High CourtsSingle Bench(2018) 11 DEL CK 0100

Construction Industry Development Council vs Subhash Chandra Agarwal

Delhi High Court · Decided on 16 November 2018

HON’BLE JUDGES
Vibhu Bakhru, J
RESULT
Dismissed
CASE NUMBER
Civil Writ Petition No. 7289 Of 2015 & Civil Miscellaneous No.s. 13391 Of 2015, 30884 Of 2017

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

108 paragraphs · 1,445 words

,,

VIBHU BAKHRU, J",,

1.

The petitioner (hereafter “CIDC”) has filed the present petition impugning the order dated 25.06.2015 (hereafter “the impugned order”)

passed by the Central Information Commission (hereafter “CIC”). By the impugned order, the CIC has held CIDC to be a Public Authority within"

the meaning of Section 2(h) of the Right to Information Act, 2005 (hereafter “the RTI Act”)."

2.

The respondent had filed an application dated 08.04.2013 under the RTI Act, inter alia, seeking information about file notings/ correspondences/"

documents regarding the establishment of CIDC. The respondent did not receive any information in response to the aforesaid application.

Consequently, on 21.05.2013, the respondent filed a complaint under the RTI Act before the CIC. The CIC took notice of the complaint and on"

25.06.2015, passed the impugned order declaring CIDC a public authority in terms of the RTI Act. The CIC further directed CIDC to appoint a"

Central Public Information Officer and a First Appellate Authority under the relevant provisions of the RTI Act and to respond to the respondent’s

application.,,

3.

The only question, which falls for consideration of this Court in the present petition, is whether CIDC is a “public authority” as defined under"

Section 2(h) of the RTI Act.,,

4.

The petitioner (CIDC) is a society registered under the Societies Registration Act, 1860. CIDC was established in terms of an Office Memorandum"

dated 11.04.1996 (hereafter “the Memorandum”) issued by the Planning Commission. It was stated therein that CIDC had been setup in light of

the recommendations received by the Planning Commission for setting up a Central Nodal Authority, “to look into construction related problems"

common to all sectors under different wings of the government” and also of the construction industry itself.

5.

The respondent, who claims to be a RTI activist, filed an application on 08.04.2013 under the RTI Act before the concerned Public Information"

Officer (PIO), inter alia, seeking the following information :-",,

1.

Complete information together with related file notings/ correspondence/documents etc. on establishing CIDC by planning Commission/Government

of India/others concerned naming ministry/department etc of Government of India having role in establishment of CIDC mentioning also date of

establishment,,

2.

Complete information on role of planning Commission/Government of India/others in establishing CIDC

3.

Complete information on assignment/role given co CIDC by planning commission/Government of India/others etc naming the

ministries/departments etc concerned for assigning any role to CIDC,,

4.

Is it true that Union Ministry of Coal has assigned some role to CIDC

5.

Complete information on role assigned by Union Ministry of Coal to CIDC

6.

Complete information of capital funded at CIDC,,

7.

Complete information on year-wise income/expenses under various heads of CIDC from the date of its establishment

8.

Complete information of CIDC complying with provisions of Right-To- Information (RTI)' Act for being a public-authority under section 2(h) of

RTI Act for being established by planning commission/Government of India,,

9.

Complete information on providing details of Public Information Officer, Appellate Authority and provisions under section 4 of RTI Act on CIDC"

website”,,

6.

The respondent did not receive any response to the said application. Consequently, on 21.05.2013, the respondent filed a complaint before CIC"

under Section 18 of the RTI Act. It was stated therein that CIDC is a public authority covered under the ambit of the RTI Act and, thus, was required"

to provide the information as sought by the respondent.,,

7.

Thereafter, the CIC passed an interim order dated 08.01.2014 directing CIDC and the Planning Commission to file submissions and documents as"

to why CIDC does not fall within the meaning of “Public Authority” under the provisions of RTI Act. On 19.05.2014, the CIC referred the matter"

to a Full Bench to consider the aforesaid issue.,,

8.

The CIC, in the impugned order, noted that, admittedly, CIDC had received Rs.6.43 crores as total corpus fund and out of that amount,"

Rs.2.74 crores were granted by the Planning Commission. The CIC further observed that Rs.72,00,000/- out of the initial corpus fund of"

Rs.1,99,40,000/- collected by CIDC was contributed by Government Organizations and Institutions. The CIC also analysed the balance sheets of"

CIDC, and observed that contribution to the extent of 84% of the total corpus of CIDC for the financial year 1997-1998, was made by the Planning"

Commission and other Government Agencies.,,

9.

