AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
Hon’ble Ravindra Maithani, J. (Oral)
Instant appeal is preferred against the judgment and order dated 08/10.08.2023, passed in Special Sessions Trial No.35 of 2021, State of Uttarakhand vs. Anushka Budhathoki, by the court of learned Special Sessions Judge (NDPS), District Pithoragarh. By it, the appellant has been convicted under Section 8 read with Section 20(b)(ii)(c) of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 (in short “the Act”) and sentenced to undergo 20 years rigorous imprisonment with a fine of `1,50,000/-. In default of payment of fine, to undergo rigorous imprisonment for a further period of five years.
Facts necessary to appreciate the controversy, briefly stated, are as follows. According to the FIR, on 07.04.2021, PW1, Priyanka Singh, PW4, A.S.I. Mohan Singh and PW6, Shrija B.T. were on Indo-Nepal Border in Dharchula bridge. They were checking the people crossing the border. At about 11:50 a.m. on that date, they spotted a woman. She was signaled to stop. When PW6, Shrija B.T. inspected that woman, she noticed that some articles were tied on her thighs. When questioned, that woman could not reply anything. She was the appellant. The appellant was taken in the check post where PW6, Shrija B.T. searched and found brownish-black-colored strips tied on her thighs, which was charas. The arresting team did inform PW7, Ram Chandra Singh, who was Commandant. These all witnesses were personnel of SSB. PW7, Ram Chandra Singh according to the recovery memo, reached the spot, interrogated the the appellant. Thereafter, the recovered article was weighed; it was 1.440 kg. The recovery memo, Exhibit P-3, records that the appellant was arrested at 13:10 hours and the articles were seized. Post recovery of these articles, the appellant was taken to Police Station Dharchula where FIR No.13 of 2021 under Section 8/20 of the Act, was lodged against the appellant. Chik FIR is Exhibit P-1, based on which case was registered. The extract of General Diary entries is P-2.
The matter was investigated. The Investigating Officer prepared site plan, Exhibit P-8. Recovered articles were forwarded for Forensic Science Examination. Forensic Science Laboratory Report received, which confirmed that the recovered article gave positive test for charas in chemical and chromatographic analysis. After completion of investigation, PW9, S.I. Hem Chandra Tiwari, the Investigating Officer submitted a charge sheet (Exhibit P-11) against the appellant, which is the basis of the case.
On 09.08.2021, charge under Section 8/20 of the Act were framed against the appellant, to which, she denied and claimed trial.
In order to prove its case, the prosecution examined nine witnesses, namely, PW1, Priyanka Singh, PW2, Constable 16 C.P. Vinay Giri, PW3, 42 A.P. Akash Arya, PW4, A.S.I. Mohan Singh, PW5, Deepak Bam, PW6, Shrija B.T., PW7, Ram Chandra Singh, PW8, S. I. Harjeet Singh and PW9, S. I. Hem Chandra Tiwari.
After hearing the parties, by the impugned judgment and order, the appellant has been convicted and sentenced, as stated hereinbefore. Aggrieved, the appellant has preferred the instant appeal.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
Learned counsel for the appellant submits that the entire prosecution case is false. According to PW1, Priyanka Singh, PW4, A.S.I. Mohan Singh and PW6, Shrija B.T., the appellant was apprehended at 11:50 a.m. and after informing PW7, Ram Chandra Singh appeared at the spot at 12:45 p.m., and the appellant was arrested at 1:10 p.m. It is argued that this is false in view of the statement of PW5, Deepak Bam, who states that the weighing machine was taken from him around 2:00 p.m. It is argued that if the weighing machine itself was taken at 2:00 p.m., how could the appellant be arrested prior to that at 1:10 p.m. after weighing the articles allegedly recovered from the appellant? He would also raise the following points in his submission:-
The appellant was arrested at 1:10 p.m. The arrest was made by the SSB personnel, but the FIR was lodged at 4:45 p.m., which is much delayed. He would refer to P-1, the chik FIR, in which the direction and distance of the place of incident from the Police Station is 200 metres. He submits that it doubts the prosecution case.
It is also submitted that it is a case of total non-compliance of the provision of Section 50 of the Act because PW7, Ram Chandra Singh has categorically stated that he was informed that a woman has been detected who is carrying charas and when he reached, in his presence search was made. It is argued that if the search was made in presence of PW7, Ram Chandra Singh after knowing that the appellant is carrying charas, the appellant ought to have been given the option under Section 50 of the Act so as to be searched before a Magistrate or Gazetted Officer, but it is argued that has not been done and it vitiates the entire recovery and entitles the appellant to acquittal. He would refer to the statement of PW1, Priyanka Singh, PW4, A.S.I. Mohan Singh, PW6, Shrija B.T. and PW7, Ram Chandra Singh on that aspect.
On the other hand, learned State Counsel would submit that it is a case of sudden recovery; charas in commercial quantity was recovered from the appellant; witnesses have deposed against it and there is no reason to make any interference.
Before the arguments are appreciated, it may be seen as to what the witnesses have stated.
