AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
Mandeep Pannu, J
This petition under Section 24 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, has been filed by the applicant seeking the transfer of the proceedings in a civil suit for recovery, filed by respondent No.1, bearing case No. Civil Suit No. 2157 of 2022 dated 21.12.2022 titled as ‘P.D.Gautam vs. Sat Narain and another’ pending in the court of Civil Judge (Senior Division), Panipat to any other court of competent jurisdiction within the State of Haryana.
Learned counsel for the applicant submits that respondent No. 1 has instituted the aforesaid civil suit for recovery against the applicant and respondent No. 2 before the competent Court at Panipat. He contends that respondent No. 1 is a senior practising Advocate at the District Courts, Panipat and, owing to his professional standing and influence, the applicant is unable to secure effective legal assistance before the said Court. It is further submitted that the applicant was proceeded against ex parte on two occasions on account of the non-appearance of his counsel and that even no reply has been filed on his behalf to the application under Section 73 of the Indian Evidence Act.
Per contra, learned counsel for respondent No. 1 has opposed the present petition. He submits that the mere fact that the opposite party is a practising Advocate does not, by itself, constitute a valid ground for seeking transfer of a civil suit for recovery. He further submits that respondent No. 1 has, at all times, adhered to the due process of law and that the ex parte orders passed against the applicant were subsequently set aside upon respondent No. 1 expressing no objection thereto. It is also contended that, even if the applicant lacks confidence in the members of the Bar at the District Courts, Panipat, he is at liberty to engage counsel practising at the nearby District Courts, Karnal. Learned counsel further submits that it is well settled that a civil suit ought not ordinarily to be transferred merely on the basis of an apprehension of undue influence arising from the fact that the opposite party is a practising Advocate.
This Court has heard learned counsel for the parties.
It is well settled that the power of transfer under Section 24 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, is to be exercised judiciously, having regard to the facts and circumstances of each case. The question of transfer is to be determined by taking into consideration various factors, including actual hardship likely to be caused to the parties, and the overarching requirement of ensuring a fair trial.
Reliance has been placed upon decision of this High Court in DAV College, Hoshiarpur Society (Regd.) and another vs. D.M.Sharma and others 2005(1) RCR (Civil) 71 wherein it was observed as under:-
“Having heard learned counsel for the parties and perusing the record and judgments of this Court, I am of the considered view that this petition is liable to be dismissed because the principal argument raised by the learned counsel for the petitioner is untenable namely that if the litigation has been initiated by an Advocate or against the Advocate that alone would be a sufficient ground for seeking transfer of proceedings u/s 24 of the Code. This argument if accepted would have pernicious and deleterious effect on the administration of justice. In a given case there may be the possibility of establishing the relationship of a particular Advocate with the Presiding Officer and the same may constitute a ground for transfer but merely because the litigant is a practicing Advocate without anything more would not constitute a valid ground for transfer of the case. If such a principle is accepted, then all cases concerning members of the legal fraternity have to be contested at a place other than the one where the member of the Bar is practicing. Such a general ostracism of legal fraternity is impermissible…….”
In the light of the aforesaid dictum and the facts of the present case, this Court is of the considered view that the apprehension expressed by the applicant does not furnish sufficient grounds for ordering the transfer of the present civil suit. Admittedly, respondent No. 1 is a practising Advocate at the District Courts, Panipat. However, the mere professional status of respondent No. 1, without any further material demonstrating the likelihood of prejudice to the applicant or interference with the fair conduct of judicial proceedings, cannot be a ground for transfer under Section 24 of the Code.
Significantly, the applicant has neither alleged any specific bias on the part of the Presiding Officer nor pointed out any particular relationship or association between respondent No. 1 and the Presiding Officer which could reasonably give rise to an apprehension that the proceedings would not be conducted fairly. No specific instance has also been brought to the notice of this Court to demonstrate that respondent No. 1 has misused his professional position or influence to prejudice the applicant's interests or to interfere with the administration of justice.
Although the applicant has been proceeded against ex parte on two occasions, it is equally noteworthy that the orders in question were subsequently set aside by the Court concerned, with respondent No. 1 having expressed no objection to the same. Thus, the mere fact that such orders were passed, particularly when they were subsequently recalled, does not, in the absence of any other material, establish that the applicant has been subjected to any prejudice on account of the professional standing of respondent No. 1.
The applicant has, therefore, failed to demonstrate any circumstance suggesting that respondent No. 1 has exercised or attempted to exercise undue influence, or has otherwise overreached his professional position in a manner that could compromise the fairness of the trial or impede the proper conduct of judicial proceedings.
It is trite that a mere apprehension, unsupported by cogent and tangible material, cannot form the basis for transferring judicial proceedings. Accepting such a plea solely on the ground that one of the litigating parties happens to be a practising Advocate would not only be contrary to the settled legal position but could also result in an unwarranted exclusion of members of the legal fraternity from litigating before the Courts where they ordinarily practise. Consequently, this Court finds no justifiable ground to exercise its discretionary jurisdiction under Section 24 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908. Accordingly, the present application is dismissed.
Nothing said herein shall be construed to have an expression of merit upon the proceedings pending inter se between the paraties.
All the pending miscellaneous applications, if any, are also disposed of.
