AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
. Heard Mr. C. A. Joshi, learned Counsel for the Petitioner, Mr. S. S. Dewani, learned Counsel for the Respondent No.1 and Ms. D. V. Sapkal, learned AGP for the Respondent No.2/State.
In the present Petition, challenge is to the Judgment and Order dated 7/3/2013 passed by the Industrial Court, Akola in Complaint ULP No. 75/2006, by which, Complaint filed by the Petitioner/Employee has been dismissed on the ground that Petitioner failed to make out a case of unfair labour practice, as contemplated under Item 5 of Scheduled IV of the Maharashtra Recognition of Trade Unions and Prevention of Unfair Labour Practices Act, 1971 (for short, ‘MRTU & PULP Act’).
The facts giving rise to the present Petition are as under :
The Petitioner/Employee has filed the Complaint before the Labour Court, alleging unfair labour practice at the instance of Respondent/Company. The Petitioner/Employee stated that he has been appointed in the year 1985 and since then he was working continuously with the Respondent/Company upto year 2000 in the shop which was located at Akola. After the year 2000, said shop has been allotted to the authorized dealer namely, Shri Madhukar Gawai. After that, he has been continued in the employment of Madhukar Gawai, who was appointed as authorized dealer of the Company. It is pointed out that in the year 2006, the authorized dealer Madhukar Gawai has closed the shop and thereby he stopped receiving monthly salary.
In view of this, Petitioner has filed proceeding before the Industrial Court bearing Complaint ULP Case No. 75/2006, alleging therein that there is an unfair labour practice at the instance of Respondent/Company, and therefore, sought direction to make him permanent with retrospective effect after completion of 240 days with all monetary benefits against the Respondent No.1 only. All allegations of unfair labour practice was raised against the Respondent No.1 only. The authorized dealer, under whom he has worked for six years, not impleaded as party Respondent nor any allegation of unfair labour practice were raised against him.
The Respondent No.1/Company appeared before the Industrial Court with a submission that the Petitioner has alleged in the Complaint that since May-2006 he has not been paid wages by the Respondent No.1. He has also stated in the Complaint that since 8/9/2006, the shop was closed. According to him, he being original employee of Respondent No.1 and his salary was stopped since last four months, and that amount to unfair labour practice. Therefore, he claimed permanency with retrospective effect. In view of this claim, it is submitted that after appointing authorized dealer by the Company, salary of the employee from the year 2000 to 2006 was paid by the said authorized dealer, therefore, relation of employer and employee between them did not exist. So also it is pointed out that they did not possess the record of Petitioner from the year 2000 to 2006.
In the light of this factual position, learned Industrial Court has dealt with this matter and initially granted interim relief in favour of the Petitioner, however, the learned Industrial Court, vide Judgment dated 7/3/2013, by holding that there is no unfair labour practice as contemplated under Items, 5, 6 and 9 of the MRTU & PULP Act at the instance of Respondent No.1/Company and further by holding that the Petitioner has failed to establish employer and employee relation with Respondent No.1 after 2000, has dismissed the Complaint.
By way of present Petition, the Petitioner has raised various grounds, but could not satisfy to this Court as to why he has not impleaded Madhukar Gawai, who was subsequent authorized dealer as a necessary party to the proceeding, particularly when it is admitted fact on record that he has worked with him since the year 2000 to 2006. So also, the Petitioner/Employee could not satisfy to this Court that once in the year 2006 the Respondent No.1 has closed the shop, how the unfair labour practice has been alleged against the Respondent No.1/Company by filing Complaint in the year 2006.
It is the submission of the Petitioner that he was working with the Respondent No.1/Company and Madhukar Gawai was merely an authorized dealer of the Company, his employment was then automatically shifted towards authorized dealer Madhukar Gawai, and therefore, he was continued in service. Therefore, that dealer was/is not necessary party in the matter.
In the present case, if the submission of the Petitioner is accepted that authorized dealer was not required to be impleaded as necessary party to the proceeding before the Industrial Court, then how the unfair labour practice against the Respondent No.1 can be said to be proved for the period from 2001 to 2006. Therefore, this submission cannot be accepted, which is made first time before this Court. So also Respondent No.1 after 2000 onwards specifically denied relationship as employer and employee with the Petitioner. Therefore, it was more necessary for the Petitioner to implead authorized dealer as a party to the proceeding and proved his case how he was in continuous employment of the Respondent No.1 and demonstrate inter-relation between Respondent No.1 and authorized dealer, under whom, he was worked for the said period. In absence of these details, Petitioner cannot claim relief of permanency, that too, with retrospective effect in the matter.
After going through the impugned Judgment, I am satisfied that the learned Industrial Court has rightly appreciated the controversy involved in the matter and by holding that Petitioner/Employee failed to establish unfair labour practice, dismissed the complaint.
In view of above, as the Judgment and order passed by the Industrial Court is correct and proper, I do not find any reason to interfere in the impugned Judgment, consequently, the Petition fails and same stands dismissed. Rule is discharged accordingly. No order as to costs.
