High CourtsSingle Bench(2010) 10 MAD CK 0032

Chinnathambi vs State

Madras High Court · Decided on 8 October 2010

HON’BLE JUDGES
T. Mathivanan, J
CASE NUMBER
Criminal R. (MD) No. 18 of 2009

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

141 paragraphs · 8,180 words

T. Mathivanan, J.—This memorandum of Criminal Revision is directed against the judgment dated 21.10.2008 and made in S.C. No. 14 of 2008 on the file of the learned Sessions Judge, Sivagangai Sessions Division acquitting the accused on the ground that the prosecution has failed to prove the charge u/s 302 of I.P.C., beyond all reasonable doubts.

Being aggrieved by the impugned judgment, the complainant to the police who has been examined as P.W.1 in this case has preferred this Criminal Revision after invoking the proviso to Sections 397 and 401 of Cr.P.C.

2.

For easy reference, the criminal revision Petitioner may hereinafter be referred to as P.W.1 and the second Respondent may herein after be referred to as the accused whereas, the first Respondent be referred to as the Investigating Officer wherever it occurs.

3.

The facts which giving rise to the memorandum of criminal revision may be summarized briefly as follows:

a) P.W.1, Chinnathambi who is the revision Petitioner herein is none other than the brother of the deceased's daughter-in-law Shenbagavalli. He is residing at M. Kovilpatti village. The accused Ramu is also residing in the same village. There was a previous enmity between the deceased Chinniah and the accused Ramu in respect of an irrigation channel. In this connection, a civil suit in O.S. No. 682 of 1994 was instituted and ended in favour of the accused Ramu. Besides this, on the strength of the complaint lodged by the accused Ramu, a criminal case in Cr. No. 72 of 2005 was registered against the deceased Chinniah and others alleging that he with the connivance of others was trying to kill the accused Ramu by administering poison in the cool drink. In the latter stage, the case was tried before the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Sivagangai and ended in conviction in respect of the other accused. Since the deceased Chinniah has been murdered, the case against him was abated.

b) That on 19.05.2007 at about 6.15 a.m., P.W.1/Chinnathambi was heading towards his house after taking tea. Whileso, the deceased Chinniah was found coming from the opposite direction by rolling his cycle.

Since previous enmity was prevailing between the accused Ramu and the deceased Chinniah, the deceased Chinniah was followed by the accused Ramu closely and suddenly, he had cut the deceased with arruval over his head from behind.

He again had cut him over his right hand twice. After receiving those injuries, the deceased had slided down.

Even after that the accused Ramu had cut him over his right leg and as a result of which it was severed. Thereafter, the accused took the cycle of the deceased and pedalled to certain distance and then, dropped it and ran away from that place. When PW 2/Mookkiah was heading towards his house after answering the calls of nature, the accused was found coming from the opposite direction with an arruval in his hand from which blood was dripping. On seeing PW 2, PW 1 was shouting that the accused Ramu had cut his uncle Chinniah and asked him to come running. The deceased had then succumbed to the injuries on the spot. Thereafter, P.W.1 and P.W.2 had been to the house of Shenbagavalli and after informing her about the incident, they gone to S.V. Mangalam Police Station wherein, P.W.1 had given an oral statement which was reduced into writing by P.W.8/the Sub-Inspector of Police. The First Information given by P.W.1 was marked under Ex.P1. On the basis of Ex.P.1, P.W.8/the Sub-Inspector of Police had registered a case in Cr. No. 47 of 2007 u/s 302 of I.P.C. The printed First Information Report was marked as Ex.P10 and thereafter, both the documents viz., Exs.P1 and P10 were sent to the Learned Judicial Magistrate's Court, Thiruppathur through P.W.5/the Head Constable, and the documents were reached at the hands of the learned Judicial Magistrate at 10 a.m. on the same day. The copies of Exs.P1 and P10 were also sent to the police higher officials for further proceedings.

c) Then, P.W.11/the Inspector of Police attached to S.V. Mangalam Police Station had taken up the case for investigation. At about 9.00 a.m., he proceeded to the place of occurrence, inspected the same in the presence of P.W.3/Mohamed Reafeek, and prepared an observation mahazor Ex.P3 and a rough sketch Ex.15 in the presence of PW3 Village Administrative Officer and one Mahendran. P.W.11 had also prepared an Observation Mahazor under Ex.P3 and drawn a rough sketch in respect of the place of occurrence under Ex.P16. He had also collected some blood stained and some unblood stained earth in the presence of the same witnesses under M.O.1 and M.O.2 respectively and subsequent to that, he had seized the cycle of the deceased which was found lying there under the seizure mahazar Ex.P4. Then, from 10.30 a.m. to 12.30 p.m., he had conducted inquest on the dead body of the deceased Chinniah in the presence of panchayatars and prepared an inquest report under Ex.P17.

