Tribunals and CommissionsDivision Bench(2026) 11 ITAT CK 2942

DCIT, Gurgaon vs Deepak Lal Agarwal

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, New Delhi · Decided on 18 November 2026

CASE NUMBER
ITA No.739/DEL/2026

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

159 paragraphs · 8,972 words

PER S. RIFAUR RAHMAN, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER :

1.

This appeal is filed by the Revenue against the order of ld. Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals)/National Faceless Appeal Centre (NFAC), Delhi [“Ld. CIT (A)”, for short] dated 24.03.2025 for the Assessment Year 2017-18.

2.

At the time of hearing, ld. DR submitted that the appeal was filed on 23.01.2026, however the order of the ld. CIT (A) is passed on 24.03.2025. For condoning the delay in filing the appeal, ld. DR submitted as under :-

“3. Delay in filing the appeal

3.1

The impugned order was communicated to the Principal Commissioner of Income-tax, Faridabad on 24.03.2025, as certified under section 253(2). The appeal was filed on 23.01.2026. The delay is disclosed by the Revenue in Form 35 itself, column 11 having been answered in the affirmative and a separate application under section 253(5) supported by an affidavit has been filed.

3.2

The scrutiny report recommending the filing of appeal was prepared on 19.05.2025, within the period of limitation. The Principal Commissioner of Income-tax, in the exercise of the function cast upon her by section 253(2), did not authorise the appeal mechanically but by letter dated 13.06.2025 called for re-verification of the record upon the question of the remand report and additional evidence, which forms the subject matter of Ground No.2. The clarification of the Assessing Officer was furnished on 19.06.2025. The matter thereafter underwent the prescribed examination and approval, authorisation under section 253(2) was issued on 21.01.2026, and the appeal was filed within two days thereof. The period was thus occupied in the examination of a substantial issue involving a tax effect of Rs.10,63,37,853, and the delay was neither deliberate nor contumacious.

3.3

It is well settled that the expression "sufficient cause" is to receive a liberal construction so as to advance substantial justice, that where substantial justice and technical considerations are pitted against each other the cause of substantial justice deserves to be preferred, and that there is no presumption that delay is occasioned deliberately: Collector, Land Acquisition, Anantnag v. Mst. Katiji (1987) 167 ITR 471 (SC) and N. Balakrishnan v. M Krishnamurthy (1998) 7 SCC 123. It has further been recognised that decisions in Government are taken through an impersonal machinery involving the movement of files and successive approvals, and that a certain latitude is therefore warranted: State of Haryana v. Chandra Mani (1996) 3 SCC 132 and State of Nagaland v. Lipok AD (2005) 3 SCC 752. Where an explanation as distinct from a mere excuse is placed upon the record, the lean is in favour of hearing the matter upon merits: Sheo Raj Singh v. Union of India (2023) 10 SCC 531.

3.4

The entries in Form 36 showing the date of the order and the date of its communication as 23.01.2026 are the date of filing typed in the wrong column. The grounds of appeal, the authorisation under section 253(2) and every enclosure identify the order under appeal as the order dated 24.03.2025, and a corrected Form 36 has been filed. No prejudice is thereby caused to the Assessee, who has at no stage been in doubt as to the order under challenge.

3.5

The passing of the order giving effect on 19.05.2025 and the dropping of the penalty proceedings under section 270A on 27.08.2025 do not amount to acceptance of the impugned order. Giving effect to an appellate order is a statutory obligation of the Assessing Officer, the penalty proceedings were dropped only in consequence of the deletion of the quantum additions, and section 275(1)(a) itself contemplates the revival of penalty upon the outcome of further appeal. There is no estoppel against the exercise of a statutory right of appeal conferred by section 253(2).

3.6

The demand already stands reduced to nil by the order giving effect, and the Assessee himself preferred his first appeal with a delay of 37 days and was heard upon merits. The delay may therefore kindly be condoned and the appeal heard upon merits.”

In view of his above submissions, ld. DR pleaded to condone the delay in filing the appeal.

3.

On the other hand, ld. AR of the assessee submitted as under :-

1.

The present appeal is ex-facie barred by limitation - The impugned order of the learned Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals)/NFAC (‘CIT(A)’) was passed on 24.03.2025. The present appeal has been instituted before this Hon'ble Tribunal only on 23.01.2026.

2.

The Revenue has itself admitted delay in filing the appeal. In Form No.36 filed before this Hon'ble Tribunal, against the column 11 of Form 36 which contains particulars of the Appeal Filing Details and in response to question ‘Whether there is any delay in filing of appeal’ the Revenue has answered "YES", thereby admitting that the appeal is delayed. Please refer page 5 of compilation.

As per the copy of Appeal Memo furnished to the Appellant by the Registrar’s office no application seeking condonation of delay is available on the record of this Hon'ble Tribunal. Please refer pages 3-6 of compilation.

Thus, despite admitting delay in Form No.36, no application under section 253(5) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 is presently available on the Tribunal's record.

3.

Form No.36 contains a material misstatement. Furthermore, the Revenue has stated in Form No.36 that the date of the appellate order is 23.01.2026. Please refer page 4 of compilation.

However, the appellate order sought to be challenged is admittedly dated24.03.2025. Please refer page 16-67 of compilation.

4.

Revenue’s action subsequent to the impugned appellate order reflects that the said appellate order was in the knowledge of the Ld. AO as far back as in May 2025

4.1.

The Assessing Officer passed an Order Giving Effect dated 19.05.2025 giving effect to the order of the learned CIT(A).The said OGE specifically records that the learned CIT(A) had passed the appellate order dated 24.03.2025 and proceeds to implement the same. Please refer page7-8 of compilation for date of OGE.

4.2.

The Assessing officer passed an order dated 27.08.2025 u/s 270A of the Act dropping penalty proceeding citing above referred appellate order dated 24.03.2025. Please refer page 9-15of compilation for copy of order u/s 270A.

