. Counsel of the Assessee. The Id. Counsel has brought on record an order passed by the Chandigarh Bench of the ITAT in the case of 'Dy. CIT vs. Partap Singh Rajendra Chamola & Co.' in IT (SS) A No. 22/Chd/2007 order dated 28.11.2008. In this order the Tribunal has held that no addition in block assessment can be solely made on the basis of statement recorded during the search. Such a statement cannot be treated as incriminating material found in the course of search. The Id. counsel has also brought on record case laws decided by the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in the case of 'CIT vs. Mantri Share Brokers (P.) Ltd.' [2018] 96 taxmann.com 280 (SC) dated 3.7.2018. In this case, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has held as under:

"...High Court in the impugned order held that where except statement of director of Assessee company offering additional income during survey in his premises, there was no other material either in form of cash, bullion, jewellery or document in any other form to justify said statement, addition made on the said income in hands of Assessee under section 69B was to be deleted - Whether SLP against said decision was dismissed -Held, yes".

8.

We have considered the findings of the Id. CIT(A) on this issue and we have also considered the written submissions and arguments made by the Id. Counsel of the Assessee during the proceedings before us and the orders of the Hon'ble Supreme court of India on this issue in the case of 'CIT Vs. Mantri Share Brokers (P.) Ltd., (supra) and the Chandigarh Bench of the ITAT in the case of 'Dy. CIT vs. Partap Singh Rajendra Chamola & Co.' In this case, the ITAT Chandigarh Bench has held "No addition in block assessment can be made solely on the basis of statements recorded during search. Such statements cannot be treated as incriminating material found in the course of search."

9.

The Id. DR relied on the order of the CIT(A).

10.

From the documents filed before us, it is clear that there is no specific incriminating document to prove the payment of Rs. 25,85,000/- over and above the cheque payment of Rs. 10,15,000/- by the Assessee for the purchase of the immovable property. In fact, there are some note pads which indicate where from the Assessee has got money for the purchase of this property but they cannot be treated as incriminating document to prove the cash payment for the purchase of this property. Though it is true that the Assessee in his statement recorded during the search has stated to have paid Rs. 36,00,000/- as total consideration for the purchase of this property but other than his statement the Department could not bring any incriminating document on record to substantiate its claim of cash payment of Rs. 25,85,000/-. As the Hon'ble Supreme Court in 'CIT Vs. Mantri Share Brokers (P.) Ltd.', (supra) has held that mere statement recorded during the search cannot be treated as incriminating document for the addition in a search case, therefore, the CIT(A) finding on this issue cannot be sustained. Accordingly, the Assessee's appeal on Ground Nos. 1 to 3 stand allowed."

Methodology of later years applied during the year under consideration for making addition (Extrapolation)

It is observed that the Assessing Officer has sought to justify the impugned addition by applying the methodology and conclusions drawn in subsequent assessment years to the year under consideration. Each assessment year is an independent and self-contained unit, and additions can be made only on the basis of material, evidence, and facts relatable to the relevant previous year. In the present case, no incriminating documentary material was unearthed during the search proceedings for the year under appeal, either in the hands of the appellant or in the hands of Montage Enterprises Private Limited. The Assessing Officer has attempted to extrapolate findings allegedly emerging in later years and has concluded that the same pattern or modus operandi prevailed during the year under consideration based only on the statements of Sh. Manoj Kandpal and Sh. Rajiv Jain. As already discussed above, the statements of other authorities of both MEPL and the assessee company namely Sh. AK Chaturvedi, Sh. Vipin Agarwal, Sh. Rajesh Bhatia and affidavit of Sh. Arvind Gupta contradicting the statements of Sh. Manoj Kandpal, Sh. Rajiv Jain, Sh. Ajay Krishna and Sh. Harvinder Singh Matharu with respect to cash exchange have not been discussed in the assessment order. It is also important to emphasize here that no documentary material has been brought on record to show continuity of such alleged activities for the relevant year. In the absence of any seized material or documentary evidence for the relevant year, the Assessing Officer could not have legally imported conclusions of later years to justify an addition for the present year.

On the issue of extrapolation of income based on evidence pertaining to other years, the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi in the case of Principal Commissioner of Income Tax vs. Pilot Industries Ltd. reported at [2023] 146 taxmann.com 233 (Delhi), wherein, it has been held as under:

"Where assessment of assessee for relevant assessment years was completed under section 143(3), however, Assessing Officer framed assessments for relevant years under section 153A and made additions on account of gross profit suppressed by obtaining bogus purchase bills after rejecting account books, since there was no evidence found during search with respect to suppression of gross profit by obtaining bogus purchase bills by assessee and Assessing Officer had merely relied upon documents seized during course of search for other financial years 2010-11 and 2011-12, impugned assessment under section 153A was unjustified"

Further, the Hon'ble High Court of Gujarat in the case of Principal Commissioner of Income-tax vs. Shri Pushkar Construction Co reported at [2023] 154 taxmann.com 22 (Gujarat) has held as under:

Whether since material in nature of seized documents was not reliable and it was not related to assessment year 2015-16 and nothing was there to show that on-money was received in respect of sale of units recognized to be sale of assessment year concerned, impugned addition was not justified - Held, yes [Para 6.1] [In favour of assessee]

Further, the Hon'ble High Court of Gujarat in the case of Commissioner of Income-tax – II vs. Standard Tea Processing Co. Ltd. reported at [2013] 34 taxmann.com 31 (Gujarat) has held as under:

"Addition for undisclosed income on account of inflated purchase price can be made only for period to which document found during search is related and not for entire block period"

Further, in the judgment of Ld. ITAT Ahmedabad Bench D in the case of Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax vs. Royal Marwar Tobacco Product (P.) Ltd. reported at [2009] 29 SOT 53 (Ahmedabad) (URO), it has been held as under:

"Assessee was a company manufacturing Gutkha - In assessment years 2000-01 to 2003-04 a search was conducted at premises of assessee - However, nothing was found against assessee - Subsequently, a search was conducted in assessment year 2004-05 whereby incriminating materials were seized which indicated suppressed sales made by assessee - On basis of materials seized relating to assessment year 2004-05, Assessing Officer assumed suppressed sales for earlier assessment years also, and, therefore, estimated same on basis of consumption of electricity and made additions"

Further, the Ld. ITAT HYDERABAD BENCH 'A' in the case of Dr. S. Surendranath Reddy vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax reported at [2000] 72 ITD 205 (HYD.) has held as under:

"Whether, therefore, where there is no material at all in relation to a particular previous year even though falling within block, no undisclosed income can be determined for that year - Held, yes"

Further, in the judgment of Ld. ITAT Pune Bench in the case of HOTEL VRINDAVAN vs. ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME-TAX reported at [2000] 67 TTJ 139 (PUNE), it has been held as under:

"Where the addition had been made on the presumption that if the assessee was suppressing the sales and expenses for the subsequent years, he must have suppressed the sales and expenses for the earlier years also, such addition could not be confirmed as the same could not be said to be supported by cogent material and evidence."

Further, in the judgment of Ld. ITAT Jaipur Bench in the case of ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME-TAX vs. M.M. SALES AGENCIES reported at [2006] 153 TAXMAN 13 (JP.) (MAG.), it has been held as under:

"Whether no sales can be estimated where no information at all had been obtained during course of search and no information is available on basis of seized record that assessee had indulged in out of books transaction for a part of year - Held, yes"

Further, in the judgment of Ld. ITAT Kolkata Bench A in the case of Fort Projects (P.) Ltd. vs. Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax reported at [2013] 29 taxmann.com 84 (Kolkata - Trib.), it has been held as under:

"We find that Hon'ble Courts and Tribunals have time and again held that assessments cannot be framed merely on extrapolation theory i.e. discrepancies in respect of items must have existed in other years or other instances or projects unless a definite trend of malpractice is conclusively proved by substantial evidence on record."

Further, in the judgment of Ld. ITAT Bangalore Bench in the case of ANJANEYA BRICK WORKS vs. ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME-TAX (INV.) reported at [2002] 74 TTJ 921 (BANG.), it has been held as under:

"Section 145 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 - Mere existence of evidence to support concealment of income for following assessment year cannot be made a basis judiciously to estimate the income for the current year or any other assessment year for that matter"

Further, the ITAT KOLKATA BENCH 'B' in the case of Mani Square Ltd. vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax, CC-3(2), Kolkata reported at [2020] 118 taxmann.com 452 (Kolkata - Trib.), in which it has been held as under:-

"Cash credits (Immovable properties) - Assessment years 2013-14 to 2017-18 - Whether theory of extrapolation cannot be applied on mere theoretical or hypothetical basis in absence of any incriminating and corroborative evidence or material brought on record by Assessing Officer to warrant same - Held, yes - Assessing Officer made additions under section 68 in case of assessee by extrapolating unaccounted sales across all units sold by assessee in its project on account of on-monies alleged to have been received against sale of flat and sale of car park to SB (HUF) - However, Assessing Officer had made independent enquiries from all flat purchasers in assessee's project and despite such enquiries, Assessing Officer did not find any statement/material or transaction which would in any manner suggest let alone prove that other flat purchasers had paid any part of consideration in cash/on-monies over and above declared sale consideration - Whether in absence of any such material Commissioner (Appeals) rightly deleted addition made on ground that extrapolation made by Assessing Officer was per se arbitrary and unreasonable - Held, yes[Para 38] [In favour of assessee]"

The Ld. ITAT Chandigarh Bench in the case of Gurdip Cycle Industries vs. Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax reported at [2024] 165 taxmann.com 299 (Chandigarh - Trib.) has held as under:

"Where statement of accountant of assessee was recorded on basis of WhatsApp chat wherein he admitted to suppression of sales in case of a party, however, AO extrapolated entire turnover of assessee and made addition with respect to under invoicing, since it was a case of sales made outside books of account, addition could be confirmed only on sales made outside books made to parties whose names figures were found in WhatsApp chat"

Further, the Ld. ITAT Chandigarh Bench in the case of M/s Auto Vogue Private Limited Versus DCIT/ACIT (Central) -1, Chandigarh in ITA No. 405/CHANDI/2025 has held as under:

Extrapolation of income - extrapolation of figures as found recorded in document found during survey action - Assessee was subjected to survey action u/s 133A wherein list of 35 employees was found from the cabin of cashier of the assessee-company - These employees were shown to have been paid salary of Rs. 2,54,115/- for the month of July, 2017 but HR Manager admitted that the list was list of bogus employees

HELD THAT: Survey addition has to be made strictly in accordance with the incriminating material only. The document found during the survey is the very foundation of the impugned addition. Unless corroboration was done by AO to support the extrapolation, no presumption could be made that similar payment was made by the assessee during the rest of the months also.

Further, the Ld. ITAT Mumbai in the case of Dy. CIT-17 (1), Mumbai Versus Late Ramesh Pannalal Ranawat Through Rahul Ramesh Ranawat (Legal Heir of Late Ramesh Pannalal Ranawat) And (Vice-Versa) in ITA No. 5688/Mum/2024 And CO No. 291/Mum/2024 has held as under:

Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
89.

On careful consideration of the facts and on perusal of the order of ld. CIT(A), it is observed that ld. CIT(A) has held that no opportunity of cross examination was allowed to the assessee and except Shri Manoj Kandpal, none of the other employee of the assessee or MEPL had ever admitted receiving of any cash from MEPL. Further, the documents found and seized during the course of search at the business premises of MEPL conducted simultaneously, certain diaries were found and seized which were marked as Annexure D-1 to D-39. The said diaries contained entries pertaining to FY 2022-23 and it is an admitted fact that no entry was found noted in any of the diary relating to the year under appeal. The hon’ble Apex Court in the case of PCIT Vs. Abhisar Buildwell Pvt. Ltd. in Civil Appeal No. 6580 of 2021 dated 24.04.2023 (reported in 150 Taxmann.com 257 (SC) (2023) has laid down the scope of assessment u/s. 153A r.w.s 153C and held the pre-condition of making an addition during assessment proceedings u/s 153A/153C for a particular year is the existence of seized material/incriminating material in that year. ld. CIT(A) by following the order of Abhisar Buildwell Pvt.Ltd. (supra) of Hon’ble Apex court has held that no addition could be made in the year under appeal without having any incriminating material.

90.

It is further observed that despite of repeated requests, the AO has denied the opportunity of cross examination of the witness of the department Shri Manoj Kandpal whose statements are heavily relied upon for making the additions. The Co-ordinate Bench of Delhi Tribunal in the case of Veena Gupta vs. ACIT in ITA No.5662/Del/2018, has followed the judgement of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Andman Timber Industries reported in 62 Taxmann.com 3 (SC) and held that by not providing the opportunities of cross examining the prime witness of the Revenue, no addition could be made. The relevant extract of the order as contained in para 11 to 15 are reproduced as under:

11.

“We have perused submissions advanced by both sides in light of records placed before. We also refer to all judicial precedents relied upon by both sides.

12.

It is observed that both Assessing Officer as well as Ld. CIT(A) is relying upon statement recorded by Investigation Department of Sh. Amit Dalmia and Sh. Narendra Kumar Jain. It is based upon their statements, that test of human probabilities has been applied to facts of present case by authorities below. Further, it cannot be ignored that assessee was not granted opportunity to cross examine Sh. Amit Dalmia and Sh. Narendra Kumar Jain. Even after assessee asking for opportunity to cross examine these persons, before First Appellate Authority, same was not granted. Assessee has contested truthfulness of statements given by Sh. Amit Dalmia and Sh. Narendra Kumar Jain before us.

