AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
PER MANISH AGARWAL, AM :
The captioned appeal is filed by the Revenue against the order dated 15.03.2011 passed by Ld. Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeal)-XVI, New Delhi [“CIT(A)”, in short] passed u/s 250 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 [“the Act”] arising from the assessment order dated 31.12.2010 passed u/s 143(3) of the Act pertaining to Assessment Year 2007-08.
Brief facts of the case are that assessee is a company and e-filed its return of income on 30.08.2007, declaring total income of INR 1,45,48,453/-. The said return was revised on 20.08.2008, declaring the same income as was declared the return of income filed u/s 139(1). The case of the assessee was selected for scrutiny and various queries were raised which were replied by the assessee. The assessee is engaged in the business of development and export of software and 100% EOU registered with Director Software Technology Park of India in terms of registration certificate dated 31.03.1999. The major shareholder in the assessee company is Shri Anil Gutpa who is having 99% shareholding and is taking substantial interest in day-to-day affairs of the assessee and also in its Associate Enterprises (“AE”) at US who is the sole buyer of the software developed by the assessee.
During the year under appeal, assessee has shown net profit @ 80% and claimed deduction u/s 10A of the Act. The AO based on the Schedule 12 to the financial accounts wherein INR 49,33,50,421/- was shown as “Arbitration Award” held that this award is not the software sales and excluded the same from the claim of exemption u/s 10A of the Act and further, denied the exemption u/s 10A of the Act on the gain on account of currency fluctuation of INR 1,23,33,934/- by holding the same being not earned from the eligible business.
Besides this, AO made the disallowance of INR 3,55,47,260/-by invoking the provision of section 40(a)(ia) of the Act as the assessee has deducted 10% TDS on buy back of shares which as per AO should be 20%. Thus, he made the disallowance of the proportionate payment without TDS. Accordingly, the total income of the assessee was assessed at INR 49,74,14,740/-.
Against the said order, assessee preferred appeal before Ld.CIT(A) who vide impugned order dated 15.03.2011, after providing the opportunities to the assessee and to the AO on his request, had allowed the appeal of the assessee wherein the additions made as well as disallowance made were deleted.
Aggrieved by the said order of Ld.CIT(A), Revenue is in appeal before the Tribunal wherein Revenue has taken following grounds of appeal :-
1.“That on the facts and circumstances and in law, the Ld. CIT(A) erred in accepting the assessee's explanation that arbitration award of Rs. 43.49 crores was in the nature of sale of source code of software and not arbitration award without any evidence. The Ld. CIT(A) accepted the assessee's explanation that there was a "Typographical Error" in the accounts. The CIT(A) failed to note that in "Notes to Accounts" of the Balance Sheet for the period pertaining to A.Y. 2007-08 and also earlier A.Y. 2006-07, this was specifically disclosed by the Auditor of the firm.
2.The Ld. CIT(A) failed to appreciate that arbitration award was not eligible income for claiming exemption u/s. 10A of the I.T. Act.
3.Without prejudice to the fact that Rs. 43.49 crores was in the nature of arbitration award and hence, not eligible for deduction u/s/10A, the Ld. CIT(A) even while holding Rs. 43.49 crores was sale of source code erred in allowing exemption on receipts arising on account of sale of source code of software developed over a period of time, ignoring the fact that sale of source code represents parting of long-term capital gains and as such, not entitled for exemption u/s. 10A.
4.Alternate Plea
(a)That on the facts and circumstances of the case and in law, the Ld. CIT(A) erred in holding that extraordinary percentage of NP ratio of 87% was on account of sale of source code of software developed over a period of time despite there being no evidence.
(b)The Ld. CIT(A) has grossly erred in accepting an extraordinarily high NP ratio of 87% (particularly where 100% profits are claimed exempt) against the provisions of Sub-section 10 of Section 801A when the assessee had failed to prove by adducing necessary evidence that the sale proceeds of alleged source code and the income therefrom were eligible for deduction u/s. 10A.
(c)That on the facts and circumstances of the case and in law, the Ld. CIT(A) erred in holding that invoking of Section 10A(7), for allocating the cost of services rendered by Dr. Anil Gupta was without sufficient evidence despite there being extraordinary percentage of NP ratio of 87%. Dr. Anil Gupta happens to be major shareholder of the company (99%) and proprietor of CAE Solution, USA to which entire sales are being made.
(d)Was the Ld. CIT(A) justified in allowing extraordinary amount of deduct ion of Rs. 43.49 crores without the assessee discharging the onus that the profit so claimed were genuine and not extraordinary giving assessee all the benefits of doubt. when the onus was fully & squared on the assessee to prove that the extraordinary profits were genuine & eligible for deduction u/s. 10A.
5.That on the facts and circumstances of the case and in law, the Ld. CIT(A) erred in holding that foreign exchange fluctuation gain is a business receipts and eligible for exemption u/s. 10A.
6.That on the facts and circumstances of the case and in law, the Ld. CIT(A) erred in deleting the addition made by the AO on the basis of the TDS deducted by the assessee on buy back of shares from Dr. Anil Gupta @10% instead of applicable TDS rate on long-term capital gain @20% under Section 40(a) (i) read with Section 195 of the Act and not appreciating that the nature of income in the hands of Dr. Anil Gupta, NRI.
7.The appellant craves to be allowed to add any fresh grounds of appeal and/or delete or amend any of the grounds of appeal.”
Ground of appeal Nos.1 to 4 raised by the Revenue are with respect to the addition of INR 43.49 crores by denying the exemption claimed u/s 10A of the Act on this amount by alleging that the assessee itself had shown the same as “Arbitration Award” in the final accounts and thus it is not the sale of software. Further in Ground of appeal No.4 assessee challenged the observations that the assessee has shown extra ordinary profit rate of 87% to claim higher amount as exempt and consequent profits in the hands of the AEs were shown at a lower rate.
Since all these grounds are inter-linked and inter-related, they are taken together for consideration.
