Tribunals and CommissionsDivision Bench(2025) 11 NCLAT CK 2239

Anil Kumar Ojha vs Revathi S Raghunathan

National Company Law Appellate Tribunal, CHENNAI Bench · Decided on 13 November 2025

RESULT
Disposed Of
CASE NUMBER
Company Appeal (AT) (CH) (Ins) No. 332/2024

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

25 paragraphs · 1,604 words

Per: Justice Sharad Kumar Sharma, Member (Judicial):

A precise question, which primarily requires consideration in the instant Company Appeal, is whether the platform provided under the I&B Code can be utilized for the purpose of taking vengeance for personal grievances. The facts with which the Appellant has approached this Appellate Tribunal, while challenging the impugned order dated 04.07.2024, arise from the order passed by the NCLT, Chennai Bench, in IA(IBC)/1242/CHE/2024 in CP No. 1264/IB/2018. It appears that in the proceedings of the Company Petition No. 1264/IB/2018, there were three interlocutory applications which require specific reference for the purpose of dealing with the instant controversy.

2.

Chronologically, the three applications that required consideration are as follows:

IA No. 1010/2022 was preferred by the Appellant, who appears in person, by filing the same before the Registry of the NCLT on 06.09.2022, allegedly invoking the provisions of Section 71 of the I&B Code as against the then Liquidator, Mr. S. Palaniappan. In the application thus preferred under Section 71 of the I&B Code, the Appellant sought relief in the following manner:

i)

It is therefore prayed that this Hon'ble Tribunal may punish the Respondent, under Section 71 of the Code for having knowledge of the books of the Corporate Debtor being falsified, yet not bring it to the knowledge of this Hon'ble Tribunal and seeking appropriate directions against the perpetuator.

Pass any such further order or relief that this Hon'ble Tribunal may deem fit considering the facts and circumstances of the case and render justice.

3.

In fact, from a reading of this application, there was a direct allegation levelled against the Liquidator named therein, asserting an act of misconduct allegedly falling within the ambit of Section 71 of the I&B Code, and seeking punishment for alleged falsification of the books of accounts of the Corporate Debtor, which upon establishment calls for imprisonment for a term not less than three years. Section 71 of the I&B Code is extracted hereunder:

On and after the insolvency commencement date, where any person destroys, mutilates, alters or falsifies any books, papers or securities, or makes or is in the knowledge of making of any false or fraudulent entry in any register, books of account or document belonging to the corporate debtor with intent to defraud or deceive any person, he shall be punishable with imprisonment for a term which shall not be less than three years, but which may extend to five years, or with fine which shall not be less than one lakh rupees, but may extend to one crore rupees, or with both.

4.

This application remained pending until another application, being IA No. 1234/2022, was preferred by the Appellant himself, in IA No. 1010/2022, which was filed by invoking Section 60(5)(a) read with Section 60(5)(c) of the I&B Code and Rule 11 of the NCLT Rules. The allegation therein was that the erstwhile Liquidator, Mr. S. Palaniappan, as described in the application, was responsible for misconduct. The basis of the argument was that subsequent to the filing of IA No. 1010/2022, the CBI had also filed FIR No. RC0322023A0020 dated 14.11.2023 for prosecuting the RP, Mr. C. Ramasubramaniam, for offences under Section 120B read with Section 420 and 409 of the IPC, and also under Section 13(2) read with Section 13(1)(a) of the Prevention of Corruption Act.

5.

In the said application, he contended that the RP, namely Mr. C. Ramasubramaniam, against whom the CBI was proceeding with an investigation for the aforesaid offences, and the opposite party to IA No. 1234/2022, i.e., Mr. S. Palaniappan, the Liquidator was also connected to the matter, and had allegedly falsified figures in the financial statements prepared by them and the said financial statements appeared to be fabricated and falsified. For this reason, on 28.11.2023, the Tribunal ordered a change of Liquidator, appointing Mrs. Revathi Raghunathan as the new Liquidator, who was directed to furnish a fresh report. Against this backdrop, the Appellant in IA No. 1234/2024 prayed for the following reliefs:

1)

File additional affidavit and bring the additional facts on record.

2)

To implead the Erstwhile RP Mr. C. Ramasubramaniam as Respondent No. 2 and the new Liquidator Mrs. Revathi Raghunathan as Respondent No. 3.

3)

To amend the prayer of the original Application to seek action against the other 2 impleaded Respondents also.

4)

Any such order/orders, direction/directions that this Hon'ble Tribunal may deem fit and proper and thus render justice.

6.

While this application for filing an additional affidavit and for impleading the erstwhile Resolution Professional and the newly appointed Liquidator remained pending, the Appellant filed a third application IA No. 1242/2024.

