AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
PER NAVEEN CHANDRA, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER :
This captioned appeal has been filed by the assessee against the order of the Learned Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals)- 26, Delhi dated 27.01.2026 arising out of the assessment order dated 20.03.2024 passed under section 153C r.w.s. 143(3) of the Income Tax Act, 1961(in short ‘the Act’) by the DCIT, Central Circle-15, New Delhi (hereinafter referred to as ‘Assessing Officer or AO’) for Assessment Year 2020-21.
Assessee has filed following grounds of appeal, which reads as under:
1.“The Ld. CIT(A) has erred on facts and in law in confirming the assessment order dated 20.03.2024 passed by the Ld. AO which was barred by limitation as per the provisions of section 153B of the Act.
2.The Ld. CIT(A) has erred on facts and in law in confirming the addition made by the AO in the assessment completed u/s 153C which were made without referring or relying or basing the same upon any seized incriminating document.
3.The Ld. CIT(A) has erred on facts and in law in dismissing the appellant’s appeal with regard to the grounds raised by the appellant against the initiation of the proceeding’s u/s 153C of the Act by the AO without following the law and procedure laid down u/s 153C of the Act which were illegal and unsustainable for various reasons including among others the following;
a. AO recorded the satisfaction note in the case of the searched person as well as the assessee in a mechanical manner;
b. AO stated the searched person to be Amar Sarin in the satisfaction note whereas at the same time recorded the PAN of searched person as AFEPG7593R and the name of the searched person is Sushen Mohan Gupta & Othrs. in proforma to the satisfaction note;
c. The AO recorded common satisfaction note for the assessment years 2014-15 to assessment years 2020-21 without identifying the specific documents having specific “bearing on the determination of the total income” of each assessment year independently.
d. The AO issued notice u/s 153C of the Income Tax Act much beyond the permissible time as prescribed in the CBDT circular no. 24/2015 [F. No.279/MISC/140/2015/ITJ] dated 31.12.2015 and the law laid down by the Supreme Court in the Calcutta Knitwears [2014] 43 taxmann.com 446(SC).
e. By recording the satisfaction note as the AO of the searched person on 20.05.2022 and recording the satisfaction note in the case of the assessee on 24.08.2022 as the AO of the assessee, even though both these satisfaction notes were drawn by the same AO.;
f. The AO provided copy of the satisfaction note towards the fag end of the assessment even though the same was requested for much earlier thereby depriving the assessee to challenge the assumption of jurisdiction u/s 153C.
4.The Ld. CIT(A) has erred on facts and in law in confirming the assessment order passed by the AO by relying the statement of Sh. Amar Sarin mentioned in the assessment order copy of which was never provided to the appellant leave alone providing an opportunity for cross examination of the aforesaid person. The assessment order passed by the AO was, therefore, in gross violation of principles of natural justice and for that reason deserves to be quashed.
5.The Ld. CIT(A) has erred on facts and in confirming the addition of Rs. 5,00,000/- made by the Ld. AO u/s 69A solely relying on the assumption made on the basis of whatsapp chat between searched person with appellant and the statement provided by the said searched person.
6.The Ld. CIT(A) has erred on facts and in law in confirming the addition of Rs.5,00,000/- made by the AO even though no such amount was stated in the purported whatsapp chats.
7.The Ld. CIT(A) has erred on facts and in confirming the addition of Rs. 5,00,000/- made u/s 69A of the Act by the AO without meeting the jurisdictional requirement for invocation of the aforesaid section as the appellant was not found to be owner of any unexplained asset as defined in section 69A of the Income Tax Act.
8.The appellant craves for liberty to add fresh ground(s) of appeal and also to amend, alter, modify any of the ground(s) of appeal.”
Brief facts of the case are that the assessee filed his return of income u/s 139 of Act on 04.03.2021 declaring total income of Rs. 53,82,770/-.