12.1

It is pertinent to note that assessee, vide letter dated 21/12/16 had asked Ld. AO to provide material based upon which various allegations have been levied by Ld. AO. These factors from para 20 of assessment order, wherein assessee raised objections, one of which is opportunity to cross examine, in case of any evidence used against assessee.

12.3

To our surprise, Ld. AO without providing any material evidence, report on which he was relying and not granting an opportunity to cross examine the persons on whose statement he arrived at certain presuppositions, made addition in the hands of assessee. This is evident from para 22 of assessment order.

13.

Before Ld. CIT (A) assessee once again raised plea of cross-examination granted to assessee and materials not based upon which the submissions have been made has not been provided for examination. Even then opportunity was not granted to assessee, though Ld. CIT (A) had coterminous powers as that of Ld. AO.

14.

In our view this amounts to gross violation of principles of natural Justice. We draw our support from the decision of Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Andaman Timber Industries versus CCE reported in (2015) 62 Taxmann.com 3, wherein Hon'ble court observed as under:

"According to us, not allowing the assessee to cross-examine the witnesses by the Adjudicating Authority though the statements of those witnesses were made the basis of the impugned order is a serious flaw which makes the order nullity inasmuch as it amounted to violation of principles of natural justice because of which the assessee was adversely affected. It is to be borne in mind that the order of the Commissioner was based upon the statements given by the aforesaid two witnesses. Even when the assessee disputed the correctness of the statements and wanted to cross-examine, the Adjudicating Authority did not grant this opportunity to the assessee. It would be pertinent to note that in the impugned order passed by the Adjudicating Authority he has specifically mentioned that such an opportunity was sought by the assessee. However, no such opportunity was granted and the aforesaid plea is not even dealt with by the Adjudicating Authority."

15.

We, accordingly, respectfully following decision of Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Andaman Timber Industries versus CCE (supra) allow appeal of assessee on legal ground raised in Ground 2(c), and quash and set-aside the assessment order so passed.”

91.

Similar view was expressed by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of CIT Vs. Odeon Builders Pvt. Ltd, reported in 110 Taxmann.com 64 (SC). The relevant observations are reproduced as under:

"However, on going through the judgments of the CIT, ITAT and the High Court, we find that on merits a disallowance of Rs.19,39,60,866/- was based solely on third party information, which was not subjected to any further scrutiny. Thus, the ld. CIT(A) allowed the appeal of the assessee stating:

"Thus, the entire disallowance in this case is based on third party information gathered by the Investigation Wing of the Department, which have not been independently subjected to further verification by the AO who has not provided the copy of such statements to the appellant, thus denying opportunity of cross examination to the appellant, who has prima facie discharged the initial burden of substantiating the purchases through various documentation including purchase bills, transportation bills, confirmed copy of accounts and the fact of payment through cheques, & VAT Registration of the sellers & their Income Tax Return. In view of the above discussion in totality, the purchases made by the appellant from M/s Padmesh Realtors Pvt. Ltd. is found to be acceptable and the consequent disallowance resulting in addition to income made for Rs.19,39,60,866/-, is directed to be deleted."

4.

The ITAT by its judgment dated 16th May, 2014 relied on the self-same reasoning and dismissed the appeal of the revenue. Likewise, the High Court by the impugned judgment dated 5th July, 2017, affirmed the judgments of the CIT and ITAT as concurrent factual findings, which have not been shown to be perverse and, therefore, dismissed the appeal stating that no substantial question of law arises from the impugned order of the ITAT.

5.

In these circumstances, the Review Petitions are dismissed."

92.

Thus, not providing the opportunity of cross examination of the person whose statements are relied upon for making the additions is not acceptable in the facts of the case. The entire case of the revenue hinges upon the presumption that the cash was received by the assessee from MEPL. However, this presumption or suspicion how strong it may appear to be true but needs to be corroborated by some evidence to establish a link. It is quite a trite law that suspicion howsoever strong may be but cannot be the basis of addition except for some material evidence on record. The theory of 'preponderance of probability' is applied to weigh the evidences of either side and draw a conclusion in favour of a party which has more favourable factors in his side. The conclusions must be drawn on the basis of certain admitted facts and materials and not on the basis of presumption of facts that might go against assessee. Once nothing has been proved against the assessee with aid of any direct material especially when various rounds of investigation have been carried out, then nothing can be implicated against the assessee. Except relying upon the statements of Shri Manoj Kandpal, the AO has made no enquiries to support the allegation of cash received by the assessee. It is also a matter of fact that no material whatsoever, was found/seized as a result from the possession of the assessee or from MEPL indicating any such cash payment to the assessee in the year under appeal. Thus, before making the allegation of receipts of such cash, burden was on the AO to bring on record material to support the allegation by making independent enquiries and investigation which has not been done in the instant case. It is a settled law that documentary evidences will always carry more weight than the oral statements, particularly when such oral statements were proved to be incorrect by filing documentary evidences. Thereafter burden is shifted upon the AO to prove the documentary evidence to be untrue/ bogus/ non genuine which in the instant case, the AO has miserably failed to do so.

93.

The Hon'ble Delhi High Court in the case of Fair Invest Ltd reported in 357 ITR 146 has held as under:

"6.

This Court has considered the submissions of the parties. In this case the discussion by the CIT(Appeals) would reveal that the assessee has filed documents including certified copies issued by the Registrar of Companies in relation to the share application, affidavits of the Directors, Form 2 filed with the ROC by such applicants confirmations by the applicant for company's shares, certificates by auditors etc. Unfortunately, the assessing officer chose to base himself merely on the general inference to be drawn from the reading of the investigation report and the statement of Mr. Mahesh Garg. To elevate the inference which can be drawn on the basis of reading of such material into judicial conclusions would be improper, more so when the assessee produced material. The least that the assessing officer ought to have done was to enquire into the matter by, if necessary, invoking his powers under Section 131 summoning the share applicants or directors. No effort was made in that regard. In the absence of any such finding that the material disclosed was untrustworthy or lacked credibility the assessing officer merely concluded on the basis of enquiry report, which collected certain facts and the statements of Mr. Mahesh Garg that the income sought to be added fell within the description of Section 68."

94.

The Hon’ble Delhi High court in the case of PCIT (Central)-3 vs. Anand Kumar Jain (HUF), ITA No. 23/2021 [Delhi High Court – 12.02.2021] has held as under:

“8.

Next, we find that, the assessment has been framed under section 153A, consequent to the search action. The scope and ambit of section 153A is well defined. This court, in CIT v. Kabul Chawla,1 concerning the scope of assessment under Section 153A, has laid out and summarized the legal position after taking into account the earlier decisions of this court as well as the decisions of other High Courts and Tribunals. In the said case, it was held that the existence of incriminating material found during the course of the search is a sine qua non for making additions pursuant to a search and seizure operation. In the event no incriminating material is found during search, no addition could be made in respect of the assessments that had become final. Revenue’s case is hinged on the statement of Mr. Jindal, which according to them is the incriminating material discovered during the search action. This statement certainly has the evidentiary value and relevance as contemplated under the explanation to section 132(4) of the Act. However, this statement cannot, on a standalone basis, without reference to any other material discovered during search and seizure operations, empower the AO to frame the block assessment. This court in Principal Commissioner of Income Tax, Delhi v. Best Infrastructure (India) P. Ltd.,2 has inter-alia held that:

“38.

Fifthly, statements recorded under Section 132(4) of the Act do not by themselves constitute incriminating material as has been explained by this Court in Harjeev Aggarwal.3”

10.

Now, coming to the aspect viz the invocation of section 153A on the basis of the statement recorded in search action against a third person. We may note that the AO has used this statement on oath recorded in the course of search conducted in the case of a third party (i.e., search of Pradeep Kumar Jindal) for making the additions in the hands of the assessee. As per the mandate of Section 153C, if this statement was to be construed as an incriminating material belonging to or pertaining to a person other than person searched (as referred to in Section 153A), then the only legal recourse available to the department was to proceed in terms of Section 153C of the Act by handing over the same to the AO who has jurisdiction over such person. Here, the assessment has been framed under section 153A on the basis of alleged incriminating material (being the statement recorded under 132(4) of the Act). As noted above, the Assessee had no opportunity to cross-examine the said witness, but that apart, the mandatory procedure under section 153C has not been followed. On this count alone, we find no perversity in the view taken by the ITAT. Therefore, we do not find any substantial question of law that requires our consideration.”

95.

In the case of Smt. S. Jayalakshmi Ammal [2016] 74 taxmann.com 35 (Madras) the Hon’ble High Court has held that mere statement is not enough to make addition, the relevant observations are as under:

"...While adverting to the above, we are of the considered view that, for deciding any issue, against the assessee, the Authorities under the Income Tax Act, 1961 have to consider, as to whether there is any corroborative material evidence. If there is no corroborating documentary evidence, then statement recorded under Section 132(4) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, alone should not be the basis, for arriving at any adverse decision against the assessee. If the authorities under the Income Tax Act, 1961, have to be conferred with the power, to be exercised, solely on the basis of a statement, then it may lead to an arbitrary exercise of such power. An order of assessment entails civil consequences. Therefore, under judicial review, courts have to exercise due care and caution that no man is condemned, due to erroneous or arbitrary exercise of authority conferred...."

"...If the assessee makes a statement under Section 132(4) of the Act, and if there are any incriminating documents found in his possession, then the case is different. On the contra, if mere statement made under Section 132(4) of the Act, without any corroborative material, has to be given credence, than it would lead to disastrous results. Considering the nature of the order of assessment, in the instant case characterized as undisclosed and on the facts and circumstances of the case, we are of the view that mere statement without there being any corroborative evidence should not be treated as conclusive evidence against the maker of the statement..."

96.

Before us, Revenue has failed to controvert the arguments of the assessee and findings given by ld. CIT(A) while deleting the additions, by placing on record any contrary material which could suggest that during the year under appeal, assessee had received cash of INR 84.00 crores from MEPL nor any evidence of unaccounted sale or under billing was found/seized as a result of search. Thus in view of above discussion and by respectfully following the judicial pronouncements as referred herein above of the hon’ble Supreme court and various high courts including the jurisdictional high court, we find no error in the order of ld. CIT(A) in deleting the additions so made. Accordingly, Ground of appeal No.3 raised by the Revenue is dismissed.

97.

Ground of appeal No.4 of the Revenue is with respect to the deletion of transfer pricing adjustment on account of delayed payment of receivables of INR 33,04,951/-.

98.

Heard the contentions of both the parties and perused the material available on record. The TPO has made the adjustment on account of notional interest by holding trade receivable as interest free loan to its AE’s. As per the ld. CIT DR, once the payment was delayed, AO/TPO has rightly made adjustment. On the contrary, it was the claim of the assessee that international transactions carried out are in the normal course of business and most of the receivables were released within the agreed credit terms and the minor delay occurred were due to Covid-19 Pandemic. The assessee further claimed that the sales have been made to AEs at a higher price so as to adjust the component and delayed payment if any. Once higher margins was taken on the sales made to AE’s, as per the assessee, there was no requirement for making any adjustment on account of outstanding receivables. Reliance is placed on the judgment of Hon’ble Jurisdictional High court in the case of Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax-V v. Kusum Health Care Pvt. Ltd. reported in [2017] (4) TMI 1254 (Delhi).

99.

After carefully examined the facts, it is observed that the assessee has not made any adjustment on account of delayed payment whereas TPO has made the adjustment of INR 33,04,951/-by applying interest rate of 6.02% by taking LIBOR + 300 basis points for foreign exchange fluctuation. The AO computed the interest for the delayed period between the invoices date and date of receipt of payment. Ld. CIT(A) appreciated the fact that assessee has already factored the cost incurred on delayed payment by charging high margin which was included in the sales price of the material sold to its AE’s as compared to the sale price charged from non-AEs. The assessee has demonstrated that it had claimed 30% high rates from the AE’s as compared to sales made to non-AE thus, delayed payment has already been considered in the sale price charged. Ld. CIT(A) further observed that no adjustment was made on this account in preceding assessment years where the assessments were completed u/s 143(3) of the Act. The observations of ld. CIT(A) while deleting the additions made are as under:-

Conclusion regarding Interest on delayed receivables

The assessment order, the transfer pricing order, and the detailed submissions of the Authorized Representative (AR), along with the judicial precedents relied upon have been carefully considered. The Assessing Officer/TPO has made an adjustment of ₹33,04,951 on account of alleged interest on delayed realization of receivables from Associated Enterprises (AEs). The TPO applied an interest rate of 6.002%, calculated by adopting LIBOR + 300 basis points and further enhanced by additional 100 basis points towards foreign exchange fluctuation, and computed the interest for the period between the invoice date and the date of receipt of payment.

The AR submitted that the delay in realization of export proceeds, if any, was minor and purely commercial in nature, and was largely attributable to unprecedented disruptions caused by the COVID-19 pandemic, which severely affected global supply chains and financial systems. It was argued that such temporary and abnormal delays cannot be equated with financing arrangements so as to warrant a separate interest adjustment.

It was further contended that the TPO has erred in observing that the assessee failed to provide transaction-wise FAR (Functions, Assets and Risks) analysis for AE transactions. On the contrary, as per AR, the assessee had duly submitted the transaction-wise FAR analysis during the transfer pricing proceedings, which has also been specifically referred to in the submissions filed before the TPO.