Before us, Ld.CIT DR for the Revenue submits that the assessee has shown an amount of INR 43.49 crores as “Arbitration Award” in Schedule 12 of the Financial Statements which is reproduced by AO at page 6 of assessment order wherein under the title “transaction with related party,” sale of software was shown at INR 12,86,24,629/- and “Arbitration Award” at INR 43,49,83,092/-. Ld. CIT DR submits that claim of the assessee that it is a “typographical error” cannot be accepted as no evidences were filed in support of the claim. Further, if the amount of “Arbitration Award” is reduced from the amount of net profit, the resultant net profit reduced to 12.59% only as against 87% shown by including the same as part of the gross receipts and net profits. Ld. CIT DR further submits that the assessee is making 100% export to only one concern namely M/s CAE Solutions Corp., USA whose proprietor is Shri Anil Gupta who is having 99% shareholding in the assessee’s company and thus such entity is Associate Enterprises of the assessee. He submits that assessee has not paid any remuneration whatsoever with respect to the services rendered by Shri Anil Gupta which clearly proved that by not recording any expenses on account of services rendered by Shri Anil Gupta, the assessee had tried to inflate its profits. Ld.CIT DR further submits that during the year under appeal, assessee company has buy back its 471 equity shares and paid a sum of INR 7,10,94,521/- which incidentally were bought from Shri Anil Gupta thus, by doing so, assessee has transferred its tax free income in the hands of Shri Anil Gupta which further proves that it is a device developed to transfer the profits on which exemption was claimed in the hands of the assessee company to Shri Anil Gupta. Ld.CIT DR further placed reliance on the submissions made in this regard which reads as under:-
Chronology of events
Assessment order u/s 143(3) was passed on 31.12.2010.
CIT(A) deleted all the additions made by AO vide his order dt. 15.03.2011.
Revenue filed appeal on 29.07.2011 before ITAT and assessee filed cross-objections on 11.09.2011.
In the meantime, notice u/s 147/148 dt.29.03.2012 was issued to assessee for AY 2007-08 and against this, assessee filed writ petition dt.29.10.2013 and in turn, Hon'ble HC quashed the re-assessment notice.
CIT passed order dt. 28.03.2013 u/s 263, setting aside the original assessment order u/s 143(3), directing for fresh assessment.
Thereafter, the assessment was completed u/s 263/143(3) vide order dt.31.03.2014, withdrawing the exemption of Rs.5,79,07,329/- claimed u/s 10A which was earlier allowed in original assessment order, holding that assessee failed to discharge its onus of proving its claim for deduction u/s 10A.
However, ITAT Delhi Bench set aside the said order passed u/s 263 vide order dt 27.12.2018.
Further, Delhi HC vide order 27.02.2024 dismissed the appeal of revenue (ITA 171/2022)against above-mentioned order of ITAT Delhi on the ground that there is no substantial question of law raised.
Additions made by A.O. and findings thereof:
1.Exemption claimed u/s 10A for arbitration award i.e. Rs.43,49,83,092/-withdrawn
Assessee submitted that it has passed on source code of software so developed over a period of time during last 7 to 8 years to its clients. No supportive document/agreement was provided. (Para 4.12, Pg 5)
As disclosed in para 10 of schedule 12 of financial statements under transactions with related party i.e. CAE Solution Inc., sale of software amounts to Rs. 12,86,24,629/- & Arbitration Award amounts to Rs.43,49,83,092/-(Para 4.14, Pg 5-6)
Computing NP ratio after deducting amount of arbitration award (which is not sale/export of software and thus, would not qualify for exemption u/s 10A) from declared NP of Rs.50.59 crore, NP ratio comes at 12.59% which is very much comparable with NP ratio declared in preceding years. It shows that the assessee has deliberately tried to present incorrect facts of export turnover to avoid tax liability. (Para 4.15 & 4.16, Pg 6)
Assessee did not file the balance sheet and P&L A/c of CAE Solutions Inc., USA. Looking at the close connection between the 2 entities, it appeared that assessee was showing entire profit in Indian company and claiming it to be exempt.(Para 4.11, Pg 4-5)
It was also observed that Mr. Anil Gupta does all the marketing at USA and gives his entire inputs for development of software without any consideration. (Pg 5)
In view of the foregoing, exemption claimed u/s 10A for arbitration award of Rs.43,49,83,092/- was withdrawn by AO. (Pg 6).
Findings of CIT(A)
* AO has accepted NP of 80% in immediately preceding year i.e. AY 06-07 without any adverse finding. (Pg 23)
* No transfer pricing adjustment was made by TPO. (Pg 23)
* No defect in the valuation report of sharesdt.01.12.06 was pointed out by AO. (Pg 24)
* "Arbitration Award" as mentioned in notes to accounts is on account of "typographical error" which is also proved by perusal of all the documents filed by assessee, report of TPO and report u/s 10A from auditors filed along with the return of assessee. (Pg 31)
* Arbitration award represents value of source code supplied by company to its associate enterprise and source code is nothing but part and parcel of computer software as defined in Sec 10A. (Pg 32)
* AO disallowed the deduction without any corroborative evidence. (Pg 33)
Conclusion:
Decision of CIT(A),deleting the disallowance of deduction claimed u/s 10A of Rs. 43,49,83,092/-, is perverse since:
* The said amount represents "arbitration award" which the assessee has disclosed itself in the notes to accounts and as such, the same cannot be interpreted as a mere "typographical error" in the accounts.
* No amount against item "arbitration award" is shown in immediately preceding year i.e. AY 2006-07 and thus, contention of CIT(A) that NP ratio of 80% was admitted by AO in AY 2006-07 without any adverse finding lacks the similarity of the facts in both the years and thus, equating the year under consideration i.e. AY 2007-08 with AY 2006-07 is not tenable.
* Further, even if the arbitration award is treated as sale of source code of software developed over a period of time, the same should not be allowed as deduction u/s 10A as sale of source code represents parting of long-term capital gains and as such, not entitled for exemption u/s 10A.
