AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
Per Satbeer Singh Godara, Judicial Member:
These Revenue’ s twin appeals in ITA Nos. 2990 & 2991/Del/2023 for Assessme nt Years 2016-17 & 2017-18, arise against the CIT(A)/NFAC, Delhi’ s DIN & order No. ITBA/NFAC/S/250/2023-24/1055437476(1) & 1055440298(1) dated 25.08.2023, in proceedings u/s 143(3) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 ( in short “ the Act”), respectively.
Heard both the p arties at length. Case files peruse d.
The Revenue’s “lead” appeal here in ITA No. 2990/Del/2023 raises the follo wing substantive grounds:
“1 . Whether on the fa cts and circumsta nces of the case and i n la w, the ld. C IT(A ) erred i n del eti ng the disal lowance of busi ness e xpendi ture amo unti ng to Rs.86,72,91,323/- in pr ofit and loss account on the gr ound tha t there is no business set up duri ng the year?
2.Whet her o n the facts and circ ums tanc es of the cas e and in law, t he ld. C IT(A ) err ed in ignori ng t he fact that no evidence has been adduced t o show that t he assess ee did not file any evide nce substa ntiating that it has undertake n nego tiati o n with s uppliers?”
We next note that the so le substantive issue between the parties is as to whether the assessee had set up it’s business in the impugned le ad assessment ye ar 2016-17 or no t; is fo und to be hardly res integra in lig ht of the learned co-ordinae bench’s order in Revenue’s twin appeals ITA No. 7506/Del/2017 and 4834/Del/2019 for assessment years 2014-15 and 2015-16, decided on 17.10.2023 rejecting the very stand as under:
“4 . Briefly, the fac ts are, assessee is a resident corporate entity stat ed to b e engaged i n the busi ness of undertaki ng si ngl e bra nd retail tradi ng of vari ous prod ucts under the ‘IK EA’ brand. For the assessment ye ar under dispute, as sessee filed its r eturn of i ncom e under Secti on 139(1) of the Act.
5.In c ourse of assessment pr oce edi ngs, while ve rifying the audited fi nancial statements o f the assessee, the Ass essi ng Officer not ed that ass ess ee has debit ed expenses to the tune of Rs.18,94,65,541 in assessment year 2014-15 and Rs.50,13,18,999 in assessment year 2015-16. Wher eas, ass essee has not shown any rec eipts from busines s in the af oresaid two assessment y ears . Bei ng of the vi ew that in absence of any busi ness operation duri ng the year, no expenses can be allowed. The Assessi ng Officer issued a s how caus e notice t o the assess ee proposi ng disallo wance of t he expenses. In r espo nse to the show cause notice, assessee filed a detailed s ubmission objecti ng to t he prop osed disallowanc e. However, rej ecti ng the contentions of t he assessee, Assessing Officer procee ded to disallow the expenses i n bot h the assess ment years under dispute.
6.Contesting t he di sal lowances, assessee pre fer red appeals before learned Commissioner (Appeals).
7.Aft er considering the s ubmissions of the ass essee i n the co ntext of facts and material on record , l ear ned Commissi o ner (A ppeals) hel d that the assessee has set up its busi ness activities. He observed, merely becaus e the ass essee has not undertaken any sal es/purc hase, it cannot be said that busi ness has not been s et up. Relying upon various j udicial pr ecedents i ncl udi ng t he decision of Ho n'bl e jurisdicti onal Hi gh Cour t i n t he c ase of Car efour WC & C India (P) Ltd. vs. DCIT (2015) 53 Taxmann.com 289, learned Commissioner (Appeals) del eted the disal lowances.
8.Before us, learned D epartmental Representative submitt ed, though, busi ness has been s et up, however, it has not co mmenc ed its busi ness as actual purchas e and sales activities have not been undertake n by the assessee. She furthe r s ubmit ted that s ome of t he expenses appear to be f alling within the provisions of section 35D of t he Act, hence, have t o be amortized. Thus, s he relied upon the obs ervati ons of t he Assessing Officer.
9.Le arned co unsel for the as sessee submitte d that before i nc orpora tion of the assessee, its holdi ng com pany has already obtai ned the approv al from the Department of Industrial Policy and Pr omoti on (DIPP) on 14.06.2013 for setti ng up of its subsidiary in India. He submitted, after inco rporation, ass essee entered into vari ous agre ements, hired empl oyees for undertaki ng business ope ration and also ope ned bank ac count for undertaki ng busi ness transactions . In t his context, he drew our attention t o the sequenc e of ev ents indicati ng vari ous steps taken by the assessee f or s etting up the busi ness. He submit ted, the maj or part of t he expenses rel ates to salary c ost of employees . He s ubmitted, once the assessee has set up its business , merely bec ause the assessee had not ear ned any r evenue by underta king purc has e and s ales transacti o ns, it cannot be said that busi ness has not been s et up. He s ubmitt ed, date of set up and date of commenc ement of business ar e di sti nc t from eac h other and expe nses i ncurred post setti ng up of the business are allowabl e as revenue expenses. He submitt ed, the term ‘set up’ means to place on foot or to establ is h. H e submitted, various ste ps tak en by the assessee such as openi ng place of busi ness, hiri ng of employees , identifyi ng clients, openi ng bank acc ounts etc. clearly demons trate s etti ng up of t he busi ness. In support o f s uch cont entions, learned c ouns el relied upon the decision of Hon'ble j uris dictional High Co urt i n case of Car efo ur WC& C India (P) Ltd. vs. DC IT (2015) 53 Taxmann.com 289 (supr a). Thus, he submitt ed, t he decisi on of learned First Appellate Aut hority has t o be af fir med.