PW6, Shrija B.T. has searched the appellant. According to her, on 07.04.2021, she was posted at a bridge check post at Indo-Nepal Border. She is a personnel in SSB, 11th Battalion. According to her, a woman was stopped and when inspected, it was revealed that she had something tied on her thighs. She was checked in the check post, where charas was recovered. In paragraph no.3 of her statement, PW6, Shrija B.T., has stated that thereafter Commander was informed, who reached at the spot at 12:45. The article recovered was weighed; it was 1.440 kg. She has identified her signatures on the recovery memo, which is Exhibit P-3. According to her, it was prepared. She has also identified her signatures on the arrest memo.
PW1, Priyanka Singh, was also posted at the same check post along with PW6, Shrija B. T. She has also corroborated the statement of PW6, Shrija B.T. So is the statement of PW4, ASI Mohan Singh; he was also posted at the same check post. He has also stated about the alleged recovery.
PW7, Ram Chandra Singh, is the Commander, who was informed by the arresting personnel about the appellant suspected to be carrying some articles on her thighs. It may be noted that PW1, Priyanka Singh has also identified her signatures on the recovery memo. PW4, A.S.I. Mohan Singh has proved the recovery memo Exhibit P-3. He has also proved other documents relating to the search and handing over of the victim, sealing of the articles, which are Exhibit P-4 & P-5. He also proved the recovered charas, MO-1, MO-2 and MO-3.
PW7, Ram Chandra Singh was the Commander, who reached the spot after having been informed that a woman is carrying charas. This is what he has categorically stated in paragraph 1, in the chief-examination, and paragraph 6 of the cross-examination. According to him, he directed PW1, Constable Priyanka Singh and PW6, Constable Shrija B.T. for search at the check post, where charas was recovered.
It may be noted that PW7, Ram Chandra Singh in paragraph 2 of his statement categorically stated that he had directed PW1, Priyanka Singh and PW6, Shrija B.T. to search the victim, and thereafter charas was recovered. He has proved his signatures on the arrest memo.
PW2, Constable 16 C.P. Vinay Giri, has proved the chik FIR and extract of GD, Exhibit P-1 and P-2.
PW3, 42 A.P. Akash Arya, took the articles to Forensic Science Laboratory. He has stated about it.
PW5, Deepak Bam, had provided an electronic weighing machine to SSB personnel on 07.04.201 at about 2:00 p.m. He has stated accordingly.
PW8, S.I. Harjeet Singh, conducted initial investigation, which was concluded by PW9, S.I. Hem Chandra Tiwari, who has stated that he took over the investigation, sent the articles for forensic examination. He has proved the letter Exhibit P-7. He has also proved the site plan which he prepared as Exhibit P-8. He has proved the documents prepared by him during investigation and finally proved the charge sheet, Exhibit P-11.
What is argued is that the arrest of the appellant was made at 1:10 p.m., whereas, according to PW5, Deepak Bam, the weighing scale was taken from him by the SSB personnel at about 2:00 p.m. This argument has little merit for acceptance. PW5 is not precise as to the exact time at which the weighing scale was taken from him by the police personnel. He merely states that it was taken at about 2:00 p.m.
It is true that according to the prosecution witnesses, the appellant was firstly spotted at 11:50 a.m., thereafter search etc. was made when PW7, Ram Chandra Singh arrived at the place of incident at 12:45 p.m., and finally after weighing the alleged article, the arrest was made at 1:10 p.m. and fact remains that FIR was lodged at 4:45 p.m., at the Police Station, which is just 200 meters away from the place of incident as revealed from the chik FIR, Exhibit P-1. Why this delay? In fact, it is not explained. What happened in those between three hours? That is one aspect of the matter.
What is most important is the non-compliance of Section 50 of the Act. Section 50 of the Act mandates that if the person to be arrested so requires, such person shall be taken without unnecessary delay to the nearest Gazetted Officer or any of the departments mentioned in Section 42, to the nearest Magistrate. Section 50, sub-section (1) of the Act reads as follows:
“50. Conditions under which search of persons shall be
conducted.- (l) When any officer duly authorised under ssction 42 is about to search any person under the provisions of section 41, section 42 or section 43, he shall, if such person so requires, take such person without unnecessary delay to the nearest Gazetted Officer of any of the departments mentioned in section 42 or to the nearest Magistrate.”
What is argued on behalf of the prosecution that it was a case of sudden search. Undoubtedly, if search is made suddenly, perhaps there may not be any occasion for the arresting officer to make substantial or due compliance of Section 50 of the Act.
PW1, Priyanka Singh, PW4, A.S.I. Mohan Singh and PW6, Shrija B.T. were those persons who first spotted the appellant at the Indo-Nepal border and signaled her to stop when they spotted something tied on the thighs of the appellant. The question is whether before search, the prosecution witnesses or the arresting team or the team making search was told or were aware that the appellant is carrying charas? If it is so, the compliance of Section 50 of the Act becomes mandatory.
