AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
PER MANISH AGARWAL, A.M.:
The captioned appeal is filed by the revenue against the order of Ld. Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals), Delhi-29 (“Ld. CIT(A)”) passed u/s 250 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (“the Act”) in appeal No. CIT(A), Delhi-29/11004/2018-19 dt. 30.01.2026 arising out of the assessment order passed u/s 147/143(3) of the Act dt. 17.03.2025 for AY 2019-20.
Brief facts of the case are that assessee company has filed its return of income on 27.09.2019 declaring total income at ₹ 4,36,40,930/-. A search and seizure action was carried out u/s 132 of the Act on 17.11.2021 on Galaxy group, Pradeep Indraprastha Agarwala, Deepak Agarwal and Himanshu Verma. During the search it was found that the assessee has obtained accommodation entry to the tune of Rs. 24,04,48,352/- from the entities controlled and managed by these persons. Accordingly, after obtaining the approval from the competent authorities under Explanation 2(iv) of Section 148 of the Act and further after passing the order u/s 148A(d) of the Act, notice u/s 148 was issued on 26.03.2024. In response assessee filed the return on 11.06.2024 declaring same income as was declared in the return of income filed u/s 139(1) of the Act. The AO then passed the reassessment order u/s 147/143(3) of the Act at an income of ₹ 29,69,19,150/-after making additions of ₹ 11,90,00,000/- u/s 68 of the Act, ₹ 12,14,48,352/- u/s 69A of the Act and ₹ 99,33,842/- u/s 69C of the Act.
Against the said order an appeal was filed before the ld. CIT(A) who in terms of the order dated 30.01.2026 has allowed the appeal of the assessee and deleted all the additions made by the AO.
Aggrieved by the said order, revenue is in appeal before the Tribunal in present appeal by taking various grounds of appeal as reproduced herein below:
1.“Whether Ld. CIT erred in deleting the addition u/s 68 of the IT Act being accommodation entry in form of loan in lieu of cash and three percent commission and interest paid in cash on this bogus loan amount.
2.The Ld. CIT failed to appreciate that Shri Himanshu Verma and Shri Deepak Agarwal are known entry operators and have been actively engaged in providing organized accommodation entries through their associated entities for a long period, despite multiple search and investigation proceedings conducted against them. These entities have consistently participated in such activities without any regard to the law.
3.The Ld. CIT did not consider the fact that the non descript entities connected with Shri Himanshu Verma are merely conduits for nongenuine transactions in the nature of accommodation entries such as bogus loans/purchases/sales. These transactions were executed in a sophisticated manner by using a network of bank accounts and manipulated books of accounts to give a color of genuineness.
4.The Ld. CIT failed to appreciate that the existence of such entities at the stated addresses could not be verified, indicating their sham and non-functional nature.
5.The Ld. CIT as well as the Hon’ble ITAT have already confirmed that these entities are accommodation entry providers, which clearly establishes their dubious and non genuine nature
6.The appellant craves leave to add, alter, amend OR withdraw any of the above grounds at the time of hearing.”
Before us, ld. AR for the assessee has filed an application under Rule 27 of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal Rules,1963 (“ITAT Rules”) wherein the assessee has challenged the reopening of assessment by taking following grounds of appeal:
1.“That the learned Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) has earned both in law and on facts in upholding the initiation of proceedings u/s 147 of the Act and, completion of assessment u/s 147 / 143(3) of the Act without appreciating that the same are without jurisdiction and hence deserves to be quashed as such.
1.1That the learned Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) has failed to appreciate that initiation of proceedings was mechanical and without any application of mind much less independent application of mind, therefore the notice issued u/s 148 of the Act was an invalid notice and assumption u/s 147 of the act was without jurisdiction.
1.2That the learned Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) has also failed to appreciate that in absence of valid approval under clause (iv) of Explanation 2 to section 148 of the Act, assumption of jurisdiction is illegal
1.3That the learned Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) has also failed to appreciate that clause (iv) of Explanation 2 to section 148 of the Act has no application to the facts of the applicant company and therefore assumption u/s 147 of the Act was without jurisdiction, particularly since no incriminating material was detected as a result of search.
1.4That the learned Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) has failed to appreciate that notice u/s 148 issued without validity complying section 151 of the Act were also without jurisdiction.”
In support ld. AR drew our attention to the provisions of Rule 27 which provides that “the respondent, though he may not have appealed, may support the order appealed against on any of the ground decided against him.” Ld. AR further placed reliance on various judicial pronouncements and requested that the application under Rule 27 of ITAT Rules be admitted in the instant case.
Per contra, Ld. CIT DR vehemently objected to the admission of the Rule 27 application filed by the assessee and requested for the rejection of the same.