Taking the aforesaid analysis into consideration, the CIC held that CIDC was running at a loss and it would not have survived without the huge"

financial support of the Planning Commission. The CIC also referred to the decision of a Coordinate Bench of this Court in Mother Dairy Fruit & Veg

Ltd. v. Hatim Ali & Anr, W.P.(C) 3110/2011, decided on 02.02.2015, wherein this Court had held that Mother Dairy Fruit & Veg Ltd. was a public"

authority in the light of the fact that it was receiving substantial funding (grants and loans) from the Central Government. The CIC also analysed the

records of CIDC and observed that the Planning Commission is a permanent member of CIDC and further, the annual reports of CIDC are presented"

in the Parliament, both of which indicates that the Central Government exercises control over CIDC. The CIC concluded that CIDC is an"

instrumentality of the Planning Commission, as the Memorandum of Association submitted by CIDC reveals that the Planning Commission had"

decided to set up CIDC as the Apex Nodal Agency “concerned with all aspects of Construction Industry”.

10.

The CIC, considering all the aforesaid documents and records, concluded that CIDC was a public authority since the role and contribution of the"

Central Government in terms of finance, control and operation, was substantial and pervasive."

Reasons & Conclusion,,

S.No.,Particulars,

i.,"Chairman of CIDC nominated by

the Deputy Chairman of

the

Planning Commission",1

,Elected Members: Elected from,

,,

,,

,"among and by each of the three

categories of members for a tenure

of two years, eligible for re-

elections only after a gap of two

years

Permanent Members 4

Corporate Members 4

Institutional Members 2

Total Elected:",10

iii.,"Industry Association:

Nominated for a period of two

years.

Eligible for re-nomination",

iv.,Institutional Members (nominated),1

v.,"Govt. Departments who are major

clients of the construction industry.

Nominated for a period of two

years. May be re-nominated",6

vi.,"Central Public Sector Undertaking with major

stake in Constructions. Nominated for a

period of two years.",3

vii.,"State Governments or their nominee

departments/PSUs (by two year rotation).

Nominated ",3

viii.,"Persons of Eminence in the field of

constructions",1

,Total,30

15.

It is also not disputed that Planning Commission ha cdontributed Rs.2.74 crores as a corpus of CIDC and the interest on the

same was required to be utilized for its functioning. The CIDC contends that the same could not be stated to form the edifice of its substratum, as it"

only amounts to 38% of the corpus fund. This contention is unpersuasive. Indisputably, Rs.2.74 crores constitutes 38% of the CIDCʼs corpus fund."

The said fund was contributed in the year 1997 and it cannot be disputed that the same is a substantial amount and such contribution was necessary

for CIDC to discharge its functions. The CIC had found that but for the aforesaid contribution, it would have been difficult for CIDC to survive. The"

CIC had found that as on 31.03.1998, the operations of CIDC indicated that it had resulted in a deficit. However, that was more than made up by"

grant of finance from the Planning Commission. The CIC also found that as on 31.03.1998, the contribution by the Planning Commission itself was"

48% in the capital of CIDC.,,

16.

In Thalappalam Service Cooperative Bank Ltd. and Ors. v. State of Kerala and Ors.: (2013) 16 SCC 8 2, the Supreme Court had explained that"

the expression “substantially financed”, as used in Section 2(h)(d)(i) and (ii) of the RTI Act, meant that degree of financing must be “actual,"

existing positive and real to a substantial extent, not moderate, ordinary, tolerable etc.” In the present case, it can hardly be disputed that the financial"

support extended by the Planning Commission was not hypocritical; it was real and substantial.At the material time, the Planning Commission had"

provided to a significant extent, the funds required by CIDC to exist."

17.

It is not necessary that the funds provided by Planning Commission ought to constitute majority of CIDC’s corpus. Th ewords “substantially

financed” must be understood in the manner as explained by the Supreme Court in Thalappalam Service Cooperative Bank Ltd. (supra); it should be

positive, real and to a substantial extent.",,

18.

In view of the above, this Court finds no reason to interfere with the decision of the CIC holding CIDC to be a public authority. The petition is,"

accordingly, dismissed. The pending applications are also disposed of.",,