A Search & Seizure action u/s 132 of the Act was conducted on 02.01.2020 on Sushen Mohan Gupta & others (SMG Group)}. During the course of Search & Seizure proceedings, various incriminating information/documents (including digital data) pertaining to the assessee were found & seized. On examination of such incriminating documents, the AO of searched person, held that ‘it contains information pertaining to assessee (other person) & have bearing on determination of his income’ and handed over the documents to AO of assessee. Subsequently, the AO of assessee, after arriving at satisfaction that ‘the data/information/documents pertain to assessee and have a bearing on determination of his income’, initiated assessment proceedings in case of assessee by way of issuing notice u/s 153C of Act dated 24.08.2022. Consequently, the assessment u/s 153C r.w.s. 143(3) of the Act dated 20.03.2024 was completed at assessed income of Rs.58,82,770/-, after making additions of (i) Rs. 5,00,000/-on account of unexplained money u/s 69A of act on account of cash receipt.
Aggrieved by the order of the AO, assessee was in appeal before the ld. CIT(A). The ld. CIT(A) dismissed the appeal of the assessee.
Aggrieved by the order of the ld. CIT(A), assessee is now in appeal before us.
Before us, the ld. Counsel of the assessee has taken several legal grounds challenging the competition of assessment under section 153C of the Act. The grievance of the assessee is with regard to assessment being time barred, that is, the assessment made under section 153C of the Act dated 20.03.2024 is beyond the prescribed time as provided under first proviso to section 153B of the Act. Another grievance is that the satisfaction note is a common satisfaction note and is recorded in a mechanical manner and relies on
CIT(A) vs. Sunil Kumar Sharma [2024] 165 taxmann.com 846 (SC)
Saksham Commodities Ltd. vs. ITO [2024] 161 taxmann.com 485 (Delhi).
SRS Panchratan Diamonds Pvt. Ltd. vs. DCIT [ITA Nos. 218 & 219/Del/2023]
Vidur Chharia vs. DCIT [ITA No. 209/Del/2025] Dated 13.01.2026
JCIT(OSD) vs. Narendra Aggarwal [2026] 182 taxmann.com 443 (Delhi – Trib.)
ACIT vs. E-Homes Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. [ITA No.5260/Del/2025] Dated 25.02.2026
Rakesh Trisal vs. DCIT [ITA No.5760/Del/2025] (A.Y 2016-17) Dated 26.02.2026
3D Tradex Pvt. Ltd. vs. ADIT [ITA Nos. 2065 to 2070/Del/2022]
Another proposition is that notice under section 153C is unsustainable when search for other person initiated after 01.04.2021 and has relied on the following decisions :
Harigovind vs. ACIT [2025] 180 taxmann.com 197 (Madras)
Smt. Geetanjali Bhayana vs. DCIT (183 taxmann.com 95) Dated 27.01.2026
Shivdham Buildtech (P.) Ltd. vs. JCIT [2026]187 taxmann.com 1103 (Delhi – Trib.) Dated 24.06.2026
Lekh Raj vs. DCIT [2026] 187 taxmann.com 1104 (Delhi – Trib.)
Parvesh Kumar vs. DCIT [ITA No. 6911 & 6912/Del/2025] Dated 05.06.2026
Ambica Steels Limited vs. DCIT [ITA Nos.3050, 3051, 3052, 3053 and 3054/Del/2026; Date of Order : 17.07.2026]
Ashok Kumar Sethi vs. ACIT [ITA No. 4100/Del/2026; Date of order 29.07.2026]
Per contra, the ld DR relied on the orders of the AO and the CIT(A).
We have heard the rival submissions and have carefully perused the materials on record. We now deal with the legal objections raised by the assessee. Firstly, the ld AR raised the objection that assessment order dated 20.03.2024 passed by the Ld. AO was barred by limitation as per the provisions of section 153B of the Act. According to the ld. Counsel, the assessment under section 153C was required to be completed by 31st December 2023, however, the same was completed on 20.03.2024 which in violation of the provision of section 153B of the Act.