On the other hand, Ld.AR for the assessee vehemently supported the order of Ld.CIT(A) and submits that during the course of assessment proceedings, AO has never asked any questions about the “Arbitration Award” shown in Profit & Loss Account. He further submits that during the course of appellate proceedings on the request of the AO, the opportunity of hearing was provided by Ld.CIT(A) to the AO and a detailed submission was made by the AO on the submissions filed by the assessee. Ld. Ar further submits that assessee had filed rebuttal to the AO’s observations made during the appellate proceedings. All these submissions are reproduced in para 3. 7 of the appellate order. He further submits that Ld. CIT(A) after considering these facts, deleted the additions and further allowed the exemption u/s 10A on the entire profits declared by the assessee. He further placed reliance on the submissions made before us which reads as under:-
GROUND NO. 1 & 2 These ground relates to the allowance of Rs. 43.49 Crores claimed u/s 10A allowed by Ld. CIT (A) which was disallowed by Ld. AO.
Ld. A.O. has discussed this issue in Para 4 at Page 2-7 of the Assessment Order whereas Ld. CIT (A) has discussed this issue in Para 3 from Page 5 to 33 of the Appeal Order. (Pg 5-7 WS) (Pg 7-12 Adverse obs of AO met) (Pg 13-22 Remand Report & RE rej) (Pg 22-33 CIT(A) finding)
PB 1—15 is written submissions before Ld. CIT (A) submitting that assessee company is exporting software exclusively to its AE and was subject to transfer pricing law on year to year basis and that assessment proceedings for last three years were completed u/s 143(3) after considering TPO's report without any adverse finding and that the impugned income was derived from software business.
Contention of the Department is that it was Arbitration award and such was so reflected in the Balance Sheets for A.Y. 2006-07 and 2007-08 and it being Arbitration award was not eligible for deduction u/s. 10A.
In fact case of the Assessee is that it was not Arbitration award but was income derived from the software business only & was eligible to deduction u/s 10A.
PB 12 - 14 are the submissions before Ld. CIT (A) submitting that no question was asked by AO during assessment proceedings regarding this typographical error (PB 51) as would be evident from para 4.14 to 4.20 of the assessment order and vide PB 348 - 350, 351 - 353 and vide PB DPB Pg 5c being show cause on 14.12.2010 and further that it was typographical error in the Balance Sheet (PB 51) and in fact this was on account of export of Software Source Code.
It was further submitted that PB 43 would show that it was software sales only which was so stated on Affidavit of the Director at PB 193.
It was further submitted that following documents including return with STPI authorities endorsing the copies of relevant invoices were filed before Ld. AO which clearly mention the subject amount as Computer Software sale.
PB 27 - 30 is CA Certificate in Form 3CEB (Report from an accountant to be furnished u/s. 92E relating to international transactions) certifying export turnover as per clause 8B - b & c filed with ITR.
PB 31 - 33 Form no. 56F (Report u/s. 10A of Income Tax Act, 1961), confirming the export turnover at Rs.56,36,07,721/- as per para 15 b of Annexure 15 b of Annexure - A, certified by the CA filed with ITR.
PB 196 - 321 Copy of SOFTEX form filed and accepted by STPI confirming sale of software submitted before AO vide letter dated 10.12.2010 along with photocopies of all sale invoices.
PB 322 - 329 are the copies of FIRC confirming advance receipt against export sales filed before Ld. AO vide letter dated ...12.2010.
PB 114 - 118 is the order u/s 92CA(3) dated 30.06.2010.
Therefore, it was not Arbitration award as contended in the departmental grounds of appeal and this fact was correctly appreciated by Ld. CIT (A) and there is no infirmity in the order of Ld. CIT (A).
It is wrong to mention that last year's balance sheet (PB 65-109) showed some arbitration award.
GROUND NO. 3: It relates to the grievance of the Revenue that even if it was sale of Software Source Code then also it should give rise to Long Term Capital Gain which is not entitled for exemption u/s 10A.
First it is submitted that section 10A does not refer at all that it should be income under the head "business". The expression used in section 10A "profits derived" which means that it should be profit which must have direct, proximate and inextricable link with undertaking. Section 10A does not use the expression "profits under the head "business" which expression has been used in section 80HHC and 80HHE etc.
Therefore it is clear that legislature has not used the expression “profits” in section 10A to mean “profits under the head “business”.
Hon’ble Tribunal in the under noted decisions has also held that in section 72 also “profits and gains of business” does not mean “income under the head business” and therefore, it was held in that case that if there is Short Term Capital Gain which was in the nature of “profits and gains from the business” it would be available to for set off of Brought Forward Business Losses.
Digital Electronics Ltd. Vs. Addl. CIT 49 DTR 484 / 135 TTJ 419 (Mum)
Sri Padmavati Srinivasa Cotton Ginning and Pressing Factory Vs. DCIT 125 TTJ 411 / 29 DTR 1(Vishakha)
Following the same analogy and presuming what Revenue has said in Ground No. 3 as correct yet it is submitted that sale of Computer Software Source Code is profits derived from the undertaking and would qualify for deduction u/s 10A.
There cannot be any dispute that assessee being in the Software Development Business and transfer of Software Source Code is the profit derived such profits from the undertaking.
Reliance:
Sodhan Technology KP 17A 2546/Eang/2019 dt 16.3.22
Without prejudice to above, even such is treated as capital asset, then in that case also, nothing is chargeable to tax as capital gain because of non determination of cost of acquisition and in view of decision of Hon'ble Supreme court in the case of B.C. Srinivas Shetty vs CIT 128 ITR 294(SC)
GROUND NO. 4: This ground relates to the action of Ld. CIT (A) in allowing the relief u/s. 10A despite the alleged abnormal not profit of 80%.
It is respectfully submitted that the appellant company is engaged in the export of computer software and web enabled information services to its associate enterprise namely CAE Solutions Inc. USA since 2002. As the appellant has been new in the business in the initial years that is why up till A.Y. 2005-06, the export turnover were not substantial and were in the vicinity of 5-6 crores of rupees per annum on which the appellant company made marginal net profit to the tune of around 12% as is evident from the chart appearing on page 4 of the impugned assessment order. Thereafter during immediate succeeding year viz. A.Y. 2006-07, its exports turnover touched at a figure of Rs.30.67 Crores which resulted in higher net margin @ 80% in comparison to 12% during previous assessment years. It is not out of place to submit that the entire export of software & services during A.Y. 2006-07 was to M/s. CAE Solutions Inc., USA who was the only customer in the impugned year also.
