AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
Heard finally with the consent of learned counsels for the respective parties.
In the present appeal, the appellant who was removed as a “Trustee” of Shri Ram Mandir Sansthan, Wathoda Ramanath, Tahsil Nandgaon Khandeshwar, Amravati and Shri Shankar Sansthan, Wathoda Ramanath, Tahsil Nandgaon Khandeshwar, Amravati, by the order dated 05.08.2026 passed by the learned Joint Charity Commissioner, Amravati Division, Amravati, in Inquiry Case No.08 of 2016 and Inquiry No.10 of 2016, has approached before this Court to challenge his removal as a “Trustee” of both the Trusts, by way of present appeal.
In the present case, the brief facts of the appeal can be summarized as under :-
There are two Public Trusts at Wathoda Ramanath, Tahsil Nandgaon Khandeshwar, Amravati namely Shri Ram Mandir Sansthan, having registration No.A-576/Amravati and Shri Shankar Sansthan having registration No.A-595/Amravati, (hereinafter referred to as “the Trusts”). After the registration of the Trusts, a scheme was framed by the learned Charity Commissioner, to run the affairs of both the trusts. The said scheme was finalized and made applicable from 04.08.1987 and 05.08.1987 respectively to both the trusts. As per the scheme framed by the learned Charity Commissioner, the minimum and maximum members of the Trust, the procedure for how to fill up the said post of Trustees, the names of founder members of the trustees, the tenure of the Executive Committee and its powers are prescribed.
As per the scheme, the number of the trustee shall be minimum four and maximum five. The founder trustees of the trust are recorded as (i) Shri Padmakar Namdeorao Thakre; (ii) Shri Ramkrushna Baliram Gaydhani; (iii) Shri Babarao Namdeorao Matode; (iv) Champatrao Barkatsa Banarse. The tenure of the Executive Committee is three years. If any, post of the Executive Member becomes vacant, the same can be filled in by a decision of the majority of the members of the Executive Committee. If the said vacancy is not filled in within a period of three months and no proposal was forwarded to the learned Assistant Charity Commissioner for filling up the said post during the period of three months, then the powers are given to the learned Assistant Charity Commissioner, to fill up the said post.
In the light of the aforesaid schemes, the Trusts were registered and their founder members were looking after the affairs of the Trusts. It is also pertinent to note that since the year 1987, no further elections of the Trusts have been held and the founder trustees are continued in the Trusts. During this period, the trustees namely Shri Padmakar Namdeorao Thakre, was expired on 30.01.2014 and Shri Ramkrushna Baliram Gaydhani, was expired on 30.03.2025. As such, at present, there are only two surviving founder trustees of the Trusts, namely, Shri Babarao Namdeorao Matode and Champatrao Barkatsa Banarse.
In this background, the applicants namely Shri Babarao Namdeorao Matode, who is the founder trustee along with Shri Ganesh Dnyandeorao Chaudhari and Shri Sanjay Bhimrao Matode (Patode), who are claiming to be the interested persons of the Trusts, filed the proceedings under Section 41D of the Maharashtra Public Trusts Act, 1950 (for short “the Act”).
After the filing of the proceedings before the learned Joint Charity Commissioner, the trustee namely Shri Ramkrushna Baliram Gaydhani, expired. Thus, challenge of removal of the appellant, who has filed the present appeal before this Court is required to be looked into.
The respondents in their applications filed against the appellant for removal as a trustee from both the Trusts, had made allegations of financial mismanagement, non-maintenance of accounts, non-filing of audit reports, non-holding of Board/General Body Meetings, non-holding of elections, unauthorized printing and use of receipt books, opening of unauthorized bank accounts with a Private Credit Society, misappropriation of the donation box and ceremonial (wedding/religious functions) income, misappropriation of lease income received to the Trusts from agricultural land, etc.
The proceedings were opposed by the present appellant by stating that only out of political rivalry and that the interested persons want to grab the Trusts and its property, has filed the complaint against him without having any iota of evidence on record, available with them. It is the submission of the appellant that no charge levelled against him can be proved in the matter and hence, the application deserves to be rejected.
