AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
PER RAMIT KOCHAR, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER:
This appeal in ITA No. 5462/Del/2024 for Assessment Year: 2017-18 has been filed by Revenue which has arisen from the Learned Commissioner of Income Tax(Appeals)’s-23, New Delhi (In Short “CIT(A)”) appellate order u/s 250 of the Income-tax Act, 1961(in Short “1961 Act”) dated 03.09.2024 in Appeal No. CIT(A), Delhi-23/10476/2016-17(DIN: ITBA/APL/M/250/2024-25/1068308482(1)), which appeal in turn has arisen from the assessment order dated 24.02.2024 passed by the learned Assessing Officer u/s 153C of the 1961 Act (DIN.: ITBA/AST/S/153C/2023-24/1061512886(1)).
The Revenue has raised following grounds of appeal in Memo of Appeal filed with the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Delhi Benches, New Delhi, which reads as under:
“1)The Ld. CIT(A) has erred on facts and in law in deleting the addition of Rs.1,11,35,948/- out of total addition of Rs. 1,11,85,948 made u/s 69A of the Act in the assessment order despite the fact that there was credible evidence to prove that the assessee had received brokerage of the said amount which was not recorded in the books of accounts.
2)Ld. CIT(A) has erred in holding that the contents of documents were not proved to be true by the Assessing Officer despite the fact that the the excel sheet (part of assessment order at para 5.1) contained comprehensive details including Client name, Booking date, Broker’s name, Unit, Floor, Area, Total value, BSP-1, BSP-2, Total BSP, Actual Value and total commission paid to Mr. Jagdish Kumar Dhingra. The payment to the assessee was corroborated by the statement of Sh. Sandip Sahni the director of M/s Solutrean Buildings Technologies Pvt. Ltd. in his statement recorded on oath u/s 131(1A) of the Act dated 23.05.2019.
3)Ld. CIT(A) has erred in holding that the AO has not furnished or brought on record any statement of any witness recorded on oath under the relevant provisions of the Act on the basis of which it can be assumed or alleged that the referred amount of Rs. 1,11,85,948/- found recorded on the impugned excel sheet is attributable to the appellant and has actually been received by the appellant per se. It is stated that the statement of Sh. Sandeep Sahni, Director of SBTL was brought on record and forms part of assessment order. The assessee during the assessment proceedings had asked for cross-examination of the director of SBTL, but on appointed date he did not appear and filed adjournment.
4)Ld. CIT(A) has erred in deleting the addition by holding that there is no mention of the brokerage amount actually paid or received and also there is no mention of cash. The Ld. CIT(A) ignored the fact that assessee acted as broker and the listed property transactions actually taken place. It would be illogical to deduce that the brokerage was not paid in absence of the use of terms ‘paid’ or ‘received’ or term ‘cash’.
5)The appellant craves leave for reserving the right to amend, modify, alter, add or forego any ground(s) of appeal at any time before or during the hearing of this appeal.”
The brief facts of the case are that the assessee filed his return of income on 07.03.2018 for the Assessment Year 2017-18 , declaring total income of Rs.9,57,290/-, which was processed by Revenue u/s 143(1) of the 1961 Act. The AO observed from the ITR filed by the assessee , that the assessee has received income from house property , profits and gains of business or profession and income from other sources, during the year under consideration. A search and seizure operations were conducted by Revenue u/s 132 of the 1961 Act in the case of Sh. Ravinder Singh Group on 18.09.2018. During the course of search and seizure proceedings , and consequential survey action on Ravinder Singh Group , incriminating documents were found and seized/impounded by Revenue. From the analysis of whatsapp chats, books of accounts, e-mails seized during the course of search and seizure action on Sh. Hirday Narayan Gupta, It was observed that out of total sales of RST Horizon Project (commercial complex) in Karkardooma , a few of the same has been written against the name of Sh. Jagdish Kumar Dhingra, the assessee. The satisfaction was recorded after going through the contents of the incriminating documents. Notice u/s 153C of the 1961 Act was issued by the AO , and claimed to have been duly served on the assessee on 31.03.2023. The assessee in response thereof submitted that the return of income filed by him originally be treated as return of income in response to notice u/s 153C of the 1961 Act. The AO issued statutory notices u/s 143(2) and 142(1) of the 1961 Act during the course of assessment proceedings. The AO observed that during the course of search and seizure operations conducted by the AO, an email dated 10.01.2018 was extracted from the impounded data, which was sent by Abhishek Jha<[email protected]> to ‘[email protected]’ containing an excel sheet as an attachment namely ‘BSP DETAIL OF SUMMIT master’. Further , the AO observed from the statement recorded during the course of post search proceedings, Sh. Sandip Sahni the Director of M/s Solutrean Buildings Technologies Pvt. Ltd. who is managing the building/marketing affaires of RST Horizon, in his statement recorded on oath u/s 131(1A) of the 1961 Act dated 23.05.2019 stated that Sh. Jagdish Kumar Dhingra is a broker in RST Horizon, and is entitled for a commission against such sales being facilitated by him.
Further, the AO observed that in the books of M/s Summit Promoter Pvt. Ltd. (SPPL) , commission expenses amounting to Rs.1,11,85,948/- has been booked against Sh. Jagdish Kumar Dhingra. The AO also verified the income tax return filed by the assessee , and observed that assessee had not offered for taxation the said commission income in the return of income filed by the assessee with the Revenue. The BSP details of SUMMIT master’ containing excel sheet as was found during the search is reproduced herein under:
| A | B | C |
|---|---|---|
| Broker | Total Sale | Commission |
| Total Sale SBTL | 4,69,81,603.00 | 4228344.27 |
| Total Sale Dhingra | 12,74,81,248.00 | 1,11,85,948.21 |
| Total Sale Direct | 2,98,71,055.00 | 0 |
| Total Sale | 20,43,33,906.00 | |
| Diff | -0.49 | |
| Total Cash Received SBTL behalf of Summit | 5,01,70,538.00 | Details Attached |
| Return | 2,52,74,290.00 | |
| Balance on SBTL | 2,48,41,958.00 | |
| Less Commission | 42,28,344.27 | |
| Net Payble balance after adjustment all on SBTL | 2,06,13,213.73 | |
| Dhingra Total @15K | 11,62,95,300.00 | |
| SBTL | 4,69,81,603.00 | |
| Total | 16,32,76,903.00 | |
| 9% | 1,46,94,921.27 | |
| On Total Sale (SBTL + Dhingra on Price) | 17,44,62,851.00 | |
| 9% | 1,57,01,656.59 | |
| Less Dhingra | 1,11,85,948.21 | |
| Balance | 45,15,708.38 |
'BSP DETAIL OF SUMMIT master'
The path of the above incriminating documents namely 'BSP DETAIL OF SUMMIT master.xlsx' is "SRS-2, A-32/HING Acc-HP LT/CARVVED/rar/-HING Acc-330703.rar/Manager KWS/manager @kwsmail.com.pst/Top of Outlook data fiel/Inbox/sbtl.eml".