The AR also highlighted that the average sale price to AEs was ₹362.13 per kg, whereas the average sale price to non-AEs was ₹253.22 per kg, resulting in a premium of ₹108.91 per kg, which works out to approximately 30.70% higher realization from AEs. It was submitted that this premium adequately compensates for any alleged delay in realization and inherently factors in the working capital impact. Therefore, as per AR, making a separate adjustment for interest on receivables would amount to double taxation, which is impermissible under transfer pricing principles.

It was also pointed out that the TPO has wrongly relied upon the RBI Master Circular dated 1 July 2010 relating to External Commercial Borrowings and Trade Credits. As per AR, the said circular applies to long-term borrowings with an average maturity of 3 to 5 years, whereas in the present case, the credit period ranged from 120 days with maximum extending up to 150 days, and delayed

payments ranging from 4 to 341 days. It was also clarified by the AR that the said circular was applicable on long term borrowings with average maturity 3 to 5 years whereas, the present case was only related to short term trade receivables and not long-term borrowings as considered by the TPO. Hence, as per AR, the reliance on the said circular is clearly misplaced and unjustified.

The AR further submitted that the same issue had arisen in earlier assessment years and was consistently decided in favour of the assessee by the CIT(A). No distinguishing facts have been brought on record by the AO to deviate from the settled position, and therefore, the principle of consistency also supports the assessee’s case.

The assessee also placed reliance on several judicial precedents, including the decision of Technip Energies India Limited, (formerly known as Technip India Limited) Versus Additional Commissioner of Income Tax, Special Range-9, New Delhi reported in 2025 (9) TMI 1189 - ITAT DELHI and the judgment of 2017 (4) TMI 1254 - DELHI HIGH COURT Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax-V Versus Kusum Health Care Pvt. Ltd. wherein it was held that once working capital adjustment is factored into the pricing of international transactions, no separate adjustment for interest on receivables is warranted. As per AR, the Delhi High Court further held that merely because receivables remain outstanding beyond a particular period, it does not automatically give rise to an international transaction warranting a separate benchmarking of interest.

Further, as per AR, the Delhi High Court in the case of 2024 (7) TMI 1338 - DELHI HIGH COURT, the Commissioner of Income Tax - International Taxation -1 Versus A.T. Kearney Ltd. held that in case the impact of receivables on working capital is already subsumed in the pricing of the main transaction then making a separate adjustment on receivables would distort the arm’s length analysis. It shall be relevant to go through the findings of order of CIT(A) in appeal No. CIT(A), Delhi-29/10172/2018-19 in assessee’s own case for AY 2016-17, wherein, the said issue has been handled in detail. The relevant part of the order dated 12.08.2025 of CIT(A) is reproduced below for ready reference:

“The appellant has also stated that Ld. CIT(A)-29, Delhi in Appeal No. 363/2016-17/CIT(A)-29 vide order dated 22.01.2018 in assessee’s own case while adjudicating the above issue has decided the matter in favor of assessee. The relevant paras of the order of the Ld. CIT(A) are reproduced below for ready reference:

“6.1

In connection with the trade receivable, the appellant has given a detailed submission. The important question herein whether the interest on trade receivable is an international transaction or not. In this regard, the appellant has relied upon the judgment of Hon’ble Delhi High Court in the case of CIT vs. Kusum Health Can Pvt. Ltd. ITA No. 765/2016, the relevant portion of judgment is reproduced as under:

“Para 10. The Court is unable to agree with the above submissions. The inclusion in the Explanation to Section 928 of the Act of the expression “receivables” does not mean that de hors the context every item of “receivables” appearing in the accounts of an entity, which may have dealings with foreign AEs would automatically be characterized as an international transaction. There may be a delay in collection of monies for supplies made, even beyond the agreed limit, due to a variety of factors which will have to be investigated on a case to case basis. Importantly, the impact this would I have on the working capital of the Assessee will have to be studied. In other words, there has to be a proper inquiry by the TPO by analyzing the statistics over a period of time to discern a pattern which would indicate that vis-à-vis the receivables for the supplies made to an AE, the arrangement reflects an international transaction intended to benefit the AE in some way.

Para 11 The Court finds that the entire focus of the AO was on just one AY and the figure of receivables in relation to that AY can hardly reflect a pattern that would justify a TPO concluding that the figure of receivables beyond 180 days constitutes an international transaction by itself. With the Assessee having already factored in the impact of the receivables on the working capital and thereby on its pricing/profitability vis-à-vis that of its comparable, any further adjustment only on the basis of the outstanding receivables would have distorted the picture and re-characterized the transaction. This was clearly impermissible in law as explained by this Court in CIT v. EKL Appliances Ltd. (2012) 345 ITR 241 (Delhi).

Consequently, the Court is unable to find any error in the impugned order of the ITAT giving rise to any substantial question of law for determination. The appeal is, accordingly, dismissed."

6.2

In the instant case, it is seen that the appellant has already factored in the interest components as the average realization of the product from other customer is Rs.274.44 per kg. whereas from the AE the average price realization is Rs.298.74. Therefore, following the judgment of Hon'ble Delhi High Court (Supra), I agree with the contention of the appellant with regard to deemed interest on trade receivable from AE that the same is not an international transaction and any further adjustment on the basis of outstanding receivable is not permissible under the law."

The Hon'ble High Court of Delhi in the case of Principal Commissioner of Income-tax vs. Global Logic India Ltd. reported at [2024] 166 taxmann.com 171 (Delhi) has held as under:

Section 92B of the Income-tax Act, 1961 - Transfer Pricing - International transaction, meaning of (Lending or borrowing/capital financing) - Assessment years 2010-11 and 2012-13 - Assessee-company was a debt free entity - It had sold certain goods to its AE and received sale proceeds after a delay of 218 days and up to 417 days - Assessing Officer held that deferred payment system followed by assessee amounted to an international transaction under clause (c) of Explanation (i) placed at end of section 92B and, thus, notional interest was to be levied on assessee - Tribunal held that when outstanding receivables was not a separate international transaction, delay in realization of sale proceeds was incidental to transaction of sale and as such no notional interest could be levied by treating same as unsecured loan and furthermore when assessee was not charging interest from unrelated third party/non-AE, in case of such delay, no adjustment on interest in case of AE can be made - Whether since Assessing Officer had clearly failed to examine or answer issue of international transactions bearing in mind Explanation (i)(c) of section 92B, there was no justification to interfere with view expressed by Tribunal - Held, yes [Para4] [In favour of assessee]"

Further, the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi in the case of Principal Commissioner of Income-tax vs. AT&T Communication Services India (P.) Ltd. reported at [2025] 171 taxmann.com 688 (Delhi) has held as under:

“Section 92B of the Income-tax Act, 1961 - Transfer Pricing - International transaction, meaning of (Lending or borrowing/Capital financing) - Assessment years 2010-11 and 2012-13 - TPO treated outstanding receivables from AE as separate international transaction and imputed interest on same - Tribunal held that outstanding receivables was not a separate international transaction - It was noted that in case similar to assessee, High Court held that since assessee was undisputedly a debt free company and it was not case of TPO that borrowed funds had been appropriated enabling AE to make delayed payment on receivables, outstanding receivables was not a separate international transaction and delay in realization of sale proceeds was incidental to transaction of sale and, thus, no notional interest could be levied by treating same as unsecured loan - Whether thus, following aforesaid view there was no justification to interfere with view taken by Tribunal - Held, yes [Para 3] [In favour of assessee]”

Further, the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi in the case of Principal Commissioner of Income Tax vs. Kusum Health Care (P) Ltd. reported at [2018] 98 taxmann.com 431 (Delhi), has held as under:

“The inclusion in the Explanation to section 92B of the expression 'receivables' does not mean that de hors the context every item of 'receivables' appearing in the accounts of an entity, which may have dealings with foreign associated enterprises, would automatically be characterized as an international transaction. There has to be a proper inquiry by the Transfer Pricing Officer by analyzing the statistics over a period of time to discern a pattern which would indicate that vis-a-vis the receivables for the supplies made to an associated enterprise, the arrangement reflects an international transaction intended to benefit the associated enterprise in some way. The figure of receivables in relation to only one assessment year could hardly reflect a pattern that would justify a Transfer Pricing Officer concluding that the figure of receivables beyond 180 days constituted an international transaction by itself.”

Section 92B of the Income-tax Act, 1961 - Transfer pricing - International transaction, meaning of (Working capital adjustment) - Assessment year 2010-11 - When assessee had already factored in impact of receivables on working capital and thereby on its pricing/profitability vis-à-vis that of its comparables, any further adjustment only on basis of outstanding receivables would distort picture and recharacterize transaction which is not permissible [In favour of assessee]

The above decision of the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi has been affirmed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in SLP No. 2297/2018. In view of the above decisions of the Hon'ble Supreme Court and the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi, the contentions of the appellant are found acceptable and addition made on the said issue is deleted. Accordingly, these grounds of appeal are allowed.”

In view of the above facts, judicial precedents, and considering that the higher sale price charged to AEs already includes the impact of delayed realization, it is held that no separate adjustment on account of interest on receivables is called for. Accordingly, the addition of ₹33,04,951 made by the AO/TPO on account of interest on delayed receivables is hereby deleted. Accordingly, these grounds of appeal are partly allowed.

100.

As observed above, the hon’ble Delhi High Court in the case of Kusum Health Care Pvt. Ltd. (supra) has held that once working capital adjustment is factored into the price of international transactions, no separate adjustment on receivables is warranted. In the instant case, assessee has been able to demonstrate that it had already charged margin of more than 30% from its AE’s as against the sales made to non-AE’s thus, has already factored the working capital adjustment on account of delayed payment of receivables. This being so, we find no error in the order of ld. CIT(A) in deleting the adjustment made on account of delayed payment of receivables. Accordingly, Ground No.4 raised by the Revenue is dismissed.

101.

Ground of appeal No.6 of the Revenue is with respect to the deletion of addition of INR 2.40 crores made towards rent paid on farm house taken by the assessee and used as its guest house.

102.

Brief facts leading to this ground of appeal are that disallowance of INR 2.40 crores was made by the AO being rent paid to Smt. Rashmi Chaturvedi, wife of the Chairman of the assessee company, Shri Ashok Chaturvedi. The AO observed that this house was utilized for the purpose of personal residence cum office of the Chairman and has no relationship with the business of the assessee company and therefore, rent paid is not for the purpose of business and he made the disallowance which was deleted by ld. CIT(A).

103.

Before us, ld. CIT DR for the Revenue vehemently supported the order of AO and submits that the assessee has failed to establish that the said property was taken by the assessee company for the purpose of business and was utilized by the Chairman of the assessee company for his personal use, therefore, the AO has rightly made the disallowance of the rent paid to Smt. Rashmi Chaturvedi and he prayed accordingly.

104.

On the other hand, ld.AR for the assessee vehemently supported the order of ld. CIT(A) and submits that the assessee has taken the farm house owned by the spouse of the Chairman on lease of 20 years and filed the broad resolution and the Lease Agreement. The property was taken on rent under commercial expediency and for the purpose of business and small part of the house was used for the residence of the chairman and remaining part was used as guest house of the company. Ld.AR further submits that in the hands of Chairman, value of perquisite attributable to such residential house has already been brought to tax as part of salary income which fact remained uncontroverted. Ld. AR further stated that rental income was duly disclosed by the recipient i.e. Smt. Rashmi Chaturvedi. In the last, it was submitted by ld.AR that rent payment on the same property was made in AYs 2013-14 to 2018-19 where this payment was not doubted by the AO, thus, as a principal of consistency, it should be allowed as claimed.

105.

Heard the contentions of both the parties at length and perused the material on record. The claim of the assessee was that major portion of the house was used for guest house where foreign clients used to stay and official meetings are conducted with them. A small portion of the house was used for the residence of the Chairman which consists of 02 bed rooms and kitchen which were separately identified and perquisite value of the same has duly been taxed in the hands of Shri Ashok Chaturvedi, chairman of the assessee company. Ld. CIT(A) after considering these facts, has deleted the addition by making following observations:-

(c) Disallowance of rental expenses in respect of Farm House

As per AR, the Assessing Officer, at page no. 104 of the assessment order, has made a disallowance of ₹2.40 crores on account of rent paid for a farm house taken on lease from Smt. Rashmi Chaturvedi, who is the spouse of Shri Ashok Chaturvedi, Chairman of the company. The AR submitted that the farmhouse [12:44, 20/08/2026] AMIT KUMAR: was taken on lease by the appellant company and was primarily used as a camp office for business purposes. It was explained by the AR that only a limited portion of the farm house was used as residential accommodation by the Chairman, while the major portion was utilized for official purposes such as business meetings and hosting of clients. It was further submitted by the AR that the portion used for residential purposes, comprising only two bedrooms and a kitchen, was separately identified, and the perquisite value of the same was duly taxed in the hands of Shri Ashok Chaturvedi. As per AR, the Chairman was paid salary and house rent allowance amounting to 72 lakhs, and the corresponding residential use had already been offered to tax as part of his salary income. Thus, as per AR, there was no revenue loss to the Department. The AR also pointed out that the appellant is a large multinational company with a consolidated turnover of approximately 7,685 crores, operating across various locations in India, outside India and having subsidiaries in several foreign countries. As per AR, considering the scale and nature of business, frequent visits of foreign customers, business associates, and high-net-worth dignitaries are inevitable. As per AR, the farmhouse is regularly used for hosting such foreign clients and for conducting official business meetings. It was further submitted by the AR that the same issue had been examined by the Assessing Officer in earlier years. Additionally, as per AR, the transaction was also scrutinized under domestic transfer pricing provisions by the TPO for assessment years 2013-14 to 2018-19. In all those years, no adverse inference was drawn, and no disallowance was made. As per AR, there being no change in facts or circumstances during the year under consideration, the AR pleaded that the principle of consistency should be followed. The AR also relied upon the lease agreement entered into with Smt. Rashmi Chaturvedi, copies of which were duly furnished before the AO. It was clarified that the rental income was duly offered to tax in the hands of Smt. Rashmi Chaturvedi. The AR contended that the disallowance was made merely on surmises and without appreciating the business necessity and supporting evidences such as board resolutions and past acceptance by the Department. Accordingly, it was prayed that the disallowance of ₹2.40 crores be deleted.”

