High CourtsSingle Bench(2026) 10 P&H CK 5152

Darshan Singh vs Ashok Kumar Sethi & Ors.

Punjab And Haryana At Chandigarh · Decided on 30 October 2026 · Citation: 2026 INSC 1122

HON’BLE JUDGES
Harkesh Manuja, J
RESULT
Dismissed
CASE NUMBER
ESA No.68 of 2026 (O&M)

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

14 paragraphs · 1,452 words

HARKESH MANUJA, J. (Oral)

1.

By way of the present Execution Second Appeal, challenge has been laid to the orders dated 24.08.2026and 28.09.2026 passed by the learned Additional Civil Judge (Senior Division), Sirsa and the learned Additional District & Sessions Judge, Sirsa, respectively, whereby the third party objections preferred at the instance of appellant were dismissed and the appeal preferred there against also stood dismissed.

2.

Briefly stating, a suit for separate possession by way of partition as well as permanent injunction was instituted at the instance of respondent No.1/plaintiff against respondent Nos.2 to 4, with respect to Gair Mumkinplot measuring 01 Kanal comprised in Khewat No.489, Khatauni No.691, Khasra No.594(1-0) situated in village Sikanderpur, Tehsil and District Sirsa. The learned Trial Court vide judgment and decree dated 23.01.2025 passed a preliminary decree in favour of respondent No.1/plaintiff wherein it was recorded that the respondent No.1/plaintiff was owner to the extent of 3½ marla, being 7/40 share, in the suit land.

3.

Based thereupon, respondent No.1/plaintiff filed an application for passing of the final decree, in which the Halqa Kanungo was appointed as Local Commissioner to suggest the mode of partition. Relying upon the mode of partition dated 30.08.2025 suggested by the Local Commissioner, whereby land measuring 0-3-4½ (K-M-S) comprised in Khasra No.594/1 was allotted to respondent No.1, a final decree was passed by the learned Addl. Civil Judge (Senior Division) Sirsa on 29.09.2025 and accordingly, the decree holder/respondent No.1 sought execution thereof. Warrant of possession was issued through the Tehsildar vide order dated 30.10.2025; however, as per report dated 10.11.2025 of the Field Kanungo, possession could not be delivered since two shops and one house in possession of the appellant were found existing over Khasra No.594/1 and the possession proceedings were resisted at the spot. During pendency of the execution proceedings, the appellant herein filed his third party objections while claiming himself to be owner in possession of land measuring 15 marlas comprised in Khasra No.593/1 and affected by the execution proceedings; however, the same were dismissed by the learned Executing Court vide order dated 24.08.2026.

4.

Aggrieved thereof, the appellant filed an appeal bearing No.CMA-94-2026. The same was dismissed by the learned Addl. District & Sessions Judge at Sirsa vide order dated 28.09.2026. Hence the present appeal.

5.

Impugning the aforesaid orders, learned counsel for the appellant submits that under the garb of execution of judgment and decree dated 29.09.2025, the construction raised by the appellant over his own property forming part of Khasra No.593/1 was sought to be demolished. Learned counsel submits that though the subject matter of the suit as well as the decree passed in favour of respondent No.1/decree holder pertained to Khasra No.594, with the share of respondent No.1 being allotted in Khasra No.594/1, the execution was sought to be enforced in respect of land forming part of Khasra No.593/1 which belonged to the appellant and in such circumstances, no execution could have been carried out, unless the subject matter of the decree was duly demarcated, so as to ascertain whether the land in possession of the appellant formed part of Khasra No.594/1 or 593/1.In support of his arguments, learned counsel relies upon the decision of this Courtin CR No.6882 of 2018 titled ‘Baljit Singh vs. Dial Kaur @ Gurdial Kaur’, decided on 27.11.2018.

5.1

Learned counsel further submits that the appellant being affected as a third party rightly preferred objections before the learned Executing Court and in the given facts and circumstances, when the identity of the subject property was disputed, the learned Executing Court was required to frame issues and the third party objections were to be decided after grant of opportunity to the appellant to prove his case. Learned counsel also contends that no separate civil suit was maintainable at the instance of the appellant in the given facts and circumstances. Reliance has been placed upon the decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case ofAlladin Charities and Zakat Wakf vs. Mohammed Saleem alias Mohd. Wajid Ali and Anr. 2026 INSC 1122.

