AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
Manoj Kumar Gupta, J.—Heard learned counsel for the petitioner and Sri. Loknath Shukla, holding brief of Sri. Luxmi Prasad Gupta appearing on behalf of the respondent. With their consent, this petition is being disposed of finally, without inviting a counter affidavit. The respondent filed an application under section 25 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 for grant of permanent alimony against the petitioner. The respondent is the divorced wife of the petitioner. The petition was registered as case No. 89 of 2003. The application for grant of permanent alimony was opposed by the petitioner by filing objection. In the year 2014, the petitioner moved an application seeking amendment in the objections. By impugned order dated 17.7.2015, the Principal Judge, Family Court, Ghazipur has rejected the application for amendment by holding that the application has been filed with the intent to delay the disposal of the proceedings. It has been further observed that all the pleas and contentions now sought to be raised, were available to the petitioner before the commencement of the trial and the same should have been raised earlier. It has also been held that almost all the pleas now sought to be raised, were already there in the original objection.
Learned counsel for the petitioner, at the very outset conceded that the only assertion which was not made in the original objection, is regarding the operation of the petitioner's eye which took place on 22.6.2014. It claimed that the petitioner is suffering from Glaucoma and despite the operation, there had been no improvement in the eye sight. It is alleged that the petitioner, as a result thereof, was rendered unemployed. It is submitted that this part of the amendment, was not pleaded in the original objection, and the same deserves to be allowed.
I have perused the original objection and I find that the plea relating to the impairment of the eye sight, was not there in it. It also could not have been there, as the objection was filed in the year 2003 whereas, the operation of his eye was performed on 22.6.2014 and the petitioner claims to be suffering from glaucoma, since last 8-9 years. The court below, while it was justified in rejecting the rest part of the amendment application, as other pleas were already there in the objection originally filed, had overlooked that the plea relating to the vision of the petitioner being impaired because of glaucoma, was neither there in the original objection, nor could have been pleaded earlier.
In the opinion of the Court, the plea which is sought to be raised in this regard is a material plea, which would determine the quantum of permanent alimony, to be awarded against the petitioner. The petitioner has alleged that on account of loss of his eye sight, he is totally unemployed and consequently, these question would assume importance while determining the compensation payable to the respondent. The court below while rejecting the amendment application has thus failed to exercise the jurisdiction vested in it, resulting in manifest error of law.
However, it cannot be gainsaid that the proceedings have remained pending since the year 2003 and should thus be concluded expeditiously. The court below has noted in the impugned order that the proceedings are at the stage of final disposal, since the date when the amendment application was filed. In such view of the matter, this Court is of the opinion that the respondent should be adequately compensated by costs.
Learned counsel for the petitioner, on suggestion of the Court has agreed for payment of cost of Rs. 10,000/- as a condition precedent for allowing the amendment in the objection only to the extent that the petitioner was operated upon on 22.6.2014 and there had been impairment of his vision. The relevant part of the amendment which thus stand allowed is to the following effect:--
The aforesaid amendment shall stand allowed on payment of cost of Rs. 10,000/-, which shall be paid by the petitioner to the respondent within two weeks from today. In case the petitioner fails to pay the cost as provided above, the order of the trial court shall stand revived.
In case cost is paid, the petitioner shall be permitted to carry out the amendment to the extent allowed by this Court. The respondent shall thereafter have two weeks to file replication, if any, in response to the amended pleadings. It is further provided that after filing of replication, the trial court shall make sincere endeavour to conclude the proceedings as expeditiously as possible, preferably within a period of next two months. The order of the court below stands modified to the extent indicated above. This petition stands disposed of accordingly.