Admittedly and apparently, the profits were substantial (at 87%) in the year under appeal in terms of percentage but it is equally important to submit at the same time that, it was reasonably comparable to the net margin of immediate preceding assessment year (at 80%). It may please seen as the appellant company had developed tailor made highly customized, non distributable software for its client and had also parted with their source code during these years. It was specifically informed to the AO in reply to show-cause dated 14.12.2010 vide letter dated 30.12.2010 (PB 194-195). Therefore, the allegation of A.O. about concocted storey about extraordinary profit on this account in para 4.16 is without any substance.
It goes without saying that the assessment of A.Y. 2006-07 was completed u/s. 143(3) and there was no adverse observation on the lines made by Ld. AO in the year under appeal. When net profit of 80% was found acceptable and reasonable during A.Y. 2006-07, there is no reason as to why net profit in the same range be viewed with suspicion and that too without any adverse evidence.
PB 110-113 is the copy of the assessment order for A.Y. 2006-07.
It is matter of records, that the export sales in A.Y. 2006-07 was also the subject matter of Transfer Pricing proceedings u/s. 92C chapter X of the I.T. Act. The TPO has accepted the value of international transaction between the appellant company and its associated enterprise as declared in Form 3 CEB after analyzing the detail & documents furnished during the proceedings. Copy of order of TPO dated 27.02.2009 u/s. 92-CA(3) is enclosed (PB 114-115).
It is also matter of records that a letter justifying the net profit rate of 80% was also filed during assessment proceeding for the A.Y. 2006-07 (PB 116-118). In other words, the Ld. A.O. accepted the trading result in toto for the A.Y. 2006-07 @ 80% as against 12% during A.Y. 2005-06 without making any adverse comments in spite of the substantially higher net profit margin during A.Y. 2006 -07.
Therefore, in view of the fact, when the net profit rate of 80% was accepted in the trade of the assessee involving the same buyer of software in the immediately preceding previous year i.e. in A.Y. 2006-07, the profit rate of 87% earned in A.Y. 2007-08 can not be held to be abnormal as is sought to be made out by Ld. AO in the impugned assessment order.
In fact in the software industry such kind of profit margin is not something which is impossible. Software industry being primarily service industry based on high specialized skill, its margin of profit is not directly related to the cost but it depends upon the usability of the software and non distributable right attached therewith. Well known theory of marginal costing that after meeting the fixed expenses, whatever contribution is there resulting from the sale is bound to give higher net profits on progressive basis has also its own role.
The net profit rate of 87% cannot be doubted or disputed by Ld. AO in the impugned year on the ground that proceeding of this year also was subject matter of transfer pricing study (PB 128-182), Transfer Pricing Audit (PB 27-30) under chapter X section 92 of the 1.T. Act. The mandate of section 92(1) is that income from international transactions between associated enterprises has to be computed having regard to the arm's length price. Computation of the arm's length price is essentially a factual exercise. Each case depends on its own peculiar facts and circumstances. In certain cases where an identical or almost similar uncontrolled transaction is available for comparison determination of the arm's length price is an easy task. However; it is not so in most transactions and rarely is one able to locate an identical transaction. In such cases the arm's length price is determined by taking the results of a comparable transactions in comparable circumstances and making suitable adjustments for the differences.
The Ld. Transfer Pricing Officer being specialist on subject has accepted the Arm Length Price of international transaction with associate concern M/s CAE Solutions Inc., USA at the rates on which invoices were raised as submitted in our replies to Ld. TPO & Ld. AO (PB 121-125 & 126-127). As per the amended provision of law w.e.f. 01.04.2007 once a transfer pricing Officer certifies the value of transaction between associate concern, the A.O. has to pass his order in conformity with the order of TPO. The Ld. A.O. himself in the para 8 at page No. 11 of impugned assessment order considered the order of TPO U/S 92CA(3) and held that no transfer pricing adjustment is required in this case. Once the export sales were the subject of transfer pricing audit and Transfer Pricing Proceedings U/S 92CA and there is no adverse observation, the argument of Ld. A.O. about any alleged excessive profit is neither here nor there and is liable to be ignored.
Adverse observations made by Ld. A.O. on account of extra ordinary high profit are specifically met as under:
1.Ld. A.O. has mentioned in Para 4.6 of his order that appellant company has shown net profit rate near 90% by inflating profits and in turn has claimed deduction u/s. 10A of the Act on the whole of the profit and at the end has diverted the funds to the key person i.e. Dr. Anil Gupta in the garb of buy back of shares.
In reply, it is respectfully submitted that justification for the high net profit rate has already been given above by us and any imputation of Ld. A.O. regarding the ,"inflated" profits being surmise is misplaced on facts. There is no basis material or evidence for this conjectured imputation. It is settled law that when allegation is leveled by a quasi judicial authority, it has to be based on evidence without which no judicial notice can be taken for such bald allegation.
Regarding the claim of deduction u/s. 10A and buy back of shares, it is submitted that section 10A allows deduction under Income Tax Act, 1961 and section 77A of the Companies Act, 1956 allows buyback of shares. Therefore anything which is done in the light of law permitting so cannot be viewed adversely. Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of UOI & Anr. vs. Azadi Bachao Andolan & Anr. 263 ITR 706 have held that a person is entitled to arrange one's own affairs within the parameters of law even if it results into reduction of tax incidence. Thus there is nothing worthwhile in the allegation of Ld. AO and the allegation is for the sake of allegation only.
Regarding the alleged "huge" premium per share, paid by the appellant company, it is submitted that Dr. Anil Gupta has paid the due taxes with reference to such "huge" premium received by him, as leviable under Income Tax Act, 1961 which is evident from the copy of his return enclosed in the (PB 331-332). Moreover, fixation of share premium is not based on any adhocism but is based on the guidelines issued by RBI for disinvestments by Foreign Resident and certified by the competent Valuer as per RBI Circular No. 16. AP (Dir Series) dated 04.10.2004 of FEMA, copy of which was filed to Ld. A.O. and is enclosed in the (PB 333-341).