The learned Joint Charity Commissioner, by considering the rival submissions of the parties have framed five charges against the present appellant and thereafter, conducted an inquiry into the matter. Out of the five charges, only one charge was proved against the present appellant, i.e. the appellant failed to conduct regular elections of the Trusts as contemplated under the scheme framed by the learned Charity Commissioner. Therefore, he was removed as a trustee of the Trusts. The learned Joint Charity Commissioner by his impugned order further directed the only surviving trustee i.e. respondent No.1 - Shri Babarao Namdeorao Matode, to conduct fresh elections by issuing a public notice in the vicinity of the Gram Panchayat Wathoda Ramnath and by completing the entire exercise, appoint the new trustees on or before 30.09.2026.
The appellant who approached before this Court to challenge the impugned judgment and order, has raised a grievance that the learned Joint Charity Commissioner, failed to appreciate the evidence available on record and the principles laid down by this Court in the catena of the judgments and further by exceeding his jurisdiction, issued the directions for conducting the elections in the matter. Hence, he sought the indulgence of this Court in the present case.
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondents states that it was proved beyond the doubt before the learned Joint Charity Commissioner, that the appellant was found to be continuously neglecting his duties by not conducting the elections from the year 1987 till date. It is stated that appellant was holding the post of President of Trust and being on higher pedestal was the responsible person to hold election. Therefore, considering the provisions of Section 41D of the Act, the learned Joint Charity Commissioner (JCC), rightly exercised his powers to remove the appellant as a trustee of the Trusts.
In respect of the directions issued for conducting the fresh elections, it is the submission of the respondents that out of the four founder trustees, two were expired and one is now removed by the order passed by the learned Joint Charity Commissioner. Hence, it has now become impossible to elect the candidates as per the scheme framed by the learned Charity Commissioner. Therefore, considering the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case, the learned Charity Commissioner has exercised his powers and thereby, directed that elections be conducted for the welfare of the Trusts. Hence, according to the respondents, the impugned judgment and order passed by the learned Joint Charity Commissioner, is just, fair and proper in the facts and circumstances of the present case.
In the light of the submissions of both the parties, it would first be necessary to consider the scope of Section 41D of the Act, whereby, the learned Joint Charity Commissioner, can remove the trustees for any of the faults, which are enumerated under Section 41D(1)(a) to 41D(1)(f), which reads as under :-
“41D. Suspension removal and dismissal of trustees.--
(1)The Charity Commissioner may, either on application of a trustee or any person interested in the trust, or on receipt of a report under section 41B or suo motu may suspend, remove or dismiss any trustee of a public trust, if he,—
(a)makes persistent default in the submission of accounts report or return;
(b)wilfully disobeys any lawful orders issued by the Charity Commissioner under the provisions of this Act or rules made thereunder by the State Government;
(c)continuously neglects his duty or commits any malfeasance or misfeasance, or breach of trust in respect of the trust;
(d)misappropriates or deals improperly with the properties of the trust of which he is a trustee; or
(e)accepts any position in relation to the trust which is inconsistent with his position as a trustee;
(f)if convicted of an offence involving moral turpitude.”
In this regard, from catena of the judgments, the principles deducible can be summarized as under :-
“In the case of removal of a trustee the Court should be guided by considerations of the welfare of the trust estate, and before a removal of the trustee is directed, a clear necessity for the intervention of the Court to save the trust property must be established. It is not every mismanagement or neglect of duty which will induce the Court to remove a trustee. There must be such gross negligence or misconduct as to evidence, a want either of capacity or of fidelity which is calculated to put the trust in jeopardy. Failure in the discharge of duty on account of mistake or misunderstanding is not a ground for removal unless such failure shows want of capacity to manage the trust. A trustee may be removed if he fraudulently misapplies the revenues of the trust property and grossly misbehaves himself in the execution of the trust.”
