AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
PER S. RIFAUR RAHMAN, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER :
The Revenue has filed appeals in the case of Ms. Aniesha Munjal against the order of ld. Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals)-29, New Delhi [“Ld. CIT (A)”, for short] dated 13.03.2026 for the Assessment Years 2015-16 to 2018-19. The assessee, Ms. Aniesha Munjal has filed cross objections in the aforesaid impugned order dated 13.04.2026 for the Assessment Years 2015-16 to 2018-19.
Since the issues are common and the appeals and cross objections, in the case of Ms. Aniesha Munjal, are connected, hence the same are heard together and being disposed off by this common order. We take up the Revenue’s appeal being ITA No.7995/Del/2026 for AY 2015-16 as lead case to adjudicate the issues under consideration.
The assessee, Mrs. Aniesha Munjal, is the wife of Shri Pawan Munjal, Chairman and Managing Director of Hero Moto Corp Limited (HMCL), and is regularly assessed to tax in India. The appeal for AY 2015-16 has been taken up as the lead year for the purpose of examining and adjudicating the common issues. Accordingly, the findings and conclusions recorded in respect of Assessment Year 2015-16 shall apply mutatis mutandis to the corresponding issues arising in the appeals for the other assessment years, to the extent that the issues, underlying facts, allegations and applicable statutory provisions are materially identical.
Brief facts of the case are, the assessee filed her original return of income for AY 2015-16 on 06.08.2015 declaring total income of Rs.51,47,040, comprising income from salary, house property and other sources. Subsequently, search and seizure proceedings under section 132 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (in short “Act”) were conducted on 23.03.2022 at various premises of companies and individuals associated with the Hero MotoCorp Group. Pursuant thereto, the assessee's case was centralised by an order passed under section 127 of the Act and notice under section 148 was issued on 02.03.2023.
The Assessing Officer completed the reassessment under section 147 read with section 143(3) of the Act vide order dated 31.03.2024, determining the total income at Rs.3,63,73,570 after making an addition of Rs.2,99,00,000/-under section 69 of the Act on account of alleged unexplained investment in land at Chhatarpur, relating to purchase of 3.54 acres of land. The assessment order, though dated 31.03.2024, was dispatched through speed post on 01.04.2024 and received by the assessee on 02.04.2024.
Aggrieved by the above order, the assessee preferred an appeal before the ld. Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals), challenging both the assumption of jurisdiction and the addition made under section 69 of the Act. During the appellate proceedings, the ld. CIT(A) called for a remand report from the Assessing Officer. The remand report dated 02.12.2025 was furnished to the assessee on 09.12.2025, to which the assessee filed a rejoinder dated 28.12.2025. After considering the material available on record and the submissions of the assessee, the ld. CIT(A) upheld the validity of the reassessment proceedings. However, on merits, the ld. CIT(A) found the addition of Rs.2,99,00,000/- made under section 69 to be unsustainable and accordingly deleted the same. Being aggrieved by the deletion of the addition, the Revenue has preferred the present appeal. The assessee, on the other hand, has filed Cross Objection challenging the decision of the learned CIT(A) upholding the validity of the reassessment proceedings.
Thus, the controversy before us involves two issues: (i) the validity of the reassessment proceedings, as challenged by the assessee in its cross-objection; and (ii) the sustainability of the addition of Rs.2,99,00,000/- made under section 69 of the Act, as challenged by the Revenue in its appeal.
At the outset, after considering the application for condonation of delay by the Revenue, we are inclined to condone the delay for the reason that the delay is caused due to reasonable cause.
We shall first deal with the cross-objection filed by the assessee challenging the validity of the reassessment proceedings. The assessee has raised various jurisdictional objections, including the limitation prescribed under section 153(2), the limitation for issuance of notice under section 148 under section 149, the applicability of the extended period of limitation and the alleged non-compliance with the statutory requirements relating to approval under section 151 and Explanation 2 to section 148.
At the outset, it is relevant to record that the jurisdictional objections raised in the present cross-objection are substantially identical to those raised by Shri Pawan Munjal, husband of the present assessee, in his connected appeal (ITA Nos. 4237/DEL/2026 (Assessee's appeal) and 7994/DEL/2026 (Revenue's appeal) for AY 2017-18). Both cases emanate from the same search and seizure proceedings conducted on 23.03.2022 in the Hero MotoCorp Group and the reassessment proceedings were initiated by notices issued on 02.03.2023. The relevant assessment orders in both cases were also dated 31.03.2024 and dispatched on 01.04.2024.