The Revenue cannot, on one hand, implement the appellate order in May 2025 and, on the other hand, state in Form No.36 that the appellate order is dated 23.01.2026.At the very least, this inconsistency raises a serious doubt regarding the correctness of the particulars furnished in Form No.36 and warrants examination before the appeal is heard on merits.

5.

The burden lies upon the Revenue to explain delay in filing the appeal and the same has not been discharged. Under section 253(3) of the Act, limitation is reckoned from the date of communication of the appellate order to the competent Commissioner. Having conceded in Form 36 that there is a delay in filing the appeal, the Revenue ought to establish sufficient cause for delay and in the absence thereof the present appeal may not be maintainable. No material in support thereof has been produced before the Hon’ble Tribunal. In these circumstances, the Revenue has failed to discharge the initial burden of establishing that the appeal is maintainable.

It is humbly submitted that the issue of limitation goes to the very root of the Tribunal's jurisdiction and deserves to be decided as a preliminary issue before the appeal is heard on merits.

6. PRAYER

The Appellant humbly pleads that the Hon’ble Tribunal may be pleased to:

(a)

dismiss the present appeal as barred by limitation, the Revenue having failed to establish that the appeal has been instituted within the period prescribed under section 253(3) of the Act and there being no application seeking condonation of delay available on the record of this Hon'ble Tribunal; or in the alternative

(b)

before the appeal is heard on merits, direct the Revenue to establish the maintainability of the appeal by producing:

In case the Hon’ble Tribunal decides to hear the appeal on merits of the case, the Appellant craves leave for filing details written submissions and pleading its case on any date convenient to the Bench after two weeks.”

4.

Considered the rival submissions and material placed on record. We observed that PCIT issued notice to the AO in order to verify the voluminous records before giving his assent to proceed with the appeal u/s 253(2) of the Act. Considering the reasons adduced in the condonation petition we hold that the revenue was prevented from sufficient cause in not filing the appeal in time before us. Therefore, we proceed to condone the delay.

5.

At the time of hearing, ld. DR of the Revenue brought to our notice relevant facts and his submissions as under. He submitted that the assessee, a citizen of the United States of America employed in India with Cairn India Limited, filed his return of income for Assessment Year 2017-18 on 26.07.2017 declaring a total income of Rs.8,67,41,130/-, in the status of a resident, In Schedule FA of his returns of income, the assessee disclosed foreign bank accounts, the aggregate peak balance whereof rose from Rs.10,82,93,276/-in Financial Year 2015-16 to Rs.40,70,04,777/- in Financial Year 2016-17, an increase of Rs.29,87,11,506/-. Interest of Rs.5,36,709/- earned in those accounts was not offered to tax.

6.

He submitted that the case was selected for limited scrutiny under CASS. Notices under section 143(2) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (for short ‘the Act’) dated 20.09.2018 and 28.09.2018 were issued and served to the Assessee and were received by him on his registered electronic mail address, and were forwarded by him to his counsel, M/s KPMG, on whose behalf adjournments were sought on 21.09.2018 and 09.10.2018. He Further submitted that hearings stood fixed on 04.10.2018, 05.10.2018 and 15.10.2018. The case was received on transfer by the Income Tax Officer, Ward 1(4), Gurgaon on 27.11.2019. Notice under section 142(1) along with questionnaire, together with notice under section 129, was issued on 15.12.2019, and a show-cause notice, also treated as a notice under section 142(1), was issued on 20.12.2019 fixing 22.12.2019 for compliance. No reply or document was furnished by the Assessee. The assessment was completed on 23.12.2019 at a total income of Rs.38,59,89,345/- by making two additions, Rs.29,87,11,506/- under section 69A and Rs.5,36,709/- on account of interest income.

7.

Aggrieved with the abovesaid order, the Assessee preferred an appeal before the NFAC, Delhi and filed detailed written submissions together with an application under Rule 46A seeking admission of bank statements of his foreign bank accounts running into 200 pages. After going through the detailed submissions, ld. CIT (A) deleted both the additions.

8.

Aggrieved with the aforesaid order, Revenue is in appeal before us raising following grounds of appeal :-

“1.

On the facts and circumstances of the case, the Ld. CIT(A) has erred in deleting the addition of Rs.29,87,11,506/- made by the AO on account of unexplained money u/s 69A of the Income Tax Act, 1961 and Rs. 5,36,709/- on account of interest income.

2.

That on the facts and circumstances of the case, the Ld. CIT(A) has erred in admitting additional evidence in the case without seeking remand report/comments of the AO and used the additional evidence as basis for deleting addition in respect of various issues in contravention to Rule 46A.”

9.

With regard to deletion of the addition of Rs.29,87,11,506/- made under section 69A, ld. DR of the Revenue submitted as under :-

“4.2 Treatment of the issue in the assessment order

4.2.1

At para 1, AO p.1, the AO records that notices under section 143(2) dated 20.09.2018 and under section 142(1) with questionnaire dated 15.12.2019 were issued, and that "the assessee has not furnished any reply or documentary evidences to the queries raised during the assessment proceedings".

4.2.2

At para 2, AO p.1-2, the show-cause notice dated 20.12.2019 is reproduced:

"2.

As per information available with this office following observations have been made from Schedule FA of ITR: 1. There is substantial increase in balance in foreign bank account (Rs. 29,87,11,506/- aggregate Peak Bank balance during the year). However, in absence of any response from you, the above have remained unexplained. ... 3. Therefore, last and final opportunity is being provided to you to furnish the complete reply of the questionnaire issued vide notice U/S 142(1) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, dated 15.12.2019 by 22.12.2019 and if you again fail to furnish the complete information/documents by the stipulated date, it will be assumed that you have nothing to state in this matter and your case will be assessed ex-parte by making addition of Rs.29,92,48,215/- to your total income for the AY 2017-18. 4. This may also be treated as notice U/S 142(1) of the Income Tax Act, 1961."