After completion of the inquest report, the dead body was sent to post-mortem examination through P.W.6/the Head Constable along with a requisition under Ex.P8. At about 1.30 p.m., P.W.7/Dr. Balsubramanian had received the dead body and in pursuant to Ex.P8 (requisition), he had started conducting of post-mortem examination. Whileso, he had found the following external and internal injuries.

External Examination:

1) Right knee joint completely severed exposing both ends of the joint with hanging of the leg below with skin support only. Reddish brown in colour.

2) A curved cut injury about 20 cm x brain depth x 6 cm in wide on the left parietal bone. The injury extends from joint above left ear to the forehead wider on the ear side and sharpen forward the forehead. Reddish brown in colour.

3) A cut injury about 10 cm x bone depth x 4 cm in size exposing two ends of the joint of right elbow joint.

Reddish brown in colour.

4) A cut injury about 10cm x bone depth x 6cm on the right forearm. Reddish brown in colour.

Internal Examination:

Hyoid bone intact.

On opening the thorax:

Heart chambers partially filled with blood and lungs congested.

On opening the abdomen:

Liver spleen, kidney are pale. Stomach contains 60 ml of digested food. Intestine with distended gas. Urinary bladder empty.

On opening the skull:

Skull bone cut through corresponding to the second injury.

Brain also cut through out. Spine-intact.

c. After completion of the post-mortem examination, P.W.7 had issued a certificate to that effect under Ex.P9 in which he had opined that the death could have been occurred due to hemorrhage and shock due to multiple injuries.

d. Thereafter, P.W.11 had examined the witnesses and recorded their statements. On 20.05.2007 at about 7.00 a.m., P.W.11 had arrested the accused Ramu at Manakkudi Bus-stop in the presence of P.W.3/Mohammed Rafik, Village Administrative Officer and Mahendran. When he was interrogated, he had voluntarily given a confessional statement which was reduced into writing by P.W.11 in the presence of the same witnesses and on the basis of his disclosure statement (Ex.P5), the crime weapon was recovered under M.O.4 at the instance of the accused which was hidden beneath a karuvelam tree near Thirukkalapatti tank. Seizure mahazar to that effect was marked as Ex.P6.

Then, the accused along with crime weapon was brought to the police station and sent to the court for being remanded to judicial custody. After the completion of the investigation, P.W.11 had laid a final report on 09.06.2007 before the learned Judicial Magistrate, Thiruppathur.

e) After taking cognizance of the offence u/s 302 of I.P.C. and furnishing the copies of the charge sheet to the accused as contemplated u/s 207 of Cr.P.C., the learned Judicial Magistrate, Thiruppathur had committed the case to the Court of Session as required u/s 209(a) Cr.P.C..

f) On hearing both sides, the learned Sessions Judge, Sivagangai Sessions division had framed a charge u/s 302 of I.P.C. When the ingredients of the charge were explained and questioned, the accused had pleaded innocent and claimed to be tried and hence, he was put on trial.

g) In order to establish it's case, the prosecuting agency had examined 11 witnesses and during the course of their examination, Exs. P1 to P17 were marked. When the accused was examined u/s 313 of Cr.P.C., after explaining the incriminating circumstances arising out of the testimonies of the prosecution witnesses, while denying their testimonies, he had replied that the case was foisted against him. Besides, he had also submitted a written statement which was received and filed along with the record.

h) Though the accused had replied that he was going to examine witness on his part, no oral evidence was let in, instead Exs. D1 and D2 alone were marked on his behalf.

i) On appraising both the oral and documentary evidences and considering the submissions made on behalf of both sides, the learned Sessions Judge, Sivagangai Session division had pronounced the judgment on 21.10.2008, acquitting the accused on the ground as stated above.

3.

Being aggrieved by the impugned judgment, P.W.1 who is the complainant to the police has come forward with this criminal revision petition.

4.

Heard both sides.

Maintainability of Revision by informant to the police:

5.

Before we go into the question of maintainability of revision by an informant to the police, it may be relevant to say that normally when an order of acquittal has been passed by the trial Court, the state is really an aggrieved party. The state should have approached this Court to revise the order of acquittal, but unfortunately, the State has not preferred any revision. Hence, PW 1 who is the informant to the police, has approached this Court by way of this memorandum of Criminal Revision.

6.

In K. Pandurangan etc. Vs. S.S.R. Velusamy and Another, it is observed that;

In so far as the question of maintainability of the revision at the instance of the complainant is concerned, we think the said argument has only to be noted to be rejected. Under the provisions of Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, the Court has suo motu power of revision, if that be so, the question of the same being invoked at the instance of an outsider would not make any difference because ultimately it is the power of revision which is already vested with the High Court statutorily that is being exercised by the High Court. Therefore, whether the same is done by itself or at the instance of a third party will not affect such power of the High Court.

7.

While writing the judgment on behalf of the Division Bench Hon'ble Mr. Justice Santosh Hegde has referred the decision in Nadir Khan Vs.

The State (Delhi Administration), .

8.

