AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
Revision on hand is filed against an order passed by Family Court, Attingal on 21.01.2016 in M.C.No.526 of 2013. The revision petitioner approached this Court challenging the order on the ground that the evidence adduced by the parties was not appreciated by the Family Court in its proper perspective and thus caused exorbitant sums to be awarded as monthly maintenance allowance in favour of the respondent.
The facts of the case relevant for consideration of the revision on hand are stated in brief hereunder. For the sake of clarity, the parties to this revision will also be referred to hereinafter as the respondent and the petitioner in accordance with their status in the M.C.
The minor girl namely, Neha V.S. is the daughter of the respondent born in his wedlock on 13.09.1999. Respondent deserted the mother of the minor girl, who represented her in the petition seeking maintenance as next friend. Minor girl is residing with her mother, who is unemployed and having no means for her sustenance. The minor girl is depending on her mother's parents for her livelihood. The respondent was paying maintenance to the minor girl till December 2011 and from January 2012 onwards, he neglected her. The minor girl was a student of Swathy Thirunal English Medium School, Chirayinkeezhu. The respondent is a driver by profession, employed abroad and is getting Rs.60,000/- as monthly income. The monthly maintenance allowance ordered originally in favour of the minor girl was enhanced by the impugned order passed under Section 127(1) Cr.P.C.
The respondent filed objection in the M.C. and contended as follows:
The mother of the minor girl as next friend and also as wife of the respondent had filed M.C.No.148 of 2011 before Judicial First Class Magistrate Court-I, Attingal and a full and final settlement of the claims was reached. An agreement was executed and based on the terms therein Rs.1,00,000/- was given to the wife and Rs.1,00,000/- was deposited in favour of the minor girl. Receipt of the Fixed Deposit made in favour of the minor was received by her mother. The mother of the minor girl was employed and earning Rs.9,000/- as monthly income. Respondent was employed as a driver at Gulf, but at present is unemployed and is having no income to meet the payment of the monthly maintenance allowance stands ordered in favour of the minor girl. She is studying in a Government School. Though interest is received from Fixed Deposit maintained in her favour, the same is insufficient even to meet her educational expenses. The respondent is prepared to pay Rs.500/- monthly in addition to Rs.952/- received from the Fixed Deposit as interest. Thus, M.C. is sought to be dismissed.
The mother of the minor girl as next friend tendered oral evidence as PW1 and marked Exts. A1 and A2. Ext.B1 alone was marked in evidence on the side of the respondent. On appreciation of evidence tendered as above the Family Court found that the minor girl is entitled to get monthly maintenance allowance from the respondent and accordingly allowed the M.C and directed the respondent to pay Rs.2,500/- monthly in addition to Rs.952/- obtained as interest, from the date of the petition. The mother as next friend was also authorised to receive the monthly maintenance allowance on behalf of the minor girl.
According to Sri.Dinesh M., the learned counsel for the respondent, the Family Court failed to appreciate the evidence on record in its proper perspective and in that context, interference with the impugned order is called for. The court below failed to take note of the fact that in M.C.No.148 of 2011 filed by the petitioner before JFCM Court-I, Attingal, a full and final settlement of all the claims have been arrived at by the parties. As per the settlement reached, Rs.1,00,000/- was given to the mother of the minor petitioner and Rs.1,00,000/- was made a Fixed Deposit in favour of the minor petitioner. According to the learned counsel, the minor girl is getting interest from the Fixed Deposit and it is sufficient to meet expenses of education in a Government School, where she is studying. According to him, since a full and final settlement was arrived at in M.C.No.148 of 2011, the present M.C. seeking for modification of the monthly maintenance allowance ought not to have been entertained and allowed by the Family Court. According to the learned counsel, the impugned order being vitiated for the reasons stated, is only to be reversed.
The contention of the learned counsel was that the mother of the minor girl being unemployed, is unable to meet the expenses of her education. According to him, Rs.952/- accrued as interest from the Fixed Deposit of Rs.1,00,000/- stands in the minor girl's favour is inadequate to meet even her legitimate requirements. In that context, M.C. was moved under Section 127 Cr.P.C. seeking for a hike in the monthly maintenance allowance.
In the backdrop of the rival contentions raised as above, the evidence on record is read and appreciated to see impropriety if any involved. The mother and next friend of the minor girl has adduced oral evidence as PW1 and documentary evidence as Exts.A1 and A2. On the side of the respondent copy of a receipt issued from the bank to establish that Rs.1,00,000/- is maintained by the bank as Fixed Deposit in the name of the minor petitioner is produced and marked as Ext.B1.