| S.No. | Client Name | Booking Date | Arrival No. | Unit | Flo | Area | Total Value @1 | BSP1 | BSP2 | Total B | Actual Val. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Veena Gambhir | 01-06-2016 | Dhingra | 1 | 2nd | 152.13 | 22,81,950.00 | 10,288.00 | 6,573.00 | 16,861.00 | 25,65,063.93 |
| 2 | Satish Kr Jain | 02-07-2016 | Dhingra | 2 | 2nd | 152.13 | 22,81,950.00 | 9,923.00 | 7,952.00 | 17,675.00 | 27,19,323.75 |
| 3 | Vijay Kumar Mahajan | 25-04-2016 | Dhingra | 3 | 2nd | 147 | 22,05,000.00 | 15,218.64 | 3,401.36 | 18,620.00 | 27,37,140.00 |
| 4 | Anita Arora | 09-07-2017 | Dhingra | 4 | 2nd | 138.5 | 20,77,500.00 | 13,355.00 | 1,645.00 | 15,000.00 | 20,77,500.00 |
| 5 | Akonshri Sharma | 12-05-2016 | Dhingra | 5 | 2nd | 138.5 | 20,77,500.00 | 14,082.00 | 3,018.00 | 17,100.00 | 23,68,350.00 |
| 6 | Neeraj Sharma | 08-06-2016 | Dhingra | 6 | 2nd | 138.5 | 20,77,500.00 | 12,002.00 | 5,098.00 | 17,100.00 | 23,68,350.00 |
| 7 | Vibhuti Tiwari | 01-04-2016 | Dhingra | 7 | 2nd | 128 | 19,20,000.00 | 9,148.00 | 7,586.00 | 16,734.00 | 21,41,952.00 |
| 8 | Nisha Sood | 14-04-2016 | Dhingra | 8 | 2nd | 138.5 | 20,77,500.00 | 10,464.00 | 6,389.00 | 16,853.00 | 23,34,140.50 |
| 9 | Ajay Kr. Jain (CLP) | 06-03-2016 | Dhingra | 9 | 2nd | 138.5 | 20,77,500.00 | 13,194.95 | 1,805.05 | 15,000.00 | 20,77,500.00 |
| 10 | Priyanka Gulati | 24-04-2016 | Dhingra | 10 | 2nd | 138.5 | 20,77,500.00 | 13,537.36 | 4,512.64 | 18,050.00 | 24,99,925.00 |
| 11 | Hemant Kumar | 22-04-2016 | Dhingra | 11 | 2nd | 138.5 | 20,77,500.00 | 18,050.00 | - | 18,050.00 | 24,99,925.00 |
| 12 | Dweep Ahuja | 05-04-2016 | SBTL | 12 | 2nd | 138.5 | - | 10,964.00 | 5,776.00 | 16,740.00 | 23,18,490.00 |
| 13 | Shikhir Dhingra | 10-08-2016 | Dhingra | 13 | 2nd | 138.5 | 20,77,500.00 | 7,500.00 | 7,500.00 | 15,000.00 | 20,77,500.00 |
| 14 | Anno Malhotra | 27-07-2016 | SBTL | 14 | 2nd | 138.5 | - | 15,994.00 | - | 15,994.00 | 22,15,169.00 |
| 15 | Dweep Ahuja | 25-03-2016 | SBTL | 15 | 2nd | 138.5 | - | 14,880.00 | - | 14,880.00 | 20,60,880.00 |
| 16 | Hemant Kumar | 22-04-2016 | Dhingra | 16 | 2nd | 138.5 | 20,77,500.00 | 18,050.00 | - | 18,050.00 | 24,99,925.00 |
| 17 | Pankaj Gulati | 26-04-2016 | Dhingra | 17 | 2nd | 138.5 | 20,77,500.00 | 13,537.36 | 4,512.64 | 18,050.00 | 24,99,925.00 |
| 18 | Anju Jain (CLP) | 06-03-2016 | Dhingra | 18 | 2nd | 138.5 | 20,77,500.00 | 13,194.95 | 1,805.05 | 15,000.00 | 20,77,500.00 |
| 19 | Girish Kr. Arora | 14-04-2016 | Dhingra | 19 | 2nd | 138.5 | 20,77,500.00 | 10,464.00 | 6,389.00 | 16,853.00 | 23,34,140.50 |
| 20 | Vibhuti Tiwari | 05-04-2016 | Dhingra | 20 | 2nd | 128 | 19,20,000.00 | 9,148.00 | 7,586.00 | 16,734.00 | 21,41,952.00 |
| 21 | Available Shop | 21 | 2nd | ||||||||
| 22 | Sujata Kataria | 10-08-2016 | Dhingra | 22 | 2nd | 138.5 | 20,77,500.00 | 7,500.00 | 7,500.00 | 15,000.00 | 20,77,500.00 |
| 23 | Harish Kumar Arora | 29-07-2017 | Dhingra | 23 | 2nd | 138.5 | 20,77,500.00 | 13,355.00 | 1,645.00 | 15,000.00 | 20,77,500.00 |
| 24 | Sunita Manchanda | 30-05-2016 | Dhingra | 24 | 2nd | 147 | 22,05,000.00 | 11,224.00 | 6,463.00 | 17,687.00 | 25,99,989.00 |
| 25 | Prachi Jain | 04-07-2016 | Dhingra | 25 | 2nd | 152.13 | 22,81,950.00 | 9,149.00 | 7,171.00 | 16,320.00 | 24,82,761.00 |
| 26 | Vijay Kumar Gambhir | 21-05-2016 | Dhingra | 26 | 2nd | 152.13 | 22,81,950.00 | 16,861.00 | - | 16,861.00 | 25,65,063.93 |
| 27 | Urmila Devi | 11-09-2016 | Dhingra | 27 | 2nd | 218.5 | 32,77,500.00 | 13,089.24 | 3,916.76 | 17,000.00 | 37,14,500.00 |
| 28 | Renu Aggarwal | 05-08-2016 | Dhingra | 28 | 2nd | 218.5 | 32,77,500.00 | 9,703.00 | 6,957.00 | 16,660.00 | 36,40,210.00 |
| 29 | Rajesh Kr. Sharma | 04-07-2016 | Dhingra | 29 | 2nd | 218.5 | 32,77,500.00 | 14,170.00 | 1,830.00 | 16,000.00 | 34,96,000.00 |
| 30 | Naresh Kant Kapoor | 09-04-2016 | Dhingra | 30 | 2nd | 218.5 | 32,77,500.00 | 15,200.00 | - | 15,200.00 | 33,21,200.00 |
| 31 | Naresh Kant Kapoor | 06-04-2016 | Dhingra | 31 | 2nd | 218.5 | 32,77,500.00 | 15,200.00 | - | 15,200.00 | 33,21,200.00 |
| 32 | Sheeja Urmy | 12-07-2016 | Dhingra | 32 | 2nd | 181 | 27,15,000.00 | 8,549.50 | 7,444.50 | 15,994.00 | 28,94,914.00 |
| 33 | Urmila Sharma | 02-05-2016 | Dhingra | 33 | 2nd | 181 | 27,15,000.00 | 11,740.00 | 5,090.00 | 16,830.00 | 30,46,230.00 |
| 34 | Available Shop | 34 | 2nd | ||||||||
| 35 | Alka Agarwal | 29-04-2016 | Dhingra | 35 | 2nd | 203.4 | 45,51,000.00 | 13,004.00 | 2,996.00 | 16,000.00 | 48,54,400.00 |
| 36 | Available Shop | 36 | 2nd | ||||||||
| 37 | Available Shop | 37 | 2nd | ||||||||
| 38 | Available Shop | 38 | 2nd |
As per AO, the path of the above incriminating documents is “SRS-2”, A-32/HING ACC-HP LT/CARVVED/rar/-HING Acc-HPLT/CARVVED/rar/-HING ACC-330703.rar/Manager KWS/manager@ kwsmail.com.pst/Top of Outlook data file/inbox/sbtl.eml”.
The relevant portion of the statement of Sh. Sandip Sahni the Director of M/s Solutrean Buildings Technologies Pvt. Ltd. as recorded on oath u/s 131(1A) of the 1961 Act , dated 23.05.2019 pertaining to the assessee is reproduced below:-
Thus, the AO has concluded that the assessee has worked as a marketing agent through which the properties/shops/space in the RST Horizon Project (commercial complex) in Karkardooma were sold. The AO observed that as per Excel Sheet , the assessee has sold property to the tune of Rs.12,74,81,248/- and the total commission earned by the assessee were to the tune of Rs.1,11,85,948/. The AO observed that details regarding sale and calculation of commission have also been mentioned in the same excel sheet as is evident from the above mentioned images.
There was another image namely ‘IMG-20180904-WA0001.jpg found and seized/impounded during the search action at Sh. Hirday Narayan Gupta u/s 132 of the 1961 Act dated 18.09.2018, which is reproduced hereunder:
The path of the above image is “RRS-7 A-4/D1/Project Infra/HN GUPA Samsung Phone/2019-01-03.19-59-41/Logical/files/Image/IMG-20180904-WA0001.jpg”
The AO observed from the above image that the brokerage charges as mentioned are @ 9% of the sale value. The assessee has received commission (brokerage) of Rs.10 lacs on 01.09.2016. The name of the assessee was also found discussed in the excel sheet (refer para 2.2 above of this order). The AO also observed that the broker Sh. Dhingra represents the person named as Jagdish Kumar Dhingra (the assessee). The total value of commission of Dhingra, the assessee is Rs.1,11,85,948/- as per the Excel Sheet. The assessee was asked by the AO vide notice u/s 142(1) dated 09.11.2023 and 13.12.2023 to submit the details of the commission received by the assessee in cash. The assessee in response thereof submitted that the assessee has not received any commission from sale of inventory in the RST Horizon Project. The AO rejected the contentions of the assessee as the assessee has not produced any documentary evidences to substantiate its claim and merely denied having received commission. The AO observed that the documents seized/impounded clearly establishes that they are related to the assessee and it was established that the assessee has earned commission income of Rs. 1,11,85,948/- in cash. The AO also referred to additional incriminating documents seized/impounded during the search and seizure operations , referred in para 5.8 and 5.9 of assessment order . The AO also observed that records have been mentioned in the Tally ERP and the same were ledger account of Sbtl(Solutrean Buildings Technologies Private Limited) in the books of Kkd. Here Sbtl refers to the company SBTL, and Kkd refers to the RST Horizon project by SPPL( SPPL referred to M/s Summit Promotors Pvt. Ltd.) at Karkardooma. The extract of ‘kkd.pdf’ found and seized/impounded during the search action of Shri Hirday Narayana Gupta u/s 132 of the 1961 Act, dated 18.09.2018 , is reproduced hereunder:
SBI SBI Ledger Account
Date Particulars Vch Type Vch No. Debit Credit 9-3-2016 To Cash Payment 1 30,00,000.00 To Cash Payment 2 30,00,000.00 60,00,000.00 By Closing Balance 60,00,000.00 60,00,000.00 60,00,000.00 60,00,000.00 1-4-2016 To Opening Balance 60,00,000.00 5-4-2016 To Cash Payment 1 50,000.00 To Cash Payment 2 50,000.00 14-4-2016 To Cash Payment 3 50,000.00 To Cash Payment 4 50,000.00 22-4-2016 To Cash Payment 5 2,50,000.00 To Cash Payment 6 9,11,000.00 By Cash Receipt 1 11,000.00 23-4-2016 To Cash Payment 7 1,00,000.00 To Cash Payment 8 1,00,000.00 28-4-2016 To Cash Payment 9 6,43,000.00 To Cash Payment 10 25,89,120.00 By Cash Receipt 2 22,66,000.00 2-5-2016 To Cash Payment 11 2,75,000.00 To Cash Payment 12 8,86,000.00 By Cash Receipt 3 11,61,000.00 To Cash Payment 13 4,65,000.00 12-5-2016 To Cash Payment 14 7,36,000.00 14-5-2016 To Cash Payment 15 5,00,000.00 To Cash Payment 16 1,28,500.00 By Cash Receipt 4 1,28,500.00 23-5-2016 To Cash Payment 17 5,64,300.00 26-5-2016 To Cash Payment 18 8,86,000.00 By Cash Receipt 5 8,86,000.00 3-6-2016 To Cash Payment 19 8,00,000.00
11-6-2016 To Cash Payment 20 12,75,000.00 By Cash Receipt 6 12,75,000.00 To Cash Payment 21 9,09,000.00 By Cash Receipt 7 9,09,000.00 20-6-2016 To Cash Payment 22 2,32,000.00 By Cash Receipt 8 1,46,000.00 To Cash Payment 23 2,00,000.00 By Cash Receipt 9 2,00,000.00 5-7-2016 To Cash Payment 24 8,00,000.00 To Cash Payment 25 51,000.00 By Cash Receipt 10 51,000.00 6-7-2016 To Cash Payment 26 6,50,000.00 By Cash Receipt 11 5,67,000.00 7-7-2016 To Cash Payment 27 10,91,000.00 Carried Over 2,12,41,920.00 76,00,500.00 continued ...