In the instant case, the facts are that the search u/s 132 of the Act on Sushen Mohan Gupta & others was conducted on 02.01.2020. The assessee being a person other than the searched person, was issued a notice u/s 153C of Act dated 24.08.2022 leading to the assessment being completed u/s 153C r.w.s. 143(3) of the Act on 20.03.2024. To adjudicate the issue of the said assessment being time barred, we find it prudent to narrate the provisions of section 153B of the Act as under:
Time limit for completion of assessment under section 153A.
153B. (1) Notwithstanding anything contained in section 153, the Assessing Officer shall make an order of assessment or reassessment,—
a)in respect of each assessment year falling within six assessment years and for the relevant assessment year or years referred to in clause (b) of sub-section (1) of section 153A, within a period of twenty-one months from the end of the financial year in which the last of the authorisations for search under section 132 or for requisition under section 132A was executed;
b)in respect of the assessment year relevant to the previous year in which search is conducted under section 132 or requisition is made under section 132A, within a period of twenty-one months from the end of the financial year in which the last of the authorisations for search under section 132 or for requisition under section 132A was executed:
Provided that in case of other person referred to in section 153C, the period of limitation for making the assessment or reassessment shall be the period as referred to in clause (a) or clause (b) of this sub-section or nine months from the end of the financial year in which books of account or documents or assets seized or requisitioned are handed over under section 153C to the Assessing Officer having jurisdiction over such other person, whichever is later:
***********
Provided also that in the case where the last of the authorisations for search under section 132 or for requisition under section 132A was executed during the financial year commencing on or after the 1st day of April, 2019,—
i)the provisions of clause (a) or clause (b) of this sub-section shall have effect, as if for the words "twenty-one months", the words "twelve months" had been substituted;
ii)the period of limitation for making the assessment or reassessment in case of other person referred to in section 153C, shall be the period of twelve months from the end of the financial year in which the last of the authorisations for search under section 132 or for requisition under section 132A was executed or twelve months from the end of the financial year in which books of account or documents or assets seized or requisitioned are handed over under section 153C to the Assessing Officer having jurisdiction over such other person, whichever is later:
********
A careful analysis of the provisions of law u/s 153B of the Act, shows that the assessee’s arguments deserves to be rejected. The law mandates two different dates for completion of assessment in cases of search. For assessee covered under the provision of section 153A, the law provides for limitation of twenty one months from the end of Financial year in which the last of the authorisation for search u/s 132 was executed. For assessee covered under the provisions of section 153C, the law provides for limitation of twenty one months from the end of Financial year in which the last of the authorisation for search u/s 132 was executed or nine months from the end of financial year in which books of account or documents or assets seized or requisitioned are handed over under section 153C to the Assessing Officer having jurisdiction over such other person, whichever is later. The law however, treats the prescribed time limit for searches taking place in Financial year 2019-20 differently. Under the provisions of the sub-clause (ii) of the 3rd proviso to section 153B of the Act, where search has taken place in FY 2019-20, in case of other person referred to in section 153C, the period of limitation for making the assessment or reassessment under shall be the period of twelve months from the end of financial year commencing on 01.04.2019 in which the last of the authorisation for search u/s 132 was executed or twelve months from the end of the financial year in which books of account or documents or assets seized or requisitioned are handed over under section 153C to the Assessing Officer having jurisdiction over such other person, whichever is later. In the instant case, the search u/s 132 took place on 02.01.2020, and there is no material placed before us to suggest that the last of the authorization took place beyond the financial year 2019-20. Therefore, twelve months from the end of the financial year, in which books of account or documents or assets seized or requisitioned are handed over under section 153C, is to be computed. The notice u/s 153C was issued on 24.08.2022, hence the presumption is that books of account or documents or assets seized, was handed over to the AO of the non-searched person i.e., the assessee on 24.08.2022 which is FY 2022-23. Computing twelve months from the end of FY 2022-23, i.e., 31.03.2023, gives the limitation date of 31.03.2024 for completion of assessment in the case of the assessee. In the given facts of the instant case, the assessment under section 153C was to be completed by 31.03.2024. As the assessment under section 153C was made on 20.03.2024, we are therefore of the considered view that under the 3rd proviso to section 153B of the Act, the assessment completed on 20.03.2024 is considered as within the prescribed time. Ground 1 dismissed.