The minor girl is aged 15 years as on date of consideration of the M.C. seeking for modification and is studying in Plus One at Azhoor H.S.S. The averment of the petitioner in the M.C. was that the respondent was working as a driver at Gulf, and has a monthly income of Rs.60,000/-. According to her, an amount of Rs.10,000/- is required monthly for meeting the expenditures of the minor girl towards food, clothing, education and health. Ext.A2, is copy of the agreement executed among PW1 and respondent in M.C.No.148 of 2011 on the files of JFCM Court-I, Attingal and it is disclosed therefrom that Rs.1,00,000/- each was given to 1st and 2nd petitioners therein and Rs.1,00,000/- granted to the 2nd petitioner was kept in the bank as Fixed Deposit. The Fixed Deposit was made on condition that the interest accrued therefrom shall be withdrawn by the next friend and utilised for the benefit of the minor girl. During cross examination, PW1 had also conceded that Rs.1,00,000/- stands in Fixed Deposit in favour of the minor girl and Ext.B1 is its receipt. It is true that M.C.No.148 of 2011 was closed on the basis of Ext.A2. This Court is convinced on a rough assessment of interest on the basis of Ext.B1 that Rs.952/- alone will be accrued as interest from the Fixed Deposit made. The minor girl is now in plus one. The mother of the minor girl in whose custody she is, proved as unemployed and devoid of any income. The claim of the petitioner that the respondent was a driver abroad and was getting Rs.60,000/- as monthly income is not substantiated by any evidence other than her own interested version as PW1. The respondent though has stated in his counter statement that his job as a driver at Gulf was lost and therefore at the relevant time, he is unemployed and not earning, evidence was not adduced by him in that regard. He did not even adduce any evidence to establish the income earned by him, while working as a driver at Gulf. The respondent may be having the materials to establish the loss of his job as driver at Gulf, the time at which and the reason for which it was lost, must produce those. The burden is on him to establish. In the case on hand, the materials having not been produced by the respondent, the Family Court is perfectly justified in taking a view that he is financially sound and therefore is liable to pay reasonable sum as monthly maintenance allowance to the minor girl. The Apex Court has repeatedly held in a number of cases that an able bodied man cannot contend that he is not earning sufficiently and therefore, unable to maintain his wife and child who had been deserted and neglected by him.
It is true that a settlement has been arrived at in the petition filed originally, seeking for monthly maintenance allowance as M.C.No.148 of 2011. Receipt of Rs.1,00,000/- each in favour of the petitioners, following an amicable settlement in M.C.No.148 of 2011 is also not disputed by the petitioners. Vide order passed in M.C.No.148 of 2011 a direction was issued to the next friend of the minor to utilise Rs.952/- accrued as interest from the Fixed Deposit of Rs.1,00,000/- made in the minor girl's favour, for meeting her expenditures. Rs.952/- accrued as interest is found by the mother of the minor girl insufficient to meet even her essential expenditures. In the above circumstances, M.C. was filed under Section 127 Cr.P.C seeking for enhancement of monthly maintenance allowance. It is pertinent to note that with Rs.952/-accrued as interest on the Fixed Deposit, the expenditures of the minor girl studying in Plus One cannot be met with. Section 125(1) Cr.P.C. speaks about the entitlement of a wife, a child, or parents to receive just and reasonable sum as maintenance allowance monthly. Therefore the right to get reasonable monthly maintenance allowance conferred by the Code on a minor girl under Section 125 cannot be waived or relinquished by her mother in her capacity as her next friend. It is true that M.C.No.148 of 2011 was filed under the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act and settlement was arrived at during its pendency. Agreeing to receive Rs.1,00,000/- and undertaking to meet the expenditures of the minor child pursuing plus one education, with the interest accrued therefrom is nothing but, relinquishment of her entitlement to get the monthly maintenance allowance fixed by a court of law. Such relinquishment of a statutory right undoubtedly is opposed to public policy and is void under Section 23 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872.
In the case on hand, M.C. was not preferred by the petitioner under Section 125 (1) Cr.P.C. On the contrary, enhancement of the monthly maintenance allowance was sought. In the said context, the Family Court has found Rs.952/- as a sum insufficient to meet the entire monthly expenditures of the minor girl and thus ordered to pay Rs.2,500/- additionally towards monthly maintenance allowance. The M.C. was filed in the year 2013 and in the absence of any evidence to establish that the respondent has lost his job as a driver abroad, the Family Court cannot be said to be erred in issuing direction to the respondent to pay Rs.2,500/- as monthly maintenance allowance in addition to Rs.952/- accrued as interest from Rs.1,00,000/- stands in favour of the minor girl as Fixed Deposit.
The revision fails for the above reasons and is dismissed.