Kkd Stat Ledge Account 1-Apr-2015 to 1-Apr-2016 Yth Type Vch No. Debit Date Particulars Page 2 Credit Brought Forward 2,12,41,920.00 76,00,500.00 7-7-2016 By Cash Receipt 12 10,91,000.00 9-7-2016 To Cash Payment 28 2,25,000.00 By Cash Receipt 13 2,25,000.00 To Cash Payment 29 1,00,000.00 By Cash Receipt 14 1,00,000.00 To Cash Payment 30 1,26,000.00 By Cash Receipt 15 1,26,000.00 12-7-2016 To Cash Payment 31 5,22,000.00 By Cash Receipt 16 5,22,000.00 To Cash Payment 32 4,00,000.00 By Cash Receipt 17 4,00,000.00 13-7-2016 To Cash Payment 33 98,100.00 By Cash Receipt 18 98,100.00 15-7-2016 To Cash Payment 34 1,00,000.00 By Cash Receipt 19 1,00,000.00 To Cash Payment 35 68,360.00 By Cash Receipt 20 68,360.00 15-7-2016 To Cash Payment 36 1,50,750.00 To Cash Payment 37 4,00,000.00 29-7-2016 To Cash Payment 38 70,00,000.00 By Cash Receipt 21 70,00,000.00 30-7-2016 To Cash Payment 39 19,00,000.00 By Cash Receipt 22 19,00,000.00 6-8-2016 To Cash Payment 40 12,09,700.00 10-8-2016 To Cash Payment 41 14,24,400.00 17-8-2016 To Cash Payment 42 15,00,000.00 By Cash Receipt 23 15,00,000.00 19-8-2016 To Cash Payment 43 6,00,000.00 By Cash Receipt 26 6,00,000.00 To Cash Payment 44 14,53,500.00 2-9-2016 To Cash Payment 45 16,12,788.00 22-9-2016 To Cash Payment 46 60,00,000.00 By Cash Receipt 27 40,00,000.00 7-10-2016 To Cash Payment 47 40,00,000.00 5,61,70,538.00 2,53,28,980.00 2,48,41,558.00 5,61,70,538.00 5,61,70,538.00 The path of the above incriminating document is "RRS-7\A-4 D1\Project Infra\HN Gupta\SamsungPhone\WhatsApp\357956082727555\sdcard\whatsApp\Media\WhatsApp\Documents\kkd.pdf"
5.11The extract of 'ssss.pdf' found and seized/impounded during the search action at Sh. Hirday Narayana Gupta u/s 132 of the Act dated 18.09.2018 is as under:
Kkul Sitti Ledger Account
Date Particulars Vch Type Vch No. Debit Page 1 Credit 29-9-2015 By Commission @ 9% Journal 1 1,18,12,750.00 9-3-2016 To Cash Payment 1 30,00,000.00 To Cash Payment 2 30,00,000.00 60,00,000.00 1,18,12,750.00 30,12,750.00 1,18,12,750.00 1,18,12,750.00 To Closing Balance 1-4-2016 By Opening Balance 30,12,750.00 5-4-2016 To Cash Payment 1 50,000.00 To Cash Payment 2 50,000.00 14-4-2016 To Cash Payment 3 50,000.00 To Cash Payment 4 50,000.00
22-4-2016 To Cash Payment 5 2,50,000.00 To Cash Payment 6 9,11,000.00 By Cash Receipt 1 11,000.00 23-4-2016 To Cash Payment 7 1,00,000.00 To Cash Payment 8 1,00,000.00 24-4-2016 By Brok Journal 1 61,500.00 By Brok Journal 2 3,23,120.00 28-4-2016 To Cash Payment 9 6,43,000.00 To Cash Payment 10 25,89,120.00 By Cash Receipt 2 22,68,000.00 By Brok Journal 3 74,400.00 2-5-2016 To Cash Payment 11 2,75,000.00 To Cash Payment 12 8,86,000.00 By Cash Receipt 3 11,61,000.00 To Cash Payment 13 4,85,000.00 12-5-2016 To Cash Payment 14 7,36,000.00 By Brok Journal 4 93,000.00 14-5-2016 To Cash Payment 15 5,00,000.00 To Cash Payment 16 1,28,500.00 By Cash Receipt 4 1,28,500.00 23-5-2016 To Cash Payment 17 5,64,300.00 By Brok Journal 5 44,640.00 26-5-2016 To Cash Payment 18 8,86,000.00 By Cash Receipt 5 8,86,000.00 3-6-2016 To Cash Payment 19 8,00,000.00 11-6-2016 To Cash Payment 20 12,75,000.00 By Cash Receipt 6 12,75,000.00 To Cash Payment 21 9,09,000.00 By Cash Receipt 7 9,09,000.00 12-6-2016 By Brok Journal 6 1,18,000.00 13-6-2016 By Cash Receipt 8 6,84,000.00 20-6-2016 To Cash Payment 22 2,32,000.00 By Cash Receipt 9 1,46,000.00 1,24,49,920.00 1,39,91,910.00 Carried Over continued...
Kkd Skill Ledger Account : 1-Apr-2015 to 7-Oct-2016
Date Particulars Vch Type Vch No. Debit Credit Brought Forward 1,24,49,920.00 1,39,91,910.00 20-6-2016 To Cash Payment 23 2,00,000.00 By Cash Receipt 10 2,00,000.00 By Brok Journal 7 80,000.00 By Mkt 9%+Exp Journal 8 7,32,000.00 5-7-2016 To Cash Payment 24 8,00,000.00 To Cash Payment 25 51,000.00 By Cash Receipt 11 51,000.00 6-7-2016 To Cash Payment 26 6,50,000.00 By Cash Receipt 12 5,67,000.00 By Brok Journal 9 83,000.00 7-7-2016 To Cash Payment 27 10,91,000.00 By Cash Receipt 13 10,91,000.00 9-7-2016 To Cash Payment 28 2,25,000.00 By Cash Receipt 14 2,25,000.00 To Cash Payment 29 1,00,000.00 By Cash Receipt 15 1,00,000.00 To Cash Payment 30 1,26,000.00 By Cash Receipt 16 1,26,000.00 12-7-2016 To Cash Payment 31 5,22,000.00 By Cash Receipt 17 5,22,000.00 To Cash Payment 32 4,00,000.00 By Cash Receipt 18 4,00,000.00 13-7-2016 To Cash Payment 33 98,100.00 By Cash Receipt 19 98,100.00 15-7-2016 To Cash Payment 34 1,00,000.00 By Cash Receipt 20 1,00,000.00 To Cash Payment 35 66,380.00 By Cash Receipt 21 66,380.00 19-7-2016 To Cash Payment 36 1,90,750.00 To Cash Payment 37 4,00,000.00 By Brok Journal 10 86,200.00 29-7-2016 To Cash Payment 38 70,00,000.00 By Cash Receipt 22 70,00,000.00 30-7-2016 To Cash Payment 39 19,00,000.00 By Cash Receipt 23 19,00,000.00 By Brok Journal 11 7,000.00
6-8-2016 To Cash Payment 40 12,09,700.00 10-8-2016 To Cash Payment 41 14,24,400.00 17-8-2016 To Cash Payment 42 15,00,000.00 By Cash Receipt 34 15,00,000.00 19-8-2016 To Cash Payment 43 6,00,000.00 By Cash Receipt 25 6,00,000.00 To Cash Payment 44 14,53,500.00 5-9-2016 By Dhingra (Broker) Journal 12 10,00,000.00 2-9-2016 To Cash Payment 45 16,12,700.00 22-9-2016 To Cash Payment 46 60,00,000.00 By Cash Receipt 26 40,00,000.00 7-10-2016 To Cash Payment 47 40,00,000.00 Carried Over 4,41,70,538.00 3,45,32,590.00 continued
Kkd Std Ledger Account 1-Apr-2015 to 7-Oct-2016
Date Particulars Vch Type Vch No Debit Credit Bought Forward 4,41,70,538.00 3,45,32,590.00 7-10-2016 By Cash Receipt 27 5,01,000.00 4,41,70,538.00 3,50,33,590.00 31,35,548.00 By Closing Balance 4,41,70,538.00 4,41,70,538.00 ssss.pdf
The path of the above incriminating documents namely 'ssss.pdf' is 'RRS-7A-4 D1\Project Infra\HN Gupta\Samsung Phone\WhatsApp\357956082727555\sdcard\whatsApp\Media\WhatsApp\Documents\ssss.pdf'
5.12The extract of 'IMG-20180904-WA0001.jpg' found and seized/impound during the search action at Sh. Hirday Narayana Gupta u/s 132 of the Act dated 18.09.2018 has been discussed in Paras 5.3 through 5.4.