The ground 2 and 3 objects that the satisfaction note by the AO, in the case of the searched person as well as the assessee, a non-searched person, was mechanically recorded and that the AO recorded common satisfaction note for the assessment years 2014-15 to assessment years 2020-21 without identifying the specific documents having specific “bearing on the determination of the total income” of each assessment year independently. To adjudicate the issues, it would be relevant to reproduce the Satisfaction note recorded by the AO as under:
Proforma for recording of satisfaction about seized assets/documents pertaining to person other than the person searched [to be filled in by the Assessing Officer of searched person(s)]
1. Name of the Group, if any, searched Sushen Mohan Gupta & others (SMG Group), D.O. S. 02.01.2020 2. Name of the assessee in whose case Assets (money, bullion, jewellery or other valuable article or things) or documents seized u/s 132 requisitioned u/s 132A of the Act. Sushen Mohan Gupta & others 3. PAN of searched person AFEPG7593R 4. Name and address of the person to whom seized assets/papers as in(2) above pertain Aman Sarin, H-65, Connaught Circus, Delhi. 5. PAN of other person AAKPS7323J 6. Identification of seized assets/papers which in the opinion of the AO of the searched person(S.No.2) pertain to the other person(S.No.4). During the course of search at the above premises of Sh. Amar Sarin, certain digital data of mobile phone having details pertaining to Aman Sarin was found and seized in hard disk drive at Sr no. 1 of Annexure-A-1 to the Panchanama dated 03-01-2020 details of which are given in the Annexure to this proforma. 7(i). Details of Panchnama and annexure through which the relevant asset/ document was seized/requisitioned Sr. no. 1 of Annexure-A-1 to the Panchanama dated 03-01-2020 7(ii). Address of the place/premises from where asset/paper was seized/ impounded H-65, Connaught Circus, Delhi. 7(iii). Brief reasons on the basis of which the AO of the searched person reached to the conclusion that the relevant seized asset/paper pertains to the other person(use annexure, if required). On review of data of mobile phone of Amar Sarin some Whatsapp messages were observed of communication with Aman Sarin containing references made to 'chocolate' or 'chocolates' which prima facie appeared to be out of context in the general application of the word and signify unaccounted financial transaction. These chats were with Aman Sarin as confirmed on oath by Mr. Amar Sarin in his statement recorded. 8. Assessment years involved 2014-15 to 2020-21 Dated 20.05.2022
(Mohit Garg)
Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax Central Circle-15, New Delhi.
Annexure to the Performa for Recording Satisfaction in the case of Aman Sarin by the Assessing Officer of searched person.
1.A search and seizure operation under section 132 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 was conducted in one office premise of Amar Sarin as part of Sushan Mohan Gupta & others (SMG Group) on 02.01.2020 at H-65, Connaught Circus, Delhi. These office premises belonged to Amar Sarin, Anil Sarin, father of Amar Sareen and Sunaini Gupta, sister of Amar Sareen. Digital data of the electronic devices was seized in a Hard Disc which included the mobile phone of Sh. Amar Sarin.
