AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
M. Jeyapaul, J.—The plaintiff aggrieved by the closure of evidence on his side by the trial Court has come forward with the present revision. There was an earlier round of revision preferred by the very same revision petitioner wherein a direction was issued to the trial Court to give one more opportunity to the revision petitioner to examine two official witnesses as prayed for by the revision petitioner. The official witnesses had brought the record of summons and the same contained the compromise deed dated 14.8.2007. The revision petitioner sought permission of the trial Court to examine two witnesses, namely Ramphal and Jagdish to the said compromise deed dated 14.8.2007.
The trial Court rejected the plea for examination of Ramphal and Jagdish on the ground that the names of those witnesses did not find a place in the list of witnesses and permission was granted by this Court in the earlier revision filed by the revision petitioner only to examine two official witnesses.
I heard the submissions made on either side.
I find that that trial Court has gone wrong in not permitting the revision petitioner to examine Ramphal and Jagdish who were witnesses to the compromise deed dated 14.8.2007, which formed part of the records summoned and produced by the official witnesses who were examined on 24.7.2012.
Even if some of the witnesses had not been cited as witnesses in the list of witnesses, the trial Court in its venture to dispense substantial justice to the litigant shall give opportunity to the party concerned to lead evidence to substantiate the case projected by him.
In the earlier revision filed by the revision petitioner, the only question which came up for consideration before this Court was whether permission should be granted to the revision petitioner to examine two official witnesses. The plea for examination of private witnesses Ramphal and Jagdish who were witnesses to the compromise deed which was produced by those two official witnesses on examination on 24.7.2012 had not come up for consideration before this Court in the earlier revision.
Denial of permission to examine the witnesses to the compromise would amount to denial of fair trial. The plaintiff who has come forward with a strong plea in the plaint is entitled to substantiate such plea by producing material witnesses. When the compromise was the core subject matter of the suit, denial to examine the witnesses to that compromise would virtually foreclose the effective steps taken by the plaintiff to prove his case. Further, it has been demonstrated that Ramphal and Jagdish were brought by the revision petitioner even on 3.2.2012, when the earlier prayer for examination of two official witnesses was declined by the trial Court.
In view of the above, the impugned order passed by the trial Court is set aside and the trial Court is directed to give opportunity to the plaintiff to examine Ramphal and Jagdish and also material witnesses, if any, on the side of the plaintiff. The revision is accordingly allowed.
