AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
PER MAHAVIR SINGH, VP :
This appeal filed by the assessee against the order of the Ld. Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals)-3, Gurgaon dated 25.08.2025 passed in Appeal No. 10064037/Ggn CIT(A)-3/2012-13 arising out of the order of the AO, NFAC dated 20.9.2021 relevant to assessment year 2013-14 u/s 144/147 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (hereinafter referred as the Act).
The first issue on merit is as regards the order of learned CIT(A) confirming the addition made by the AO of Rs. 1,90,12,500/- on account of payment made in cash for purchase of agricultural land under section 69 read with section 115BBE of the Act on the basis of forged agreement. Without prejudice, also the assessee raised the issue that assessee's actual purchase value of agricultural land is Rs 27.65 lakhs which has duly been disclosed and addition has been made without reducing the sale value already paid and declared by the assessee. So, for this assessee has raised following grounds:
1(i) On the facts and circumstances of the case, the learned CIT(A) has erred both on facts and in law in confirming the addition of Rs. 1,90,12,500/- made by the AO alleging that the assessee has made the payment in cash for purchase of agricultural land under section 69 read with section 115BBE of the Income Tax Act.
(ii)That the above said addition has been confirmed rejecting the detailed submissions and explanations made by the assessee to justify that no such payment has been made by the assessee to the seller.
2.Without prejudice to the above, the learned CIT(A) has erred in confirming the addition of Rs, 1,90,12,500/- despite the fact that actual purchase value of assessee's share is Rs 27.65 lacs which has duly disclosed by the assessee and addition has been made without reducing the value of Rs 27.65 lacs already paid and declared by the assessee.
We have gone through the rival contentions and gone through the facts and circumstances of the case. The brief facts are that information was received from ITO Ward-2, Hisar vide letter dated 12 February 2019 that the assessee has purchased land jointly with his brother Ajay Kumar Aggarwal from Shri Om Prakash, S/o Sh. Prabhu Ram and Smt. Gayatri Devi, w/o Shri Om Prakash, Residents of H.NO. 22 Defence Colony, Hisar during the financial year 2012-13 relevant to assessment year 2013-14. vide agreement dated 14 August 2012 for an amount of Rs. 3,80,25,000/-. Accordingly, the AO noted that assessee's half share of Rs. 1,90,12,500/- is to be verified in regard to sources of payment. The AO issued letter to the assessee specifically requiring the assessee to explain the source of investment made in purchase of the agricultural land vide letter no. 425 dated 29-7-2019. On 8th August 2019, assessee along with his counsel appeared and filed reply explaining that purchase of property is to the tune of Rs 27,65,000/- (his share) and not for Rs. 1,90,12,500/-. The assessee filed copy of sale deed for purchase of land which was purchased along with his brother for an amount of Rs. 55,30,000/-. Accordingly, the AO issued notice under section 148 of the Act dated 26 September 2019 after recording reasons that income to the tune of Rs. 1,90,12,500/- is escaped assessment for the relevant assessment year 2013-14. In response to notice under section 148 of the Act, the assessee filed return of income on 14 October, 2019 repeating the same income as original filed on 16 July 2013. During the course of assessment proceedings, the assessee was confronted with the agreement a copy of which is enclosed in assessee's paper book at pages 12 and 13 and according to the agreement the assessee has entered into an agreement for purchase of land for a sum of Rs. 3,80,25,000/-. To counter this, the assessee submitted copy of sale deed dated 28 August 2012 which is enclosed in assessee's paper book at pages 79 to 82. As per the sale deed, the assessee along with his brother has purchased this land for a sum of Rs 55,30,000 and assessee's share comes to Rs. 27.65. This land was purchased by assessee through his father Sh. Santlal which is recorded in the sale deed. When the agreement depicting the sale proceeds particular of Rs. 3,80,25,000/- was confronted to the assessee, he categorically denied this very signature of his and his brother and contested the same. The assessee also filed report of the handwriting expert which is enclosed in assessee's paper book at pages 131 to 148. The relevant report and final opinion dated 12.9.2021 is recorded at page number 138, which is reproduced as under:-
“After examination and comparison of above said disputed and specimen signature of Ajay Agarwal, I am of the opinion that the person who wrote the specimen signatures marked as S1 to S10, did not write the disputed signature marked as Q1. So, the disputed signature marked as Q1 is free hand forged signatures of Ajay Agarwal or that the disputed signature marked Q1 is written by another writer than that of Ajay Agarwal on the document – “Agreement to Sell” dated 14.08.2021.
The enlarged photograph have been prepared with the help of digital camera and same are submitted here with the original report.”
The assessment was completed on 20 September 2021. Further the AO has also considered order of the Ld. Additional Civil Judge, (Senior Division), Siwani in Civil Suit No. 121 of 2018 dated 15 April 2021 and noted that as per the said order that there is no finding in the order that the agreement to sell dated 14 August 2012 is forged. Accordingly he relied on the agreement and assessed the entire purchase consideration (assessee's half share) of Rs. 1,90,12,500/- as unexplained investment under section 69 of the Act and taxed the same under section 115BBE of the Act.