2.During the ESI review of the electronic backup of Amar Sarin's mobile phone, numerous Whatsapp messages were observed containing references made to "chocolate" or "chocolates", which prima facie appeared to be out of context in the general application of the word. Relevant data is reproduced below:
b. Aman Sarin
Message ID Direction Remote party Name Time (UTC) Content 133941 Outgoing message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 25-06-2019 12:08 Do you need any chocolates? 133942 Incoming message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 25-06-2019 12:09 Can , but will do Rigs after 10-12 days 133944 Outgoing message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 25-06-2019 12:10 Like 133946 Outgoing message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 25-06-2019 12:11 Please let me know when the RTGS is ready 133947 Outgoing message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 25-06-2019 12:11 Will do it then 133948 Incoming message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 25-06-2019 12:11 Ok 137615 Incoming message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 04-07-2019 07:42 Also the chocolates pls 137616 Outgoing message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 04-07-2019 07:43 Ok 138181 Incoming message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 05-07-2019 05:35 Who will coordinate the chocolates 138184 Outgoing message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 05-07-2019 05:40 I will 138187 Incoming message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 05-07-2019 05:41 K , let me know 138285 Incoming message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 05-07-2019 06:51 Chocolate 138288 Outgoing message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 05-07-2019 06:52 Unreal 138637 Outgoing message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 05-07-2019 12:47 Before you start sir the chocolates will be available at 7pm on Monday. 138646 Incoming message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 05-07-2019 13:03 Like 139972 Incoming message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 06-07-2019 12:33 Chocolates *
210046 Outgoing message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 29-11-2019 16:15 Hello, You need any dark chocolates? 210057 Incoming message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 29-11-2019 16:39 Hello - Ok. 210058 Incoming message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 29-11-2019 16:40 Will let you know by Tom Morning 210059 Outgoing message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 29-11-2019 16:40 Ok ☺ 210330 Incoming message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 30-11-2019 09:29 Can you do 2 chocolates 210335 Outgoing message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 30-11-2019 09:37 Let me check
210336 Outgoing message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 30-11-2019 09:38 I can do 5 on Wednesday 210337 Incoming message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 30-11-2019 09:38 Whatever you can do today, Rest Wednesday ok 210338 Outgoing message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 30-11-2019 09:40 Ok getting back Just so we clear this is not to be adjusted against any account ☺ 210340 Incoming message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 30-11-2019 09:41 Yes Sir, ok ☺ 210341 Incoming message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 30-11-2019 09:41 Will take that on Monday separately 210342 Outgoing message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 30-11-2019 09:41 ok 2.1Further, Statement of Amar Sarin was recorded on oath u/s 131(1A) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 dated 24.02.2021. vide the said statement he was confronted with the above-mentioned whats app chats done by him with Aman Sarin wherein the term chocolate is mentioned. In response to the same he stated that the term chocolate refers to Rs. 1 lac in cash when he chats with Aman Sarin.
3.After examining the documents I am satisfied that the above referred seized documents and information contained therein pertain to Aman Sarin (PAN: AAKPS7323J), person other than the searched person and have a bearing on the determination of the income of Aman Sarin(PAN: AAKPS7323J). I am further satisfied that action u/s 153C of the Act is required to be taken in the case of Aman Sarin(PAN: AAKPS7323J). Accordingly, the above seized material are being handed over with this satisfaction note to the AO holding the jurisdiction over the case of Aman Sarin(PAN: AAKPS7323J) for taking action u/s 153C r.w.s 153A of the I.T. Act, 1961.
(Mohit Garg)
Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax Central Circle-15, New Delhi.
Satisfaction note for initiating proceedings under Section 153C read with Section 153A of the Income Tax Act,1961 in the case of Aman Sarin (PAN AAKPS7323J) – Assessment years 2014-15 to 2020-21.
Action under section 132 of the Income Tax Act was carried out in Sushen Mohan Gupta & others (SMG Group by the Investigation Wing, New Delhi on 02.01.2020. The AO of Sushen Mohan Gupta, in whose cases action under section 132 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 was carried out, recorded his satisfaction that the referred seized documents, seized in the case of searched person, pertain to and information contained therein relates to Aman Sarin(PAN: AAKPS7323J), the person other than the searched person. The Assessing Officer of the searched person (undersigned is the AO of persons searched as well as other person) has recorded his satisfaction dated 20.05.2022 and handed over the following seized material to the AO of the other person i.e. the AO of the assessee Aman Sarin.:
(i)ESI review of the electronic backup of Amar Sarin's mobile phone wherein Whatsapp messages were observed containing references made to "chocolate" or "chocolates".