4.2.3

At para 3, AO p.3, the addition is made in the following terms:

"3.

Since the assessee has not filed any reply/documentary evidence/s during the assessment proceedings, it is assumed that the assessee has nothing to state in the matter. In absence of any response by the assessee, aggregate peak balance of Rs.29,87,11,506/- in foreign Bank accounts of the assessee during the FY 2016-17 has remained unexplained. Accordingly, the same is treated as unexplained money in possession of the assessee and addition ... is made U/S 69A of the Income Tax Act, 1961 to total taxable income of the assessee for the AY 2017-18 .... (Addition: Rs. 29,87,11,506/-)"

4.2.4

At para 5, AO p.4, the income is re-computed by adding Rs. 29,87,11,506 as per para 3 and Rs. 5,36,709 as per para 4 to the returned income of Rs.8,67,41,130, and the total income is assessed at Rs. 38,59,89,345. The figure of Rs.40,70,04,782 appearing in the body of para 3 is the aggregate peak. balance of Financial Year 2016-17; the addition actually made, as stated in the bracket to para 3 and in the computation at para 5, is Rs. 29,87,11,506.

4.2.5

The assessment order is extracted by the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) at para 5, CIT(A) p.6-8 (PB 21-23) and again at para 7, CIT(A) p.38-39 (PB 53-54).

4.3 Treatment of the issue in the impugned order

4.3.1

At paras 10 to 12, CIT(A) p.40 (PB 55), the explanation of the Assessee for his non-participation is recorded, namely that the notice under section 143(2) was forwarded to M/s KPMG, that the subsequent notices went to the Spam folder of his electronic mail account, and that he came to know of the assessment on 25.02.2020 upon receiving a telephone call from RBL Bank.

4.3.2

At para 13, CIT(A) p.40-41 (PB 55-56), it is held:

"13.

In the aforementioned background and submissions, I agree with the submissions made by the appellant. Ideally, this case should have been assessed under section 144 after duly serving the notice. In that scenario, I could have remanded the matter back to the ld. AO for fresh assessment. However, same is not the case and therefore I have no other option but to proceed on the basis of submissions and evidence filed by the appellant. "

4.3.3

At para 14, CIT(A) p.41-44 (PB 56-59), paras 5.6 to 5.10 of the submissions of the Assessee are reproduced, including his claim that the peak balance of the CFCU account for Financial Year 2015-16 was "wrongly stated" in the return as Rs.7,91,04,000 and was in fact Rs.23,91,69,354, and a reconciliation table concluding in a negative figure of Rs.(3,27,66,629).

4.3.4

At para 15, CIT(A) p.45 (PB 60), the entire finding upon this addition reads:

"15.

In the light of the aforementioned submissions, I am of the view that Ld. AO did not have these explanations before him while deciding the case and therefore was unable to reach the correct conclusion. I agree with the submissions made and explanations offered by the appellant. I am of the view that the Appellant's income sources are well documented and declared. As a result, the appeal is allowed on this ground."

4.4 Submissions of the Revenue

A. Section 69A places the onus upon the assessee

4.4.1

Section 69A deems money of which the assessee is found to be the owner to be his income where he offers no explanation about the nature and source of its acquisition, or where the explanation offered is not, in the opinion of the Assessing Officer, satisfactory. The Assessee offered no explanation whatsoever before the AO. The opinion of the AO rested not upon surmise but upon the Assessee's own declaration in Schedule FA of two successive returns of income, which disclosed an increase of Rs.29,87,11,506 in the aggregate peak balances of his foreign bank accounts, and upon a show-cause notice which quantified the proposed addition and afforded him an opportunity to explain.

4.4.2

The onus of proving the nature and source of a receipt lies upon the person in whose hands it is found: Kale Khan Mohammad Hanif v. err (1963) 50 ITR 1 (SC); Roshan Di Hatti v. CIT (1977) 107 ITR 938 (SC); CIT v. P. Mohanakala (2007) 291 ITR 278 (SC). Where no explanation is furnished, the deeming provision operates: Chuharmal v. CIT (1988) 172 ITR 250 (SC).

4.4.3

The decisions relied upon by the Assessee before the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals), namely State of Kerala v. C. Velukutty (1966) 60 ITR 239 (SC) and ITO v. Girish M Mehta (2007) 105 ITD 585 (Rajkot) at CIT(A) p.13 (PB 28), require that an assessment made in the absence of the assessee bear a reasonable nexus to the material available. In the present case that nexus is direct and immediate, the figure having been taken from the Assessee's own return of income.

B. The non-compliance was the default of the Assessee and the assessment is validly made

4.4.4

The Assessee had knowledge of the scrutiny proceedings. By his own admission he received the notice under section 143(2) upon his registered electronic mail address on 20.09.2018, forwarded it to his counsel, and adjournments were sought on his behalf on 21.09.2018 and 09.10.2018. Hearings stood fixed on three dates in October 2018. Having so appeared in the proceedings, the Assessee is precluded by section 292BB from contending that the subsequent notices were not served upon him or were not served in time or in the proper manner, no such objection having been raised before the completion of the assessment.

4.4.5

Service by electronic mail is a statutory mode of service. Section 282 read with Rule 127 of the Income-tax Rules, 1962 provides for service at the electronic mail address available with the Department, and the subsequent notices were issued to the very address which the Assessee admittedly used in the year 2018.

4.4.6

In Form 35 at item 2(c) the Assessee has himself declared the date of service of the assessment order as 23.12.2019, that is, the order issued to the same electronic mail address was served upon him on the very date on which it was passed. The case that he learnt of the assessment only on 25.02.2020 does not stand with his own verified Form 35. Any lapse upon the part of his counsel in not pursuing the proceedings, as pleaded at CIT(A) p.15 (PB 30), is a matter between the Assessee and his counsel and does not affect the validity of the assessment.