We have examined the jurisdictional issues in detail in the connected appeal of Shri Pawan Munjal. Since the grounds raised in the present cross-objection arise from the same reassessment proceedings and involve substantially identical facts, statutory provisions and legal contentions, we adopt the reasoning and conclusions recorded in the case of Shri Pawan Munjal, mutatis mutandis, while adjudicating the present cross-objection. The findings recorded in the connected appeal shall accordingly be read as forming part of this order.
In particular, in the connected appeal, we have considered the assessee's objection that the reassessment order, though bearing the date 31.03.2024, was dispatched only on 01.04.2024, beyond the period prescribed u/s 153(2) of the Act. The relevant limitation expired on 31.03.2024, being twelve months from the end of the financial year in which the notice under section 148 was served. The assessment order in the present case also bears the date 31.03.2024 but was dispatched on 01.04.2024 and received on 02.04.2024. The facts being identical, we follow the finding recorded in the connected appeal of Shri Pawan Munjal on this issue and apply the same conclusion to the present assessee.
As regards the objection relating to the three-year limitation under section 149, we have also considered this issue in the connected appeal of Shri Pawan Munjal. It has been held therein that the expiry of the ordinary three-year period does not, by itself, invalidate a notice under section 148 where the conditions for invoking the extended period under section 149(1)(b) are satisfied. The reasons recorded in the present case specifically refer to the alleged unexplained investment in Chhatarpur land, representing escaped income in the form of an immovable asset and exceeding the prescribed monetary threshold of Rs.50 lakh. The alleged unexplained investment of Rs.2,99,00,000/- is also substantially above the statutory threshold. The assessee's objection on this ground is accordingly rejected by following the reasoning adopted in the connected appeal.
The remaining jurisdictional objections relating to the approval under section 151(ii), the applicability of Explanation 2 to section 148 and the alleged absence of valid information for initiating reassessment proceedings are also substantially identical to those raised in the connected appeal of Shri Pawan Munjal. We accordingly adopt the findings recorded therein on these issues as well. To the extent that any of these grounds do not require separate adjudication in view of our conclusion on the limitation prescribed under section 153(2), they are left open and no separate finding is considered necessary.
Accordingly, following the findings recorded in the connected appeal of Shri Pawan Munjal, the cross-objection filed by the assessee is allowed on the jurisdictional ground relating to limitation under section 153(2) of the Act and the reassessment order dated 31.03.2024 is quashed.
The same findings as above shall apply mutatis mutandis to the corresponding domestic-event based perquisite addition u/s 17(2) of the Act in all connected assessment years of the assessee. The chart below provides the application of above findings to remaining years as well.
| Issue involved in jurisdictional grounds raised by the assessee in CO | Ground number in assessee’s appeal | Tribunal findings /conclusion |
|---|---|---|
| General challenge to validity of reassessment | Ground 1 - all seven years | General grounds and hence not specifically adjudicated - specific grounds discussed below |
| Limitation under section 153(2) | Ground 1.1 - AYs 2015-16 to 2018-19 | Assessee’s grounds in cross objections are allowed for AY 2015-16 and AY 2016-17 and dismissed as not pressed for AY 2017-18 & AY 2018-19. |
| First proviso to section 149 / grandfathering provision | Ground 1.2 in AYs 2015-16 to 2018-19 | Not allowed and hence dismissed. |
| Extended limitation under section 149(1)(b) - 3 years | Ground 1.2 in AYs 2015-16 to | Not allowed and hence dismissed. |
| 2018-19 | ||
| Explanation 2(iii)/(iv) versus Explanation 2(i) to section 148 | Grounds 1.3 &1.4 in AYs 2015-16 to 2018-19 | Not specifically adjudicated and hence dismissed. |
| Invalid/mechanical sanction, invalid/mechanical sanction and DIN on approval/proforma | Ground 1.5 in AYs 2015-16 to 2018-19 | Not adjudicated and hence dismissed. |
| Invalid/unreliable third-party information and failure to dispose of objections | Ground 1.6 in AY 2015-16 to 2018-19 | Not adjudicated and hence dismissed. |
| Assessment order, demand notice or ITNS without digital signature | Ground 1.7 in AY 2015- 16 to 2018-19 | Not adjudicated and hence dismissed. |
| Natural justice, third-party material and denial of rebuttal/cross-examination | Ground 1.8 in AY 2015-16 to 2018-19 | Not adjudicated and hence dismissed. |
Coming to the revenue appeal challenging the deletion of the addition of Rs.2,99,00,000/- made under section 69 of the Act on account of alleged unexplained investment in Chhatarpur land. Although the reassessment itself has been quashed on the jurisdictional ground discussed above, we consider it appropriate to record our findings on the merits of the addition as an alternative conclusion, particularly because the issue arises out of common land transactions considered in the connected appeal of Shri Pawan Munjal.