2.As per the satisfaction note recorded by the AO of the searched person, the above documents pertains to Aman Sarin. The satisfaction note recorded by the AO of the person searched has been placed on record. As the AO of the person other than searched person, I have examined the above referred seized material and the contents of the same. The details are as below:
2.1During the ESI review of the electronic backup of Amar Sarin's mobile phone, numerous Whatsapp messages were observed containing references made to "chocolate" or "chocolates", which prima facie appeared to be out of context in the general application of the word. Relevant data is reproduced below:
b. Aman Sarin
Message ID Direction Reason party Name Time (UTC) Content 133941 Outgoing message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 25-06-2019 12:08 Do you need any chocolates? 133942 Incoming message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 25-06-2019 12:09 Can, but will do Rigs after 10-12 days 133944 Outgoing message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 25-06-2019 12:10 133946 Outgoing message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 25-06-2019 12:11 Please let me know when the RTGS is ready. 133947 Outgoing message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 25-06-2019 12:11 Will do it then 133948 Incoming message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 25-06-2019 12:11 Ok 137615 Incoming message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 04-07-2019 07:42 Also the chocolates pls 137616 Outgoing message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 04-07-2019 07:43 Ok 138181 Incoming message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 05-07-2019 05:38 Who will coordinate the chocolates 138184 Outgoing message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 05-07-2019 05:40 I will 138187 Incoming message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 05-07-2019 05:41 K, let me know 138285 Incoming message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 05-07-2019 06:51 Chocolate 138288 Outgoing message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 05-07-2019 06:52 Unreal 138637 Outgoing message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 05-07-2019 12:47 Before you start sir the chocolates will be available at 7pm on Monday. 138646 Incoming message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 05-07-2019 13:03 139972 Incoming message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 08-07-2019 12:33 Chocolates ?
210046 Outgoing message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 29-11-2019 16:15 Hello. You need any dark chocolates? 210057 Incoming message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 29-11-2019 16:39 Hello - Ok. 210058 Incoming message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 29-11-2019 16:40 Will let you know by Tom Morning 210059 Outgoing message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 29-11-2019 16:40 Ok 210330 Incoming message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 30-11-2019 09:29 Can you do 2 chocolates 210335 Outgoing message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 30-11-2019 09:37 Let me check
210336 Outgoing message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 30-11-2019 09:38 I can do 5 on Wednesday 210337 Incoming message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 30-11-2019 09:38 Whatever you can do today, Rest Wednesday ok 210338 Outgoing message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 30-11-2019 09:40 Ok getting back. Just so we clear this is not to be adjusted against any account 210340 Incoming message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 30-11-2019 09:41 Yes Sir, ok 210341 Incoming message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 30-11-2019 09:41 Will take that on Monday separately 210342 Outgoing message 919810124005 Aman Bhai 30-11-2019 09:41 2.2Further, Statement of Amar Sarin was recorded on oath u/s 131(1A) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 dated 24.02.2021 vide the said statement he was confronted with the above-mentioned whats app chats done by him with Dhruv Bhasin and Aman Sarin wherein the term chocolate is mentioned. In response to the same he stated that the
We note that the author of the Satisfaction note of searched and non-searched person are same. The perusal of the Satisfaction note by the AO of the searched person as well as the non-searched person shows that the Ld AO has recorded, in the proforma, the name of the person searched as Sushen Mohan Gupta & Others (SMG Group) having PAN as AFEPG7593R and the name of the person to whom the seized documents pertain to, as Aman Sarin having PAN as AAKPS7323J. We also note that the seized documents show that all the entries of the whatsapp messages bear the time stamp for FY 2019-20 relevant to AY 2020-21. The Ld AO has referred to the seized materials and has recorded that the information contained therein relates to the assessee and has a “bearing on the determination of the income of the assessee”. We therefore are of the considered view that the assessee has failed to demonstrate that the satisfaction note is mechanically recorded. Further, we note that though the AO has recorded a consolidated satisfaction note for AY 2014-15 to AY 2020-21, the seized documents, referred to in the satisfaction note, have specific reference of incriminating material pertaining to AY 2020-21 only and no other AYs are involved. Furthermore, the hon’ble Delhi Court in the case of Indian National Congress v. DCIT reported in 463 ITR 431(Del) has held that consolidated or "common" satisfaction notes under Section 153C of the Income-tax Act, 1961, is permissible under Section 153C of the Income-tax Act as the provisions of law does not mandate independent or separate satisfaction notes for each assessment year as long as the note sufficiently references incriminating material for the block of years as a whole. Accordingly, ground 2 and 3 are dismissed.