In Satyendra Nath Dutta and Another Vs. Ram Narain, a Division Bench of the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India has observed that;

Section 439(1) Code of Criminal Procedure (New Section 401 Cr.P.C) which deals with the revisional powers of the High Court provides that in the exercise of revisional jurisdiction the High Court may exercise any of the powers conferred on a court of appeal. As the Court of appeal is entitled u/s 423(1)(a) to reverse an order of acquittal or to direct a re-trial, the High Court in the exercise of its revisional powers would also be entitled to record a conviction by reversing the order of acquittal. But Sub-section (4) of Section 439 provides expressly that nothing contained in the section "shall be deemed to authorise a High Court to convert a finding of acquittal into one of conviction".

9.

On coming to the instant case on hand, when the revision came up for hearing, the learned Counsel appearing on behalf of the accused has raised a serious question about the maintainability of this memorandum of criminal revision. He has also submitted that since P.W.1 being a private party, he could not maintain this criminal revision as he is not having locus-standi and that this revision might to be rejected in limine.

10.

By way of answering this question, the learned Counsel appearing on behalf of the revision Petitioner has submitted that only on the basis of the information given by the revision Petitioner, the law was set in motion and the investigation was taken up by the Investigating Agency and since the judgment of the trial Court seems to be perverse and material evidences have been over looked, PW 1 has approached this Court by way of this revision, as he is not permitted to prefer an appeal u/s 378(4) of Code of Criminal Procedure against the judgment of acquittal. He has also laid emphasis on the proviso to Section 378(4) of Cr.P.C.

Section 378(4) - If such an order of acquittal is passed in any case instituted upon complaint and the High Court, on an application made to it by the complainant in this behalf, grants special leave to appeal from the order of acquittal, the complainant may present such an appeal to the High Court.

11.

He has also added that PW 1 who is the complainant to the police is having locus-standi to prefer this revision after invoking the revisional powers vested with the High Court u/s 401 of Criminal Procedure Code. He has also drawn the attention of this Court to the proviso to Section 401 of Cr.P.C.

Section 401(1) In the case of any proceeding the record of which has been called for by itself or which otherwise comes to its knowledge, the High Court may, in its discretion, exercise any of the powers conferred on a Court of Appeal by Section 386, 389, 390 and 391 or on a Court of Session by Section 307 and, when the Judges composing the Court of revision are equally divided in opinion, the case shall be disposed of in the manner provided by Section 392.

(2) No order under this section shall be made to the prejudice of the accused or other person unless he has had an opportunity of being heard either personally or by pleader in his own defence.

(3) Nothing in this section shall be deemed to authorise a High Court to convert a finding of acquittal into one of conviction.

(4) Where under this Code an appeal lies and no appeal is brought, no proceeding by way of revision shall be entertained at the instance of the party who could have appealed.

(5) Where under this Code an appeal lies but an application for revision has been made to the High Court by any person and the High Court is satisfied that such application was made under the erroneous belief that no appeal lies thereto and that it is necessary in the interests of justice so to do, the High Court may treat the application for revision as a petition of appeal and deal with the same accordingly.

12.

In order to substantiate his argument, he has also placed reliance upon the decision in Kishan Swaroop v. Govt. Of NCT of Delhi (1998 SCC 1587). In this case, a Division Bench of the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India, comprising their Lordships Hon'ble Mr. Justice M.K. Mukherjee and Hon'ble Mr. Justice K.T. Thomas, has observed that ""Revision against order of acquittal passed in a case instituted on a police report is entertainable even at the instance of a private party in exceptional cases

13.

In the above cited case, on a report lodged by the Appellant with the Sadar Bazar Police Station, Delhi, a case was registered against three persons. The accused therein stood there for trial for the offence punishable under Sections 381 and 411 of I.P.C. The trial ultimately ended in their acquittal and aggrieved thereby, the Appellant filed a revision in Delhi High Court. At the time of hearing, the Delhi High Court posed the question as to whether the Appellant was required to obtain permission from the public prosecutor to file such petition. The Delhi High Court had answered the question in the affirmative and dismissed the revision petition without prejudice to the Appellant's right to approach it afresh after obtaining the requisite permission. The above order was challenged in the appeal. While pronouncing the impugned judgment, the Delhi High Court has referred to the provisions of Sections 378 and 210 of the Code of Criminal Procedure to conclude that it was the primary responsibility of the State to file appeal/revision and therefore, no criminal revision in respect of the order which is appealable at the instance of the State should be entertained without a requisite permission of the public prosecutor. On noticing this observation by the Delhi High Court, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has held that "" In drawing the above inference the High Court failed to notice that if the Code of Criminal Procedure did not empower a private party to file a revision petition against an order of acquittal passed in a case instituted on a police report a formal permission of the Public Prosecutor would not entitle him to do so.

The public prosecutor cannot vest a private party with a right which it has not got under the code.

14.