It is important to submit that it is not the case of Ld. A.O. that buy-back of shares was not at the price at which the transaction had taken place in the absence of which any indirect imputation is nothing but surmise and conjecture which has to be dismissed as such as held by Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case Dhakeshwari Cotton Mills Ltd. vs. CIT: 26 ITR 775 (SC). This is such settled law that the appellant does not want to burden the written submissions with more case laws on such plain law.
2.The appellant could not file copy of balance sheet and profit & Loss Account of CAE Solutions Inc. USA during the course of assessment proceedings as mentioned by the A.O. in para 4.11 of the impugned assessment order.
In reply it is submitted that due to the reason that under the Federal Law of USA assessee is required to keep assessment records for three previous calendar year only. Therefore, these were not available with Dr. Anil Gupta. However, he kept on trying with his counsel at USA in anticipation that he might have copy of the same. Unfortunately, the tax Consultant could not look into the records in the month of December, (US Financial year ending) as he was also pre-occupied in finalisation of US LT. Returns. With the result, it was not available with Dr. Anil Gupta & thus could not be filed.
3.Ld. A.O. has alleged in Para 4.11 and Para 4.12 of his order that it seems Dr. Anil Gupta is working on Charity and no cost attributable to Dr. Anil Gupta was debited in the appellant's books of accounts though he is providing all kinds of marketing / technical assistance and software development inputs & by saying so, Ld. AO probably meant that the profits have been shown at higher figure due to such non charging of expense concerned.
In reply, it is respectfully submitted that the Ld. A.O. at his own wisdom has alleged that Dr. Anil Gupta is providing all sort of marketing services to the appellant company, knowing fully that appellant company does not require any marketing of its software as the appellant is exclusively exporting software and services to M/s. CAE Solutions Inc. USA since the date of incorporation, or in other words the appellant company has got only one customer since very beginning therefore there is no question of any marketing as alleged by the A.O. With due respect, marketing if any, is required, it is only by CAE Solutions Inc. USA the proprietorship concern of Dr. Anil Gupta.
As far as technical assistance and software development inputs are concerned, on perusal of profit & loss account (PB 43) your honour will appreciate that the appellant has paid substantial amount of salary of Rs.4,78,90,110/- during the year. Employee-wise detail of which was furnished to the A.O. during the course of assessment proceedings vide letter dated 26.11.2010 copy (PB 183-192). The A.O. himself in para 4.7 has admitted that there are qualified person who are being paid salary more than Rs.10,00,000/-p.a. Further, submitted that the appellant company had large number of technically qualified personnel which is evident from the designation so marked in the detail so filed.
It is not the case of Ld. A.O. that any salary is being paid to Dr. Anil Gupta and yet the same has not been charged to profit and loss account. It is matter of records that Dr. Anil Gupta being the majority shareholder of the appellant company has got handsome returns on its investment in the form of premium earned on surrender of his share in the buyback scheme floated by the appellant company within the framework of law.
Business prudence of an assessee may not be subject matter of justifiability of Ld. AO as was held by Hon'ble Supreme Court in the following cases in which Hon 'ble apex court have said that it is not for the AO to sit in the armchair of the businessman and dictate as to how the business is to be done.
The test of prudence by substituting its own view in place of the businessman's view has not been approved by the Supreme Court in the decisions of CIT vs. Walchand & Co. (P) Ltd. 65ITR 381 and J.K. Woolen Manufactures Vs. CIT 72 ITR 612.
It is not for the revenue to question the commercial expediency of the expenditure as the commercial expediency is a matter which is entirely left to the judgment of the assessee as was held by Hon'ble Madras High Court in the case of CIT Vs. Gobald Motor Service (P) Ltd. 100 ITR 240, 242.
Held, that under fiscal laws, authorities have no right to re-write a transaction unless it is held that it is sham or bogus or entered into by the parties in bad faith to avoid and evade taxes. Sony India P. Ltd. v/s. DCIT (2009) 114 ITD 448 -ITAT Delhi.
The Hon'ble ITAT Bench of Chennai vide its order dated 18.03.2009 reported as 2009 TOIL - 271 ITAT (Mad) has held A.O. cannot decide how business has to be done. The assessee has liberty to choose its business model. In a complex manufacturing process it is the assessee who decides as to what to produce in the factory, what to buy and what to outsource. The A.O. cannot justifiably claim to put himself in the armchair of the businessman and assume the role to decide how to do the business having regard to the circumstances of the case. The A.O. has to put himself in the shoes of the assessee and see how a prudent businessman would act. How should not look at the matter from his own view point but from that of a prudent businessman.
4.Ld. A.O. has in Para 4.18 & 4.19 of the assessment order has invoked the section 10A(7) r.w.s. 80IA(10) according to the A.O. if cost of the services of Dr. Anil Gupta is taken at Rs.25crores, then also the profit of the company will be at Rs.25.52 crores and even in that case the net profit rate would be 45.28% which would still be excessive and much higher to other comparative companies of similar nature. It is respectfully submitted that there is no basis, material or evidence of any cost, much less of Rs.25 crores incurred in relation to Dr. Anil Gupta. It is not and certainly could not be, as there was no evidence. The case of Ld. A.O. that any such expense was not incurred nor any evidence been brought on record to this effect. Therefore the series of imaginary hypothesis of Ld. A.O. lack factual and legal legs to stand.
The provisions of section 80IA do not give arbitrary power to the Assessing Officer to fix the profit of the assessee, therefore, the reduction of eligible profit of the appellant company by the A.O. by invoking section 80IA(10) read with section 10A(7) of the Act is not sustainable particularly, when the transactions between two associated enterprises one in India and one outside India has been considered and accepted at Arm Length Price U/S 92C then it cannot be treated as an arrangement to avoid tax as contemplated U/S 10A(7) of the Act. The intention of the provisions of Transfer Pricing are to see that when international transactions are done between two or more associated enterprises, the affair of the enterprises (the appellant) are not adjusted in such a manner as to deprive the country or the local associated enterprises to the correct revenue, which would result in reduction of taxable income of the local associated enterprises of the country.