Heard both the parties at length and perused the material available on record. It is observed that ld. CIT(A) has allowed the appeal of the assessee by deleting the additions made however, has not adjudicated the legal Ground of appeal Nos. 1 to 2.5 challenging the initiation of reassessment proceedings u/s 147 of the Act. The Revenue has filed the present appeal before the Tribunal, challenging the order of ld. CIT(A) for deletion of additions made by the AO, however, no cross objection was filed by the assessee. As per the provision of Rule-27 of ITAT Rules, an assessee cannot be precluded to challenge that part of order of Ld. CIT(A) which is against him merely because no cross objection was filed by the assessee. The Hon’ble Jurisdictional High Court in the case of Sanjay Sawhney vs. PCIT in ITA No.834/2019 vide order dated 18.05.2020 held that the assessee was entitled to defend the ground decided against him by ld. CIT(A) and support the order in appeal on any of the grounds decided against it. The Hon’ble Court further observed that the assessee could rely upon Rule 27 of AT Rules and advance his arguments, even though it had not filed cross objections against the findings which are against his.
As observed above, in the instant case the ld. CIT(A) has not decided he legal grounds of appeal taken by the assessee wherein the assessee has challenged the assumption of jurisdiction u/s148 of the Act. Thus, by respectfully following the judgments of the hon’ble jurisdictional high court and other Hon’ble High Courts as relied upon by the assessee, we admit the petition filed under Rule 27 of ITAT Rules. Since the legal grounds of appeal raised by the assessee goes to the root of the matter, we are taking them first for adjudication.
Before us ld. AR for the assessee submits that no valid approval has been obtained u/s 151 of the Act before issue of notice u/s 148 on 26.03.2024. For this our attention was invited to pages 25 and 26 of Paper Book which is the copy of approval memo granted by Ld. CIT u/s 151 of the Act which according to assessee was unsigned. He further drew our attention to Item number 8 of approval memo wherein for the query “Approval needed for”, it is stated that “issue of notice under section 148 where there is no requirement of passing order u/s 148A(d).’ Ld. AR submits that though the AO has initiated the reassessment proceedings under clause (iv) of explanation 2 to section 148 which provides that “the assessing officer with the prior approval of the principal commissioner or commissioner that books of accounts or documents, seized or requisitioned under section 132 or 132A in case of any other person on or after first day of April, 2021, pertains to or pertain to, or any information contained therein, related to the assessee”. Thus, for invocation of clause (iv) to Explanation 2 to Section 148, AO was first obliged to establish that any books of accounts or documents are seized which pertains or pertain to the assessee or information collected therein relate to the assessee. Ld. AR submits that in the instant case despite of repeated request till date no copies of the documents / books of accounts that were allegedly seized in the course of search of Galaxy group which allegedly show that these are pertains or pertain to the assessee or information contained therein relates to the assessee has not yet been supplied, despite specific requests before the assessing officer. He submits in the assessment order for the first time the AO has reproduced the copy of Ledger account of the assessee in the books of accounts of the companies from whom loans were taken thus when the satisfaction was recorded under clause (iv) of Explanation 2 to section 148, the AO has not brought on record any such material or books of accounts which is precondition. He thus submits that the no separate approval as contemplated in clause (iv) of Explanation 2 section 148 was obtained and only one approval u/s 151 was obtained before issue of the notice u/s 148 of the Act and therefore the entire reassessment proceedings are bad in law.
Ld. AR further submits that notice u/s 148 was issued on 26.03.2024, copy placed at page 24 of the Paper Book and stated that in the said notice, AO in first para has observed as under:-
"I have information that a search was initiated under section 132 of the Act in your case or in the case of the person in respect of which you are the assessable under the Act as on date 17/11/2021.”
Ld. AR submits that notice u/s 148 is inherently vague and ambiguous, as could be seen from the language as contained in Para-1 of the notice, as reproduced herein above, which neither identifies the person searched nor clarifies whether the jurisdiction has been assumed against the appellant as a searched person or as the person other than the searched person. Ld. AR submits that Explanation 2 to section 148 provides distinction between the person searched and the person other than searched person for which separation procedure is provided in Explanation 2(iv) of section 148 of the Act. Ld. AR submits that identical issue considered by the Hon’ble Jurisdictional High Court in the case of PKS Build Mart Pvt. Ltd. vs ITO & Anr. in W.P.(C) 6751/2023 (Del. HC) wherein the hon’ble court has held the notice containing the identical language as vague and ambiguous and quashed the same. The Co-ordinate Bench of Tribunal in the case of Madhu Bala Vs. ACIT in ITA No. 1746/Del/2026 held that the notice issued u/s 148 containing the identical language which was vague and ambiguous and thus the said notice is bad in law and consequent reassessment proceedings were quashed. He prayed accordingly.