It is also a well settled legal position of law that the removal of a trustee is a drastic action. The charge of misfeasance or malfeasance is a serious one. The proceedings before the learned Charity Commissioner are of a quasi civil and quasi criminal nature. Though, the proceedings under Section 41D of the Act, are not criminal proceedings, the proof required to sustain the charges is a high standard. In other words, the standard of proof should be more than normally required in cases governed by the preponderance of probabilities and somewhat less than required in criminal trials or criminal cases. The imputation reflecting on integrity of the trustees have to be fortified by proof of high degree, which would be somewhere in between standard of proof required in civil proceedings like a suit and criminal proceedings, like a trial for offenses of criminal breach of trust, or that of cheating. Therefore, the lapse on the part of a trustee shall be proved by a substantial evidence and it must be demonstrated that the said trustee is guilty of misfeasance or malfeasance. Then in that event, the drastic action under Section 41D of the Act, may be warranted.
In the light of this proposition of law laid down by the catena of the judgments of this Court, I have perused the impugned judgment as well as the relevant record which is produced before this Court for deciding the present appeal. In the present matter, as only on the ground of non-conduct of regular elections, as per the scheme framed by the learned Charity Commissioner in the year 1987, of both the trusts were not followed, the appellant is removed as a trustee of both the Trusts. Therefore, to that extent only, the issue required to be decided, as to whether the learned Joint Charity Commissioner, has rightly exercised his jurisdiction in the light of law laid down by this Court and by considering the provisions of Section 41D of the Act.
In the present matter, as already stated, as per the scheme framed by the learned Charity Commissioner, the elections of the Executive Committee are required to be held after every three years. The election of the Executive Committee shall be in the general meeting of the Trusts. If any vacancy arises, then the same is required to be filled by a decision of the majority of the members present in the general meeting. If within a period of three months, such vacancy is not filled in, then the powers are made available to the learned Assistant Charity Commissioner, to fill in the said vacant post. This provision is not disputed by any of the parties, who appeared in the present matter. It is a general principle of law that if the elections are not taken place within the prescribed time period, the other members of the Trusts can very well raise a grievance or can make a requisition to the trustees that such election shall be held. But, here in present case, in addition to same if such elections are not held, then the learned Assistant Charity Commissioner, is empowered to fill up the vacant posts. Therefore, to establish that the appellant is only the person responsible for not holding the elections, it was necessary for the respondents to establish on record the necessary evidence to demonstrate that the attempts were made by them to hold the elections of the Trusts within the time prescribed. But, all their efforts were failed and therefore, as a last resort, they were required to file the proceedings against the appellant under Section 41D of the Act.
Upon perusal of the record, it nowhere demonstrates that any such evidence was placed on record from the perusal of which any conclusion can be drawn that the present appellant was the sole person responsible for not conducting the elections of the Trusts.
It is the submission of the respondents that not holding the regular elections by the appellant amounts to continuously neglect of his duties and therefore, the removal is justified in the present matter. The word “continuous neglect” is required to be considered in the matter. The continuously neglect means, a person brought to the notice of the trustee, certain facts in a specific manner and the same was intentionally neglected by the trustee and thereby, he failed to discharge his duties. However, in the present matter, as stated above there is nothing on record to demonstrate that any such attempts were made by the respondents to brought to the notice of the appellant and the same was neglected by him. Therefore, in my considered opinion, in absence of any such attempt or any record available before this Court, merely, not holding the elections cannot be termed as “continuously neglect” of the duty.
It is further pertinent to note that clause 6(b) of the scheme framed by the learned Charity Commissioner, is very much clear in the present matter. In such circumstances, the learned Joint Charity Commissioner, ought to have verify, if the posts were not filled in, then why the learned Assistant Commissioner, did not take any steps in the matter. So also, ought to have verified whether any communication in that regard was available with the learned Assistant Charity Commissioner, or not. But, no such efforts are seen to be made by the learned Joint Charity Commissioner, while reaching to the conclusion that the appellant is solely responsible for not conducting the elections.
