AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
Heard learned counsel for the petitioners.
The challenge is to the order dated 26.04.2024 of the State Commission, vide which the appeal filed by the petitioner herein was dismissed. Earlier, the District Forum allowed the complaint in part, ordering refund of Rs.49,000/- with 9% simple interest and compensation and litigation cost etc. The State Commission has duly addressed the various contentions raised by the petitioner herein, and we are in agreement with the observation / findings of the State Commission. Extracts of the relevant paragraphs of the State Commission are reproduced below:
"We have seen the invoice of the vehicle. The sale invoice as mentioned the price of the vehicle having chassis and engine number and one key set. In the sale invoice dated 25.4.2012, there is nothing about CNG kit. Thereafter, there is another sale invoice dated 17.5.2012 in which the price of CNG kit and CNG container has been mentioned for which an amount of Rs.48,015.00 has been paid. Therefore, it is clear that the vehicle was purchased on 25.4.2012 but CNG kit was got fitted in the vehicle later on 17.5.2012. If the vehicle would have been company fitted CNG kit, the sale invoice dated 25.4.2012 would have mentioned this fact and there was no need to issue another sale invoice after 22 days regarding CNG kit.
We have seen the judgment of the Id. District Consumer Forum. The Id. District Consumer Forum has held that the vehicle is of petrol and the opposite party has not authorized to fit CNG kit in the vehicle. There is no authority of the manufacturer in favour of the dealer regarding fitting of CNG kit in the in the vehicle. The Id. District Consumer Forum has passed the judgment for refund of Rs.49,000.00 to the complainant because this amount has been charged extra for which the opposite party has been held liable. Therefore, we do not find any illegality in this order and the appeal is liable to be dismissed."
Both the State Commission and the District Forum have given the concurrent findings against the petitioner herein. We have carefully gone through the orders of the State Commission, the District Commission, and other relevant records. Both the fora below have passed well-reasoned orders, and we do not find any reason to interfere with their findings and there is no illegality or material irregularity in the orders of the State Commission.
Accordingly, the order of the State Commission is upheld and RP/2359/2024 is dismissed.
Registry of NCDRC is directed to send a copy of this order (free certified copy) to both sides, in particular the Respondent(s), on the address given in the Memo of Parties, within a maximum period of one week from the date of this order.
All other pending IAs, if any, also stand disposed off.