106.

Before us, Revenue has failed to controvert the findings given in order of ld. CIT(A) that partial uses of the property by the Chairman for his residential house has already been suffered taxes as perquisite and the Revenue has not denied the use of the remaining part of the house as guest house purposes where the same was used for stay of foreign clients and conducting the business meetings.

107.

Considering the overall facts and circumstances of the case, we find no error in the order of ld. CIT(A) in deleting the disallowances made by AO. Accordingly, Ground of appeal No.6 raised by the Revenue is dismissed.

108.

Ground of appeal No.7 raised by the Revenue is with respect to the disallowance of deduction claimed u/s 80IB of the Act on other receipts such as insurance claim, remission, write back of liabilities, scrap sales, purchase discounts and other miscellaneous income.

109.

Heard the contentions of both the parties at length and perused the material on record. The allegation of the AO was that the assessee has claimed deduction u/s 80IB of the Act @ 30% on the profits of the eligible unit situated at Jammu identified as “Unit-3”. The AO has not disputed the eligible unit however, disallowed the claim to the extent of INR 58,97,071/- being 30% of the other receipts which according to AO, were not earned from the eligible unit. The claim of the assessee was that other receipts comprising of insurance claim, remission write back of liabilities, scrap sales, purchase discounts and other incidental receipts which are directly related to manufacturing activity and therefore, are eligible for the deduction u/s 80IB of the Act. It is observed that deduction u/s 80IB was claimed since Unit-3 had started commercial production and income generated was offered for tax. The AO had made the disallowance by making similar allegation with respect to other income and the Co-ordinate Bench of Delhi Tribunal has allowed the same vide its order for AY 2011-12 and such order has been accepted by the Revenue. Thereafter, the deduction claimed on such other income was never doubted. Thus, following the principal of consistency, deduction as claimed should be allowed. Ld. CIT(A) has appreciated these facts and deleted this disallowance by making following observations:-

(b) Disallowance of Deduction under Section 80-IB

“The appellant claimed deduction of 12,71,90,249/- under section 80-IB in respect of profits earned by Jammu Unit-3, an eligible industrial undertaking, which earned total profits of 42,39,67,495/-. The deduction was computed at the statutory rate of 30% and was duly supported by Form 10CCB in accordance with Rule 18BBB. The Assessing Officer has not disputed the eligibility of the unit, the correctness of the audited books of account, or the computation of profits. As per AR, the sole dispute raised by the Assessing Officer relates to the treatment of certain components classified under the head "other income," which were erroneously held to be ineligible for deduction under section 80-IB.

The Assessing Officer disallowed a sum of 58,97,071/-, being 30% of certain receipts, on the ground that such income was not "derived from" the eligible business. As per AR, this finding is legally unsustainable, as the Assessing Officer failed to appreciate the true nature and source of the receipts. As per AR, the interest income amounting to 43,84,434/- was voluntarily excluded by the appellant from the eligible profits and was offered to tax under the head "Income from Other Sources." As per AR, despite this, the Assessing Officer again treated the same amount as ineligible while computing the disallowance, resulting in an impermissible double disallowance.

The remaining components of "other income," excluding interest income, comprise scrap sales, purchase discounts, insurance claims, write-back of liabilities, remission of customs duty, and other incidental receipts. As per AR, all these receipts arise directly from and are intrinsically linked to the manufacturing operations of the eligible unit. As per AR, scrap sales represent proceeds from by-products generated during the manufacturing process and are taxable as business income under section 28. As per AR, scrap cannot exist independently of manufacturing activity and has consistently been held to be eligible for deduction under section 80-IB in the appellant's own case in earlier years, including Assessment Year 2011-12, as confirmed by the Hon'ble ITAT, with no reversal by any higher forum.

As per AR, purchase discounts arise in the normal course of procurement of raw materials and effectively reduce the cost of inputs. Such discounts are embedded in the manufacturing cost structure and do not constitute independent income. As per AR, merely because these receipts are presented separately in the accounts does not alter their character as business income. As per AR, identical receipts were allowed in earlier assessment years, including Assessment Year 2013-14, and the principle of consistency requires the same treatment to be followed in the year under consideration.

As per AR, insurance claims received on account of damage to raw materials represent compensation for business losses incurred in the ordinary course of manufacturing operations. As per AR, such receipts substitute trading losses and are taxable as business income under section 28 or section 41(1). As per AR, the direct nexus between the insurance claim and the manufacturing activity is undisputed, and the levy of GST on such receipts further reinforces their business character. As per AR, these receipts have also been allowed as eligible for deduction in earlier years and confirmed by the Ld. ITAT.

As per AR, the write-back of liabilities amounting to 1,20,465/-pertains to liabilities originally incurred for the import of raw materials. As per AR, such write-back signifies the cessation of a business liability and is deemed to be business income undersection 41(1) of the Act. As per AR, the Hon'ble Delhi High Court in CIT-III v. Shri Vardhman Overseas Ltd. (2011) has categorically held that such write-backs constitute business income. As per AR, these receipts directly impact the cost of inputs and profitability of the eligible undertaking and therefore satisfy the "derived from" test undersection 80-IB.

As per AR, the remission of customs duty and insurance claim aggregating to 3,03,872/-represent receipts that either reduce the cost of imported raw materials or compensate business losses. As per AR, both are revenue receipts arising directly from manufacturing operations and form an integral part of business profits. As per AR, the Assessing Officer's attempt to segregate these receipts and deny deduction is contrary to the settled legal position and the object of section 80-IB, which is to promote industrial activity.

It is submitted by the AR that the expression "derived from" used in section 80-IB requires a direct nexus between the receipt and the eligible business. As per AR, all the aforesaid receipts arise solely because the manufacturing activity exists and are commercially inseparable from the business of the eligible undertaking. As per AR, the narrow interpretation adopted by the Assessing Officer defeats the legislative intent and ignores binding judicial precedents as well as consistency followed in the appellant's own case.”

110.

As observed above, the claim of the assessee was consistently been allowed by the Revenue and never disputed in the orders passed u/s 143(3) of the Act. The assessee has placed reliance on the following judgments with respect to the other income on which disallowance has been made:-

Sl.No.ComponentJudgement Relied upon
1.Scrap Sales

(i). [2011] 11 taxmann.com 322 (Delhi) High Court of Delhi, Commissioner of Income-tax-III v. Sadhu Forging Ltd. (Refer page no. 1294-1298 of the case law PB).

ii. High Court of Delhi, Commissioner of Income-tax vs. Dabur India Ltd. [2024] 161 taxmann.com 202 (Delhi) [12-03-2024] (Refer page no. 1430-1434 of the case law PB).

iii. [2014] 42 taxmann.com 403 (Gujarat) High Court of Gujarat, Commissioner of Income-tax v. Jikar A Saiyed (Refer page no. 1299-1301 of the case law PB).

iv. [2023] 151 taxmann.com 246 (Gujarat) High Court of Gujarat, Principal Commissioner of Income-tax v. Reckitt Benckiser Healthcare India Ltd.

v. [2014] 48 taxmann.com 90 (Delhi) High Court of Delhi, Commissioner of Income-tax (C)-III v. Flakes-N-Flavourz, New Delhi (Refer page no. 1315-1319 of the case law PB).

vi. Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax vs. Reckitt Benckiser Healthcare India P. Ltd. [2025] 176 taxmann.com 573 (Ahmedabad - Trib.) [16-07-2025] (Refer page no. 1302-1310 of the case law PB).

vii. 2024 (11) TMI 818 - ITAT MUMBAI M/s. Hindustan Unilever Limited Versus Dy. CIT-1(1)(2), Mumbai and vice versa (Refer page no. 1320-1337 of the case law PB).

2.Other Misc. Income (Discount on Purchase of Raw Materials)

viii. High Court of Gujarat, Commissioner of Income-tax-II vs. Metrochem Industries Ltd. [2017] 79 taxmann.com 440 (Gujarat) / [2016] 389 ITR 181 (Gujarat) [19-07-2016] (Refer page no. 1338-1353 of the case law PB).

ix. High Court of Punjab and Haryana, Commissioner of Income-tax, Ludhiana vs. Metalman Auto (P.) Ltd. [2011] 11 taxmann.com 51 (Punjab & Haryana) /[2011] 199 Taxman 149 (Punjab & Haryana) (Mag.) / [2011] 336 ITR 434 (Punjab & Haryana) [11-02-2011] (Refer page no. 1354-1359 of the case law PB).

3.Insurance claim on Damage of Raw material

x. Commissioner of Income-tax vs. Meghalaya Steels Ltd. [2016] 67 taxmann.com 158 (SC) / [2016] 238 Taxman 559 (SC) / [2016] 383 ITR 217 (SC)/[2016] 284 CTR 321 (SC) [09-03-2016) (Refer page no. 1360-1373 of the case law PB).

xi. Commissioner of Income-tax-III vs. Sportking India Ltd. [2009] 183 Taxman 312 (Delhi)/[2010] 324 ITR 283 (Delhi) [19-08-2009) (Refer page no. 1311-1314 of the case law PB).

xii. [2000] 108 Taxman 524 (Madras) High Court of Madras, Commissioner of Income-tax v. Needle Industries (India) Ltd. (Refer page no. 1426-1429 of the case law PB).

xiii. [2005] 144 Taxman 109 (Punjab & Haryana) High Court of Punjab and Haryana, Commissioner of Income-tax v. Khemka Container (P.) Ltd. (Refer page no. 1374-1375 of the case law PB).

xiv. Commissioner of Income-tax-IV vs. Shree Rama Multi Tech Ltd. [2013] 33 taxmann.com 194 (Gujarat)/(2013] 215 Taxman 90 (Gujarat) (Mag.) (28-01-2013] (Refer page no. 1376-1378 of the case law PB).

4.Write-back of Liability (Import of Raw Materials)xv. Gujarat Industries Power Co. Ltd. vs. Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax [2023] 157 taxmann.com 243 (Ahmedabad - Trib.) [28-07-2023]- where it is held that Section 80-IA of the Income-tax Act, 1961 Deductions - Profit and gains from infrastructure undertakings (Sundry creditors) Assessment years 2009-10 to 2012-13 - Assessee-company was engaged in business of generation and sale of power Whether income arising on account of writing back balances of sundry creditors having direct nexus with income derived from business of industrial undertaking was eligible for deduction under section 80-IA Held, yes [Para 18] [In favour of assessee) (Refer page no. 1379-1388 of the case law PB).
5.Other Misc. Non-Operating Income (Remission of Custom duty and Insurance claim)

xvi. Commissioner of Income-tax vs. Dharam Pal Prem Chand Ltd. [2009] 180 Taxman 557 (Delhi) / [2009] 317 ITR 353 (Delhi) / [2009] 221 CTR 133 (Delhi) [27-11-2008] (Refer page no. 1389-1396 of the case law PB).

xvii. Commissioner of Income-tax, Delhi-IV vs. Eltek SGS (P.) Ltd. [2008] 169 Taxman 283 (Delhi) / [2008] 300 ITR 6 (Delhi) / [2008] 215 CTR 279 (Delhi) [19-02-2008] (Refer page no. 1397-1401 of the case law PB).

xviii. [2010] 189 Taxman 39 (JP.) (Mag.) ITAT Jaipur Bench 'B', Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Circle-1, Jaipur v. Poddar Associates (Refer page no. 1402-1404 of the case law PB).

xix. Suzlon Energy Ltd. vs. Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax [2013] 32 taxmann.com 349 (Ahmedabad Trib.) / [2012] 20 ITR(T) 391 (Ahmedabad Trib.) / [2013] 57 SOT 54

(Ahmedabad Trib.) (URO) [21-09-2012) (Refer page no. 1405-1425 of the case law PB).

111.

Considering the facts that the other income was generated from the regular manufacturing activity of and Revenue has failed to bring on record any material to hold that such income was not derived from the eligible undertaking therefore, we find no reason to interfere in the order of ld. CIT(A) allowing deduction u/s 80IB on such other income who has followed the orders of the coordinate bench in assessee’s own case in the first year of the claim of deduction u/s 80IB of the Act. Accordingly, Ground of appeal No.7 raised by the Revenue is dismissed.

112.

Ground of appeal Nos.8 to 10 raised by the Revenue are general in nature hence, not adjudicated.

113.

In the result, appeal of the assessee is partly allowed and appeal of the Revenue is dismissed for AY 2020-21.

114.

Now we take appeals of the assessee IT(TP)A No.260/Del/2026 and appeal of the Revenue in ITA No.5367/Del/2026 for Assessment Year 2021-22.

IT(TP) No.260/Del/2026 [Assessee’s appeal] & ITA No.5367/Del/2026 [Revenue’s appeal]

[Assessment Year 2021-22]

115.