4.4.7

The observation at para 13 of the impugned order that the case should have been assessed under section 144 does not assist the Assessee. The AO completed the assessment upon merits based upon the material available on record after issuing a show-cause notice, the Assessee had earlier participated through counsel, and any mis-description of the provision is saved by section 292B. It is significant that the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) did not annul the assessment.

4.4.8

Even upon the assumption that the opportunity afforded to the Assessee was inadequate, the remedy is to restore the matter to the stage at which the defect occurred and not to delete the addition: Guduthur Bros. v. ITO (1960) 40 ITR 298 (SC); Kapurchand Shrimal v. CIT (1981) 131 ITR 451 (SC); Tin Box Co. v. CIT (2001) 249 ITR 216 (SC). The authorities relied upon by the Assessee at CIT(A) p.17 (PB 32), namely Ponkunnam Traders v. Addl. ITO (1972) 83 ITR 508 (Ker.) and ZaJrul Hassan Iraqi v. ITO (1999) 68 ITD 276 (Jaipur), concerned orders passed without any opportunity at all, whereas here the Assessee was represented in the proceedings and was issued a show-cause notice quantifying the proposed addition.

C. The finding of the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) is non- speaking

4.4.9

Section 250(6) requires an appellate order to state the points for determination, the decision thereon and the reasons for the decision. Para 15, which contains the whole of the finding upon an addition of Rs.29,87,11,506, consists of an observation that the AO did not have the explanations before him, an expression of agreement with the submissions, and a conclusion that the income sources are well documented and declared. There is no examination of any entry in the bank statements, no computation, no finding upon the source of any credit, and no reference to any report of the Assessing Officer. An order which reproduces the submissions of the assessee across four pages and then agrees with them does not satisfy section 250(6).

4.4.10

The powers of the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) being co-terminus with those of the Assessing Officer, there is a corresponding duty to enquire before deleting an addition: CIT v. Kanpur Coal Syndicate (1964) 53 ITR 225 (SC); Jute Corporation of India Ltd. v. CIT (1991) 187 ITR 688 (SC); Smt. Prabhavati S. Shah v. CIT (1998) 231 ITR 1 (Bom.). Section 250(4) expressly empowered him to make such further inquiry as he thought fit or to direct the Assessing Officer to make inquiry and report, and that power was not exercised.

D. The explanation accepted is incomplete and inconsistent upon its own terms

4.4.11

Even upon the explanation of the Assessee as reproduced at para 14 of the impugned order, the following matters remained unexamined:

•

The Assessee contends that the peak balance of the CFCU account for Financial Year 2015-16 declared by him in Schedule FA as Rs. 7,91,04,000 was "wrongly stated" and was in fact Rs. 23,91,69,354 (CIT(A) p.20, PB 35). This single revision of Rs.16,00,65,354 accounts for more than one half of the addition. A figure declared in a verified return cannot be displaced by assertion, and the source of the further sum of about Rs. 16 crore held abroad as on 31.03.2016 and never earlier disclosed itself called for examination. The figure now furnished is moreover the balance as on 31.03.2016, being USD 36,07,380.91, which is not the peak balance during that year.

•

Credits described as inter-account transfers (net) of Rs.3,49,74,555 into the CFCU account (CIT(A) p.20-21, PB 35-36) are not traced to any source. Upon the Assessee's own table the other disclosed accounts, namely BP Federal Credit Union and Bank of America, together declined by about Rs. 46.7 lakh only, and the Capital One account was itself funded out of CFCU. The accounts from which a net inflow of about Rs. 3.5 crore was received into CFCU are not identified.

•

Credits of Rs.15,40,000 described merely as "Other Credits" are not explained at all.

•

The table at para 5.1 0 (CIT(A) p.43-44, PB 58-59) deducts from the addition the sum of Rs. 16,00,65,354 on account of the revision of the opening figure, the entire gross credits of Rs.7,17,54,615 in the CFCU account and the entire peak balance of Rs.9,96,58,166 of the Capital One account, and arrives at a negative figure of Rs.(3,27,66,629). A reconciliation of balances cannot yield a negative result, and the exercise sets off credits against a difference between balances without any statement of the flow of funds. The three credit items moreover aggregate to Rs.7,17,54,555 and not Rs.7,17,54,615 as stated.

•

If USD 15,00,000 was transferred from the CFCU account to the Capital One account on 30.01.2017 as claimed at para 5.8, it was necessary to demonstrate the balance of the CFCU account before and after that transfer and the aggregate balance of all the accounts upon common dates. No statement of the opening and closing balances of each account as on 01.04.2016 and 31.03.2017, with the rates of exchange applied, was placed upon the record or examined.

•

It is claimed that salary of Rs.3,52,40,000 was credited in the United States account and Rs.5,03,53,320 in India. No certificate of the employer, salary slips or remittance records were produced to relate those credits to the salary of Rs.8,55,93,323 offered to tax in India.

•

The summary of deposits and withdrawals referred to at para 5.14 is a statement prepared by the Assessee himself which no authority has examined.

4.4.12

The explanation of an assessee is to be tested upon the surrounding circumstances and the test of human probabilities: CIT v. Durga Prasad More (1971) 82 ITR 540 (SC) and Sumati Dayal v. CIT (1995) 214 ITR 801 (SC). Where the source of deposits has not been examined by the fact-finding authorities, the matter is to be restored for that purpose: CIT v. K. Chinnathamban (2007) 292 ITR 682 (SC).

4.5 Conclusion upon Ground No. 1(a)

The addition made by the AO rests upon the Assessee's own Schedule FA and upon his failure to explain the source of the increase despite specific notice, whereas the deletion rests upon untested additional evidence and a non-speaking finding. The order of the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) upon this issue deserves to be reversed and that of the AO restored.

10.