The AO observed on perusal of excel sheet (para 2.2 of this order) bearing title ‘BSP details of SUMMIT master.xlsx’ that the amount of Rs. 5,01,70,538/-with the title ‘Total Cash received SBTL behalf of SUMMIT’ exactly matches with the kkd.pdf as ledger account of Sbtl in the books of kkd placed at para 5.10 above. Thus, the AO observed that it proves that the incriminating material titled as ‘BSP DETAIL OF SUMMIT master.xlsx’ and ‘kkd.pdf’ both are genuine and authentic . The AO observed that it is mentioned at ‘BSP DETAIL OF SUMMIT master.xlsx’ that the assessee has received an amount of Rs. 1,11,85,948/- by way of commission on total sale of Rs. 12,74,81,248/-. The AO further observed that the ‘ssss.pdf’ is interlinked with the extract of incrimination document namely ‘IMG-20180904-WA0001.JPG’ wherein amount of Rs. 1,18,12,750/- (sum of Rs.76,09,000/- , Rs.37,63,000/- and Rs.4,40,750/-) in the form of 9% commission, dated 20.09.2015 exactly match with amount of Rs.1,18,12,750/- dated 20.09.2015 mentioned at ‘ssss.pdf’. Further, the amount of Rs. 10,00,000/- mentioned against the name of Broker (dhingra)’ as on 01.09.2016 in the document ‘IMG-20180904-WA0001.jpg’ exactly matches with the entry in the document ssss.pdf vide entry dated 01.09.2016 in the name ‘Dhingra(Broker)’ amounting to Rs. 10,00,000/- . Thus, the AO concluded that incriminating documents namely ‘IMG-20180904-WA0001.jpg’ , ‘kkd.pdf’ , ‘ssss,pdf’ and ‘BSP DETAILS OF SUMMIT MASTER.xlsx’ are true and authentic. The AO further observed that the cash entries found in the ledger of Sbtl maintained in the books of kkd(kkd.pdf) match with ‘ssss.pdf’ found during search and seizure action as majority of cash entries have similar dates and amounts i.e. Cash entry of Rs. 50,000/- dated 05.04.2016 , Cash entry of Rs. 70,00,000/- dated 29.07.2016 etc. Thus. As per the AO these documents are authentic and genuine. Thus, the AO came to the conclusion that the assessee has received an amount of Rs. 1,11,85,948/- in the form of commission in cash.
The AO also rejected the contentions of the assessee challenging invocation of provisions of Section 153C , keeping in view the fact that several incriminating material were seized/impounded which had bearing on the income of the assessee. The AO also rejected contentions of the assessee wrt no DIN being mentioned on the satisfaction note, because as per AO recording of DIN is not required while recording satisfaction note, but, however as per AO in the instant case, DIN was duly mentioned in the communication while sending satisfaction note to the assessee. The AO also rejected contention of the assessee wrt challenge raised by the assessee that certificate u/s 65B under Information Technology Act, 2000 dated 16.05.2023 is in different name than the search person, while the AO observed that name of the assessee is duly mentioned on the certificate and the premises belong to the searched person Ravinder Singh Group. The AO also observed that the assessee has been provided with copy of all material , including the statement in this regard which is used against the assessee. The AO also observed that the name of the assessee is clearly mentioned in the statement recorded on oath u/s 131(1A) of the 1961 Act of Shri Sandip Sahni, Director of Soultrean Building Technologies Private Limited and the amount of Rs. 1,11,85,948/- is clearly mentioned against the name of the assessee in the incriminating document namely ‘BSP DETAIL OF SUMMIT.xlsx’. The AO also allowed to the assessee opportunity for cross examination of all related persons/parties . Summons u/s 131(1) of the 1961 Act were issued to Sh. Sandip Sahni , Director of M/s Solutrean Building Technologies Pvt. Ltd., Sh. Hirday Narayan Gupta and the assessee himself (Sh. Jagdish Kumar Dhingra) on 17.02.2024 . On the compliance date, no one appeared before the AO. The assessee filed for adjournment. Fresh Summons were issued by the AO u/s 131(1) of the 1961 Act to all the aforesaid persons, but again there was no compliance made by the aforesaid parties including assessee. Thus, the AO concluded that the assessee has no intention of availing of the opportunity for cross examination.
The AO concluded that the assessee has earned a commission of Rs. 1,11,85,948/- in cash from the sale of space in the RST Horizon Project at Karkardoom by SPPL, and the assessee has failed to offer any cogent explanations, the said amount of Rs. 1,11,85,948/- was added to the income of the assessee u/s 69A r.w.s. 115BBE of the 1961 Act by the AO being unexplained money for the year .
Aggrieved, the assessee filed first appeal before the Ld. CIT(A), who deleted the additions as were made by the AO, by holding as under:
“19.In respect of issue raised in ground no.6 and 7, it is found that the Assessing Officer made addition on the basis of the document containing the details of amount payable to the appellant. The document contained the details of some money due to the appellant. Apparently, the amount due to the appellant was not disclosed in the accounts of the appellant. Therefore, the Assessing Officer was justified in invoking the provisions of section 69A of the Act.
20.The ground raised by the appellant as well as written submission furnished by the appellant alongwith the objections raised by AO and its rebuttal submitted by the appellant have been carefully perused. The document based on which the Assessing Officer has made addition is already reproduced above. The contents of the document has been deciphered by the Assessing Officer to mean that the appellant has received the amount of Rs.11185948/-and that the same was not disclosed in the accounts of the appellant.
21.The Assessing Officer has proceeded to make addition on the basis of the impugned document. However, the content of the document was never proved to be true and correct by the Assessing Officer. The AO has failed to bring anything on record which can corroborate the amount of Rs. 1,11,85,948/- as found recorded on the impugned excel sheet as actually been received or earned by the appellant.
22.The AO has not furnished or brought on record any statement of any witness recorded on oath under the relevant provisions of the IT Act 1961 on the basis of which it can be assumed or alleged that the referred amount of Rs. 1,11,85,948/-found recorded on the impugned excel sheet is attributable to the appellant and has actually been received by the appellant per se. It is also been observed that the AO has not furnished such a statement even after specific objection raised by the appellant and forwarded to him for his comments thereon.
23.The AO has also failed in applying the provisions contained u/s 292C of the Act while analysing the impugned excel sheet as well as the ledger accounts and documents relied upon as at no stage there is a mention of amount of Rs. 1,11,85,948/- been actually paid or been actually received to or by the appellant. There is also no mention of cash where the name of the appellant is appearing on the impugned ledger accounts relied upon by the AO. For the sake of argument, even if, it is believed that the appellant was to receive the amount, in that case also, the addition could not be made. Undisclosed Income cannot be taxed on due basis. The principle of real income applies to unaccounted and undisclosed income. Unaccounted income in order to be taxed as to be actually earned by the appellant. In the instant case, there is no evidence to establish that any unaccounted income was actually earned by the appellant. In the absence of any evidence to establish the actual receipt of money, the Assessing Officer could not have made addition.
24.As per the provisions of section 292C(1)(ii) of the Act, the contents of the document are to be treated as true and correct. On perusal of the impugned document, it is seen that there is entry of credit in the name of the appellant. That means that the appellant was supposed to receive Rs.10 Lakhs. Except for the entry dated 01.09.2016 (page 14 of the assessment order) there is no mention of the name of the appellant in the document. The appellant with the help of evidence establish that it has actually received Rs.9.90 Lakhs and the same has been treated as its income (Rs.5.50 Lakhs in the F.Y 2016-17 and Rs.4.40 Lakhs in the F.Y 2017-18).