The Additions made by the AO and deleted /sustained by ld. CIT(A) are tabulated as under:

S.No.ParticularsAY 2021-22
Addition By AOSustained by CIT(A)Deleted by CIT(A)
1.Addition u/s 68 Unexplained unsecured loans25,25,00,0004,00,00,00021,25,00,000
2.Addition u/s 69C ---Estimated commission50,50,0008,00,00042,50,000
3.Disallowance of deductionu/s 80-IB1,91,21,7768,00,0001,83,21,776
4.Disallowance of rent expense2,04,00,000NIL2,04,00,000
5.Addition of unexplained cash receipts u/s 69A84,00,00,000NIL84,00,00,000
6.Enhancement on account of Arm’s Length Price determined by TPO on Corporate Guarantee Commission41,15,310NIL41,15,310
7.Enhancement on account of Arm’s Length Price determined by TPO on Interest on receivables5,49,35,98925,54,6365,23,81,353
116.

In Ground of appeal No.1, the assessee has challenged the order passed u/s 143(3) r.w.s.144B of the Act since there was a search carried out in the case of the assessee after 01.04.2021 thus in terms of the amended provisions, the proceedings should have been completed u/s 148 of the Act as provided in Explanation 2(i) to section 148 of the Act.

117.

Heard the contentions of both the parties at length and perused the material on record. At the outset, it is observed that this issue has been considered and decided by us in afore-mentioned paras while disposing the Gound of appeal No. 1 of the assessee in ITA No.259/Del/2026 for AY 2020-21. Before us, both the parties are fairly admitted that facts are identical in the present case also. Thus, by respectfully following the observations as made in ITA No.259/Del/2026 for AY 2020-21 which are Mutatis Mutandis applicable to the facts of present case also we held that the order passed u/s 143(3) r.w.s. 144B of the Act is invalids and thus quashed. The Ground of appeal No.1 raised by the assessee is allowed.

118.

Though we have allowed the legal ground taken by the assessee and quashed the assessment order passed u/s 143(3) dt. 20.02.2025 however, in the interest of justice, the other grounds of appeal taken on the merits of the additions made/ deleted are decided as under:

119.

Ground of appeal Nos. 2 to 8 of the assessee are with respect to the confirmation of the additions of INR 4.00 crores on account of unsecured loans treating the same as unexplained credit u/s 68 of the Act out of total addition of INR 25.25 crores made by the AO. The Revenue is also in appeal against the deletion of the addition of INR 21.25 crores in Ground of appeal No.1 & 2.

120.

During the year under appeal, the assessee has taken total unsecured loans of INR 65.00 crores from 24 parties out of which the loans taken from 10 parties, totaling to INR 25.25 crores were alleged as unexplained credit and addition was made u/s 68 of the Act and further addition of INR 50.50 Lakhs was made u/s 69C as alleged commission paid on such accommodation entries of unsecured loans.

121.

In first appeal, ld. CIT(A) has confirmed the addition to the extent of INR 04.00 crores of the loans taken from three lender companies namely, Pravesh Credit & Securities Ltd. of INR 1.50 crores; Radha Fincom Ltd. of INR 1.00 crore; and Supriya Fincom Ltd. of INR 1.50 crores and remaining addition of INR 20.25 crores of the loans taken from 07 different lender companies were deleted.

122.

Aggrieved by the said order, both the parties are in appeal before the Tribunal. It is observed that additions sustained by ld. CIT(A) of the loans taken from three lender companies are common in AY 2020-21 where after considering the entirety of the facts, the addition sustained by the ld. CIT(A) stood deleted by us herein above while deciding the appeal of the assessee in IT(TP)A No. 259/Del/2026 for AY 2020-21 by holding that the loans taken from these parties are genuine loans. The observations made in IT(TP)A No.259/Del/2026 for AY 2020-21 are Mutatis Mutandis applicable to the facts of the present case therefore, by following the said observations, we delete the addition of INR 4.00 crores made u/s 68 and sustained by ld. CIT(A).

123.

Now coming to the additions deleted by ld. CIT(A) with respect to the 07 lender companies out of which loans taken from 05 lender companies tabulated as below are common in AY 2020-21:-[i] Kamalpur Finance Ltd. INR 1.00 crore [ii] Maharaj Ji Agro Products Pvt. Ltd. INR 3.5 crores [iii] Neelam Securities Marketing Pvt Ltd INR 1.00 crore [iv] Paritosh Electricals Pvt Ltd INR 25.00 Lakhs [v] Ricon Merchants Pvt Ltd INR 50.00 Lakhs

124.

The unsecured loans were taken also from above companies in immediately preceding AY 2020-21 wherein loans taken from these companies were held as unexplained credit by the AO. The same were deleted by ld. CIT(A) and while deciding the appeal of the Revenue in IT(TP)A No. 272/Del/2026 for AY 2020-21, we have confirmed the order of ld. CIT(A) treating the loans taken from these parties are genuine as the assessee has been able to establish the identity, creditworthiness and genuineness of the transactions. The observations made by us in IT(TP)A No. 272/Del/2026 are Mutatis Mutandis applicable to the facts of the present case therefore, by following the same observations, we confirm the order of ld. CIT(A) deleting the additions to the extent of INR 6.25 crores of the loans taken from the aforesaid 05 lender companies.

125.

Remaining loans of INR 15.00 crores taken from two companies namely M/s Hallow Securities Private Limited of INR 5.00 crore sand M/s Dhankalash Distributors Pvt. Ltd of INR 10.00 crores which were deleted by ld. CIT(A). Loans taken from these companies are decided as under:-

126.

Before us, ld. CIT DR for the Revenue vehemently supported the orders of the AO and submits that the AO has observed that the company M/s Hallow Securities Private Limited was identified as a shell company and its whereabout and other particulars have been discussed at length by the AO in para 8.12 to 8.18 wherein a reference was made to the statements of its Directors and further observed that the registered office is not available at the given address and other particulars were also discussed. Ld. CIT DR drew our attention to the assessment order para 8.1.4 which is the survey report given by the Assessing Unit wherein it is observed that no actual business was carried out by this company. Ld. CIT DR further referred the statement of Shri Ashish Begwani wherein he specifically admitted that the accommodation entries of loans were provided to Uflex Ltd. owned by Shri Ashok Chaturvedi and accordingly, ld. CIT DR requested for the confirmation of the loan taken from Hallow Securities as the same was established as bogus accommodation entries.

127.

With respect to the loan taken from M/s Dhankalash Distributors Pvt. Ltd, ld. CIT DR submits that the company has not responded to the notice issued u/s 133(6) of the Act. As per the AO, the information received that it was a Kolkata based company who had provided accommodation entries to M/s Hallow Securities Private Limited. Further ld. CIT DR for the Revenue submits that there were direct evidences found suggesting that M/s Dhankalash Distributors Pvt. Ltd. was used as a conduit to route the funds of M/s Hallow Securities Private Limited to camouflage the accommodation entries and therefore, requested for the confirmation of the same.

128.

On the other hand, ld.AR for the assessee vehemently supported the order of ld. CIT(A) and submits that in the case of the Allure Developer Pvt. Ltd., the Co-ordinate Delhi Bench of Tribunal has confirmed the order of ld. CIT(A) where after making inquiries from SFIO, it was concluded that no inquiry/investigation was pending against the M/s. Hallow Securities Pvt. Ltd. and it was a genuine NBFC. It was further observed by the Co-ordinate bench that M/s Hallow Securities Private Limited has received funds of INR 195.00 crores from a company Teesta Retails which is a NBFC of Reliance Group. Ld. CIT(A) after considering these facts, deleted the addition made towards the loans taken from both the companies i.e. M/s Hallow Securities Private Limited and M/s Dhankalash Distributors Pvt. Ltd. It was further submitted by ld.AR that the Co-ordinate Bench in the case of DCIT vs M/s. Bright Buildtech Pvt.Ltd. for AY 2020-21 in ITA No.4106/Del/2025 has held the loan taken from M/s Dhankalash Distributors Pvt. Ltd. as genuine. Ld.AR thus, submits that ld. CIT(A) has rightly deleted the additions which orders be upheld.

129.

Heard the contentions of both the parties at length and perused the material on record. The ld. CIT(A) while deleting the addition, has made following observations:-

(i)

Hallow Securities Pvt. Ltd. Rs. 5,00,00,000

The Assessing Officer has made an addition of ₹5 crore in respect of the loan raised by the appellant from Hallow Securities Pvt. Ltd. The Assessing Officer held that the lender company is a shell company and relied upon the press release issued by Ministry of Finance dated 08.06.2018, thereby treating the lender as a non-genuine entity. This office had conducted an inquiry with Hallow Securities Pvt. Ltd. in the case of Allure Developers Pvt. Ltd. in Appeal No. CIT (Appeal), Noida-3/10037/2018-19 for AY 2019-20 and as per the information received, it is noticed that Hallow Securities Pvt. Ltd. has regularly filed its statutory returns with the ROC and RBI. Further, inquiries were also made with SFIO under section 250(4) in the case of Allure Developers Pvt. Ltd. in Appeal No. CIT (Appeal), Noida-3/10037/2018-19 for AY 2019-20 and as per the response received from SFIO, no investigation is pending or has been disposed of against Hallow Securities Pvt. Ltd. It is further noticed that during the year under consideration, the lender company had received ₹195 crore from M/s Teesta Retails Pvt. Ltd. an entity connected to Reliance Group, and the said transaction has been considered as genuine by the AO during the assessment proceedings in the ACE Group of companies. The AO has relied upon the statement of Ashish Begwani recorded in the year 2017 to support his contentions regarding the loan received from Hallow Securities Pvt. Ltd. by the assessee. Further, the AO has delved into the financials of Hallow Securities Pvt. Ltd. and the role of its directors etc. It is further seen that the AO has placed reliance on the statement of Shri Ashish Begwani recorded on 23.01.2017 and Ramesh Poddar recorded on 12.06.2014 but the said statements pertain to year 2014 and 2017 respectively and no direct nexus could be established by the AO with respect to impugned transactions for AY 2021-22. No statements of the said persons have been recorded during the present search, nor has any incriminating material been unearthed linking the appellant's loan transaction to any alleged accommodation entry activity. The AO has also stated that notice u/s 133(6) was not served upon M/s. Hallow Securities Pvt. Ltd. and premises was not found. But it is seen that search was also conducted on M/s. Hallow Securities Pvt. Ltd., statements of Directors were also recorded leading to framing of assessment orders in the cases of the said concern. Even during the course of passing of assessment orders in the ACE group of companies, the credits received by Hallow Securities Pvt. Ltd. from genuine sources like Teesta Retails Pvt. Ltd. and HFCL were excluded by the AO meaning thereby that existence of Hallow Securities Pvt. Ltd. as a legal entity was not doubted. Without prejudice to the above discussion and without making any observations on the credibility of Hallow Securities Pvt. Ltd., it is observed that the ultimate source of funds received by the appellant company is out of unsecured loan raised by Hallow Securities Pvt. Ltd. from MN Ventures Pvt. Ltd. The AO has already made an addition of Rs. 10 crores in the hands of Hallow Securities Pvt. Ltd. during the AY 2021-22 in assessment order passed u/s 144 r.w.s. 263 dated 09.03.2026 and it is noticed that out of the said money, Rs. 5 crores was advanced to the appellant. The relevant bank account statement of M/s. Hallow Securities Pvt. Ltd. is scanned below for ready reference:

Picici Bank Your Security With Us: M/S.HALLOW SECURITIES PVT LTD 9 LSC, MASRD MOTH,MASRD MOTH, GREATER KAILASH PART -2 NEW DELHI OFF 10 - INDIA - 110048 Your Base Details: 0.24.68.7.5.1.4.7.4.7.4.7.4.7.4.7.4.7.4.7.4.7.4.7.4.7.4.7.4.7.4.7.4.7.4.7.4.7.4.7.4.7.4.7.4.7.4.7.4.7.4.7.4.7.4.7.4. Summary of Account as on 22-09-2020 L Operative Account in INR

Type of AccountAccount NumberService (N.T.)MCSICLNumber
11.00.38.819.28 Cr1.00.38.819.28 Cr
TOTAL1.00.38.819.28 Cr

Statement of transactions in Current account number: 022505006192 in INR For the period 22-09-2020 To 22-09-2020

DateTransactionCreditAmountAmountAmountAmount
22-09-20200702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-07020.0010,000.0010,000.00
22-09-20200702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-00.000.000.00
22-09-20200702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-00.000.000.00
22-09-20200702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-00.000.000.00
22-09-20200702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-0702-00.000.000.00

Legends for transactions in your account statement VAT/MAT/NFS - Cash withdrawal at other Bank ATM's EBA - Transaction on ICICI direct VPS/NPS - Debit card transaction TOP - Mobile recharge INF - Internet fund transfer in linked accounts BIL - Internet Bill payment or funds transfer to Third party

Uflex Limited, AY 2020-21

The said bank statement must have been available with the AO while framing the assessment order in the case of Hallow Securities Pvt. Ltd. and in the case of assessee itself. In above circumstances, once the amount of Rs. 10 crores has been taxed in the hands of Hallow Securities Pvt. Ltd. in AY 2021-22 and the amount of Rs. 5 crores advanced to the assessee emanates from the same sum of Rs. 10 crores, taxing the receipt in the hands of assessee would tantamount to double taxation.