As far as the grievance in ground 4 is concerned regarding opportunity to cross examination of Amar Sarin is concerned, we find that there is no evidence or any materials placed before us to show that the assessee had asked or requested the Ld AO for cross examination of Amar Sarin. It is pertinent to mention that the ld AO gave the assessee opportunities by way of show cause notices dated 01.03.2024 and 12.03.2024 to explain the seized/incriminating materials. We also note that the assessee was supplied the statement of Amar Sarin on 23.01.2024, yet the assessee failed to ask for a cross examination. We therefore are of the view that raising a grievance of cross examination at this stage, has no relevance. Ground 4 is accordingly dismissed.
Another objection of the assessee that notice under section 153C dated 24.08.2022 is unsustainable on the ground that the search for other person i.e., the assessee, was initiated after 01.04.2021. It is the claim of the assessee that the documents were handed over to the ld AO of the assessee on 24.08.2022, the date of recording satisfaction note, and therefore according to the 1st proviso of section 153C(1), the reference to date of search would be construed as reference to the date of receiving the books of accounts or document by the AO of the non-searched person. Since the books of account and documents were received on 24.08.2022, the same would be the date of search and applying the provisions of section 153C(3), no assessment can be made on the assessee u/s 153C of the Act. The ld AR has relied on various decisions of High Court and Tribunals. The foremost reliance is on the Madras High Court decision in the case of Harigovind vs. ACIT ((2026) 485 ITR 509 (Mad) wherein the single bench of Madras High Court quashed the Section 153C notices issued on 07.02.2023, holding that under Section 153C(3), the provisions are barred for searches/receipt of seized materials falling on or after 01.04.2021. This decision was followed by the Tribunals in the case of Smt. Geetanjali Bhayana vs. DCIT; Parvesh Kumar vs. DCIT; Ambica Steels Limited vs. DCIT; Ashok Kumar Sethi vs. ACIT. The decision in Shivdham Buildtech (P.) Ltd. vs. JCIT and Lekh Raj vs. DCIT has followed Hon'ble Jurisdictional High Court in the case of Ojjus Medicare(P) Ltd.
We further note that the Income Tax Department filed an appeal (WA/1481/2026) against the single-judge order. The Division Bench of hon’ble Madras High Court, granted an interim stay of the operative order dated October 28, 2025, and directed both parties to maintain status quo regarding the assessment proceedings. In such factual matrix, since the decision of single judge bench of hon’ble Madras High Court has been stayed by a larger bench of the same High Court, the Tribunal decisions following the same can be considered as stayed.
On the issue of date of search, for the purposes of section 153C, it would be relevant to narrate the provisions of section 153C(3) w.e.f. 01.04.2021 as follows:
(3)Nothing contained in this section shall apply in relation to a search initiated under section 132 or books of account, other documents or any assets requisitioned under section 132A on or after the 1st day of April, 2021.