The Ld. AO also alleged that even after allocating the cost of Dr. Anil Gupta, the net profit ratio of 45.2% which had arisen, is much higher to other comparative companies of the similar nature. With due respect, the Assessing Officer would be expected to use a comparable case to determine the possible ordinary profit which the assessee could be expected to generate from his business. In the absence of the same or any other substantial evidence available with him, the assessee's own past performance would obviously be the best comparable.
The Hon'ble ITAT Chennai in a similar case of Tweezerman (India) Pvt. Ltd. v/s ACIT (2010) 004 ITR (Trib) 0130 held as under:
Where Assessing Officer denied assessee deduction uls. 10B of profits in excess of Arm's Length Price by invoking provisions of section 10B(7) read with section 801A(l), and a perusal of order of Transfer Pricing Officer for relevant assessment year showed that TPO had verified Arm Length Price and had confirmed that no adjustment on account of transfer pricing was required to be made under these circumstances, reduction of eligible profits of assessee by an amount of Rs.3.54 Crores as done by Assessing Officer invoking provisions of section 801A(l) read with section 10B(7) was unsustainable ( A.Y. 2004-05) in favour of assessee).
The above judgment of ITAT applies all forms to the facts of the assessee's case. Copy of judgment is placed in (PB 342-347).
Attempt of Ld. AO in para 4.15 of the order that if so called arbitration award is excluded from the net profits, the net profit so earned would be at a figure of 12.59% which would then compare favorably with net profit rates of earlier years is misplaced, as in A.Y. 2006-07 as submitted above on more than one occasions, the net profit rate accepted was 79.97%. Moreover, the AO is wrong while calculating the net profit of 12.59% by way of eliminating the figure of Rs. 43.49 crores from numerator only whereas it should also have been eliminated from denominator for the purpose of comparison of trading results. Had this being done like this, the net profit ratio would have been around 55% as demonstrated below:
Thereafter, this attempt of Ld. AO lacks factual accuracy.
Net Profit 50.59 - 43.49 = 07.09
Turnover 56.36 - 43.49 = 12.87
NP/Turnover 7.09 / 12.87 = 55.08%
Therefore, all contemporary evidences establish that in the notes to the accounts there was mere typographical error and nothing adverse can be inferred from this typographical error as is otherwise sought to be made out by Ld. AO and denial of exemption to the tune of Rs.43,49,83,092/- is mis-conceived and it is prayed that the same may please be reversed.
Contention of Revenue in Ground No. 4(a) of appeal that there was no evidence of sale of Source Code of Software, it is submitted that above mentioned evidences would show that there was sale of Software Source Code and that there was extraordinary profits of 87%.
Contention of Revenue in Ground No.4(b) of appeal that there was application of section 80IA(10) and that assessee failed to prove by necessary evidence that it was the sale of Software Source Code (SCC) eligible for deduction u/s.10A.
In the last, it is prayed by ld. AR that Ld. CIT(A) has rightly deleted the additions which order deserves to be uphold.
Heard the contentions of both the parties and perused the material available on record. From the series of events submitted by Ld. CIT DR, it is seen that in the instant case, issue of exemption u/s 10A was raised by Ld. Pr.CIT in the order passed u/s 263 dated 28.03.2013 which was quashed by the Co-ordinate Bench of Tribunal and further appeal of the Revenue against the said order was dismissed by the Jurisdictional High Court vide its order dated 27.02.2024 in ITA No.171/2022.
Further the assessment for preceding assessment years were completed u/s 143(3) where in AY 2005-06, the assessee has shown net profit margin of 12% and in AY 2006-07, the net profit margin of 80% was declared by the assessee. The revenue had accepted such a sharp increase in the profit margin in the order passed u/s 143(3) of the Act and never doubted the claim of exemption u/s 10A by the assessee. Once the substantial increase in profits from 12% to 80% stood accepted without raising any doubts about the net profit margin achieved by assessee and claimed of exemption u/s 10A on such profits, in the instant year when there were no change in the circumstances neither the nature of business was changed nor the customer is changed and 100% export is made to the same party then increase in net profit from 80% to 87% cannot be questioned solely for the reason that buyer is a controlled party which fact as discussed above, was existed in preceding year also. It is further seen that a reference was made to TPO for determination of ALP of the transactions with AE however, neither in preceding years nor in the year under appeal, TPO has proposed any adjustments and the sales price declared was accepted. These facts were admitted by the AO in his order.
Shri Anil Gupta is the largest shareholder of the assessee company and also the proprietor of buyer company. This fcat does not make any difference with respect to sale price charged and development of software at the end of the assessee company where the development was done with the team of experts to whom sufficient salaries as per their job profile were paid and were never doubted by the Revenue. Merely because Shri Anil Gupta had not been compensated for the services rendered, it cannot be said that such arrangement was made to disclose higher profits by the assessee company to claim higher exemption. It is further observed by us that AO has not placed any material on record to hold that sum of INR 25 crores is reasonable compensation to Shri Anil Gupta towards the services rendered by him. It appears that such observations are solely made on conjectures and surmises. Moreover, this observation had not been applied to the computation of income and simply an alternate remarks was given by the AO which are directed to be excluded as have no impact when these observations were made without any supporting material.
It is further seen that all the objections raised by the AO have duly been rebutted by the assessee and were appreciated by Ld.CIT(A) in its order. As observed above, it is further seen that the assessee has claimed that there was a “typographical error” due to which sale of software was wrongly classified as “Arbitration Award” in the final accounts and assessee has been successfully demonstrated that it was a typographical error by filing necessary details such as CA certificate in Form 3CEB certifying export turnover, Form 56F i.e. report for claiming exemption u/s 10A of the Act confirming the export turnover of INR 56,36,07,721/-, copy of SOFTEX form filed and accepted by STPI confirming the sale of software, copy of FIRC duly confirming the advance received against the export sales and most important fact that in the order passed by TPO u/s 92CA, export turnover of software of INR 56,36,07,721/- was accepted by the TPO thus now raising doubts by the AO is contrary to the accepted fact by TPO.