The Hon'ble High Court of Delhi in the case of Principal Commissioner of Income-tax-Central-1 vs. Surya Agrotech Infrastructure Ltd. reported at [2023] 154 taxmann.com 156 (Delhi) has held as under:

Where assessees were part of 'P' group of companies, which was subject to search operations, during which director of flagship company admitted that group of companies earned unaccounted income which was routed as bogus share capital, since such undisclosed income had already been surrendered to tax by flagship company and settled by order of Income-tax Settlement Commission, it could not again be subjected to tax in hands of assessee companies in form of application of said income as their share capital

Further, the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi in the case of Principal Commissioner of Income-tax (Central)-2 vs. Heritage Beverages (P.) Ltd. reported at [2024] 166 taxmann.com 217 (Delhi) has held as under:

Section 68 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 - Cash Credits - Assessment years 2009-10 and 2011-12 - Assessing Officer made addition under section 68 for unexplained share capital and share premium - Assessee contended that unexplained money which formed corpus of share application already stood taxed - Tribunal accordingly, deleted addition - It was noted that that an identical question arose for consideration in Pr. CIT-Central-1 v. Surya Agrotech Infrastructure Ltd. [2023] 154 taxmann.com 156/295 Taxman 745 (Delhi), where Coordinate Bench of this Court held that once a company had paid tax on its unaccounted income, same money could not be subjected to tax again in form of share capital - Held, yes - Whether in view of said decision addition under section 68 deserves to be deleted - Held, yes [Paras 4 and 6] [In favour of assessee]

Further, the Ld. Chandigarh Bench of ITAT in the case of SGARG Enterprises P. Ltd., vs. the DCIT, Central Circle-1, Chandigarh in ITA No. 96/Chd/2023 has held as under:

11.

The Id. CIT(A), while confirming the addition, has observed that the assessee did not furnish copies of ITR of Shri Sunny Garg and that no explanation regarding the source of credits in the bank account of Shri Sunny Garg was furnished. We find that the ITR in the case of Shri Sunny Garg was filed on 30.03.2023, i.e., after the passing of the order of the Id. CIT(A), on 18.01.2023, in the case of the assessee. In pursuance of the ITR, assessment order in the case of Shri Sunny Garg stands independently passed on 30.05.2023, where the ITR was filed on 30.03.2023. The amount of Rs.16,97,000/- stands assessed in the hands of Shri Sunny Garg, Director of the assessee company. Therefore, there is no occasion for assessing the

Uflex Limited, AY 2020-21 same in the hands of the assessee as this would amount to double taxation, which is impermissible in law.

Further, the Ld. Tribunal Bench of Kolkata in the case of ONE Point Commercial Pvt. Ltd. vs. ITO, Wad 6(3), Kolkata in ITA No. 473/Kol/2019 has held as under:

18.

From going through the above details, we notice that alleged share applicants have been subjected to additions of approx. Rs.15.95 Cr. whereas the alleged sum in dispute before us is approx. 4.78 Cr. only. In the assessment orders of the alleged share applicants the source of source of share application money which has been received by the assessee has already been taxed in the hands of the share applicants and taxing the same again in the hands of the assessee would tantamount to double additions. Our attention was drawn to the judgment of the Hon'ble Apex court in the case of Mahaveer Kumar Jain (supra) wherein the Hon'ble Court has held as under:

"It is a fundamental rule of law of taxation that, unless otherwise expressly provided, income cannot be taxed twice. Furthermore, a taxing Statute should not be interpreted in such a manner that its effect will be to cast a burden twice over for the payment of tax on the taxpayer unless the language of the Statute is so compelling that the court has no alternative than to accept it. In a case of reasonable doubt, the construction most beneficial to the taxpayer is to be adopted. So, it is clear enough that the income in the present case is taxable only under one law. By virtue of clause (k) to Article 371 F of the Constitution which starts with a nonobstante clause, it would be clear that only the Sikkim Regulations on Income-tax would be applicable in the present case. Therefore, the income cannot be brought to tax any further by applying the rates of the IT Act."

19.

Considering the ratio laid down by the Hon'ble Apex Court and on finding that the alleged share applicants have been subjected to substantial addition, we find merit in the second fold of argument of the Ld. Counsel for the assessee and, therefore, on this ground also the impugned addition u/s. 68 of the Act is uncalled for. We accordingly, set aside the finding of the Ld. CIT(A) and delete the addition u/s. 68 of the Act made by the AO. Effective grounds of appeal of the assessee raised are allowed."

From above, it appears that the money added in the income of the appellant emanates out of the funds which have already been added in the hands of M/s. Hallow Securities Pvt. Ltd. So, once the credits stand added to the income in the case of Hallow Securities Pvt. Ltd., the money emanating out of the said credits which has been routed to the appellant cannot be taxed u/s 68. Therefore, in view of the above facts and circumstances, the addition made in respect of the loan received from Hallow Securities Pvt. Ltd. is not sustainable and is hereby deleted.

(ii)

Dhankalash Distributors Pvt. Ltd. Rs. 10,00,00,000

The Assessing Officer has made an addition in respect of unsecured loan of ₹10 crore raised by the appellant from Dhankalash Distributors Pvt. Ltd. The Assessing Officer alleged that the lender company failed to respond to the notice issued under section 133(6) and further held that the said company was acting as a pass-through entity for Hallow Securities Pvt. Ltd.

The appellant has submitted that non response to notice u/s 133(6) cannot be the only criteria to disregard the creditworthiness of an entity. The appellant further stated that during the assessment proceedings, the appellant had filed audited financial statements and Income-tax Return of the lender vide reply dated 20.03.2024 bearing acknowledgement No.148193831200324. Refer Page No 99-124 of PB. The appellant further submitted that the relevant supporting documents of the lender were also filed before the AO and the same have been enclosed at Page No. 95, 134 (Confirmation), 96-98, 125 (bank statement, 126-129 (Form 16A), 130-132, 135-137 (loan agreements), 146-147 (Post-dated cheques) of the Paper Book for ready reference.

During the appellate proceedings, the AR submitted that Dhankalash Distributors Pvt. Ltd. had duly responded to the statutory notice in the case of Bright Buildtech Pvt. Ltd. for AY 2020-21 before the same AO, and therefore the Assessing Officer was fully aware of the existence and functioning of the said company. The AR further submitted that the assessment order of Hallow Securities Pvt. Ltd. for AY 2021-22 has already been passed and no adverse finding has been recorded in the hands of Hallow Securities Pvt. Ltd. in respect of receipt of funds from Dhankalash Distributors Pvt. Ltd. Therefore, as per AR, branding Dhankalash Distributors Pvt. Ltd. as a pass-through entity without any substantive addition or conclusive finding is not sustainable.

It is further observed that the appellant has duly shown the identity of the lender, genuineness of the transaction and creditworthiness of the lender by furnishing documentary evidences such as copy of audited financial statements, bank statements, MCA records and other supporting documents. The AR also submitted that the appellant had initially raised the loan in the year 2020 and the same has subsequently been repaid, and the copy of the ledger account reflecting the said repayment has also been placed on record in the paper book.

The AR further clarified that Dhankalash Distributors Pvt. Ltd. is engaged in issuing inter-corporate deposits (ICDs) and possesses sufficient financial strength. It has been shown that the company has share capital of ₹2,44,65,160 and reserves and surplus of ₹63,68,87,497, aggregating to shareholders' funds of approximately ₹66 crore. It was also explained that the company has issued CCDs aggregating to about ₹400 crore, out of which ₹20 crore was invested during the year under consideration.

It is also noticed that the lender company has made investments of around ₹97 crore in reputed companies such as Vodafone Idea Ltd. and Vipul Securities Ltd., which further shows its financial capacity.

The issue of creditworthiness of M/s. Dhankalash Distributors Pvt. Ltd. has been examined in detail in the appellate case of Ajay Realcon Pvt. Ltd. for AY 2020-21 in Appeal No. CIT (Appeal), Noida-3/10017/2019-20 vide order dated 22.03.2025, wherein it has been observed that the company possesses adequate financial strength and creditworthiness. The creditworthiness of the lender can be analyzed from the chart reproduced below:

Sr. No.AYIncome (In Rs.)Shareholder funds (In Rs.)Other Income / Revenue (In Rs.)Other Expenses (In Rs.)Long Term Borrowings (In Rs.)Trade Payable (In Rs.)Non-Current Investments (In Rs.)
1.2018-1949,21,867/- (Loss)89,24,38,2693,85,41,45143,81,00,3022,57,70,27411,43,10,00042,46,18,073
2.2019-207,15,99,930 (Loss)79,16,15,7714,22,96,7925,21,13,55310,22,00,00018,09,20034,61,80,228
3.2020-215,53,59,160 (Loss)64,93,63,942(6,83,99,751)1,36,00,178204,89,14,88110,000124,23,47,336
4.2021-2252,22,232 (Under MAT)66,13,52,6578,68,56,63431,74,873217,32,87,0942,14,52,199125,31,34,488
5.2022-233,79,96,065 (Book Profit Under MAT)69,89,87,28736,01,7421,97,85,5524,11,00,0001,86,03,203197,32,05,094

In view of the above facts and evidences placed on record, it is evident that the identity of the lender, genuineness of the transaction and creditworthiness of the lender stand duly proved. Further, the repayment of the loan has also been established through documentary evidence. Also, the Ld. ITAT Bench of Delhi in the case of Bright Buildtech Pvt. Ltd. for A.Y. 2021-22 in ITA No. 4106/Del/2025 vide order dated 27.11.2025 has treated Dhankalash Distributors Pvt. Ltd. as genuine and deleted the addition of ₹25 lakhs. The relevant part of the order of the Ld. ITAT Bench is reproduced below for ready reference:

"10.

Ground of appeal No.3 raised by the Revenue is with respect to deletion of loan of INR 25,00,000/- taken from M/s. Dhankalash Distributors Pvt. Ltd. which was made by the AO by holding the same as bogus unsecured loan.

11.

We have heard the rival contentions and perused the material available on record. AO has made the addition by doubting the creditworthiness of the lender company and further observed that source of source is not established. AO observed that company has low income as compared to the loan given to the assessee. Accordingly, the AO has made the addition by holding the same as bogus accommodation entries. The claim of the assessee is that during the course of assessment proceedings, it had submitted copy of ITR, bank statement and confirmation of lender. Regarding the source of source, it was the submission of

Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
130.

It is observed that assessee has filed all the relevant details and in the case of both the companies, the Co-ordinate Bench of Delhi Tribunal in the case of Allure Developers Ltd. (supra) and in Bright Buildtech Pvt. Ltd (supra) has already held the loans taken from these companies as genuine. Further in the case of loan taken from M/s Hallow Securities Private Limited, Co-ordinate Bench has referred some inquiries conducted from SFIO according to which no investigation was pending against this company. Moreover, the source in the hands of M/s Hallow Securities Private Limited were found to be from genuine sources and it is not the year where the “source of source” are required to be explained.

131.

It is also a matter of fact that by making similar allegations, loans taken from various parties including certain parties from whom loans were taken in this year also, additions were made u/s 68 of the Act in immediately preceding assessment year i.e. in AY 2020-21 where the additions so made stood deleted by us, while deciding the appeal of the assessee herein above, in IT(TP)A No. 259/Del/2026 and of the revenue in IT(TP)A No. 272/Del/2026 which observations are Mutatis Mutandis applicable to the facts of the present case. Accordingly, by following the same, we hereby deleted the total additions made of INR 25.25 crores u/s 68 of the Act which includes the additions sustained by the ld. CIT(A). Accordingly, Grounds of appeal Nos. 2 to 8 of the assessee are allowed and Grounds of appeal Nos.1 & 2 of the Revenue are dismissed.

132.

Ground of appeal No.9 of the assessee is with respect to the confirmation of addition of INR 50.50 Lakhs made u/s 69C of the Act by alleging the said as commission paid on the alleged accommodation entries on unsecured loans.

133.

Heard the contentions of both the parties at length and perused the material on record. At the outset, it is observed that this issue has been considered and decided by us in afore-mentioned paras while disposing the appeal of the assessee in ITA No.259/Del/2026 for AY 2020-21. Before us, both the parties are fairly admitted that facts are identical in the present case also. Thus, by respectfully following the observations as made in ITA No.259/Del/2026 for AY 2020-21 which are Mutatis Mutandis applicable to the facts of present case also therefore, Ground of appeal No.9 raised by the assessee is allowed.

134.

Ground of appeal No.10 is with respect to the confirmation of addition of INR 25,54,636/- towards corporate guarantee commission by applying 0.50 % as against 0.40 % benchmarked by the assessee.

135.

Heard the contentions of both the parties at length and perused the material on record. Addition of similar nature by making identical observations were made in immediately preceding assessment year i.e. in AY 2020-21 wherein the AO has made the adjustment on account of corporate guarantee commission by applying 2.10% rate which has been reduced by 0.50% by ld. CIT(A) in respect to corporate guarantee given for Flex Africa and deleted the corporate guarantee commission given for Flex Egypt & Flex USA. Similarly, in the year under appeal, AO/TPO made adjustment of INR 5,49,35,989/- by benchmarking the transaction by taking 1.50% rate of fee as against 0.40% benchmarked by the assessee. Ld. CIT(A) had deleted the adjustment made with respect to the corporate guarantee given to Flex Egypt and Flex USA however, sustained the addition of INR 25,54,663/- computed @ 0.50% on the corporate guarantee given to Flex Africa.

136.

Before us, both the parties have fairly admitted that facts are identical with the facts of immediately preceding assessment year thus, by respectfully following our observations made in IT(TP)A No. 259/Del/2026 in assessee’s appeal and in Revenue’s appeal in IT(TP)A No. 272/Del/2026, wherein we have held that the transaction benchmarked by the assessee by taking 0.40% rate is fair and reasonable accordingly, deleted the adjustment made and upheld by ld. CIT(A). Such observations are followed Mutatis Mutandis in the present case also. Accordingly, the adjustment so sustained of INR 25,54,636/- is hereby, deleted. Ground of appeal No.10 of the assessee is thus, allowed.