25.On perusal of the document, it is seen that the same contains some calculation of commission due to various persons including the appellant. However, there is no evidence as to whether or not such commission have actually been paid to the appellant or not. It is reiterated that undisclosed income cannot be brought to tax on due basis/mercantile basis. For taxing undisclosed Income there has to be evidence that the money has actually been received.
26.It is unlikely that the appellant could have received the amount as mentioned in the document. The project against which the commission has been computed could not be completed by the builder and majority (about 90%) of the clients through Court cases took back their money. Under such a circumstances, it is highly improbable that the appellant would have actually received the money.
27.It is further seen that the amount of Rs.5.50 Lakhs was received through banking channels in the F.Y 2016-17. However, the appellant only disclosed an amount of Rs.5 lakhs as his income for the A.Y 2017-18. Therefore, the appellant even though received the amount of Rs.5.50 lakhs, the amount of Rs.50,000/- was not offered by him as his income. Therefore, the addition to the extent of Rs.50,000/- is confirmed. It is also seen that the appellant received the money in his bank account but did not offer Rs.50,000/- as his income, therefore, it is held that the income is liable to be taxed u/s 69A of the Act r.w.s. 115BBE of the Act.
28.It is further seen that in the F.Y 2017-18 (A.Y 2018-19), the appellant has received an amount of Rs.4.40 Lakhs. Out of the same an amount of Rs.4 lakhs was treated as receipts but the provisions of section 44AD was applied and the appellant only offered an amount of Rs.3.20 lakhs as income. Apparently, the appellant received commission to which the provisions of section 44AD do not apply. The provisions of section 44AD(6) (ii) of the Act states that the provisions of section 44AD do not apply to "a person earning income in the nature of commission or brokerage". The appellant was required to treat an amount of Rs.4.40 lakhs as his income. Thus, the amount of Rs.1.20 lakhs escaped assessment for the A.Y 2018-19. The Assessing Officer is directed to take remedial measure to bring to tax the amount escaped assessment. This direction is given u/s 150 (1).
29.In view of the above discussion, addition of Rs.11185948/- is liable to be restricted to Rs.50,000/- u/s 69A r.w.s 115BBE of the Act for the A.Y.2017-18. Accordingly, the addition u/s 69A amounting to Rs.1,11,35,948/-.
30.Thus, ground no.6,7,11 and 12 are partly allowed.
31.In view of the above discussion, appeal of the appellant is partly allowed.”
Heard both the rival parties. We have considered rival submissions and have perused the materials available on record. The facts are recorded in preceding para’s of this order and are not repeated. We have observed that the assessee filed original return of income declaring total income of Rs.9,57,290/-. There was search and seizure action carried on by Revenue u/s 132(1) of the 1961 Act as well consequential survey on Ravinder Singh Group, on 18.09.2018. Incriminating documents were found and seized/impounded during search and survey operations. After analysis of the aforesaid documents, satisfaction were recorded by Revenue and proceedings u/s 153C were initiated by Revenue against the assesee. The assessee has received income from house property , profits and gains from business or profession and income from other sources during the year under consideration. Statement of Shri Sandip Sahni, the Director of Solutrean Buildings Technologies Private Limited(hereinafter called ‘Sbtl’) was recorded u/s 131(1A) dated 23.05.2019, who was managing the building/marketing affairs of RST Horizon, and he stated in the statement that the assssee is broker in RST Horizon (Commercial complex) at Karkardooma and the assessee is entitled for a commission against such sales being facilitated by him. The copy of the statement is reproduced in preceding para’s of this order and is reproduced again:-
The said project RST Horizon was a commercial complex being developed at Karkardooma and was developed by Summit Promoter Private Limited (hereinafter called ‘SPPL’). The said Sbtl was also selling units in RST Horizon project as is emerging from the incriminating documents found and seized/impounded during the search and survey operations, although it is claimed by its Director Shri Sandip Sahni whose statement was recorded that they were receiving payments against the construction work from SPPL and they have not made any sales/booking in the said project. But, the facts as are emerging from the seized/impounded documents voluminously speaks of the fact that Sbtl also acted for marketing/selling of the aforesaid project RST Horizon at Karkardooma. The said Director further stated in his statement recorded by department that they introduced ‘Shri Jagdish Dhingra’ to SPPL in 2016 and thereafter, all the sales have been booked either by Shri Jagdish Dhingra or directly by SPPL. From the documents seized/impounded, it transpired that the total sales made by Shri Jagdish Dhingra was 12,74,81,248/-and he was entitled for commission of Rs. 1,11,85,948/- (Refer document BSP DETAIL OF SUMMIT master , which is an email sent by Shri Abhishek Jha accountant of SPPL and one employee/authorized signatory Shri Vinod Batura) . In this email , excel sheets detailed working is there which is unit wise sales made through Sbtl , direct by the promoters as well sales made through Shri Jagdish Dhingra, assessee, and the entitlement of commission of the brokers. The said document also shows sales made by Sbtl which is to the tune of Rs. 4,69,81,603/-. The sales are mostly made by Sbtl prior to Mar/April, 2016, and post March, 2016, the sales are made by ‘Dhingra’ which is decoded as assessee i.e Shri Jagdish Kumar Dhingra. There were also direct sales made by SPPL. The sales made by Sbtl was to the tune of Rs. 4,69,81,603/- , and total of sales made by Sbtl and Shri Dhingra amounts to Rs. 17,44,62,851/- (Rs. 12,74,81,248/- + Rs. 4,69,81,603/- ) , and the said amounts are mentioned in the said seized documents. The total commission stated to be payable is 9% which comes to Rs. 1,57,01,656.59 which is stated in the said seized document. Out of the above, Rs. 1,11,85,948.21 is payable to the assessee, while remaining Rs. 45,15,708,38 is payable to Sbtl. The amount matches. The unit wise details of the sales along with name of buyer, details of unit , floor , area , date of booking, Basic Sale Price etc. are duly mentioned in the excel sheet. It is further mentioned in the excel sheet that the total cash received by Sbtl on behalf of promoter Summit i.e. SPPL is Rs. 5,01,70,538/- which confirms that the cash was received by Sbtl albeit it is stated by Director of Sbtl in his statement that he has received payment for construction from Mr. Abhishek Jha accountant of SPPL and Shri Vinod Batura, authorized signatory/employee of SPPL who use to collect funds from buyers/clients.However, documents speaks voluminously that Sbtl was also engaged in marketing /selling of units in RST Horizon. It is further mentioned in the said document that there was return of Rs. 2,53,28,980/- and balance on SBTL was Rs. 2,48,41,558/- . Thereafter commission payable to Sbtl to the tune of Rs. 42,28,344.27 was adjusted against the amount recoverable from Sbtl ( which tantamount to effective payment being made to Sbtl for its commission entitlement) , and the net payable by Sbtl to the promoter SPPL was Rs. 2,06,13,213.73. Then ,there are workings made for commission payable to Sbtl and Dhingra. It is pertinent to mention that Dhingra viz. the assessee was introduced by Sbtl to SPPL in 2016 as stated by Shri Sandeep Sahni, Director of SPPL. Thus, it can be said that these documents are systematic records of transactions carried on for sale of RST Horizon Project and computation of sale price as well commission payable thereof. It is also pertinent to mention that in the excel sheet, the last details mentioned are of sale of unit number 23 , 2nd Floor, area 138.5 to Sh. Harish Kumar Arora, dated 29.07.2017(S.no. 23 in the excel sheet), thus, it can be presumed that this documents were prepared until 29.07.2017. We are concerned with previous year 2016-17 i.e assessment year 2017-18, and hence our period is covered . The said documents are reproduced hereunder for ready reference:
AAFPD1498Q- JAGDISH KUMAR DHINGRA A.Y. 2017-18 ITBA/AST/S/153C/2023-24/1061512886(1)
A B C Broker Total Sale Commission Total Sale SBTL 4,69,81,603.00 4228344.27 Total Sale Dhingra 12,74,81,248.00 1,11,85,948.21 Total Sale Direct 2,98,71,055.00 0 Total Sale 20,43,33,906.00 Diff -0.49 Total Cash Received SBTL behalf of Summit 5,01,70,538.00 Details Attached Return 2,52,74,290.00 Balance on SBTL 2,48,41,958.00 Less Commission 42,28,344.27 Net Payble balance after adjustment all on SBTL 2,06,13,213.73 Dhingra Total @15K 11,62,95,300.00 SBTL 4,69,81,603.00 Total 16,32,76,903.00 9% 1,46,94,921.27 On Total Sale (SBTL + Dhingra on Price) 17,44,62,851.00 9% 1,57,01,656.59 Less Dhingra 1,11,85,948.21 Balance 45,15,708.38 'BSP DETAIL OF SUMMIT master'
The path of the above incriminating documents namely 'BSP DETAIL OF SUMMIT master.xlsx' is "SRS-2, A-32/HING Acc-HP LT/CARVVED/rar/-HING Acc-330703.rar/Manager KWS/manager @kwsmail.com.pst/Top of Outlook data fiel/Inbox/sbtl.eml".