While penning down the judgment, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has referred the decision in K. Chinnaswamy Reddy Vs. State of Andhra Pradesh, . In this case (viz., Chinnasamy Reddy case), the Hon'ble Supreme Court has observed that ""It is true that it is open to a High Court in revision to set aside the order of acquittal even at the instance of private parties, though the State may not have thought fit to appeal; but this jurisdiction should in our opinion be exercised by the High Court only in exceptional cases, when there is some glaring defect in the procedure or there is a manifest error on a point of law and consequently, there has been a flagrant miscarriage of justice.

15.

On coming to the instant case on hand, it is obvious to note here that P.W.1 who is the revision Petitioner herein is a private party. As per the case of prosecution, he is the only eye witness to the occurrence and P.W.2 happens to be a circumstantial witness. Hence, it is apparent that the whole case of prosecution hinges around the testimony of P.W.1. The other witnesses viz., PW 2, PW 7, PW 8 and PW 11 are only supportive witnesses.

As already discussed, P.W.1 is the brother of Shenbagavalli who is the daughter-in-law of the deceased Chinniah.

Hence, on the acquittal of the accused from the clutches of the charges u/s 302 of I.P.C., he has preferred this revision after invoking the proviso to Section 401 of Cr.P.C., as he is not permitted to maintain an appeal u/s 378 of Cr.P.C.

16.

It is not disputed that the case in S.C. No. 14 of 2008 has been instituted on a police report that too on the basis of information given by the P.W.1. Of course, it is the state who is the aggrieved party and ordinary complainant has no locus-standi to come into the Court but an order if it is perversed could cause miscarriage of justice could be interfered by the High Court after invoking the powers of revision as contemplated u/s 401 of Criminal Procedure Code. This principle has been well established in Krishan Kant Vs. Dilip Kumar and Others, .

17.

Even in Harpal Singh v. the State of Bihar reported in 2004 Cri.L.J.256 (Jharkhand) this principle has been laid down after observing that the revision as against the order of acquittal in police case, at the instance of informant is maintainable as he has no right to file appeal u/s 378 Code of Criminal Procedure Hence, it is palpably made clear that PW 1 is having competency to maintain the revision against acquittal of the accused.

Motive suggested for the occurrence Motive suggested for the occurrence is in two-fold:

1) There was a dispute between the deceased Chinniah and the accused Ramu in respect of an irrigation channel.

In this connection, a suit in O.S. No. 682 of 1994 was instituted by one Vadivel who is the father of the accused Ramu as against the deceased chinniah and ultimately it ended in favour of the said Vadivel. The certified copy of the decree has also been marked as Ex.D1.

2) A case in Cr. No. 72 of 2005 u/s 328 was registered by P.W.10/the Sub-Inspector of Police attached to S.V. Mangalam Police Station on 28.08.2005 on the strength of a complaint lodged by the accused Ramu alleging that the deceased Chinniah along with others was trying to kill him by administering poison in the cool drink. That case was tried before the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Sivagangai in S.C. No. 9 of 2007.

Since the deceased Chinniah was murdered, it was ended in conviction in respect of other accused. These facts are revealed from the testimonies of P.W.1, P.W.10 and P.W.11/Investigating Officer.

18.

The above mentioned motives have been suggested by the prosecuting agency for the commission of the gruesome murder by the accused herein.

It is settled law that motive has always been relegated to the secondary place. It acts as a double edged weapon and as such it can be used by either sides.

In Basdev Vs. The State of Pepsu, it is held that Motive, Knowledge, interest and intention are different aspects, motive is that force which prompts a man to form an intention and knowledge is awareness about after efforts of an offence.

19.

In Yaswant v. State of Maharastra (1972 SCC 684), the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India has held that It is not Indian jurisprudence that in all murder cases-motive is necessarily to be proved.

20.

On coming to the instant case on hand, as discussed in the opening paragraphs, the two-fold motive has been spoken to by P.W.1, P.W.10 and P.W.11 and they have also spoken to about it's existence.

Evidentiary value of solidarity eye witness:

21.

P.W.1/Chinnathambi claims to have witnessed the occurrence directly. P.W.2/Mookkiah is the circumstantial witness. According to P.W.1 at about 6.15 a.m., on 19.05.2007 after taking tea he was coming by walk, in order to go to his house. While so, the deceased Chinniah was found coming from the opposite direction by rolling his cycle. At that time, the accused came behind with a billhook (arruval) and cut the deceased Chinniah over his head. On seeing this, P.W.1 had raised hue and cry.

Again, the accused had cut the deceased twice over his right hand and after receiving the cut injuries over his right hand and head, the deceased Chinniah had slided down.

Immediately, the accused had cut his right leg and as a result of which it was severed. Thereafter, the accused Ramu had taken the cycle of the deceased Chinniah and proceeded towards the northern side and after pedalling for some distance, he had dropped the cycle and run away from that place.

On coming to the evidence of P.W.2:

22.

He would state in his chief examination that on the fateful day at about 5 a.m., he had been to answer for the call of nature. Thereafter, at 6.15 a.m., when he was returning to his house, the accused Ramu was found coming from the opposite direction with a bill hook (arruval) and blood was also found dripping from the bill hook. He would depose further that P.W.1 had seen him and shouted that Ramu had cut his uncle Chinniah and asked him to rush up to the place of occurrence.