137.

Ground of appeal No.11 is with respect to the adjustment of INR 1,60,92,66,164/- made by the AO in the book profit u/s 115JB of the Act.

138.

Heard the contentions of both the parties at length and perused the material on record. It is observed that AO has not provided computation sheet based on which adjustment was made in the book profit therefore, AO is directed to provide the same to the assessee so as to enable the assessee to take the necessary action in this matter.

139.

Now coming to remaining grounds of in Revenue appeal in ITA No.5367/Del/2026 for Assessment Year 2021-22.

140.

Ground of appeal Nos.3 & 4 raised by the Revenue is with respect to the deletion of addition of INR 84.00 crores made on account of unexplained cash credit u/s 69A of the Act.

141.

Heard the contentions of both the parties at length and perused the material on record. At the outset, both the parties have fairly admitted that the issue under appeal is identical with the issue involved in AY 2020-21 in revenue’s appeal in IT(TP)A No. 272/Del/2026 wherein we have confirmed the order of ld. CIT(A) deleting the addition made by the AO and the observations made therein are Mutatis Mutandis applicable to the facts of the present case. Thus, by following the said observations, we confirm the order of ld. CIT(A) deleting of addition of INR 84.00 crores on account of alleged cash received from M/s. Montage Enterprises Pvt. Ltd. Accordingly, Ground of appeal No.3 & 4 raised by the Revenue are dismissed.

142.

Ground of appeal No.5 raised by the Revenue is with respect to the deletion of addition on account of transfer pricing adjustment of INR 41,15,310/- made towards interest on delayed payment on outstanding receivables against AEs and Ground of appeal No.6 raised by the Revenue is with respect to the restriction of ALP of Corporate Guarantee commission to 0.50% as against 1.50% determined by TPO.

143.

Heard the contentions of both the parties at length and perused the material on record. At the outset, it is observed that both the issues have been decided by us in afore-mentioned paras while disposing the appeal of the assessee in IT(TP)A No. 259/Del/2026 and of the Revenue in IT(TP)A No. 272/Del/2026 for AY 2020-21. Before us, both the parties fairly admitted that facts are identical in the present appeals also. Thus, by following the observations as made in IT(TP)A Nos. 259 & 272/Del/2026 for AY 2020-21 which are Mutatis Mutandis applicable in the present case also, the additions so made by AO are deleted. Accordingly, Grounds of appeal No.5 & 6 raised by the Revenue are dismissed.

144.

Ground of appeal No.7 raised by the Revenue is with respect to the deletion of addition of INR 2.04 crores made on account of rent paid of the farm house owned by the spouse of the chairman of the assessee by alleging the same was used for business purposes.

145.

Heard the contentions of both the parties at length and perused the material on record. At the outset, it is observed that this issue has been considered and decided by us in afore-mentioned paras while disposing the appeal of the Revenue in ITA No.272/Del/2026 for AY 2020-21. This fact is fairly admitted by both the parties. Thus, by following the observations as made in ITA No.272/Del/2026 for AY 2020-21 which are Mutatis Mutandis applicable to the facts of present case also, the order of ld. CIT(A) deleting the disallowance is hereby confirmed. Accordingly, Ground of appeal No.7 raised by the Revenue are dismissed.

146.

Ground of appeal No.8 raised by the Revenue is with respect to the deduction u/s 80IB of the Act on account of insurance claims, remission or write back of liabilities, scrap sales, purchase discounts and other miscellaneous receipts.

147.

Heard the contentions of both the parties at length and perused the material on record. At the outset, it is observed that this issue has been considered and decided by us in afore-mentioned paras while disposing the appeal of the Revenue in ITA No.272/Del/2026 for AY 2020-21. This fact is fairly admitted by both the parties. Thus, by following the observations as made in ITA No.272/Del/2026 for AY 2020-21 which are Mutatis Mutandis applicable to the facts of present case also, the order of ld. CIT(A) deleting the disallowance is hereby confirmed. Accordingly, Ground of appeal No.8 raised by the Revenue are dismissed.

148.

Ground of appeal Nos. 9 & 10 raised by the Revenue are general in nature hence, not adjudicated.

149.

In the result appeal of the assessee in IT(TP)A 260/Del/2026 is allowed and appeal of the revenue in ITA No. 5367/Del/2026 is dismissed.

150.

Now we take assessee’s appeal in ITA No.280/Del/2026 for Assessment Year 2022-23.

IT(TP)A No.280/Del/2026 [Assessment Year 2022-23]

[Assessee’s appeal]

151.

The Additions made by the AO and deleted /sustained by ld. CIT(A) are tabulated as under:

S.No.ParticularsAY 2022-23
Addition By AOSustained by CIT(A)Deleted by CIT(A)
1.Addition u/s 68 Unexplained unsecured loans20,35,00,00010,50,00,0009,85,00,000
2.Addition u/s 69C ---Estimated commission40,70,00021,00,00019,70,000
3.Disallowance of deductionu/s 80-IBNILNILNIL
4.Disallowance of rent expense2,07,60,000NIL2,07,60,000
5.Addition of unexplained cash receipts u/s 69A84,00,00,00084,00,00,000NIL
6.Enhancement on account of Arm’s Length Price determined by TPO on Corporate Guarantee Commission56,41,069NIL56,41,069
7.Enhancement on account of Arm’s Length Price determined by TPO on Interest on receivables2,66,73,71924,24,883.502,42,48,835.50
152.

In Ground of appeal No.1, the assessee has challenged the order passed u/s 143(3) r.w.s.144B of the Act since there was a search carried out in the case of the assessee after 01.04.2021 thus in terms of the amended provisions, the proceedings should have been completed u/s 148 of the Act as provided in Explanation 2(i) to section 148 of the Act.

153.

Heard the contentions of both the parties at length and perused the material on record. At the outset, it is observed that this issue has been considered and decided by us in afore-mentioned paras while disposing the Ground of appeal No. 1 of the assessee in ITA No.259/Del/2026 for AY 2020-21. Before us, both the parties are fairly admitted that facts are identical in the present case also. Thus, by respectfully following the observations as made in ITA No.259/Del/2026 for AY 2020-21 which are Mutatis Mutandis applicable to the facts of present case also we held that the order passed u/s 143(3) r.w.s. 144B of the Act is invalids and thus quashed. The Ground of appeal No.1 raised by the assessee is allowed.

154.

Though we have allowed the legal ground taken by the assessee and quashed the assessment order passed u/s 143(3) dt. 22.05.2025 however, in the interest of justice, the other grounds of appeal taken on the merits of the additions made/ deleted are decided as under:

155.

Grounds of appeal Nos. 2 to 7 raised by the assessee which are related to the confirmations of addition of INR 10.50 crores made u/s 68 of the Act on account of loan taken from Pravesh Credit and Securities Ltd. of INR 3.50 crores; Radha Fincom Ltd. of INR 1.00 crore; Supriya Fincom Ltd. of INR 3.50 crores; Premnarayan Mercantile Pvt.Ltd. of INR 50.00 Lakhs and First Agri-Tech Pvt. Ltd. of INR 2,00 crores.

156.

Heard the contentions of both the parties at length and perused the material on record. Before us, both the parties have fairly admitted that additions of identical nature on account of loan taken from these parties were made in AYrs 2020-21 & 2021-22 wherein while deciding the appeal of both the parties for AY 2020-21 in ITA No. 259/Del/2026 [Assessee’s appeal] and in ITA No.272/Del/2026 [Revenue’s appeal], detailed discussion on the facts and argument made by both the parties were considered and after considering the same, additions sustained by ld. CIT(A) were deleted and further action of ld. CIT(A) in deleting the addition with respect to the loans taken was also confirmed, resulting into the deletion of the entire additions made by the AO. Thus, by respectfully following the observations as made in captioned appeals for AY 2020-21 which are Mutatis Mutandis applicable to the facts of the present case therefore, Grounds of appeal Nos. 1 to 7 raised by the assessee are allowed.

157.

Ground of appeal No.8 raised by the assessee is with respect to the confirmation of addition of INR 21.00 Lakhs made u/s 69C on account of alleged commission paid for obtaining the accommodation entries of unsecured loans.

158.

Heard the contentions of both the parties at length and perused the material on record. At the outset, it is observed that this issue has been considered and decided by us in afore-mentioned paras while disposing the appeal of the assessee in ITA No.259/Del/2026 for AY 2020-21. Before us, both the parties have fairly admitted that facts are identical in the present case also. Thus, by respectfully following the observations as made in ITA No.259/Del/2026 for AY 2020-21 which are Mutatis Mutandis applicable the Ground of appeal No.8 raised by the assessee is allowed.

159.

Ground of appeal No.9 raised by the assessee is with respect to the confirmation of addition of INR 24,24,883.50 towards transfer pricing adjustment on corporate guarantee commission by adopting 0.50% instead of 0.40% benchmarked by the assessee.

160.

Heard the contentions of both the parties at length and perused the material on record. At the outset, it is observed that this issue has been considered and decided by us herein above, while disposing the appeal of the assessee in ITA No.259/Del/2026 for AY 2020-21. Before us, both the parties have fairly admitted that facts are identical in the present case also. Thus, by respectfully following the observations as made in ITA No.259/Del/2026 for AY 2020-21 which are Mutatis Mutandis applicable, the addition sustained by ld. CIT(A) of INR 24,24,883.50 is hereby, deleted. Accordingly, Ground of appeal No.9 raised by the assessee is allowed.

161.

Ground of appeal Nos. 10, 11 & 12 raised by the assessee are with respect to the confirmation of addition of INR 84.00 crores based on the material found during the course of search on the third party i.e. MEPL.

162.

In Ground of appeal No.10, the assessee has challenged the additions made in the order passed u/s 143(3) without initiating the proceedings u/s 148 with respect to the documents found from the possession of third party and without following proper procedure as provided in Clause (iv) of Explanation (2) to section 148 of the Act. In Grounds of appeal Nos. 11 & 12 assessee has challenged the additions on merits.

163.

Brief facts of the case are leading to this issue are that a search and seizure action u/s 132 was carried out in the case of Montage Enterprises on 21.02.2023. During the course of search, certain incriminating material in the shape of diaries marked as Annexure D-1 to D-39 was found and seized. The AO based on the entries found noted in the said diaries and further relying upon the statement of one Shri Manoj Kandpal, an employee of MEPL, alleged that the assessee company has received cash of INR 84.00 crores (INR 7.00 crores monthly) and made the addition for the same by treating the same as undisclosed income of the assessee. IN first appeal the same was confirmed by ld. CIT(A).

164.

Before us, it is submitted by the ld. AR that the impugned addition was made in the order passed u/s 143(3) of the Act though the material relied upon was found from the possession from the third party and further search u/s 132 of the Act was also carried out in its own case on 21.02.2023 therefore, no addition could be made for the documents found from the possession of third person during the course of search in the case of such other party without following the procedure as provided in section 148 Explanation (2) clause (iv) of the Act.

165.

Ld.AR thus, submits that addition made to be deleted. In this regard, reliance is placed on the judgment of Co-ordinate Bench of Chandigarh “A” Bench in the case of Homelife Buildcon (P.) Ltd. Vs DCIT [2025] 176 taxmann.com 614 (Chandigarh-Trib.) dated 17.07.2025 wherein Co-ordinate Bench has held that after 01.04.2021 if the documents found and seized from the possession of third person and considered as belonged to or pertained to the assessee, due procedure as provided u/s 148 Explanation (2) should be followed wherein the approval from Competent Authority has to be taken which is the prerequisite and mandatory. He thus, prayed that in the instant case additions made on the basis of entries alleged as found noted during the search in the case of MEPL without following the due procedure deserves to be deleted.

166.

On the other hand, Ld. CIT DR for the Revenue supported the orders of lower authorities and submits that once the assessment proceedings were initiated by issue of notice u/s 143(2) of the Act, the AO can make the addition for the information available before him which was gathered in the course of search in the case of third party and therefore requested to confirm the additions so made.

167.

Ld. CIT DR further placed reliance on the provision of section 292C of the Act which makes clear that presumption is that seized documents belong to the assessee and contents of the documents are true and correct and therefore, he requested for confirmation of the order of lower authorities.

168.

Heard the contentions of both the parties and perused the material available on record. Undisputedly, the order for the year under appeal was passed u/s 143(3) of the Act and while disposing the Ground of appeal No. 1 of the assessee, we have already held that the action of the AO in completing the assessment proceedings us/s 143(3) as invalid.

169.

Coming to the issue whether any addition can be made in the order passed u/s 143(3) based on some material found during the course of search conducted after 01.04.2021 in the case of third party, the answer is provided in sub clause (iv) of Explanation 2 of section 148 as existed at the relevant year. The Explanation (2) to section 148 as amended by Finance Act, 2021 is reproduced as under:-

"Explanation 2.-For the purposes of this section, where,-

(i)

a search is initiated under section 132 or books of account, other documents or any assets are requisitioned under section 132A, on or after the 1st day of April, 2021, in the case of the assessee; or

(ii)

a survey is conducted under section 133A, other than under sub-section (2A) or sub-section (5) of that section, on or after the 1st day of April, 2021, in the case of the assessee; or

(iii)

the Assessing Officer is satisfied, with the prior approval of the Principal Commissioner or Commissioner, that any money, bullion, jewellery or other valuable article or thing, seized or requisitioned under section 132 or section 132A in case of any other person on or after the Ist day of April, 2021, belongs to the assessee; or

(iv)

the Assessing Officer is satisfied, with the prior approval of Principal Commission Commissioner, that any books of account or documents, seized or requisitioned under section 132 or section 132A in case of any other person on or after the Ist day of April, 2021, pertains or pertain to, or any information contained therein, relate to, the assessee, the Assessing Officer shall be deemed to have information which suggests that the income chargeable to tax has escaped assessment in the case of the assessee for the "three assessment years" immediately preceding the assessment year relevant to the previous year in which the search is initiated or books of account, other documents or any assets are requisitioned or survey is conducted in the case of the assessee or money, bullion, jewellery or other valuable article or thing or books of account or documents are seized or requisitioned in case of any other person."