All these facts, leads to believe that there was a typographical error wherein sale of software was inadvertently stated as “Arbitration Award”. It is also a matter of fact that on one hand, AO has alleged the higher profit when he tried to establish that assessee has claimed excess exemption u/s 10A where AO himself computed the margin of net profits by taking the export turnover at INR 56,36,07,721/-and further in para 4.15 while computing the net profit after reducing the profit of “Arbitration Award”, the AO has not reduced the amount of “Arbitration Award” from the gross export turnover. This clearly shows the bias and contrary approach taken by the AO who at one place too the gross export turnover at INR 56,36,07,721/- and at a later stage himself has treated the part of such turnover as “Arbitration Award” not eligible for exemption u/s 10A of the Act.
In view of the above facts and discussion made and further looking to the facts that Revenue has failed to controvert the findings given by Ld. CIT(A) who after appreciating all these facts has deleted the addition made by AO, thus we find no reason to infirmity in the order of Ld. CIT(A). Accordingly, order of Ld. CIT(A) on this issue is upheld. The grounds of appeal Nos. 1 to 4 raised by the Revenue are dismissed.
Ground of appeal No.5 is with respect to the deletion of action of the AO in holding the foreign exchange fluctuation as non business receipt and denied the exemption u/s 10A of the Act.
Before us, Ld.CIT DR vehemently supported the orders of the AO and submits that foreign exchange fluctuation gain is post-export funds and should not be clubbed with export turnover. He further submits that it is not a profit earned from the export and therefore, cannot be treated as part of export turnover. He thus, prayed for exclusion of the same from the eligible profit for claiming exemption u/s 10A of the Act.
On the other hand, Ld. AR vehemently supports the order of Ld. CIT(A) and submits that assessee has gained from foreign exchange fluctuation which is in the regular course of business of export software. Ld.AR further submits that in preceding assessment years, the gain on foreign exchange fluctuation was treated by AO himself as income from export of software eligible for exemption u/s 10A of the Act. Thus, by following the principle of consistency, the same deserves to be held as income from export of turnover in the year under appeal also. He further placed reliance on the submissions made before Ld.CIT(A) in this regard as reproduced in para 4.2 of Ld. CIT(A)’s order which is reproduced herein below for sake of clarity:-
4.2.“The AR of the appellant during the course of appellate proceedings further filed written submissions, the same are reproduced below:-
"Ld. AO disallowed the exemption w/s 10A to the extent of Rs. 1,23,33,934/- in respect of foreign exchange fluctuation gain on the ground that gain on account of forex rate fluctuation cannot be considered as profit derived from export as these being the result of post export events or scenario. Further the Ld. A.O. relying upon the decision of Supreme Court Pandian Chemicals v/s. CIT (2003) ITR 278 has alleged that the same cannot be said to have been derived from basic and core activity of export.
It is respectfully submitted that the appellant company is in the business of export of software and is eligible to claim exemption u/s 10A which has been accepted by Ld. AO also in the year under appeal and in earlier years.
During the year under review, the appellant company earned foreign exchange gain amounting to Rs. 1,23,33,934/- on realization of various export invoices as per detail annexed at (PB 330). The appellant company through oversight while filing its original I.T. Return did not include this figure into gross sales credited to Profit & Loss Account. However, while finalizing the balance sheet for the subsequent financial year ended on 31.03.2008, the appellant company realized its mistake and accordingly revised the return alongwith letter dated 23.08.2008 copy at (PB 26) treating the same as part and parcel of net profit derived from export of computer software and claimed deduction u/s 10A of the Act. It goes without saying that the revised return of income stood accepted by Ld. AO and that being so, there was no occasion for Ld. AO to deny the benefit of impugned foreign exchange gain.
As per provisions of sub-section (4) of section 10A which reads as under-
(4)For the purposes of sub-sections (1) and (1A) the profits derived from export of articles or things or computer software shall be the amount which bears to the profits of the business of the under taking, the same proportion as the export turnover in respect of such articles or things or computer software bears to the total turnover of the business carried on by the undertaking" Therefore, u/s 10A deduction of profit & gain derived by an undertaking from export of articles or things or computer software is admissible. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Pandian Chemicals (SUPRA) has define the word "derived from" in section 80 HH of the 1.T. Act must be understood as something which has direct or immediate nexus with assessee's industrial undertaking. The Hon'ble ITAT Mumbai Bench in the case of Renaissance Jewellery P. Ltd. v. ITO [2007] 289 ITR (AT) 65 (Mum) has held that the crucial words "derived from" there is hardly any material difference between the legal requirements of section 80HH and section 10A.
During the year under review, the appellant booked export sales on the basis of a prevailing rate of exchange on the date of invoices. However, later on it realized a different sum in Indian rupees as sale proceeds as per detail at (PB 330), the net excess or the shortfall is booked as foreign exchange gain as it is does not have a different character from the export turnover and it is also part of export profits.
In the case of C IT v/s. Sony India Pvt. Ltd. [2009] 315 ITR (A.T.) 0150-[ITAT-Delhi] relying upon DCIT v/s. K. K. Doshi and Co. [2000] 245 ITR 849 (Bom) held Any profit or loss as a result of foreign exchange fluctuation ultimately goes to increase or reduce the figure of export turnover recorded initially by the assessee in its books of account. The basic character of receipt on account of foreign exchange thus remains the same. Therefore income from foreign currency fluctuation is part of export turnover and is a sort of additional sales price. Therefore foreign exchange gain is includible in the profits eligible for deduction under section 104/10B of the Act. Further reliance can be placed on the following judicial pronouncements:-
a)Smt. Sujatha Grover v. Deputy CIT (2002) 74 TTJ 347 (Delhi)
b)Priyanka Gems v. Asst. CIT [2005] 94 TTJ 557 (And)
c)CIT v. Rane (Madras) Ltd. [1999] 238 ITR 377 (Mad), where even a forward contract in foreign exchange, which had nexus with the export of goods could be treated as relating to the activity eligible for deduction in the context of sections 80E and 80-I.
