Tribunals and CommissionsDivision Bench(2025) 03 NCLAT CK 1683

C. Natarajan vs CA Mahalingam Suresh Kumar

National Company Law Appellate Tribunal, CHENNAI Bench · Decided on 7 March 2025

RESULT
Dismissed
CASE NUMBER
Company Appeal (AT) (CH) (Ins) No. 138/2025 (IA Nos. 369, 370, 371, 372 & 373/2025)

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

8 paragraphs · 741 words

ORDER

The Appellant questions the impugned order dated 17.11.2023, as it has been passed in IA No. 348/CHE/2023, in IBA No.1045/(CHE)/2019 and IBA No.1169/(CHE)/2019. There were number of Interlocutory Applications, which were clubbed together and decided by the NCLT, Chennai. The said order was rendered on 17.11.2023, wherein the IA/348/CHE/2023, preferred by the Appellant stood rejected and as a consequence, this instant Appeal has been filed, challenging the said Impugned Order. This Appeal was filed on 13.02.2024. The Registry has reported that there is a delay of 58 days which has chanced in preferring the Appeal. It has been attempted to be argued to the contrary by the Learned Counsel for the Appellant, on the ground which he has raised in his pleading in the Condone Delay Application, that IA No. 348(CHE)/2023 was listed for arguments on 17.11.2023, that order was reserved on the same and was not pronounced, that the said order was uploaded and made available on the online portal on 05.01.2024, that thereafter he applied for certified copy on 17.01.2024 and obtained it on 25.01.2024 and filed the appeal on 13.02.2024 (which is 39 days from 05.01.2024) and that there is only a delay of 9 days which may be condoned.

This contention raised by the Learned Counsel for the Appellant, seeking condonation of 9 days of delay based on the claim that limitation period should commence from 05.01.2024 runs contrary to his own pleading raised in para-2(iv) of the Condone Delay Application, wherein he has submitted that the order was pronounced on 17.11.2023. Apart from that, the endorsement slip accompanying the Impugned Order bears the endorsement of all the counsels including that of the Appellant who appeared in the proceedings before the Leaned NCLT on 17.11.2023. It affirms that the Appellant was present during the pronouncement of the judgement.

Even from the perusal of the Impugned Order, it does not reflect anywhere that, the Learned Tribunal has ever reserved the Judgement, which has been attempted to be argued otherwise, by the Learned Counsel for the Appellant. On the contrary, the Learned Counsel for the Respondent has vehemently opposed the application for condone delay contending that, the argument of the Learned Counsel for the Appellant pertaining to the aspect of reserving the order and pronouncement of the judgement is absolutely contrary to the records, because the Impugned Order itself does not show that, the order was ever reserved and rather it reflects that it was pronounced on 17.11.2023. He further submits that, the order of 17.11.2023, was a composite order which had also disposed of various other applications, one of them being IA No. 1421/2022. The rejection of the said application IA No. 1421/2022 was subjected to challenge before this Appellate Tribunal in CA (AT) (CH) (Ins) No. 26/2024 in the matter of M/s. Sbeecables (India) Limited Vs. CA Mahalingam Suresh Kumar and this Tribunal vide its 3-member bench, vide its judgement dated 04.04.2024 had dismissed the same on the ground of limitation.

Hence, there cannot be a different view, which we can now take from the view which was already expressed by this Appellate Tribunal, while rendering the judgement on 04.04.2024 in CA(AT)(CH)(Ins) No. 26/2024. Apart from it, it has been pointed out by the Learned Counsel for the Respondent that the instant case happens to be a case of lesser merit, than what has been decided by this Appellate Tribunal on 04.04.2024 for the reason being that, that in the Appeal CA(AT)(CH)(Ins) No. 26/2024, the application for procuring the certified copy of the order itself was filed within the prescribed period of limitation whereas in the instant case the application for providing the certified copy was filed only on 17.01.2024 which is, much beyond the period of limitation prescribed for preference of the Appeal.

Hence, there is no reason for this Appellate Tribunal to take a contradictory view, than what has already been settled by this Tribunal in the judgement of 04.04.2024, rendered in the matters of M/s. Sbeecables (India) Private Limited (Supra). Owing to the aforesaid reasons, coupled with the fact that the number of days of delay in preferring the Appeal is beyond the prescribed period under Section 61(2), the instant Appeal would stand dismissed, holding it to be barred by limitation.

Consequently, the IA No. 370/2025, seeking Condonation of Delay of 58 days in filing of this Appeal would stand dismissed.

All the pending Interlocutory Applications are directed to be laid to rest.