170.

From the above, it is clear that if any addition is to be made after recording the satisfaction that the documents found and seized during the course of search in the case of third pertained to assessee and some income has escaped assessment. Therefore, the action of the AO in ignoring the Explanation-2(iv) of Section 148 and not recording the satisfaction on the material found from the possession of third person and without taking approval of the Prescribed Authority of such satisfaction is bad in law. The Co-ordinate Bench of Chandigarh Tribunal in the case of Homelife Buildcon (P.) Ltd. (supra) has observed as under:-

20.

“We have gone through the additional ground of appeal as taken before us and also the assessment order, order of the CIT(A), written brief synopsis of the assessee on the issue of additional ground of appeal and also the arguments of the Ld. CIT DR. The facts are not in dispute viz-a-viz the facts that the search was conducted on the assessee on 16.11.2021 and also the fact that separate search was conducted on Sh. Ajay Prabhakar (Deed Writer) and Sh. Ravi Kapoor (Broker in real estate) and distinct and different Panchanama was drawn in their respective names in their cases. In so far as, the first issue regarding the passing of order u/s 143(3) instead, of framing the assessment u/s 147 is concerned, we find that after the search was conducted on 16.11.2021, the case was centralized on 11.03.2022 and the return of Income was filed by the assessee for Asstt. Year 2021-22 as per the extended time available on 5th of March 2022 and, thus, it is a case where the notice u/s 143(2) was issued after centralization of case and a sufficient time had passed from the date of search i.e. 16.11.2021 to the date of issue of notice u/s 143(2), dated 17th of June 2022 and the Assessing Officer was well aware of the information and material including, the material found and seized from the third parties namely Sh. Ajay Prabhakar and Sh. Ravi Kapoor and further to that, we have carefully gone through explanation -2 to section 147 as amended by Finance Act 2021 as ‘cited supra’, which clearly lays down the mandatory procedure to be followed in search assessment and which apparently has not been followed in the present case.

21.

The core question before the Bench is whether, in the facts and circumstances of the case, the assessment ought to have been framed under section 143(3) or under section 147 of the Income-tax Act, 1961. From the plain reading of the statutory provisions and in light of Explanation 2 to section 148, it becomes abundantly clear that the legislature has widened the scope of reassessment, particularly through the Finance Act, 2021, which introduced significant changes to the reassessment regime. These amendments explicitly include instances involving third-party search material and make it incumbent upon the Assessing Officer (AO) to follow the procedure under section 148, including obtaining prior approval from the Principal Commissioner of Income Tax (PCIT).

23.

In the present case, the AO proceeded to frame the assessment under section 143(3) despite relying heavily on material found during searches conducted on third parties. The AO, instead of complying with the jurisdictional preconditions laid down under the reassessment provisions, proceeded without recording the mandatory satisfaction and without obtaining prior sanction from the competent authority. This conduct not only, violates the express mandate of law, but also renders the assessment a jurisdictional error. The AO has, in fact, gone a step further by bypassing the legal safeguards embedded in section 147, thereby vitiating the assessment proceedings ab initio.

24.

Furthermore, a plain reading of the Finance Act, 2021 and the Explanatory Memorandum to the Finance Bill clearly indicates that the legislative intent was to bring all searches conducted on 20 or after 1st April 2021 within the ambit of the new reassessment regime under section 147 of the Income-tax Act, 1961. This new regime was introduced through significant amendments to section 147 and section 148, along with the insertion of Explanations 1 and 2, and the concept of "information suggesting escapement of income" was explicitly defined. From the reading of Explanation 2 to Section 147, it is evident that in cases where a search is initiated on or after 1st April 2021, the Assessing Officer shall be deemed to have information, which suggests that income chargeable to tax has escaped assessment for three assessment years immediately preceding the assessment year relevant to the previous year, in which, the search is initiated, provided that books of account, documents, assets, bullion, jewellery, or other valuable articles are seized or requisitioned in the course of the search. This deeming provision is not limited only to the person searched, but also extends to "other persons", provided that due procedure under the law-specifically, the recording of satisfaction that such seized material belongs to the assessee and obtaining prior approval from the PCIT-is followed.

25.

In the present case, where the AO has admittedly relied upon material seized during searches conducted on other persons, i.e., Sh. Ravi Kapoor and Sh. Ajay Kumar Prabhakar, it was mandatory for the AO to invoke the provisions of section 147 and not to bypass the statutory framework by proceeding under section 143(3). Granting such unfettered powers to the AO to rely on third-party material without adhering to the safeguards under section 147 would defeat the very purpose of the amendment and open the floodgates to arbitrary assessments.

26.

The relevant extract Memorandum explaining the finance bill is reproduced as under:-

‘(ii) Assessments or reassessments or in re-computation in cases where search is initiated under section 132 or requisition is made under 132A, after 31st March 2021, shall be under the new procedure.

(VI)

Further, in search, survey or requisition cases initiated or made or conducted, on or after 1st April, 2021, it shall be deemed that the Assessing officer has information which suggests that the income chargeable to tax has escaped assessment in the case of the assessee for the three assessment years immediately preceding the assessment year relevant to the previous year, in which, the search is initiated or requisition is made or any material is seized or requisitioned or survey is conducted.”

27.

The notice issued under section 143(2) was also produced by the AR. Upon perusal of the said notice, it is evident that the assessment under section 143(3) was initiated solely for the purpose of verifying the return of income filed by the assessee. In such circumstances, the importing and reliance upon material seized from third-party searches, namely, those conducted on Sh. Ajay Kumar Prabhakar and Sh. Ravi Kapoor, goes beyond the jurisdiction conferred under section 143(3). Particularly, where the applicable law— Explanation 2 to section 148 (as amended by the Finance Act, 2021) mandates prior approval from the Principal Commissioner of Income Tax (PCIT) before initiating reassessment proceedings on the basis of such material, the failure to comply with that requirement renders the assessment legally untenable.

28.

In the present case, the AO did not issue a notice under section 148, nor did he follow the due process of law under the new reassessment framework, including recording of satisfaction and obtaining prior sanction from the PCIT. Therefore, the assessment framed under section 143(3), because of being based on third-party material without adhering to statutory safeguards, is bad in law. The AO was only empowered to verify the return of income and restrict his scope of inquiry accordingly; he was not permitted to expand the assessment by importing and relying upon third-party seized material without following the mandatory procedure laid down under the law.

29.

Furthermore, there exists a mandatory statutory requirement that in all cases involving search-related assessments falling within the assessment year, immediately preceding the year of the search, the prior approval of the Joint Commissioner is required under section 148B of the Income-tax Act, 1961. In the present case, the Assessing Officer (AO) has proceeded without obtaining such approval, which is a clear violation of the procedural safeguards envisaged under the law and, as such, vitiates the assessment proceedings. In the present case, approval has been granted for assessment framed u/s 143(3) only. The relevant provision of section 148B reads as under:

Prior approval for assessment, reassessment or recompilation in certain case.

148B. No order of assessment or reassessment or recompilation under this Act shall be passed by an Assessing Officer below the rank of Joint Commissioner, in respect of an assessment year to which clause (i) or clause (ii) or clause (iii) or clause (iv) of Explanation 2 to section 148 apply except with the prior approval of the Additional Commissioner or Additional Director or Joint Commissioner or Joint Director.

30.

A comparison of the requirement of approval under section 153D and section 148B is drawn, from which it is evident that approval under section 153D was earlier required only in cases where assessments were completed under section 153A/153C and also for search year. However, under the amended provisions, approval under section 148B is now required in all cases where proceedings are initiated pursuant to a search, requisition, or survey, or where asset/material/documents found during such search pertain to or relate to another person. In such cases, the Assessing Officer must take the approval under section 148B from the specified higher authority.

Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
31.

This requirement has also been explicitly discussed in the Explanatory Memorandum to the Finance Bill, 2022, which emphasizes the need to protect taxpayer rights by ensuring that no reassessment is carried out without proper sanction and due process. It is further seen that the Joint Commissioner has not even been supplied seized material relied upon as seized from third party in the present assessment. There exists a prescribed procedure under which such seized material (including material found from third-party premises) is to be forwarded to the approving authority at least 30 days in advance of granting approval. This procedural safeguard is crucial to prevent arbitrary and unregulated use of third-party material.

32.

In the present case, there is no evidence to demonstrate that the prescribed procedure was followed, or that the Joint Commissioner was apprised of the seized material by forwarding copies of the documents found from the third party prior to framing the assessment. The complete failure to comply with the mandatory _provisions of section 148B renders the reassessment not only. procedurally defective but also without jurisdiction.

33.

Even we find while framing the assessment under section 143(3), the Assessing Officer (AO) has, on the last page of the assessment order, referred to an approval obtained from the supervisory authority. However, a bare perusal of this approval 25 shows that it was obtained in reference to F. No. 299/36/2020/1DAR/INV3(3)/577 dated 15.07.2022, i.e., in accordance with the CBDT Circular dated 15th July 2022, and not under the mandatory provisions of section 148B of the Income tax Act, 1961. At the outset, it is important to note that the approval so obtained does not mention or consider any of the seized materials sourced from the third-party. searches conducted on Sh. Ajay Kumar Prabhakar and Sh. Ravi Kapoor, despite the AO having heavily. relied on those materials in framing the additions. The approval merely states that the appraisal report was considered, without any reference to the original documents seized or to the statutory procedure outlined under section 148B. It is pertinent to refer to the Manual of Office Procedure in February 2003, which lays down a mandatory protocol: that in all search cases, especially where material pertains to persons other than the one searched, such material is to be forwarded in original to the approving authority, and a draft order is required to be submitted for approval at least 30 days in advance. In the present case, the approval letter was issued by the DCIT only on 22nd August 2023, which clearly contravenes this procedural requirement. This procedural lapse is further compounded by the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Serajuddin and Co. case, [2024] 163 taxmann.com 118 (SC) wherein it was held that in search cases, strict adherence to the approval protocol as laid down in the departmental Manual of Office Procedure in February 2003 and law is essential to uphold the validity of the assessment.

34.

Thus, from the above, it is quite evident from the approval granted by the Addl.CIT(Central), there is no mention or consideration of the seized material sourced from the third party, namely Sh. Ajay Prabhakar and Sh. Ravi Kapoor, though, we find that in the assessment order and in the order of CIT(A), both the authorities have heavily relied upon on such seized material and it only states that the appraisal report have been considered without any reference to any original documents seized for statutory procedure outlined u/s 148. Thus, in view of above, the assessment as framed by Assessing Officer vide order dated 24.08.2023 is quashed.”

171.

As observed above, in the instant case, the AO has not followed the procedure as provided in clause (iv) of Explanation 2 to section 148 of the Act and made the additions based on the entries alleged as found noted in the material seized from the possession of third person. Since no action of initiation of re-assessment proceedings was taken before making the additions and therefore, we are in agreement with the view taken by the Chandigarh bench of tribunal in the case of Homelife Buildcon (P.) Ltd. (supra) and accordingly, held that no addition could be made on the basis of the documents found and seized form the possession of third person without following procedure as prescribed in sub clause (iv) of Explanation 2 to section 148 and without obtaining mandatory approval from the prescribed authority to use such material against the assessee.

172.

In view of above discussion, we delete the addition made on account of the entries found recorded in the documents found and seized from the possession of third person. Ground of appeal No.10 raised by the assessee is thus, allowed.

173.

Coming to the Grounds of appeal Nos.11 & 12 of the Assessee wherein the assessee has challenged the additions of INR 84.00 crores on merits. At the outset it is observed that additions of similar nature were also made in AY 2020-21 and 2021-22 where the same were deleted by the ld. CIT(A) by holding that no incriminating material was found / seized pertaining to those years. However, for the year under appeal, ld. CIT(A) has confirmed the addition by observing that the material found and seized from the possession of MEPL contained name of the assessee.

174.

While deciding this issue in AY 2020-21 in ITA No. 272//Del/2026, we have made detailed observations on the merits of the additions also and held that the additions was made solely on the basis of statements of one of the employee of MEPL which were rebutted by the assessee by filing every possible and credible evidences and thus in the absence of any link with the assessee of the material so found, no additions could be made, more particularly when no such money was found from the possession of the assessee as a result of search for which the provisions of section 69A could be invoked. Such observations are Mutatis Mutandis applicable to the fact of present appeal thus by respectfully following the same, even on merits, the additions made u/s 69A of the Act is hereby deleted.

175.

In the result, appeal of the assessee is allowed.

176.

In the final result, captioned three appeals of the assessee in IT(TP)A No.259/Del/2026 [Assessment Year 2020-21]; IT(TP)A No.260/Del/2026 [Assessment Year 2021-22]; & IT(TP)A No.280/Del/2026 [Assessment Year 2022-23] and both captioned appeals of the Revenue in IT(TP)A No.272/Del/2026 [Assessment Year 2020-21] and ITA No.5367/Del/2026 [Assessment Year 2021-22] are dismissed.