We find that unlike the 1st proviso to section 153C(1), section 153C(3) does not use the term ‘construe’ or ‘reference’. To our mind, the provisions of section 153C(3) do not create a legal fiction. It unambiguously proscribes the application of section 153C in cases where search have been initiated u/s 132 on or after 01.04.2021.
As far as the 1st proviso to section 153C(1) is concerned, the hon’ble Supreme Court of India in CIT V Jasjit Singh on 26 September, 2023 had analysed it to hold that the 1st proviso is for the purposes of reckoning the date from which the six year period is to be calculated as follows:
“9.It is evident on a plain interpretation of Section 153C(1) that the Parliamentary intent to enact the proviso was to cater not merely to the question of abatement but also with regard to the date from which the six year period was to be reckoned, in respect of which the returns were to be filed by the third party (whose premises are not searched and in respect of whom the specific provision under Section 153-C was enacted”.
Similarly, the Hon’ble Delhi Court in PCIT vs Ojjus Medicare Pvt. Ltd. on 3 April, 2024, held that 1st proviso to section 153C creates a legal fiction to be considered for computing the six year block as follows:
“D. The First Proviso to Section 153C introduces a legal fiction on the basis of which the commencement date for computation of the six year or the ten year block is deemed to be the date of receipt of books of accounts by the jurisdictional AO. The identification of the starting block for the purposes of computation of the six and the ten year period is governed by the First Proviso to Section 153C, which significantly shifts the reference point spoken of in Section 153A(1), while defining the point from which the period of the "relevant assessment year" is to be calculated, to the date of receipt of the books of accounts, documents or assets seized by the jurisdictional AO of the non- searched person”.
We are of the considered view that neither the hon’ble Supreme Court nor the hon’ble Delhi Court in the above cases, were dealing with the interpretation of the provisions of section 153C(3) of the Act. To our mind, no legal or deeming fiction is created in the provisions of section 153C(3) with regard to date of search initiated u/s 132 of the Act. In the instant case, the search, on the basis of which proceedings u/s 153C of the Act was initiated on the assessee, was initiated on 02.01.2020, hence there is no application of the provisions of section 153C(3) of the Act in the case of the assessee. This ground is therefore dismissed.
On merits, the assessee has raised the grievance in ground 9 that the AO invoked the provisions of section 69A without meeting the requirement of section 69A. The ld AR argued that Section 69A can be applied only in the case if the assessee is found to be the owner of money, bullion, jewellery and any other valuable asset. It is submitted that there was no discovery of any money, bullion, jewellery or any other valuable asset of like nature as stipulated in section 69A of the Income Tax Act and the AO never alleged that the assessee is owner of the money. The assessee relied on the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of M/s D.N Singh Vs. CIT, Central 1023 LiveLaw (SC) 451 dated 16.05.2023 in the context of section 69A of the Act.
We find that in the instant case, the AO made addition of Rs 5 lakh u/s 69A on the strength of whatsapp message from Amar Sarin to the assessee. We agree with the assessee that deeming provisions under section 69A can be applied only in the case if the assessee is found to be the owner of money, bullion, jewellery and any other valuable asset and it is settled law that to invoke deeming provisions in the Income Tax Act, no presumptions can be made regarding the existence of the essential conditions within the deeming provisions. We note, in the instant case, it is admitted fact that no money was found on the assessee. It is also not controverted by the Revenue that there is any finding of the AO showing the assessee as “owner” of the money. We are therefore of the considered view that the mandatory requirements of section 69A is not fulfilled in the instant case. Following the decision of the hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of M/s D.N Singh Vs. CIT, Central (supra), we hold that since the ingredients of section 69A is not satisfied, no additions can be made in the case of the assessee and accordingly we direct the AO to delete the said addition. Ground 9 is allowed.
In the result, appeal filed by the assessee in ITA No.3073/Del/2026 is partly allowed.