23.

Then in the cross examination, P.W.1 says that the house of the deceased Chinniah is located at a distance of 50 feet away from the place of occurrence. The place of occurrence is the road which runs from south to north. It is also revealed from his evidence that houses were there on either side of the road, and that, ten persons were standing near the place of occurrence but none of them had come nearer. The occurrence was taken place just 15 feet away from the place where he was standing and deposed further that soon after the receipt of the cut injuries over his head, the deceased did not fall down and, he slided down only after receiving injuries on his right hand. After the deceased had slided down, the accused had lifted his right leg and cut it with arruval and severed his right leg at the level of knee.

24.

P.W.2 in his cross examination has deposed that though he did not witness while the accused was cutting Chinniah, he had seen when he was coming with arruval.

With regard to the involvement of the accused in the criminality, the testimonies of P.W.1 and P.W.2 have not been shaken as they stood to the test off cross examination.

25.

The learned Counsel for PW1 has also argued that though P.W.1 is closely related to the deceased Chinniah since he being the ocular witness, his evidence cannot be discorded. But the evidence of P.W.1 was brushed aside by the trial Court for some obvious reasons. He has also maintained that even though several houses were located on either side of the road in which the occurrence was taken place i.e., near the house of one Meenakshi that no witness has been examined and non production of independent witness will not vitiate the case of prosecution. It is also known fact that no individual can come forward to involve himself in a criminal case to be a witness on account of fear of police. He has also submitted that the evidence given by P.W.1 is unassailable and unambiguitive and depict the reality of the occurrence. When such being the case multiplying the examination of the witness does not require and that the quality of the witness alone is essential to establish the case and not the quantity.

26.

In order to substantiate his arguments, he has relied upon the decision in Pyara and Others Vs. State of Rajasthan, . In this case, it is observed that ""When in a murder case only an interested witness had seen the whole incident, then non production of an independent witness will not vitiate whole prosecution.

27.

Coming to the instant case on hand, the presence of P.W.1 at the place of occurrence is found natural and that his presence could not be doubted as his testimony flows without any embellishment or exaggeration. As observed in the earlier decision, only because of his close relation to the deceased, his evidence cannot be brushed aside. Even in Chunni Lal Vs. State of U.P., , two eye-witnesses were sons of the deceased.

They were present at the place at the time of occurrence in usual and natural manner. They have given a vivid account of incident and manner in which it had occurred. Under this circumstance, a Division Bench of the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India has held that ""Their evidence could not be shaken by defence in their cross examination and there is no reason to discord their evidence merely because they were closely related to the deceased.

28.

Admittedly, P.W.1 is the only eye-witness to speak about the occurrence as well as the overt act of the accused. The trial Court has not placed trust upon the evidence of P.W.1. It appears from the judgment delivered by the trial Court that since P.W.1 was having animosity against the accused, his evidence cannot be based to maintain conviction upon the accused. In this connection, this Court consider that it is the high time to refer the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in the State of Uttar Pradesh v. Satish Chandra reported in 1985 SCC 508. In this case, It is answered that there is no legal necessity that all sole witness are to be corroborated first, corroboration may be required when the evidence of sole eye witness is not found fully reliable.

29.

In Ramesh Krishna Madhusudan Nayar Vs. The State of Maharashtra, , a Division Bench of the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India comprising their Lordships Hon'ble Dr. Arijit Pasayat and Hon'ble Mr. Justice Aftab Alam has held that On the basis of solitary evidence, conviction can be maintained. Section 134 of Evidence Act clearly states that no particular number of witnesses is required to establish the case. Conviction can be based on the testimony of the single witness if he is wholly reliable.

Corroboration may be necessary when he is only partially reliable. If the evidence is unblemished and beyond all possible criticism and the Court is satisfied that the witness was speaking the truth then on his evidence alone conviction can be maintained.

30.

In the given case on hand, P.W.1 has given a vivid account about the presence of the accused, his overt act, his involvement and also about his subsequent conduct. It is pertinent to note here that as rightly observed in the above cited decisions, the testimony of P.W.1 doesn't require any corroboration. By way of adding additional strength, P.W.2 has also corroborated his evidence. In fact PW 2 has lent a supporting hand to the evidence of P.W.1. It is not the case of prosecution that P.W.2 had also witnessed the occurrence. The prosecution has fairly admitted that P.W.2 had not witnessed the occurrence directly. However, he had seen the accused while he was coming from the opposite direction with arruval from which blood was dripping. This piece of evidence would be sufficient to be fit in fair congruence with the evidence of P.W.1, then what else is required to prove the involvement of the accused in the cold blooded murder that too at the dawn of the day?

Consistency of ocular evidence with the medical evidence:

31.

P.W.7/Dr. Balasubramanian had conducted post-mortem examination on the dead body of the deceased Chinniah at 1.30 p.m. on the date of occurrence i.e., 19.05.2007.