Aggrieved, assessee preferred appeal before the learned CIT(A). The Ld. CIT finally affirmed the action of the AO vide para 4.1 of the order , which read as under:-
“4.1The appellant claimed that his signatures were forged and he and his brother entered into the registered sale deed dated 28 August 2012 for Rs 55,30,000 only. The appellant has relied upon a decision of a court case dated 15 April 2021 by Additional Civil Judge, Senior Division, Karnal's order in his case wherein it is mentioned that
“even for sake of arguments, it is admitted that the agreement dated 14 August 2012 was executed between the parties thereto, after execution of sale deed number 1143 dated 28 August 2012 which is not challenged, the same stood enforced.”
The AO has observed that, however, from the said judgment, it cannot be inferred that the agreement dated 14 August 2012 is forged, as there is no mention about this in the said judgment. Furthermore, whether the seller has accepted the above judgment and has not filed further appeal against was also not clear. The same judgment also mentions that the Commissioner of Income Tax Appeal-5 Ludhiana vide order dated 24 June 2019 passed in the case of plaintiff (Gayatri Devi, daughter of Shambhu Dayal) has recognized the agreement dated 14 August 2012 for the purpose of tax liability of the plaintiff. Thus, perusal of entire facts however negate the existence of agreement / Ikrarnama dated 14 August 2012 as per which this payment already stood made by the appellant to the said same parties. On the backside of this Ikrarnama, the payment of Rs. 2 crores in cash is seen to be made by Shri Pawan Agarwal and not the appellant, as per appellant's contention. But Ikrarnama clearly states that consideration is Rs. 3,80,25,000/- and the appellant and his brother are the purchasers and Rs. 1 crore has been received by the sellers on the date of Ikrarnama and remaining Rs. 2,80,25,000 will be paid at the time of registry. The formal sale deed was executed within a fortnight of execution of Ikrarnama also hints the authenticity of the contents of this Ikrarnama. The preponderance of probability is heavily tilted against the appellant in light of circumstantial evidence and the fact that the appellant's main contention is forged signature. For this, he has submitted a report from a private forensic consultant claiming that his signatures on the Ikrarnama were forged. In this regard, it is seen that neither the judicial order nor the appellate order in the case of sellers mention of any adversity about this Ikrarnama. Further, regarding issue of replying on photocopy of agreement, comma the Hon'ble Judge made no adverse reference about the issue of using the photocopy of agreement by the AO for making assessment. Further, the Hon'ble Civil Judge did not accept the appellant's request of making reference to the signature expert for verifying appellant's signature on the agreement. Moreover, it is possibility that such agreements may contain intentionally deviated signatures with a preconceived motive to claim denial of execution of such agreements after formal sale deed is registered and hence the contention raised is dismissed. The appellant has failed to discharge the burden of proof in the light of evidence regarding payment of excess cash. The source of which also remained unexplained and unsubstantiated with any supporting documentary evidence. It is not correct to state that no proper opportunity of being heard was given by the AO as it can be seen from the AO order that it is the appellant who was asked whether any complaint against forged signature was filed by the, but the same could not be replied with any cogent reply. And further, comma also failed to disclose the source of investment for purchase of agricultural land.”
We have gone through the facts entirety and noted that the agreement dated 14 August 2012 was referred by the assessee to the handwriting expert and handwriting expert has given his opinion which is reproduced in para 3 of this as aforesaid. Thus, wherein, the handwriting expert has categorically denied the handwriting of the assessee as depicted in the agreement. It means that it is established that the agreement is not signed by the assessee. Admittedly there is sale deed which is the registered document and which proves the sale consideration of Rs. 55,30,000 and half share of assessee comes to Rs. 27,65,000. The assessee from the beginning has denied very existence of agreement which has not been proved by the revenue as genuine document. Moreover, the Additional Civil Judge, Senior Division Siwani has clearly neither admitted the agreement dated 14th August 2012 nor denied because the plaint is not maintainable and the plaintiff (Gayatri Devi) has no locus standi. Hence the same was dismissed against the plaintiff and decided in favour of the defendants. One of the defendant is the assessee namely Shri Amit Kumar Aggarwal. It means the agreement dated 14 August 2012, on the basis of which the addition is made is not at all admitted. In terms of this, we find finding of the AO as well as Ld. CIT(A) are perverse on the issue of agreement dated 14 August 2012. Hence the evidence led by the assessee clearly speaks that the agreement dated 14 August 2012 has no evidentiary value. Hence, the same is not to be considered for the purpose of assessment. Therefore, the addition made by the AO and confirmed by the Ld. CIT(A) is liable to be deleted. We hold and direct accordingly. Thus, appeal of the assessee is allowed on merit.
As regards issue of jurisdiction that is assumption of jurisdiction by the AO for reopening under section 147 read with 148 and also the issue of notice under section 143(2) raised by the assessee have become academic for the reasons that we have already adjudicated the issue on merits as above and allowed the appeal of the assessee.
In the result, appeal of the assessee is allowed.