In the light of above observations, it would be relevant to refer the judgment which is relied upon by the appellant in the case of Mallikarjuanappa S/o. Sidramappa Bidve Vs. Joint Charity Commissioner, Maharashtra State, Mumbai and Others reported in 2008(1) Mh.L.J. 148, wherein, the Coordinate Bench has observed in para No.18, which reads as under :-
“18.The legal position, which may be kept at back of the mind, is that removal of a trustee is a drastic action. The charge of malfeasance and/or misfeasance is serious one. The proceedings are of quasi civil and quasi criminal nature. Though the proceedings under section 41D is not criminal proceeding as such, yet, proof required to sustain the charges is of high standard. The standard of proof in such proceedings is somewhat more than normally required in cases governed by preponderance of probabilities and somewhat less than required in trials of criminal cases. The degree of proof required in criminal case is such that would prove criminal charge beyond a reasonable realm of doubt. The imputation reflecting on integrity of trustees have to be fortified by proof of high degree which would be somewhere in between standard of proof required in civil proceedings like a suit and criminal proceedings like a trial for offence of criminal breach of trust, or that of cheating. Thus, unless the lapse on part of the trustee is proved to be actuated by dishonesty or active connivance with other trustees, who are guilty of misfeasance or malfeasance, the drastic action under section 41-D of the BPT Act, may not be warranted.”
In view of aforesaid legal position, it is thus clear that the imputation reflecting on the integrity of the trustee have to be fortified by a proof of high degree, which will have to be higher than the standard proof, required in the civil proceedings. Unless and until the lapse on the part of the trustee is proved to be actuated by dishonesty, the drastic action under Section 41D of the Act, is not warranted.
In view of above, it would be further necessary to verify from the evidence, which were brought on record by the respondents justifies the action, which is taken by the learned Joint Charity Commissioner, against the present appellant in the present matter. Before the learned Joint Charity Commissioner, respondent No.1 - Shri Babarao Namdeorao Matode, has filed his evidence by way of affidavit. In the said affidavit, there is no specific version that because of not conducting the elections for this outgoing years of the Trusts, how the present appellant is sole responsible for the misconduct or how he has continuously neglected his duty to conduct the election. On the contrary, the entire deposition is in respect of not performing the work by taking into confidence with other trustees or not maintaining the records etc. Hence, in absence of any such evidence available on record, it was not justified on the part of the learned Joint Charity Commissioner, to reach to the conclusion that the appellant alone is responsible for not conducting the elections of the Trusts.
In these circumstances, it is clear that the standard of proof required to prove the charge is not established in the matter and therefore, merely on the statement that elections were not held, the same cannot be a reason to initiate drastic action under Section 41D of the Act.
The respondents have pointed out from the record that the present appellant has tendered his resignation on 24.10.2025 and that the same was accepted by the Committee Members on 25.10.2025. After acceptance the said resignation, the change report Nos.923 of 2025 and 921 of 2025 in respect of both the Trusts were filed before the learned Charity Commissioner and the same are under consideration before him. In this regard, the learned Joint Charity Commissioner, has recorded the specific findings that admittedly, out of four founder trustees, only two were reported to be dead. Therefore, there are only two existing trustees. If one of the trustee had tendered his resignation, it is difficult to accept how the same was accepted by the Committee Members when there was admittedly only one member have remained in the Trusts. Therefore, the resignation which was alleged to have been tendered by the appellant cannot be said to be valid.
The learned Joint Charity Commissioner has also specifically recorded that though it was stated that resignation was tendered on 24.10.2025 and the same was accepted by the Committee Members on 25.10.2025, but, the change reports in that regard which were filed before the learned Assistant Charity Commissioner, shows that the resignation was tendered by the appellant on 06.10.2025 and appointed the legal heirs of Shri Ramkrushna Baliram Gaydhani and Shri Champatrao Barkatsa Banarse as a members of the Trusts. Therefore, these all facts create doubt and as such, same cannot be decided in the present proceedings. So also, by relying upon the judgment delivered by the Coordinate Bench in Writ Petition No.5724 of 2017 in the case of Namdeo S/o. Bhikaji Rajput and Another Vs. Joint Charity Commissioner, Amravati Region, Amravati and Another, decided on 15.10.2018 wherein, it was held that the said issue though involved in the matter, the Court was not precluded from deciding the issue under Section 41D of the Act.
In view of above, prima-facie, I am not satisfied with the submissions of the respondents that appellant has tendered the resignation and therefore, the said aspect needs consideration in the present matter.