| S.No. | Client Name | Booking Date | Arrival No. | Unit | Flo | Area | Total Value @1 | BSP1 | BSP2 | Total B | Actual Value |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Veena Gambhir | 01-06-2016 | Dhingra | 1 | 2nd | 152.13 | 22,81,950.00 | 10,288.00 | 6,573.00 | 16,861.00 | 25,65,063.93 |
| 2 | Satish Kr Jain | 02-07-2016 | Dhingra | 2 | 2nd | 152.13 | 22,81,950.00 | 9,923.00 | 7,952.00 | 17,675.00 | 27,19,323.75 |
| 3 | Vijay Kumar Mahajan | 25-04-2016 | Dhingra | 3 | 2nd | 147 | 22,05,000.00 | 15,218.64 | 3,401.36 | 18,620.00 | 27,37,140.00 |
| 4 | Anita Arora | 09-07-2017 | Dhingra | 4 | 2nd | 138.5 | 20,77,500.00 | 13,355.00 | 1,645.00 | 15,000.00 | 20,77,500.00 |
| 5 | Akonshri Sharma | 12-05-2016 | Dhingra | 5 | 2nd | 138.5 | 20,77,500.00 | 14,082.00 | 3,018.00 | 17,100.00 | 23,68,350.00 |
| 6 | Neeraj Sharma | 08-06-2016 | Dhingra | 6 | 2nd | 138.5 | 20,77,500.00 | 12,002.00 | 5,098.00 | 17,100.00 | 23,68,350.00 |
| 7 | Vibhuti Tiwari | 01-04-2016 | Dhingra | 7 | 2nd | 128 | 19,20,000.00 | 9,148.00 | 7,586.00 | 16,734.00 | 21,41,952.00 |
| 8 | Nisha Sood | 14-04-2016 | Dhingra | 8 | 2nd | 138.5 | 20,77,500.00 | 10,464.00 | 6,389.00 | 16,853.00 | 23,34,140.50 |
| 9 | Ajay Kr. Jain (CLP) | 06-03-2016 | Dhingra | 9 | 2nd | 138.5 | 20,77,500.00 | 13,194.95 | 1,805.05 | 15,000.00 | 20,77,500.00 |
| 10 | Priyanka Gulati | 24-04-2016 | Dhingra | 10 | 2nd | 138.5 | 20,77,500.00 | 13,537.36 | 4,512.64 | 18,050.00 | 24,99,925.00 |
| 11 | Hemant Kumar | 22-04-2016 | Dhingra | 11 | 2nd | 138.5 | 20,77,500.00 | 18,050.00 | - | 18,050.00 | 24,99,925.00 |
| 12 | Dweep Ahuja | 05-04-2016 | SBTL | 12 | 2nd | 138.5 | - | 10,964.00 | 5,776.00 | 16,740.00 | 23,18,490.00 |
| 13 | Shikhir Dhingra | 10-08-2016 | Dhingra | 13 | 2nd | 138.5 | 20,77,500.00 | 7,500.00 | 7,500.00 | 15,000.00 | 20,77,500.00 |
| 14 | Annu Malhotra | 27-07-2016 | SBTL | 14 | 2nd | 138.5 | - | 15,994.00 | - | 15,994.00 | 22,15,169.00 |
| 15 | Dweep Ahuja | 25-03-2016 | SBTL | 15 | 2nd | 138.5 | - | 14,880.00 | - | 14,880.00 | 20,60,880.00 |
| 16 | Hemant Kumar | 22-04-2016 | Dhingra | 16 | 2nd | 138.5 | 20,77,500.00 | 18,050.00 | - | 18,050.00 | 24,99,925.00 |
| 17 | Pankaj Gulati | 26-04-2016 | Dhingra | 17 | 2nd | 138.5 | 20,77,500.00 | 13,537.36 | 4,512.64 | 18,050.00 | 24,99,925.00 |
| 18 | Anju Jain (CLP) | 06-03-2016 | Dhingra | 18 | 2nd | 138.5 | 20,77,500.00 | 13,194.95 | 1,805.05 | 15,000.00 | 20,77,500.00 |
| 19 | Girish Kr. Arora | 14-04-2016 | Dhingra | 19 | 2nd | 138.5 | 20,77,500.00 | 10,464.00 | 6,389.00 | 16,853.00 | 23,34,140.50 |
| 20 | Vibhuti Tiwari | 05-04-2016 | Dhingra | 20 | 2nd | 128 | 19,20,000.00 | 9,148.00 | 7,586.00 | 16,734.00 | 21,41,952.00 |
| 21 | Available Shop | 21 | 2nd | ||||||||
| 22 | Sujata Kataria | 10-08-2016 | Dhingra | 22 | 2nd | 138.5 | 20,77,500.00 | 7,500.00 | 7,500.00 | 15,000.00 | 20,77,500.00 |
| 23 | Harish Kumar Arora | 29-07-2017 | Dhingra | 23 | 2nd | 138.5 | 20,77,500.00 | 13,355.00 | 1,645.00 | 15,000.00 | 20,77,500.00 |
| 24 | Sunita Manchanda | 30-05-2016 | Dhingra | 24 | 2nd | 147 | 22,05,000.00 | 11,224.00 | 6,463.00 | 17,687.00 | 25,99,989.00 |
| 25 | Prachi Jain | 04-07-2016 | Dhingra | 25 | 2nd | 152.13 | 22,81,950.00 | 9,149.00 | 7,171.00 | 16,320.00 | 24,82,761.00 |
| 26 | Vijay Kumar Gambhir | 21-05-2016 | Dhingra | 26 | 2nd | 152.13 | 22,81,950.00 | 16,861.00 | - | 16,861.00 | 25,65,063.93 |
| 27 | Urmila Devi | 11-09-2016 | Dhingra | 27 | 2nd | 218.5 | 32,77,500.00 | 13,089.24 | 3,916.76 | 17,000.00 | 37,14,500.00 |
| 28 | Renu Aggarwal | 05-08-2016 | Dhingra | 28 | 2nd | 218.5 | 32,77,500.00 | 9,703.00 | 6,957.00 | 16,660.00 | 36,40,210.00 |
| 29 | Rajesh Kr. Sharma | 04-07-2016 | Dhingra | 29 | 2nd | 218.5 | 32,77,500.00 | 14,170.00 | 1,830.00 | 16,000.00 | 34,96,000.00 |
| 30 | Naresh Kant Kapoor | 09-04-2016 | Dhingra | 30 | 2nd | 218.5 | 32,77,500.00 | 15,200.00 | - | 15,200.00 | 33,21,200.00 |
| 31 | Naresh Kant Kapoor | 06-04-2016 | Dhingra | 31 | 2nd | 218.5 | 32,77,500.00 | 15,200.00 | - | 15,200.00 | 33,21,200.00 |
| 32 | Sheeja Urmy | 12-07-2016 | Dhingra | 32 | 2nd | 181 | 27,15,000.00 | 8,549.50 | 7,444.50 | 15,994.00 | 28,94,914.00 |
| 33 | Urmila Sharma | 02-05-2016 | Dhingra | 33 | 2nd | 181 | 27,15,000.00 | 11,740.00 | 5,090.00 | 16,830.00 | 30,46,230.00 |
| 34 | Available Shop | 34 | 2nd | ||||||||
| 35 | Alka Agarwal | 29-04-2016 | Dhingra | 35 | 2nd | 203.4 | 45,51,000.00 | 13,004.00 | 2,996.00 | 16,000.00 | 48,54,400.00 |
| 36 | Available Shop | 36 | 2nd | ||||||||
| 37 | Available Shop | 37 | 2nd | ||||||||
| 38 | Available Shop | 38 | 2nd |
It is an admitted position that the assessee acted as broker/agent in RST Horizon Project as the assessee itself has declared commission income of Rs. 10,00,000/- in his return of income filed with the Revenue. Even TDS was deducted under Chapter XVIIB by SPPL while making payment of brokerage. The dispute has arisen because in the incriminating documents so found and seized/impounded during search and survey operations , the total commission stated to be payable to the assessee is to the tune of Rs. 1,11,85,948.21, which got added to the income of the assessee by invoking Section 69A read with Section 115BBE of the 1961 Act. The assessee has simply denied the contents of the aforesaid documents. The assessee was afforded by the AO an opportunity twice to cross examination of Shri Sandip Sahni, Director of SBTL and Shri Hirday Narayan Gupta, but the assessee chose not to come forward to avail the said opportunity. On being asked by the Bench, the ld. Counsel for the assessee submitted that there was no retraction of the statement given by Shri Sandip Sahni, Director of Sbtl. It was also submitted by ld. Counsel for the assessee that the assessee is not relying on the orders passed by authorities including in appellate proceedings, in the case of the persons on whom the search and survey proceedings were conducted by Revenue. It is also observed that even in Remand Report proceedings, the assessee is in denial mode , but the fact of the matter is that the assessee has acted as broker for RST Horizon Project at Karkardooma being developed by SPPL, and it is an admitted position that the assessee has himself offered for taxation income of Rs. 10,00,000/- as commission earned from this project from SPPL on 01.09.2016 which also found recorded in the seized documents, and on which TDS was duly deducted under Chapter VIIB of the 1961 Act. Proceeding further, the Revenue has also found and seized/impounded document ‘IMG-20180904-WA0001.jpg’ during search action at Shri Hirday Narayan Gupta u/s 132 of the 1961 Act, dated 18.09.2018, reproduced hereunder:
The above document also reveal that an account is made with respect to construction and brokerage paid/payable, and the said brokerage is 9%. The assessee is merely denying all these documents and has stated that he has not received any commission.