On the other hand, ld. CIT DR for the Revenue vehemently supported the orders of the lower authorities and requested for the confirmation of the same.
Heard the contentions of both parties at length and perused the material available on record. Explanation 2(iv) to section 148 provides that “where the Assessing Officer is satisfied, with the prior approval of Principal Commissioner or Commissioner, that any books of account or documents, seized under section 132 in case of any other person on or after the 1st day of April, 2021, pertains or pertain to, or any information contained therein relate to the assessee, the Assessing Officer shall be deemed to have information which suggests that income chargeable to tax has escaped assessment in the case of the assessee where the search is initiated or books of account, other documents or any assets are requisitioned or survey is conducted in the case of the assessee or money, bullion, jewellery or other valuable article or thing or books of account or documents are seized or requisitioned in case of any other person.”
In the instant case, nothing was brought on record which suggest that the AO has recorded the satisfaction with the prior approval from the competent authority that books of accounts or document seized which pertains to the assessee thus the pre-condition as provided in Clause (iv) of Explanation 2 of Section 148 of the Act is not met. The Co-ordinate bench of Mumbai Tribunal in the case of Pace Iron and Steel (P) Ltd. Vs. ITO in ITA No. 253/Mum/2026 vide its order dt. 07.07.2026 while dealing with the issue of reopening of assessment based on the information received as a result of search in Galaxy Group of alleged accommodation entry of unsecured loans has made following observation in this regard:
29.“In light of aforesaid statutory mandate, let's see how the Assessing officer has recorded his satisfaction in the instant case. From perusal of the reasons so recorded, we find that firstly, the Assessing officer has referred to the information so received from the Investigation Wing and thereafter, the Assessing Officer has stated that the information so received from the investigation wing, wherein the documents seized during the search u/s. 132 in the case of the Galaxy Group pertains or pertain to, or any information contained therein, relates to the assessee and he accordingly recorded his satisfaction stating that the matter is covered under Explanation 2(iv) of Section 148 of the Act. As we have noted earlier, if we looks at the Explanation 2(iv) of Section 148 of the Act, it talks about the satisfaction of the Assessing Officer, with the prior approval of Principal Commissioner or Commissioner, that any books of accounts or documents, seized or requisition u/s. 132 or 132A in case of any other person on or after the 1stday of April, 2021, pertains or pertain to, or any information contained therein, relate to the assessee. For the purposes, firstly, there has to be identification of books of accounts and documents which has been seized in case of any other person and which pertains to the assessee. Where the books of accounts and documents so seized do not pertain to the assessee, there has to be determination as to whether any information contained therein relates to the assessee. Such determination and satisfaction is to be recorded by the Assessing officer and that too, with the prior approval of the Principal Commissioner or Commissioner. However, in the instant case, there is nothing on record in terms of particulars of the books of accounts or documents so seized which pertain to the assessee or any information contained therein which relates to the assessee and whether the Assessing Officer has sought any prior approval of Principal Commissioner or Commissioner before recording his satisfaction. Mere fact that certain documents have been seized from search in case of any other person, cannot by default lead to satisfaction as so contemplated by the statute. The satisfaction so recorded by the Assessing officer therefore doesn't meet the statutory requirement as so provided under Explanation 2(iv) of Section 148 of the Act.”
In the present case also live and in fact concrete link between the information/entries in the books of accounts to suggest that income have escaped assessment has not been established before initiating the proceedings u/s 148 of the Act. Thus, the initiation of reassessment proceedings is in contravention to the provisions of Explanation 2(iv) of section 148 and thus bad in law and cannot be approved.
Further, the notice issued u/s 148 of the Act dt. 26.03.2024 is reproduced herein below:-
As is observed from the aforesaid notice, the AO himself was not sure whether the reassessment proceedings have been initiated in the case of assessee as a person searched or as the other person. The Hon’ble Delhi High Court in the case of PKS Build Mart Pvt. Ltd. (supra) under identical circumstances has held that notice issued u/s 148 containing the identical language as vague and quashed the reassessment proceedings by making following observations:-
12.1“We would assume that the notice, along with the annexure stands withdrawn. The reason that we have reached this conclusion is that the third notice which is dated 31.03.2023, which was issued under Section 148 of the Act, simply states as follows:
" in I have information that a search was initiated under Section 132 of the Act in your case or in the case of the person respect of which you are the assessable under the Act on the date 17.11.2021."
13.In the notice, there is no clue as to who is the person who was searched, which resulted in triggering the reassessment proceedings against the petitioner. The notice, to say the least, is vague.”