During the course of his examination, four external injuries were found on the person of the deceased:

1) Right knee joint completely severed exposing both ends of the joint with hanging of the leg below with skin support only. Reddish brown in colour.

2) A curved cut injury about 20 cm x brain depth x 6 cm in wide on the left parietal bone. The injury extends from joint above left ear to the forehead wider on the ear side and sharpen forward the forehead. Reddish brown in colour.

3) A cut injury about 10 cm x bone depth x 4 cm in size exposing two ends of the joint of right elbow joint. Reddish brown in colour.

4) A cut injury about 10cm x bone depth x 6cm on the right forearm. Reddish brown in colour.

32.

When P.W.7 had examined the inner parts of the body, he happened to open the skull. At that time, the skull bone was found cut through and corresponding to the second external injury. Brain was also found cut through out. The doctor had opined in Ex.P9/ post-mortem certificate, that the death would have occurred due to hemorrhage and shock due to the multiple injuries sustained by the deceased Chinniah from 6.30hrs. to 7.30hrs. prior to post-mortem examination. It is relevant to note here that the time of occurrence was 6.15 a.m., and the time of death opined by P.W.7/Dr. Balasubramanian has been tallied with the time of occurrence i.e., 6.15 a.m. on the fateful day.

33.

When PW 7 was questioned by the learned Public Prosecutor, during the time of his chief examination, after showing the crime weapon i.e., MO4 billhook (arruval) he had answered that the injury No. 2 could have been inflicted by MO4. But he has also stated that he could not ascertain as to whether other injuries could have been inflicted by MO4, arruval. Even in his cross-examination also PW 7, has stated that excepting injury No. 2, the other injuries could have been inflicted by other weapons rather than the said MO4 arruval. While answering about the injury No. 2 he would say that injury No. 2 could have been inflicted by a curved sharp edged weapon. He has also stated that the injury No. 2 could have been inflicted from the front side of the deceased. Then he has also deposed that since, the second injury, which extends from the joint above left ear to the forehead wider on the ear side and sharpen forward the forehead, could have been inflicted when the deceased was cut from his front side. But these questions and answers will not in anyway falsify the case of the prosecution. The evidence of Doctor, is not a gospel truth.

In fact PW 7 has not witnessed the occurrence directly and only on the basis of the nature of injuries and it's site where those injuries were inflicted, he has given evidence. In so far as the evidence with regard to the nature of injuries is concerned, all his answers in the cross-examination would be only on mere gestures and assumptions. The Court has to compare the evidence of PW 1 and PW 7 with reference to the ocular witnesses and medical witnesses and then come to a conclusion.

34.

Normally the defence would first try to convince the Court and if the the Court is not convinced then would try to confuse the Court. The Court must be very careful in sifting the evidences which are placed before it and shall not get confused.

Arrest of the accused and recovery of crime weapon

35.

As evident from PW 11 investigating officer, the accused was arrested at 07.00p.m., on 20.05.2007 at Manakudi Bus Stop in the presence of Surakuddi Village Administrative Officer and one Mahendran. On the basis of his disclosure statement under Ex.P5 the crime weapon MO 4 was recovered at the instance of the accused which was hidden beneath a karuvelam tree near Thirukkalapatti tank.

This piece of evidence of PW 1 has been corroborated by PW 3.

36.

It is obvious to note here that the crime weapon was discovered by PW 11, only on the identification of the accused. It is not the case of the defence that the recovery of crime weapon was doubtful and that the weapon was purposefully prepared to connect the accused in the criminality.

It is also important to note here that PW 3 Village Administrative Officer of Surakuddi Village is a Government employee and that he is not having any animosity against the accused to depose against him. As already discussed, the evidence of PW 3 tagged with creditworthiness and nothing is there to disbelieve his evidence as it is smoothly merged with the evidence of PW 11.

37.

It is also not the case of the defence that the weapon was recovered from an open place and in fact it was discovered by PW 11 at the instance of the accused, beneath a karuvelam tree near Thirukkalapatti tank.

38.

As adumbrated supra that since no material is available to show that the recovered crime weapon (MO4)was planted at the place of recovery the disclosure statement of the accused under Ex.P5, is reliable and is admissible in evidence as rightly observed in Anuj alias Anu and Another

etc. Vs. State of H.P., .

39.

Under this circumstance, the trial Court has lost sight on the fact that the disclosure statement of the accused under Ex.P5 has been is duly corroborated by the discovery of crime weapon MO4 as well as by other material evidences viz., PW 3 and PW 11. Hence there may not be any impediment or obstacle in maintaining conviction on the accused. The evidence of PW 11 in his cross-examination saying that the crime weapon arruval was not buried in the mud, but it was hidden in the bushes beneath a karuvelam tree on the northern side of Thirukkalapatti tank, would probablise the case of the prosecution.

40.

Ex.P14 is the Biological report whereas PW 15 is the Serology report. From Ex.P14 it appears that five material objects were sent for chemical examination.