PW1, Priyanka Singh in paragraph 3 of her statement submits that when search was made, they recovered charas; thereafter they informed PW7, Ram Chandra Singh. This is so stated by PW1, Priyanka Singh in paragraph 4 of her statement. She also tells about the videography of which pen drive has also been proved by her. But in paragraph 13 of her examination, which is in fact part of cross-examination, PW1, Priyanka Singh has stated that when the appellant was taken for search in the room, she had revealed that she had charas, which means the searching team knew in advance, before actual recovery, that the appellant is carrying charas.
PW4, A.S.I. Mohan Singh was also a part of the arresting team. In paragraph 3 of his statement, he tells that search was made and charas recovered; thereafter information was given to PW7, Ram Chandra Singh. PW6, Shrija B.T., has in paragraph 7 of her examination, which is part of cross-examination, has stated that before the appellant was taken for search, they were told that she was carrying charas. But PW7, Ram Chandra Singh speaks otherwise. In paragraph 1 of his statement, PW7, Ram Chandra Singh has stated that at 12:29 he received an information from PW4, ASI Mohan Singh that a woman is carrying charas. Thereafter, in paragraph 2 of his statement, this witness tells that he permitted PW1, Priyanka Singh and PW6, Shrija B.T. for search of the appellant and thereafter charas was recovered. This witness was particularly asked as to whether the searching team knew in advance that the appellant is carrying charas. In answer to a question in paragraph 6 of his statement, PW7 has stated that before search, it was known to the searching team that charas is tied around the thighs of the appellant. The statement of PW1, Priyanka Singh so and PW6, Shrija B.T. and PW7, Ram Chandra Singh makes it abundantly clear that in fact the searching team knew in advance that the appellant is carrying charas and charas is tied around her thighs. It was a case of personal search. The appellant was not given any option of search to be made either before Magistrate or before the nearest Gazetted Officer. It is a case of total non-compliance of Section 50 of the Act.
In fact, the provisions of the Act are so stringent which carries grave punishments. The mandatory compliance if not made, vitiates the recovery and Section 50 of the Act is one of such mandatory provisions which is a safeguard to ensure that search is made in accordance with the Rules and the statutory provisions. In the case of Vijaysinh Chandubha Jadeja vs. State of Gujarat, (2011) 1 SCC 609, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has discussed the question of compliance of Section 50(1) of the Act and held that it is a mandatory provision and requires strict compliance. Failure to its compliance renders the recovery of illicit article suspect and vitiates the conviction, if it is recorded. In paragraph 29 of the judgment, the Hon'ble Supreme Court observed as follows:
“29.In view of the foregoing discussion, we are of the firm opinion that the object with which the right under Section 50(1) of the NDPS Act, by way of a safeguard, has been conferred on the suspect viz. to check the misuse of power, to avoid harm to innocent persons and to minimise the allegations of planting or foisting of false cases by the law enforcement agencies, it would be imperative on the part of the empowered officer to apprise the person intended to be searched of his right to be searched before a gazetted officer or a Magistrate. We have no hesitation in holding that insofar as the obligation of the authorised officer under sub-section (1) of Section 50 of the NDPS Act is concerned, it is mandatory and requires strict compliance. Failure to comply with the provision would render the recovery of the illicit article suspect and vitiate the conviction if the same is recorded only on the basis of the recovery of the illicit article from the person of the accused during such search. Thereafter, the suspect may or may not choose to exercise the right provided to him under the said provision.”
In the instant case, the searching team of SSB, PW1, Priyanka Singh, PW4, A.S.I. Mohan Singh, PW6, Shrija B.T. and PW7, Ram Chandra Singh knew in advance that the appellant had tied charas around her thighs. In fact, PW7 is categorical that before reaching at the spot, he was told that the appellant is carrying charas and in paragraph 2 of his statement, PW7 has categorically stated that he has directed PW1, Priyanka Singh and PW6, Shrija B.T. for search of the appellant in his supervision. Knowingly that search of a charas is being made from a person of the appellant, compliance of Section 50 of the Act was not made. It is a case of total non-compliance of Section 50 of the Act, which vitiates the alleged recovery and also vitiates the conviction.
In view of the above discussions, this Court is of the view that the prosecution has not been able to prove its case without beyond any reasonable doubt against the appellant and the appellant ought to have been acquitted of the charge levelled against him. Learned court below has committed an error in convicting and sentencing the appellant. Therefore, the appeal deserves to be allowed.
The appeal is allowed.
The judgment and order dated 08/10.08.2023, passed in Special Sessions Trial No.35 of 2021, State of Uttarakhand Vs. Anushka Budhathoki, by the court of learned Special Sessions Judge (NDPS), District Pithoragarh is set aside.
The appellant Anushka Budhathoki is acquitted of the charge under Section 8 read with Section 20(b)(ii)(c) of the Act.
The appellant is in jail. Let she be released forthwith, if not wanted in any other case, subject to her furnishing personal bonds and two sureties each of the like amount to the satisfaction of the court concerned under Section 437A of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.
Let a copy of this judgment along with the trial court record be sent to the court concerned.