With regard to addition of interest of Rs.5,36,709/-, ld. DR submitted as under :-

“5.2 Treatment of the issue in the assessment order

5.2.1

At para 2(b), AO p.2, the show-cause notice states: "You have earned interest of Rs.5,36,709/- in foreign bank account during the year. However, in absence of any response from you, source of the above have remained unexplained."

5.2.2

At para 4, AO p.3, the addition is made:

"4.

Further, it is seen that the assessee has earned interest of Rs. 5,36,709/-but has not offered any tax on the same in the ITR. In absence of any response from the assessee the taxability of the interest received has remained unverified. Accordingly, addition of Rs.5,36,709/- is made to the taxable income of the assessee for the AY 2017-18."

5.2.3

At AO p.l , the residential status of the assessee is recorded as "Resident".

5.3 Treatment of the issue in the impugned order

5.3.1

At para 16, CIT(A) p.4S-Sl (PB 60-66), the submissions of the Assessee are reproduced. They open at para 6.1 with the statement that "the Appellant is a US citizen and for the subject year, is an ordinary resident in India for the purposes of the Act", and at the first tie-breaker test state: "(a) Availability of permanent home - During the impugned year, the Appellant did not own a permanent home in either US or in India" (CIT(A) p.47, PB 62). Reliance is placed upon DC/Tv. Kumar Sanjeev Ranjan, ITA No. 1655/Bang/2017.

5.3.2

At para 17, CIT(A) p.S1 (PB 66), it is held:

"17.

In light of the foregoing submissions, I am inclined to agree with the appellant's argument that, based on the tie-breaker rules, it can be concluded that the appellant is a tax resident of the USA, and thus, the interest income earned should be taxed exclusively in the USA. Since the appellant relocated to India to work as an expatriate for a US-based company, he has maintained his expat status, including for the relevant year, receiving his salary in US dollars with most of it deposited into US bank accounts. The appellant has consistently filed US tax returns on his global income since 1989 ...Consequently, the interest income of Rs.5,36,709/- was incorrectly taxed in India by the learned Assessing Officer."

5.4 Submissions of the Revenue

A. The Assessee is a resident and ordinarily resident and his global income is taxable

5.4.1

The Assessee returned his income in the status of a resident. The AO and the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) both record his status as "Resident" (AO p.1; CIT(A) p.1), and his own Statement of Facts and written submissions describe him as resident and as an ordinary resident in India (CIT(A) p.2 and p.24, PB 17 and 39). He has resided and worked in India since the year 2012. Under section 6(6)(a) as applicable to the assessment year under consideration, having been resident in India in the preceding years and having been in India for far more than 729 days during the preceding seven years, he was not a person not ordinarily resident. The interest earned upon his foreign bank accounts is accordingly includible in his total income under section 5(1)(c).

B. The tie-breaker rule has been applied in the wrong sequence and upon a wrong premise

5.4.2

A benefit under a treaty is an exception which the assessee must establish, section 90(2) operating only in relation to an assessee to whom the agreement applies: Union of India v. Azadi Bachao Andolan (2003) 263 ITR 706 (SC). Article 4(2) of the Agreement between India and the United States of America is hierarchical. It directs attention first to the State in which a permanent home is available to the individual; only where a permanent home is available in both States does the test of closer personal and economic relations arise; where the centre of vital interests cannot be determined, or where no permanent home is available in either State, the test is that of habitual abode; thereafter nationality; and finally mutual agreement.

5.4.3

The test under Article 4(2)(a) is whether a home is available to the individual and not whether it is owned by him. A dwelling taken on rent or provided by an employer, being of a permanent character and continuously available, is a permanent home. The submission of the Assessee that he did not own a home in either State therefore answers a question which the Article does not ask. His residential address throughout, as recorded in Form 35 and in the impugned order, is G-601, Caitriona, Ambience, behind Leela Hotel, Gurugram, a home continuously available to him in India. In the United States, upon his own statement, his household goods were lying in storage at Houston (CIT(A) p.48, PB 63), and no dwelling available to him in the United States during the relevant year is asserted. Upon the first test the Assessee is a resident of India and the enquiry ends there.

5.4.4

Upon the Assessee's own premise that no permanent home was available to him in either State, Article 4(2)(b) requires the application of the test of habitual abode and not that of the centre of vital interests. The Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) nevertheless rested his conclusion upon the centre of vital interests. Upon the test of habitual abode the Assessee resided in India continuously from the year 2012 through the year under consideration, and no stay in the United States during the relevant year is shown. The habitual abode is therefore also India, and the test of nationality under Article 4(2)( c) is never reached.

5.4.5

Even upon the test of the centre of vital interests the result is the same. During the year under consideration the economic life of the Assessee was centered in India. He was in full-time employment with Cairn India Limited, an Indian company, as he himself states at CIT(A) p.2S (PB 40); salary of Rs. 8,55,93,323 was earned and offered to tax in India; he resided at Gurugram; and he was present in India to care for his parents. His own table records the country of residence as India (CIT(A) p.48, PB 63). The premise at para 17 of the impugned order that he worked as an expatriate for a US-based company is contrary to the record. The place of residence of the spouse, an Australian citizen, is not stated, and children stated to be based overseas at universities do not establish a centre of vital interests in the United States.

5.4.6

No Tax Residency Certificate, no Form 10F, no return of income filed in the United States, no evidence of tax paid there upon the interest, and no material in support of the assertions regarding voting, social security, driving licences or the storage of goods was produced before the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals). The application under Rule 46A covers bank statements alone (CIT(A) p.33, PB 48). The finding at para 17 therefore rests entirely upon unsupported assertion.

5.4.7

The decision in Kumar Sanjeev Ranjan is distinguishable. In that case the assessee had produced Tax Residency Certificates for the years 2012 and 2013, and the Tribunal proceeded upon a finding that the assessee had a permanent home in both States, which made the centre of vital interests the applicable test, the period in question being that of his departure from India (CIT(A) p.50-51, PB 65-66). In the present case no Tax Residency Certificate was produced, no home in the United States is shown, and the Assessee had been residing in India for five years.