6.

I have heard learned counsel for the appellant and perused the paper book. I am unable to find substance in the submissions made on behalf of the appellant.

7.

In the given facts and circumstances, the decree under execution relates to Khasra No.594/1, which fell to the share of respondent No.1 in the final decree. Admittedly, the claim set up by the appellant is with respect to land measuring 15 marlas forming part of Khasra No.593/1. Qua the said land, the appellant has already filed a suit for permanent injunction bearing No.CS/1152/2025 titled 'Darshan Singh vs. Ashok Kumar Sethi' with prayer for restraining respondent No.1 from interfering in any manner in the ownership and physical possession of the appellant over the residential house. An ex parte interim order dated 27.11.2025 has been passed in that suit qua the property described therein. The learned Executing Court took note of the report of the Kanungo that the obstruction to the warrant of possession qua Khasra No.594/1 was caused by the appellant. It held that the execution was confined to Khasra No.594/1 and the objections, which pertained to a different khasra number, could not be sustained. The learned First Appellate Court summoned the Kanungo and the Patwari concerned. The Kanungo specifically stated that the entire area of Khasra No.594/1 is in occupation of the appellant in the form of two shops and one house constructed by him. It was thus found that instead of being in possession of the land purchased by him in Khasra No.593, the appellant is occupying Khasra No.594/1. It was further found that no counter demarcation report was produced by the appellant to show otherwise.

8.

The plea set up in the third party objections is that under the garb of execution of the final decree, the possession of the appellant over land forming part of Khasra No.593/1 is sought to be taken from him. The appellant contends that since the identity of the property is in issue, demarcation of the subject land ought to be carried out before proceeding further in the execution. However, admittedly, no application for such demarcation has been filed by the appellant in his own civil suit preferred against respondent No.1/decree holder. If the appellant was so concerned about the identity of the property, he ought to have at the first instance moved an appropriate application for seeking demarcation of the subject property therein. No such prayer was made either in his own suit or in the objections preferred before the learned Executing Court. The objections sought only withdrawal of the warrant of possession.

9.

In such circumstances, wherein the appellant, though raising the issue of identity of the subject property, has not moved any appropriate and specific application for carrying out demarcation thereof in his own suitand has placed nothing on record to dislodge the report dated 10.11.2025 and the statement of the Kanungo, no interference can be called for with the findings recorded by the learned Courts below that the objections preferred by the appellant did not disclose even a prima facie case, and that the resistance offered by him to the execution of the final judgment and decree dated 29.09.2025 passed in favour of respondent No.1/plaintiff was without any rightful claim. Thus, once the objections raised by the appellant were found to be prima facie without substance, there was no reason for the learned Courts below to have framed issues thereon.

10.

Moreover, the judgments relied upon by learned counsel for the appellant do not advance his case. In Baljit Singh (supra), the decree holder had herself pleaded, in reply to the objections, that part of Khasra No.1842 overlapped with Khasra No.1843. The parties were otherwise ad idem as to their respective ownership of the two khasra numbers, and the dispute was confined to measurement alone. Demarcation was directed in that backdrop. Further, in Alladin Charities (supra), the identity of the property depended upon correlation of the descriptions in the earlier title documents, the agreement of sale and the decree schedule, which itself required adjudication, whereas in the present case, the identity of the land in occupation of the appellant was examined by the learned First Appellate Court by summoning the Kanungo and the Patwari concerned. Neither judgment, therefore, applies to the facts of the present case.

11.

In view of the discussion made hereinabove, the findings recorded by the learned Courts below being based on proper appreciation of pleadings and the material available on record, there being no illegality or perversity in the impugned orders, no interference is called for. Consequently, the present Execution Second Appeal is hereby dismissed.

12.

Pending application(s), if any shall also stand disposed of.