Further it reveals that blood was detected on each of the items No. 3 to 5 [(3) a torn pale blue T-Shirt (4) a torn eight cubit dhoti and (5) a rusty metal bill hook with a hollow handle plugged on a bamboo stick] and not on Item No. 1 i.e., Earth mixed with stones and vegetable matter.

41.

Ex.P15 Serology report reveals that the blood found on Item No. 3 T-Shirt, Item No. 4 Dhoti and Item No. 5 Billhock was detected as of Human origin and in so far as grouping test is concerned with regard to Item No. 3, it is stated in the remarks column as result of grouping test inconclusive, whereas in Item No. 4 Dhoti, the blood was grouped as "A" and in respect of Item No. 3 Billhook, it is stated that the result of grouping test inconclusive. But it does not mean that MO4 (Crime weapon Item No. 5) was not employed in the crime. The crime weapon was rightly identified by PW 1 and PW 3.

Creditworthiness of the testimonies of PW 1 and PW 2.

42.

The learned Counsel for the accused has adverted to, that it was not clearly proved that PW 1 Chinnathambi was residing in the village where the occurrence took place. He would submit further that after his marriage he was residing at his in-laws house and he had come to Kovilpatti Village only three months prior to his recording of statement by the investigating officer. Referring this position, the learned Counsel has submitted that keeping in view of the above circumstances it is to be presumed that PW 1 Chinnathambi was residing at his in-law's house as he had come to Kovilpatti only three months ago and that he could not have seen the occurrence as he was not residing there.

43.

Secondly, he would submit that as per the evidence of PW 1, he was going to his house after taking tea in a tea shop which is located 1 km., away from his residence and that the prosecution has not clarified as to why PW 1 could not have taken tea in the nearby tea shop. Thirdly, he has argued about the conduct of PW 1 when the occurrence was taken place. He would submit that when the deceased was assaulted by the accused, PW 1 did not make an attempt to prevent the accused from cutting the deceased. Even he did not make an attempt to catch the accused when he ran away from the scene of occurrence after taking the cycle.

He has also stated that the wearing apparels of PW 1 did not stain with the blood and these circumstances would go to show that PW 1 could not have been present at the place of occurrence, when the incident was taken place.

44.

With regard to the evidence of PW 2, the learned Counsel appearing for the accused would submit that, it is obvious that PW 2 did not see the occurrence directly. He has also referred the evidence of PW 2 saying that on the fateful day, he was returning to his house after attending the call of nature. Whileso, the accused came from the opposite direction with an arruval from which blood was dripping. In this connection he would state that PW 2 was having animosity against the accused as he was the reason for removal of his hut which was put up in the common land.

He has also submitted that since PW 2 did not vacate the hut from the common land he was ex-communicated by the villagers. He added further that as revealed from the testimonies of PW 2, that he had not entered into the village for the past 4 years prior to the occurrence and only on the date of occurrence he had been to the village.

He has also added that when PW 2 Mookaiya was excommunicated, his testimonies, that on the date of occurrence he came to the village could not be considered.

He has also submitted that even Ex.P1 complaint did not have any reference to show that PW 2 was also present at the time of occurrence. For the above assigned reasons, the learned Counsel for the accused would submit, that the testimonies of PW 1 and 2 could not be taken into account for maintaining conviction.

(a) Admittedly, PW 1 is the resident of M. Kovilpatti Village. A partition was effected in respect of the common properties among the brothers of PW 1. Excepting the house the other properties were partitioned. It is revealed from his cross-examination that 3 months prior to 09.09.2008 on which date PW 1 was examined, the dispute was brought to an end. This does not mean that PW 1 was not at all residing in the above said village at the time of occurrence. He has admitted that 14 years before his marriage was solemnized and after his marriage he was residing in his in-laws house for two years. A suggestion was put to him during the course of cross-examination, that since, there was a dispute over the common residential house and it was put under lock and key, he was not at all residing in Kovilpatti Village at the time of occurrence. This suggestion has been specifically denied by PW 1.

(b) PW 1 has admitted that he was contesting for the election of M. Kovilpatti Village President. The opposite candidate was one Chellamani.

Four persons including Ramu had approached him to withdraw from his candidature. Since he had not withdrawn from contesting the election it cannot be termed that he was having motive or animosity against the accused.

(c) PW 1 has admitted that the accused is one of the important persons in the village and that the accused was also running a grocery shop in that village. When PW 1 was in the witness box a suggestion was put to him saying that since PW 1 and the accused were having enmity when they were participating in a Jellikatu, he was deposing against the accused. This suggestion has also been stoutly denied by PW 1.

(d) PW 2 would depose in his cross-examination that he had put up a hut in the village common place. Since he did not remove the hut even after repeated requests made by the villagers, he was ex-communicated from the village and hence, he was taking food from his daughters house. But it does not mean that he was not at all residing in M. Kovilpatti village. His stray admission in his crossexamination that he had entered into the village only at the time of occurrence will not tend his whole evidence as unbelievable. The other circumstances must be looked into.