In the present case, appellant has pointed out that in the year 2014, the deceased trustee namely Shri Ramkrushna Baliram Gaydhani, made an attempt to fill up the vacancy by filing a change report on 29.03.2014 to fill up the vacancy caused due to the death of Shri Padmakar Namdeorao Thakre, on 30.01.2014. It is also pointed out that the said change report was objected before the learned Charity Commissioner. However, due to the objections raised on change report, the deceased Shri Ramkrushna Baliram Gaydhani, did not prosecute the said proceedings and hence, the change report was rejected in respect of Shri Ram Mandir Sansthan, Wathoda Ramanath, Tahsil Nandgaon Khandeshwar, Amravati, as well as Shri Shankar Sansthan having registration number A-595/Amravati, by order dated 24.08.2015 passed by the learned Assistant Charity Commissioner. But, this aspect is not considered positively by the learned Joint Charity Commissioner in the matter.
The learned Joint Charity Commissioner, failed to appreciate the fact that as per clause 6(b) of the scheme, the appellant cannot solely hold responsible for not holding the elections. So also, evidence available on record, falls short for drawing the conclusion that the appellant is sole responsible for not conducting the elections. As such, after considering the overall factual as well as legal position, in my considered opinion, the action under Section 41D of the Act, being a drastic action, learned Joint Charity Commissioner in absence of concrete evidence and without considering the legal position passed the impugned judgment and wrongly removed the appellant as a Trustee of the Trusts. Considering the aforesaid position, interference of this Court is necessary in the facts and circumstances of the present case.
The appellant, also submitted that the learned Joint Charity Commissioner, has exceeded his jurisdiction by issuing direction in what manner, election of the Trust should be held. According to appellant, the learned Joint Charity Commissioner, cannot exercise the said powers while dealing with the matter under Section 41D of the Maharashtra Public Trusts Act, 1950.
In the light of submissions made before this Court, I have perused the Section 41D(4) of the Act, wherein, the legislation has made clear that if the learned Charity Commissioner has made an order of removing any trustee and such trustee is the sole trustee or where there remain a sole trustee and according to the instrument of trust, trust cannot function or administer the trust without the vacancy being filled, then in that case the learned Charity Commissioner to appoint a fit person to discharge the duties and perform the function of the trust, and such appointment can be made by the learned Charity Commissioner, until the trustees are duly appointed, according to the provisions of the instrument of the trust.
The aforesaid provision makes it clear that the learned Charity Commissioner, has to act in a manner prescribed and shall not exceed his powers by issuing directions as to how the election should be held, that too contrary to the scheme framed by the learned Charity Commissioner. It is clear from the impugned order that the learned Joint Charity Commissioner, by exceeding his jurisdiction, directed the manner in which the elections of the Trusts shall be conducted. Therefore, such directions are contrary to the Section 41D(4) of the Act. Therefore, directions are also necessary to be quashed and set-aside in the matter.
It is needless to mention that under the provisions of the Maharashtra Public Trusts Act, 1950, there are ample provisions to deal with the situation as arose in the present matter and accordingly, the parties are always at liberty to exercise that powers under the provisions of the Act. Accordingly, the following Order is passed:-
O R D E R
The First Appeal No.664 of 2026 is allowed.
The Judgment and order dated 05.08.2026 passed by the Joint Charity Commissioner, Amravati, in Inquiry Case No.8 of 2016 and Inquiry No.10 of 2016, is hereby quashed and set-aside.
The appellant is directed to be restored as a “Trustee” of the Trust namely Shri Ram Mandir Sansthan, Wathoda Ramanath, Tahsil Nandgaon Khandeshwar, Amravati as well as Shri Shankar Sansthan, Wathoda Ramanath, Tahsil Nandgaon Khandeshwar, Amravati.
The Assistant Charity Commissioner, shall take necessary steps to fill up the vacant posts of Trustees of both the Trusts, as per scheme framed by him to run the affairs of the Trusts.
In view of above, the first appeal stands disposed of. No order as to costs. Pending civil application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of, accordingly.