7.

IA No. 1242/2024 was preferred in CP No. 1264/2018, invoking Section 60(5) of the I&B Code read with Section 70(2) of the I&B Code, read with Regulations 2(1)(b)(a), 31, 30, 31A and 32B of the IBBI (Liquidation process) Regulations, 2016, under the same factual backdrop as IA No. 1010/2022 and IA No. 1234/2022. The Appellant, while elaborating on the issues, in the application IA No. 1242/2024, prayed for a direction against the Respondents in the Company Petition to accept the factum of the non-disclosure agreement signed and provided to the Respondent, and consequently to provide the Applicant with the minutes of the third SCC meeting held on 24.01.2024, along with any documents circulated in the meeting. Besides that, he also prayed that cognizance be taken regarding the alleged violation of the provisions of the I&B Code and for initiation of prosecution under Section 70(2) read with Section 236 of the I&B Code.

8.

On a comparative analysis of the three interlocutory applications referred to above, what may primarily be summarized is that the Appellant's main concern was for action against the RP and the Liquidator for their alleged misconduct, which necessitated invocation of Sections 71 and 70(2) of the I&B Code for seeking prosecution, and simultaneously, in IA No. 1242/2024, a prayer was made for supply of documents and minutes of the meeting held on 24.01.2024. When these applications were taken up for consideration, the Learned Tribunal, by the impugned judgment dated 04.07.2024, passed an order observing as follows:

1.

The Respondent had accepted that they would provide a copy of the non-disclosure agreement through email to the Appellant, and were directed to supply a hard copy as well. Secondly, while passing an order on IA No. 1242/CHE/2024, it was observed with respect to IA No. 1010/2022 that appropriate action for initiation of prosecution under Section 70(2) read with Section 236 of the I&B Code was pending consideration in IA No. 1010/2022.

9.

The argument of the Appellant is that, under the garb of deciding IA No. 1242/2024 - which was solely for procurement of minutes of the meeting and acceptance of the non-disclosure agreement – the Tribunal treated it as a reason for deciding IA No. 1010/CHE/2022, on the ground that in IA No. 1234/2022, which had been filed to implead the erstwhile RP as R2 and the new Liquidator as R3 in IA No. 1010/2022, a reply had been called for.

10.

The grievance of the Appellant is that no effective order has been passed on IA No. 1010/CHE/2022, where he prayed for punishing the Respondents under Section 71 of the I&B Code for having knowledge of the books yet failing to proceed in accordance with law.

11.

During arguments, the Appellant produced a copy of the order dated 29.07.2025 rendered by the Learned NCLT in IA No. 1234/2022, where he had prayed for impleadment of the RP, Mr. C. Ramasubramaniam, and the new Liquidator, Mrs. S. Revathi Raghunathan, as Respondent Nos. 2 and 3 respectively. As a consequence of the order dated 29.07.2025 passed in IA No. 1234/CHE/2024, the RP and the Liquidator have now been directed to be impleaded as parties to IA No. 1010/2022 and the necessary observations has been made in the order of 29.07.2025, to the following manner:

Learned Counsel for the new Liquidator and erstwhile RP submit that there are no allegations in IA No. 1010/2022 against the proposed Respondents. Considering the averments and the fact that proposed Respondents will have an opportunity to reply and rebut the allegations, we allow the Application IA No. 1234/2024 and implead the erstwhile RP and the new Liquidator as Respondents in IA No. 1010/2022. Amended memo of parties be filed along with amended Application and copy be served on all the Respondents.

12.

The effect of the order is that those against whom allegations were made in IA No. 1010/2022 now stand impleaded, and thus, in light of the order dated 29.07.2025, the reasoning adopted in disposing of IA No. 1010/2022 by the impugned order dated 04.07.2024 loses its significance. Since the impediment regarding non-impleadment has been removed, IA No. 1010/CHE/2022 is now free from any procedural hindrance and must be considered independently on its own merits.

13.

Hence, limited to the extent of IA No. 1010/2022, wherein the Appellant has prayed for punishing the Respondents under Section 71 of the I&B Code and the matter still remains to be adjudicated on merits, this Company Appeal is accordingly disposed of, with a request to the NCLT, Chennai, that in view of the order dated 29.07.2025 rendered in IA No. 1234/CHE/2024, whereby the RP and the Liquidator have already been impleaded in IA No. 1010/CHE/2022, the said application must now be decided independently on its merits, as the impediment of non-impleadment no longer survives.

The Company Appeal is disposed of, with the direction to the NCLT, Chennai, to decide IA No. 1010/CHE/2022, exclusively on its own merits without being influenced by any observation made by us in today's order.