Further, the revenue has also seized whats app conversation between Shri Hirday Narayan Gupta and Shri Abhishek Jha ( representative of Shri Ravinder Singh in ‘RST Horizon Project’ , wherein two pdf files ‘kkd.pdf’ and ‘ssss.pdf’ as well one image ‘IMG-20180904-WA0001.jpg’ were found and seized. Analysis of these document showed that these records were maintained in the tally ERP and were ledger account of Sbtl in the books of kkd ( refers to RST Horizon Project by SPPL at Karkardooma) , which is reproduced hereunder :
| 11-6-2016 | To Cash | Payment | 20 | 12,75,000.00 | |
| By Cash | Receipt | 6 | 12,75,000.00 | ||
| To Cash | Payment | 21 | 9,09,000.00 | ||
| By Cash | Receipt | 7 | 9,09,000.00 | ||
| 20-6-2016 | To Cash | Payment | 22 | 2,32,000.00 | |
| By Cash | Receipt | 8 | 1,46,000.00 | ||
| To Cash | Payment | 23 | 2,00,000.00 | ||
| By Cash | Receipt | 9 | 2,00,000.00 | ||
| 5-7-2016 | To Cash | Payment | 24 | 8,00,000.00 | |
| To Cash | Payment | 25 | 51,000.00 | ||
| By Cash | Receipt | 10 | 51,000.00 | ||
| 6-7-2016 | To Cash | Payment | 26 | 6,50,000.00 | |
| By Cash | Receipt | 11 | 5,67,000.00 | ||
| 7-7-2016 | To Cash | Payment | 27 | 10,91,000.00 | |
| Carried Over | 2,12,41,920.00 | 76,00,500.00 | |||
continued ...
| Kkd | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Stat | Ledge Account | 1-Apr-2015 to 1-Apr-2016 | Yth Type | Vch No. | Debit |
| Date | Particulars | Page 2 | |||
| Credit | |||||
| Brought Forward | 2,12,41,920.00 | 76,00,500.00 | |||
| 7-7-2016 | By Cash | Receipt | 12 | 10,91,000.00 | |
| 9-7-2016 | To Cash | Payment | 28 | 2,25,000.00 | |
| By Cash | Receipt | 13 | 2,25,000.00 | ||
| To Cash | Payment | 29 | 1,00,000.00 | ||
| By Cash | Receipt | 14 | 1,00,000.00 | ||
| To Cash | Payment | 30 | 1,26,000.00 | ||
| By Cash | Receipt | 15 | 1,26,000.00 | ||
| 12-7-2016 | To Cash | Payment | 31 | 5,22,000.00 | |
| By Cash | Receipt | 16 | 5,22,000.00 | ||
| To Cash | Payment | 32 | 4,00,000.00 | ||
| By Cash | Receipt | 17 | 4,00,000.00 | ||
| 13-7-2016 | To Cash | Payment | 33 | 98,100.00 | |
| By Cash | Receipt | 18 | 98,100.00 | ||
| 15-7-2016 | To Cash | Payment | 34 | 1,00,000.00 | |
| By Cash | Receipt | 19 | 1,00,000.00 | ||
| To Cash | Payment | 35 | 68,360.00 | ||
| By Cash | Receipt | 20 | 68,360.00 | ||
| 19-7-2016 | To Cash | Payment | 36 | 1,50,750.00 | |
| To Cash | Payment | 37 | 4,00,000.00 | ||
| 29-7-2016 | To Cash | Payment | 38 | 70,00,000.00 | |
| By Cash | Receipt | 21 | 70,00,000.00 | ||
| 30-7-2016 | To Cash | Payment | 39 | 19,00,000.00 | |
| By Cash | Receipt | 22 | 19,00,000.00 | ||
| 6-8-2016 | To Cash | Payment | 40 | 12,09,700.00 | |
| 10-8-2016 | To Cash | Payment | 41 | 14,24,400.00 | |
| 17-8-2016 | To Cash | Payment | 42 | 15,00,000.00 | |
| By Cash | Receipt | 23 | 15,00,000.00 | ||
| 19-8-2016 | To Cash | Payment | 43 | 6,00,000.00 | |
| By Cash | Receipt | 26 | 6,00,000.00 | ||
| To Cash | Payment | 44 | 14,53,500.00 | ||
| 2-9-2016 | To Cash | Payment | 45 | 16,12,788.00 | |
| 22-9-2016 | To Cash | Payment | 46 | 60,00,000.00 | |
| By Cash | Receipt | 27 | 40,00,000.00 | ||
| 7-10-2016 | To Cash | Payment | 47 | 40,00,000.00 | |
| 5,61,70,538.00 | 2,53,28,980.00 | ||||
| 2,48,41,558.00 | |||||
| 5,61,70,538.00 | 5,61,70,538.00 | ||||
The path of the above incriminating document is "RRS-7\A-4 D1\Project Infra\HN Gupta\SamsungPhone\WhatsApp\357956082727555\sdcard\whatsApp\Media\WhatsApp\Documents\kkd.pdf"
5.11The extract of 'ssss.pdf' found and seized/impounded during the search action at Sh. Hirday Narayana Gupta u/s 132 of the Act dated 18.09.2018 is as under:
Kkul Sitti Ledger Account
Date Particulars Vch Type Vch No. Debit Page 1 Credit 29-9-2016 By Commission @ 9% Journal 1 1,18,12,750.00 9-3-2016 To Cash Payment 1 30,00,000.00 To Cash Payment 2 30,00,000.00 60,00,000.00 1,18,12,750.00 30,12,750.00 1,18,12,750.00 1,18,12,750.00 To Closing Balance 1-4-2016 By Opening Balance 30,12,750.00 4-4-2016 To Cash Payment 1 50,000.00 To Cash Payment 2 50,000.00 14-4-2016 To Cash Payment 3 50,000.00 To Cash Payment 4 50,000.00
22-4-2016 To Cash Payment 5 2,50,000.00 To Cash Payment 6 9,11,000.00 By Cash Receipt 1 11,000.00 23-4-2016 To Cash Payment 7 1,00,000.00 To Cash Payment 8 1,00,000.00 24-4-2016 By Brok Journal 1 61,500.00 By Brok Journal 2 3,23,120.00 28-4-2016 To Cash Payment 9 6,43,000.00 To Cash Payment 10 25,89,120.00 By Cash Receipt 2 22,68,000.00 By Brok Journal 3 74,400.00 2-5-2016 To Cash Payment 11 2,75,000.00 To Cash Payment 12 8,86,000.00 By Cash Receipt 3 11,61,000.00 To Cash Payment 13 4,85,000.00 12-5-2016 To Cash Payment 14 7,36,000.00 By Brok Journal 4 93,000.00 14-5-2016 To Cash Payment 15 5,00,000.00 To Cash Payment 16 1,28,500.00 By Cash Receipt 4 1,28,500.00 23-5-2016 To Cash Payment 17 5,64,300.00 By Brok Journal 5 44,640.00 26-5-2016 To Cash Payment 18 8,86,000.00 By Cash Receipt 5 8,86,000.00 3-6-2016 To Cash Payment 19 8,00,000.00 11-6-2016 To Cash Payment 20 12,75,000.00 By Cash Receipt 6 12,75,000.00 To Cash Payment 21 9,09,000.00 By Cash Receipt 7 9,09,000.00 12-6-2016 By Brok Journal 6 1,18,000.00 13-6-2016 By Cash Receipt 8 6,84,000.00 20-6-2016 To Cash Payment 22 2,32,000.00 By Cash Receipt 9 1,46,000.00 1,24,49,920.00 1,39,91,910.00 Carried Over continued...
