High CourtsDivision Bench(2023) 10 CHH CK 0019

Ashok Kumar Arora vs Executive Engineer, Kelo Project

Chhattisgarh High Court · Decided on 12 October 2023

RESULT
Dismissed
CASE NUMBER
FAM No. 38 Of 2018

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

10 paragraphs · 1,239 words
1.

The instant appeal under Section 54 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1884 (hereinafter referred to as ‘Special Act’) is filed by appellant against the judgment dated 06.10.2017 passed by the First Additional District Judge, Raigarh, Chhattisgarh in Misc. Civil Suit No.71 of 2010 whereby the suit filed by the appellant was dismissed. The said judgment is being referred to as “judgment in question”.

2.

Appellant- Ashok Kumar Arora preferred a reference under Section 18 of the Special Act before the First Additional District Judge, Raigarh, Chhattisgarh challenging the part of award dated 30.09.2009 passed by the Land Acquisition Officer and Sub-Divisional Officer (Revenue), Raigarh, Chhattisgarh in Land Acquisition Case No.05/A-82/2006-07, by which, he had challenged the compensation amount fixed for land acquisition. The said order passed by Land Acquisition Officer and Sub-Divisional Officer, Raigarh is being referred to as “award”.

3.

According to the said award, land of appellant Ashok Kumar Arora was situated at Village Bhagwanpur, Patwari Halka No.14, Revenue Division Bhagwanpur, Tehsil and District Raigarh, Chhattisgarh bearing Khasra No.63/5, area 0.135 hectare. The said land was acquired for construction of main canal of Kelo Project. The compensation was fixed at Rs.1,37,025/- (Rupees One Lac Thirty Seven Thousand Twenty Five), upon which, 30% compensation amount (solatium) and interest amount was fixed. The said land is being referred to as ‘suit land’.

4.

Learned counsel for the appellant would submit that suit land is diverted land and its market value is higher as the same is situated within 0.137 hectare on the main road of village Bhagwanpur. According to the guidelines, compensation should be determined at the rate of Rs.2,375/- (Rupees Two Thousand Three Hundred Seventy Five) per square meter, which comes to Rs.32,47,967/- (Rupees Thirty Two Lacs Forty Seven Thousand Nine Hundred Sixty Seven). On the said amount, solatium amount 30% comes to Rs.9,74,390/- (Rupees Nine Lac Seventy Four Thousand Three Hundred Ninety) and 12% annual interest amounting to Rs.10,06,670/- (Rupees Ten Lac Six Thousand Six Hundred Seventy) for 31 months from 03.03.2007 to 30.09.2009 were added, as such, total compensation comes to Rs.52,29,227/- (Rupees Fifty Two Lac Twenty Nine Thousand Two Hundred Twenty Seven). He would further submit that OP Jindal Hospital and Research Centre, Jindal School and Commercial Complex, Transport Nagar, Auditorium etc. are also situated around the suit land and thus, it is a valuable land. It is contended that in another similar case, the Court had allowed the claim and passed its award on 03.01.2017, in which the compensation amount has been enhanced, but, in judgment in question, principles of natural justice propounded by the Court have not been followed. Therefore, judgment in question is liable to be set aside and compensation amount should be enhanced to Rs.52,29,227/- (Rupees Fifty Two Lac Twenty Nine Thousand Two Hundred Twenty Seven).

5.

Per contra, learned counsel for the State/respondents would submit that as per award, distance of suit land from main road is more than 20 meters and appellant has not presented the evidence in its proper perspective. He would further submit that there is no basis for calculating the suit land in square metres. It is contended that appellant has not come to the Court with clean hands. It is argued that in order to bring the suit land within the scope of 0.137 hectare, at the time of land acquisition proceedings, appellant has deliberately sold the land in 4 parts to get more compensation amount. It is further argued that suit land has not actually been diverted and it has not been made clear that for what purpose, suit land was diverted as paperwork was done with the aim of getting more compensation. It is further argued that said facts has been mentioned in the order passed by the Land Acquisition Officer in its award. In the statement before Court of First Additional District Judge, Raigarh, appellant himself has admitted that he has not started any business in relation to the purpose, for which, he had diverted the land. The said land has been purchased by appellant after publication of land acquisition proceeding in daily newspaper. Thus, award passed by the Land Acquisition Officer and judgment in question passed by First Additional District Judge, Raigarh are well merited, which do not call for any interference.

6.

We have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record of the case with utmost circumspection.

7.

From perusal of the record, it is clear from the award passed by Land Acquisition Officer that for construction of main canal of Kelo Project at Village Bhagwanpur, Patwari Halka No.14, Revenue Division Raigarh 1, Tehsil and District Raigarh (C.G.) of private land of several persons located, whose total area was about 4.921 hectares, a notification under Section 4(1) of the Special Act was published in Chhattisgarh Gazette on 09.03.2007, in local newspaper ‘Kelo Pravah’ on 03.03.2007 and announcement was made by Tehsildar Raigarh in the village on 19.03.2007. Thereafter, objections were invited from private individuals and after hearing them, an award was passed on 30.09.2009 by Land Acquisition Officer, Raigarh in which, it has been clearly mentioned that proceedings regarding land acquisition were started in the office of the Collector on 22.02.2007. The suit land was purchased by the appellant from Ashish Goyal on 23.02.2007. In the said award, it has been mentioned in detail that how Ashish Goyal artificially sold the Tikra land by dividing it into 4 parts to his own family members, the appellant and his wife. On the basis of which, it has been believed that only paperwork has been done regarding land diversion, which was said to have been diverted in a mechanical manner without any apprehension. The appellant has admitted in paragraph-17 of his cross-examination that the purpose for which he had diverted his land, he has not started business. Thus, it reveals that after getting information about the land acquisition proceedings in Collector's office, just for the purpose of getting more compensation, Ashish Goyal (owner of suit land), immediately divided the land into 4 parts and artificially purchased the same so that the compensation could be fixed at the rate of per square metre and in a hurry, the land was diverted without ensuring the commercial purpose, which was also to get more compensation. The said finding has been mentioned in detail in the award passed by Land Acquisition Officer.

8.

It has been reflected in the judgment in question passed by First Additional District Judge, Raigarh that appellant has not mentioned in his affidavit that on which date, suit land was diverted. It is clear from the report of revenue officers that work was not being done on the said land for commercial purpose, but on the date of notification, said land was Tikra land. According to the record, proceedings relating to land acquisition were started on 22.02.2007, whereas said suit land was purchased by appellant from Ashish Goyal on 23.02.2007. In such a situation, no irregularity was found in action taken by Land Acquisition Officer in determining the compensation.

9.

In view of the aforementioned facts and circumstances of the case as well as after perusing the entire records, we do not find any irregularity or illegality in the judgment in question passed by First Additional District Judge, Raigarh and the arguments advanced by learned counsel for the appellant are not acceptable.

10.

In the result, the appeal sans merit, is liable to be and is hereby dismissed.