His evidence seems to be realistic because at 06.15 am., the occurrence was taken place. He says that after answering the call of nature, he was returning to house in the early morning. Since his evidence seemed to be of natural flow, some stray admission will not in any way shake the case of the prosecution.

Chances of involvement of others in the crime rather than

the accused - Whether proved ?

45.

It was suggested by the learned Counsel to the accused that one Pichaivetti who is the son of the deceased had been staying in abroad and doing Human Resource Business i.e., to select persons from India and send them to Qatar for securing jobs and in this connection, several persons had paid money to the deceased Chinniah so as to send them to abroad through his son-inlaw.

It was suggested that even after receiving the amount the deceased Chinniah did not secure jobs for the depositors. Hence, enmity was prevailing between the deceased Chinniah and the depositors and on account of this reason, any one of the aggrieved persons could have murdered of the deceased Chinniah.

46.

It was also suggested on behalf of the defence that prior to the lodging of complaint by PW 1, the police came to the place of occurrence and inspected the same and it would go to show that the first information given by PW 1 under Ex.P1 which was said to have been reduced into writing by PW 8 could not be the original complaint since, prior to that information the Station House Officer of S.V. Mangalam Police Station was informed that a gang consisting of 15 members had hacked the deceased to death and hence, the original complainant was burked by the prosecuting agency for the reasons best known to them.

47.

When PW 11 investigating officer was in the box, a question was specifically put to him by the learned Counsel for the accused that on 19.05.2007 at about 05.00 am., M. Kovilpatti Panchayat President, Village President, the accused and other important persons came to S.V.

Mangalam Police Station and informed about the murder of the deceased Chenniah. Another question was also put to him that on the receipt of the message from the above said persons he (PW 11) and other police officials had been to the place of occurrence and examined the witnesses and these facts have been completely put in the dark.

48.

One another question was also put to PW 1 during the course of his cross-examination that the said Pitchaivetti who is the son of the deceased Chinniah and P.W.1 had jointly sent reports to the District Superintendent of Police and also to the Special Cell of the Hon'ble Chief Minister and other higher officials stating that a gang consisting of 15 members had murdered the deceased Chinniah and that a communication was forwarded to P.W.11 under No. 2/23935/1202/07 Reference No. 308/STOT/2007 and No. 2/23435/1202/07 Reference No. 308/STOT/07 for enquiry and report. For this question, P.W.11 had vehemently answered in negative form. Having come forward to put suggestions as stated above, creating a doubt that excepting the accused somebody could have committed the murder of the deceased, the burden rests on the defence to prove them. But the defence has miserably failed to establish the above mentioned suggestions.

49.

The testimonies of PW 1, PW 2, PW 7, PW 8 and PW 11 and the documentary evidences viz., Exs.P1, P5, P6, P9, P10, P14 and P15 are very much sufficient to connect the accused to the criminality. But the Learned Sessions Judge, Sivagangai, has not approached the evidences both oral and documentary with proper perspective. When adequate evidences are available to nail the accused in the crime, the order of acquittal seems to be miscarriage of justice and perversed. Minor infirmities and discrepancies arisen from the testimonies of prosecution witnesses will not in any way falsify the case of the prosecution. As adumbrated supra, the testimonies of prosecution witnesses are probablizing the case of the prosecution. Even though PW 1 has given a vivid picture about the occurrence, which was supported and corroborated by PW 2 and also by the medical evidence given by P.W.7/Dr. Balasubramanian, to which the trial Court has gone to the extent of acquitting the accused which is liable to be set aside.

50.

In the above circumstance it may be appropriate to place reliance upon the decision in Ram Briksh Singh and Others Vs. Ambika Yadav and Another, . In this case it is observed that;

The order of acquittal, if it seems to be miscarriage of justice and perversed can be set aside and the case may be remitted back to the trial Court for retrial as the material evidence is overlooked by the trial Court.

51.

On coming to the instant case on hand, in the circumstances narrated above, it is but legitimate to conclude that the manner in which the trial Court dealt with the evidences on record and came to its conclusion by totally overlooking the material evidences has undoubtedly resulted in the miscarriage of justice and the interest of public justice requires this Court, to interfere so as to prevent gross miscarriage of justice. It goes without saying that on this ground alone the revision petition has to be succeeded.

52.

In the result the criminal revision is allowed.

The judgment dated 21.10.2008 in S.C. No. 14 of 2008 on the file of the learned Sessions Judge, Sivagangai is hereby set aside and the case in S.C. No. 14 of 2008 is remitted back to the trial court for retrial.

53.

It is made clear that the evidence already recorded at the initial trial shall not be erased or wiped out from the record of the case. The trial Judge is directed to decide the case on the basis of the evidence already on record and the additional evidences which would be recorded on retrial. The trial Judge shall not be influenced with the observations made on this judgment and he is directed to decide the case on the basis of the evidences available on record. The case in S.C. No. 14 of 2008 shall be disposed of, within two months from the date of receipt of a copy of this judgment.