C. The alternative plea of credit for foreign taxes

5.4.8

The Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) did not adjudicate the alternative plea of the Assessee for credit of taxes paid in the United States. Credit under section 90 read with Article 25 of the Agreement and Rule 128 of the Income-tax Rules, 1962 is admissible only upon proof of tax actually paid and upon compliance with the conditions prescribed, and no such material exists upon the record.

5.5 Conclusion upon Ground No. l(b)

The interest of Rs.5,36,709 is taxable in India in the hands of a resident and ordinarily resident individual. The Assessee fails at the first tie-breaker test and, even upon his own premise, at the test of habitual abode. The deletion deserves to be reversed and the addition made by the AO restored.”

11.

With regard to Ground No.2 regarding admission and use of additional evidence in contravention of Rule 46A, ld. DR submitted as under:-

“6.2 Position in the assessment order

At para 1, AO p.1 and para 2, AO p.2 it is recorded that no reply or document was filed before the AO, in the words "the assessee has not furnished any reply or documentary evidences to the queries raised during the assessment proceedings" and "You have not filed any response to the above notices despite being afforded sufficient number of opportunities". At para 3, AO p.3 the addition is made in the absence of any response. Every document considered by the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) was therefore evidence produced for the first time in appeal.

6.3 Position in the impugned order

6.3.1

In Form 35 at item 12 the Assessee declared that no evidence other than that produced before the income-tax authority had been filed in terms of Rule 46A.

6.3.2

At CIT(A) p.31-35 (PB 46-50) is reproduced the application of the Assessee dated 12.02.2021 under Rule 46A seeking admission of "Copy of bank statements of the foreign bank accounts of the Appellant" at "Pages 1-200IPB", invoking Rule 46A(l )(b), with an alternative prayer for a virtual hearing "should Your Honour not concur with our request for admission of additional evidences".

6.3.3

At CIT(A) p.37-38 (PB 52-53) the Assessee confirms that the documents were filed as additional evidence, as Annexures 4 and 5.

6.3.4

At paras 13 and 15, CIT(A) p.40-41 and p.45 (PB 55-56 and 60), quoted at para 4.3 above, the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) proceeds "on the basis of submissions and evidence filed by the appellant" and deletes the addition for the reason that the "Ld. AO did not have these explanations before him".

6.3.5

The impugned order contains no order admitting the additional evidence, no reasons recorded under Rule 46A(2), no reference to any remand report, and no mention of any opportunity having been afforded to the Assessing Officer under Rule 46A(3). The table of hearings at para 4, CIT(A) p.5 (PB 20) records compliances by the appellant alone.

6.4 Submissions of the Revenue

6.4.1

Rule 46A, reproduced by the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) himself at CIT(A) p.31-33 (PB 46-48), contains three distinct safeguards. Under sub-rule (1) additional evidence may be admitted only in the four situations specified. Under sub-rule (2) no evidence shall be admitted unless the Commissioner (Appeals) records in writing the reasons for its admission. Under sub-rule (3) the Commissioner (Appeals) shall not take into account any evidence so produced unless the Assessing Officer has been allowed a reasonable opportunity to examine the evidence and to produce evidence in rebuttal. Sub-rules (2) and (3) are couched in mandatory negative language.

6.4.2

Each of these safeguards was bypassed. 0 reasons for admission were recorded. The Assessing Officer was never confronted with the two hundred pages of foreign bank statements. And that very material was used as the sole basis for deleting the addition. Para 15 itself records that the Assessing Officer did not have these explanations before him, which is an acknowledgment that the decision turned upon material which he never saw. The requirements of Rule 46A are to be strictly complied with: CIT v. Manish Build Well (P) Ltd. (2011) 204 Taxman 106 (Del.).

6.4.3

The view expressed at para 13 that there was "no other option" is a misdirection in law. The Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) was empowered to call for a remand report under Rule 46A(3), to direct further inquiry under section 250(4), and, in the case of an assessment of the present character, to set aside the assessment under the proviso to section 251 (1)(a) as it stood upon the date of the impugned order. Having resorted to none of these courses, he could not decide the appeal upon evidence which had not been tested.

6.4.4

The breach goes to the root of the matter. An appellate order resting upon evidence taken into account in violation of Rule 46A(3) is vitiated, and the appropriate course is to restore the matter so that the Assessing Officer may examine the evidence and the issue may be decided afresh: Kapurchand Shrimal v. CIT (supra) and CIT v. K. Chinnathamban (supra).

6.4.5

In regard to the interest income the position is stronger still. The factual assertions accepted at para 17, relating to the permanent home, the storage of goods at Houston, voting rights, social security and the filing of returns in the United States since 1989, were not supported by any document whatsoever and were never placed before the Assessing Officer.

6.5 Conclusion upon Ground No.2

The impugned order is vitiated by non-compliance with Rule 46A(2) and Rule 46A(3) and deserves to be set aside.”

12.

On the other hand, ld. AR of the assessee submitted as under :-

1. Submissions qua Ground no. 1 of the Revenue’s appeal in respect of addition under Section 69A and Interest Income

A. Addition of Rs. 29,87,11,506/- under section 69A

2.1

The Assessing Officer treated the difference in peak balances of the foreign bank accounts between FY 2015-16 and FY 2016-17 (as disclosed in Schedule FA) as unexplained money under section 69A. The Assessee humbly submits that the Ld. AO erred in law and on facts for the following reasons:

(i)

Increase in peak balance over two years cannot, by itself, be treated as income of the year. Peak balance is a fluctuating figure and does not represent the effective increase in the net bank balance or any unexplained accretion.