The assessee's case, as set out in the synopsis, is that the addition made in her hands is based upon the same underlying transactions and material as considered in the case of her husband, Shri Pawan Munjal. The assessee and her husband were the ultimate purchasers of the relevant land and the alleged additional consideration was apportioned between them. The Assessing Officer proceeded on the basis of an alleged agreement to sell relating to 5.41 acres of land for a consideration of Rs.82.25 crore and sought to infer that the consideration recorded in the subsequent registered sale deeds did not represent the actual consideration paid for the land.
We have examined this issue in detail in the connected appeal of Shri Pawan Munjal ITA Nos. 4237/DEL/2026 (Assessee's appeal) and 7994/DEL/2026 (Revenue's appeal) for AY 2017-18). In that case, after considering the alleged agreement to sell, the loose sheets and other documents relied upon by the Assessing Officer, the statements of third parties and the transactions involving M/s Labhlaxmi, M/s Glocera and M/s Apple, we have held that the material relied upon by the Assessing Officer does not establish, through cogent and corroborative evidence, that the assessee had actually paid any consideration over and above the amount recorded in the registered sale deeds.
We have also held in the connected appeal that the alleged agreement to sell between the original sellers and M/s Labhlaxmi cannot, by itself, establish that the present assessee or her husband had paid additional consideration in cash. The subsequent registered transaction between the intermediary company and the ultimate purchasers is a distinct transaction. Merely because the Revenue alleges that the intermediary entities were conduit or pass-through companies, it cannot be presumed that the funds for the alleged cash component were provided by the ultimate purchasers. Such an inference must be supported by reliable evidence demonstrating the actual flow of funds and establishing the connection of the assessee with the alleged payment.
The essential factual and evidentiary foundation of the addition in the present case is identical to that considered in the connected appeal of Shri Pawan Munjal. The assessee has also expressly adopted the synopsis and submissions filed by her husband Mr. Pawan Munjal in the connected appeals. No distinguishing material or independent evidence has been brought to our notice by the Revenue to establish that the present assessee paid an additional amount of Rs.2,99,00,000/- in cash over and above the consideration recorded in the registered sale deed.
We accordingly hold that the findings and conclusions recorded by us in the connected appeal of Shri Pawan Munjal on the issue of alleged unexplained investment in Chhatarpur land shall apply, mutatis mutandis, to the present case. For the detailed reasons recorded therein, which are adopted and incorporated herein by reference, we hold that the Revenue has failed to establish the making of any unexplained investment by the present assessee within the meaning of section 69 of the Act.
Consequently, the deletion of the addition of Rs.2,99,00,000/- made u/s 69 of the Act by the learned CIT(A) is upheld. The grounds raised by the Revenue are dismissed.
The same findings as above shall apply mutatis mutandis to the corresponding additions u/s 69 of the Act in all connected assessment years of the Revenue’s appeals. The chart below provides the application of above findings to remaining years as well :-
| AY | Appeal | Ground number | Amount | ITAT finding |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2015-16 | Assessee CO -364/Del/2026 | - | - | ‘CO’ allowed as indicated above. |
| Revenue - ITA 7995/Del/2026 | Grounds 1-3 | ₹2,99,00,000/- | Revenue’s grounds are dismissed and deletion of disallowance made by the CIT(A) is upheld. | |
| 2016-17 | Assessee CO -365/Del/2026 | - | - | ‘CO’ allowed as indicated above. |
| Revenue - ITA 7930/Del/2026 | Grounds 1-3 | ₹20,04,75,000/- | Revenue’s grounds are dismissed and deletion of disallowance made by the CIT(A) is upheld. | |
| 2017-18 | Assessee CO -366/Del/2026 | - | - | NA |
| Revenue - ITA | Grounds | ₹35,28,82,500/- | Revenue’s grounds are dismissed and deletion of | |
| 7996/Del/2026 | 1-3 | disallowance made by the CIT(A) is upheld. | ||
| 2018-19 | Assessee CO -367/Del/2026 | - | - | NA |
| Revenue - ITA 7997/Del/2026 | Grounds 1-3 | ₹9,39,53,025/- | Revenue’s grounds are dismissed and deletion of disallowance made by the CIT(A) is upheld. |
In the result, the assessee’s cross objections on jurisdictional issues are allowed in AY 2015-16 and AY 2016-17 on ground of limitation, while the Revenue’s appeal for all four assessment years are dismissed.
