High CourtsSingle Bench(2012) 07 P&H CK 0140

Ashok Kumar vs Ashwani Kumar

Punjab And Haryana At Chandigarh · Decided on 17 July 2012

HON’BLE JUDGES
Ajay Tewari, J
RESULT
Dismissed
CASE NUMBER
Regular Second Appeal No. 2821 of 2012

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

8 paragraphs · 652 words

Ajay Tewari, J.—This appeal has been filed against concurrent judgments of the Courts below decreeing the suit of the respondent for specific performance of an agreement to sell and for handing over symbolic possession of the property in dispute. Parties are real brothers. By an agreement dated 3.6.2002, the appellant agreed to sell the property in dispute which is a house built on 161 sq. yards of land in Mahesh Nagar, situated within the revenue estate of village Babyal, Tehsil and District Ambala. The respondent paid an amount of Rs. 25,000/- and the remaining amount of Rs. 2,26,000/- was to be paid on the agreed date which was fixed as 30.11.2002. It was further the case of the respondent that he was put in possession of the house on the agreement to sell and it was for this reason that he had sought symbolic possession. 30.11.2002 and 1.12.2002 being holidays, the respondent appeared before the Sub Registrar on 2.12.2002 but the appellant defaulted and did not appear before the Sub Registrar for execution of the sale deed. Thereafter, the respondent sent various notices to the appellant, last one being on 14.11.2004 as per which he again called upon the appellant to execute the sale deed within one week of the receipt thereof. Notices having been un-answered, the instant suit was filed on 14.12.2004.

2.

Counsel for the appellant has fairly stated that all the above mentioned facts are admitted except for handing over of the possession. He has raised the following questions of law :-

(i) Whether the suit had to be dismissed on the ground that the respondent valued the suit at Rs. 2.26 lacs (the amount which remained to be paid), whereas it should have been valued at Rs. 2.51 lacs

(ii) Whether the respondent was entitled to decree of specific performance as he did not appear after giving notice dated 14.11.2004 to execute the sale deed within one week

(iii) Whether the suit ought not to have been decreed on account of delay

3.

As regards question No. (i), it is not disputed that neither this plea was taken in the written statement nor was it raised in the grounds of appeal. This Court in Municipal Council v. Mohal Lal and others, 2010(3) RCR (Civil) 98, held as follows :-

11.

The arguments raised by the learned counsel for the appellant are without any merit. From the perusal of the impugned judgment and decrees, I find that the aforesaid objection to the jurisdiction of the civil Court and the finality of the or4ders passed by the authorities under the Act, was nowhere taken in the pleadings of the parties, neither this argument was raised before the trial Court as well as before the lower appellate Court. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in Bachaaj Nahar v. Nilima Mandal and another, JT 2008(13) SC 255, has observed that no substantial question of law can be raised in the Regular Second Appeal based on a argument which was neither raised nor pleaded before the Courts below.

In view of the above judgment, question No. (i) does not arise in the present appeal. As regards question No. (ii), counsel for the appellant has not been able to substantiate as to under what provision of law it was incumbent upon the respondent to appear before the Sub Registrar repeatedly once it had been proved that he had duly appeared before the Sub Registrar on the appointed date. As regards question No. (iii), this question is based on discretion. The Courts below have considered the said point and have still exercised their discretion in favour of the respondent. Counsel for the appellant has not been able to persuade that the discretion has been exercised perversely or on extraneous material. Resultantly, all the questions raised are decided against the appellant. Consequently, finding no merit in this appeal the same is dismissed with no order as to costs.