AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
PER SHRI SATBEER SINGH GODARA, JUDICIAL MEMBER:
This Revenue's appeal ITA No. 6452/Del/2026 with assessee's cross objection C.O. No. 337/Del/2026; for assessment year A.Y. 2019-20, arise against the Commissioner of Income Tax(Appeals) (for short, "CIT(A)"), Delhi-23's DIN & Order No. ITBA/APL/S/250/2025-26/1087372497(1) dated 27-Jul-2026, involving proceedings u/s 153C r.w.s. 144 of the Income Tax Act, 1961; hereinafter referred to as, “the Act”.
Heard both the parties. Case files perused.
Delay of 08 days in filing of the assessee’s instant appeal is condoned in larger interest of justice
It emerges at the outset during the course of hearing that there arises the first and foremost issue of validity of the impugned assessment itself for want of the learned Assessing Officer’s proper satisfaction recorded u/s 153C of the Act. There does not appear to be much a dispute between the parties that the learned departmental authorities had carried out the search in issue dated 23.03.2021 in M/s KK Spun group of cases. And that the learned Assessing Officer recorded his satisfaction on 1.5.2023 that there was some incriminating material found seized therein which belonged to the (pages 12 to 166 in the case record). This being the clinching factual position, the assessee’s case before us is that after the statutory amendment in section 153C(1) of the Finance Act, 2015 with effect from 1.6.2015 that such seized material couldn’t be held belonging to a third party; except that specified in clause (a) thereof. It further invites our attention to the learned Assessing Officer’s section 153C satisfaction note; as under:
“While drawing the satisfaction note, the AO of the searched person i.e., undersigned has gone through the seized material and the statement of various persons recorded during the course of search mentioned above in his satisfaction note and the satisfaction note is drawn based on the perusal of the seized material as mentioned above. Further, after examining these documents and on the basis of the entries/transactions/contents, it is noticed that documents as referred and discussed at para no. 10.1 and sub para 1 above do belong to person other than the searched person ie..s., M/s Chrysalis Trading Private Limited (PAN: AACCC7944C). The sales and purchases shown are not genuine and bogus. Accordingly, I am satisfied that the documents seized during the course of search mentioned above, have a bearing on the determination of income of M/s Chrysalis Trading Private Limited (PAN: AACCC7944C) for the A.Ys. 2015-16 to 2021-22. Accordingly, Notices are to be issued as per section 153C r.w.s. 153A of the Act for the A.Y. 2015-16 to 2021-22”
Faced with this situation, we hereby note that the instant issue of validity of the impugned section 153C assessment framed in the assessee's case is no more res integra as the tribunal's earlier coordinate bench in Bharatiya International Limited versus DCIT in ITA 5413/Delhi/2025 decided on. 22.04.2026 having settled the same in the assessee's favour and against the department, arising out of the very search, as under:
'4. It is at this stage that the learned counsel vehemently submits that going by the statutory amendment in section 153C(1) of the Act vide Finance Act 2015 w.e.f. 01.06.2015, no such document could be held as "belonging" to a third party whereas the Revenue seeks to justify the same on the ground that it is not the grammatical expressions used in section 153C satisfaction but overall facts and circumstances which ought to be considered whilst deciding the instant legal issue.
5.We have given our thoughtful consideration to the assessee's and the Revenue's respective vehement submissions. We find no reason to sustain the impugned assessments in light of the tribunal's earlier order in Narender Nath Vs. DCIT, ITA No. 4990/Del/2025 decided on 08.01.2026; reading as under:
'3. We advert to the assessee's first and foremost substantive ground/legal arguments herein that both the learned lower authorities have erred in law and on facts in framing the impugned section 153C r.w.s. 143(3) assessment dated 30.03.2024; in furtherance to the searched party's Assessing Officer's satisfaction dated 25.03.2023 and his assessing authority on the very date, as the case may be, which has been wrongly upheld in the lower appellate discussion.
4.That being the case, learned CIT-DR vehemently argues that the impugned twin satisfactions herein had been properly recorded by the Assessing Officer(s); be it that of the searched assessee or appellant third party herein. Her case accordingly is that we ought to uphold the same in very terms.
5.We have given our thoughtful consideration to both the party's foregoing rival pleadings. There is hardly any dispute that the learned departmental authorities had carried out the impugned search on 23.03.2021 in M/s KK Spun Group. And that the said searched party’s learned Assessing Officer recorded his section 153C satisfaction dated 25.02.2023 for proceeding against assessee/appellant before us. The said learned Assessing Officer appears to have recorded that the corresponding seized document during the course of search “belonged to” the assessee/appellant who happens to be the third party u/s 153C of the Act.
6.Faced with this situation, the Revenue could once again not dispute that section 153C(1)(a) stipulates the category of the seized material as “any money, bullion, jewellery … …” which could be held as belonging to a third person and such documents etc. could only be treated as pertaining to or in formation therein as relating to such a person. Meaning thereby that the learned Assessing Officer has not properly recorded his satisfaction that the impugned seized documents either pertained to or related to the assessee which forms a conditioned precedent before proceedings him/third person. This tribunal’s recent decision in Prashant Premchand Bafana Vs. ACIT IT(SS)A No. 119 & 120/Pun/2022 decided on 08.04.2025 has already settled the very issue in the assessee’s favour and against the department. We thus conclude in this backdrop that the impugned assessment dated 30 .03.2024 deserves to be quashed since based on an imp roper section 153C satisfaction. Ordered accordingly.”
6.We adopt judicial consistency to quash all these three impugned section 153C assessments in very terms for want of any exception pinpointed at the Revenue’s behest in law or on facts, as the case may be. Ordered accordingly.
7.All other remaining pleadings between the parties stand rendered academic.
All these clinching intervening developments have gone unrebutted from the Revenue side. We thus conclude in this factual backdrop the learned Assessing Officer in the searched assessee’s case had failed to record a proper section 153C satisfaction which vitiates the entire assessment itself framed in the assessee’s hands. We quash the same in very terms therefore.
All other remaining pleadings between the parties on merits stand rendered academic.
This Revenues appeal ITA No. 6452/Del/2026 is dismissed and the assessee’s cross objection CO No. 337/Del/2026 is allowed in above terms. A copy of this common order be placed in the respective case files.