Kkd Skill Ledger Account : 1-Apr-2015 to 7-Oct-2016
Page 2
Date Particulars Vch Type Vch No. Debit Credit Brought Forward 1,24,49,920.00 1,39,91,910.00 20-6-2016 To Cash Payment 23 2,00,000.00 By Cash Receipt 10 2,00,000.00 By Brok Journal 7 80,000.00 By Mkt 9%+Exp Journal 8 7,32,000.00 5-7-2016 To Cash Payment 24 8,00,000.00 To Cash Payment 25 51,000.00 By Cash Receipt 11 51,000.00 6-7-2016 To Cash Payment 26 6,50,000.00 By Cash Receipt 12 5,67,000.00 By Brok Journal 9 83,000.00 7-7-2016 To Cash Payment 27 10,91,000.00 By Cash Receipt 13 10,91,000.00 9-7-2016 To Cash Payment 28 2,25,000.00 By Cash Receipt 14 2,25,000.00 To Cash Payment 29 1,00,000.00 By Cash Receipt 15 1,00,000.00 To Cash Payment 30 1,26,000.00 By Cash Receipt 16 1,26,000.00 12-7-2016 To Cash Payment 31 5,22,000.00 By Cash Receipt 17 5,22,000.00 To Cash Payment 32 4,00,000.00 By Cash Receipt 18 4,00,000.00 13-7-2016 To Cash Payment 33 98,100.00 By Cash Receipt 19 98,100.00 15-7-2016 To Cash Payment 34 1,00,000.00 By Cash Receipt 20 1,00,000.00 To Cash Payment 35 66,380.00 By Cash Receipt 21 66,380.00 19-7-2016 To Cash Payment 36 1,90,750.00 To Cash Payment 37 4,00,000.00 By Brok Journal 10 86,200.00 29-7-2016 To Cash Payment 38 70,00,000.00 By Cash Receipt 22 70,00,000.00 30-7-2016 To Cash Payment 39 19,00,000.00 By Cash Receipt 23 19,00,000.00 By Brok Journal 11 7,000.00
6-8-2016 To Cash Payment 40 12,09,700.00 10-8-2016 To Cash Payment 41 14,24,400.00 17-8-2016 To Cash Payment 42 15,00,000.00 By Cash Receipt 34 15,00,000.00 19-8-2016 To Cash Payment 43 6,00,000.00 By Cash Receipt 25 6,00,000.00 To Cash Payment 44 14,53,500.00 5-9-2016 By Dhingra (Broker) Journal 12 10,00,000.00 2-9-2016 To Cash Payment 45 16,12,700.00 22-9-2016 To Cash Payment 46 60,00,000.00 By Cash Receipt 26 40,00,000.00 7-10-2016 To Cash Payment 47 40,00,000.00 Carried Over 4,41,70,538.00 3,45,32,590.00 continued
Kkd
Std Ledger Account 1-Apr-2015 to 7-Oct-2016 Page 3
Date Particulars Vch Type Vch No Debit Credit Bought Forward 4,41,70,538.00 3,45,32,590.00 7-10-2016 By Cash Receipt 27 5,01,000.00 4,41,70,538.00 3,50,33,590.00 31,35,548.00 By Closing Balance 4,41,70,538.00 4,41,70,538.00 ssss.pdf
The path of the above incriminating documents namely 'ssss.pdf' is 'RRS-7A-4 D1\Project Infra\HN Gupta\Samsung Phone\WhatsApp\357956082727555\sdcard\whatsApp\Media\WhatsApp\Documents\ssss.pdf'
5.12The extract of 'IMG-20180904-WA0001.jpg' found and seized/impound during the search action at Sh. Hirday Narayana Gupta u/s 132 of the Act dated 18.09.2018 has been discussed in Paras 5.3 through 5.4.
Perusal of the above documents read in context of account prepared vide IMG-20180904-WA0001.jpg , reflects that opening balance as per sheet on 28.09.2017 is Rs. 91,36,950/- which is matching with debit balance of Sbtl ledger account in tally ERP of kkd. Tally ERP ledger accounts shows cash payments and receipts. Further, IMG-2018090-WA0001.jpg reflects further commission paid to the tune of Rs. 1,45,19,610/- which include both cash as well payment through bank , and thus the total comes to Rs. 2,36,56,560/-(shown as A+B). Further, the said document IMG-20180904-WA0001.jpg, shows that there are receivables from brokers on account of direct payments given by SPPL to ADMAX to the tune of Rs. 1,46,543/- and Direct given as per attachment to the tune of Rs. 5,47,555/- , which were on behalf of the brokers . These two direct payments are ostensibly made by SPPL directly for which onus was on brokers to make agreements as per their agreement/understanding ( copy of agreement not produced ) and hence recoverable from the brokers. This leads to an amount totaling to Rs. 2,43,50,658/- recoverable by SPPL. There is an entry of Rs. 10,00,000/- being credited to Dhingra(Broker) on 01.02.2016. Now, the entry shows that Rs.61,94,824/- is as per agreement , thr broker charges @9% due on receipt basis , sheet enclosed, which is reduced from the aforesaid amount, which gives total recoverable by SPPL to the tune of Rs. 1,81,55834/- . Thus, the total commission/brokerage comes to Rs. 61,94,824/-which is based on agreements based on receipt made by SPPL.The taxable event will occur when right to receive is vested. Now, if this is read in conjunction with document ‘BSP details of SUMMIT master’, it is observed that the commission earned by the assessee was to the tune of Rs. 1,11,85,948/- and Sbtl has earned commission of Rs. 45,15,708.38 . Both were selling/marketing the project RST Horizon. SBTL is also engaged in construction . The assessee was introduced to SPPL by SBTL. The total sales of Sbtl+ Dhingra is Rs. 17,44,62,851/- and 9% commission comes to Rs. 1,57,01,658/- . It is admitted position that the assessee declared commission income of Rs. 10,00,000/- in his return of income filed with Revenue. It is also admitted position that the assessee has acted as broker/agent for RST Horizon Project. The documents speaks voluminously that the assessee was entitled for commission @9%. It is also true that commissions become due normally based on the realizations made by the promoter of the project if the payments are construction linked. It is also true that the document IMG-20180904-WA001.jpg speaks of the commission becoming due of Rs. 61,94,824/- on receipt basis meaning thereby based on the project payments of sale of units received from the buyers , that is when right to receive commission is vested i.e. real income got vested and become chargeable to tax. It is also observed by ld. CIT(A) as well stated by ld. Counsel for the assessee, that some of the booking got cancelled . It is also true that the assessee is not forthcoming with proper reply and is giving evasive replies by denying the receipt of payment of commission . Reference is also drawn to provisions of Section 132(4), 132(4A) and 292C of the 1961 Act . It is also true that the assessee has not availed cross examination twice offered by the AO. Thus, the assessee is not able to discharge onus cast on it and presumption drawn under the aforesaid provisions of the 1961 Act was not rebutted. It is also observed from seized material that substantial bookings of units in RST Horizon Project got concluded in the previous year relevant to the impugned assessment year. It was for the assessee to have come forward and submitted complete and truthful details, but the assessee is merely on denial mode, while the seized material speaks voluminously that the assessee has earned brokerage / commissions on the booking of RST Horizon Project and the assessee has not made complete and truthful disclosure of income while filing his return of income. Thus, under these circumstances , it will be fair and appropriate to split the commission income which has become due and payable as per contract to the tune of Rs. 61,94,824/- ( i.e. real income being brokerage becoming vested in Sbtl and the assessee i.e. right to receive got vested in favour of Sbtl and the assessee) in the ratio of total commission of the assessee and Sbtl as is mentioned in the seized material viz. 1,11,85,948 : 45,15,708 between sales/marketing done by the assessee and Sbtl, and going by this aforesaid ratio , the assessee income chargeable to tax comes to Rs. 44,13,151/-. The assessee has already declared Rs. 10,00,000/- ( ld. CIT(A) has referred to in its order that the assessee has declared Rs.5,00,000/- in the year under consideration, thus AO can verify this fact as to how much income stood declared by the assessee out of Rs.10,00,000/-in the year under consideration or subsequent years, and accordingly grant credit to the assessee) as income from brokerage/commission from RST Horizon Project, and hence consequently balance amount of Rs. 34,13,151/- is brought to tax (subject to verification by the AO as directed above), and the additions accordingly made by the AO are upheld to the tune of Rs. 34,13,151/-(subject to verification by the AO as directed above). We order accordingly.
It is observed that ld. CIT(A) has given relief to the assessee by deleting the additions as were made by the AO in the most casual manner. The proceedings before ld. CIT(A) are merely extension of assessment proceedings. The ld. CIT(A) powers are co-terminus with the power of the AO which include even power of enhancement. The ld. CIT(A) failed to observe that the assessee failed to avail cross examination granted by the AO twice of Shri Sandip Sahni, Director of SBTL and Shri Hirday Narain Gupta. The ld. CIT(A) merely accepted the contentions of the assessee that it has not earned commission / brokerage from RST Horizon Project. The ld. CIT(A) failed to observe that Shri Sandip Sahni , Director of Sbtl in its statement has stated that Sbtl introduced assessee to SPPL to act as broker for RST Horizon Project. The ld. CIT(A) failed to observe that documents seized/impounded are systematic record bring maintained by SPPL for RST Horizon Project. The name of the assessee stood clearly find mentioned in these document. Under these circumstances, we allow the appeal of the Revenue partly in the manner as indicated above. We order accordingly.
In the result, appeal filed by the Department is partly allowed in the manner indicated above.