Similar view is expressed by the Co-ordinate Bench of Tribunal in the case of Madhu Bala vs ACIT in ITA No.1746/Del/2026 wherein after considering the notice issued u/s 148, the Co-ordinate Bench in para 5 to 8 has observed as under:-
5.“As we examined the content of the notice u/s 148 along with Annexure A2 which is the profarma for approval by the specified authority which in itself has Annexure A & Annexure B and which for convenience we have reproduced by way of scanning, above we find that in the notice dated 29.08.2023 in first bullet point it is not specifically mentioned that the case of the assessee has been reopened on the basis of information in the case of the assessee or in the case of other person. In second bullet point it is not coming up as to approval was taken from which specified authority. Then, in para 2 AO alleges that by way of notice he proposes to assess or reassess such income or recompute the loans or the depreciation allowance or any other allowance for AY: 2021-22. The content of the notice indicates as if a profarma of the notice has been used which certainly is not prescribed under the Act or the rules thereupon. The notice issued u/s 148 of the Act is a vital consequence and certainly should indicate expressly his jurisdiction has been assumed in the case of assesse as searched person or the person other than the searched as the corresponding approval required to be taken has different scope.
6.In the aforesaid context, if the approval is examined in the form of proforma for approval Annexure A2 and the corresponding Annexure A & Annexure B appended to Annexure A2. We find that nowhere the AO or the Addl. CIT Central Range-4, putting recommendations in annexure A or ld. PCIT-2, Central Delhi giving sanction in Annexure B, if at all even mentioned of the quantum of escapement. A perusal of these three documents indicate that merely contents of Bare Act provisions of Explanation 2 (iv) to Section 148 of the Act and Section 149(1)(a) of the Act are mentioned. The proforma for approval drawn by the AO and the corresponding Annexure A & Annexure B only mention of a search being initiated u/s 132 of the Act of a specific group on 17.11.2021 and what was the information available or document found has not been specifically narrated and in very broad manner AO mentions “information contained in the books of account/ documents seized during search relates to assessee”. In Annexure A while giving recommendations Addl. CIT, Central Range-4, Delhi makes similar reference and so does ld. PCIT-2, Central, Delhi while giving the approval merely refers the narration of facts of the AO in column 7 and the recommendations of the Addl. CIT, Central Range, 4, Delhi to grant of approval.
7.Thus, the approval as such is granted is on vague information and certainly nothing is there as live link and same only indicates non application of mind and a mechanical exercise of powers of reopening while law indicates that due application of mind becomes basis of recording reasons for reopening. The impugned show cause notice or the corresponding proforma for approval in the approval so granted do not exhibit any supporting material having live nexus with the material found during search revealing information in case of assessee for reopening the assessment. We are of the considered view that in order to exercise these powers of reopening by recourse to explanation 2(iv) to Section 148 of the Act, apart from the seized material found during search there should be some other live nexus of the seized material to indicate an escapement of income in the case of the person whose case is being reopened. As for this proposition our attention has been drawn by ld. Counsel to the decision dated 16.09.2025 of Hon’ble Gujrat High Court in R/Special Application No. 210 of 2024 and Others titled Dhirajlal Laljibhai Patel Vs. ACIT, Central Circle-1(2) in Trupti Aakash Desai Vs. ITO, Ward 3(3)(5) Ahmedabad R/Special Civil Application No 985 of 2026 order dated 08.04.2026, where Hon’ble Gujarat High Court observes in para 6.3 as follows:
“It is true that the cash transactions are done in a clandestine manner using coded script, the revenue before re-opening the assessment has to establish a live link of the assessee on the basis of seized material only. The expression " relates to" and "pertains to" used in Clause(iv) to Explanation 2 to Section 148 of the Act cannot be used in vacuum. The revenue after the seizure of incriminating material is under an obligation to analyze such material, in light of attendant circumstances and record relevancy and a prima facie opinion linking such material establishing escapement of income at the hands of the assessee. The information which is derived from the incriminating material in the instant case, does not establish livelink.”
8.Thus, in the given facts and circumstances having considered the impugned notice u/s 148 dated 29.08.2023 and the corresponding proforma of approval along with approval granted, made available at page No. 13-17 of the paper book and reproduced by us above, we are inclined to sustain ground no. 10(A), 10(B), 10(D), 10(E) & 10(F). As consequence of same, the appeal is allowed and the impugned assessment order is quashed.”
Thus, by respectfully following the judgements of Hon’ble Delhi High Court and Co-ordinate Bench of Tribunal (supra), we hold that the notice issued u/s 148 dated 26.03.2024 is vague and ambiguous where the AO himself was not sure whether the reassessment proceedings were initiated in the case of the