(ii)

The peak balance of the primary account (CFCU) reported for FY 2015-16 in the earlier return was incorrect (Rs. 7,91,04,000/-). The correct peak balance as on 31.03.2016 was Rs. 23,91,69,354/- (USD 36,07,380.91), as evidenced by the bank statements filed as additional evidence. Consequently, the effective increase in the CFCU peak was only Rs. 4,16,64,116/- and not Rs. 20,17,29,471/- as assumed by the Assessing Officer.

(iii)

All major credits/deposits in the CFCU account (which was the primary account of the Assessee during FY 2016-17)were fully explained by way of copies of bank account statements and also a summary of deposits and withdrawals. The same were filed vide submissions dated 18.8.20. Copy placed at pages 17-263/PB.

Vide the said submissions it was explained that:

- Salary credits (part of the total salary of Rs. 8,55,93,323/- already offered to tax in India);

- Sources of other credits; and net inter-account transfers were also adequately explained and demonstrated by reference to contra entries/ inter-bank transfers.

(iv)

The Capital One account was opened in January 2017 by transferring USD 5,10,000/- from the CFCU account (entries dated 2.4.2017/pg. 129/PB.) Treating the entire peak balance of this newly opened account as unexplained income results in double counting of the same funds (once in CFCU and again in Capital One).

(v)

Credits in the other accounts (Chase, BP Federal Credit Union and Bank of America) are primarily interest credits, which were not significant amounts and had were fully explained.

2.2

A summary reconciliation demonstrates that after correcting the opening peak and accounting for explained credits (salary, inter-account transfers, etc.), there remains no unexplained money. Section 69A applies only when the assessee offers no explanation or the explanation is unsatisfactory. Once the source of every credit is explained with primary bank statements, the addition cannot be sustained.

2.3

The Ld. CIT(A) correctly appreciated these facts after examining the bank statements and the charts of deposits/withdrawals filed by the Assessee. The findings of the Ld. CIT(A) on this issue are based on documentary evidence and call for no interference.

B. Addition of Rs. 5,36,709/- on account of interest income

2.4

The Assessee is a dual resident of USA and India within the meaning of Article 4 of the DTAA between India and USA. While he qualifies as a resident under the domestic law of India on the basis of physical presence, he is also a tax resident of the USA by virtue of his citizenship of USA. Applying the tie-breaker rules under Article 4(2) of the India-USA DTAA in sequential order -

- No permanent home was owned in either country during the relevant year.

- Centre of vital interests lies in the USA (dependent family members, personal belongings stored in Houston, voting rights exercised in USA, social ties spanning 27 years, major investments and social security contributions in USA, intention to settle in USA after parental responsibilities).

- Habitual abode and nationality further support USA residency.

It was submitted that the interest income earned by the Assessee in USA was to be taxed in USA only under the provisions of the India USA tax treaty.

Detailed submissions in this regard as filed before the Ld. CIT(A) are at pg.26-29/PB and for the said brevity are not being reproduced here. The Assessee relies upon the same in support of his contention the interest income arising from US bank accounts is taxable only in the USA. The said interest was duly offered and taxed in the USA. Bringing the same to tax in India would result in double taxation, contrary to the object of the Treaty. Section 90 of the Act mandates that the provisions of the DTAA shall apply to the extent they are more beneficial.

2.5

The Ld. CIT(A) has correctly applied the tie-breaker rules on the basis of the factual matrix placed on record and has deleted the addition. The decision of the Bangalore Bench of the Tribunal in DCIT v. Shri Kumar Sanjeev Ranjan (ITA No. 1655/Bang/2017) fully supports this position.

3. Submissions qua Ground no. 2 of the Revenue’s appeal – alleged contravention of Rule 46A

3.1

Revenue’s allegation that additional evidence was admitted without seeking remand report/comments of the Assessing Officer is factually incorrect and contrary to the record.

3.2

The Assessee humbly submits that the Ld. AO post receipt of additional evidences from the Ld. CIT(A) and his directions to submit a remand report issued three notices to the Assessee in remand proceedings and in response thereto the Assessee filed written submissions on four different dates. Details and copies thereof are as under:

- Application for admission of additional evidence was filed before the Ld. CIT(A) – copy at pg.59-263.

- Remand notices were issued by the Assessing Officer on 02.06.2024, 15.07.2024 and 09.09.2024.copies at pg. 446-448.

- The Assessee filed detailed submissions dated 04.06.2024, 13.06.2024, 25.07.2024 and 12.09.2024 before the Assessing Officer during remand proceedings, enclosing bank statements, charts explaining every credit entry, US tax returns and salary credit evidences. Copies at pg. 449-484/PB.

- The Assessing Officer had full opportunity to examine the evidence, seek clarifications and submit comments/report.

3.3

It is humbly pleaded that the mandate of Rule 46A has been duly complied with and that the Ld. CIT(A) has not admitted additional evidence mechanically as alleged by the Revenue. The evidence was subjected to the remand process and was considered only after the Assessing Officer had the opportunity to examine it. Accordingly, there is no violation of Rule 46A.

3.4

Even otherwise, the additional evidence consists of primary bank statements of the Assessee’s own accounts, which go to the root of the matter and enable the appellate authority to decide the case on merits rather than on the basis of an ex-parte order passed in violation of principles of natural justice. Denial of opportunity to place these documents would have perpetuated a high-pitched and incorrect assessment.

13.

Ld. AR further brought to our notice detailed findings of the ld. CIT (A) and also brought to our notice reconciliation at page 450 of the paper book which is nothing but inter-bank transfers. For the sake of brevity, it is reproduced below :-

Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
14.