10.We have considered rival submissions in t he light of judicial prec edents cited before us and perus ed t he mat erial on r ecord. The dispute b etween the ass essee and the R evenue i s within the narr ow c ompass as to whether the asses see has set up its busi ness ac ti viti es so as to claim expe nses . T he Assessi ng Offic er has observed, si nc e, assess ee has not r eport ed any i nco me from busi ness operati on, it cannot be said t hat it has commenced its busi ness activiti es. However, from t he mat erial avail able on record, it i s obse rved that assessee’s holdi ng c ompany has obtai ned a n approval from D IPP on 14.06.2013 to set up a subsi diary in Indi a. Ther eafter, assessee company was i ncorporated on 02.08.2013. Aft er its inco rporati on, assess ee has entered into trade mark and t rade name agr eement , s ervice agre ement with anot her gro up entit y for availing vari ous servic es. It has opened a bank account with Standar d Chartered Ba nk in A ugust 2013 for carryi ng out i ts busi ness activities. Furt her, i t has e ntered into vari ous land agreeme nt to kic k start its busi ness activities incl udi ng a greeme nt with St ate Gover nment and ot her entities for purchase/l easi ng space for its re tail stores. The assess ee has also hir ed employees such as CEO, Deputy C ountry Sales Mana ger, Financ e Manager, HR Manager, Real Estates Proj ec t Manager, Legal Manager , Admi nistrative Officer, Marketi ng A ssess ment and Risk Manager, and various other supporting staff to undertake the busines s operation. The ass essee has also acqui red ta ngibl e and other asse ts, essentially requir ed for basic infra-structure and runni ng of busi ness.
11.On a perusal of audited fi nancial stat ement, it is observed t hat major part of the expe nses rel at e to salary, r ent payme nt, s ecuri ty expenses, rat es and tax es, electricity and wate r char ge s, repairs and mai ntena nce, tr avelling and conveyance, ins uranc e, legal and professio nal fee, communicati on e xpenses, vehicle expenses etc. It is further observed, c ertai n expenses incurred by the as sessee have b een am or tiz ed. Thus , the af ores aid facts brought o n rec ord clearly demonstrat e tha t t he assessee has set up its busi ness activiti es. In our view, the Assessi ng Officer has di sallowed t he expenses without understandi ng the fi ne disti nction bet ween the terms ‘set up’ and ‘commencement’ and has, theref ore, fall en into error while disal lowi ng t he expenses. In o ur view, t he issue is squarely c overed by the decision of the Hon'ble j uri sdictional High Cour t in the case of C aref our WC& C India (P) Ltd. vs. DCIT (2015) 53 Taxmann.com 289 (supra), wherei n, t he Ho n'bl e Hi gh Court while c onsideri ng identical nature of dispute has held as under:
“Ther e is no dispute about the fact ual as pect o f t he expenses i ncurred by t he a ss essee. The p osition of t he prima ry obje4ctives of the assessee c ompa ny is also not in di spute. In the facts of the insta nt case, t he assessee company was i ncorporat ed on 19.9.2007. Eve n befor e the incorpora tion, corr esp ondence had bee n made with well-known co mpanies like Nestl e, Cadbur y, Nivea India (P) Ltd., Pepsi, Col gate, Uniliv er etc. It rent ed out the offic e pr emises i n the m onth of Octobe r, 2007. Bank account was o pened on 4.10.2007. Empl oyees were al so ap poi nted during t he said period. TDS deducti on for the said employees was also plac ed on record. R egistrati on under the Shops and Establishment Act was als o affect ed. Thes e activities are t he first s tage activitie s whic h would lay foundatio n for placing orders for pr ocuri ng the stoc k and st ori ng them i n a warehouse/s hop followe d by t he thir d stage of ma rketi ng t hem. S uffice t o s tat e for a forei gn entity wit o9 ut es ta bl ishi ng itself under t he local laws, appointi ng personnel , identifying t he prospective manufac tures, cl ients, etc. obt aini ng stora ge facilities followed by s toc k-in-trade, t he busi ness of trading cannot commence. The Tribunal misse d the point t hat the assessee as a prudent trader could not hav e made p urchases wi thout undertaki ng the a for esaid e xercis e. The said exe rcise was a precurs or to c omme ncement but post s et up. The af ores aid activiti es demonstrate setti ng up of t he busi ness by the ass essee wi th a commitment to comme4 nce the busi ness. Nothi ng barred or prevented the as sessee from maki ng fir st purc hases, aft er nec essary legal approvals, but the fact that t he assessee wanted t o c ommence actual tradi ng aft er nego tiati o ns with sever al parti es , would not post pone the dat e when the busi ness was se t up.”
As coul d be seen fr om t he observations of t he Ho n'bl e jurisdi cti onal Hi gh Court, co mmencement of actual tra di ng cannot pos tpo ne t he d ate of s et up of busi ness. In t he facts o f t he pres ent appeal, merely because, assessee has not co mmenced its purc has e and sales activities, it cannot be s aid that the busi ness has not been s et up. In vi ew of the aforesaid, we uphold t he decisi on of lear ne d Firs t Appellate Aut hority while dismissing the grounds raised by t he Rev enue.”
That being the case, we hardly see any reason to adopt a differe nt view in the impugned assessment order on the very issue once the same already concluded in the assessee’s favour regarding setting up of it’s business. We acco rdingly adopt judicial co nsistency to affirm the lear ned CIT(A) findings accepting the assessee’s contentions in the lo wer appellate proceedings in very terms. This Revenue ’s lead appeal ITA No. 2990/Del/2023 fails therefore.
Same order to follow in the Revenue’s latter appeal ITA No. 2991/Del/2023 since raising the very sole substantive ground.
These Revenue’s tw in appeals ITA Nos. 2990 & 2991/Del/2023 are dismissed in above terms. A copy of this common order be placed in the respective case files.