In fact, the case of the appellant is also covered by the decision of Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of CIT v/s. Woodward Governor P Ltd. 312 ITR 254.
It is pertinent to mention here that gain on account of foreign exchange during A.Y. 2006-07 has been accepted as export profit u/s 143(3) of the Act. Copy of I.T. Assessment for the A.Y. 2006-07 and profit & loss account as on 31.03.2006 are enclosed at (PB 101-113 & 99) respectively. Therefore, it is prayed that deduction w/s 104 on account of foreign exchange gain as claimed by the assessee in the revised return may please be allowed."
Heard the contentions of both the parties and perused the material available on record. From the perusal of the order of Ld.CIT(A), it is seen that Ld.CIT(A) based his findings that foreign exchange fluctuation gain is income from software export and eligible for exemption u/s 10A by placing reliance on various judgements including the judgements of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of CIT v/s. Woodward Governor P Ltd. 312 ITR 254.(SC) and further ton he decision of coordinate bench of Tribunal in the case of CIT v/s. Sony India Pvt. Ltd. [2009] 315 ITR (A.T.) 0150-[ITAT-Delhi). The relevant observations of Ld. CIT(A) in para 4.3 are as under:-
4.3.“I have considered the assessment order, written submissions filed by the counsel and judicial pronouncements as relied upon. Admittedly, the appellant being in the business of export of software is eligible to claim exemption u/s 10A. Whenever, the exports are made, the invoices are raised in USD and booked into the financial books in INR at the rate prevailing as on date of invoice. However, as the export invoices are realized subsequently at a different price due to change in exchange rate of USD, net excess or short fall has been booked by the assessee as foreign exchange gain. The assessee has filed detailed calculation of foreign exchange gain realized by it. The A.O. in the assessment order has observed that any gain or loss on account of fluctuation in foreign exchange rate is post export event and not out of the core activity of export. The contention of the A.O. is not sustainable under the law as the profit on account of foreign exchange gain is directly referable to the articles and things exported by the assessee.
Such profits are, therefore, in the same nature as the sale proceeds and there is no reason why deduction under section 10A should not be allowed in respect of such exchange gain. Reliance is placed on the following judicial pronouncements:-
CIT v/s. Woodward Governor P Ltd. 312 ITR 254.(SC) CIT v/s. Sony India Pvt. Ltd. [2009] 315 ITR (A.T.) 0150- [ITAT-Delhi) Renaissance Jewellery P. Ltd. v. ITO [2007] 289 ITR (AT) 65 (Mum) Priyanka Gems v. Asst. CIT [2005] 94 TTJ 557 (Ahd) Smt. Sujatha Grover v. Deputy CIT [2002] 74 TTJ 347 (Delhi) DCIT v/s. K. K. Doshi and Co. [2000] 245 ITR 849 (Bom) CIT v. Rane (Madras) Ltd. [1999] 238 ITR 377 (Mad). The appellant succeeds on these grounds of appeal.”
From the perusal of the order of Ld.CIT(A), it is seen that Ld.CIT(A) observed that gains from foreign exchange fluctuations is directly relatable to the article and things exported by the assessee where the payments were received in convertible foreign exchange and due to timing difference, fluctuation gains earned by the assessee. It is also seen that in preceding assessment years, revenue has accepted foreign exchange fluctuation gain of identical nature as profit derived from the business eligible for exemption u/s 10A od the Act thus, by following the principle of consistency also, we find no error in the order of Ld.CIT(A) who has rightly held the foreign exchange fluctuation gain as income derived from export of software.
In view of the above facts and discussion made, we uphold the order of Ld.CIT(A) on this issue. Accordingly, Ground of appeal No. 5 raised by the Revenue is dismissed.
Ground of appeal No.6 raised by the Revenue is with respect to the deletion of addition of INR 3,55,47,260/- by invoking the provision of section 40(a)(ia) of the Act.
Heard the contentions of both the parties and perused the material available on record. At the outset, admittedly assessee has deducted tax at source @ 10% on the payments made to Shri Anil Gupta on the payment made at the time of buy back of his shares. The AO’s allegation is that as per section 195 of the Act, 20% TDS was to be made and accordingly, he made the proportionate disallowance of 50% of the amount paid on buy back of the shares. We find that Ld.CIT(A) while deleting the disallowance, has observed that provision of section 40(a)(ia) of the Act are applicable only when the amount on which tax is to be deducted is claimed as expenditure in the Profit & Loss Account. Admittedly, assessee has never claimed any such expenditure for the amount paid on buy back of its shares and the amount paid was reduced from the Reserves and Surplus therefore, provision of section 40(a)(ia) of the Act is not applicable to the facts of the present case. Moreover, once the assessee has deducted the tax at source though at a lower rate, the due compliances has been made to satisfy the condition of section 40(a)(ia) which provide TDS should be made at the time of any payment of expenditure. Therefore, the provision of section 40(a)(ia) could not be invoked for making disallowances where even short deduction is made. This view is supported by the judgement of Hon’ble Rajasthan High Court in the case of CIT vs M.C.Sharma Associates wherein the Hon’ble High Court has confirmed the order of the Co-ordinate bench of ITAT under identical circumstances.
As in the instant case, the assessee has deducted the tax @ 10% therefore, the compliance has been made. The Hon’ble Kolkata High Court in the case of CIT vs. S.K.Tekriwal reported 361 ITR 432 held that in case of lower deduction, provision of section n 40(a)(ia) are not attracted. In view of above facts and by respectfully following the judgement of Hon’ble Rajasthan High Court and Hon’ble Kolkata High Court in the cases referred herein above, we are not inclined to interfere in the order of ld. CIT(A) which is hereby upheld. Accordingly, Ground of appeal No.6 raised by the Revenue is dismissed.
In the result, appeal of the Revenue is dismissed.