Further he brought to our notice page 53 to 262 of the paper book which is the relevant bank submissions under consideration. Further, he brought to our notice page 263 which is the summary of deposit and withdrawals during FY 2016-17. He further brought to our notice detailed submissions made before the ld. CIT (A) relating to the peak balance in bank accounts maintained by the assessee outside India in FYs 2015-16 and 2016-17, from pages 318 to 321 of the paper book. Based on the above submissions, he submitted that the peak credit considered by the Assessing Officer is factually wrong without considering any details at the time of assessment proceedings. He submitted that all these details and relevant material submitted before the ld. CIT (A) are properly appreciated by the ld. CIT (A) and by applying co-terminus power, he has given relief. Therefore, he relied on the detailed findings of the ld. CIT (A).

15.

Considered the rival submission and material placed on record. It is fact on record that the assessee is a citizen of USA and employed in India with CIL during the year under consideration. The assessee earned income in India as well as other income earned in the other resident country. It is noticed that the assessee had already declared income earned in India as salary income and other related income in his return of income filed in India. The issue raised in this appeal relates to the assessment for the year under consideration by the AO on the basis of ROI filed in India and part compliances/non-response to the various notices issued for the assessment of his income chargeable to tax in India and completion of assessment by the AO on the basis of material and understanding on the financial records made available before him. Before us Ld DR tried to substantiate the findings of AO for the various reasons submitted by him in the elaborate submissions, which we have reproduced in the above paragraphs. It is fact on record that the AO had completed the assessment on the basis of the information available before him and unable to make proper enquiry and with minimal justification from the assessee side. He had interpreted the information only based on his understanding without proper explanation from the assessee side.

16.

It is fact on record that the AO had merely compared the opening balance and the closing balance of various assets and liabilities placed on record. We noticed that the AO had observed that the peak balance rose by Rs.29,87,11,506/- in the year under consideration and also observed that there is interest income earned outside India, global income also is chargeable to tax in the hands of the assessee as a resident in India. From the record, we noticed that assessee is a dual citizen having income both in India as well as in USA. It is also fact that the citizen having dual citizenship must be treated differently than the regular citizen. We noticed that the AO had completed the assessment on the basis of ordinary citizen whereas in the given case, the assessee had multiple interest in both countries. Let us address the main concerns submitted by the Ld DR in his submissions which we have reproduced in earlier part of order.

17.

On the issue raised by the revenue on ground no.1(a) in which Ld DR brought to our notice paras 1 to 5 of the assessment order and submitted that assessee had not furnished any reply or documentary evidence to the various queries raised by the AO and therefore, he tried to justify the additions made by the AO only upon the information which was already available on record in the form of return of income, the figures stated in the return of income cannot be denied. He further brought to our notice the detailed findings of Ld CIT(A) and objected to the relief granted by him. He submitted that Ld CIT(A) himself observed that the assessment was not completed u/s 144 and justified to proceed to adjudicate the matter himself. He submitted that the assessee side of the submissions were accepted and proceed to give major relief for wrongly stating the figures in the opening balance of the CFCU account in the financial year 2015-16. He further submitted that the provisions of sec.69A demands when the assessee found to be the owner of his income where he offers no explanation about the nature and source of the same or the explanation offered is not to the satisfaction of the AO. In the given case, the assessee had not offered any explanation whatsoever before the AO. By relying on various case law, he submitted that the onus is on the assessee to prove the nature and source of the income. Further, the assessment made in the absence of the assessee bear a reasonable nexus to the material available. Since in this case no nexus is established direct and immediate, figures were taken from his own return of income. After considering the above submissions, in our view, whether the above difference will be considered as undisclosed income based on the material available on record. We noticed that the AO had compared the peak balance of two years, this itself cannot be treated as income of the assessee. We noticed that the assessee had filed the relevant additional evidence to prove that the opening peak credit considered as well as declared in the return of income is not correct. That is the main source of relief granted by the Ld. CIT(A). We agree that the Ld CIT(A) had not remitted the issue back to the file of AO for the reason that the assessment was not completed u/s 144 of the Act but on the basis of material available on record. Since the Ld. CIT(A) had coterminous power, he proceeded to accept the additional evidence filed before him. It is fact on record that the assessee could not file the relevant documents during the assessment proceedings, the Ld CIT(A) had appreciated the fact on record and remanded the matter to AO. Upon consideration of remand report, he proceeded to appreciate the information on record and adjudicated the appeal by fully appreciating the material/ facts on record. Since the AO had no occasion to appreciate the bank statements and other related materials, he came to the conclusion that the case falls u/s 69A. However, ld. CIT (A) having co-terminus power granted the relief.

18.

Further we observed that Ld DR submitted that the findings of Ld CIT(A) is non-speaking and also the explanation accepted by him is incomplete and inconsistent upon its own terms. In this regard he tabulated certain observation. We noticed that Ld CIT(A) had remanded the matter to the AO and AO had not found any discrepancies in the bank statements or any thing in the additional evidence submitted. He had also not substantiated with any other material. After considering the material place on record, we do not see any reason to disturb the detailed findings of Ld CIT(A). Therefore, we are inclined to dismiss the ground raised by the Revenue.

19.

With regard to ground 1(b) on the deletion of interest income earned outside India. We noticed that Ld DR submitted that assessee is a resident and global income is chargeable to tax in India over-looking the fact that the assessee is a dual citizen and Ld CIT(A) had properly appreciated the facts on record and also applied the tie breaker rule as per facts on record. We do not see any reason to disturb the findings of Ld CIT(A). In the result, ground raised by the Revenue is dismissed.

20.

With regard to ground 2 relating to admission and use of additional evidence in contravention of rule 46A. We noticed from the facts on record that the assessment was completed without any proper records available on record and the additional evidence submitted by the assessee was dutifully remanded to the AO. Upon verification of the same after taking four detailed submissions from the assessee, AO filed the remand report. At this stage raking up the issue under consideration, particularly the CIT(A) had explained in detail the reason for admission of the additional evidence, therefore, there is no violation of rule 46A in this case. Therefore, we are inclined to dismiss this ground as well.

21.

In the result, appeal filed by the Revenue is dismissed.